Anda di halaman 1dari 6

Surg Radiol Anat (2006) 28: 189–194

DOI 10.1007/s00276-005-0062-z

TEACHING

René Yiou Æ Daniel Goodenough

Applying problem-based learning to the teaching of anatomy: the example


of Harvard Medical School

Received: 4 October 2004 / Accepted: 21 October 2005 / Published online: 7 March 2006
Ó Springer-Verlag 2006

Abstract The introduction of problem-based learning


techniques into the teaching of anatomy has been subject
Introduction
to great controversies. This paper debates the rationale
The teaching of medicine has been the subject of pro-
behind this concept using the example of the curriculum
found changes during the past decades at several uni-
of Harvard Medical School in which problem-based
versities in the United States. In many of these, the
learning techniques have been used during the past
lectures have become progressively more conceptual and
20 years. The anatomy curriculum is covered during the
less dense, and a more interactive approach of learning,
eight first weeks of the medical studies, and is an original
based on the resolution of clinical problems in small
combination of discussions of clinical cases in small
groups, has been introduced. This method of teaching,
groups, and work in gross anatomy, histology and
named the new pathway at Harvard Medical School
radiology laboratories. The lectures are reduced to
which incorporates components of problem-based
the minimum and emphasize general concepts. In this
learning, was initially developed with the aim of
setting, the learning of anatomy is mostly led by students
encouraging students’ motivation and responsibility to-
who have prepared for the different laboratory sessions
ward learning [14]. The rationale was based on the idea
and tutorials. The implementation of problem-based
that it is not realistic to assign students to assimilate the
learning to the teaching of anatomy requires a close
increasing mass of essential details generated by the
follow-up of each student with regular feedbacks on his
evolution of medicine, and that the development of
work. Tutorials must be considered as a cornerstone
appropriate skills and attitudes of learning is preferable
between lectures and work in laboratories. Traditional
to rote memorization. While most of the Universities in
aspects of the teaching of anatomy, such as work in
North America have integrated problem-based learning
dissection laboratories, are given an important role
in the clinical disciplines, it remains controversial
as they are aimed to clear-up misunderstood points.
whether such a concept of teaching can be applied to
Further studies are required to compare at the long term
basic sciences, and in particular to anatomy.
the level of medical students who learned anatomy in a
The teaching of anatomy occupies a unique place in
problem based versus traditional learning setting.
the medical curriculum. Like no other discipline, it
constantly gives rise to great debates and surveys con-
Keywords Problem-based learning Æ Anatomy Æ
cerning what exactly should be taught and how [2, 3, 6,
Medical education
10]. This may be explained partly by the fact that it is, by
essence, interdisciplinary, and, henceforth, highly influ-
enced by concepts introduced in other areas of medicine.
In that sense, anatomy is a very living and modern
R. Yiou (&) subject. An important task assigned to the teaching
Service d’Urologie et département d’Anatomie, C.H.U. Henri anatomy department consists of balancing modern and
MONDOR, 56 Avenue du Maréchal de Lattre de Tassigny,
94010, Créteil, France traditional basic anatomy while still providing the
E-mail: rene.yiou@hmn.ap-hop-paris.fr foundations of a medical education.
Tel.: +33-1-49812559 The methods of teaching of anatomy are also bound
Fax: +33-1-49812552 to be modified dramatically with the arrival of the
D. Goodenough Æ R. Yiou
computer and the internet. The use of interactive soft-
Department of Cell Biology, Harvard Medical School, ware has been suggested to help in the understanding of
240 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115, USA anatomical concepts in several venues such as during
190

lectures [4], in gross anatomy laboratories [8] and for Medical School are displayed in Tables 1 and 2. This
students’ self-preparation. However, the exact role that course takes place during the eight first weeks of the first
these new technologies should play in the learning pro- year of the medical curriculum. During this period, the
cess and their place with regard to classical blackboard students are given a global vision of gross anatomy,
drawings remain vague and vary considerably from one radiology and histology. Each day is arranged as
university to another. As mentioned by Reidenberg and follows: 1 h of tutorial (discussion of clinical cases), 1 h
Laitman [11], newer generations of students may advo- of lecture and 2 h of histology laboratory exposure or
cate a greater interactivity, and this should be taken into 3 h of gross anatomy laboratory exposure (with dissec-
consideration in the design of the curriculum. tion). Afternoons are dedicated to the preparation of the
Thus, the anatomy curriculum requires regular next tutorials, and practical experience in either the
updates in terms of presentation and content. However, histology or gross anatomy laboratories.
there has been a lack of consensus regarding the way
these modifications should be performed. In addition,
adaptation of the curriculum has become problematic
because the time, importance and academic credit allo- Organization of the tutorials
cated to anatomy has been progressively restricted to the
benefit of other emerging disciplines, such as neurobi- Nine clinical cases are discussed during the eight weeks
ology or ethics. As a result, most of the departments that deal successively with the anatomy of (1) the fore-
constantly struggle to preserve essential—yet costly and arm (case of a prematurely sutured soiled wound com-
time-consuming—aspects of the curriculum such as plicated by compartment syndrome of the forearm); (2)
dissections. the rachis and spinal cord (case of sciatic nerve com-
A pragmatic way of addressing these issues has been pression); (3) the thoracic outlet (case of thoracic outlet
adopted at several universities in the United States by syndrome with vascular compression of the subclavian
applying the concepts of the new pathway to the teaching artery); (4) the thorax (case of spontaneous pneumo-
of anatomy. In this setting, the lectures and tutorials are thorax); (5) the neck (case of a retropharyngeal abscess
limited to provide only general and clinically relevant secondary to trauma); (6) the sinus of the face and their
anatomical concepts. From this material, the students relationship with the meninges (case of frontal sinusitis
have to define their own set of objectives with the with meningitis); (7) the abdominal wall and the peri-
underlying principle that they acquire the anatomical toneum (inguinal hernia); (8) the abdomen (case of acute
knowledge important in solving clinical problems. By pancreatitis); (9) the pelvis (case of ectopic pregnancy).
bridging the gap existing between anatomy and clinical Groups of eight students meet for 1 h every day
disciplines, the students are given a greater responsibility under the supervision of a faculty member (tutor), and
for their learning of anatomy and can be sensitized to discuss the clinical cases with the help of books (medical
newer technologies and imaging techniques with the help dictionary, Grant’s Atlas, Histology, Cell Biology and
of computers. The limitation of the number of lectures the Harrison’s Internal Medicine) and of a computer
permits a relative increase in the proportion of time spent connected to internet. Sessions usually start by the
in the gross anatomy laboratory, during which most of reading of the text describing the initial symptoms and
the teaching of descriptive anatomy is provided. are followed by the definition of the new vocabulary.
The principles of this method of teaching have often Several hypotheses concerning the organs and structures
been perceived with skepticism, because of the lack of involved in the clinical symptoms are generated. Since
detailed lectures and the role of facilitator played by the the students have not yet seen the clinical disciplines, the
teacher. In addition, the implementation of problem- hypotheses are initially based on student’s prior
based learning to anatomy requires a radical reorgani- knowledge and experience. The questions that cannot
zation of the curriculum and a precise definition of the be answered are written on the blackboard, and the
role played by the tutorials, the lecture and the work in students define tasks for the next sessions in order to
the laboratory, each aspect being strongly complemen- solve these problems. The students then study on their
tary from the others. The aim of this paper was to own, using the library, computers and may return in the
provide a detailed description of the organization of the histology or gross anatomy laboratories. During the
curriculum of anatomy of Harvard Medical School, a next session, each student brings his or her contribution
university of reference in the United States and a pioneer to the understanding of the case, and progressively, the
in the new pathway, in order to illustrate the principles patient’s symptoms are related to anatomical concepts.
of problem-based learning applied to the teaching of A new part of the case is then disclosed by the tutors.
anatomy. The clinical evolution raises new questions and
hypotheses that are progressively focused on a specific
part of the body. Radiological images are shown to
Description of the curriculum of anatomy illustrate the case and the principle of treatment, usually
based on surgery, is discussed. Discussion around
The global organization of the curriculum of anatomy radiological material and therapeutic options serve as
and the characteristics of the faculty panel in Harvard support to review anatomy. The role of the tutors is to
191

Table 1 Global organization of the curriculum of anatomy in Table 3 Description of the topics of the lectures. These were
Harvard Medical School arbitrarily divided in conventional and nonconventional lectures
with regard to a traditional curriculum
Gross anatomy laboratory 41 h (31.3%)
Histology laboratory 26 h (19.8%) Nonconventional lectures
Radiology laboratory 7 h 30 min (5.7%) Cellular biological systems (1 h)
Lectures 28 h 30 min (21.5%) Organization of the human body I: building tissue
Tutorials 28 h (21.3%) from molecules (1 h)
Total number of hours 131 h Organization of the human body II: compartments
Numbers of teachers/students 36/172 and planes (1 h)
Sections and projections (1 h)
Anatomy of circulation of body fluid (2 h)
Mechanism of respiration (1 h)
clarify the group’s objectives, rather than to provide Examination of the head and neck
detailed information. (clinical exercise with clinician) (3 h)
At the end of each case, the important points are Clinical issues in the pelvis and their anatomy (1 h)
Putting it together (1 h)
summarized by answering to three questions: (1) what Anatomical basis of diagnosis
spaces or compartment boundaries have been violated in (case of esophageal cancer with a patient) (2 h)
this case? (2) what homeostatic mechanisms were com- Conventional lectures
promised in this case? (3) how does a local event have a Organization of the nervous system (2 h)
global consequence? Organization of the limbs (1 h)
Organization of thoracic cavity (1 h)
Organization of the immune system (1 h)
Organization and compartment of head and neck (3 h)
Lectures Endocrine organ (1 h)
Organizations of abdomen: peritoneum (1 h)
The topics of the lectures are displayed in Table 3. Most Gastrointestinal system and liver (1 h)
of the lectures provide general concepts such as the Kidney: nature’s dialysis bag (1 h)
Peritoneum and referred pain (1 h)
global organization of one part of the body and Organization of the pelvis (1 h 30 min)
emphasize the notion of compartments and boundaries.
The lectures are presented with the aid of a computer
using PowerPoint and animations, videos and drawings
on the blackboard. All of them are filmed and retrans- Gross anatomy, histology and radiology sessions
mitted on the web site.
Problem-based learning may be used as a support to The topics of the gross anatomy, histology and radiology
introduce anatomical basis of a region. For instance, a sessions are displayed in Table 4. In the different labo-
case of traumatic hemopneumothorax is presented to ratories, an average of 32 students works under the
cover the anatomy of the thoracic wall and pleura. supervision of four tutors. A handout that defines the
During this lecture (1 h), the students learn how to goals of each session is distributed at the beginning of the
recognize a broken rib radiolographically, while the course. It may, for instance, describe the different steps of
anatomy of the lung and pleura is described on CT scans dissection in gross anatomy laboratories, emphasize
with the aid of projected cross-sectional drawings. The important points of structural and functional anatomy
function of respiratory muscles is explained and the and raise several clinically relevant questions that the
pathophysiology of respiratory failure relevant to students will have to answer in group. The students
the case is detailed. A clinician then introduces the use this material to orientate their preparation for the
anatomical basis of pleural drainage. sessions.

Table 2 Global organization of


the curriculum of anatomy in Lectures Tutorials Histology Gross anatomy Radiology
Harvard Medical School laboratory laboratory laboratory

Surgeons 1 4 3 4 b
(n=7)
Clinical 1 3 3 5 b
a physicians
Some tutors (category miscel- (n=8)
laneous) may not have a med- Radiologists 6 3 2 2 6
ical or biological background (n=6)
b
At the exception of the radi- Biologists 2 9 8 6 b
ologists, the participation to the (n=10)
teaching in radiology labora- Miscellaneousa 2 2 2 5 b
tories of other categories may (n=5)
vary
192

Table 4 Topics of histology lab and radiology and gross anatomy with formation of a microthrombus in the subclavian
sessions artery and emboli to the finger. This presentation comes
Gross anatomy lab (41 h) after a lecture about the global organization of the limbs
Superficial structures (2 h) (1 h), and is accompanied by three sessions of 3 h of
Limbs (9 h) dissection of the limbs in the gross anatomy laborato-
Thoracic walls, lungs and pleurae (3 h) ries. The observation begins with the description of the
Mediastinum and root of the neck (3 h)
Head and neck (9 h)
initial symptom, a sudden blue coloration of a finger in a
Abdomen (9 h) woman while she carries her heavy baby. The students
Pelvis (6 h) have to associate the cyanosis of the finger to a patho-
logical process of vascular or neurological origin. The
Histology lab (26 h) study of the innervation of the hand has been seen in the
Cells and tissues (2 h)
Epithelium and connective tissues (2 h) first tutorial (case of compression of the median nerve at
Cartilage and bone (2 h) the forearm) and the arm and forearm have been dis-
Nerve and muscle (2 h) sected in the gross anatomy laboratories. Based on this
Heart lung and trachea (2 h) prior knowledge, the students orientate their hypotheses
Immune system (2 h)
Esophagus tongue and exocrine glands (2 h) toward a vascular disease because of the localization of
Blood and blood vessels (2 h) the cyanosis. They determine next what should be done
Stomach and small intestine (2 h) in the clinical exam. One of the tasks defined by the
Liver colon and RA junction (2 h) group consists of reviewing the location of the palpable
Kidney, ureters and bladder (2 h)
Female reproductive system (2 h)
pulses of the upper limb and their anatomical land-
Male reproductive system (2 h) marks. The disclosure of a supraclavicular murmur and
a positive Adson’s test orientates toward pathology of
Radiology lab (7 h 30 min) the subclavian artery. The relationship between possible
Extremities and breast (1 h 15 min) disease in the subclavian artery and the ischemia of the
Cardiovascular (1 h 15 min)
Chest (1 h 15 min) finger is discussed. The question of the vascular supply
Head and neck (1 h 15 min) of the fingers is then approached paying attention to
Abdomen (1 h 15 min) the deep and superficial palmar arch of the hand. The
Pelvis (1 h 15 min) students try to figure out how a disease of the subclavian
artery can result in the cyanosis of an isolated finger.
The pathophysiology of thrombus and of emboli for-
mation is discussed under the guidance of the faculty
Active cadaver dissections in the gross anatomy lab- member, while the notion of variations of the palmar
oratory form the core of the curriculum where concepts arches and their functional significance is covered in the
described in lectures and tutorials are reviewed in detail gross anatomy sessions. A radiograph and an angiogram
and deepened. Four students dissect one cadaver. The are then displayed showing a cervical rib and a stenosis
faculty members watch over each table and clear-up the of the subclavian artery with a slight dilatation down-
misunderstood points using, if necessary, drawings on a stream. The students analyze these exams in detail
blackboard and a skeleton present in the laboratory. paying attention to the anatomy of the subclavian
Prosections prepared by the teachers are available to the artery, and to the radiological anatomy of the ribs and
students at the end of the sessions. clavicle. The mechanism of vascular compression is
The students have an introduction to each histology related to the functional anatomy of the thoracic outlet
sessions using slide projection images in an amphitheater and the respiratory muscles. The therapeutic options
setting. In the laboratory, each student has his or her and the possibility to remove the cervical rib are then
own microscope and slide box. Multihead microscopes discussed. It is revealed that the resection of the cervical
and microscopes connected to a video camera can be rib and of a Scalenus Minimus muscle was performed.
used to review the slides of the day, allow interactive The surgical approach of this procedure is finally
teaching to occur between faculty members and detailed by the students.
students, to answer student questions and to clarify This case is intercalated between the lectures on the
important teaching points. organization of the limbs and before the lectures
During radiology sessions, CT scan, MRI and involving the neck and thorax. During the period of this
radiographs are analyzed by the students in groups under tutorial (4 days), two lectures (2 h) entitled ‘‘Anatomy
the supervision of faculty members. of Circulation of Body Fluid’’ are given and 3 h in the
histology laboratories are spent in a small group tutorial
An illustrative example of the interdisciplinary covering the histology of blood vessels, muscles and
nature of each case nerves. At the end of the tutorial in the gross anatomy
laboratories, the thorax is opened and the clavicle
During the tutorial of the third week, a case is presented is divided allowing the entire subclavian artery to be
of finger ischemia due to a thoracic outlet syndrome, displayed from its origin to its end.
193

Table 5 Roles attributed to computers

Planning of the laboratory work. Distribution of the handouts for tutorials and laboratory sessions
Source of preparation for the tutorials. Online access to most of the international reviews and some medical books
Disclosure and illustrations of the clinical cases (pictures, X-ray, CT scan, MRI, relevant to the ongoing case)
Retransmission of the lectures or slides displayed during the lectures
Demonstrations of the dissections
Bank of images. Interactive software for recognition of anatomical structure on CT scans or describing anatomic layers of dissections
Examination
Feed back tutor/student and student/tutor

Role of computers physiology of ischemia of the upper limb and relate the
symptoms to the angioanatomy of this area. This
Students are required to enter individualized code learning process goes in an opposite direction of a tra-
numbers to access the web site of Harvard Medical ditional way of teaching anatomy that would describe
School. The tutor can control the resources that the first a normal pattern of vascularization of the upper
students of his tutorials have access to and can com- limb, region by region, and would then briefly mention
municate with them individually or in groups on the how ischemia can occur. In the curriculum described,
network. The roles played by computer are shown in the basic anatomy relevant to the case is taught, prior
Table 5. to the tutorials, by short lectures. For instance, the
organization of the upper and lower limbs is covered in a
1-h lecture that mainly focuses on the notion of com-
Examination and evaluation partment and muscle function. The learning of detailed
anatomy is left to the students themselves, and reviewed
Each tutor individually meets with the students of his during the dissection sessions that occur concurrently
tutorial four or five times during the course. The aim of with the tutorial cases.
these meetings is to give the student a feedback on his or This lack of detailed lectures has given rise to
her progression and preparation during the tutorials. passionate debates among North American teachers.
The students give their global impression on the different Cahill and Leonard wrote very provocative papers
aspects of the courses and fulfill a self-evaluation form in accusing the new pathway of considerably lowering the
which they have to define their goals of learning and level of medical student knowledge in anatomy [2, 3]. In
assess their strengths and goals for improvement. particular, the function of the tutors was very criticized
A take-home exam with clinical question is given at because they mainly act as discussion facilitators during
midterm. The aim of this exam is to test the ability of the the tutorials, resulting in a risk of missing important
student to solve clinical problems using anatomy. A final points. Mc Lean [9] found that if most of the tutors
examination is given at the end of the 8 weeks by the believe in the philosophy of problem-based learning,
students resulting in an appreciation pass or marginal 61% were doing so for promotional purposes. In the
pass. All questions are problem based and are corrected curriculum described here, the tutorials must be con-
by the tutors in group. Usually 2–3 students/year get a sidered as an intermediate step between the lectures and
‘‘marginal pass’’. If they get a marginal in another the cadaveric dissections and not as an isolated entity.
course, they go on academic probation, meaning that An essential goal of the tutorials is to have the student
they must give up all extracurricular activities and work define objectives for their own learning. This method of
with a designated faculty member to get them on track. teaching certainly imposes a greater investment from the
Examples: faculty as a close follow-up of each student is necessary
1. Explain the neuroanatomical bases of peritoneal to orientate his way of working. The gross anatomy
pain. sessions usually clear-up misunderstood points and may
2. Identify the muscles of the shoulder on a CT scan of a actually be considered as a substitute to traditional
patient with poliomyelitis and severe atrophy of the lectures.
left arm and determination of the nerves involved. As noted by several authors [1–3], the time allotted to
cadaver dissection has decreased progressively in most
universities. This may result in a dramatic impairment of
the understanding of anatomy required to start prac-
Discussion ticing medicine safely and competently. It is noteworthy
that, in the curriculum described, the number of hours
The anatomy curriculum described in this paper differs allocated to work in gross anatomy laboratories, both in
dramatically from the traditional methods of teaching. absolute and in relative (41 h, and 31.3% of the global
One of its most striking aspects is the use of clinical time allocated to anatomy and histology), is higher than
material to introduce anatomy. In the tutorial example in most of the traditional forms of curriculum [6].
provided, the students have to understand the patho- Hence, we believe that the progressive diminution of the
194

work in gross anatomy laboratories is not an effect of reported. One could assume that the basic knowledge of
the new pathway approach, but instead can be explained anatomy may be higher right after following a tradi-
by the fact that new disciplines have emerged which tional way of teaching, but it remained unclear how it
influence the overall make-up of the medical curriculum. would persist at the long term, since problem solving has
Interestingly, the entire curriculum of anatomy, with the been shown to be a more efficient process of memori-
exception of neuroanatomy and additional course of zation [5, 12]. Hence, an evaluation would have to be
clinical anatomy, is covered during the eight first weeks done latter in the medical curriculum and should take
of the medical studies, and the global number of hours is into consideration the ability to find an anatomical
lower than with a traditional curriculum which is usually interpretation to a clinical problem.
spread over a period of 2–3 years. This compaction of
the curriculum of anatomy may facilitate the perception Acknowledgements We would like to thank Geoffrey Liu for shar-
of the body as a whole and the understanding of sub- ing his experience of teaching and for his critical reading of the
manuscript, and Amel Ounnoughene for her technical support.
sequent disciplines. The integration of histology to the
curriculum gives the students a broader vision of struc-
tural anatomy, and may result in an additional gain of
References
time due to a better coordination of the disciplines.
Neuroanatomy is taught as part of the 8 weeks block 1. Aziz MA, McKenzie JC, Wilson JS, Cowie RJ, Ayeni SA,
called ‘‘Human Nervous System and Behavior’’ during Dunn BK (2002) The human cadaver in the age of biomedical
the second year. It comprises two 3-h laboratory ses- informatics. Anat Rec 269:20–32
sions/week that include dissection of human brain, 2. Cahill DR, Leonard RJ (1999) Missteps and masquerade in
radiological anatomy and some neuropathology. American medical academe: clinical anatomists call for action.
Clin Anat 12:220–222
An optional summer course of clinical anatomy is 3. Cahill DR, Leonard RJ, Marks SC Jr (2000) A comment on
offered to the third year medical students interested in recent teaching of human anatomy in the United States. Surg
surgery or radiology. During these sessions, an average Radiol Anat 22:69–71
of 30 students will review basic anatomy in a clinical 4. Chevrel JP (1995) The modern teaching of modern anatomy.
Surg Radiol Anat 17:285–286
context, complete guided dissections based on surgical 5. Finucane PM, Johnson SM, Prideaux DJ (1998) Problem-
approaches in the gross anatomy laboratory and attend based learning: its rationale and efficacy. Med J Aust
clinical anatomy lectures by leading surgeons and radi- 168:445–448
ologists in a variety of clinical specialties. 6. Heylings DJ (2002) Anatomy 1999–2000: the curriculum, who
teaches it and how? Med Educ 36:702–710
The profile of the faculty panel in Harvard Medical 7. Jones DG (1999) Research-based clinical anatomists: response
School also contrasts with most of the universities to ‘‘AACA: purpose, vitality and pride’’. American Association
over Europe, in which anatomy is essentially taught by of Clinical Anatomists. Clin Anat 12:223–224
surgeons or radiologists. Although this aspect is 8. Levine MG, Stempak J, Conyers G, Walters JA (1999) Imple-
also often criticized [13], the diversification of area of menting and integrating computer-based activities into a
problem-based gross anatomy curriculum. Clin Anat
expertise, including biologists and nonphysicians, per- 12:191–198
mits to increase the number of teachers available. It 9. McLean M (2003) What can we learn from facilitator and
remains to be determined whether the additional costs student perceptions of facilitation skills and roles in the first
required to pay the faculty salaries ($200,000 per year at year of a problem-based learning curriculum? BMC Med Educ
3:9
Harvard Medical School for the curriculum of anatomy) 10. Miller SA, Perrotti W, Silverthorn DU, Dalley AF, Rarey KE
would be acceptable in other universities. However, it is (2002) From college to clinic: reasoning over memorization is
noteworthy that the student’s fees (approximately key for understanding anatomy. Anat Rec 269:69–80
$25,000 a year) do not significantly differ from other 11. Reidenberg JS, Laitman JT (2002) The new face of gross
anatomy. Anat Rec 269:81–88
universities in United States. 12. Schmidt HG (1983) Problem-based learning: rationale and
Evaluation of the level of medical students who description. Med Educ 17:11–16
learned anatomy in a traditional versus problem-based 13. Skandalakis JE (2000) The teaching of anatomy. A dialogue
learning setting would be extremely interesting, as well with a cell biologist. Surg Radiol Anat 22:1–2
as an evaluation of the global cost of each curriculum. 14. Tosteson DC (1990) New pathways in general medical educa-
tion. N Engl J Med 322:234–238
To our knowledge, such an evaluation has never been

Anda mungkin juga menyukai