Shannon Walsh
To cite this article: Shannon Walsh (2015) Addressing sexual violence and rape
culture: Issues and interventions targeting boys and men, Agenda, 29:3, 134-141, DOI:
10.1080/10130950.2015.1050817
abstract
While girl-led projects that address sexual violence can empower girls to seek consent and to understand their right to
safety, this alone cannot deal with the reality of everyday violence. While girls are told to empower themselves and to
voice their concerns, the surrounding cultural environment often reinforces silence, dismissal and retribution towards
women who speak out. Men and boys need to be part of the solution. This briefing investigates the potentials of pro-
feminist approaches to gender-based violence (GBV) targeting boys and men.
Using examples from South Africa and North America, I look at various approaches and initiatives taken by and
with men and boys, often with a desire to centre more radical analysis of patriarchy within the work itself. The
briefing unpacks some of the dilemmas and potentials that have been raised by working with men and boys as allies
around sexual violence, and ways to distinguish pro-feminist projects.
keywords
masculinities, patriarchy, gender-based violence (GBV), rape culture, interventions
briefing
donor funding is being funnelled to male
given more credence. For us, this didn’t focused initiatives. In South Africa:
mean to throw up our hands and say that
it’s sexist for men to become leaders; “Gender stripped of notions of power and
rather we said it gave us a particular taken to mean ‘women and men’ has
responsibility to be leaders (as well as resulted in greater attention to men as
particular challenges to do so in a way key actors working for gender equality.
that did not take away women’s voices or This in turn has resulted in an increasing
leadership)” (ibid.:150) [emphasis mine]. shift in donor funding to men and boys,
most notably in HIV and AIDS and health
While Kaufman is right to say men hold power programmes, further threatening women’s
and many will trust and believe men more, movements, and seeming to represent the
this solution delinks violence with its struc- handing over of the reins of gender equality
tural root in patriarchy – violence that comes struggles to men” (Meer, 2013:30).
from modes of entitlement, privilege and
power. This approach is mimicked in other There is a real danger when men are targeted
campaigns such as Real Men and Man Up, for initiatives (often through donor emphasis
which problematise traditional masculinities and funding) it is in ways that both co-opt
at the same time that they promote an idea of funding from frontline women’s issues, and
men taking care of vulnerable women. Even reinvent patriarchal ideas about what needs
though Kaufman explicitly says this was not to be done to end gender based violence. A
their intention, and calls the work pro-femin- quantitative study showing where, and to
ist, it is difficult not to see the problematic whom, money flows in relation to GBV issues
tone. This slippage points to the complexity in is urgently needed.
teasing out what pro-feminist projects could
look like when deeply entrenched and com-
plex power structures organise so much of Conclusions: Diversity of
how the world is experienced by both men
and women.
approaches, consent, and analysis
It is important to recognise that the sexualisa-
tion of coercion and socialisation runs very
there is real potential for education campaigns deep, as evidenced in a new study in the US
that found almost one third of male university
focused on consent to broaden what men and
student respondents claimed they would rape
boys understand rape to mean a woman if there were no consequences
(Edwards et al, 2014). Central to their findings
Contrast this approach to men’s writing in
was the significant difference in positive
On the Road to Healing (Men’s Centre, 1999)
responses between respondents who claimed
which acknowledges up front the dangers of
they would use coercion to have sexual rela-
falling in the trap of taking over once again,
tions (31.7%), and those who would use the
and attempts to foreground the need to
label ‘rape’ (13.6%). This indicates that there
encourage men to listen and believe women’s
is real potential for education campaigns
voices. As Shamim Meer laments in her report
focused on consent to broaden what men
‘Struggles for Gender Equality: Reflection on
and boys understand rape to mean. That said,
the place of men and men’s organisations’ the study also found that men most likely to
(Meer, 2011:4): “Men are once more in charge say they would rape (using that terminology)
- only this time they’re in charge of women’s also held antagonistic and deep-seated negat-
liberation struggles.” The idea that men are in ive feelings about women. Their findings have
charge, and necessary as caretakers of wo- significant implications for programmes tar-
men is often reproduced in the kinds of geting men, and they specifically reject a one-
projects that get funded and publicised. size-fits all approach, stating:
The potential for depoliticising sexual and
gender-based violence in order to bring men “If men who sexually assault harbour dif-
into leadership roles is a real concern. This is ferent motivations to varying degrees,
exacerbated in South Africa where resource identifying them ahead of time and target-
drain is a significant issue, and there has been ing interventions toward groups of men
increasing discussion about how much of the with similar motivations, or better even,
briefing
Action for Equality, Development and Peace -
to end men’s violence: Statement of principles’, Platform for Action’. United Nations, available at:
November 1991, available at: http://wwwmi http://www.un.org/esa/gopher-data/conf/fwcw/
chaelkaufman.com, site accessed 6 March 2015. off/a–20.en, site accessed 6 March 2015.
United Nations (UN) (1995) ‘Fourth World Conference
on Women, Beijing, China – September 1995