Abstract:
Philanthropy in Islam
Charity is one of the five pillars of faith in Islam and is obligatory for every Muslim. As
such, it channels massive wealth, both in material and human forms. Throughout this
paper charity and philanthropy will be used interchangeably.
Charities have played many significant functions in Islamic societies and have
contributed to making these societies more just and fair through a number of
mechanisms, in addition to the ultimate objective of upliftment of the poor. Islamic
charities served as an instrument for narrowing social distance and reducing inequalities.
1
In particular, these charities served as a linkage between the haves and the have-nots.
They have provided a way, by which the wealthier elements of society interact with poor
individuals, and to assist them in combating poverty, its causes, and effects.
Charitable giving in the form of Zakat is one of the basic tenets of Islam, a donation equal
to 2.5 percent of annual income required for all Muslims who have resources remaining
after meeting the basic requirements of their family. While Zakat is the only obligatory
from of charity, additional voluntary giving is also prevalent, and takes various forms,
such as Infak (a voluntary gift for restricted purpose) and Sadaqah (voluntary or
discretionary charity, not necessarily monetary in nature for unrestricted purposes).
In addition to individual giving, Islam also has a highly structured pattern of institutional
religious foundations called Waqf (pl: Awqaf). These foundations can be endowed by
individuals, families, or institutions and they often have income-producing activities
attached. Not all awqaf have served strictly religious purposes, however. A study of
Turkish awqaf founded in the eighteenth century showed that less than one-third were
clearly religious while almost one-half provided secular services (Kuran 2001, 13).
2
Problems surrounding management of Islamic Philanthropy
Although philanthropy is high, and there is a promising giving culture in Muslim world,
the challenge remains how to mobilize and manage these resources to achieve
development, and help save this enormous wealth from being lost in never-ending circles
of charity that on the long run create dependency and do not achieve whether
development nor attempts to solve issues of community development.
Over the centuries, Islamic charities emerged as the major provider of large economic
wealth devoted for development purposes of the weaker section of society.
Unfortunately, concomitant with the rapid growth of institutional Islamic philanthropy,
poor governance and mismanagement also became a problem within the sector, providing
the modern states just the excuse they needed to step in and expropriate Islamic charitable
assets (Bremer, 2004). Even Muslims are less concerned about the use of their
philanthropy, arguing that their responsibility ends with fulfillment of the obligation to
give, and that charitable institution have to account for their use of funds.
As the charities grew in number the sector suffered from poor governance. While many
charities continued to serve the communities and families for which they were created the
assets of many were diverted to illicit private use or fell into a pattern of seemingly
endless legal disputes. In many countries, the state seized upon these abuses as the excuse
it needed to repress privately managed charities. In the name of reform the state moved
3
to assume control over how charitable assets could be used to take the revenues for its
own, and then to seize the assets themselves, greatly limiting or even eliminating
privately managed charities altogether.
In this regard it can be seen that mismanaged awqaf are becoming a nearly
insurmountable block to development. Since awqaf properties could not be sold,
unutilized or mismanaged waqf properties could fall into abandonment and ruin, thus
undermining the financial stability of the social services that depended on them. Disputes
over poor or corrupt awqaf management are common and could drag on for decades
while properties committed to crumble. A recent study by the Aga Khan Foundation on
Pakistan finds that giving by Pakistanis is four times the amount of foreign aid that
Pakistan receives. However, the muzzling of endowments (awqaf) has thwarted the
philanthropic capability and aspiration of the Muslim communities.
Before the paper go into the in-depth analysis of Shariah based venture philanthropy it
would be appropriate to define what venture philanthropy in practice is?
Venture philanthropy can be defined as:
“The use by grant-makers and investors of certain principles traditionally associated with
venture capitalists to either build the capacity of a non-profit organization or to invest in a
social purpose business venture. Key elements include long-term relationships (three to
six years), development of business plans, provision of cash and expertise, and an exit
4
strategy. Donors and/or investors make long-term funding commitments, closely monitor
performance objectives through pre-defined measurement tools, and problem-solve
jointly with the leadership team on a regular basis” (The Institute for Social
Entrepreneurs).
Where as Social Venture Partners defined it as: “Venture Philanthropy takes some of the
principles of venture capitalism and applies them to philanthropy. Venture Philanthropy
is the process whereby, (usually wealthy) individuals invest time and money in voluntary
organisations and social enterprises. Venture Philanthropy means funding organizations
with not only financial resources, but also management and technical support. This
support is focused on enabling nonprofits to build greater organizational capacity and
infrastructure via long term, engaged relationships with investees.”
It is apparent from both the definitions above that whereas both traditional and venture
philanthropy funds seek to raise capital from high net-worth individuals and institutions,
Shariah-compliant venture philanthropy funds will focus on raising money from Zakat
Sadaqah and monetary waqf, the charitable contributions given by faithful Muslims.
While public institutions in a few Muslim countries are very well developed in both
collecting and allocating Zakat and Sadaqah, in many Muslim and non-Muslim countries,
no such developed collection and allocation mechanism exists. As a result, Zakat and
Sadaqah resources are often under-leveraged and not effectively applied towards helping
the Ummah. Venture philanthropy funds will provide an effective mechanism for pooling
Zakat and Sadaqah funds towards maximising their impact upon the Ummah and
promoting greater sustainable community development.
This section will discuss the model or mechanism on which Shariah based venture
philanthropy will be applied for an establishment for International Islamic Charitable
Foundation. This foundation will act in deliberate and planned manner to for poverty
5
alleviation and sustainable development for Muslim communities worldwide. The
proposed model is shown in figure 1.
6
4
1 Islamic
Banking
Investment Relief Work
2
Country
1 International Islamic
Charitable Foundation
3
4
1
Islamic Education
Projects Projects
2
Country
2
3
4
1
Islamic Community
2 Capital Empowerment
Country Market
3
3
1-4
Represents Small Charitable
Fig. 1: Islamic Venture Philanthropy Model Bodies
7
As in establishing any successful global financial firm, the development of Shariah-
compliant venture philanthropy foundation will be a long and tedious process. In
additional to the traditional steps and partnerships required in establishing this
foundation, stakeholder analysis, partner identification as well as project selection will be
essential steps in order to generate both economic and social returns from the
establishment.
The first and foremost step in successful establishment of this foundation will be
approval from all the countries having exorbitant wealth base from Islamic charities. A
charter has to be formulated clearly outlining the objective and mission of this global
entity duly approved by all the member countries. The ultimate objective of International
Islamic Charitable Foundation (IICF) will be generating profit from different Islamic
investment projects which in turn can be applied for the betterment of the weaker section
of societies.
In order to establish IICF, all member countries have to mobilize the funds from scattered
charitable bodies, state and national level charitable institutions and NGOs receiving
charitable contributions from individuals and organizations. A national level institution
will monitor this work and will prepare the accounts of charitable amounts available for
the nation as whole. This process will be replicated among all the member countries of
IICF to create centralized account at IICF. IICF will maintain the books of each member
country and its corresponding contribution. Rest of the work will now be solely vested on
IICF which is explained in the following section.
The first step in the operation of the foundation will be to conduct a meticulous and
robust stakeholder analysis that will include all possible vested interests that could be
affected by the development and execution of the funds at IICF. Following stakeholder
analysis, it will be crucial to find appropriate partners and projects within both the
Islamic financial and social services sectors. The costs of poor or inadequate partners and
projects identification will not only hamper financial returns, but will also threaten to
destroy rather than generate social returns.
8
Once projects have been selected in the area of Islamic banking investments and Islamic
capital market the next step will be to decide on appropriate investment decision. Funds
from respective member countries will be invested in proportion to their total
contribution to IICF. Profit generated from these investments will be subjected to two
fold purpose. A part of profit will be kept aside for needy Muslim communities at
international level while the remaining will be given back to member countries in
proportion to their contribution for local community development.
Fund kept aside for global Muslim communities will be utilized for community
development programmes such as education projects, humanitarian works and
community empowerment, while the country specific profits will be used for local
development purposes. This will benefit respective countries in getting substantial
profitable return from vast amount of wealth lying idle for long time.
For IICF to be successful in its objective, it has to undertake the following key elements
of operation to generate the greatest social impact. These elements can be listed as:
9
• Provision of expertise: IICF will provide business expertise, project matter know
how, investor forums, evaluation expertise, etc. all necessary for tackling the
biggest social issues enveloping Islamic community.
Thus with the application of this Islamic venture philanthropy model, disorganized and
mismanaged charitable bodies that often lack the business, leadership and planning
capacity to impact social issues at significant scale can make a difference at larger scale.
With the support of managerial expertise and guidance from proposed IICF they can
develop effective program assessment techniques and improve technology systems to
demonstrate the value of services for Muslim communities at large.
As we are aware that the needs of the Ummah are diverse and vary significantly between
countries and even within any specific region. Nevertheless, there are certain needs that
are global, the first of which is education. Human capital, as any entrepreneur knows, is
the essential element to development, and one of the key criterion used when assessing an
investment opportunity. When we look at investment in education, especially in the
Muslim world, we find there is significant underinvestment, especially at the lower levels
of the socio-economic stratum. Investment in educational institutions be it in their
10
construction or operation within local education centers, such as Masjids and schools, can
generate significant return on both the financial and social levels.
All Muslim countries are preparing Poverty Reduction Programmes (PRP) required by
donor agencies to provide funds for development. Many of these countries have extreme
poverty as people are suffering from starvation, hunger, diseases, absence of potable
drinking water. Even though some of these countries have an organized system of
collection and distribution of Zakat and are also supervising Awqaf under government
machinery. But none of these countries has integrated the institutions of Zakat and
Awqaf in their PRP. With this proposed model of IICF, these countries will have a solid
platform for better management of these funds and integrating them with PRP.
One more important aspect will be informal activities of IICF. One such activity is
responding to natural disasters such as earthquakes and floods. Muslim charities have
earned acclaim for their performance in such circumstances, often providing more rapid
and effective responses than government agencies with the same tasks. Their quick
provision of emergency aid to victims of the tsunami that hit Indonesia and Sri Lanka in
December 2004 is a recent example. At the country level, profit will be directed towards
society’s infrastructure, especially healthcare, social housing, community care,
environmental programs, education and training. IICF with its local counterpart will also
s arranges funding for these services.
Islam requires us, and in fact blesses us, with the obligation to give to others. We can
assert that this Shariah-compliant venture philanthropy program in leveraging Zakat and
Sadaqah can be an essential driver in addressing the development needs of Muslim
countries while simultaneously generating significant financial returns and growth.
11
This combined approach of wealth creation, wealth transfer, and openness to inter
sectoral and market-based approaches for social change could attract and unleash an
unprecedented level of new financial resources and better community development
through Islamic venture philanthropy. Islamic venture philanthropy incorporating new
approaches for social investment and the creation of social capital using new tools and
approaches will stretch philanthropy beyond traditional grant making into more growth
and development oriented models.
Concluding Thoughts
It is high time to recognize that Islamic charities are important and potentially powerful
tool for sustainable community development, but in order to be effective in its ultimate
objective of development of weaker section of society they must overcome several
internal and external challenges if they are to carry out their duty effectively. To
overcome these obstacles a well planned strategy like proposed model of IICF have to be
well established in practice. Issues related to Islamic philanthropy have its implications
for different aspects of the reform agenda for Muslim communities: economic growth,
social harmony, reform of social services and sustained community development. Despite
growing interest in Islamic microfinance in last few years, the Islamic charitable sectors
remains poorly understood. Case studies, working paper series and comparative studies
are urgently needed to help build an understanding of this wealthier sector within Islamic
world.
12
Bibliography
Bremer, Jennifer, ‘Islamic Philanthropy: Reviving Traditional Forms for Building Social
Justice’ (Paper presented at Fifth Annual Conference on ‘Defining and Establishing
Justice in Muslim Societies,’ Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy, Washington
DC, 28-29 May 2004):
www.islam-democracy.org/documents/pdf/5th_Annual_Conference_Bremer_paper.pdf
on 20 November 2007
Ismail, Zafar Hameed, (2002), ‘Law and the Nonprofit Sector in Pakistan’ (Social Policy
and Development Centre Working Paper No. 3, in collaboration with the Aga Khan
Foundation (Pakistan) and the Center for Civil Society Studies, Johns Hopkins
University)
Ismail, Zafar Hameed and Quadeer Baig, (2004), ‘Philanthropy and Law in Pakistan’ in
Mark Sidel and Iftekhar Zaman (eds), Philanthropy and Law in South Asia
Kahf, Monzer, ‘Waqf and its sociopolitical aspects’ (1992) [published by Islamic
Research and Training Institute (IRTI) of the Islamic Development Bank (IDB), Jeddah,
Saudi Arabia]
http://monzer.kahf.com/papers/english/WAQF%20and%20its%20Sociopolitical%20Aspe
cts.pdf on 20 November 2007
13
Kuran, T. (1986), The economic system in contemporary Islamic thought: Interpretation
and assessment. International Journal of Middle East Studies 18 (2): 135–64.
Kuran, T. (1995), Islamic economics and the Islamic subeconomy. Journal of Economic
Perspectives 9 (4): 155–73.
Kuran, T. (2001), ‘The Provision of Public Goods under Islamic Law: Origins, Impact,
and Limitations of the Waqf System’ 35 Law and Society Review 841
Sidel, Mark and Iftekhar Zaman. (2004), ‘Philanthropy and Law in South Asia: Key
Themes and Key Choices’ in Mark Sidel and Iftekhar Zaman (eds), Philanthropy and
Law in South Asia.
14