Cave) 1
Sarah J. Parker
Longwood University
Case Study (M. Cave) 2
III. Assessment
Mia Cave is an 11th grade student in my Social Studies Skills class, which is the
last block of the day and is composed of four students including her. Mia was
assessed during on a one-to-one basis during class over the course of five class
meeting days. Mia was cooperative, engaged, and responded to the best of her
ability; however, at times, she communicated she felt tired and informed me I was
“torturing” her. Mia requested several breaks in between assessments in addition
to rewards because she said I “owe” her for putting her through the assessment.
Case Study (M. Cave) 4
Case Study (M. Cave) 5
Section 2: Mia was administered the QRI in February 2019. Results indicated
that Mia is on instructional level when automatically identifying words on 1st
(85%) and 2nd grade level (75%), and Mia exhibited frustration with
automatically identifying words on 3rd grade level (60%); however, when given
time to decode words untimed, Mia was able to identify 100% of the 1st grade
words, 90% of the 2nd grade words, and she was able to identify 80% of the 3rd
grade words. When asked to read a 2nd grade level narrative passage, Mia read
with 96% accuracy at 101 words per minute. Mia scored 100% on
comprehension. When given a 3rd grade level narrative passage, Mia was able to
read with 94% accuracy at 76 words per minute. When given a 4th grade level
passage, Mia was able to read with 97% accuracy at 81 words per minute, but her
comprehension score was 62.5%. In other words, Mia reads at a slow rate, but she
comprehends what she reads and hears. Most miscues were due to decoding and
were similar in articulation (for example: “plus” instead of “pulse” or “types”
instead of “tapes”). Other miscues included insertion of words such as “so” prior
to a sentence or including “in” after “fell” or including “struggling” between
“kicking strongly”. Mia also said “blow” instead of “blew high” and omitted
Case Study (M. Cave) 6
some words in some areas such as omitting “water” in “he was about to go under
(water)”. Mia substituted “and” for “as” and “at” for “as” as well. Most errors
were similar in meaning, and some were still made the sentence grammatically
correct. Despite errors, Mia was able to answer all comprehension questions
accurately through the 3rd grade level. Mia communicated she did not enjoy
reading the passages out loud. Mia was administered the Words their Way
Elementary Spelling Inventory Feature Guide. Results indicated she was
frequently exhibiting confusions with Common Long Vowels: (flote instead of
float, trane instead of train, brite instead of bright) and Other Vowel Patterns:
(spole instead of spoil, surveing instead of serving, muched instead of marched).
These results indicate she is spelling on the Middle Within Word Pattern level of
development. Mia sometimes writes in complete simple sentence structures at
times including combination of two adjectives or objects, but she writes in
fragments, uses weak verbs, exhibits little variability in sentence structures, and
makes frequent errors with spelling/grammar. Given results from these
assessments, Mia is instructionally reading in the 2nd-3rd grade range, which is
considerably below her grade level.
Section 3: Mia's disability in Broad Reading affects her education. Because Mia
struggles with her abilities in decoding, fluency, spelling, and writing, Mia has not
developed the skillset needed to complete work on grade level involving reading
and writing at a reasonable pace compared to her peers. She often will use
incorrect grammar and sentence structure when writing passages. Mia utilizes her
audio resources often, and she will opt to respond verbally instead of in writing
unless she is given the option to copy and paste responses using her Chromebook
or the option to circle answers and draw lines to the question. Mia frequently uses
her spell check software accommodation on her computer when asked to
complete written assignments. On independent reading tasks, she prefers to read
on her own instead of having an adult read to her, which would make it difficult
for Mia to comprehend texts she reads independently and analyze in the general
education classes. Grade level content texts contain vocabulary she would
struggle to comprehend, and her writing skillset would make it difficult for her to
exhibit proof to the teacher she has learned the content.
Additionally, remaining on task can be a struggle for Mia, and she will
occasionally request to take walks especially when she feels frustrated.
Occasionally, she requires prompts to begin her classwork, take her seat, or lift
her head. She is highly motivated by rewards, opportunities to work outside or
other areas of the building, and leisure time. Mia does sometimes advocate for
herself by asking for help, however this is only after being asked by a teacher
before requesting assistance. When asked what was difficult for her she has
difficulty being specific and commonly says, "I don’t understand any of it" or "I
don't know". With teacher prompting, she is often able to identify the specific
problem. Mia receives special education services in the Skills Math, English and
the Life Skills Social/Science class to address weakness due to Broad Reading.
Case Study (M. Cave) 7
Because she is not able to complete grade level work, receives specially designed
instruction that is below grade level and taught by a special education teacher in a
special education class. Her skills are below grade level, and she requires
instruction on a modified curriculum with redirection. Mia requires extra support
due to distractible behaviors, weaknesses in working memory, and her skillset in
reading. Mia responds well to adapted texts, graphic organizers, and hands-on
activities.
Instructional Plan
Use the Graphic Organizer below to list the highlights of your instructional plan.
Unit EQ:
Lesson Lesson Readin Word Comprehension Writing
Question g for Knowledge
Fluency
Activity highlighting
: read important details
aloud
poetry Outcome
Assessed:
Vocabulary
was assessed by
informal
observation
while filling out
a graphic
organizer. Mia
is still working
on learning
how to identify
reminder
words and use
reference
words to build
sentences. She
had no trouble
locating a
picture online
but using all
the columns to
build a sentence
should be a
skill she
continues to
work on. Mia
was able to
silently read,
obtain some
general
understanding
of what she
read, highlight
details with
prompt, and
provide a
verbal
statement. She
continues to
work on
putting those
Case Study (M. Cave) 10
thoughts in
writing.
3 How did the Text General Text title: Task:
completion of title: feature: EI vs Railroad Networks Journal
the AI
Transcontinent
Text
al Railroad source: Sort Text source: US
affect the Shel categories: History Shorts 2 Skill
growth and Silverstei sound and Text level: 3rd focus:
settlement in n Poetry word pattern Write in
the West? Text Content focus: a
level: Activity: Rail Road complet
2nd word sort Expansions e
and summary sentence
Skill of rules Skill focus:
focus: distinguishin Vocabulary,
phrasal g the spelling Identifying and
fluency pattern highlighting
important details
Activity
: read Outcome
aloud Assessed:
poetry Outcome
Assessed:
Vocabulary
was assessed by
informal
observation
while filling out
a graphic
organizer. Mia
is still working
on learning
how to identify
reminder
words and use
reference
words to build
sentences. She
had no trouble
locating a
picture online
but using all
the columns to
build a sentence
should be a
skill she
continues to
Case Study (M. Cave) 11
on learning
how to identify
reminder
words and use
reference
words to build
sentences. She
had no trouble
locating a
picture online
but using all
the columns to
build a sentence
should be a
skill she
continues to
work on. Mia
was able to
silently read,
obtain some
general
understanding
of what she
read, highlight
details with
prompt, and
provide a
verbal
statement. She
continues to
work on
putting those
thoughts in
writing.
5 What problems Text General Text title: Help Task:
did workers title: feature: EE for Factory Workers Journal
face at the turn vs EA
of the century?
Text
source: Sort Text source: US
Shel categories: History Shorts 2 Skill
Silverstei sound and Text level: 3rd focus:
n Poetry word pattern Write in
Text Content focus: a
level: Activity: Factory Workers complet
2nd word sort e
and summary Skill focus: sentence
Skill of rules Vocabulary,
focus: distinguishin Identifying and
Case Study (M. Cave) 13
Activity Outcome
: read Assessed:
aloud Outcome
poetry Assessed:
Vocabulary
was assessed by
informal
observation
while filling out
a graphic
organizer. Mia
is still working
on learning
how to identify
reminder
words and use
reference
words to build
sentences. She
had no trouble
locating a
picture online
but using all
the columns to
build a sentence
should be a
skill she
continues to
work on. Mia
was able to
silently read,
obtain some
general
understanding
of what she
read, highlight
details with
prompt, and
provide a
verbal
statement. She
continues to
work on
Case Study (M. Cave) 14
putting those
thoughts in
writing.
Overarchin Mia will identify major benefits and risks people made to expand and how it impacted
g Outcome the quality of life in America for settlers and Native Americans. Mia will be
motivated by this topic because loves the country life in Powhatan County in addition
Assignment to easy access to resources and activities that entertain her busy social life. She enjoys
Related to having her space without being disconnected, so Mia will consider how she would
EQ: feel if someone expanded into her space, if it were to be over-crowded/over-taken in a
movement like westward expansion.
Fluency
Since my student is reading on 2nd grade level, she is working on improving her
phrasal fluency accuracy, rate, and expression by reading aloud poetry such as selections
fluent reading is processing words at an acceptable rate, fluency also entails reading
meaningful phrases and with appropriate expression”. Because she is reading in smaller
groupings with little expression, this goal is appropriate as eventually this will build on
her ability to retrieve knowledge and understanding from higher level passages.
Word Knowledge
on 2nd grade level in isolation, she is working on decoding words with complex long
vowels in the within word pattern of spelling. Since she is in high school and far behind,
we are also working on using word parts to decode multi-syllabic words to help build her
confidence. She is working on this by completing word sorts and reading decodable
reading activities. Because she is student with higher comprehension, she heavily relies
on context clues to help her figure out puzzling words. According to Gunning on page
Case Study (M. Cave) 15
253, when a student overuses context clues, the student should have “wide reading of
easy materials” because “poor readers often need extra practice for their skills to become
automatic.” Additionally, Gunning states, “before students read a section, review key
phonics patterns that appear in the piece, so the student will ne better prepared to use
needed phonic skills” and “review the phonics strategies for attacking unknown words.
When students are stumped by a word, ask ‘What can you do to figure out that word?
Are there any parts that you can say? Is the word like any word you know?’” Based on
this information, the strategies used to complete word sorts and decodable readings are
appropriate in addition to the vocabulary capsule strategy I am teaching her prior to the
words, and I am teaching her word parts, so she can learn to piece unfamiliar words
together in isolation rather than just using context clues. Lack of word knowledge makes
reading and writing difficult because students spend more time trying to figure out how to
decode and spell instead of the content which makes it difficult to stay connected to what
students read and write. While this is not automatic, the goal is eventually it will become
automatic as she practices over time; therefore, word knowledge is another key ingredient
Comprehension
and using strategies to understand unfamiliar words such as identifying word parts and
familiar words and using the word in a sentence prior to reading. According to Gunning
on page 311, “using graphic organizers to process words at a deeper level can increase
Case Study (M. Cave) 16
students’ retention of the words”. Many students, including my student, say unfamiliar
words and vocabulary make reading hard. If a student cannot make sense of vocabulary,
it makes it difficult for students to convey the message they are reading. Because these
students are only focusing on the surface of reading or writing task, they struggle to make
Writing
on page 469, “quick writes enable students to get their ideas down on paper and to write
struggling writer and is reluctant to write in complete sentences, this serves the need for
essential questions with comprehension and writing plans in reading passages and her
writing quick writes.
During the tutoring process, Mia demonstrated her greatest strength is in her
verbal comprehension and how she can use strategies such as context clues to help her
understand text she reads. She demonstrated significant weaknesses in her ability to
automatically decode, but in reflection to her work habits, she demonstrated use of
learned strategies to accommodate her weaknesses in reading. Mia struggles greatly and
is very reluctant to compose simple complete sentences even when given the tools and
technology to help her with her spelling. While she is pursuing an Applied Studies
diploma, this is suitable for graduation requirements; however, she recently
communicated an interest in enlisting in the military. This was very concerning as her
case manager since she is not on track with the appropriate course of study or the skillset
to pursue a General Education Diploma or a Standard Diploma without investing
additional years after her expected date of graduation in courses she will most likely
struggle to pass.
Mia’s lessons in the areas of phrasal fluency, word study, vocabulary, and writing
were generally just right for her needs. She demonstrated challenges with complex long
vowel patterns especially if provided more than two at a time. When completing
vocabulary tasks, it was helpful for Mia to locate pictures prior to writing as sentence to
help her formulate an idea before writing about it. Comprehension-wise, it was helpful
for Mia to read a passage on grade level; however, it would be beneficial for Mia to
continue to read high interest books and complete tasks such as “Somebody Wanted But
So” and “Book, Head, Heart, Questions” reflections. It would be helpful also for Mia to
continue quick writes in addition to journal entries, which would be more personally
driven than content driven. I continue to look for ways to do this and meet the content
demands within a timely manner.
The QRI and WTW Spelling Inventory were effective in gaining perspective on
Mia’s ability to decode, read, and spell words. Continuous informal observations and
writing samples are also beneficial for measuring progress and determining her needs for
instruction.
1. For the progress monitoring section, you will monitor what you previously
identified as an area of instructional need. Simply put, you are trying to
measure the influence of your instruction. You likely have some of this
information in your reflective comments. In this section, you should bring in
something more objective (i.e., running record, spelling quick check on
covered features, writing prompt, etc.). After the final progress monitoring is
completed in the last lessons, write no more than a one-page summary of the
results. You are encouraged to include a visual representation (i.e., graph,
chart, etc.) of growth, if applicable.
Case Study (M. Cave) 19
2. For the "What you Learned" section, in no more than 1-page, describe what
you collectively learned from the objective progress monitoring you were able
to complete, the subjective final interview/discussion you had, and your
reflections on your tutee's learning throughout the sessions. How have the
results and reflections (re-)informed your thinking (i.e., If you were to rewrite
a new instructional plan for the student’s teacher to implement, what advice
would you share? Where would you start?). Did you see growth? Areas for
more instructional review?
References