The Tussle With China in The Mekong Basin

4/24/2019 The tussle with China in the Mekong Basin, SE Asia News & Top Stories - The Straits
mp; Top Stories - The Straits Times
THE STRAITS TIMES

AsianWriters'Circle
The tussle with China in the Mekong

Basin
Supalak Ganjanakhundee
 PUBLISHED NOV 17, 2018, 5:00 AM SGT

Cooperation between the six countries of the region needs to improve for
mutual benefit
Countries in the Mekong Basin, notably those located in the lower part of the river - Asia's seventh longest -
are in need of a collective strategy to secure their future, given China's control of the upstream part and
ongoing changes in global geopolitics.
The 4,909km river runs from Tibet in China through Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam.
But only its lower portion is regulated by an international agreement and an organisation.
The lower part is popularly known as the Mekong, while the upper part in China is called the Lancang.
While all six countries in the basin increasingly utilise resources from the Mekong - such as for the
construction of dams in its mainstream and major tributaries, navigation and fishery - there remains no
clear procedures for all countries to ensure proper management of the environment and fair resource
distribution.
Differences and sometimes disputes over water resource utilisation and management have occurred
occasionally over the past decade, when some of these activities led to cross-boundary impacts in the
subregion.
Hydro-power construction and operation in the Mekong mainstream in China and Laos' territories have
also caused severe impact to the downstream countries. Dams can create fluctuation of water flows, block
navigation routes and prevent the natural migration of fish up and down the river.
Four countries in the lower Mekong comprising Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam signed an
agreement back in 1995 to establish regulations for river utilisation and set up the Mekong River
Commission (MRC) to coordinate and enforce the agreement.
https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/the-tussle-with-china-in-the-mekong-basin 1/9
4/24/2019 The tussle with China in the Mekong Basin, SE Asia News & Top Stories - The Straits Times
As the intergovernmental organisation, the MRC is struggling to influence the decisions of the individual
sovereign nations over the water utilisation, with Laos, a member, deciding to push ahead with the
construction of Xayaburi and Don Sahong dams in the Mekong mainstream. More dams, including those in
Pak Beng
Thisand
sitePak Lay,
uses are in to
cookies thehelp
pipeline.
us serve you better. By continuing to
explore our site, you accept our use of cookies.
✓ Accept
Thai soldiers at the Ban Kaen Kai operation base along the Mekong River at the border between Thailand and Laos. The
4,909km river runs through China, Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam. But the writer notes that only its
lower portion is regulated by an international agreement and an organisation. PHOTO: REUTERS
While the MRC's major mechanism under the 1995 agreement, known as the Procedures for Notification,
Prior Consultation and Agreement (PNPCA), is blamed for not being so effective in influencing its
members' decisions, Laos has decided to redesign its Xayaburi project to be a more environmentally
friendly dam.
Although the creditability of the PNPCA as a mechanism to consult stakeholders is less, as seen in the
move by civic groups to boycott the latest public hearing on the planned Pak Lay dam recently, MRC
officials argue that the mechanism is the sole game in the region to handle the differences on development
projects.
The MRC and its four members now face another big challenge in terms of being able to manage the
Mekong Basin affairs, as China has sponsored the establishment of the Lancang-Mekong Cooperation
(LMC) in 2016 that includes all six Mekong countries into one framework.
While jurisdiction of the MRC and the LMC is different, there are some overlapping areas, particularly in
water resource management.
There have been calls over the past few years for the expansion of the MRC to cover the upper part of the
Mekong Basin, by inviting China and Myanmar to become full members.
Yet both have

This sitemaintained
uses cookiestheir
to status
help usasserve
"dialogue partners"
you better. since 1996.toWith this status, the MRC has been
By continuing
able toexplore
get a certain degree
our site, of cooperation
you accept our use on
✓ Acceptto share
water resource management, with China agreeing
of cookies.
hydrology information with the organisation.
But other matters remain illusive.
The LMC's institutions and mechanisms show trends of eclipsing the MRC in the near future as Beijing has
plenty of resources and funds to forge bilateral cooperation with countries downstream.
Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi, who oversees the LMC, has rejected the idea that the MRC is being
overshadowed and has suggested that the two organisations would support and complement each other.
This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

✓ Accept
The MRC also tries to have closer relations with the LMC's Water Resources Cooperation Centre.
MRC chief executive officer Pham Tuan Phan met senior Chinese officials in Kunming on the sidelines of
the First Lancang-Mekong Water Resources Cooperation Forum last week to discuss further cooperation
between the two organisations.
"China has welcomed our call to strengthen cooperation between the Lancang-Mekong Water Resources
Cooperation Centre and the MRC for the benefit of the whole Mekong River basin," said Dr Phan. "We will
be working on further identifying key areas of cooperation that are vital to our work for sustainable
development
This siteofuses
the Mekong
cookies River and
to help us the basin's
serve people."
you better. By continuing to
✓ Accept
According to Dr Phan, the head of the Chinese Joint Working Group for the centre Yu Xingjun said the
LMC was trying to find possible ways to work with the MRC.
One of the key areas where cooperation is needed is the sharing of flood forecast data from the Jing Hong
hydropower station.
Sharing of the hydrological data during the dry season will benefit development planning and drought
management in the Mekong, said Dr Phan.
In 2013, China and the MRC renewed the 2002 agreement on the provision of hydrological information on
the Mekong River.
Under the agreement, China now provides water-level data during the flood season for five months from
June to October twice daily from two stations located on the Mekong in China. This information is fed into
the MRC's flood forecasting system.
China contributes 13.5 per cent of the flow of the Mekong River, according to an MRC statement.
The MRC said it needs more cooperation from China and the LMC to update its strategic plans on
sustainable hydropower and basin development strategy.
"There is no better time than now for China to cooperate with the MRC if it is for the interest of the whole
basin population of over 70 million people," said Dr Phan.
Indeed, the proposal to have closer cooperation between the MRC and the LMC was stressed clearly during
an MRC summit in Cambodia's Siem Reap in April this year.
But the leaders of Cambodia, Laos, Thailand and Vietnam did not spell out the term "cooperation" clearly,
given the fact that many countries mostly rely on China under many other subregional cooperation
schemes.
Cooperation in this sense is not based on equality and reciprocity, but China in many aspects plays the role
of a "donor" country.
• The writer is editor of The Nation, Thailand.
• The Asian Writers' Circle is a series of columns on global affairs written by top editors and writers
from members of the Asia News Network and published in newspapers, websites and social media
platforms across the region.
Unlock more articles at just $0.99/month

Subscribe and get access to all Premium stories today. Cancel anytime.

✓ Accept
Subscribe Now
Andy Hui scandal: 5 Susan Lim granted Sri Lanka Deliveryman gets off
other celebrities who voluntary erasure explosions: Scale of with a warning for
survived infidelity from UK register attacks suggests abusive behaviour
scandals sophisticated
planning, training
 Apr 22, 2019  Apr 21, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019
Recommended by
MORE FROM THE STRAITS TIMES
Andy Hui scandal: Peeping Tom caught Faye Wong's CapitaLand raises
Hong Kong filming in NUS hall daughter wins Best $530m in first
broadcaster TVB in shower: Thousands Supporting Actress closing of equity
hurry to repair sign petitions calling award for movie fund
Jacqueline Wong for tougher action debut
 Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 22, 2019  Apr 23, 2019
FROM AROUND THE WEB

✓ Accept
NZXT's updated His E-Commerce Get Fancy With Under 65 And No

HUE 2 Ambient Story: From Zero To These Chanel Life Insurance? Why
lighting kit will Hero Selling Online Accessories 2019 Is The Time To
drench your On Qoo10 Change This
workstation in RGB
HardwareZone Workshop SG Sponsored Experts In Money Insurance
Recommended by
ST VIDEOS
'It was a river of blood': Dashcam footage shows explosion
outside Sri Lanka church
Sri Lanka explosions: Government says local Islamist group

behind blasts, to declare…
Netflix lands deal with Beyonce worth a reported US$60

million: Variety

✓ Accept
Victims of Sri Lanka attacks: Who they were
Recommended by
BRANDED CONTENT
CUT your risk of diabetes
5 Ways to Smarter Food Management at Home
It Changed My Life: She paddles to help others stay afloat
Radio DJ Andre Hoeden is tuned in to thrift and saving
Aspiring tech-entrepreneurs, you could be the future
Ask the expert: What are my chances of getting breast cancer?

✓ Accept
 Terms & Conditions  Data Protection Policy

 Need help? Reach us here.  Advertise with us
SPH Digital News / Copyright © 2019 Singapore Press Holdings Ltd. Co. Regn. No. 198402868E. All rights reserved

The Tussle With China in The Mekong Basin

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Judul Asli

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

The Tussle With China in The Mekong Basin

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

4/24/2019 The tussle with China in the Mekong Basin, SE Asia News & Top Stories - The Straits

mp; Top Stories - The Straits Times

THE STRAITS TIMES

The tussle with China in the Mekong

 PUBLISHED NOV 17, 2018, 5:00 AM SGT

Yet both have

But other matters remain illusive.

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

• The writer is editor of The Nation, Thailand.

Unlock more articles at just $0.99/month

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

MORE FROM THE STRAITS TIMES

FROM AROUND THE WEB

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

NZXT's updated His E-Commerce Get Fancy With Under 65 And No

Sri Lanka explosions: Government says local Islamist group

Netﬂix lands deal with Beyonce worth a reported US$60

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

Victims of Sri Lanka attacks: Who they were

5 Ways to Smarter Food Management at Home

It Changed My Life: She paddles to help others stay afloat

Radio DJ Andre Hoeden is tuned in to thrift and saving

Aspiring tech-entrepreneurs, you could be the future

Ask the expert: What are my chances of getting breast cancer?

This site uses cookies to help us serve you better. By continuing to

 Terms & Conditions  Data Protection Policy

Anda mungkin juga menyukai