Miriam College
October 4, 2011
Abstract
We cannot deny the difficulty of finding a job here in the Philippines. Even those with degrees
are having a hard time finding a job that meets their needs and their family’s needs and because of this, a
lot of Filipinos are taking the opportunity to work abroad but in doing this they must learn to adapt with
the culture of the people they’re working with. The purpose of this study is to find out the degree of
conformity among overseas Filipino workers. In order to do so, the researchers went to POEA where they
got 170 OFWs as the participants. Four domains were used: belief, decision-making, lifestyle and
Working overseas nowadays is an ordinary thing for Filipinos. According to the 2010
census released by the Philippine National Statistics Office, there is about 2 million Overseas
Filipino Workers who works abroad (Ericta, 2011). It is common to know that in every Filipino
family there is at least one who is working in another country. Each of them has their own
different reasons why they want to work in another country; some might think that it’s a superb
opportunity while others might find it as their last resort in order to fulfill their family’s needs.
But accepting the fact that they are going to another country for hope of a good job, they are also
challenged to adapt the culture of the country where they will be staying.
However, the researchers have no interest with the personal reasons of Filipinos going
abroad but with the degree on which OFWs’ adapt a new environment, culture, and different
people. Also, with regards to what Herbert Kelman proposed, this study sought to find out if in
assessing the level of conformity of OFWs, this can help the researchers to make an assumption
about the how well they live in foreign countries in terms of adapting to changes. This would
also help in gathering more information about the social status of Filipinos working abroad.
Review of Related Literature
According to Ducanes and Abella, Overseas Filipino Workers (OFWs) are figures who
are both much celebrated and much lamented from within the Philippines and outside of it.
OFWs are often called modern day heroes and their remittances frequently credited with having
kept the country’s economy afloat in the face of myriad political and economic crises over the
past three decades. On the flipside, OFWs are also often held as symbolic of the sad state of
Philippine society, especially as it is feared that the most talented workers are among those
leaving the country, at times to take on lower-skilled jobs not commensurate with their
qualifications.
There are many traits that Filipinos are well-known for; one of these is conformity. It was
described as the practice of making oneself fit in to his surroundings or accommodating the
norms that are being practiced in the place where he lives. (Tadiar, 2009) Conformity is not just
doing what other people do but it is also being affected with what you change in the way you do
something. It is being different, acting strangely from how one person knows himself personally
(Myers, 2010).People conforms and adapts their unreal personality. When they conform, they
became more powerless and to be able to break this people should achieve self realization
(Fromm, 2009). Conformity becomes a positive attitude when it boosts one’s self confidence. It
makes people feel even better when the result of their conformity is social approval especially in
groups where they have a great need to belong. (Psych Blog, 2010)
Leon Mann’s definition of conformity is “yielding to group pressures”. People who are
not so confident with their self are more likely to conform with others even at times when they
don’t exactly share the same belief or idea (Pasupathi, 1999). As summarized by Bibb Latane
and Sharon Wolf, “traditional approaches to social influence have concentrated almost
exclusively on situations in which the majority serves as the source of influence pressure.”
(Allen, 1965; Darley & Darley, 1976; Kiesler & Kiesler, 1969)
along with the group even if he believes that they are wrong and he does not change his opinion.
Internalization is changing ones opinion because he is persuaded that the group is right. Lastly,
Groups influence the way people conform. Most individuals do not conform with all the
groups that they belong rather they only conform with important groups where they value their
belongingness and to groups where they look forward to being a part of. (Robbins, 2009) A study
conducted by Lennart J. Renkema, Diederik A. Stapel and Nico W. Van Yperen (2007) of the
the majority’s beliefs and opinion. The possible reasons for this are the capability of the general
public to provide accurate information and social approval. These motives are thought to
People are strongly influenced when they think about how others will react if place in the
same situation they are in, particularly when they are not sure of how they should act in the
situation. (Cialdini, 2001). The more we recognize the level of consensus, the more we are
swayed. It also happens easily if the person knows limited information about the situation or
issue and if the person can’t be disturbed to understand the situation or issue carefully. (J. Dean,
2010)
Having accepted the challenge to go overseas and make a living in a foreign land, OFWs
face another challenge of adapting to the culture of their host country when they get there. They
adapt by learning every aspect of the country’s culture so they could adjust well to their life
previous study entitled “A Peek into Socio-Economic and Cultural Transfers (A Study on
Synovate Inc. and was authorized by the Western Union Company, have proven that when
overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) return home, they tend to end up adopting certain traits and
practices which are prevalent in the country they came from. 97 percent of their participants
established an observable change, influenced by the culture of their host country, when they
returned home. There were changes in attitude and behavior, but the most observable ones were
This study pointed out the contributions of OFWs to the economy of the country, as well
as its culture. When OFWs learn some practices which are advantageous for them, they conform
and bring these with them when they return home. The results of the study also showed
significant proof that despite bringing observable cultural changes when returning home, OFWs
remain Filipinos at heart. Their Filipino traits and values are still seen in their heart, mind, and
sometimes, they even return home with a stronger Pinoy spirit than ever before (Abellana, 2010).
Method
Participants
The respondents were chosen conveniently. One hundred fifty OFWs whose age ranges
from 20-50 were our target respondents. Twenty participants were used as buffer in case there
will be questionnaires that are not completely answered. The respondents who answered were
chosen regardless of what country they have worked at, how long they have been working there
and what kind of worked they are into. The participants that were chosen are those who were at
the Philippine Overseas Employment Administration and other agencies. In exception on taking
the scale are OFWs who happen to work outside the country for the first time.
Materials
The scale on conformity among OFWS is a six point Likert scale (See Appendix 1). This
means that there is no right or wrong answer. The respondents will just indicate where he or she
stands on the continuum between agreement and disagreement. The set of statements deals with
how OFW act and behave when they are in another country. Most of the statements are about
their everyday interaction with other people, friends, and companions. Negative questions were
combined in the whole questionnaire to eliminate response pattern bias and encourage the
participants to read each statements well enough. In scoring it, we will reverse the equivalent
score of their answer. The respondents will also be provided with a pen/pencil.
Procedures
The scale on conformity among OFWs is composed of statements about how OFW a deal
with people, act and behave when they are in another country. There are six (6) choices: strongly
agree, agree, slightly agree, slightly disagree, disagree, and strongly disagree. The respondents
simply checked the box that corresponds to their answers. The instructions were explained to
respondents. Questions from the participant were entertained before they started to answer the
scale. We asked the respondents to answer the scale on conformity among OFWs honestly and
completely. There was no time limit in answering the scale. As much as possible, we did not
CONFORMITY
Figure 1.1: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Overall Cronbach’s Alpha)
As Figure 1.1 above shows, the overall Cronbach’s aApha obtained is .476, which is relatively
low and indicates low internal consistency among the items. This suggests that participants who
selected high rankings for a certain item did not select high rankings for the others; and those
who selected low rankings for a certain item did not select low rankings for the others. Thus, it is
not possible to accurately predict the scores for a domain using the results gathered from another
domain. However, had the alpha been higher, this ability to predict would have been possible.
Figure 1.2: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Correlated Item-total Correlation)
370.2446 and a standard deviation of 18.66557, which indicates that the items have large
BELIEFS
Figure 2.1: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Cronbach’s Alpha for Domain 1: Beliefs)
The Cronbach’s Alpha obtained for the 23 items that were used to describe the first
domain (Beliefs), as shown in Figure 2.1 above, was .087, which is relatively low thus indicates
Figure 2.2: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Correlated Item-total Correlation for Domain 1:
Beliefs)
Figure 2.3: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Scale Statistics for Domain 1: Beliefs)
The 23 items used to describe the first domain obtained a mean score of 80.9568, with a
DECISION-MAKING
Figure 3.1: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Cronbach’s Alpha for Domain 2: Decision-
making)
As shown in Figure 3.1, the overall Cronbach’s Alpha obtained for the 12 items used to
describe the second domain (decision-making) was .004, which is very low, thus indicates a very
low internal consistency. This suggests that this domain does not measure conformity
consistently.
Figure 3.2: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Correlated Item-total Correlations for Domain 2:
Decision-making)
Figure 3.3: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Scale Statistics for Domain 2: Decision-making)
The 12 items used for the second domain (Decision-making) obtained a mean score of
LIFESTYLE
Figure 4.1: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Cronbach’s Alpha for Domain 3: Lifestyle)
The overall Cronbach’s Alpha obtained for the third domain (Lifestyle) was .094. A low
alpha as such indicates a low internal correlation among the items. This suggests that this domain
Figure 4.2: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Correlated Item-total Correlation for Domain 3:
Lifestyle)
30 items were used to describe this domain. The scores obtained a mean score of
Figure 5.1: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Cronbach’s Alpha for Domain 4: Relationships)
35 items were used to measure this domain. The overall Cronbach’s Alpha obtained was
.429 which is significantly low, but relatively higher than the alpha obtained from the other
domains. The low alpha indicates low internal correlation, but suggests that this measure is more
Figure 5.2: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Correlated Item-total Correlation for Domain 4:
Relationships)
Figure 5.3: Statistical Results for Reliability Analysis (Scale Statistics for Domain 4: Relationships)
The items under the fourth domain (Relationships) obtained a mean score of 133.7643, a
In conclusion to this study, the researchers measured the reliability of the scale using
Cronbach’s Alpha. For the overall Cronbach’s Alpha, the results showed low estimates of
reliability which means that the scale is not designed to measure only one construct, conformity.
The researchers used the domain sampling model in which several domains were identified that
represents conformity and each item is an individual sample of his/her degree of conformity.
Results showed that the four domains: belief, decision-making, lifestyle and relationship do not
measure conformity which means that the scale is not internally consistent. However, the data
may be inconclusive to draw a clear conclusion that each of these four domains does not measure
the degree of conformity of the target respondents. The researchers cannot reach a strong
conclusion and to be able to reach a clearer conclusion, the scale must be given to more subjects.
The researchers can also search for different domains which can represent conformity better.
The Philippine Overseas Employment Agency allowed the researchers to conduct the
distribution of the scale for two weeks. Due to the lack of control on the time of day, extraneous
variable of time might have been present. This extraneous variable can also be linked to another
variable which is the selection of subjects. The subjects were OFWs; they were all busy filling
up their forms. Some of the scales that were answered were incomplete and some respondents
might have been guessing. As the researchers tallied the gathered data, in an estimate, only 50%
of the respondents seemed to answer the scale seriously. Some of the respondents skip one page
of the scale. The target respondents of the researchers were one hundred and seventy but because
some of the answered scales were void, only one hundred and forty participant’s responses were
included. Also, the researchers had a hard time in explaining the purpose of the DSC Scale.
Some of the respondents were unkind in asking about the scale. Aside from that, the respondents
demand to have the scale translated in Filipino. The researchers should have considered having
the DSC Scale in Filipino language since most of the OFW came from different provinces in the
Philippines.
References
Retrieved from:
http://books.google.com/books?printsec=frontcover&vid=ISBN1565182251&vid=LCCN
2005011376#v=onepage&q&f=false
Latane, B., & Wolf, S. (1981). The Social Impact of Majorities and Minorities.
http://www.socialpc.com/Psychology/Conformity.html
No author. (2010, february 10). Psych Blog. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from Spring Org:
http://www.spring.org.uk/2010/02/conformity-ten-timeless-influencers.php
Myers, D. (2010). Social Psychology 10th ed. New York: Mc Graw-Hill Companies, Inc.
Inc.
Tadiar, N. X. (2009). Things fall away: Philippine historical experience and the makings
Is Being a Member of the Out-group an Advantage. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from Spring
Org: http://www.spring.org.uk/2010/02/conformity-ten-timeless-influencers.php
Bond, R. (2005). Group Size and Conformity. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from Spring Org:
http://www.spring.org.uk/2010/02/conformity-ten-timeless-influencers.php
McKay, A. (2010, May 27). Psychology @ Suite 101. Retrieved July 13, 2011, from
http://www.suite101.com/content/psychologist-solomon-aschs-research-on-conformity-
a243175
http://www.scribd.com/doc/22699592/Filipino-Psychology-Or-Sikolohiyang-Pilipino-In-
Filipino-Is-Defined-As
http://pstalker.com/ilo/resources/ILO%20MGREU%20WP05%20-
%20Overseas%20Filipino%20Workers%20and%20Poverty.pdf
Yperen, N. W. (2007, November 6). Go with the Flow: Conforming to others in the face
http://rug.academia.edu/NicoWVanYperen/Papers/614200/Go_with_the_flow_Conformi
ng_to_others_in_the_face_of_existential_threat
http://rug.academia.edu/NicoWVanYperen/Papers/614200/Go_with_the_flow_Conformi
ng_to_others_in_the_face_of_existential_threat
Appendix
These are statements about how you deal with people, act and behave when you are in another country. There are
six (6) choices: strongly agree (SA), agree(A), slightly agree(SLA), slightly disagree(SLD), disagree(D), and strongly
disagree(SD). Put a check on the box that corresponds to your answers. Please answer this scale as honestly as you can.
Your favorable response would be much appreciated. We guarantee that your answers will be kept confidential. Thank
you!
SA A SLA SLD D SD
9. When I’m in other country, I tend to buy material things just to keep
up with what the people have.
10. I tend to act the way my co-workers do, so that they have nothing to
say against me.
11. I am likely to speak the way my co-workers do.
20. When it comes to making decisions, I feel that the majority of my co-
workers is always right that’s why I don’t bother to speak out my
opinion.
21. I do not usually talk to new people around me especially those who
have a different language and culture.
29. For me, a country is unlikely to survive in the long run unless people
can overcome their differences and disagreements.
30. I admire other OFWs who go their own way without worrying about
what people in other country think.
31. I am always concerned about what other people would think of me
especially because I have a different nationality.
32. In a group composed of people with different nationalities, I tend to
act differently in front of other people to gain their acceptance.
33. I like to stress out my own opinion about things in even if I know that
our personal beliefs contradict with each other.
34. It is okay for me even if foreigners do not like the way I act in front of
them.
35. When I am assigned in a place where I do not know my new co-
workers, I approach them first and introduce myself.
36. I don’t like to be in a group of foreigner because it’s difficult to
understand what they are saying.
37. I follow the ideas of people from another country because I think they
know better.
38. It is hard for me to accept the opinion of others especially if they are
not Filipinos.
39. I make sure that everything I do will be accepted by other races, even
if it does not show my real personality..
40. I would prefer to leave my job if my beliefs do not match those of my
co-workers.
41. I don’t let other cultures affect my belief.
42. If my co-workers reject me, I keep myself away from them.
43. I listen to my co-worker’s opinion even if they are opposing my
opinions.
44. I value my relationship with people from another country.
45. When there is a need to decide, I leave it to my co-workers.
46. I feel confident when other people accept me in a group where we
have different nationalities.
47. It is better to be alone than to be in a group where I do not act as
myself and do not agree with the beliefs of other races.
48. I love being who I am even in front of many people from different
countries.
49. I feel embarrassed when foreign people do not like the way I work.
50. Even if I’m in a different country, I still want to be involved when
making decisions in the work place.
51. I feel uncomfortable around foreign people.
52. Being the “foreigner” within a group bothers me.
53. I always share my thoughts with my co-workers.
54. I am very open to knowing about new customs, beliefs, and traditions
of other cultures
55. I find it difficult to ask for help from foreign people.
56. It is okay for me to have a friend who is a foreigner even though we do
not share the same beliefs
57. When I’m in another country, it doesn’t take long for me to adjust to
their customs.
58. When working abroad, creating a good impression matters to me
because I am representing my own country.
59. I practice the Filipino culture abroad without minding what others will
say about me.
60. I don’t adjust for people in different country. I expect them to adjust
for me.
61. I love working abroad because I love being around people who thinks
I’m different.
62. For the sake of belongingness, I tend to act as if I share the same
beliefs with other cultures.
63. When I am in another country, I follow their traditions so that I won’t
feel out of place.
64. When I am in another country, I only mingle with people who are of
the same nationality as I am.
65. I feel nervous when trying new things without my co-workers
approval/assistance.
66. I firmly stand by my beliefs and I cannot be influenced by others.
67. Even if others are doing something wrong in our job, I will still keep
on doing what is right.
68. When doing my job, I like to have it my way without asking for
others’ opinions.
69. I am easily affected by other’s criticisms about my beliefs.
70. I always join groups because it makes me feel that I belong, even if
I’m the only Filipino.
71. I listen to the opinion of other people and I will be the one to decide if
I will agree with them or not
72. I act in accordance to how the majority acts.
73. Other people’s opinions matter most to me when I am making any
decision.
74. I am certain of who I am regardless if others will not agree with me.
75. I let my co-workers influence me even if it’s against my own beliefs.
76. I abide by the rules of another country only if it fits my beliefs.
77. I practice my own way of doing things even if I’m not in my own
country.
78. Wherever I go, I always want to have a Filipino companion with me.
79. I live independently.
80. I agree to what my co-workers believe is right for us.
81. I stand by my decisions without my co-workers’ approval.
82. I am comfortable hanging out with a group where I am the only
Filipino.
83. Being part of a group is necessary to survive when you are working
in another country.
84. I prefer being on my own to avoid conflicts and misunderstanding
with others, especially foreign people.
85. I compare the people in my own country with others in different
nation.
86. I try to understand different languages for the sake of a good
conversation with other people of a different country.
87. I believe in the phrase, “fake it till you make it” especially when I
cannot handle the pressure of being with foreign natives.
88. I believe that I don’t need to compete with my co-workers when it
comes to work just to please my boss with different nationality.
89. I adjust to the beliefs of my co-workers, especially those from
different cultures.
90. I’d rather be alone than to have a hard time coping with the way
foreigners act.
91. Adjusting to a different culture doesn’t mean pretending to be
something I’m not.
92. I am willing to do anything in order to please foreigners.
93. I love having foreign friends rather than only having Filipino friends.
94. There is no reason for me to befriend others because it is hard to
familiarize myself with the attitudes of people with different
nationality.
95. When I am in another country, I focus on taking care of myself
before trying to make friends with others.
96. I find it hard to work with other people who have a different race.
97. I only leave the house to go to work and rarely go to crowded places
in order to avoid interactions with other races.
98. I share whatever I have to my companions who are of different race.
99. In decision-making, a proposition becomes true/good if it is believed
by the majority.
100. When I need help, I can turn to the people around me even if
they have a different nationality.