ScienceDirect

Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364

(O&RQWUROGH3RWHQFLD\)UHFXHQFLDHQORV6LVWHPDV
(OpFWULFRV0XOWLiUHD5HYLVLyQ\1XHYRV5HWRV

)%DUUHUR*RQ]iOH]0,0LODQpV0RQWHUR(*RQ]iOH]5RPHUD&5RQFHUR&OHPHQWH 3*RQ]iOH]&DVWULOOR
Grupo de Investigación en Sistemas Eléctricos y Electrónicos de Potencia (PE&ES). Departamento de Ingeniería Eléctrica, Electrónica y Automática, Escuela de
Ingenierías Industriales de Badajoz (Universidad de Extremadura), Avda. Elvas, s/n – 06006 Badajoz (España).


5HVXPHQ

&RQODOOHJDGDGHODOLEHUDOL]DFLyQDORVVLVWHPDGHHQHUJtDHOpFWULFDLQWHUFRQHFWDGRVODRSHUDFLyQEDVDGDHQPHFDQLVPRVGHPHUFDGRV
\ OD SURJUHVLYD LQFRUSRUDFLyQ GH ODV HQHUJtDV UHQRYDEOHV ORV UROHV GH OD JHQHUDFLyQ HO WUDQVSRUWH \ OD GHPDQGD HVWiQ FDPELDQGR
PLHQWUDV TXH ORV PHFDQLVPRV GH FRQWURO SRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLD SHUPDQHFHQ HQ VX IRUPD RULJLQDO (VWR KDFH SUHYLVLEOH TXH VXUMDQ
QHFHVLGDGHVGHIRUPDFLyQLQYHVWLJDFLyQGHVDUUROORHLQQRYDFLyQSDUDGDUUHVSXHVWDDORVQXHYRVUHWRVTXHVHSODQWHDQ

(QHVWHFRQWH[WRHOSUHVHQWHWUDEDMRSUHWHQGHDSRUWDUHOFRQRFLPLHQWRQHFHVDULRDORVSURIHVLRQDOHVGHODLQJHQLHUtDUHODFLRQDGRVFRQ
HVWHFDPSRTXHQHFHVLWDQDILDQ]DU\DFWXDOL]DUVXIRUPDFLyQDVtFRPRVHUYLUGHEDVHSDUDORVTXHLQLFLDQWUDEDMRVGHLQYHVWLJDFLyQ3DUD
HOOR VH SUHVHQWDQ ORV UHVXOWDGRV GH OD VLPXODFLyQ GH XQ VLVWHPD HOpFWULFR HTXLSDUDEOH D XQ VLVWHPD UHDO \ VH UHYLVDQ \ DFWXDOL]DQ ORV
DVSHFWRV OHJDOHV QRUPDWLYRV \ GH DSOLFDFLyQ SUiFWLFD HQ HO FRQWH[WR QDFLRQDO H LQWHUQDFLRQDO Copyright ‹ 2015 CEA. Publicado por
Elsevier España, S.L.U.
S.L. Todos
Todosloslos
derechos
derechosreservados.
reservados.

Palabras Clave:
6LPXODFLyQGHVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRVFRQWUROMHUDUTXL]DGRUHJXODFLyQGHIUHFXHQFLDVHUYLFLRVDX[LOLDUHVGHUHJXODFLyQ&RQWURO$XWRPiWLFR
GHOD*HQHUDFLyQHQHUJtDVUHQRYDEOHVUHGHVLQWHOLJHQWHVsmart gridsVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRV\HOHFWUyQLFRVGHSRWHQFLD


 ,QWURGXFFLyQ SURIHVLRQDOHV GH OD LQJHQLHUtD UHODFLRQDGRV FRQ HVWH iPELWR TXH
QHFHVLWDQ XQD DFWXDOL]DFLyQ GH VXV FRQRFLPLHQWRV SHUR WDPELpQ
(QHOFRQWH[WRHXURSHRODVOtQHDVPDHVWUDVGH,'HQUHODFLyQ SDUD ORV TXH LQLFLDQ WDUHDV GH LQYHVWLJDFLyQ /DV H[SOLFDFLRQHV
FRQORVVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRVHVWiQGHILQLGDVHQ(1762(D
(Q HVWH GRFXPHQWR VH PDUFDQ ORV REMHWLYRV GH OD SROtWLFD
HQHUJpWLFDGHDFXHUGRFRQORVGHQRPLQDGRV³2EMHWLYRV´
GH OD 8QLyQ (XURSHD \ FRQ OD ³+RMD GH 5XWD GH OD (QHUJtD SDUD
´ $GHPiV VH DSXQWD DO GHVDUUROOR GH OD UHG GH WUDQVSRUWH
SDQHXURSHD \ D OD LPSODQWDFLyQ GHO PHUFDGR LQWHUQR GH OD
HOHFWULFLGDG HQ (XURSD /R DQWHULRU MXQWR FRQ OD SUHYLVLEOH
SUROLIHUDFLyQ GH VLVWHPDV DLVODGRV FRQ SRVLELOLGDG GH FRQH[LyQ D
FOiVLFDV DGROHFHQ D PHQXGR GH IDOWD GH DFWXDOL]DFLyQ GDGRV ORV
FRQWLQXRVFDPELRVVXFHGLGRVHQORV~OWLPRVDxRV\GHDGDSWDFLyQ
DO FRQWH[WR HXURSHR WRGD YH] TXH JUDQ SDUWH GH OD OLWHUDWXUD
WpFQLFD SURYLHQH GHO HQWRUQR GH (VWDGRV 8QLGRV (VWH WUDEDMR
SUHWHQGH VXSOLU HQ SDUWH HVDV FDUHQFLDV SUHVHQWDQGR XQD
H[SOLFDFLyQUHVXPLGD\DFWXDOL]DGDGHORVPHFDQLVPRVGHFRQWURO
DSR\DGDHQKHUUDPLHQWDVGHVLPXODFLyQGHXVRFRQRFLGRKR\GtD
HQWUH ORV SURIHVLRQDOHV GH OD LQJHQLHUtD 6H LQGLFDQ WDPELpQ ORV
OD UHG 0LNDWL HW DO  \ GRWDGRV GH VLVWHPDV GH DVSHFWRV OHJDOHV QRUPDWLYRV \ GH DSOLFDFLyQ SUiFWLFD HQ HO
DOPDFHQDPLHQWR PLFURUHGHV R microgrids OD SURJUHVLYD FRQWH[WRGH(XURSD\(VSDxD<SRU~OWLPRVHUHDOL]DXQDEUHYH
LQFRUSRUDFLyQ GHO FRFKH HOpFWULFR OD LQVWDODFLyQ GH HTXLSRV UHYLVLyQ GHO HVWDGR GHO DUWH D WUDYpV GH XQD PXHVWUD GH OD
EDVDGRVHQODHOHFWUyQLFDGHSRWHQFLDSDUDHOFRQWURO\JHVWLyQGH OLWHUDWXUDWpFQLFDUHODFLRQDGD
ODV UHGHV Flexible AC Transmission Systems, FACTS \ OD (Q ORV VLVWHPDV HOpFWULFRV HQ FRQGLFLRQHV QRUPDOHV GH
DSOLFDFLyQ GH OD DXWRPDWL]DFLyQ \ ODV FRPXQLFDFLRQHV DYDQ]DGDV IXQFLRQDPLHQWR ORV JHQHUDGRUHV HVWiQ JLUDQGR HQ VLQFURQLVPR \
smartgridsSODQWHDQXHYRVGHVDItRVSDUDODRSHUDFLyQ\FRQWURO
GHORVVLVWHPDVGHHQHUJtDHOpFWULFD
(VWDVLWXDFLyQKDFHSUHYLVLEOHTXHVXUMDQRSRUWXQLGDGHVHQHVWH
FDPSRSRUORTXHHOFRQRFLPLHQWRDGHFXDGRGHORVPHFDQLVPRV
GHFRQWUROGHORVVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRVHVGHJUDQLPSRUWDQFLDSDUD
$XWRUHQFRUUHVSRQGHQFLD
Correo electrónicocroncero@peandes.net
85/KWWSSHDQGHVXQH[HV
© 2015 CEA. Publicado por Elsevier España, S.L.U. Todos los derechos reservados
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.riai.2015.07.001
MXQWRVJHQHUDQODSRWHQFLDTXHHVWiVLHQGRGHPDQGDGD'DGRTXH
OD HQHUJtD HOpFWULFD QR SXHGH VHU DOPDFHQDGD HQ JUDQGHV
FDQWLGDGHVVLDXPHQWDODSRWHQFLDFRQVXPLGDSRUODVFDUJDVSHUR
OD SRWHQFLD PHFiQLFD DSRUWDGD SRU ODV WXUELQDV SHUPDQHFH
FRQVWDQWH HO LQFUHPHQWR GH GHPDQGD VyOR SXHGH REWHQHUVH GH OD
HQHUJtD FLQpWLFDDOPDFHQDGDORTXH VXSRQHOD GLVPLQXFLyQGHOD
YHORFLGDG GH JLUR GH ORV JHQHUDGRUHV \ OD FDtGD GH OD IUHFXHQFLD
HOpFWULFDGHOVLVWHPDGLUHFWDPHQWHUHODFLRQDGDFRQHVDYHORFLGDG
358 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364

&RPRODGHPDQGDHVWiFDPELDQGRFRQWLQXDPHQWHVHUHTXLHUHXQ FRQVWDQWHHHVODGHQRPLQDGDconstante de inercia normalizada

VLVWHPD GH FRQWURO TXH DMXVWH DXWRPiWLFDPHQWH OD SRWHQFLD
JHQHUDGD HQ FDGD XQLGDG JHQHUDGRUD LQWHQWDQGR PDQWHQHU OD
IUHFXHQFLDGHQWURGHFLHUWRVOtPLWHV
(O HOHPHQWR EiVLFR SDUD HMHUFHU HO GHQRPLQDGR FRQWURO
SRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLDHVHOJHQHUDGRUVtQFURQR/RVGLVSRVLWLYRVGH
FRQYDORUHVWtSLFRVHQHOUDQJRGHDVHJXQGRV
B. Modelo de la Carga
(QFRQMXQWRHOLQFUHPHQWRGHGHPDQGDWRWDOSXHGHH[SUHVDUVH
FRQWURO HQ FDGD XQLGDG JHQHUDGRUD )LJXUD  UHJXODQ SRU XQD FRPR
SDUWH OD WHQVLyQ HQ ORV WHUPLQDOHV GHO JHQHUDGRU \ SRU RWUD OD 
SRWHQFLD DFWLYD 6XSyQJDVH FRPR HVWDGR LQLFLDO GH ǻPe ǻPD  DǻZ  
IXQFLRQDPLHQWR HQ XQ GHWHUPLQDGR JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU HO
FRUUHVSRQGLHQWH D OD SRWHQFLD DFWLYD D JHQHUDU DVLJQDGD FRPR

UHVXOWDGR GHO PHUFDGR HOpFWULFR 20,(  5(( D
GRQGH ǻPD HV HO LQFUHPHQWR GH SRWHQFLD LQGHSHQGLHQWH GH OD
3ODWDIRUPD (QHUJtD \ 6RFLHGDG  (Q HTXLOLEULR OD IUHFXHQFLD\DHVHOcoeficiente de autorregulaciónTXHUHODFLRQD
YHORFLGDG DQJXODU Ȧm HV FRQVWDQWH \ HVWi UHODFLRQDGD FRQ OD
OD YDULDFLyQ GH Ȧ FRQ OD YDULDFLyQ GH SRWHQFLD GHPDQGDGD TXH
IUHFXHQFLDfSRUODH[SUHVLyQȦm ʌf/pGRQGHpHVHOQ~PHURGH SURYRFD /RV YDORUHV WtSLFRV SUiFWLFRV SDUD HVWH SDUiPHWUR HQ
SDUHVGHSRORVGHOJHQHUDGRU6HDVXPHTXHHOFRQWUROGHWHQVLyQ YDORUHVSXHVWiQHQHOUDQJR±
PDQWLHQH pVWD HQ XQ YDORU FRQVWDQWH OR TXH HTXLYDOH D VXSRQHU
TXH ORV FRQWUROHV GH WHQVLyQ \ GH SRWHQFLD VRQ WRWDOPHQWH C. Modelo de la Turbina
LQGHSHQGLHQWHV$QWHXQDYDULDFLyQHQODSRWHQFLDGHPDQGDGDHO
VLVWHPDGHFRQWUROSRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLDUHDOL]DVXIXQFLyQFRQXQD /D WXUELQD WLHQH XQD IXQFLyQ GH WUDQVIHUHQFLD TXH HQ HO FDVR
HVWUXFWXUD GH YDULRV OD]RV HO FRQWURO SULPDULR HO FRQWURO
VHFXQGDULRHOFRQWUROWHUFLDULRHOFRQWUROGHWLHPSRVtQFURQR\HO
GHVODVWUH DXWRPiWLFR GH FDUJDV (Q ORV DSDUWDGRV VLJXLHQWHV VH
WUDWDQFDGDXQRGHHVWRVFRQWUROHV
 D. Modelo del Regulador
 &RQWURO3ULPDULR
(O FRQWURO SULPDULR HV HO TXH UHDOL]D HQ FDGD JUXSR WXUELQD
JHQHUDGRUHOUHJXODGRUGHYHORFLGDGGHODWXUELQD$FRQWLQXDFLyQ
VH SUHVHQWDQ ORV PRGHORV LQFUHPHQWDOHV GH ORV HOHPHQWRV
LQYROXFUDGRV HQ HO FRQWURO UHVSHFWR GHO HVWDGR GH HTXLOLEULR
UHSUHVHQWDGR SRU OD IUHFXHQFLD QRPLQDO f0   +] ORV GHWDOOHV
PiVVLPSOHWXUELQDGHYDSRUVLQUHFDOHQWDPLHQWRVHUHGXFHDXQ
VLVWHPDGHSULPHURUGHQFRQXQDFRQVWDQWHGHWLHPSRTTHQWUH
\VHJXQGRV
(O UHJXODGRU XWLOL]DGR HV GHO WLSR SURSRUFLRQDO FRQ
UHDOLPHQWDFLyQ GH OD YHORFLGDG \ XQD VHxDO GH FRQVLJQD GH
SRWHQFLD GH UHIHUHQFLD 6X FRPSRUWDPLHQWR TXHGD UHSUHVHQWDGR
SRU HO GLDJUDPD GH EORTXHV TXH VH PXHVWUD HQ OD )LJXUD 
LQWHJUDGR \D FRQ ORV EORTXHV FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHV D OD WXUELQD DO
JHQHUDGRU \ D OD FDUJD FRQIRUPDQGR DVt HO OD]R GH FRQWURO
SXHGHQYHUVHHQ.XQGXU\%DUUHUR SULPDULR (Q OtQHD GH WUD]RV VH UHSUHVHQWD HO OD]R GH FRQWURO
 VHFXQGDULRTXHVHUiWUDWDGRPiVDGHODQWH


 

A V


—”„‹ƒ ‡”…‹ƒ›…ƒ”‰ƒ
 
V


‡‰—Žƒ†‘”
‘–”‘Žƒ†‘”‹–‡‰”ƒŽ



 

 )LJXUD'LDJUDPDGHEORTXHVGHXQJUXSRWXUELQDJHQHUDGRUTXHLQFRUSRUD
)LJXUD&RQWUROHVGHIUHFXHQFLD\WHQVLyQHQXQJUXSRWXUELQDJHQHUDGRU XQ UHJXODGRU GH YHORFLGDG (Q OtQHD GH WUD]RV GH PXHVWUD HO OD]R GH FRQWURO
VHFXQGDULR

A. Modelo del Generador R HV OD GHQRPLQDGD constante de regulación \ UHSUHVHQWD OD
FDtGD GH YHORFLGDG GHO JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU HQ UpJLPHQ
3DUD XQ JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU HO HTXLOLEULR GLQiPLFR VH SHUPDQHQWH FXDQGR Pm SDVD GH  D  6X YDORU WtSLFR HVWi HQ HO
SXHGHH[SUHVDUGHODPDQHUDVLJXLHQWH UDQJR±VLVHH[SUHVDHQWDQWRSRUXQLGDG/DFRQVWDQWH
 GHWLHPSRTRWLHQHXQYDORUWtSLFRHQWUH\V
(QJHQHUDOXQVLVWHPDGHSRWHQFLDHVWDUiIRUPDGRSRU]RQDVR
d ǻZ 
H ǻPm  ǻPe   áreas de controlHQFDGDXQDGHODVFXDOHVSXHGHVXSRQHUVHTXH
dt ORV JHQHUDGRUHV TXH OD LQWHJUDQ IRUPDQ XQ JUXSR FRKHUHQWH HV
(Q HVWD HFXDFLyQ WRGDV ODV PDJQLWXGHV HVWiQ HQ YDORUHV SRU GHFLUTXHJLUDQDOXQtVRQR\SRUWDQWRHQFDGDiUHDODIUHFXHQFLD
XQLGDGHQDGHODQWHSXPm HVODSRWHQFLDPHFiQLFDVXPLQLVWUDGD HVXQLIRUPHHQWRGRLQVWDQWH
SRUODWXUELQDPeODSRWHQFLDHOpFWULFDDFWLYDVXPLQLVWUDGDSRUHO (OUHSDUWRGHSRWHQFLDVHVWRHVODYDULDFLyQHQODSURGXFFLyQ
JHQHUDGRU Ȧ HV OD SXOVDFLyQ DQJXODU HOpFWULFD Ȧ  ʌf /D GHFDGDXQLGDGJHQHUDGRUDiDQWHODYDULDFLyQGHODGHPDQGDHV



 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364 359

ǻȦ /DVLPXODFLyQHVHTXLSDUDEOHDOFDVRGHODLQWHUFRQH[LyQHQWUH
ǻPmi   GRVSDtVHVGH(XURSDFRQWLQHQWDOFRQFDSDFLGDGGHLQWHUFRQH[LyQ
Ri
GHO RUGHQ GH  *: YDORU TXH VH GD SRU HMHPSOR HQ OD
 LQWHUFRQH[LyQ (VSDxD)UDQFLD 5(( D FRQ GHWHUPLQDGDV
/DH[SUHVLyQDQWHULRUWLHQHXQDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQPX\LPSRUWDQWH FDSDFLGDGHV GH JHQHUDFLyQ EDMR FRQWURO HQ FDGD iUHD SDUD FLHUWR
VL WRGRV ORV JUXSRV WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU WLHQHQ OD PLVPD R HVWDGRGHFDUJD
H[SUHVDGD HQ SX UHVSHFWR GH VXV UHVSHFWLYDV SRWHQFLDV (Q OD \D PHQFLRQDGD )LJXUD  VH PXHVWUD HO GLDJUDPD GH
QRPLQDOHVGHOLQFUHPHQWRWRWDOGHSRWHQFLDDFWLYDGHPDQGDGRSRU EORTXHVLQFOX\HQGRORVYDORUHVGHORVSDUiPHWURVH[SUHVDGRVHQ
ORV UHFHSWRUHV FDGD JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU VH KDFH FDUJR SXVREUHXQDSRWHQFLDEDVHFRP~QGH09$(OLQFUHPHQWR
DXWRPiWLFDPHQWH XQD YH] FRPSOHWDGD OD DFFLyQ GHO FRQWURO GHGHPDQGDVH PRGHOD PHGLDQWHXQHVFDOyQGHYDORUSXHQHO
SULPDULRGHXQDIUDFFLyQSURSRUFLRQDODVXSRWHQFLDQRPLQDO LQVWDQWHt V(QOD)LJXUDDUULEDVHPXHVWUDQORVUHVXOWDGRV
 GH OD VLPXODFLyQ GRQGH SXHGH DSUHFLDUVH OD HYROXFLyQ WHPSRUDO
GH OD SXOVDFLyQ DQJXODU \ GH ODV SRWHQFLDV GH LQWHUFDPELR \
E. Modelo de la Interconexión entre Áreas PHFiQLFDVWRWDOHVGHFDGDiUHD2EVpUYHVHTXHFDGDiUHDDSRUWDDO
LQFUHPHQWR GH SRWHQFLD GHPDQGDGD WRWDO  0: XQD
8Q iUHD GH FRQWURO QRUPDOPHQWH FRLQFLGH FRQ HO iPELWR GH IUDFFLyQSURSRUFLRQDODVXWDPDxRUHODWLYR\TXHHOiUHDUHFLEH
UHVSRQVDELOLGDG GH XQ 2SHUDGRU GHO 6LVWHPD 26 XQ SDtV R XQ SRWHQFLDGHOiUHD
iUHDJHRJUiILFD
(Q HO FDVR VLPSOLILFDGR GH GRV iUHDV OD GHVYLDFLyQ GH OD 2.2. Aspectos Prácticos y Marco Normativo del Control Primario
SRWHQFLDGHLQWHUFDPELRVDOLHQWHGHOiUHDHQWUDQWHHQHOiUHD en Europa y España
P12UHVSHFWRGHODSURJUDPDGDFRQWUDWDGD P12, programada HVǻP12 
P12 ± P12, programada 6X PRGHOR LQFUHPHQWDO .XQGXU  VH /RVVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRVHXURSHRVFX\DJHVWLyQFRRUGLQDGDHVWi
H[SUHVDSRUODHFXDFLyQVLJXLHQWH DVLJQDGD D OD HQWLGDG (1762( (1762( E VH DJUXSDQ
 HQ FLQFR iUHDV VtQFURQDV (XURSD &RQWLQHQWDO (& 1yUGLFD
ǻP  
T Z ³ǻZdt  Z ³ǻZ dt   %iOWLFD *UDQ %UHWDxD H ,UODQGD (O VLVWHPD HOpFWULFR HVSDxRO
FRQHFWDGR D ORV VLVWHPDV GH )UDQFLD 3RUWXJDO \ 0DUUXHFRV VH

HQFXHQWUDLQWHJUDGRGHQWURGHOiUHD(&TXHLQFOX\HDODSUiFWLFD
GRQGHTHVHOcoeficiente de par sincronizante,TXHGHSHQGHGH
WRWDOLGDGGHORVSDtVHVGH(XURSDRFFLGHQWDO
ODFDSDFLGDGGHWUDQVSRUWHGHODLQWHUFRQH[LyQ
(QORVGRFXPHQWRV8&7(\8&7(VHLQGLFDHO
(Q OD )LJXUD  VH PXHVWUD HO GLDJUDPD GH EORTXHV SDUD XQ
UHTXHULPLHQWR GH UHJXODFLyQ SULPDULD SDUD HO iUHD VtQFURQD (&
VLVWHPDGHGRViUHDVFRQFRQWUROSULPDULRLQFRUSRUDQGRHOPRGHOR
3DUDHOORVHGHILQHHOGHQRPLQDGR³LQFLGHQWHGHUHIHUHQFLD´FRPR
GHODLQWHUFRQH[LyQ6HKDLQFOXLGRWDPELpQHQOtQHDGHWUD]RVHO
ODSpUGLGDGH0:GHJHQHUDFLyQHQFXDOTXLHUOXJDUGHOiUHD
OD]RGHFRQWUROVHFXQGDULRTXHVHUiWUDWDGRPiVDGHODQWH
(& 3DUD WDO LQFLGHQWH OD Pi[LPD GHVYLDFLyQ GH IUHFXHQFLD

2.1. Resultados de Simulación solo con Control Primario
(Q HVWH DSDUWDGR VH PXHVWUDQ ORV UHVXOWDGRV REWHQLGRV GH OD
VLPXODFLyQ HQ HO HQWRUQR 0$7/$%Simulink GH XQ VLVWHPD
IRUPDGR SRU GRV iUHDV GH FRQWURO FXDQGR DFW~D VyOR HO FRQWURO
FRP~Q FRQVLGHUDQGR D   QR GHEH VXSHUDU HO PDUJHQ “ 
P+] /D característica potencia-frecuencia HQ HO iUHD (& SDUD
 VH GHWHUPLQD HQ ORV FLWDGRV GRFXPHQWRV HQ EDVH D HVRV
YDORUHV \ DxDGLHQGR YDULDV FRQVLGHUDFLRQHV DGLFLRQDOHV
UHVXOWDQGR HO YDORU GH ȕEC   0:»+] /D FDUDFWHUtVWLFD
SRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLDSDUDFDGDiUHDGHFRQWUROjVHGHWHUPLQDFRPR

SULPDULR /RV GDWRV VH KDQ HVFRJLGR SDUD UHSUHVHQWDU XQ VLVWHPD E j c j ˜ E (& 
HTXLSDUDEOH D XQD UHG UHDO FRQ SDUiPHWURV UHDOLVWDV GH DFXHUGR
FRQ8&7(\.XQGXU6HKD LQWHQWDGRSUHVHUYDU 
FLHUWD PRGXODULGDG HQ HO SODQWHDPLHQWR FRQ HO ILQ GH TXH SXHGD GRQGHHOFRHILFLHQWHcjVHFDOFXODFRPR
VHU IiFLOPHQWH UHSURGXFLEOH SDUD RWUDV VLPXODFLRQHV 
UHSUHVHQWDWLYDVGHFDVRVFRQFUHWRV/RVGDWRVVRQORVVLJXLHQWHV (QHUJLDSURGXFLGDHODxRDQWHULRUHQHOiUHDj
Fj 
x ÈUHDJUXSRVWXUELQDJHQHUDGRUiUHDJUXSRV (QHUJtDSURGXFLGDHODxRDQWHULRUHQHOiUHDVtQFURQD(&
WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU 
x &RHILFLHQWHVGHDXWRUUHJXODFLyQGHFDGDiUHDD D  3DUD HO FDVR GH (VSDxD FRQ GDWRV GH (1762( F UHVXOWy
0:+] cES 
x &DGD JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU GH SRWHQFLD QRPLQDO 3RU RWUR ODGR DO PDUJHQ GH SRWHQFLD GH XQ JUXSR WXUELQD
0:IUHFXHQFLDQRPLQDO+]H VR  JHQHUDGRU GHVGH XQ SXQWR GH IXQFLRQDPLHQWR GHWHUPLQDGR KDVWD
UHIHULGRVDVXSRWHQFLDQRPLQDO VX SRWHQFLD Pi[LPD HQ HO TXH HO UHJXODGRU GH YHORFLGDG SXHGH
x &DSDFLGDG HVWiWLFD GH WUDQVSRUWH GH OD LQWHUFRQH[LyQ  DFWXDUGHIRUPDDXWRPiWLFDHVORTXHVHFRQRFHFRPR reserva de
*:2SHUDQGRHQHTXLOLEULRLQLFLDOFRQį10 ±į20 ž control primaria GH OD XQLGDG JHQHUDGRUD 7DPELpQ HQ 8&7(
 \8&7(VHHVWDEOHFHODUHVHUYDGHFRQWUROSULPDULD
6H FRQVLGHUD FRPR FRQWLQJHQFLD OD GHVFRQH[LyQ EUXVFD HQ HO SDUD HO iUHD VtQFURQD (& HQ HO YDORU RPEC   0: LJXDO DO
LQVWDQWH t   V GH XQ JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU HQ HO iUHD  OR YDORUGHSRWHQFLDGHOLQFLGHQWHGHUHIHUHQFLD<VHDVLJQDDFDGD
TXHHTXLYDOHDXQLQFUHPHQWRGHGHPDQGDHQHVHiUHDGHOPLVPR iUHDODUHVSRQVDELOLGDGGHDSRUWDUXQDIUDFFLyQGHHVDUHVHUYDHQ
YDORUHVWRHVǻPD1 0: IXQFLyQ GHO PLVPR FRHILFLHQWH cj GHILQLGR HQ  3RU WDQWR OD
UHVHUYDSULPDULDSDUDXQiUHDjRPjVHGHWHUPLQDFRPR


360 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364

6EDVH 09$

5

 
ͳ ȟܲ஽ଵ ȟ߱ଵ
ߚଵ ൌ ൅ ‫ܦ‬ଵ
ܴଵ
=HUR2UGHU
+ROG ± ±
    SL 
 
,V  V V ± V V

5HJXODGRU 7XUELQD ,QHUFLD FDUJD ,QWDQJXOR
$&( ,QWHJUDO
ͳ &RQWURODGRU ȟܲଵଶ
ȟܲ௠ଵ
଴ 
.
ܶ ±
ଵଶ

ȟܲ௠ଶ ƒ’ƒ…‹†ƒ†–”ƒ•’‘”–‡ ͳ
Ǥ
=HUR2UGHU ’‡”ƒ†‘ƒߜଵ଴ െ ߜଶ଴ ൌ Ͷͷι
+ROG
±    SL 
,V   
  V V
± V V
$&( ,QWHJUDO ,QHUFLD FDUJD ,QWDQJXOR
ʹ &RQWURODGRU 5HJXODGRU  7XUELQD

ͳ
ߚଶ ൌ ൅ ‫ܦ‬ଶ 
ܴଶ
ȟ߱ଶ

5


)LJXUD  'LDJUDPD GH EORTXHV SDUD OD VLPXODFLyQ GH XQ VLVWHPD IRUPDGR SRU GRV iUHDV GH FRQWURO LQWHUFRQHFWDGDV (Q OtQHD GH WUD]RV VH PXHVWUD HO OD]R
VHFXQGDULR

[


 










         


[








 


 
             


)LJXUD&RPSRUWDPLHQWRGLQiPLFRGHXQVLVWHPDHOpFWULFRIRUPDGRSRUGRViUHDVGHFRQWURODQWHODSpUGLGDGHXQJUXSRJHQHUDGRUGH0:HQHOiUHDHQHO
LQVWDQWH t   V $UULED VROR FRQ FRQWURO SULPDULR $EDMR FRQ FRQWURO SULPDULR \ VHFXQGDULR ,]TXLHUGD HYROXFLyQ GH ǻȦ1 e ǻȦ2. 'HUHFKD HYROXFLyQ GH ODV
SRWHQFLDVJHQHUDGDVWRWDOHVHQFDGDiUHD\GHODSRWHQFLDGHLQWHUFDPELR

RPj c j ˜ RP(&   UHVHUYDSULPDULDGHOTXHVHEHQHILFLDFDGDiUHDDOIRUPDUSDUWHGH

XQVLVWHPDLQWHUFRQHFWDGR$VtHQHOFDVRGH(VSDxDVLIXHUDXQ

iUHD DLVODGD QHFHVLWDUtD GLVSRQHU DO PHQRV GH SRWHQFLD GH
3DUDHOFDVRGH(VSDxDFRQcES HVWDUHVHUYDUHVXOWD
UHVHUYD SULPDULD SDUD KDFHU IUHQWH D OD SpUGLGD GHO PD\RU JUXSR
FRPR PtQLPR GH  0: 2EVpUYHVH HO QRWDEOH DKRUUR HQ


 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364 361

WXUELQDJHQHUDGRUGHOSDtV/DSpUGLGDGHXQRGHORVJUXSRGHOD
&HQWUDO1XFOHDUGH&RIUHQWHVLPSRQGUtDXQDUHVHUYDSULPDULDGH
 0: PX\ VXSHULRU D ORV  0: UHTXHULGRV D (VSDxD
FRPRSDUWHGHOiUHDVtQFURQD(&
/DV HVSHFLILFDFLRQHV \ HO UHTXHULPLHQWR GH UHVHUYD GH FRQWURO
SULPDULR GHO VLVWHPD SHQLQVXODU HVSDxRO HVWiQ LQGLFDGRV HQ ORV
PiV OHQWR TXH HO SULPDULR GH WDO PDQHUD TXH GHEH KDFHU HIHFWR
GHVSXpVGHTXHHOSULPDULRKDFRPSOHWDGRVXDFFLyQHVWDELOL]DQGR
ODIUHFXHQFLD
3.1. Resultados de Simulación con Control Secundario
SURFHGLPLHQWRVGHRSHUDFLyQ32\5((EGRQGH /D )LJXUD  PXHVWUD HO GLDJUDPD GH EORTXHV HQ 0$7/$%
HVWH FRQWURO VH GHILQH GHQWUR GHO RUGHQDPLHQWR GHO PHUFDGR SimulinkGHOHMHPSORGHGRViUHDV\DVLPXODGRVRORFRQFRQWURO
HOpFWULFR FRPR XQ VHUYLFLR FRPSOHPHQWDULR GH FDUiFWHU SULPDULR DQWHULRUPHQWH \ FX\RV UHVXOWDGRV VH PRVWUDURQ HQ OD
REOLJDWRULRSDUDWRGDVODVXQLGDGHVGHJHQHUDFLyQ\QRUHWULEXLGR
(QFRQFUHWRVHUHTXLHUHTXHFDGDJHQHUDGRUSXHGDYDULDUKDVWDHO
 GH VX SRWHQFLD QRPLQDO EDMR OD DFFLyQ GH VX UHJXODGRU
SULPDULRGHYHORFLGDG
 JHQHUDGRUHV\VRORVHVLPXODHOFRPSRUWDPLHQWRGHFDGDiUHDHQ
 &RQWURO6HFXQGDULR
(Q HO FDVR GH XQ VROR JUXSR JHQHUDGRU HO OD]R GH FRQWURO
VHFXQGDULR VH UHSUHVHQWD HQ OtQHD GH WUD]RV HQ OD )LJXUD (Q OD
)LJXUD  VH PXHVWUD HO HVTXHPD FOiVLFR GH LPSOHPHQWDFLyQ GHO
)LJXUD  DUULED (O OD]R GH FRQWURO VHFXQGDULR UHSUHVHQWDGR HQ
OtQHD GH WUD]RV VH KDFH LQWHUYHQLU DKRUD HQ OD VLPXODFLyQ 'H
QXHYRVHFRQVLGHUDXQJHQHUDGRUHTXLYDOHQWHSRUFDGDiUHDSRUOR
TXH QR HQWUDQ HQ MXHJR ORV IDFWRUHV GH SDUWLFLSDFLyQ GH ORV
FRQMXQWR /RV GDWRV DGLFLRQDOHV QHFHVDULRV VRQ ODV FRQVWDQWHV GH
WLHPSRGHORVLQWHJUDGRUHVTXHVHILMDQHQHOPLVPRYDORUGH
VSDUDDPEDViUHDVHVWRHVODVFRQVWDQWHVGHORVLQWHJUDGRUHVGH
FDGD iUHD VRQ KI1  KI2   (VWD HOHFFLyQ VH MXVWLILFD HQ HO
DSDUWDGRVLJXLHQWH
FRQWURO VHFXQGDULR SDUD XQ iUHD GH FRQWURO 6H WUDWD GH XQ OD]R (Q OD )LJXUD  DEDMR VH PXHVWUDQ ORV UHVXOWDGRV GH OD
~QLFRTXHHVWDUiXELFDGRHQHOFHQWURGHFRQWUROGHOiUHD7LHQH VLPXODFLyQGRQGHSXHGHDSUHFLDUVHODHYROXFLyQWHPSRUDOGHǻȦ
FRPR HQWUDGDV ODV PHGLGDV GH SXOVDFLyQ DQJXODU Ȧ  ʌf GHO \ GH ODV SRWHQFLDV GH LQWHUFDPELR \ PHFiQLFDV WRWDOHV GH FDGD
iUHD\GHSRWHQFLDVGHLQWHUFDPELR(VWDVVHxDOHVVRQFRPSDUDGDV iUHD6HREVHUYDHOHIHFWRGHFRUUHFFLyQGHODIUHFXHQFLDGHFDGD
UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH FRQ OD SXOVDFLyQ QRPLQDO Ȧ0  ʌf0 \ FRQ ODV iUHD3RUVXSDUWHHOHUURUGHSRWHQFLDGHLQWHUFDPELRVHKDFHFHUR
SRWHQFLDV GH LQWHUFDPELR SURJUDPDGDV REWHQLpQGRVH ORV HUURUHV HQUpJLPHQSHUPDQHQWHRORTXHHVORPLVPRODSRWHQFLDYXHOYH
ǻȦHǻPLQWHQHOFDVRGHGRViUHDVGHOD)LJXUDǻPint ǻP12 DVHUODSURJUDPDGD(QFXDQWRDODVSRWHQFLDVWRWDOHVJHQHUDGDV
&RQHVWRVYDORUHVVHFDOFXODHOHUURUGHFRQWUROGHiUHD(&$ SRUFDGDiUHDODGHOiUHDDOFDQ]DHOYDORUTXHFRLQFLGHFRQHO
 LQFUHPHQWR GH GHPDQGD DFDHFLGR HQ HVH iUHD PLHQWUDV TXH OD
(&$ ǻPLQW  E ǻZ   SRWHQFLD WRWDO JHQHUDGD HQ HO iUHD  HV FHUR (Q OD SUiFWLFD ODV
 VHxDOHVGHFRQWUROVRQHQYLDGDVGHVGHHOFHQWURGHFRQWUROGHOiUHD
GRQGH ȕ HV OD característica de potencia-frecuencia GHO iUHD /D D FDGD JUXSR JHQHUDGRU HQ LQVWDQWHV GH WLHPSR GLVFUHWRV
VHxDO GH (&$ ILOWUDGD VH OOHYD FRPR HQWUDGD DO LQWHJUDGRU TXH WtSLFDPHQWH FDGD  D  V 6H LOXVWUD HVWR SUHVHQWDQGR OD
JHQHUDUiODVHxDOGHFRQWUROJOREDOGHOiUHDTXHPXOWLSOLFDGDSRU VLPXODFLyQSHURFRQODVVHxDOHVGHFRQWUROHQYLDGDVGHIRUPDQR
HO IDFWRU GH SDUWLFLSDFLyQ DVLJQDGR HV HQYLDGD D FDGD JUXSR FRQWLQXD3DUDXQDPHMRUDSUHFLDFLyQGHOHIHFWRVHVLPXODFRQODV
WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU VHxDOHVGHFRQWUROHQYLDGDVFDGDVEORTXHzero-order holdGH
 OD)LJXUD
‡–”‘†‡…‘–”‘Ž†‡Žž”‡ƒ
3.2. Aspectos Prácticos y Marco Normativo del Control
Secundario en Europa y España

(Q ORV GRFXPHQWRV GH UHIHUHQFLD 8&7(  \ 8&7(

VHLQGLFDTXHHOFRQWUROVHFXQGDULRGHFDGDiUHDWLHQH TXH
HPSH]DUVXDFWXDFLyQQRPiVGHVGHVSXpVGHSURGXFLUVHXQD
‘–‡…‹ƒ•†‡
‹–‡”…ƒ„‹‘
SHUWXUEDFLyQ \ GHEH UHGXFLU D FHUR HO (&$ HQ  PLQXWRV 3DUD
FRQVHJXLU HVWR UHFRPLHQGD HO DMXVWH GHO YDORU GH OD FRQVWDQWH GH
WLHPSRGHOLQWHJUDGRUHQHOUDQJRGHDVHJXQGRV3RURWUR
ODGRFRPRYDORUGHȕQHFHVDULRSDUDHOFiOFXORGHO(&$LQGLFD
‘–‡…‹ƒ•†‡
‹–‡”…ƒ„‹‘
 GLVSRQHUGHPDUJHQGHYDULDFLyQSDUDVXELUREDMDUPrefDSDUWLUGHO
)LJXUD  ,PSOHPHQWDFLyQ GHO FRQWURO VHFXQGDULR SRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLD HQ XQ
iUHDGHFRQWURO
'H HVWH PRGR OD SRWHQFLD GH FDGD JUXSR WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU
HVWDUiYDULDQGRKDVWDTXHVHDQXOHHO(&$ORFXDOJDUDQWL]DTXH
XQD YH] FRPSOHWDGD OD DFFLyQ GH FRQWURO VHFXQGDULR QR KDEUi
GHVYLDFLyQ GH IUHFXHQFLD QL GH SRWHQFLD GH LQWHUFDPELR UHVSHFWR
ODXWLOL]DFLyQGHXQYDORUHVWLPDGRPHGLDQWHODHFXDFLyQTXH
VHFRQVLGHUDUiFRQVWDQWHGXUDQWHWRGRHODxR
3DUD TXH SXHGD IXQFLRQDU HO FRQWURO VHFXQGDULR HV QHFHVDULR
SXQWR GH IXQFLRQDPLHQWR HQ ORV JHQHUDGRUHV TXH SDUWLFLSDQ (O
PDUJHQ GHVGH HO SXQWR GH IXQFLRQDPLHQWR KDVWD OD SRWHQFLD
Pi[LPDGHOJUXSRWXUELQDJHQHUDGRUHVODreserva de regulación
secundaria a subir < HO PDUJHQ GHVGH HO SXQWR GH
IXQFLRQDPLHQWR KDVWD HO PtQLPR WpFQLFR HV OD reserva de
regulación secundaria a bajar
GHODSURJUDPDGD\TXHVRORORVJHQHUDGRUHVGHOiUHDGRQGHVHKD (QHOiUHDVtQFURQD(&8&7(UHFRPLHQGDFRPRYDORU
SURGXFLGRHOLQFLGHQWHVHKDUiQFDUJRILQDOPHQWHGHOLQFUHPHQWR GHUHVHUYDVHFXQGDULDDVXELUPtQLPDHQFDGDiUHDGHFRQWUROHO
GH GHPDQGD SXHGH YHUVH XQD VLPSOH MXVWLILFDFLyQ GH HVWR HQ GDGRSRUODVLJXLHQWHH[SUHVLyQHPStULFD
.XQGXU  6X KRUL]RQWH WHPSRUDO GH HMHFXFLyQ HV PXFKR 


362 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364

RS aLmax  b   b   FRPR HV QRUPDO KD\ YDULDFLRQHV GH IUHFXHQFLD HO WLHPSR
VtQFURQR VH GHVYtD UHVSHFWR DO WLHPSR 87& (O REMHWLYR GHO
 FRQWUROGHWLHPSRHVOLPLWDUHVWDGLVFUHSDQFLD
GRQGHLPD[HVODGHPDQGDHQ0:Pi[LPDSUHYLVWDHQHOiUHD (Q8&7(VHDVLJQDODWDUHDGHPRQLWRUGHWLHPSRDXQ
HQ HO SHUtRGR FRQVLGHUDGR \ ORV SDUiPHWURV a \ b KDQ VLGR 26GHOiUHDVtQFURQD(&DFWXDOPHQWHHO26GH6XL]DSwissGrid
GHWHUPLQDGRVHPStULFDPHQWHFRQORVYDORUHVVLJXLHQWHVa  6ZLVVJULG  GHVGH VX FHQWUR GH FRQWURO HQ /DXIHQEXUJ (O
0:\b 0:LQGLFDGRVHQODFLWDGDUHIHUHQFLD8&7( SURFHGLPLHQWRGHFRQWUROFRQVLVWHEiVLFDPHQWHHQORVLJXLHQWHHO
/DUHVHUYDDEDMDUVHHVWDEOHFHHQWUHHO\HOGH 26 DVLJQDGR FDOFXOD OD GHVYLDFLyQ GH WLHPSR (7  76 ± 87&
OD UHVHUYD D VXELU 3DUD HO FDVR GH (VSDxD SHQLQVXODU FDGD GtD D ODV  DP \ RUGHQD DO UHVWR GH ORV 26 GHO iUHD
FRQVLGHUDQGRODPi[LPDGHPDQGDGHUHVXOWDXQYDORUGH VtQFURQD (& ILMDU OD UHIHUHQFLD GH IUHFXHQFLD f0 VHxDO SDUD HO
RSHQWRUQRD0: FRQWUROVHFXQGDULRYpDVHOD)LJXUDGHVGHODVDODV
 KRUDVGHOGtDVLJXLHQWHD+]VL(7!VRD+]VL
/RV SURFHGLPLHQWRV UHODWLYRV D OD UHVHUYD GH UHJXODFLyQ (7  ±  V $Vt VH PDQWLHQH HO HUURU GHQWUR GH ORV OtPLWHV
VHFXQGDULDGHO VLVWHPDSHQLQVXODUHVSDxROHVWiQUHFRJLGRVHQ ORV REMHWLYR“V
SURFHGLPLHQWRVGHRSHUDFLyQ32\5((E&RPR
HQ HO FDVR GH OD UHJXODFLyQ SULPDULD VH LQWHJUD HQ HO PHUFDGR
HOpFWULFRHVSDxROFRPRVHUYLFLRFRPSOHPHQWDULRHQHVWHFDVRGH
FDUiFWHUYROXQWDULR\UHWULEXLGR(OJUXSRWXUELQDJHQHUDGRUUHFLEH
FRPR SDJR GHO VHUYLFLR XQD FDQWLGDG SRU OD GLVSRQLELOLGDG GH
C. Medidas en Situación de Emergencia
/DSpUGLGDV~ELWDGHXQYROXPHQGHJHQHUDFLyQSRUHQFLPDGHO
YDORUGHILQLGRSDUDHOiUHD(&FRPRLQFLGHQWHGHUHIHUHQFLD
SRWHQFLD GH UHVHUYD \ XQD FDQWLGDG SRU OD HQHUJtD UHDOPHQWH 0: SURYRFDUi XQD FDtGD EUXVFD GH OD IUHFXHQFLD TXH QR SRGUi
XWLOL]DGDVLHVHOFDVR VHU FRPSHQVDGD FRQ OD VXILFLHQWHPHQWH UDSLGH] SRU ORV
 PHFDQLVPRVGHUHJXODFLyQSULPDULD\VHFXQGDULD(QHVWRVFDVRV
 2WURV&RQWUROHV VH DSOLFD OR TXH VH FRQRFH FRPR PHFDQLVPR GH GHVFRQH[LyQ R
deslastre de cargas por subfrecuencia
6HLQFOX\HQHQHVWHDSDUWDGRRWURVPHFDQLVPRVTXHFRPSOHWDQ (O GHVODVWUH VH HIHFW~D GH PDQHUD WRWDOPHQWH DXWRPiWLFD \ HV
ODHVWUDWHJLDGHFRQWUROSRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLDTXHVHHMHFXWDQHQXQ HMHFXWDGR SRU ORV UHOpV DVRFLDGRV D ORV LQWHUUXSWRUHV GH FLHUWDV
KRUL]RQWH WHPSRUDO PiV DPSOLR TXH HO SULPDULR \ VHFXQGDULR \ OtQHDVSUHVHOHFFLRQDGDV(Q(VSDxDHO325((EGH
TXHHQJUDQSDUWHVRQFRQWUROHVQRDXWRPiWLFRV
A. Control Terciario
$QWH XQ LQFUHPHQWR GH OD GHPDQGD OD DFWXDFLyQ GHO FRQWURO
VHFXQGDULR FDPELD OD Pref GH ORV JUXSRV WXUELQDJHQHUDGRU \ ORV
OOHYD D SXQWRV GH IXQFLRQDPLHQWR PiV FHUFDQR D VX Pi[LPD
FDSDFLGDG GH SURGXFFLyQ UHGXFLHQGR OD UHVHUYD SDUD HO FRQWURO
VHFXQGDULR (O FRQWURO WHUFLDULR WLHQH FRPR REMHWLYR UHVWLWXLU HVD
UHVHUYD PHGLDQWH OD YDULDFLyQ GH OD SRWHQFLD GH FRQVLJQD GH
JHQHUDGRUHVHQVHUYLFLRPHGLDQWHODFRQH[LyQGHJHQHUDGRUHVHQ
HVWDGRGHHVSHUDWtSLFDPHQWHDTXHOORVTXHDUUDQFDQUiSLGDPHQWH
DFXHUGRFRQODVUHFRPHQGDFLRQHVGH8&7(HVWDEOHFHTXH
HVWHPHFDQLVPRGHEHLQLFLDUVXDFFLyQFXDQGRODIUHFXHQFLDFDHD
 +] VLJXLHQGR XQD VHFXHQFLD GH GHVFRQH[LyQ HQ YDULRV
HVFDORQHV UHSUHVHQWDGRV SRU HO YDORU GH IUHFXHQFLD HQ HO TXH VH
SURGXFH\HOSRUFHQWDMHGHFDUJDGHVFRQHFWDGD


 &RQWH[WR,QWHUQDFLRQDO\3URSXHVWDVGH0HMRUD
3DUD HQWHQGHU DGHFXDGDPHQWH HO PDUFR LQWHUQDFLRQDO \ ODV
SRVLELOLGDGHV GH LQYHVWLJDFLyQ \ GHVDUUROOR HQ HVWH FDPSR HV
LPSRUWDQWHWHQHUHQFXHQWDTXHGHELGRDTXHODOLEHUDOL]DFLyQGHO
FRPR ODV WXUELQDV GH JDV R PHGLDQWH OD PRGLILFDFLyQ GH ORV VHFWRUKDHYROXFLRQDGRGHIRUPDGLVWLQWDHQGLIHUHQWHVSDUWHVGHO
SURJUDPDV GH LQWHUFDPELR FRQ RWUDV iUHDV (Q JHQHUDO OD PXQGR \ WDPELpQ GHELGR D ODV GLIHUHQFLDV HVWUXFWXUDOHV HQ ODV
DFWXDFLyQGHOFRQWUROWHUFLDULRHVORVXILFLHQWHPHQWHOHQWR± UHGHV HOpFWULFDV ODV GHILQLFLRQHV \ QRUPDV YDUtDQ
PLQXWRV FRPR SDUD SHUPLWLU TXH VHD XQ OD]R GH FRQWURO GH FRQVLGHUDEOHPHQWH HQWUH SDtVHV 3DUD D\XGDU D UHGXFLU HVWD
DFWXDFLyQPDQXDO FRQIXVLyQ HQ OD UHIHUHQFLD 5HERXUV HW DO  VH SUHVHQWD XQ
(QHOVLVWHPDSHQLQVXODUHVSDxROODUHVHUYDPtQLPDQHFHVDULD HVWXGLR FRPSDUDWLYR GH GLIHUHQWHV PDUFRV QRUPDWLYRV \ VH
GH UHJXODFLyQ WHUFLDULD 32  5(( E D VXELU HQ FDGD HVWDEOHFHQ ODV HTXLYDOHQFLDV GH GHILQLFLRQHV HQ YDULRV SDtVHV \
SHUtRGRGHSURJUDPDFLyQVHUiFRPRUHIHUHQFLDLJXDODODSpUGLGD UHJLRQHVGH(VWDGRV8QLGRV\(XURSD
Pi[LPD GH SURGXFFLyQ SURYRFDGD GH IRUPD GLUHFWD SRU HO IDOOR 'XUDQWH ODV ~OWLPDV GpFDGDV KD KDELGR XQD JUDQ FDQWLGDG GH
VLPSOHGHXQHOHPHQWRGHOVLVWHPDHOpFWULFRPD\RUDGDHQXQ LQYHVWLJDFLyQ VREUH DOWHUQDWLYDV D OD IRUPXODFLyQ FOiVLFD GHO
GHO YDORU GH OD GHPDQGD SUHYLVWD HQ FDGD SHUtRGR GH FRQWUROSRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLD,EUDKHHPHWDO6FKHUHUHWDO
SURJUDPDFLyQ 6H DVLJQD OD SUHVWDFLyQ GHO VHUYLFLR 32   3RU RWUR ODGR OD DSDULFLyQ GH ORV QXHYRV FRQFHSWRV GH
5(( E FRQ FULWHULRV GH PtQLPR FRVWH SDJDQGR D microrredessmartgridsVLVWHPDVGHDOPDFHQDPLHQWRRYHKtFXOR
SRVWHULRULVLIXHUDHOFDVRVRORSRUODHQHUJtDUHDOPHQWHXWLOL]DGD HOpFWULFR SODQWHD QXHYDV IRUPDV GH HQWHQGHU \ GH HMHFXWDU HO
SDUDFRQWUROWHUFLDULR FRQWURO \ DEUH WDPELpQ QXHYDV SRVLELOLGDGHV TXH QR HUDQ
DERUGDEOHV FRQ OD HVWUXFWXUD FOiVLFD 8QD PXHVWUD GH WUDEDMRV HQ
B. Control de Tiempo HVWHVHQWLGRVHHQFXHQWUDQHQODVUHIHUHQFLDV0DVXWDHWDO
2WD HW DO  0ROLQD*DUFLD HW DO  6KDIILH HW DO
9DQGRRPHWDO
6HGHQRPLQDWLHPSRVtQFURQR76DOWLHPSRPHGLGRWRPDQGR
/DQHFHVDULDDFWXDOL]DFLyQGHOUHVSDOGRQRUPDWLYRVHFRQFUHWD
FRPRXQLGDGGHPHGLGDHOSHUtRGRUHDOGHODWHQVLyQGHODUHG(O
HQ OD HODERUDFLyQ SRU SDUWH GH (1762( GHO GHQRPLQDGR
WLHPSR XQLYHUVDO FRRUGLQDGR R 87& Universal Time
Network Code on Load Frequency Control & Reserves NC
CoordinatedHVHOSULQFLSDOHVWiQGDUGHWLHPSRHQHOPXQGR6L


 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364 363

LFCR (1762( H (1762( I /D WHUPLQRORJtD )LJFRQHODGHFXDGRFRQWUROGHORVFRQYHUWLGRUHVGHSRWHQFLD

XWLOL]DGDSRUHVWHFyGLJRSUHVHQWDDOJXQDVQRYHGDGHVSRUORTXH SXHGH WHQHU XQ IXQFLRQDPLHQWR FRQMXQWR VLPLODU DO REWHQLGR FRQ
SDUD D\XGDU HQ VX OHFWXUD HQ OD 7DEOD , VH LQGLFDQ ODV XQJUXSRWXUELQDJHQHUDGRUFRQYHQFLRQDOORTXHKDFHSRVLEOHTXH
HTXLYDOHQFLDV GH ORV WpUPLQRV PiV UHOHYDQWHV HQ LQJOpV +DVWD OD HVWDV SODQWDV SXHGDQ SURSRUFLRQDU VHUYLFLRV FRPSOHPHQWDULRV GH
IHFKD DFWXDO $EULO  QR VH KD FRPSOHWDGR HO SURFHVR OHJDO UHJXODFLyQ 8QD IRUPD GH FRQVHJXLU HVH FRPSRUWDPLHQWR HV
TXH OR KDUi GH REOLJDGR FXPSOLPLHQWR HVWH SURFHVR SXHGH FDOFXODUGLJLWDOPHQWHXQDVHxDOGHFRPSHQVDFLyQSDUDODFRQVLJQD
VHJXLUVHHQODZHEGHGLFDGDHOHIHFWR(1762(J GH SRWHQFLD GH VDOLGD FRQ UHVSXHVWD SURSRUFLRQDO D OD IUHFXHQFLD
7DEOD(TXLYDOHQFLDHQWUHODWHUPLQRORJtDFOiVLFD\ODXWLOL]DGDHQORVQXHYRV
+LOOHWDO
FyGLJRVGHUHGGH(1762( $GHPiVHODOPDFHQDPLHQWRGHHQHUJtDSHUPLWHSDUWLFLSDUHQHO
GHVSOD]DPLHQWR GH ORV SLFRV GH FDUJD DEVRUELHQGR HQHUJtD GH OD
7HUPLQRORJtD 7HUPLQRORJtDXWLOL]DGDHQ1HWZRUN&RGHRQ UHGHQODVKRUDVGHEDMDGHPDQGD\JHQHUDQGRHQODVKRUDVGHDOWD
FOiVLFD /RDG)UHTXHQF\&RQWURO 5HVHUYHV GHPDQGDSHUPLWLHQGRODSURGXFFLyQGHHQHUJtDFRQVWDQWHGXUDQWH
Primary
Frequency Containment Process, FCP FDGD SHUtRGR KRUDULR %HOWUDQ HW DO  (Q RWUDV SDODEUDV
Control SHUPLWH KDFHU JHVWLRQDEOHV ODV SODQWDV GH UHQRYDEOHV OR FXDO
Secondary
Frequency Restoration Process, FRP SRVLELOLWDUtDHODFFHVRWDPELpQDOPHUFDGRHOpFWULFRGHHQHUJtD
Control 
Tertiary
Reserve Replacement Process, RRP
Control
Area Control
Frequency Restoration Control Error, FRCE
Error, ACE

 &RQVLGHUDFLyQGHODVIXHQWHVGHJHQHUDFLyQEDVDGDVHQ
HQHUJtDVUHQRYDEOHVHQHOFRQWUROSRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLD

/D JHQHUDFLyQ D SDUWLU GH IXHQWHV GH HQHUJtDV UHQRYDEOHV

GLVWULEXLGDV VLJXH XQD WHQGHQFLD FUHFLHQWH $ ILQDOHV GH  D 
QLYHO PXQGLDO VH DOFDQ]DURQ  *: \  *: GH SRWHQFLD )LJ (VTXHPD XQLILODU VLPSOLILFDGR GH XQ VLVWHPD GH DOPDFHQDPLHQWR GH
LQVWDODGD SDUD JHQHUDFLyQ HyOLFD \ IRWRYROWDLFD UHVSHFWLYDPHQWH HQHUJtDHQSDUDOHORFRQXQDSODQWDGHJHQHUDFLyQIRWRYROWDLFDFRQHFWDGRVDOD
FRQHFWDGDVSULQFLSDOPHQWHDODVUHGHVGHGLVWULEXFLyQ UHGHQXQQXGRFRP~Q
 /DV SODQWDV GH JHQHUDFLyQ UHQRYDEOH FRPELQDGDV FRQ ORV
VLVWHPDVGHDOPDFHQDPLHQWRKDQVLGR\VRQREMHWRGHQXPHURVRV
HVWXGLRV GH LQYHVWLJDFLyQ FXDQGR IRUPDQ SDUWH GH ODV
GHQRPLQDGDV PLFURUHGHV ([LVWHQ QXPHURVDV HVWUDWHJLDV GH
RSHUDFLyQ \ JHVWLyQ HQ 3DOL]EDQ HW DO  VH SODQWHD XQ
FRQWURO MHUiUTXLFR HQ  QLYHOHV GH FHUR D WUHV EDVDGR HQ
,(&,62(OQLYHOFHURLQFOX\HORVOD]RVGHFRQWUROLQWHUQRV
GHOFRQYHUWLGRUSDUDODDGHFXDGDJHQHUDFLyQGHWHQVLyQ\FRUULHQWH
LQ\HFWDGD /RV YDORUHV GH UHIHUHQFLD SDUD ORV OD]RV LQWHUQRV VRQ
JHQHUDGRV SRU HO QLYHO XQR FRQWURO SULPDULR *XHUUHUR HW DO
 %LGUDP HW DO  FDUDFWHUL]iQGRVH SRU VX UiSLGD
GLQiPLFD\ODDXVHQFLDGHVLVWHPDVGHFRPXQLFDFLyQ(OQLYHOGRV
VXSHUYLVD\PRQLWRUL]DHOVLVWHPDSRUWDQWRVtVRQUHTXHULGRVHQ
HVWH FDVR EXVHV GH FRPXQLFDFLyQ \ ILQDOPHQWH HO WHUFHU QLYHO
 JHVWLRQDORVIOXMRVGHSRWHQFLDHQWUHODPLFURUHG\HOH[WHULRU
)LJ  3RWHQFLD LQ\HFWDGD HQ OD UHG PHGLGD HQ XQD SODQWD IRWRYROWDLFD 
ORFDOL]DGDHQ(VSDxDHQGRVGtDVGLIHUHQWHV  &RQFOXVLRQHV
(O FRPSRUWDPLHQWR LQWHUPLWHQWH GH HVWDV LQVWDODFLRQHV
(OSUHVHQWHDUWtFXORUHDOL]DXQDUHYLVLyQGHORVPHFDQLVPRVGHO
SURGXFWRUDV \ VX GLVSHUVLyQ JHRJUiILFD VRQ VXV UDVJRV
FRQWUROSRWHQFLDIUHFXHQFLDHQORVVLVWHPDVHOpFWULFRVMXVWLILFDGR
GLIHUHQFLDOHV UHVSHFWR GH ORV VLVWHPDV GH JHQHUDFLyQ
SRUORVFDPELRVTXHVHHVWiQSURGXFLHQGRHQVXFRQILJXUDFLyQ6H
FRQYHQFLRQDOHV (Q OD )LJ  VH PXHVWUD D PRGR LOXVWUDWLYR OD
UHVXPHQ DGHPiV ORV UHTXHULPLHQWRV DFWXDOHV HQ ORV VHUYLFLRV GH
SRWHQFLD PHGLGD HQ XQD SODQWD IRWRYROWDLFD GH  0: SLFR HQ
UHJXODFLyQ SULPDULD HQ ORV SDtVHV HXURSHRV GHVWDFiQGRVH ORV
(VSDxDHQGRVGtDVGLIHUHQWHV
FyGLJRV HVWiQGDUHV \ QRUPDWLYDV DSOLFDEOHV /RV FRQFHSWRV
6X FRQH[LyQ D OD UHG VH UHDOL]D D WUDYpV GH FRQYHUWLGRUHV
SUHVHQWDGRV VH KDQ LOXVWUDGR FRQ VLPXODFLRQHV HQ XQ HVFHQDULR
HOHFWUyQLFRV GH SRWHQFLD TXH SDUD DSURYHFKDU DO Pi[LPR OD
UHDOLVWDHTXLSDUDEOHDODLQWHUFRQH[LyQHQWUHORVSDtVHVGH(VSDxD
HQHUJtD SURGXFLGD OOHYDQ LQFRUSRUDGRV DOJRULWPRV SDUD HO
\ )UDQFLD /D FRQWLQXDFLyQ GH HVWH WUDEDMR HVWDUi GHGLFDGD D
VHJXLPLHQWR GHO SXQWR GH Pi[LPD SRWHQFLD Maximum Power
DQDOL]DUPHGLDQWHVLPXODFLyQ\GHPDQHUDH[SHULPHQWDODHVFDOD
Point Tracking 0337 5RPHUR&DGDYDO HW DO 
OD LQIOXHQFLD GH OD SUHVHQFLD GH IXHQWHV GH HQHUJtD UHQRYDEOHV \
LQ\HFWDQGR HQ OD UHG OD Pi[LPD SRWHQFLD DFWLYD SRVLEOH \ SRU
VLVWHPDVGHDOPDFHQDPLHQWRHQORVHVFHQDULRV\DHVWXGLDGRVSDUD
WDQWRVLQSURSRUFLRQDUVHUYLFLRVFRPSOHPHQWDULRV
OD UHJXODFLyQ 3I (Q HVWD OtQHD VH KD H[SXHVWR XQ DYDQFH GH ODV
(Q HVWH HVFHQDULR XQ VLVWHPD GH DOPDFHQDPLHQWR GH HQHUJtD
WHQGHQFLDVHQFRQWUDGDVHQRWURVWUDEDMRVGHLQYHVWLJDFLyQ
FRQHFWDGR HQ SDUDOHOR FRQ XQD SODQWD GH JHQHUDFLyQ UHQRYDEOH


364 Barrero-González et al. / Revista Iberoamericana de Automática e Informática industrial 12 (2015) 357–364

(QJOLVK6XPPDU\ (1762( H 6XSSRUWLQJ 'RFXPHQW IRU WKH 1HWZRUN &RGH RQ /RDG
)UHTXHQF\&RQWURODQG5HVHUYHV>2QOLQHFRQVXOWD@'LVSRQLEOH
HQ KWWSQHWZRUNFRGHVHQWVRHHXZSFRQWHQWXSORDGV
/RDG)UHTXHQF\ &RQWURO RI 0XOWLDUHD (OHFWULF 3RZHU 1&B/)&56XSSRUWLQJB'RFXPHQW,VVXHSGI
6\VWHPV5HYLHZDQG1HZ&KDOOHQJHV (1762(I1HWZRUN&RGHV0LQL:HEVLWH>2QOLQHFRQVXOWD@
 'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSQHWZRUNFRGHVHQWVRHHX
$EVWUDFW *XHUUHUR HW DO  $GYDQFHG &RQWURO $UFKLWHFWXUHV IRU ,QWHOOLJHQW
 0LFURJULGV²3DUW , 'HFHQWUDOL]HG DQG +LHUDUFKLFDO &RQWURO ,(((
7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ ,QGXVWULDO (OHFWURQLFV YROXPHQ  Q~PHUR  S 
:LWK WKH DGYHQW RI OLEHUDOL]DWLRQ LQ WKH LQWHUFRQQHFWHG SRZHU '2,7,(
V\VWHP WKH RSHUDWLRQ EDVHG RQ PDUNHW PHFKDQLVPV DQG WKH +LOO HW DO  %DWWHU\ (QHUJ\ 6WRUDJH IRU (QDEOLQJ ,QWHJUDWLRQ RI
JUDGXDO LQFRUSRUDWLRQ RI UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ WKH JHQHUDWLRQ 'LVWULEXWHG 6RODU 3RZHU *HQHUDWLRQ ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ 6PDUW *ULG
WUDQVPLVVLRQ DQG GHPDQG UROHV DUH FKDQJLQJ ZKLOH WKH ORDG YROXPHS'2,76*
IUHTXHQF\FRQWUROPHFKDQLVPVUHPDLQLQWKHLURULJLQDOIRUP7KLV ,EUDKHHPHWDO5HFHQW3KLORVKRSKLHVRI$XWRPDWLF*HQHUDWLRQ&RQWURO
6WUDWHJLHV LQ 3RZHU 6\VWHPV ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQ RQ 3RZHU 6\VWHPV 9RO
PDNHV SUHGLFWDEOH DULVLQJ WUDLQLQJ UHVHDUFK GHYHORSPHQW DQG S'2,KWWSG[GRLRUJ73:56
LQQRYDWLRQQHHGVWRPHHWQHZFKDOOHQJHV
,Q WKLV FRQWH[W WKLV SDSHU WULHV WR SURYLGH WKH QHFHVVDU\
LQIRUPDWLRQIRUHQJLQHHULQJSURIHVVLRQDOVUHODWHGWRWKLVILHOGWKDW
QHHGWRFRQVROLGDWHDQGXSGDWHWKHLUNQRZOHGJHDQGWRVHUYHDVD
EDVLV IRU LQLWLDWLQJ UHVHDUFK 7R GR WKLV VLPXODWLRQ RI D UHDOLVWLF
SRZHUV\VWHPDUHSUHVHQWHGDQGWKHOHJDOUHJXODWRU\DQGSUDFWLFDO
DSSOLFDWLRQ IUDPHZRUN LQ WKH QDWLRQDO DQG LQWHUQDWLRQDO FRQWH[W
DUHUHYLHZHGDQGXSGDWHG
 9ROXPHQQ~PHURS'2,MULDL
Keywords:
(OHFWULFDO V\VWHP VLPXODWLRQ KLHUDUFK\ FRQWURO IUHTXHQF\
FRQWURO DXWRPDWLF JHQHUDWLRQ FRQWURO UHQHZDEOH HQHUJLHV
.XQGXU 3  (Q 0F*UDZ+LOO (G 3RZHU 6\VWHP 6WDELOLW\ DQG
&RQWURO1HZ<RUN,6%1
0DVXWD HW DO  6XSSOHPHQWDU\ /RDG )UHTXHQF\ &RQWURO E\ 8VH RI D
1XPEHU RI %RWK (OHFWULF 9HKLFOHV DQG +HDW 3XPS :DWHU +HDWHUV ,(((
7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ 6PDUW *ULG YROXPHQ  S  '2,
76*
0LNDWL HW DO  0RGHODGR \ 6LPXODFLyQ GH XQ 6LVWHPD &RQMXQWR GH
(QHUJtD6RODU\(yOLFDSDUD$QDOL]DUVX'HSHQGHQFLDGHOD5HG(OpFWULFD
5HYLVWD ,EHURDPHULFDQD GH $XWRPiWLFD H ,QIRUPiWLFD ,QGXVWULDO 5,$,
0ROLQD*DUFtD HW DO  'HFHQWUDOL]HG 'HPDQG6LGH &RQWULEXWLRQ WR
3ULPDU\ )UHTXHQF\ &RQWURO ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ 3RZHU 6\VWHPV
YROXPHQS'2,73:56
20,(  2SHUDGRU GHO 0HUFDGR ,EpULFR3ROR (VSDxRO 6$ >2QOLQH
FRQVXOWD@'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSZZZRPLHHV
VPDUWJULGVSRZHUHOHFWULFDODQGHOHFWURQLFV\VWHPV 2WD HW DO  $XWRQRPRXV 'LVWULEXWHG 9* 9HKLFOHWR*ULG 6DWLVI\LQJ
 6FKHGXOHG &KDUJLQJ ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQ RQ 6PDUW *ULG YROXPHQ  S
'2,76*
 3DOL]EDQ HW DO  0LFURJULGV LQ DFWLYH QHWZRUN PDQDJHPHQW²3DUW ,
$JUDGHFLPLHQWRV +LHUDUFKLFDO FRQWURO HQHUJ\ VWRUDJH YLUWXDO SRZHU SODQWV DQG PDUNHW
 SDUWLFLSDWLRQ 5HQHZDEOH DQG 6XVWDLQDEOH (QHUJ\ 5HYLHZV YROXPHQ 
(VWH WUDEDMR KD VLGR UHDOL]DGR EDMR HO SUR\HFWR WLWXODGR S'2,MUVHU
³6LVWHPD GH DOPDFHQDPLHQWR KtEULGR SDUD KDFHU JHVWLRQDEOHV ODV 3ODWDIRUPD (QHUJtD \ 6RFLHGDG  >2QOLQH FRQVXOWD @
'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSHQHUJLD\VRFLHGDGHV
LQVWDODFLRQHVGHJHQHUDFLyQIRWRYROWDLFD´FRQUHIHUHQFLD,%
5HERXUV HW DO  $ 6XUYH\ RI )UHTXHQF\ DQG 9ROWDJH &RQWURO $QFLOODU\
\ ILQDQFLDGR SRU HO *RELHUQR GH ([WUHPDGXUD (VSDxD D WUDYpV
GH ODV D\XGDV GHVWLQDGDV D OD UHDOL]DFLyQ GH SUR\HFWRV GH
LQYHVWLJDFLyQHQORVFHQWURVS~EOLFRVGH,'LGHOD&RPXQLGDG
$XWyQRPDGH([WUHPDGXUD
5HIHUHQFLDV
6HUYLFHV3DUW , 7HFKQLFDO )HDXWXUHV ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ 3RZHU
6\VWHPV YROXPHQ  S  '2, KWWSG[GRLRUJ
73:56
5(( D 5HG (OpFWULFD GH (VSDxD >2QOLQH FRQVXOWD @
'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSUHHHV
5((E5HG(OpFWULFDGH(VSDxD3URFHGLPLHQWRVGH2SHUDFLyQ>2QOLQH
FRQVXOWD @ 'LVSRQLEOH HQ KWWSZZZUHHHVHVDFWLYLGDGHV
RSHUDFLRQGHOVLVWHPDSURFHGLPLHQWRVGHRSHUDFLRQ
5RPHUR&DGDYDOHWDO*ULG&RQQHFWHG3KRWRYROWDLF*HQHUDWLRQ3ODQWV
%DUUHUR)(Q3DUDQLQIR(G6LVWHPDVGH(QHUJtD(OpFWULFD0DGULG &RPSRQHQWV DQG 2SHUDWLRQ ,((( ,QGXVWULDO (OHFWURQLFV 0DJD]LQH
,6%1 YROXPHQ~PHURS'2,0,(
%HOWUDQHWDO(YDOXDWLRQRI6WRUDJH(QHUJ\5HTXLUHPHQWVIRU&RQVWDQW 6KDILHHHWDO'LVWULEXWHG6HFRQGDU\&RQWUROIRU,VODQGHG0LFUR*ULGV
3URGXFWLRQ LQ 39 3RZHU 3ODQWV ,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ ,QGXVWULDO $1HWZRUNHG&RQWURO6\VWHPV$SSURDFKWK$QQXDOFRQIHUHQFHRQ,(((
(OHFWURQLFV YROXPHQ  Q~PHUR  S  '2, ,QGXVWULDO (OHFWURQLFV 6RFLHW\ ,(&21  S  '2,
7,( ,(&21
%LGUDP HW DO  +LHUDUFKLFDO 6WUXFWXUH RI 0LFURJULGV &RQWURO 6\VWHP 6FKHUHU HW DO  ,PSURYHG )UHTXHQF\ %LDV )DFWRU 6L]LQJ IRU 1RQ
,((( 7UDQVDFWLRQV RQ 6PDUW *ULG YROXPH  Q~PHUR  S  ,QWHUDFWLYH&RQWURO&LJUHVHVVLRQQXPEHU
'2,76* 6ZLVVJULG  2SHUDGRU GHO 6LVWHPD GH 6XL]D >2QOLQH FRQVXOWD 
(1762(D5HVHDUFKDQG'HYHORSPHQW5RDGPDS>2QOLQH @'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSZZZVZLVVJULGFK
FRQVXOWD@'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSVZZZHQWVRHHXSXEOLFDWLRQVUG 8&7(  8&7( 2S+%7HDP2SHUDWLRQ +DQGERRN $SSHQGL[  /RDG
UHSRUWVUGURDGPDS )UHTXHQF\ &RQWURO DQG 3HUIRUPDQFH (Q KWWSVZZZHQWVRHHX
(1762(E(XURSHDQ1HWZRUNRI7UDQVPLVVLRQ6\VWHP2SHUDWRUVIRU ILOHDGPLQXVHUBXSORDGBOLEUDU\SXEOLFDWLRQVHQWVRH2SHUDWLRQB+DQGERRN
(OHFWULFLW\ >2QOLQH FRQVXOWD @ 'LVSRQLEOH HQ 3ROLF\BB$SSHQGL[BILQDOSGI>2QOLQHFRQVXOWD@
KWWSVZZZHQWVRHHX 8&7(  8&7( 2S+%7HDP 2SHUDWLRQ +DQGERRN 3ROLF\  /RDG
(1762( F 6WDWLVWLFDO <HDUERRN  >2QOLQH FRQVXOWD @ )UHTXHQF\&RQWURODQG3HUIRUPDQFH(QKWWSVZZZHQWVRHHXILOHDGPLQ
'LVSRQLEOH HQ KWWSVZZZHQWVRHHXILOHDGPLQ XVHUBXSORDGB XVHUBXSORDGBOLEUDU\SXEOLFDWLRQVHQWVRH2SHUDWLRQB+DQGERRN3ROLF\BB
OLEUDU\SXEOLFDWLRQVFH6WDWLVWLFDOB<HDUERRNBSGI ILQDOSGI>2QOLQHFRQVXOWD@
(1762( G 1HWZRUN &RGHR Q /RDG)UHTXHQF\ &RQWURO DQG 5HVHUYHV 9DQGRRP HW DO  0LFURJULGV +LHUDUFKLFDO &RQWURO DQG DQ 2YHUYLHZ RI
>2QOLQHFRQVXOWD@'LVSRQLEOHHQKWWSQHWZRUNFRGHVHQWVRHHX WKH &RQWURO DQG 5HVHUYH 0DQDJHPHQW 6WUDWHJLHV ,((( ,QGXVWULDO
ZSFRQWHQWXSORDGV1&B/)&5,VVXHSGI (OHFWURQLF 0DJD]LQH YROXPHQ  S  '2, 
0,(