In this paper we review the evidence for such early nutritional influences on
Bnh»/i Medico/ BuH.tin 1997,53 (No 1).123-134 ©Th» Bntuh Counal 1997
Fetal and early childhood environment: long-term health implications
Animal studies
Protein-energy undernutntion
Iron deficiency
Breast milk: Children who were breast fed have often been shown to
perform better in terms of tests of development or cognition, verbal
ability or school performance14"18. Results have been similar in both
children born at term and preterm. However, there are two major
sources of confounding.
Iron deficiency: Children who have iron deficiency anaemia (in some
cases after being randomised to receive iron supplementation) have been
shown to have lower developmental scores than those with haemoglobin
levels in the accepted normal range11-23-24. Infants who were studied by
Lozoff et al in Costa Rica were followed up at the age of 5 years23.
Children who had been anaemic in infancy (haemoglobin <10 g/100 ml)
had lower developmental scores at age 5 than those who had not been
anaemic, regardless of treatment group and despite similar mean current
haemoglobin values in the two groups. These results were confounded
Mother was asked whether she wished to provide her own expressed breast milk for her
baby
No Yes
I
Randomlte to
I
Randomise to
Mother was asked whether she wished to provide her own expressed breast mHk for her
baby
1
No
I
Yes
I I
Randomise to
Randomise to
Term formula vs Preterm formula Term formula vs Preterm formula
as sole diets as supplements to mother's milk
Fig. 1 Study design. n=160 n=264
Breast milk: In study 1 (see Fig. 1), a unique group of children were
randomly allocated human breast milk. The milk was fed by nasogastric
tube to infants whose mothers had chosen not to provide their own
breast milk. The two major potential areas of confounding were avoided
in this study because all the mothers had chosen not to provide breast
milk, avoiding social and demographic confounding and since the
infants were fed by nasogastric tube the human milk fed group were not
exposed to the influence of intimacy with the mother during breast
feeding. In a comparison of infants fed donor milk with those fed
standard term formula (from two parallel trials and all with mothers
who had chosen not to provide breast milk), the human milk group had
significantly higher PDI31. Furthermore, despite substantial nutrient
differences between the banked donor milk and preterm formula, there
was no advantage for the preterm formula fed group. These findings
contrast sharply with those from study 2 (preterm versus preterm
formula comparison) and lend weight to the hypothesis that human milk
does contains a factor or factors which promote neurodevelopment and
The brain and retina are rich in both DHA and arachidonic acid (AA)
and uptake by these tissues increases substantially during the last
trimester of pregnancy and for several months after birth35. There is
good evidence that the DHA content of the infant's diet is reflected in the
composition of the infant's tissues36'37.
To date there are few published data on the influence of LCPUFA
supplementation on developmental status and most studies have been
too small to provide convincing evidence38. The issue of whether dietary
long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids in infancy confer a cognitive
advantage and are at least part of the explanation for the generally found
advantage for breast fed subjects is as yet unresolved. The results of
current large randomised trials of dietary LCPUFA are awaited with
interest.
Dietary iron
Overview
The importance of early nutrition for later cognitive development
continues to be debated. Previous studies of malnourished babies in
developing countries may sometimes have been motivated by political
needs to stimulate aid programmes, though it should be unnecessary to
prove that malnutrition damages a baby's brain in order to provide a
stimulus to reduce poverty and hunger.
However, despite many studies that have related early undernutrition
to later cognitive deficits, extensive reviews43"45 of this body of work
have suggested that most studies were too confounded by flaws in design
to provide compelling evidence. More recently, however, tightly
designed nutritional intervention studies have provided new and more
convincing evidence that the brain may be vulnerable to suboptimal
nutrition in early life. For instance, the new randomised trials of early
nutrition in preterm babies suggest that nutrition prior to full term may
have profound later effects, with major implications for clinical practice.
But there is still much that remains unresolved: does breast feeding really
21 Gale CR, Martyn CN. Breast feeding, dummy use and adult intelligence. Lancet 1996, 347:
1072-5
22 Lucas A, Morley R. Lancet 1996,
23 Lozoff B, Jimenez E, Wolf AW. Long-term developmental outcome of infants with iron
deficiency. N Engl J Med 1991 ; 325: 687-94
24 Walter T. Impact of iron deficiency on cognition in infancy and childhood Eur ] Clm Nutr
1993; 47: 307-16
25 Joos S, Pollitt E, Meuller W, Albright D. The Bacon Chow study: maternal nutritional
supplementation and infant behavioral development. Child Dev 1983; 54: 669-76