ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 91
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
production yield, purity, and environment impact, to reach rapidly the equilibrium state. The
by developing the enzymatic synthesis of laboratory equipment has been described in detail in
acetophenone. In this purpose, aminotransferase or previous paper [24]. The phase mixing was made by
transaminase from Escherichia coli has been used in means of a perforated disk with 45 mm diameter
free or immobilized form [16-20]. One of the most and 20 % free section. The vibrations had a
attractive enzymatic syntheses of acetophenone is frequency of 50 s-1 and 5 mm amplitude. The
by methylbenzylamine conversion under perforated disk position was maintained at the initial
transaminase action, according to the following contact interface between the aqueous and organic
reaction mechanism [16]: phases. The extraction time was 1 minute at a
constant temperature of 25 oC. The resulted
emulsion was broken in a centrifugal separator at
5000 rpm.
The initial concentrations of methylbenzylamine
or / and acetophenone in the aqueous solution were
3 g/l for each compound. These compounds have
been extracted individually or selectively from their
mixture.
The extraction has been carried out using four
organic phases: n-heptane, mixture between n-
The main problem of acetophenone biosynthesis heptane and 10 % vol. 1-octanol (phase modifier),
is its severe inhibitory effect, which can affect the mixture between n-heptane and 20 g/l di-(2-
efficiency of microbial or enzymatic process [19]. ethylhexyl) phosphoric acid (D2EHPA), and
For removing acetophenone from the fermentation mixture between n-heptane and 20 g/l tri-n-
or enzymatic medium, several methods have been octylamine (TOA) (extractants). The volumetric
tested: vacuum distillation, physical extraction, ratio of aqueous and organic phases was of 1 (20 ml
separation through membranes or hollow-fiber of each phase).
membranes, selective inclusion in ß-cyclodextrin, In all cases, identical extraction conditions have
and capillary electrophoresis [19-23]. The extraction been used.
method seems to be the most efficient one, the For respecting the enzymatic reaction pH [16],
extraction capacity and the biocompatibility being the pH-value of initial aqueous solutions was 5, 7,
the main criteria required for solvent selection. and 9, respectively. The pH adjustment was made
However, the highest extraction yields of with a solution of 3 % sulfuric acid or 3 % sodium
acetophenone were reached for solvents exhibiting a hydroxide, depending on the prescribed pH-value.
toxic effect against the microorganism or enzymes The pH-values were determined using a digital
(benzene, toluene, cyclohexanone, dioctylphtalate) pH-meter of Consort C836 type and have been
[19]. The other mentioned separation methods do recorded throughout each experiment. Any pH
not allow to reaching satisfactory efficiency for change was recorded during the extraction
applying them at larger scale. experiments.
In this context, this work is dedicated to the The extraction process was analyzed by means of
study on the possibility to remove efficiently the extraction yield and selectivity factor. For
acetophenone from the enzymatic medium by calculating these parameters, the concentrations of
extraction with a biocompatible solvent, namely n- methylbenzylamine and acetophenone in the initial
heptane. For increasing the extraction efficiency, aqueous solution and in the raffinate have been
different extractants and phase modifier have been measured, the mass balance being applied for the
added in the solvent phase, their effects being entire extraction system. These compounds
quantified in terms of extraction yield and concentrations have been determined by high
selectivity. In the experiments, the enzymatic performance liquid chromatography technique
synthesis of acetophenone from methylbenzylamine (HPLC), according to the previous method
has been considered. described in literature [16].
Each experiment has been repeated three times
under identical conditions, the average value of the
2 Experimental considered parameters being used. The average
The extraction experiments have been carried out experimental error was 4.03 %.
using an extraction column with vibratory mixing,
which offers high interfacial area and the possibility
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 92
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
80
n-Heptane + 20 g/l D2EHPA methylbenzylamine with D2EHPA is possible only
n-Heptane + 20 g/l TOA if the aminic group exists in the protonated form
into the aqueous phase, respectively at pH-value
60 lower than that corresponding to this amine pKa
[28]. By increasing pH, the protonation of amine is
40 affected, this compound becoming unable to react
with the organophosphoric extractant. For this
20 reason, at pH = 9, the yield of reactive extraction
with D2EHPA is higher than that of extraction with
n-heptane, but lower than that reached in presence
0
pH 5 pH 7 pH 9 of 1-octanol.
pH-value of aqueous phase The behavior of extraction system containing
TOA differs significantly from those above
Fig. 1. Influence of pH-value on yields of presented. According to Fig. 1, the efficiency of
methylbenzylamine individual extraction. reactive extraction with this extractant is very low,
the extraction yield increasing from 11 %, at pH = 5,
The yield of physical extraction of to 22 %, at pH = 9. Although in this case the aminic
methylbenzylamine with n-heptane varies between extractant cannot react with the aminic solute, it was
41 and 53 %, being slightly enhanced by increasing supposed that the extractant could solvate the solute
the pH-value of aqueous phase. Because n-heptane and, implicitly, enhances its solubility in the organic
is a low-polar solvent (dielectric constant 1.90 at phase. As it was reported in literature, the aminic
25 oC [27] which can solubilize especially the extractants are able to extract different solutes by
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 93
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
their solvation without chemical interactions, by extraction of methylbenzylamine with the same
forming aminic aggregates especially in non- or extractant. Moreover, although the variation of pH-
low-polar solvents [24,26]. value from 5 to 9 induces the reduction of
The results plotted in Fig. 1 suggest that the acetophenone extraction efficiency, it amplified the
addition of TOA hinders the methylbenzylamine difference between the extraction yields of the two
extraction, reducing significantly the extraction compounds. The more important positive effect of
yield compared to the other three analyzed systems. D2EHPA on acetophenone extraction is due to its
This effect can be explained by the presence of superior ability to react with D2EHPA cumulated to
TOA in the organic phase which restricts its superior solubility in the n-heptane phase.
additionally the limited ability of n-heptane to solve Because the efficiency of reactive extraction with
ionizable molecules as amines. Depending on the D2EHPA is comparable or below that of the
yield of acetophenone extraction, the negative physical extraction with the mixture between n-
influence of TOA on the methylbenzylamine heptane and 1-octanol, it can be concluded that the
extraction could represent an important factor relative magnitude of the positive influence of
enhancing the selectivity of the two compounds enhanced solubility of acetophenone in organic
separation from their mixture. phase exceeds the effect of D2EHPA presence in
Regardless of the used solvent, the yields of this phase.
individual extraction of acetophenone are Similar to the extraction of methylbenzylamine,
considerable higher than those of MBA extraction, the use of TOA leads to the decrease of the
being around 90% for all studied extraction systems acetophenone extraction yield compared to the other
(Fig. 2). solvents (Fig. 2). But, this reduction is with 5 to
10%, being considerably less pronounced than that
n-Heptane recorded for methylbenzylamine. This result
n-Heptane + 10% vol. 1-Octanol
n-Heptane + 20 g/l D2EHPA suggests that the higher solubility of acetophenone
100 n-Heptane + 20 g/l TOA in organic phase counteracts the negative effect of
Extraction yield, %
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 94
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
supplementary reduction of the organic phase ability According to the aforementioned reason, the
to induce the solvation and, implicitly, solubilization slight change of the solvent phase capacity to
of this compound. This phenomenon could be the solubilize acetophenone is due to the presence of co-
result of the change of the intermolecular extracted methylbenzylamine.
interactions inside the organic phase, due to the These results indicate the possibility to extract
presence of extracted acetophenone, more soluble in selectively acetophenone from the enzymatic media
the used solvents. containing its mixture with methylbenzylamine. For
selecting the optimum extraction conditions,
50
n-Heptane corresponding both to the highest selectivity of
Extraction yield, %
n-Heptane 25
n-Heptane + 10% vol. 1-Octanol
n-Heptane + 20 g/l D2EHPA
100 n-Heptane + 20 g/l TOA 0
pH 5 pH 7 pH 9
Extraction yield, %
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 95
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
extraction from the enzymatic media, this affecting [6] Lasekan O., Khatib A., Juhari H., Patiram P.,
the enzymatic process. Lasekan S., Headspace Solid-Phase
Microextraction Gas Chromatography-Mass
Spectrometry Determination of Volatile
Compounds in Different Varieties of African
4 Conclusions Star Apple Fruit (Chrysophillum albidum), Food
The studies on acetophenone and Chemistry, Vol. 141, 2013, pp. 2089-2097.
methylbenzylamine extraction underlined the [7] Bryant J.R., Matsuo T., Mayer J.M., Cumene
possibility to separate them selectively from the Oxidation by cis-[RuIV(bPy)2(Py)(O)]2+
enzymatic media. Therefore, by using different Revisited, Inorganic Chemistry, Vol. 43, 2004,
solvents consisting of a biocompatible solvent pp. 1587-1592.
(n-heptane) in which have been dissolved either 1- [8] Ogata Y., Oxidations with Nitric Acid and
octanol, as phase modifier, or D2EHPA and TOA, Nitrogen Oxides, in Organic Chemistry, Part 3,
as extractants, it was concluded that the highest Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2012.
extraction efficiencies is related to acetophenone. [9] Cripps R.E., Trudgill P.W., Whateley J.G., The
The difference between the extraction yields of Metabolism of 1-Phenylethanol and
acetophenone and methylbenzylamine has been Acetophenone by Nocardia T5 and Arthrobacter
amplified during the separation of these compounds species, European Journal of Biochemistry, Vol.
for their mixture, this difference allowing to 86, 1978, pp. 175-186.
reaching high selectivity of extraction. [10] Cox C.D., Parker J, Use of 2-
By analyzing the values of selectivity factor Aminoacetophenone Production in Identification
which correspond simultaneously to the avoidance of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Journal of Clinical
of substrate removal from the media and to the Microbiology, Vol. 9, 1979, pp. 479-484.
optimum pH for enzymatic reaction, pH = 7, it was [11] Farbood M.I., Kim A.Y., Blocker R.W.,
concluded that the most adequate solvent is the Process for Preparing Acetophenone, Products
mixture between n-heptane and 1-octanol. In this Produced therefrom and Organoleptic of Said
case, the extraction yield of acetophenone is 94.5 %, Products, Patent US 6482794 B1, 2002.
while that of methylbenzylamine is reduced to 0.3 %. [12] Hilton M.D., Cain W.J., Bioconversion of
Cinnamic Acid to Acetophenone by a
Pseudomonad: Microbial Production of a Natural
Acknowledgements Flavor Compound, Applied and Environmental
This work was supported by the Grant ERA-NET, Microbiology, Vol. 56, 1990, pp. 623-627.
ERA-IB “MICROTOOLS” authorized by The [13] Holland H.L., Bergen E.J., Chenchaiah P.C.,
Romanian Executive Unit for Financing Higher Khan S.H., Munoz B., Ninnissa R.W., Richards
Education, Research, Development and Innovation D., Side Chain Hydroxylation of Aromatic
(UEFISCDI). Compounds by Fungi - Products and
Stereochemistry, Canadian Journal of
References: Chemistry, Vol. 65, 1987, pp. 502-507.
[1] Burdock G.A., Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor [14] Jobst B., Schühle K., Linne U., Heider J., ATP-
Ingredients, 5th Edition, CRC Press, New York, dependent Carboxylation of Acetophenone by a
2005. Novel Type of Carboxylase, Journal of
[2] Clark J.H., McQuarrie D.J., Handbook of Green Bacteriology, Vol. 192, 2010, pp. 1387-1394.
Chemistry and Technology, London, Blackwell [15] Lee K., Gibson D.T., Toluene and
Science Ltd, 2002. Ethylbenzene Oxidation by Purified Naphthalene
[3] Gadamasetti K., Braish T., Process Chemistry in Dioxygenase from Pseudomonas sp. Strain
the Pharmaceutical Industry, CRC Press, New NCIB 9816-4, Applied and Environmental
York, 2007. Microbiology, Vol. 62, 1996, pp. 3101-3106.
[4] Siegel H., Eggersdorfer M., Ketones, in [16] Halim A.A., Szita N., Baganz F.,
Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, Characterization and Multi-step Transketolase-
Weinheim, Wiley-VCH, 2002. ω-Transaminase Bioconversions in an
[5] Garcia-Salas P., Morales-Soto A., Segura- Immobilized Enzyme Microreactor (IEMR) with
Carretero A., Fernández-Gutiérrez A., Phenolic- Packed Tube, Journal of Biotechnology, Vol.
Compound-Extraction Systems for Fruit and 168, 2013, pp. 567-575.
Vegetable Samples, Molecules, Vol. 15, 2010, [17] Kaulmann U., Smithies K., Smith M., Hailes
pp. 8813-8826. H., Ward J., Substrate Spectrum of ω -
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 96
Mathematical and Computational Methods in Applied Sciences
ISBN: 978-1-61804-328-3 97