October 2016
Abstract
The objectives of this research were to find out (1) the students' attitude towards learning English,
(2) the students' language learning strategies, and (3) students' language learning strategies related
to their achievement. The research employed mix method design. The subjects of this research
consisted of second semester of Deck (Nautical) department of Politeknik Ilmu Pelayaran
Makassar. The data were collected using attitude scale, strategy inventory for language learning,
and interview. The quantitative data were first tabulated and then classified according to the given
score ranges, and finally categorized in regard to the given criteria. The data interviews were used
to support the quantitative data. The Chi-Square was used to know the correlation between
language learning strategies and achievement. The result of this research showed that (1) the
student had positive attitude towards learning English, (2) the dominant language learning
strategies that the student used was metacognitive, and (3) there was no relation between the
students' language learning strategies and their achievement. In conclusion, the students enjoyed
learning English and realized the need of English in their department.
that the result of the research could be a good researcher formulated the research questions
motivation to other students in learning. as follows:
1. What is the attitude of Nautical
In connection with the purposes, Oxford department students of Politeknik Ilmu
(1990:8) views that learning strategies help Pelayaran Makassar towards learning
learners participate actively in such authentic English?
communication. This is supported by Ellis 2. What learning strategies do they apply
(1997:73) mentions several factors such as based on their attitude?
personalities, learning styles, language 3. What is students' achievement relating
aptitude, motivation and also differences in with their strategies?
learning strategies as factors that strongly
affect the learner's development in learning. Literature Review
According to Freeman (1991:179) views that Previous Related Studies
lecturer's attitude can also affect the quality (1) Related studies about attitude:
and quantity of the learning which take place. Marwan (2012) conducted a research study
In addition, Harmer (1998:1) said that about Researching Indonesian Students'
lecturer should make their lesson interesting. Attitude towards Foreign Language and
This can be concluded that the relationships found that the result of the study, overall,
between lecturer and students could not be indicated that Indonesian students had
separated in process of learning and teaching. positive attitude towards foreign language.
This is because they support each other to The students are happy to learn foreign
gain the goals. language. Pepople who feel forced in
learning will not benefit much in learning
This research is important to find the process. Gajalaksmi (2013) conducted about
students' attitude towards language learning High School Students' Attitude towards
because there still less information about the Learning English Language. The researcher
students' attitude in learning language found that there is significant difference
especially for Nautical Department students based on gender, locality of the school, type
in Maritime polytechnic. The lecturers need of school, type of management. Hence it was
for the research result to help them make the concluded that more classroom activities in
suitable or relevant English teaching and the study of English enhance pupils' attitude
learning for Nautical. The relevant English to learn English.
learning and teaching will prepare Nautical (2) Related studies about language learning
department students who are hoped that after strategies :
graduating from the school, they have special Said (2013) conducted the research study
competence to face the real workplace. under the title Learning Strategies Used by
the Students of English Department of
English is a compulsory subject in Maritime Tarbiyah Faculty at STAIN Palopo found
polytechnic. Nautical department students of that 1) the strategies applied by high
this school have to learn English because achievers in memory strategies were "review
they need English for communication in the English lessons". 2) metacognitive strategies
job. They are prepared to have the huge is the most frequently strategy used by sixth
opportunities after graduating in this school. semester students of English department of
Therefore, this research is feasible to be STAIN Palopo. 3) there is a significant
conducted in order to find out students' different in using language learning strategies
attitude towards learning English in relation between high achievers and low achievers.
to their learning strategies and achievement. The most frequently used by high achievers
Based on the background above, the is metacognitive strategies and the lowest
frequently used is affective strategies. learning activities which can influence the
Furwana (2012) researched about Learning students' performance in learning.
Strategies of Sixth Semester Students of
English Department of Tarbiyah Faculty at Attitude is rather permanent way of thinking,
UIN Alauddin Makassar researched about the feeling or behaving towards someone or
most dominant strategies that used by something Rasyid, (2015). The students have
Tarbiyah Faculty at UIN Alauddin Makassar response tendency by relatively way to
and that the metacognitive strategies was the people, thing or etc. with the positive or
most dominant language learning strategies negative attitude. If the students have
used by sixth semester students of English positive attitude, it becomes the good
department of Tarbiyah Faculty at UIN beginning for the learning and teaching
Alauddin Makassar. process. In accordance, Syah (2013:150)
(3) Related studies about achievement : notes that lecturer must have the positive
Rachmawati (2013) in her thesis under the attitude to her/his self and to the lesson in
title The Application of Language Learning order to make the students have the positive
Strategies and their Correlation with attitude too to the lecturer and to the material
Students' Achievement, found that there were will be learnt.
correlation between students' strategies and
their achievement. Bouirane (2015) In general, the concept of attitude in
conducted a correlation study among psychology defined as an evaluation of
metacognitive language learning strategies positive or negative toward thing or people.
use, gender, and learning achievement at Rasyid (2015) defined attitude is learned and
Farhat Abbes University Algeria, found that acquired before it becomes a predisposition
the third year EFL students used which comprises cognitive, affective and
metacognitive language learning strategies skill aspects. 1) Cognitive aspect involves the
that linked to their success in language beliefs of the language learners about the
learning. knowledge that they receive and their
In relation to this research study, understanding in the process of language
some researchers above discuss about learning. 2) Affective aspect refers to the
students' attitude, language learning positive or negative feeling. In fact, learners
strategies and achievement, but the express whether they like or dislike the
difference of this research that tried to situation or materials of learning and
correlate the students' attitude towards teaching process. 3) Skill aspect deals with
learning English, students' learning strategies the way one react in particular reaction.
and the students score in Nautical department
of Politeknik Ilmu Pelayaran Makassar. In Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary
(1995:1179), the word strategy means a plan
Pertinent Ideas designed for a particular purpose. And
Attitude has a close relationship with according to Oxford (1990:7-8) "Strategy"
motivation. O'Malley and Chamot comes from the ancient Greek term strategia
(1990:160) emphasize that the students who refers to generalship or the art of war. In
have experienced success in learning have more specific sense, strategy entails the
developed confidence in their own ability to optimal management of troops, ships or
learn. This is in line with McDonough aircraft in a planned campaign. In addition,
(1991:153) stated that no relationship Oxford (1990): stated that learning strategies
between achievement and attitudes for the are specific actions taken by the learner to
students who have direct experience of the make learning easier, faster more enjoyable,
language. Students' attitude is the behavior to
more self-directed, more effective, and more involving the target language. These two
transferable to new situations. categories of learning strategies support each
other in order to help students in learning
In other hand, Brown (1994:4) refers the language.
strategies as specific methods of approaching
a problem or task, modes of operation for Direct strategies. All direct strategies require
achieving a particular end, planned designs mental processing of the language, there are
for controlling and manipulating certain three group of direct strategies (Oxford,
information. While Cook (1991:78) refers the 1990:37) memory, cognitive and
learning strategies to a choice that the learner compensation strategies, but the three groups
makes while learning or using the second of direct strategies do this processing
language that affects learning, as distinct differently and for different purposes. (1)
therefore from discourse moves or Memory strategies have been used by people
communication strategies, both of which aim for thousand years for remembering or
at language use. differentiating things. To achieve fluency,
learners have to remember the large amount of
O'Malley and Chamot (1990:1) states that the vocabulary with different meanings;
learning strategies are the special thought or memory strategies help language learners to
behaviors that individuals use to help them cope this difficulty. In these learning strategies
comprehend, learn, or retain new involves brain activity to acquire the
information. And in other statement, Chamot language. Many ways that learners do in
(2004:16) defines learning strategies as the memorizing the language, Oxford (1990:38)
conscious thought that learners take in order divided memory strategies into four sets: Creating
to achieve a learning goal. Another expert, Mental Linkages, Applying Images and
Ellis (1997:76), notes that learning strategies Sounds, Reviewing Well, and Employing
are the particular approaches or techniques Actions. (2) Cognitive strategies are the practical
that learners employ to try to learn a second for language learning (Oxford, 1990:43). There are
language. They can be behavioral (for four set of cognitive strategies; practicing,
example, repeating new words in order to receiving and sending message, analyzing and
help remember them) or they can be mental reasoning and creating structure for input and
(for example, using the linguistic or output. (3) Compensation strategies enable
situational context to infer the meaning of the learners to use the new language for
new word). They are typically problem- comprehension or production despite limitations
oriented. In addition, learners employ in knowledge (Oxford, 1990:7). There are two
learning strategies when they are faced with strategies in compensation strategies, they are
some problem, such as how to remember guessing intelligently and overcoming limitations.
new word. Learners are generally aware of
the strategies they use and, when asked, can Indirect strategies. All direct strategies require
explain what they did to try to learn mental processing of the language, there are
something. three group of direct strategies (Oxford,
1990:37) memory, cognitive and compensation
Generally Oxford (1990:14) classified strategies, but the three groups of direct strategies
learning strategies into two categories; they do the this processing differently and for different
are direct strategies and indirect strategies. purposes. (1) Metacognitive strategies according to
Language learning strategies that directly Oxford (1990:136) are actions which go beyond
involve the target language are called direct purely cognitive devices, and which provide a way
strategies. Indirect strategies support and for learners to coordinate their own learning
manage language learning without directly process. Metacognitive strategies help learners
focus in learning target language. There are three classes. The total number of the population is
sets of metacognitive strategies based on Oxford 197 students. To determine sample of this
(1990:136) centering your learning, arranging research, the researcher used purposive
and planning your learning, and evaluating your sampling. The present researcher took 2
learning. (2) Affective strategies. The learners can classes of Nautical department students as the
gain emotions, attitudes, motivations, and values sample in even semester academic year
through affective strategies (Oxford, 1990: 2014/2015, because the students were
140). There are three main set of affective demanded to use more English for supporting
strategies exist: Lowering your anxiety, their skill later. Therefore, the total number of
Encouraging yourself, and Taking your the sample was 52 students.
emotional temperature. (3) Social strategies.
Language is a form of social behavior; it is In order to collect data, the researcher used
communication, and communication occurs four instruments, they are: (1) Attitude scale
between and among people (Oxford, 1990: 144). (2) Interview (3) Adapted Strategy Inventory
People are needed each other to communicate or for language Learning (SILL) version 7.0 by
for social interaction. Social strategies are very Oxford (1989); and (4) Documentation.
important in the process of interaction. Thus,
learner needs the ways in learning target language. This research used the Attitude scale to
Social strategies divided into two set such as measuring the attitude towards learning
asking question, cooperating with others and English. It aimed to explore the differences in
empathizing with others. the participants' attitude by their information
based on the questionnaire. There were 15
In Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary items concerning language attitudes in terms
(1995:1179), the word achievement means a thing of: cognitive aspects (5 items), affective aspects
done successfully. According to Kusaeri and (5 items) and behavioral aspects (5 items).
Suprananto (2012:7) that achievement is The items were put in 5 point Likert scale.
knowledge or individual skill in a material which Interview was used to support the attitude
had been learnt. In relation to the English towards learning English. The interview was
achievement, it can be conclude that the students' used as a crosscheck to see the consistency
mastery in English knowledge or English skill of the students' reply questionnaire. This study
which had been learnt. In the end of learning and used LLS of Oxford's (1990) Strategies
teaching process, Lecturer has to evaluate the Inventory for Language Learning (SILL). This is
students' mastery in current subject. It aims to the most popular strategies inventory in studies
determine the students' achievement in order to conducted to investigate the language learning
prepare the good preparation in teaching for the strategies used by the learners. The instrument
next learning and teaching process (Sardiman, specifies six learning strategies represented by a
2012:174). number of statements each with a corresponding
Likert scale between 1 and 5. Memory strategies
Research Method comprise 9 items, Cognitive strategies: 14 items,
This research employed mixed method design. Compensation strategies: 6 items,
This research used QUAN-Qual model, also Metacognitive strategies: 9 items, Affective
known as the explanatory mixed methods strategies: 6 items, and Social strategies: 6 items.
design, in which the quantitative data are The total numbers of the items were 50 items. In
collected first then supported by qualitative data. this research, the researcher asked the Lecturers'
documentation of students' record of their English
The population of this research was the achievement. In this case the document here was
Second Semester students of Politeknik Ilmu the students' record in the last semester.
Pelayaran Makassar that consists of six
After tabulating and analyzing the data from the learn English. The interview result affirm
two data collection instruments, the data analysis the finding that that the students were
were continued to the correlational analysis interested to learn English because they
between the language learning strategies that the choose Nautical Department and realized the
students use and their English achievement. The importance of learning English. As confirm
analysis is intended to answer the given hypothesis in the cited excerpt below:
as follows: Excerpt 1 :
H0 : the students‘ English achievement doesn‘t M : ―Mengapa Anda tertarik belajar Bahasa
correlate to their language learning strategies. Inggris?‖
H1: the students‘ English achievement correlates to A : ―Karena saya ambil jurusan yang
their language learning strategies. banyak pakai Bahasa Inggris
The computation of correlation coefficient of the M : “ Why are you interested to learned
data was assisted by SPSS 18 using Chi-Square English?”
technique. A : “It is because I choose Nautical
department that using English more‖
Findings and Discussion (A interviewed on 13th , April 2015)
Research Questions 1: What is the attitude
of Nautical department students of Politeknik Excerpt 2 :
Ilmu Pelayaran Makassar towards learning M : ―Mengapa Anda suka belajar Bahasa
English? Inggris?:
Finding 1 : B : ― Karena saya ambil jurusan Nautika
The finding is shown in the following table : yang banyak pakai Bahasa Inggris‖
Table 1. Percentage of Students‘ Attitude M : “ Why do like to learnd English?”
Interval Category Frequency Percentage B : “ Because I choose Nautical department
score
63-75 Strongly 8 15,38
that using English more”
positive (B interviewed on 15th ,April 2015)
51-62 Positive 41 78,85 Excerpt 3 :
39-50 Neutral 0 0
27-38 Negative 3 5,77
M : ―Jadi bagaimana menurutta pentingkah
15-26 Strongly 0 0 itu dipelajari Bahasa Inggris lisan atau
Negative tulisan?‖
Total 52 100
C : ―Kalau saya penting sekali, karena kelak
ketika kami akan bekerja di kapal, semua
Table 1 shows that answer students research instruksi dan buku manual menggunakan
questions number 1 is 78,85% of the students Bahasa Inggris‖.
have positive attitude towards learning M : “How do you think about the
English (finding 1). This findings is importance of oral and written
supported by Rasyid (2015) that attitude is English?”
rather permanent way of thinking feeling or C : “ I think it is very important, because
behaving towards someone or something, when we are going to work on board, all the
and the result of this research showed that the instruction and manual book uses English”
student have positive attitude towards (C interviewed 15th, on April 2015)
learning English. This finding is supported
Marwan‘s (2012) research that the students Excerpt 4 :
are happy to learn language because people M : ― Mengapa anda tertarik belajar Bahasa
feeling forced in learning will not benefit Inggris ?‖
much in learning process, this means that the D : ― Karena saya suka cara gurunya
students have positive attitude towards mengajar‖
learning. For many reasons, the student of
Nautical Department of PIP Makassar like to
the students have good score that was 82,69 evaluation tools, material for evaluation, and
% student got good score and 17,31 % situation of evaluation are the factors can
students got average score . affect the students ‗achievement.
(2) The Correlation between Students‘LLSs
with their English Achievement Other researchers (Rachmawati, 2013 and
The result of analysis as seen in the table Bouirane, 2015), found that learning
below: strategies correlated with their language
Table 4. LLSs and Achievement Cross- achievement. Therefore, this issue is still
Tabulation debatable.
Achievement
Good Averag Total Conclusion and Suggestions
e
Conclusions
Strategie Memory 2 1 3
s Cognitive 3 3 6 Based on the research findings and
Compensatio 3 1 4 discussion in the previous chapter the
n 19 4 23 researcher concludes that:
Metacogniti 6 0 6 1. The students have positive attitude
ve 7 3 10 towards learning English because of they
Affective
Social felt enjoy when learning and realized the
Total 40 12 52 need of English in their department.
2. The students used all language learning
strategies in learning English although
Table 5. Chi Square Tests Result
Asym.sig
they have different attitude towards
Value df learning English.
(2-sided)
Pearson Chi-square 5,125a 5 ,401 3. The achievement is different among the
Likelihood Ratio 6,075 5 ,299 students, no matter that they use
Linear-by-linear ,979 1 ,322 language learning strategies or not, but
Association they had different result in learning with
N of Valid Cases 52
different strategies.
The table above shows that Pearson Chi Suggestions
square was 5.12 and the significance was Based on the conclusions above, the
0.401. Because of the significant test is larger researcher addresses the following
than 0.05, therefore, HO is accepted. It suggestions:
means that the dominant categories of 1. The students understand the need of
language learning strategies that the students English in their department, therefore,
use do not correlate with their English the teacher should direct the students to
achievement. Hence, it could not be assumed practice their English more based on
that a certain category of language learning their needs department.
strategies in only used by students with 2. Through learning strategies, teachers
certain level of English achievement. This should help the low achiever students to
finding supported Ikhsan (2014) research in maintain their motivation and confidence
Palopo that the students learning strategies in learning target language.
do not correlate with their language 3. The teachers should understand the
achievement. The students‘achievement students‘ strategies towards learning
related closely to the students‘ achievement. English to compose the suitable
This research support Djamarah and Zain activities in learning and teaching
(2006) statement that purpose, teacher, process.
learner, learning and teaching process,