Anda di halaman 1dari 6

Construction Power Design, Installation & Control Considerations for a Large

Industrial Construction Project

ESW2015-09

Scott Mitchell Mark Cross


Cianbro Corporation TIC Southern
PO Box 1000 785 Greens Parkway
Pittsfield, ME 04967 Houston, TX 77067
smitchell@cianbro.com mark.cross@ticus.com

Abstract- Provisions for Construction Power With any electrical supply there are hazards
often present many unique electrical safety related to electrical shocks and arcs. It is a
challenges both in logistics and in hazard miti- common misconception that temporary wiring
gation, which must be addressed.[1] An aware- represents a lower standard than that of other
ness and familiarization of the regulations and wiring. Per NFPA 70, the same rules of work-
standards that govern electrical safety require- manship, ampacity and overcurrent protection
ments can be challenging.[2] It is often the re- apply to temporary installations as to others.
sponsibility of electrical supervisory personnel “Except as specifically modified in this article, all
whom in many cases do not have an engineer- other requirements of this Code for permanent
ing background, but are familiar with assessing wiring shall apply to temporary wiring installa-
needs and components used to meet those tions”.[3] Due to the nature of construction ac-
needs. One consideration is the variety of tivities on projects exposure to damage must be
equipment needed and the types of loads that carefully analyzed.
they introduce to the supply system. As the The level of risk to electrical hazards can be
project progresses there may be a need for ad- affected by many variables including but not
ditional specialized equipment so it is necessary limited to the following:
to allow for increase in demand. The complexity • Safety culture
of the construction power scheme must be suf- • Project leadership
ficient to safely meet the needs of the project. • Type of construction activity
• Location / environment
I. Introduction
• System design
This paper will demonstrate some of what a • Availability of equipment
contractor should consider in the design, instal- • Condition of equipment
lation and control of construction power for a • Project schedule
large industrial project. • Documentation and Control

II. Safety Culture / Project Leadership

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
What is the safety culture of your organiza- to understand the work plan for this in the be-
tion? Has the value of a properly designed elec- ginning. This post weld heat treatment (PWHT)
trical system been agreed upon? Does the requirement could be the biggest electrical load
budget carry the cost? Does the safety culture to consider. These PWHT loads are resistive
of your organization support the value of a sys- loads that will draw steady current for a length
tem that will stand up to the needs of the of time. The loss of this circuit during the treat-
project? What type of conversations should the ment phase will cause the weld to be cut out
electrical leaders have with project leaders? and started all over. This is not what any man-
What does project management need to under- ager wants to see happen.
stand so they will support the cost and installa- Many projects require cranes to supply lifts
tion of a system that meets or exceeds all appli- to complete the work and consideration for
cable codes and safety standards? Are company mobile cranes verses tower cranes can be cru-
policies and procedures in alignment with NFPA cial to a properly sized electrical distribution
70E? [4] system. Physical space on a site could be a rea-
son to use electric tower cranes. If so, and de-
III. Type of construction activity pending on their size, these electrical loads will
The type of activity and how the activity will also take special consideration. If at all possible
be accomplished is important for everyone to these loads should have dedicated circuits.
understand from the project estimators at the Usually in the hoist down travel mode these
bid phase, through the commissioning phase of cranes will have dynamic braking and can have
turn over to the owner. a regenerative effect on the electrical system.
There are always needs for electrical services These loads will draw more current than some
in addition to accomplishing the direct work may anticipate or plan for.
activities. The field offices, lunchrooms, ware- Specialty equipment and electrical needs will
housing, onsite equipment maintenance, fuel arise throughout the project. Some could in-
storage, site lighting security gates, cameras, clude machining for valve repair, bolt heaters,
warning systems, communications, weather sky climbers and preservation power needs
stations, internet needs , environmental and such as de-humidifiers, climate controls anti
sanitary needs are all areas that should be con- condensation heaters etc. Use of dewatering
sidered in the overall construction power plan- equipment, where water tables require this ac-
ning and design. The projects of today have be- tivity, can introduce substantial electrical load
come more complex with additional but neces- on a construction power system.
sary considerations from just a few years ago.
Welding is the primary method of attach- IV. Location / Environment
ment with Industrial work. Knowing that the
When a project is spread out to cover offic-
managers will want to use fueled welding ma- es, parking areas, warehousing, etc. there may
chines or rectified electric machines is critical. be need for multiple power sources. In all loca-
Experience has taught that the majority of
tions, consideration for where the source will
welding will be from electrical sources. If there come from, where it will be distributed to, and
will be pre heat and post weld treatment re- a need for a locale that will not have to be dis-
quirements for the project, it will be paramount
turbed later for any construction activity should

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
be planned. Access for operability, protection lighting, communications, and battery systems,
from traffic, grading, flooding, corrosion and without energizing facility permanent power
environmental concerns are all important con- systems. This can avoid the perceived need to
siderations. have energized permanent plant electrical
The NEMA rating of the distribution equip- equipment scattered throughout the facility
ment must be suitable for its environment. [5]. before construction is substantially complete.
One of the major environmental concerns is Provisions to have construction activities per-
moisture, as it not only has a negative effect on formed in electrically safe conditions will reduce
electrical equipment, but also increases risk of risk of injury to the workers.
electrical hazards. Whether the construction It is very likely that many local distribution
activity takes place on land and the concern is boxes will be used to minimize the number of
precipitation related, or marine based activities small power cords and related voltage drop is-
which could include corrosive salt water expo- sues. These boxes should always be positioned
sure, all wet environments offer unique chal- close to activities which they serve and in a rela-
lenges. tively dry and safe location. Routing feeder
Many safety procedures and training re- cords and extension cords overhead will elimi-
quirements have been introduced and added to nate both tripping hazards for workers and risk
company policies due to the complications of of physical damage to the cords. Often it is
work in wet locations. Specific training must worth constructing temporary supports to ac-
target those workers who do not have an un- complish this. Cords should always be sup-
derstanding of electricity and yet depend on it ported using nonconductive ties. If overhead
to support their construction activities. These activities such as crane use make overhead
workers are likely to make dangerous choices in routing infeasible, cords routed on walking and
order to complete their tasks without realizing working surfaces should be guarded with run-
the increased risk. For example, portable GFCI’s ning boards on either side or other suitable pro-
could be removed when work is being per- tection.
formed in particularly wet locations due to what Cord connections should be minimal to avoid
is perceived as nuisance tripping. Making and increased risk to workers from connecting and
breaking power cord connections above disconnecting as well as problems related to
125/250V single phase, is an at-risk activity for environment and physical damage such as loose
untrained workers, as these are not required to blades, cracked housings, and loose connec-
be GFCI protected.[6]. tions. Connections when needed should be
Hazard awareness training which fosters an made with approved listed devices suitable for
understanding of how protective devices oper- the application and should always be kept dry.
ate and why special procedures are mandated System design should include large frame
will improve compliance with written policies. feeder breakers with adjustable trip settings.
Ground fault, short circuit, over current, short-
V. System Design time and long-time settings should all be part of
Consider coordinating construction power the scheme.
system design with project engineered design
to support facility critical power systems such as

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
VI. Availability of equipment: • Defective parts
• Ground faults
In the development of the overall construc-
• Unguarded live parts
tion power scheme one must consider the type
• Corrosion
and availability of electrical equipment to be
used on the project. From the main distribution VIII. Project schedule:
equipment supplying feeders out to areas, sub
feeders, panels and branches to end of the line Every project schedule has construction de-
outlets, all need to be sized and properly pro- lays. Schedules are living documents that need
tected as in any designed system. The equip- to be updated and managed within themselves.
ment used may be engineered and manufac- Equipment and material deliveries, weather,
tured switchgear mixed with specifically con- manpower, holidays, and sequence of events
structed equipment on the project similar to will affect a schedule. Construction managers
the “Bang Board” approach of distribution. are always reviewing and trying to make the
Many times your specific needs drive the deci- best progress forward with the current condi-
sion to buy, build or rent. In some coastal areas, tions.
depending on season, rental electrical distribu- The need for electrical distribution can
tion gear can be very hard to acquire. Rentals in change and knowledge of how the priorities can
Florida during hurricane season may be in stock change, from day to day on a project can greatly
but unavailable for possible emergency needs. enhance the initial design and setup of the con-
struction power system. Always have some
VII. Condition of equipment: room for growth and adjustment. Most times
the issue is not necessarily total KVA or load,
All electrical equipment should be cleaned,
but rather the lack of outlets to distribute the
tested, torqued, bonded and grounded as part
loads.
of the installation procedure. Whether it is
called temporary power, construction power or IX. Documentation and Control:
permanent power is irrelevant. The physics of
electricity are unaltered. The equipment may Begin documentation of the design with a set
have been used several times before, used in of one-line drawings. Many cases require these
harsh environments, shipped long distances, drawings be approved and stamped by a Pro-
damaged in removal, transit, or installation. fessional Engineer. This is especially helpful
Even new equipment fails from time to time. when county or city permits are required. Con-
Our policies are to treat construction power tractors should work with the engineering
provision as any other power provision. Quality group for the project to help with this design
Control and Assurance should be completed on and develop professional drawings.
each component of the system as if it were a Maintain and post an up to date single-line
permanent system. diagram. Posting of this diagram should be in
The nature of electrical accidents from un- the safety office, electrical office or conference
safe equipment and installations can be due to: rooms where discussions and planning may take
• Faulty insulation place. The drawings should include protective
• Improper Grounding device details such as fuse and circuit breaker
• Loose connections types and ratings. The drawings should indicate

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
available fault currents and arc hazard incident Documentation of the original installation
energy at the equipment. and maintenance records are key components
Maintain and post an up to date general ar- to a safe and effective system.
rangement or layout drawing along with the
one line drawing to show underground and XI. Acknowledgements
overhead utilities installed on site. This will aid Thanks to Jim Mitchem of TIC for leadership
in locating obstacles for future excavations, in policy development and in training and to
placement of cranes or equipment. Daryld Ray Crow of DRC Consulting, Ltd. for his
Conduct a monthly audit and action item knowledge and support in the IEEE community.
checklist of the construction power once it is
installed. Verify labeling and placards are in XII. References
place and correct. [7].
[1] Meeting the Electrical Safety Challenges.
Check for open holes or penetrations that
Dennis Neitzel and Timothy Gauthier, ESW
should be sealed or covered and verify power
2014-28
panel directories are correct and in place.
Maintain safety training records to verify that [2] CFR29-OSHA 1926.405, CFR-29-OSHA
all workers have been made aware of the ha-
zards involved and risk reducing measures. 1910.302, NECA – 200 -210, Cal OSHA 2320
Complete monthly continuity and grounding
[3] NFPA 70 2014 Article 590.2(A) & (B)
checks and document as needed. Complete
checks for ground fault device operation. [4] NFPA 70E 2012 Article 105

X. Conclusions [5] NFPA 70 2014 Article 110.28

A shock or arc blast from a temporary instal- [6] NFPA 70 2014 Article 590.6
lation can be just as deadly as one from a per-
manent installation. Either type of installation is [7] NFPA 70 2014 Article 110.16
capable of igniting a fire if the conductors over-
XIII. Vito
heat or an arc is produced by faulty wiring or
poor installation practices. It is only reasonable Mark A. Cross has been in the electrical
that the same rules in regard to workmanship, construction industry since 1974. With more
conductor ampacity limits and overcurrent pro- than 35 years in the Industrial segment, Mark
tection should apply to both kinds of installa- has experience as a craftsman, in front-line
supervision, and for the past 25 years as
tions.
superintendent. In 30 years with TIC Industrial
Large scale construction projects may last Mark has constructed and managed projects
more than a year. Construction Power design across the United States including geothermal
should start at the beginning phases of the power, gold and copper mills and smelters,
project while still with Engineering. EPC con- cement plants, natural gas, mining projects,
tracts provide a good opportunity for the con- surface and underground, fossil unit upgrades,
tractor and engineers to work together. Design and many combined cycle power projects up to
1200 MW.
the system to be flexible.
In his role as Superintendent, Mark is
responsible to direct the work and to meet goals

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE
for safety, schedule, quality, and productivity.
Mark has long been passionate about electrical
safety, and conducts electrical safety training
both on his projects and in support of other
projects. Mark has been a leader within TIC in
minimizing employee exposure to electrical
hazards and building a sustainable electrical
safety culture. Mark carries various state
electrical licenses.

Scott B. Mitchell has been involved with the


electrical industry since 1980 and is currently
the Electrical Training Coordinator for Cianbro
Corporation, a general contractor headquar-
tered in Pittsfield, Maine. Beginning his career
on his tools as an electrician, Scott progressed
into various electrical leadership roles.
Scott has experience in residential, commer-
cial, and industrial wiring with 12 years as an
instructor for electrical apprentices and elec-
trical safety trainer for all Cianbro team mem-
bers. He holds Master Trainer credentials with
NCCER, and serves as a subject matter expert
assisting with electrical curriculum develop-
ment. Scott also holds OSHA outreach trainer
and American Heart Association instructor certi-
fications. Scott has become an electrical safety
resource for Cianbro and has developed specific
electrical trainings designed to increase the
skills of the electrical group and promote safe
work practices. Scott carries various state elec-
trical licenses.

978-1-4799-4782-9/15/$31.00©2015 IEEE

Anda mungkin juga menyukai