Global
Initiating Coverage
July 23, 2008
BUY
Power Up
We initiate coverage on Hub Power Company (HUBCO) with a “BUY” Industry Power Gen.
recommendation, based upon our estimates of its IRR and intrinsic value. The
stock offers an attractive PKR IRR of 23%, and USD IRR of 20%, and is currently Industry view Positive
trading at a discount of 32% from our estimated intrinsic value of PKR 40/share.
Robust & escalating dividend yield Ticker
HUBCO offers relatively low-risk and robust dividend pay-offs with a prospective
KATS HUBC
FY09 dividend yield of 13%; dividends are expected to grow at a 5yr CAGR of
12%. Bloomberg HUBC PK
Hedge against currency devaluation Reuters HPWR.KA
The tariff structure ensures that a foreign investor’s return is hedged for PKR
devaluation against the USD and for US inflation. Local investor will benefit in the
form of higher PKR based returns if the PKR devalues against the USD, while a Market Data
US based investor’s real return stays hedged. Market cap PKR mn 31,891
Low operational risk USD mn 452
The company’s fixed and variable costs and principle repayments are pass-
through, i.e. they are part of the tariff charged to the purchaser. Hubco’s sole Shares outstanding (mn) 1,157
power purchaser is Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA), whose
credit worthiness is backed by a sovereign guarantee. Free float (%) 65
WAPDA’s ability to pay depends on the government’s fiscal position. The burden
of fuel subsidies has recently strained the fiscal position of the government,
Stock Performance
which has affected WAPDA’s ability to pay. However, the government has
sponsored short-term working capital loans for HUBCO from commercial banks, (%) 1M 3M 12M
which are expected to continue in the medium term. With expected phase-out of
subsidies by year end the fiscal position of the government is expected to Absolute (3) (20) (16)
improve, which would enhance WAPDA’s ability to pay. Besides the sovereign risk Relative to mkt 4 11 3
there is the risk of PKR appreciation, which adversely affects the return of a local
investor.
Earnings Data 120
Oct-07
Nov-07
Dec-07
Feb-08
Jul-08
Jul-07
Aug-07
Jan-08
Mar-08
Apr-08
May-08
Jun-08
Shabbir M. Malik
shabbir.malik@gslpk.com
+92.21.246.9420 to 27
Global Securities Pakistan Ltd. │ 9th Floor Muhammadi House │ I.I. Chundrigar Road │ Karachi │ Pakistan
www.gslpk.com
The Hub Power Company Ltd
Table of Contents
Investment case
Dividend yield
HUBCO is expected to shine in an unfavorable macro-economic environment,
courtesy of its Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with WAPDA as per which the
investor receives relatively low-risk payoffs. Dividend yield for FY08 is expected
to be 13% and is projected to grow at a 5yr CAGR of 12%, primarily due to a
scalable trend in its agreed tariff with WAPDA and devaluation of the PKR.
90
20 80
70
15 60
50
10 40
30
5 20
10
- -
FY08
FY09
FY10
FY11
FY12
FY13
FY14
FY15
FY16
FY17
FY18
FY19
FY20
FY21
FY22
FY23
FY24
FY25
FY26
FY27
DPS (LHS) Dividend yield (RHS)
Enticing IRR
At current price the stock offers an attractive USD IRR of 20% and a PKR IRR of
23%. Our estimated PKR required rate of return, based on CAPM, is 16.7%.
Low operational risk
The company’s variable and fixed costs and loan repayments are pass-through
items, i.e. HUBCO charges WAPDA for them in its tariff. Variable costs include
the cost of fuel used in power generation, while fixed costs include operating and
maintenance cost, interest expense and insurance. HUBCO’s margins are not
vulnerable to volatility in oil prices, since its fuel bill is a pass-through item and
paid for by WAPDA.
Tariff hedged for PKR devaluation and US inflation
The tariff is indexed with the PKR/USD exchange rate and offers a pre-
determined real USD return. Local investor gains in the form of higher PKR
dividends if the PKR devalues against the USD, while a US based investor’s
return is hedged for exchange rate movements and US inflation.
No taxes
HUBCO does not pay any corporate tax, as it enjoys a tax holiday for the
duration of the PPA, expiring in CY27.
New project to be value additive
The company is setting up a new 225MW power project in Narrowal which would
be value additive based on our analysis. The project offers a real USD IRR of
15% and is expected to add PKR 0.70/share to the intrinsic value of HUBCO’s
existing project.
Valuation snapshot
We have used sum of parts valuation where we have estimated the intrinsic
value of HUBCO’s existing plant using the Dividend Discount Valuation technique
and added on the value of the new project in Narrowal by estimating the NPV
using its expected IRR and a hurdle rate. For HUBCO’s current business we have
projected dividends until the expiration of the PPA (CY27), assumed no terminal
value and used the required rate of return derived from the CAPM to discount the
dividends. Narrowal’s NPV is determined using a real USD IRR assumption for
new power projects of 15%, a hurdle rate equal to the required rate of return
and an equity investment of USD 73.3mn.
The required rate of return of 16.7% is estimated using the CAPM, where we
have used a risk free rate of return of 12.5% based on our long-term view of
interest rates, a risk premium of 6% and a Beta of 0.7 based on 2-year historical
systematic risk of the stock.
Sensitivities
Fair value sensitivity to required rate of return
Other Sensitivities
1% lower devaluation of PKR: -7% change in Fair value
1% lower devaluation of PKR: -8% change in PKR dividends
Risk factors
WAPDA’s financial position
WAPDA is HUBCO’s sole customer; the payments made by WAPDA besides
compensating for non-fuel costs are used to make payments to Pakistan State
Oil (PSO) for the supply of furnace oil used to run the plant. Due to financial
strains in WAPDA and limited fiscal space of the government, payments to be
made to HUBCO have been delayed and as a result HUBCO has had to borrow
money from banks to maintain fuel supply. These loans are effectively owed by
the government, but are booked on HUBCO’s balance sheet. Principal
repayments and interest expense of these working capital loans are pass through
items and should neither affect the profitability of the company, nor, in our
opinion, its dividend pay-out.
Appreciation in PKR
This is a tangible risk for local investors since HUBCO’s dividends are based on
real USD return, which in PKR terms fluctuate with the exchange rate. The trend
in the economy’s trade deficit however suggests that a PKR appreciation is
unlikely in the near-term.
Key Assumptions
Projections
US inflation: 2.60%
PKR devaluation against the USD: 2.20%
Discount Rate
Risk Free Rate: 12.5%
Market Risk Premium: 6%
Beta: 0.7
Structure
HUBCO’s bond like characteristics
To understand HUBCO’s pay-offs consider a 30 year semi-annual amortizing
bond maturing in FY27. The repayment structure of the bond is such that the
bulk of the principal re-payments are towards the back-end of the loan term. The
bond holder essentially gets a half-yearly interest income and a partial re-
payment of the principal; as the bond nears maturity the principal repayment
increases. Like all bonds the inherent risk of the instrument is lower than equity,
because 1) the payments and their schedule are pre-determined and 2) the
amount borrowed is protected by collateral or a sovereign guarantee. As per the
PPA, HUBCO’s equity holder is entitled to pre-determined dividends composed of
invested capital and a return on capital whose payment is guaranteed by the
government.
Like any bond HUBCO is not risk free. Return on capital invested can vary
depending on variances between actual expenses incurred in operation and
planned expenses agreed upon by HUBCO’s shareholders and WAPDA in the PPA.
In addition PKR based returns may vary depending on the exchange rate of USD
vs. PKR. Although unlikely, the government may back down from its sovereign
guarantee if it is faced with a fiscal crunch.
Tariff composition
As per the PPA, Hub Power’s tariff is composed of Energy Purchase Price (EPP)
and Capacity Purchase Price (CPP).
EPP
The EPP incorporates two elements of the cost structure which are fuel cost and
the variable operating and maintaining costs. Fuel cost is linked to the capacity
utilization and the market price of furnace oil. Variable operating and
maintenance costs, within a prescribed limit agreed in the PPA, are pass through
costs.
Figure 3: EPP
PKR mn
50,000 46,935
45,000 42,595
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
-
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11
CPP
CPP is composed of a scalable component and a non-scalable component. The
company’s fixed costs excluding depreciation are in the scalable portion of the
CPP. They are scalable because they are indexed for PKR devaluation and US
inflation. The CPP section also includes the Project Company Equity (PCE) which
is the return the investors get on the project as per PPA. PCE is escalated in sync
with US inflation and the Pak rupee devaluation. Interest expense and principal
repayments against outstanding loan make up the non-scalable component of
CPP.
Figure 4: CPP
PKR mn
10,000
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
-
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11
Escalable Non-Escalable
PPA
The agreement with WAPDA determines the principles under which the plant is
operated and the tariff arrangements. Under the agreement WAPDA may instruct
HUBCO to generate and deliver electricity into the Grid up to the available Net
Capacity of the plant. Tariff payments will be made by WAPDA whether or not
the power is dispatched, provided that it is available for dispatch. If HUBCO fails
to meet WAPDA’s generation demands, it will incur penalties payable to WAPDA.
Bonuses are paid by WAPDA for generation in excess of 65% capacity utilization
of the plant.
Industry overview
Power demand
Demand for electricity consumption in Pakistan has been growing at an average
rate of 9.5% over the past four years. The rise in demand for power in recent
years came on the back of higher GDP growth (5 yr CAGR of 7%), increasing
rural electrification, commercialization and industrialization. Pakistan has a total
installed electricity generation capacity of 19,566 MW, which produced more than
93,621 GWh of electricity in FY08. Currently, there is a peak time power shortfall
of 4,000 MW and the government plans to alleviate the deficit by encouraging
private investment in the sector, which would add about 2,200 MW over the next
year.
15,000
10,000
Thermal 57%
5,000
-
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Demand Supply Hydel Thermal IPP's
Power supply
The current installed capacity is 19,566MW which is theoretically enough to meet
peak load demand. However, due to inadequate fuel supplies thermal plants,
which account for 65% of the country’s total generation capacity, are not able to
generate at optimum utilization level. As a result in May’08 the power deficit
reached a peak of 4,000MW. The government has planned extra efforts in FY09
to ensure adequate fuel supply for power plants so that the utilization and load
factors can improve. Further, in order to meet the growing demand more power
plants are being encouraged to increase capacity and to reduce the power deficit.
The government is actively pursuing new investments in all types of plants, be it
thermal or hydro. It held bidding for setting up six independent power projects to
generate 2,200MW electricity on a fast track basis by Apr09. In addition it has
allocated PKR 76.2bn for investment in the power sector in FY09.
50,000 10,000
40,000 8,000
30,000 6,000
20,000 4,000
10,000 2,000
-
-
FY08 FY10 FY15 FY20 FY25 FY30
WAPDA IPP's Nuclear KESC
Nuclear Hydel Coal Renewable Oil Gas FY07 FY08
Thermal Power
WAPDA operates the majority of thermal power plants in Pakistan, with over
5,000 MW of installed capacity in its control. The Guddu plant is the largest plant
operated by WAPDA, with a capacity of 1,650 MW. In recent years, growth in
Pakistan’s thermal power generation has come primarily from new Independent
Power Producers (IPPs), some of which have been funded by foreign investors.
The two largest IPP’s in Pakistan are Kot Addu Power Company (1,600MW) and
HUBCO (1,200MW). The government policy is currently focused on setting up
thermal power plants (both oil & gas): 90% of foreign investment in the power
sector is directed towards thermal power. Thermal power plants are relatively
cheap to install and have a short set-up time compared to hydro power units,
which is why the government is favoring them to overcome the current power
crisis. Thermal plants have high operating costs since they rely on expensive fuel
such as furnace oil, coal and natural gas.
9000
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
Existing Capacity Expected Capacity
Source: WAPDA
Hydro Power
Hydro power plants involve huge capital outlays and take longer to set-up
compared to thermal plants. They have, however, one of the lowest operating
costs which translate into cheaper power and lower stress on the trade balance.
The prospects of installation of Hydro projects continue to be marginalized due to
the incessant political disagreement on the setup of such projects.
18,000
16,000
14,000
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
-
NWFP Punjab AJK Northern Areas
Installed Potential
Source: PPIB
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
Kanupp Chasnupp-1 Chasnupp-2*
WAPDA
WAPDA is the cornerstone of Pakistan’s power sector. Since its establishment in
1958, the company has implemented a number of major infrastructure projects
for the generation, transmission and distribution of Pakistan’s electricity supply.
Today, it employs 137,000 people, has a customer base of over 10 million, and is
at the center of the restructuring of Pakistan’s power sector. To streamline
operations the state-owned giant has been divided into 14 new companies. An
experienced private sector management has been put in place to enhance
operational efficiencies and improve its financial position.
60,000
50,000
40,000
30,000
20,000
10,000
-
FY07 FY08
Hydro Thermal
Source: Pepco
NEPRA regulates the electric power sector to promote a competitive structure for
the industry and to ensure the coordinated, reliable and adequate supply of
electric power in the future. By law, NEPRA is mandated to ensure that the
interests of the investor and the customer are protected through judicious
decisions based on transparent commercial principals and that the sector moves
towards a competitive environment.
Company overview
The development of the Hub Power Project began when the Government
requested sponsors led by Xenel Industries of Saudi Arabia to present proposals
for a 1,292 MW plant.
In 1991, HUBCO was incorporated in Pakistan as a limited liability company for
the purpose of implementing the project. During the three years that followed, a
series of agreements were negotiated between HUBCO and the Government of
Pakistan and certain of its institutions, the construction consortium and National
Power. It was on the basis of these agreements that long-term finance was
raised without direct guarantees from the Government.
Debt syndication was completed during the last quarter of 1994 and by the end
of the year, the full financing, including equity was in place. This was the single
largest issue of domestic shares at one time. Financial closure was finally
achieved in Jan95.
Fauji
Foundation
18%
Others Hubco
Plant details
HUBCO consists of four generating units each rated at 323MW gross output, with
an oil-fired single re-heat boiler, two cylinder condensing steam turbines directly
coupled to a hydrogen cooled generator. The design net available output is
exported to WAPDA's national grid via the power station's 500kv switchyard.
Both the plant configuration and the steam conditions represent conventional
design based on proven technology. HUBCO is one of the most efficient oil fired
thermal plant in Pakistan and can provide 8% of country's electricity demand.
The plant is operated in such a way that it is available at a short notice during
high demand period and can switch to flexible operations during low demand
periods. Hubco holds 21% of the total installed capacity of IPP’s.
Narowal project
The Hub Power Company Limited is setting up a combined cycle power plant
based on reciprocating engines technology with a total project cost of
USD 244.3mn and having an installed capacity of 225MW at Narowal district,
Punjab. The government has approved formal request and the tariff structure
has also been agreed upon with NEPRA. The plant will be powered by 11, 18
cylinder V-configuration four stroke engines which will run on Residual Fuel Oil.
The plant is expected to contribute to the national grid by the end of Mar10.
The project cost will be financed by 30% equity which comes to USD 73.3mn and
70% debt worth USD 171mn. The plant will have the ability to run on High speed
diesel oil as an alternative fuel source. 100% generation from the plant would be
supplied to the National Transmission and Dispatch Company Ltd (NTDC).
Financial Statements
Income Statement
Balance Sheet
Key ratios
Glossary
Analyst certification
Each research analyst primarily responsible for the content of this research
report, in whole or in part, certifies that with respect to each security or issuer
that the analyst covered in this report: (1) all of the views expressed accurately
reflect his or her personal views about those securities or issuers; and (2) no
part of his or her compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related
to the specific recommendations or views expressed by that research analyst in
the research report.
This report has been prepared by Global Securities Pakistan Limited for distribution only under such circumstances as may be permitted by
applicable law, including the following:
This report is intended solely for distribution to professional and business customers of Global Securities Pakistan Limited. It is not intended for
distribution to non-professional or private investors. The report has no regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular
needs of any specific recipient. The report is published solely for informational purposes and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to
buy or sell any security or options thereon. The report is based on information obtained from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed
as being accurate, nor is it a complete statement or summary of the securities, markets or developments referred to in the report. The report
should not be regarded by recipients as a substitute for the exercise of their own judgment. Any opinions expressed herein are subject to change
without notice. Global Securities Pakistan Limited, and/or its directors, officers and employees may have or have had interests or positions or
traded or acted as market-maker in the relevant securities. Furthermore, they may have or have had a relationship with or may provide or have
provided corporate finance or other services to or serve or have served as directors of the relevant Company. Global Securities Limited accept no
liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this report. Additional information will be made
available on request.
© Copyright reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any manner without the written permission of Global Securities
Pakistan Limited. Global Securities Pakistan Limited specifically prohibits the re-distribution of this report, via the Internet or otherwise, to non-
professional or private investors and accepts no liability whatsoever for the actions of third parties in this respect.