Anda di halaman 1dari 6

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/229953209

Female genital tuberculosis

Article  in  The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist · January 2011


DOI: 10.1576/toag.7.2.075.27000

CITATIONS READS

17 441

6 authors, including:

Vanessa Kay Solwayo Ngwenya


University of Dundee Mpilo Central Hospital & Royal Women's Clinic & National University of Science & …
23 PUBLICATIONS   352 CITATIONS    37 PUBLICATIONS   109 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Mpilo Central Hospital Mortality Reduction View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Solwayo Ngwenya on 29 November 2017.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


10.1576/toag.7.2.075.27000 www.rcog.org.uk/togonline

Female genital tuberculosis REVIEW


The Obstetrician
David K Gatongi, Godfrey Gitau, Vanessa Kay, & Gynaecologist
Solwayo Ngwenya, Cyril Lafong, Adnan Hasan
2005;7:75–79
Tuberculosis affects a large number of people worldwide and the
incidence is increasing. Tuberculosis bacilli reach the genital tract
mainly by haematogenous spread from foci outside the genitalia. The Keywords
fallopian tubes, endometrium and ovaries are affected in most cases. anti-tuberculous
Genital tuberculosis may be asymptomatic and could go unrecognised chemotherapy,
or masquerade as other gynaecological conditions. A combination of genital tuberculosis,
HIV, infertility,
tuberculin testing, culture, histology, hysterosalpingogram and nucleic tuberculosis
acid amplification testing is useful in establishing a diagnosis.
Multidrug anti-tuberculosis chemotherapy is the mainstay of
treatment. After treatment spontaneous conception is low with an Author details
increased risk of ectopic pregnancy and spontaneous miscarriage.

Introduction In the UK, the overall TB rate is increasing. A


rate of 12.9/100 000 was reported in 2002,
Tuberculosis (TB) is an increasing public health which is an increase of 4% on the 2001 rate.This
concern worldwide, with about six million new upward trend has been evidenced since 1988 in David K Gatongi MRCOG,
Specialist Registrar, Dumfries and
cases a year. It is one of the most important causes England and Wales,7 while the overall incidence Galloway Royal Infirmary, Bankend
of infectious morbidity and mortality. On a global in Scotland has remained stable over the last 10 Road, Dumfries DG1 4AP, UK
e-mail: davidspax@yahoo.com
scale, TB has a devastating impact in developing years. This increase is attributed to increasing (corresponding author)
nations with 13 countries accounting for nearly migrants from high prevalence countries, rising
75% of all cases.1 TB exists in two forms: HIV infection rates, homelessness, drug abuse
pulmonary tuberculosis and extrapulmonary and emergence of multidrug resistant strains of
tuberculosis. Genital TB is one form of TB bacilli. Similar trends have been reported in
extrapulmonary TB and is not uncommon, the USA.1,7
particularly in communities where pulmonary TB
is prevalent, but it is rare in Western societies.This The surge in TB rates in the UK has been Godfrey Gitau MRCOG, Specialist
is evidenced by the paucity of literature on this characterised by an increase in the ratio of Registrar, Royal Victoria Infirmary,
subject in developed countries as compared with extrapulmonary to pulmonary TB, with Newcastle upon Tyne, UK

less developed countries. Genital TB affects about extrapulmonary TB representing 40% of all TB
12% of patients with pulmonary tuberculosis2 and cases in 2001 compared with 33% in 1988.7
represents 15–20% of extrapulmonary
tuberculosis.3 Genital TB may be asymptomatic Within England,Wales and Northern Ireland,TB
and diagnosis requires a high index of suspicion. infection rates vary between regions and
Moreover, the disease may masquerade as other different population groups. There is a strong
gynaecological conditions and can go urban association with London, the Midlands Vanessa Kay MD MRCOG,
unrecognised.4 Multiple drug chemotherapy, and the North West accounting for over 70% of Consultant Obstetrician and
Gynaecologist, Ninewells Hospital,
comprising isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol and cases. The rate in London is the highest at Dundee, Scotland, UK
pyrazinamide, is the mainstay of treatment. 41/100 000.7 Among population subgroups the
rate was highest in black Africans (272/100 000)
Epidemiology followed by Indian, Pakistani and Bangladeshi
ethnic groups (124/100 000).7
The actual incidence of genital TB in the general
population cannot be accurately determined, as HIV has altered the dynamics of TB worldwide.
some patients are asymptomatic and may remain Between 1993 and 1998, the numbers of
Solwayo Ngwenya DFFP
undiscovered.5 It is estimated to affect 1.5/100 tuberculosis patients co-infected with HIV in MRCOG, Specialist Registrar,
000 inhabitants in the UK. Worldwide, genital England and Wales, although small, had nearly Huddersfield Royal Infirmary,
Huddersfield, UK
TB is found in 5-10% of women with infertility doubled from 61 (2.2%) to 112 (3.3%).8 Patients
problems,6 with low rates in Australia (1%) and co-infected with HIV contributed about 8.5% of Cyril Lafong BAO FRCPath,
Consultant Microbiologist, Victoria
high rates of up to 19% in India.5 the increase in tuberculosis cases.8 Extrapulmonary Hospital, Kirkaldy, Scotland, UK

75
2004 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
© 2005
REVIEW TB is more common in HIV-positive patients,9 (3.7%)12 TB may therefore have a pathogenic
The Obstetrician and in African countries, 60–90% of patients with role in abnormal uterine bleeding.
& Gynaecologist extrapulmonary TB are HIV-positive.9
Clinical presentation
2005;7:75–79 Microbiology and pathology Although genital TB can occur in any age group,
Mycobacterium tuberculosis accounts for 90–95% of the majority of patients are in the reproductive
cases of genital TB. However, Mycobacterium bovis age group, 75% being in the 20–45 years age
Author details may be the causal agent (5–10%), especially bracket.11 Postmenopausal women account for
when the organisms are acquired from the 7–11% of cases of genital TB.
gastrointestinal tract.1,5
Genital TB may be asymptomatic and the majority
TB bacilli are spread from person to person by the of women are diagnosed during investigations for
inhalation of aerial droplets produced by coughing, infertility.6,9 Systemic constitutional symptoms of
sneezing and talking.1 Infection by oral ingestion is weight loss, feeling unwell and night sweats may be
rare, as is transmission by sexual intercourse.5,10 present. In the acute phase, the picture may
Adnan Hasan MSc MRCOG,
resemble classical acute pelvic inflammatory
Hospital Specialist, Forth Park TB of the female genital tract is nearly always disease (PID)9 with pelvic pain, fever and vaginal
Hospital, Kirkaldy, Scotland, UK
secondary to a focus elsewhere in the body.11 The discharge. Fitz-Hugh Curtis syndrome may result
TB bacilli reach the genital tract by three principal from tuberculous PID.
routes. Haematogenous spread represents about
90% of cases, with the primary focus being the Genital TB may present with a variety of
lungs, lymph nodes or skeletal system. Descending gynaecological symptoms of infertility, menstrual
direct spread occurs, with infection reaching the disturbance and chronic pelvic pain (Table
genital organs via the lymphatic system or directly 1).11,13,14 In the postmenopausal woman, genital
from the gastrointestinal tract, mesenteric nodes or TB presents with postmenopausal bleeding,
the peritoneum.3 persistent leucorrhoea and pyometra.13,15

Primary infection of the vulva, vagina and cervix Tuberculous lesions of the cervix present with
may result from direct inoculation at sexual postcoital bleeding, abnormal discharge and, on
intercourse with persons having genitourinary examination, have appearances similar to cancer of
TB. Ascending spread of infection from the the cervix.10 Lesions on the vulva appear as
vagina, cervix and the vulva may occur.5,10 shallow ulcers, which may be painful, especially
Genital organs commonly involved include the with secondary bacterial infection.Vaginal lesions
fallopian tubes (95–100%) endometrium are often painless and are usually sited at the
(50–60%) and ovaries (20–30%). The cervix introitus. Both can result in bloodstained purulent
(5–15%), vulva/ vagina (1%) and the discharge and may be identified as sexually
myometrium (2.5%) may also be involved.3,11 transmitted infection.16 The Bartholin’s gland may
be affected, presenting with pain and fistula
Haematogenous spread of TB bacilli to the tubes formation despite adequate antibiotic cover.
results in involvement of the submucosa
(endosalpingitis) at the outer ends with gradual Involvement of the ovaries may result in an adnexal
spread medially to the endometrium. Direct ovarian mass. Fistula formation to the bowel, skin
spread of infection to the fallopian tubes results or vagina may be seen. Peritoneal involvement may
in exosalpingitis with tubercles on the surface.3 give rise to ascites.This, in addition to an adnexal
mass and a raised serum CA125 level, can be
The appearance of genital organs infected with mistaken for ovarian cancer and can result in
TB can vary: in some, the tubes may appear unnecessary surgical intervention.4 Occasionally,
normal. During active infection they appear red
and oedematous and in chronic infection they
Table 1. Presenting symptoms
appear fibrosed. Tubal obstruction may result in
Symptom Percentage of total
pyosalpinx or hydrosalpinx. Extensive pelvic
adhesions may result.6 Endometrial involvement Infertility 43–74
Primary 55–78
may result in an endometrial ulcer or Secondary 11–72
accumulation of caseous material to form Normal menstrual function 50–88
pyometra. Intrauterine adhesions and partial Oligomenorrhoea 54
Amenorrhoea 14
obliteration of the uterine cavity may also occur.3 Menorrhagia 19
Abdominal pain 42.5
The endometrium may be proliferative (37%), Dyspareunia 5–12
Dysmenorrhoea 12–30
secretory (18%), mixed (11.7%) or hyperplastic
© 2004 Royal College of Obstetricians and
76 Gynaecologists
pleural effusion in association with a pelvic mass fits Whenever feasible, every effort should be made to REVIEW
into the picture of Meigs’ syndrome. send specimens and tissue for culture, in order to
The Obstetrician
confirm diagnosis and establish drug sensitivities.
& Gynaecologist
General, abdominal and pelvic examination Suspected tuberculous lesions in accessible sites
findings are normal in majority of genital TB such as the vagina, cervix and the vulva may be
2005;7:75–79
patients.2,14 A pelvic mass may be identified and biopsied directly. Endometrial tissue may be
adnexal tenderness may be elicited. obtained by aspiration biopsy or by dilatation and
curettage or directly at hysteroscopy. Endometrial
biopsy is best performed in the premenstrual
Diagnosis
period. Menstrual fluid can be obtained from the
Diagnosis is achieved most effectively through vagina during the first day of menstruation for
a combination of a high index of suspicion, culture and microscopy.18 Less accessible lesions
especially in areas of low prevalence, thorough on the tubes, ovaries and adnexae can be obtained
initial clinical assessment and the use of at laparoscopy or laparotomy. Laparoscopic
appropriate investigations. High risk factors findings include adhesions, tubal abnormalities
include a history of previous pulmonary TB and ascites.6
infection, contact with a pulmonary TB
sufferer, recent travel to or migration from high Histology demonstrates the typical caseous
prevalence countries, residence in high granulomatous lesions with giant epithelioid
prevalence areas such as London, low cells (Figure 1). This lesion is highly suggestive
socioeconomic background, drug abuse, HIV of TB but is not diagnostic, as it appears in
positive status and history of chronic chest fungal infections and sarcoidosis. Microscopy for
symptoms, night sweats and weight loss. alcohol and acid-fast bacilli (AAFB) can provide
Individuals of black African and Asian descent a quick diagnosis (Figure 2). Fluorescent
are high-risk race groups.1,5,6 auramine-phenol and Ziehl-Neelsen (Z-N)
staining can be performed on endometrial
Tuberculosis should be considered in a woman aspiration biopsy.
with high risk factors presenting with
unexplained infertility, amenorrhea not Culture on solid media, such as egg-based
explained by other causes, pelvic infection that Löwenstein-Jensen medium, can give positive
does not respond to ordinary treatment and, in results for M. tuberculosis in 4 weeks but can take
postmenopausal women with bleeding, up to 12 weeks. Liquid culture with radiometric
persistent leucorrhoea and pyometra where growth detection such as BACTEC-460 or non-
endometrial neoplasia has been excluded. radiometric (CO2) growth detection such as
BacTAlert 3D, provides more rapid growth
(average 10–14 days), specific identification of
Investigations Figure 1. Granulomatous
M. tuberculosis and rapid drug susceptibility
Although demonstration of the TB bacilli testing to guide therapy.1 lesion in a woman with
endometrial TB
confirms the diagnosis, other indirect tests are
useful.A full blood count is often normal but the
erythrocyte sedimentation rate is usually raised.1
With increasing numbers of TB patients being
co-infected with HIV, testing for HIV is
recommended for all patients with genital TB.9

The tuberculin skin test has a sensitivity of 55%


and specificity of 80% in patients with genital
tuberculosis.17 False-positive reactions do occur
and represent non-tuberculous mycobacterium
infections. False-negative reactions, although
uncommon in otherwise healthy patients with
tuberculosis, occur in at least 20% of patients
with known active tuberculosis. HIV infection
and corticosteroid therapy may cause false-
negative test results.1

Chest X-ray is aimed at demonstrating current


or past tuberculous lesions in the lungs, which
are a common site for primary infection.
However, most chest X-rays are normal.
© 2004 Royal College of Obstetricians and
Gynaecologists 77
REVIEW Rapid nucleic acid amplification techniques such features include ascites, omental and mesenteric
as polymerase chain reaction (PCR) allow direct infiltration and smooth thickening of the parietal
The Obstetrician
identification of M. tuberculosis in clinical peritoneum.21
& Gynaecologist
specimens. Such methods can detect fewer than
ten organisms in clinical specimens compared with
2005;7:75–79 Hysterosalpingogram
10 000 necessary for smear positivity, an important
Hysterosalpingogram (HSG) is performed
frequently22 as an investigation for infertility, this
being a common presentation of genital TB. It
should not be performed where TB is diagnosed
by other means, as it may result in dissemination
and flare-up of disease.23 Tubal occlusion is the
most common HSG finding in genital
tuberculosis. Occlusion occurs most commonly
at the junction between the isthmus and
ampulla. Multiple constrictions along the tube
give the ‘beaded’ appearance on HSG, while
scarring gives the ‘rigid pipe system’ appearance.
Tubal dilatation, hydrosalpinx, irregular tubal
outline and calcifications are other features that
can be identified on HSG. Chavhan et al.22
reported TB in 7.5% of HSGs performed for
infertility in a series of 37 patients. The HSG
features identified included tubal occlusion in 30
women, rigid pipe appearance in nine, tubal
dilatation in 17, irregularity of the tube in 6 and
peritubal adhesions in 11 of the women.
Figure 2. Ziehl-Neelsen feature because genital TB is paucibacillary with
staining showing AAFB cultures and smears usually being negative. Endometrial tuberculosis has been reported to
cultured from
Although PCR is more sensitive (85–95%) than have nonspecific features on HSG, commonly
endometrial curettings
microscopy and bacteriological culture on characterised by synechiae, distorted uterine
pulmonary and extrapulmonary specimens, it does contour and venous and lymphatic intravasation.
not distinguish live from killed bacilli.1,19 Scarring of the uterus may lead to unilateral
obliteration of the uterus, giving rise to
unicornuate appearance ‘pseudounicornuate
Imaging uterus’ or conversion of the uterine cavity into a
Abdominal and pelvic ultrasound, computed T-shape or an asymmetric small uterus.
tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance Synechiae were seen in six patients and venous
imaging (MRI) are employed in circumstances and lymphatic intravasation in 10 of 37 patients
where an abdominal or pelvic mass is present. in the study by Chavhan et al.22
They are also useful in the presence of ascites
where malignancy is a possibility. Although the various features that HSG
describes are not specific for genital tuberculosis,
Sonographic features of wet tuberculosis (with they are highly suggestive of it.
ascites) include septated ascites, particulate ascites,
loculated fluid, thickened peritoneum, thickened
Treatment
omentum, endometrial involvement and adnexal
masses. Features of dry tuberculosis (no ascites) It is essential that physicians and microbiologists
include adnexal masses, adhesions and loculated experienced in TB management are involved in
fluid. When compared with laparoscopy/ the treatment of genital TB. Six-month regimens
laparotomy, ultrasound was able to identify including four drugs in the initial phase
ascites/loculated fluid (100%), adnexal masses (rifampicin, isoniazid, pyrazinamide and
(93%), peritoneum thickening (69%), omental ethambutol) followed by rifampicin and
thickening (61%), and endometrial thickening isoniazid in the continuation phase are highly
(83%). Awareness of these features may improve effective in patients with fully sensitive
diagnostic accuracy and avoid misdiagnosis and organisms. Combined therapy enhances
unnecessary surgical intervention.20 compliance and reduces the risk of secondary
drug resistance. Relapse after treatment is seen in
CT findings of abdominal tuberculosis may 0–3% of cases. All anti-tuberculous drugs can
mimic diffuse peritoneal malignancy. These cause adverse reactions; these are seen in about

78
© 2004 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
10% of patients and are common in HIV-positive involved.5,6,27 Adhesiolysis may be performed for REVIEW
patients. Isoniazid and rifampicin both are chronic pelvic pain. The Obstetrician
associated with hepatitis, cutaneous
& Gynaecologist
hypersensitivity and haemolytic anaemia. Isoniazid After treatment for genital TB, the conception rate
may cause peripheral neuropathy. Pyrazinamide is low (19.2%) with a livebirth rate of 7.2%.There is 2005;7:75–79
causes anorexia, nausea, hepatitis, arthralgia and also an increase in ectopic pregnancy and
hyperuricaemia. Ethambutol is associated with miscarriage rates. In vitro fertilisation should
retrobulbar neuritis, hepatitis and peripheral therefore be offered to those who fail to conceive
neuropathy. Monitoring visual acuity for those spontaneously.23
taking ethambutol is therefore necessary. Liver
function should also be monitored.24
Conclusion
The incidence of multi-drug resistant strains of The incidence of female genital TB is increasing,
TB bacilli is increasing worldwide mainly as so gynaecologists will be increasingly faced with
result of under-treatment. In the UK, 1.2% of TB cases of TB and its consequences. Genital TB may
isolates were found to be multi-drug be asymptomatic or may present with atypical
resistant.25,26 Multi-drug resistance in the UK is symptoms or mimic other conditions. It is
commonly seen in young men, people not born imperative to consider the possibility of TB in
in the UK, HIV-positive patients and people women in the reproductive age group who
with a previous history of TB.25,26 It is therefore present with the symptoms of infertility, chronic
absolutely essential that compliance be ensured. pelvic pain and menstrual dysfunction, where
The World Health Organization advocates a other causes have been excluded. This is
strategy of direct observation of therapy to particularly important when these women fall into
improve cure rates and minimise the the high-risk category for TB infection. Genital
development of drug resistance.1,26 TB should also be considered in postmenopausal
women with pyometra and persistent vaginal
Although chemotherapy is the mainstay of discharge.
treatment, surgery may be indicated where
medical therapy has failed to resolve symptoms Failing to consider the possibility of TB may result
and in presence of a persistent pelvic mass. In in unnecessary and ineffective interventions. To
these circumstances, total abdominal increase the chances of identifying TB bacilli,
hysterectomy is the operation of choice, while immunological, bacteriological and nucleic
bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy may be amplification tests should be employed, as they are
considered if the ovaries are severely complementary. ■

References
1. Haas DW. Mycobacterial diseases. In: Mandell GL, case report. Eur J Obstet Gynaecol Reprod Biol subfertile women in an endemic zone. J Obstet
Bennet JE, Dolin R, editors. Principles of Practice of 1998;80:227–9. Gynaecol India 2003;53:260–3.
Infectious Diseases. Philadelphia, PA: Churchill 10. Lamba H, Bryne M, Goldin R, Jenkins C.Tuberculosis 20. Yapar EG, Ekici E, Karasahin E, Gokmen O.
Livingstone; 2000. p. 2576–607. of the cervix: case presentation and a review of the Sonographic features of tuberculous peritonitis with
2. Aka N,Vural TZE. Evaluation of patients with active literature. Sex Transm Infect 2002;78:62–3. female genital tuberculosis. Ultrasound Obstet Gynaecol
pulmonary tuberculosis for genital involvement. 11. Qureshi RN, Sammad S, Hamd R, Lakha SF. Female 1995;6:121–5.
J Obstet Gynaecol Res 1997;23:337–40. genital tuberculosis revisited. J Pak Med Assoc 2001;51: 21. Zissin R, Gayer G, Chowers M, Sapiro-Feinberg M,
3. Rajamaheswari N. Pelvic tuberculosis [www.Sunmed. 16–18. Kots E, Hertz M. Computerised tomography findings
org/pelvictb.html]. 12. Gaur BM, Meheshwari B, Lal N.Tuberculous of abdominal tuberculosis: report of 19 cases Isr Med
4. Cow TWP, Lim KB,Valliparim S.The masquerades of endometritis: a clinico-pathological study of 1000 Assoc J 2001;3:414–18.
female pelvic tuberculosis: case reports and review of cases. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1983;90:84–6. 22. Chavhan GB, Hira P, Rathod K, Zacharia TT, Chawla A,
literature on clinical presentation and diagnosis. J 13. Samal S, Gupta U, Agarwal P. Menstrual disorders in Badhe P, et al. Female genital tuberculosis: hystero-
Obstet Gynaecol Res 2002;28:203-10. genital tuberculosis. J Indian Med Assoc 2000;98: salpingographic appearances. Br J Radiol 2004;77: 164–9.
5. Chowdhury NN. Overview of tuberculosis of the 126–7. 23. Tripathy SN,Tripathy SN. Infertility and pregnancy
female genital tract. J Indian Med Assoc 1996;94: 14. Margolis K,Wranz PA, Kruger TF, Joubert JJ, Odendaal outcome in female genital tuberculosis. Int J Gynaecol
345-6. HJ. Genital tuberculosis at Tygerberg Hospital: Obstet 2002;76:159–63.
6. Figueroa-Damian R, Martinez-Velazco I,Villagrana- prevalence, clinical presentation and diagnosis. S Afr
24. Joint Tuberculosis Committee of the British Thoracic
Zesati R, Arredondo-Garcia JL.Tuberculosis of the Med J 1992;81:12–15.
Society. Chemotherapy and management of tuberculosis
female reproductive tract: effect on function. Int J 15. Muechler E, Minkowitz S. Postmenopausal endometrial
in the United Kingdom: recommendations 1998.
Fertil Menopausal Stud 1996;41:430-6. tuberculosis. Obstet Gynaecol 1971;38:768–70.
Thorax 1998;58:536–48.
7. Health Protection Agency. Preliminary Annual Report 16. Sardana K, Koranne VR, Sharma RC, Mahajan S.
on Tuberculosis Reported in 2002 in England,Wales and Tuberculosis of the vulva masquerading as a sexually 25. Joint Tuberculosis Committee of the British Thoracic
Northern Ireland. London: HPA; 2004 [www.hpa.org. transmitted disease. J Dermatol 2001;28:505–7. Society. Control and prevention of tuberculosis in the
uk/infections]. 17. Raut VS, Mahashir AA, Sheth SS.The Montoux test United Kingdom: Code of Practice 2000 Thorax
8. Rose AMC, Sinka K,Watson JM, Mortimer JY, in the diagnosis of genital tuberculosis in women. Int 2000;55:887–901.
Carlett A. An estimate of the contribution of HIV J Gynaecol Obstet 2001;72:165–9. 26. Djuretic T, Herbert J, Drobniewski F,Yates M, Smith EG,
infection to recent rise in tuberculosis in England and 18. Oosthuizen AP,Wessel PH, Hefer JN.Tuberculosis of Magree JG, et al.Antibiotic resistant tuberculosis in the
Wales. Thorax 2002;57:442–5. the female genital tract in patients attending an United Kingdom: 1993–1999. Thorax 2002;57: 477–82.
9. Giannacopoulos KC, Hatzidaki GE, Papanicolau infertility clinic. S Afr Med J 1990;77:562–4. 27. Sutherland AM. Surgical treatment of tuberculosis of
NC, Relakis KJ, Kokori HG, Giannacopoulou CC. 19. Himanshu R, Shanti R, Sharika R. Use of PCR for the female genital tract. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1980;
Genital tuberculosis in a HIV infected woman: a the diagnosis of endometrial tuberculosis in high risk 87:610–12.

79
© 2004 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists

View publication stats

Anda mungkin juga menyukai