0 penilaian0% menganggap dokumen ini bermanfaat (0 suara)
140 tayangan6 halaman
The document provides a review of Assimil Spanish, a self-study language book. It summarizes the book's structure, which includes 109 lessons with parallel Spanish and English texts and accompanying audio recordings. The reviewer shares their learning strategy of listening, reading, shadowing, and transcribing lessons. Positives highlighted are the lack of English and amount of content, while negatives include the unnatural and sometimes bizarre dialogues, inconsistent pacing, and slow audio speed. Overall, the reviewer believes Assimil Spanish is effective for learning the language despite its flaws.
The document provides a review of Assimil Spanish, a self-study language book. It summarizes the book's structure, which includes 109 lessons with parallel Spanish and English texts and accompanying audio recordings. The reviewer shares their learning strategy of listening, reading, shadowing, and transcribing lessons. Positives highlighted are the lack of English and amount of content, while negatives include the unnatural and sometimes bizarre dialogues, inconsistent pacing, and slow audio speed. Overall, the reviewer believes Assimil Spanish is effective for learning the language despite its flaws.
The document provides a review of Assimil Spanish, a self-study language book. It summarizes the book's structure, which includes 109 lessons with parallel Spanish and English texts and accompanying audio recordings. The reviewer shares their learning strategy of listening, reading, shadowing, and transcribing lessons. Positives highlighted are the lack of English and amount of content, while negatives include the unnatural and sometimes bizarre dialogues, inconsistent pacing, and slow audio speed. Overall, the reviewer believes Assimil Spanish is effective for learning the language despite its flaws.
If you’re looking to learn a new language, especially if you plan on doing it on
your own, one of the best ways to get started is with a self-study book. There are a lot of them out their but one of the biggest names you’ll hear out there is Assimil, a French company started by Alphonse Chérel in 1929. They offer a wide range of languages, though most of their titles are only published in French with a fraction available in English. In this review I’m going to talk about my personal experience with the 1987 version of the “Assimil Spanish with Ease”. The Spanish taught is standard European and some of the expressions you’ll find will not make sense to people from Latin America but Spanish is Spanish and this won’t be much of a problem in all honesty. The course is set up as follows: The book has 109 lessons. The intention is to do one lesson per day which would give you a 16 week course. The first 6 lessons of every week have parallel texts, Spanish on the left English and the right, and foot notes that give useful information on vocabulary, grammar and cultural references. There are also two short exercises at the end of each lesson, but I never did them. Every seventh lesson is a review of the content encountered in the previous six lessons. Each lesson except the review lessons is accompanied by an audio of the Spanish, usually a dialogue followed by a series of sentences intended to be used in exercises. The speed is a lot slower than normal speech which is intended to make it easier for the learner to understand but gets extremely annoying once you reach higher levels and want something a bit more natural. When I used it I focused mostly on shadowing, where you listen to the speaker and repeat their words as closely as you can. I would listen to the audio to understand, then go through the footnotes and parallel texts to understand everything I missed. Once I was confident I knew what was going on I would shadow the text, first listening and reading, then just listening until I could speak at the same rate as the speakers and understand 80-100% of the lesson. How I used it While using the book I had my own personal learning strategy which I’ll share with you. 1. Listen to the audio without reading 2. Listen to the audio while reading 3. Read all the notes and look up all the words, phrases and structures I don’t understand so I can get the full meaning of the dialogue 4. Listen again without reading 5. Listen again while reading 6. Shadow while reading 7. Shadow without reading (Shadowing is a technique where you repeat what the speaer says as closely as possible) 8. Listen to the audio and transcribe it This last step helps keep what I’ve learned in my memory. Now let’s look at what I liked and disliked about this book after having gone through all of it. The Good Parts 1. NO English My number one favourite thing about this book is that there is absolutely no English on the audios. It’s purely in the target language. Nothing makes my ears bleed more than an annoying ‘instructor’ telling you in their best receptionist’s voice that you will now listen to section X of lesson Y then do exercise Z. The audio is also really clear, words properly enunciated, no background noise, it’s great for shadowing; all in all great for beginners. 2. A lot of content Language learning is all about input. You need to ingest A LOT of content to learn the vocabulary and develop the comprehension skills to understand a language and Assimil definitely gets you there. 3. Wide range of topics you’ll encounter dialogues about the country side, city, beach vacations, poetry, the market etc. It gives you a lot of exposure to more than just introductions and tourist phrases that many other books focus on so it can be a welcome change from another book you may be working with. 4. Absolute best approach to grammar Grammar in this course is literally a footnote. It’s an afterthought and the author makes no attempt to bog you down with lengthy explanations or tedious grammar exercises that will not help- The Bad Parts 1. NOT colloquial Despite what Assimil might tell you the language of these books is certainly not every day. It’s standard and neutral so you won’t sound like Macbeth but it’s definitely not colloquial; the style is stiff and the dialogue formal. I’ve shown this book to native speakers and they find some of it hard to follow and full of big words. 2. Dry, sometimes bizarre content. The content can get pretty boring at times. It does not spark joy. A lot of the contexts are not the sort of ordinary conversations that a beginner would normally encounter and some of them are just wack. The lessons dealing with the character Baldomero are a perfect example of this. Really weird story full of useless vocab that just begs the question “Why is this even in here?” I think the irony was lost on the author when he spoke of “his extraordinary faculty of boredom” 3. Pacing The progression of the lessons is inconsistent. The book does not slowly build you up to more advanced topics and structures in a meaningful way. One lesson will jump to a level much higher than the one before it and several lessons further down the line have a level much lower than the ones around it for no apparent reason. I found that at one point it became too difficult to follow and I had to leave the book for a couple weeks and come back. 4. Lack of cultural references They do briefly touch on the autonomous regions and mention a few major cities but I didn’t learn all that much about Spain. Maybe this was intentional but I think more effort could have been made. 5. Audio is too slow In the beginning it’s nice because you can actually follow what they’re saying but this speed never changes. It gets really annoying as you progress and also leaves you high and dry as you don’t get exposure to native like speech you would actually hear in real life. Final Thoughts After having gone through all 109 lessons several times I must say that this book is one of the main reasons I speak Spanish today. Despite its flaws it does outshine a lot of other materials out there because of its approach. Don’t use this book if you’re an absolute beginner. The speed picks up quickly after the first week and you won’t be able to follow. Get a little bit of exposure from some other beginner course and then add Assimil to your regimen. Take it with a grain of salt as well. You don’t have to learn everything last thing in the book especially when considering some of the really weird vocab in it.
I personally like Assimil and this book gets my approval.
German Dialogues for Beginners Book 2: Over 100 Daily Used Phrases & Short Stories to Learn German in Your Car. Have Fun and Grow Your Vocabulary with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: German for Adults, #2
German Short Stories for Beginners Book 5: Over 100 Dialogues and Daily Used Phrases to Learn German in Your Car. Have Fun & Grow Your Vocabulary, with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: German for Adults, #5
Spanish Dialogues for Beginners Book 2: Over 100 Daily Used Phrases & Short Stories to Learn Spanish in Your Car. Have Fun and Grow Your Vocabulary with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: Spanish for Adults, #2
Italian Short Stories for Beginners Book 5: Over 100 Dialogues and Daily Used Phrases to Learn Italian in Your Car. Have Fun & Grow Your Vocabulary, with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: Italian for Adults, #5
Italian Dialogues for Beginners Book 2: Over 100 Daily Used Phrases & Short Stories to Learn Italian in Your Car. Have Fun and Grow Your Vocabulary with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: Italian for Adults, #2
Spanish Short Stories for Beginners Book 5: Over 100 Dialogues and Daily Used Phrases to Learn Spanish in Your Car. Have Fun & Grow Your Vocabulary, with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: Spanish for Adults, #5
French Short Stories for Beginners Book 5: Over 100 Dialogues and Daily Used Phrases to Learn French in Your Car. Have Fun & Grow Your Vocabulary, with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: French for Adults, #5
French Dialogues for Beginners Book 2: Over 100 Daily Used Phrases & Short Stories to Learn French in Your Car. Have Fun and Grow Your Vocabulary with Crazy Effective Language Learning Lessons: French Language Lessons, #2