31)
© Società Geologica Italiana, Roma 2019
(1) CNR-IRPI, Research Institute for Geo-Hydrological Protection – Strada delle Cacce 73, 10135 Torino (Italy).
(2) UNIGE-Distav, Department of Earth, Environmental and Life Sciences, Genoa University Corso Europa, 27 16144, Genova (Italy).
Corresponding author e-mail: gpaliaga@gmail.com
Fig. 2 - Comparison of historical (1815-1823) and present-day map for the Polcevera stream final stretch; the riverbed width reduction is
evidenced on the right.
maximum possible error in the georeferencing process, city (Brandolini et al., 2018). The culvert extends on most
would lead to about 25%. In many situations, not reported of the very small basins and is often complete for the
in tab. 1, narrowing has resulted greater than 50% and entire section of the floodplain relative to the watercourses
even than 75% as in T. Sturla (Genova, Est from catchment of the first hierarchical orders (sensu Strahler) directly
12 in Fig. 1), T. S. Pietro (Imperia, West from catchment 4 leading to the sea. Another case of well-known culvert
in Fig. 1) and T. Arroscia (a right tributary of Centa stream, sadly famous for frequent and damaging floods on a larger
catchment 6 in Fig. 1). basin concerns the Bisagno stream that crosses the center
The Fig. 2 also shows the progradation of the of Genoa and is culverted up to its mouth for the last 1,5
watercourse at sea for subsequent dropouts and filled at sea km (Faccini et al., 2018). The diversion of the riverbed in
embankment to recover flat areas near the sea, tied to the the last century are more represented in the area of the
growth of the port of Genoa and the industrial development Genoese metropolitan city with examples such as the
of Italy which was born with the establishment of the heavy stream Ruscarolo in Sestri Ponente (Faccini et al., 2015)
industry in Polcevera Valley starting from the second half and Polcevera in Bolzaneto, the San Siro torrents in Santa
of the 19th century. Margherita Ligure and Boate in Rapallo (Brandolini et al.,
The progradation at sea and in any case the formation 2017), while other diversions related to the economic and
of the ‘techno–coast’ concern almost all the Ligurian coastal commercial activities of the Republic of Genoa between
floodplains (Tab.1), as well as the narrowing of the riverbed the late Middle Ages and the beginning of the modern era
with other examples already studied as on the Bisagno and include, for example, the stream Recco, the river Entella in
Entella rivers (Faccini et al., 2018; Roccati et al., 2018). Chiavari and the Centa river in Albenga.
Other types of morphological variation of anthropic origin Examining the morphological evolution of Ligurian
highlighted in the Ligurian floodplains are the culverting watercourses by adopting the recent methodologies for the
and the diversion of the riverbed, above all in Genoa old analysis of geomorphic effects due to flash floods (Belletti
Anthropogenic changes in the alluvial plains of the Tyrrhenian Ligurian basins 13
et al., 2018; Surian, 2018), we can highlight various The analysis of historical data concerning the casualties
evolutionary mechanisms for Ligurian watercourses that of geo-hydrological events according to the National
often presented an initial braided morphology and are Research Council statistics (available at: http://polaris.
often evolved towards a transitional morphology or more irpi.cnr.it/) shows that the number of victims due to floods
often single thread (Fig. 3). The originally single-threaded and landslides is very high and growing exponentially over
waterways were nevertheless channeled and often grafted time (Fig. 4b) with over 400 deaths since 1700 among
or otherwise subject to a techno-coast near their mouth. which 300 from 1900 and 200 from 1950.
The braided torrents have followed various evolutionary The fatalities are distributed throughout the region as
lines that have led them to evolve into narrow channels, well as the displaced persons (Fig. 4c) which reach more
sometimes totally culverted and almost always subject to than 250 in some areas of Liguria.
‘techno–coast’ (Tab. 1).
In the selected Ligurian floodplains a high consumption
of soil is observed, always higher than 20%, but often
higher than 60 and even 80% (peaks in land consumption
DISCUSSION
at Genova Sestri Ponente, see Fig. 4a). The maximum
values are recognized in the central area of the Ligurian The historical cartographic analysis has allowed to
arc, between Savona a W and Sestri Levante a E: this strip highlight evolutionary trends common to the coastal
of coast is most affected by the effects of cyclogenesis on floodplains of the Tyrrhenian Ligurian catchments and
the Gulf of Genoa and therefore by more frequent and the close correlation between anthropic intervention,
intense floods. Similarly, in all the selected cases, there morphological changes and land use and increase in flood
is a strong narrowing of the riverbed of 50% on average, risk in urbanized areas.
sometimes even more than 70%. The transformation from a predominantly rural
To such values of soil consumption in the plain landscape, with cultivated fields and wide naturally
correspond very often values of soil consumption on the vegetated sectors, to a strongly man modified landscape
entire basin often higher than 5% or even 10% in the with a dense urban fabric and extensive artificial areas,
Genoese area in the valleys of the Bisagno and Polcevera is a consequence of the rapid and often disorderly
streams (Tab. 1). urbanization of the coastal floodplains from the end of
Fig. 3 - The channel classification from Surian et al. (2003), basing on incision and narrowing, on the left; on the right the Polcevera riverbed
modification B-D-F-H as detected through the cartographic analysis.
14 F. Luino ET AL.
TABLE 1
Nineteenth century and particularly after the post-war the total artificialization of the areas of natural expansion
period (Sacchini et al., 2016; Faccini et al., 2018). The of the rivers during the floods, and the growing anthropic
industrial, commercial and tourist development of the presence in sectors of the floodplain historically occupied
coastal centers, the construction of new communication by the waters in the course of alluvial events, have caused
and transport routes, and the progressive depopulation of an increase in flood risk (Faccini et al., 2018). This trend
the rural hinterland sectors have caused a considerable is highlighted by the increase in flooding phenomena in
increase in population and the consequent search for new recent decades (Acquaotta et al., 2018b), both in terms
spaces for construction of residential neighborhoods, of the number of events and the extent of the damage
roads, industrial, commercial and port sites (Antrop, 2000; caused and the population involved. Although it is difficult
Vogt et al., 2004; Hearn et al., 2014; Paliaga et al., 2018). to assess whether the greater frequency with which
The increasing urbanization and anthropic pressure damaging alluvial events occur is related to the change
on the coastal floodplains cause the ever-increasing in rainfall or anthropogenic forms that have influenced
consumption of soil: an ever denser and more compact the geomorphological processes, nevertheless from the
urban fabric has replaced whole cultivated or naturally historical analysis it is evident the negative impact that
vegetated sectors, modifying the morphology of the urbanization has exercised on the balance between the
watercourses that cross the plains, deleting beaches and different elements that form the floodplain.
profoundly transforming the profile of the coastline. The The knowledge of morphological variations of coastal
narrowing of riverbeds, the diversion, channeling and plains and riverbeds in relation to human activities,
culverting of whole stretches, especially terminals and at together with the historical memory of alluvial phenomena,
the mouth, are directly related to the continuous search is therefore fundamental for sustainable urban planning
for spaces for the construction of buildings, roads, bridges, and aimed at flood risk reduction activities (Petrucci &
infrastructures, industrial sites, tourist and sports facilities Polemio, 2007).
(Scalenghe & Marsan, 2009). The extraction of gravel and
sand from the riverbeds and beaches due to the growing
demand for building materials, between the end of the 19th CONCLUSIONS
and the first half of the 20th century, and the creation of new
artificial spaces used for port facilities or airports in the In the last centuries, the Ligurian coastal floodplains
course of the twentieth century, through carryovers, fills, have been affected by significative morphological changes.
groins and breakwaters, have caused deep morphological The causes are to be found in the natural environment, but
variations of the waterways and of the coastline (Kondolf, above all in the important anthropic conditions that these
1997), with the obliteration of entire beaches and the territorial realities have undergone.
transformation into ‘techno-coast’ (Anthony, 2014b). Historical and current cartography, multi-temporal
The progressive reduction of the distances from the aerial photography and present days images were
riverbeds, the culverts of the channels and in many cases compared by using GIS systems. Through these last
Anthropogenic changes in the alluvial plains of the Tyrrhenian Ligurian basins 15
Fig. 4 - Top: thematic map of the soil consumption in the floodplain and artificial coastline for all the 30 studied catchments. Bottom: casualties
and flood events.
ones, the evolution of the coastal floodplain has been floodplains, already constrained between steep slopes and
evaluated, in terms of reduction of the natural spaces (due the sea (Antrop, 2004). The main morphological changes
to canalization), variation in the use of the territory and of the Ligurian alluvial floodplains are connected to: i)
exploitation of the coastal stretch. land-use change from mainly agricultural to complete
The quantitative analysis carried out through the urbanization of the flood-plain until culverted channels;
diachronous documentation of the maps and photos ii) change in the channel width narrowing of the riverbed
reveals the trend over time of the watercourse connected section; iii) displacement of the watercourse and river
to obvious changes in channel length, width, sinuosity and diversion; iv) coastal plain progradation.
position, the transition from natural areas (with vegetated The morpho-evolutive preliminary model has led to a
and cultivated areas) to anthropic environments (with rapid evolution of the morphological plain with channel
large artificial areas) and the progressive regression of the narrowing (from 20% to 71%) and pattern changes in over
coast. 30% of watercourse cases, from braided to transitional or
The increase in urban development has compromised to single thread. The change in land use, the narrowing
the naturalness of the morphological context of coastal and channeling of watercourses (through containment and
16 F. Luino ET AL.
culvert) has increased the risk of flooding (Wheater et al., Faccini F., Luino F., Paliaga G., Sacchini A., Turconi L. & de Jong
2009) for those living in coastal areas. The floods risk is C. (2018) -Role of rainfall intensity and urban sprawl in the
2014 flash flood in Genoa City, Bisagno Catchment (Liguria,
increasing considering the occurrence of heavy rains on Italy). Applied Geography, 98, 224-241.
a very urbanized area (Acquaotta et al., 2018a; Faccini Hearn R., Watkins C. & Balzaretti R. (2014) - The cultural and land
et al., 2018), above all combining the ongoing climate use implications of the reappearance of the wild boar in North
change and a potential increase in sea levels. It is therefore West Italy: a case study in the Val di Vara. Journal of Rural
Studies, 36, 52-63.
useful to compare the maps as a tool to evaluate the
ISPRA (2017). Carta nazionale del consumo di suolo (risoluzione
geomorphological evolution of the floodplains, based on 10 m) v.1.0 20/06/2017 Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la
an integrated approach of geomorphology and the allied Ricerca Ambientale. http://groupware.sinanet.isprambiente.it/
discipline. uso-copertura-e-consumo-di-suolo/library/consumo-di-suolo/
carta-nazionale-consumo-suolo, Last access date: 09 March 2019.
Kondolf M.G. (1997) - Hungry water: effects of dams and gravel
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT mining on river channels. Environmental Management, 21(4),
533-551.
Research carried out with financial support from the RECONECT Luino F. & Turconi L. (2017) - Eventi di piena e frana in Italia
Project – EU H2020. settentrionale nel periodo 2005-2016. Ed. Soc. Meteor. Supalbina,
Stamperia Artistica, Torino.
Ollero A. (2010) - Channel changes and floodplain management in the
REFERENCES meandering middle Ebro River, Spain. Geomorphology, 117(3-4),
247-260.
Acquaotta F., Faccini F., Fratianni S., Paliaga G., Sacchini A. & Vilìmek Paliaga G., Faccini F., Luino F. & Turconi L. (2019) - A spatial
V. (2018a) - Increased flash flooding in Genoa Metropolitan multicriteria prioritizing approach for geohydrological risk
Area: a combination of climate changes and soil consumption? mitigation planning in small and densely urbanized Mediterranean
Meteorology and Atmospheric Physics, 1-12. basins. Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci, 19, 53-69.
Acquaotta F., Faccini F., Fratianni S., Paliaga G. & Sacchini A. (2018b) Paliaga G., Luino F., Turconi L. & Faccini F. (2018) – Inventory of
– Rainfall intensity in the Genoa Metropolitan Area (Northern geo-hydrological phenomena in Genova Municipality (NW Italy).
Mediterranean): secular variations and consequences. Weather, Journal of Maps.
73(11), 356-362. Petrucci O. & Polemio M. (2007) - Flood risk mitigation and
Anthony E. J., Marriner N. & Morhange C. (2014a) - Human influence anthropogenic modifications of a coastal plain in southern Italy
combined effects over the past 150 years. Natural Hazards and
and the changing geomorphology of Mediterranean deltas and
Earth System Sciences, 7, 361-373.
coasts over the last 6000 years: From progradation to destruction
phase?. Earth-Science Reviews, 139, 336-361. Rinaldi M., Amponsah W., Benvenuti M., Borga M., Comiti F., Lucía
A., Marchi L., Nardi L., Righini M. & Surian N. (2016) - An
Anthony E. J. (2014b) - The Human influence on the Mediterranean integrated approach for investigating geomorphic response to
coast over the last 200 years: a brief appraisal from a extreme events: Methodological framework and application to
geomorphological perspective. Géomorphologie: relief, processus, the October 2011 flood in the Magra River catchment, Italy. Earth
environnement, 20(3), 219-226. Surface Processes and Landforms, 41(6), 835-846.
Antrop M. (2000) - Changing patterns in the urbanized countryside of Roccati A., Luino F., Turconi L., Piana P., Watkins C. & Faccini F.
Western Europe. Landscape Ecology, 15, 257-270. (2018) - Historical geomorphological research of a Ligurian
Antrop M. (2004) - Landscape change and the urbanization process in coastal floodplain (Italy) and its value for management of flood
Europe. Landscape and urban planning, 67(1-4), 9-26. risk and environmental sustainability. Sustainibility, 10, 3727.
Belletti B., Nardi L., Rinaldi M., Poppe M., Brabec K., Bussettini Sacchini A., Faccini F., Ferraris F., Firpo M. & Angelini S. (2016) -
M., Comiti F., Gielczewski M., Golfieri B., Hellsten S., Kail J., Large-scale landslide and Deep-Seated Gravitational Slope
Deformation of the Upper Scrivia Valley (Northern Apennine,
Marchese E., Marcinkowski P., Okruszko T., Paillex A., Schirmer
Italy). Journal of Maps, 12(2), 344-358.
M., Stelmaszczyk M. & Surian N. (2018) - Assessing Restoration
Effects on River Hydromorphology Using the Process-based Scalenghe R. & Marsan F.A. (2009) - The anthropogenic sealing of
Morphological Quality Index in Eight European River Reaches. soils in urban areas. Landscape and urban planning, 90(1-2), 1-10.
Environmental Management, 61(1), 69-84. Scorpio V., Crema S., Marra F., Righini M., Ciccarese G., Borga M.,
Brandolini P., Faccini F., Paliaga G. & Piana P. (2017) - Urban Cavalli M., Corsini A., Marchi L., Surian N. & Comiti F. (2018)
Geomorphology in Coastal Environment: Man-Made - Basin-scale analysis of the geomorphic effectiveness of flash
floods: A study in the northern Apennines (Italy). Science of the
Morphological Changes in a Seaside Tourist Resort (Rapallo,
Total Environment, 640-641, 337-351.
Eastern Liguria, Italy). Quaestiones Geographicae, 36(3), 97-110.
Surian N. & Rinaldi M. (2003) - Morphological response to
Brandolini P., Faccini F., Paliaga G., & Piana P. (2018) - Man-made river engineering and management in alluvial channels in
landforms survey and mapping in an urban historical center on Italy. Geomorphology, 50(4), 307-326.
coastal Mediterranean environment. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica
Quaternaria, 41, 24-34. Surian N. & Rinaldi M. (2004) – Channel adjustments in response to
human alteration of sediment fluxes: examples from italian rivers.
Brandolini P., Faccini F., Robbiano A. & Terranova R. (2008) - In: Sediment Transfer through the Fluvial System, Proceedings
Relationship between flood hazards and geomorphology applied Symposium held in Moscow, August 2004, IAHS Publ.288, 276-
to land planning in the upper Aveto Valley (Liguria, Italy). 282.
Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria, 31, 73-82. Surian N. (2018) – Geomorphic response to estreme floods: from
Camarasa-Belmonte A.M. & Soriano-Garcia J. (2012) - Flood process understanding to hazard assessment. AGU Fall Meetings
risk assessment and mapping in peri-urban Mediterranean Abstracts
environments using hydrogeomorphology. Application to Vogt J., Puumalainen J., Kennedy P. & Folving S. (2004) - Integrating
ephemeral streams in the Valencia region (eastern Spain). information on river networks, catchments and major forest
Landscape and Urban Planning, 104(2), 189-200. types: towards the characterisation and analysis of European
Faccini F., Luino F., Sacchini A. & Turconi L. (2015) - The 4th October landscapes. Landscape and Urban Planning, 67(1-4), 27-41.
2010 flash flood event in Genoa Sestri Ponente (Liguria, Italy). Wheater H. & Evans E. (2009) - Land use, water management and
Disaster Advances, 8 (8), 1-14. future flood risk. Land use policy, 26, S251-S264.