Case 5.

Jona car Rental: Before the Next Teardrop Falls

Mr. Jose Naguimbing went about as a general manager of Jona Car Rental for
only fourteen months. The main branch was situated in Makati City and branches in
Angeles City, Olongapo City, and Baguio City.

Jose has a sibling, Pedro, who established the company and was well-enjoyed by
his subordinates. Pedro left the car rental company to build up another business. Jose
was excited during the initial couple of months of his stewardship. On the fifth month, his
staff started losing trust in his capacities to run the firm. Once, when a request for three
units of Toyota vehicle was displayed to him by the office manager for his signature, he
sign it right away. Then the manager filed the request with the dealer on that day. The
following morning, be that as it may, Jose change his mind and instruct the manager to
drop the request. He additionally instructed the manager to purchase three units of
Mitsubishi cars from a dealer.

When the position of branch manager of Angeles City wound up empty, he

designated somebody whom his prompt staff thought to be the least meriting the three
up-and-comers. His staff were demonstrated rights: the incomes of the branch were
radically decreased in only three months. Contrasted and the rival in the area, the
presentation of the branch was terrible.

At the point when Jose chose to set up another branch, he requested that his staff
recognize three potential destinations for him to look over. He picked Laoag City. It
worked out that Laoag had the weakest potential. Following a couple of long periods of
activity, the branch had not given any indication of guarantee. Conversely, the contender
who set up a branch in Santiago City around the same time was enlisting significant
incomes. Santiago City was one of the potential destinations sent to Jose for thought.

Case Analysis

I. Problem:

What can Mr. Jose do to improve his performance and gain the trust of his
employees again?

II. Case Facts:

1. Mr. Jose Naguimbing change his mind the next day and instruct the
manager to cancel the order of three Toyota vehicles and purchase
three units of Mitsubishi cars from a dealer.
2. Appointing a least deserving branch manager within the three
candidates and without any evaluating the performance and capacity to
handle the position.
3. Laoag City had the weakest potential site for another branch.
4. Santiago City was one of the potential destinations.
III. Alternative Cause of Action

ACA I
Bontia v. NLRC (96)
“The rule is well settled that labor laws discourage interference with an
employer’s judgment in the conduct of hid business. Even as the law is
solicitous of the welfare of the employees, it must also protect the right of
an employer to exercise what are clearly management prerogatives.

ACA II
G.R. No. 81262 August 25, 1989
Globe Mackay Cable and Radio Corp., and Herbert C. Hendry,
petitioners, vs. The Honorable Court of Appeals and Restituto M.
Tobias, respondents, Article 19, states that “Every person must, in the
exercise of his rights and in the performance of his duties, act with justice,
give everyone his due, and observe honesty and good faith.”

ACA III
Republic Act No. 386 dated June 18, 1949, The Civil Code of the
Philippines, Chapter II, Human Relations, Article 19 states that “ Every
person must, in the exercise of his rights and in the performance of his
duties, act with justice, give everyone his due, and observe honesty and
good faith.”

IV. Recommendation

ACA II
An individual who does not showcase his motivations without
thinking about the most noticeably awful repercussion that may emerge out
of his choice which is needing of intellectual or astute circumspection.

V. Conclusion

Mr. Jose Naguimbing needs to follow the decision-making process to

improve his performance. If he follows the right process he will never failed
again in making decisions for the company. For choosing the right place of
another branch, signing the request on ordering a three units of vehicle on
Toyota, then cancelling the transaction the other day for the three units of
Mitsubishi cars. Finally, choosing a wrong site for the new branch