electromagnetic transient

© All Rights Reserved

0 tayangan

electromagnetic transient

© All Rights Reserved

- Nth UE Selection Algorithm Modification
- OR ASGMT 236
- age prob
- d
- webquest rubric
- Model Predictive Control of Van de Vusse Reactor
- Modelo de Fisher
- Main
- 2steps
- Artificial Intelligence in MIS
- Algorithm(3)
- Supper Clocks Presentation Aos 5
- 1
- 10309779.xlsx
- Full Text 01
- 05-A Efremov DGLR Manching 081112
- Paper 2 Solution
- Hardy Cr 327
- Distributions
- Some Problems of ai

Anda di halaman 1dari 7

Research Article

ISSN 1751-8687

Fast electromagnetic transient simulation for Received on 31st March 2016

Revised on 25th May 2016

over-voltages of transmission line by high Accepted on 24th June 2016

doi: 10.1049/iet-gtd.2016.0476

www.ietdl.org

College of Electrical Engineering and New Energy, China Three Gorges University, YiChang 443002 Hubei, People’s Republic of China

✉ E-mail: fzwang@ctgu.edu.cn

Abstract: To improve the computational efficiency of electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulation in power system, as well as

avoid the numerical oscillation, the high order Radau method is proposed for EMT simulation in this study. For solving the

differential equation in EMT simulation effectively, the high order Radau method uses its weighting coefficient matrix

satisfying the important V-transformation feature to make the relevant high dimension linear algebraic equation

decoupled into blocks in time domain, then forms the multi-stage block recursive method. Because of this technology, in

every integration step, the variable value at each different internal point can be calculated simultaneously. On this basis,

bigger integration step can be selected to improve the computational speed when carrying out EMT simulation since the

high order Radau method is of high computational accuracy. Besides, because this method is both L-stable and B-stable,

it can be free of numerical oscillation in EMT simulation effectively. Finally, the validity of this high order Radau method

has been demonstrated compared with critical damping adjustment by implementing EMT simulation of transmission line.

time-integration step, leading to its lower efﬁciency compared with

traditional implicit trapezoidal method or CDA.

The electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulation can be applied into

It is not hard to ﬁnd that the methods mentioned above are all low

many categories in power system, including over-voltages,

order numerical integration methods, naturally leading to the low

insulation coordination, inrush currents, abnormal resonances,

computational efﬁciency in some degree. Therefore, the high order

relay settings, and so on [1–4]. In EMT simulations, considering

integration methods [14–16] may be taken into considerations when

the characteristics of the non-linear property of component,

it comes to solve the differential equations in EMT simulation.

electromagnetic coupling, wave process of transmission line and

Since the high order integration method always has high

so on, differential equations should be established. Accordingly,

computational accuracy, it can adopt bigger integration step

numerical integration algorithms will be used to discretise these

compared with low order method when they are equal in

differential equations into algebraic equations for obtaining

computational accuracy. However, the existed high order integration

variable values at each integration point.

methods always involve in high dimension matrix computations,

So far, the most fundamental and classic time-integration

which may also lead to considerable computations. Given this

algorithm used in EMT simulations is implicit trapezoidal method.

factor, we should settle the problem of solving high dimension

The implicit trapezoidal method is a simple one-step integration

algebraic equation ﬁrst when using high order method with big

method with A-stability, and has second-order accuracy [5]. With

integration step to solve the differential equation in EMT simulation.

this method, the value of state variable at present time step can be

In this paper, the high order Radau IIA method is brieﬂy

calculated only from value of previous time step, making it of

introduced in Section 2. First, we have a brief introduction of

great convenience in programming. However, the trapezoidal

implicit Runge–Kutta method, including its Butcher table and

method is not L-stable, resulting in ‘ﬁctitious’ sustained numerical

simpliﬁed order condition. Then, the integration scheme of high

oscillation easily when a sudden change happens to a state

order Radau IIA method and its features are displayed next in line,

variable [6, 7]. Therefore, critical damping adjustment (CDA) [8]

among which the coefﬁcient matrix satisfying V-transformation is

has been proposed to settle this problem, as well as implemented

emphasised. In Section 3, we deduce how to use the high order

in electromagnetic transients program [9–11] taking place of the

Radau IIA method and V-transformation to form the multi-stage

original implicit trapezoidal method. In CDA, the trapezoidal

block recursive method in EMT simulation in detail. In Section 4,

method is basically used, and the back Euler method will be used

the EMT simulations for over-voltages of transmission line are

when experienced with sudden changes. Considering that the back

implemented by both high order Radau IIA method and CDA.

Euler method is both A-stable and L-stable with heavily damped

The result fully demonstrates that the high order Radau IIA

property, the numerical oscillation can be avoided in most

method shows excellent advantages in numerical stability and

situations. However, there are still numerical oscillations when

computational speed. The conclusions are ﬁnally given in Section 5.

sudden changes cannot be detected effectively in carrying out

CDA [12]. For instance, it is difﬁcult to detect the ‘critical’ sudden

moment when a sudden change of voltage or current is transported

from sending end to receiving end of a transmission line. Besides, 2 High order Radau IIA method

the amplitude limiting operations in control system may also result

in numerical oscillations [13] even though the CDA is used. 2.1 Brief introduction of implicit Runge–Kutta method

Accordingly, Noda et al. [12] have proposed applying the

two-stage diagonally implicit Runge–Kutta (2S-DIRK) method to Consider the initial value problem of ordinary differential equation

EMT simulations. The 2S-DIRK method is L-stable, making the

result free of numerical oscillation the same as back Euler method.

Though the 2S-DIRK method does not need detections for sudden ẋ(t) = f (t, x(t)) , x(t = 0) = x0 (1)

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 3639

where, t is time and f (t, x(t)) is the function of time and variable x; from the computational accuracy angle, since the multi-stage

x0 is the initial value of variable. high-order method owns high computational accuracy, bigger

One of the main methods used for solving formula (1) is implicit integration step can be adopted in comparison with low order

Runge–Kutta method, and the integration scheme of the s-stage method when they are equal in computational accuracy.

implicit Runge–Kutta method can be described as In additional, because the s-stage Radau IIA method satisﬁes the

simpliﬁed order condition of C(s), the coefﬁcient matrix A satisﬁes

⎧

⎪

s the important V-transformation feature as [5]

⎪

⎨ x̃i = xn + h

⎪ aij f (tn + cj h, x̃j )

j=1

, i [ (1, s). (2) A = VDV −1 (7)

⎪

⎪

s

⎪

⎩ xn+1 = xn + h bi f (tn + cj h, x̃j )

j=1

where

where, h is the integration step; aij andbi are the integral

sweighting ⎡ ⎤

s 1 c1 · · · cs−1

coefﬁcients, and they satisfy j=1 aij = ci , i=1 bi = 1;

1

ci , i [ (1, s) are the internal points with 0 ≤ c1 ≤ · · · ≤ cs ≤ 1, ⎢ 1 c2 s−1 ⎥

· · · c2 ⎥

⎢

and x̃i ≃ x(tn + ci h) is the approximate value of state variable at V =⎢. . .. .. ⎥ (8)

⎣ .. .. . . ⎦

internal point ci.

For convenience, we often rewrite the integration scheme of 1 cs · · · cs−1

s

⎡

a1 ⎤

formula (2) as Butcher table form [17]:

0

⎢1 0 a2 ⎥

c1 a11 · · · a1s ⎢ ⎥

⎢ . ⎥

c A .. .. .. D=⎢

⎢ 1/2 . . a3 ⎥⎥,

. . . . ⎢

= (3)

⎣ .. .. ⎥ (9)

bT cs as1 · · · ass . 0 . ⎦

b1 · · · bs 1/(s − 1) as

T 1

as = a 1 · · · as = V −1 cs

Usually, the features of an implicit Runge–Kutta method, including s

stability, accuracy and so on, are decided by the parameters A, b, c,

and each implicit Runge–Kutta method often satisﬁes different V-transformation is a very important feature of the multi-stage

simpliﬁed order conditions of formula (4) [18]: high-order Radau IIA method. It is also the basic reason why the

⎧ multi-stage high-order Radau IIA method can be decoupled, then

⎪ s 1 form the multi-stage block recursive method.

⎪

⎪ B(p) : bi ck−1 = , k [ (1, p)

⎪

⎪ i

k

⎪

⎪ i=1

⎪

⎨ s ck

C(h) : aij ck−1 = i , i [ (1, s), k [ (1, h) (4) 3 EMT simulation of transmission line by Radau

⎪

⎪

j

k IIA method and V-transformation

⎪

⎪

j=1

⎪

⎪ s bj

⎪

⎪ D(j) : bi ck−1 aij = (1 − ckj ) , j [ (1, s), k [ (1, j) .

⎩ i Considering the distributed parameter characteristic of transmission

i=1 k

line, we often use a pair of partial differential equation to describe

it, which can be called as telegraph equation. When using time

domain methods to analyse the EMT of transmission line, one of

the practicable method is to do spatial discretisation, and transform

2.2 High order Radau IIA method the partial differential equation into differential equation

The s-stage Radau IIA method is one kind of implicit Runge–Kutta ẋ = f (t, x) = Bx + w(t) (10)

method, and its internal points ci, i [ (1, s) are the zero points of the

right Radau polynomial [5] where, x is the state variable, B is the coefﬁcient matrix related to

system parameters, and w(t) is the non-homogenous term.

ds−1 s−1 When B is constant, with formula (2) or (3), we can solve (10) by

(x (x − 1)s ). (5)

dxs−1

X = es ⊗ xn + h(A ⊗ B)X + h(A ⊗ I m )

w (11)

Besides, the integral weighting coefﬁcient bi is decided by the

simpliﬁed order condition of B(2s − 1), and aij is decided by D(s). where, the symbol ⊗ denotes the tensor product; m is the amount of

Since the s-stage Radau IIA method satisﬁes the simpliﬁed order state variables; es is a column vector with all elements being 1; I m is

conditions of B(2s − 1), C(s) and D(s − 1), it is A-stable, L-stable, a unit matrix with m × m dimension; and

non-linear B-stable, and with the accuracy of (2s − 1)-order [19].

As is well known, the integration method with B-stability satisﬁes ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤

x(tn + c1 h) x̃1

unilateral Lipschitz condition, that is

⎢ ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥

X =⎣ ... ;

⎦ ⎣ .. ⎦,

kf (t1 , x1 ) − f (t2 , x2 ), x1 − x2 l ≤ 0 (6) x(tn + cs h) x̃s

⎡ ⎤ (12)

w(tn + c1 h)

where, k†, †l represents inner product. Therefore, the method with

B-stability is of energy dissipation property. From the physical =⎢

w ⎣ ..

.

⎥

⎦[R

(sm)×1

non-linear damped property. Therefore, when sudden change

happens, the B-stable method can be free of numerical oscillation

because of this non-linear damped property. Besides, since the Obviously, the formula (11) can be expressed as a simple linear

back Euler method is the single-stage Radau IIA method with algebraic equation as [20]

B-stability and simple integration scheme, it is widely used in

EMT simulations for avoiding numerical oscillation. What’s more, JX = F (13)

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

3640 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016

where The equation of forward process can be expressed as

⎡ ⎤

J = (I s ⊗ I m ) − h(A ⊗ B) [ R(sm)×(sm) (14) Im

⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤

⎢ −hB Im ⎥ b1 b1

F = h(A ⊗ I m )

w + es ⊗ xn [ R(sm)×1 ⎢ ⎥

(15) ⎢ h . ⎥⎢ b2 ⎥ ⎢ b2 ⎥

⎢

⎢ − B .. ⎥⎢ ⎥ ⎢

⎥⎢ . ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥

⎥

⎢ 2 ⎥⎢ .. ⎥ = ⎢ .. ⎥ (25)

On the basis of formula (6), we can get that ⎢ . .. ⎥⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥

⎢ .. . Im ⎥⎣ b ⎦ ⎣ b ⎦

⎢ ⎥ s−1 s−1

⎣ ⎦ b bs

J = (V ⊗ I m ) (I s ⊗ I m ) − h(D ⊗ B) (V −1 ⊗ I m ) (16) h s

− B Im

s−1

Let

where, b1 , b2 , . . . , bs are the middle variables, and they can be

J̃ = I s ⊗ I m − h(D ⊗ B) (17) calculated by

⎧

and it can be expressed as formula (18) based on formula (9) ⎨ b1 = b1

h (26)

⎡

Im −a1 hB

⎤ ⎩ bj = bj + Bb , j [ (2, s).

j − 1 j−1

⎢ −hB Im −a2 hB ⎥

⎢ ⎥

⎢ h . .. ⎥

⎢ − B .. ⎥ The equation of backward process can be expressed as

⎢ . ⎥

J̃ = ⎢ 2 ⎥ (18)

⎢ . .. ⎥ ⎡ ⎤⎡ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤

⎢ .. . Im −as−1 hB ⎥ Im b1 x1 b1

⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ x ⎥ ⎢ b ⎥

⎣ ⎦ Im b2

h ⎢ ⎥⎢ 2 ⎥ ⎢ 2 ⎥

− B I m − as hB ⎢ .. .. ⎥⎢ . ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥

s−1 ⎢ . . ⎥⎢ . ⎥ = ⎢ . ⎥ (27)

⎢ ⎥⎢ . ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥

⎢ . ⎥⎣ ⎦ ⎣ b ⎦

Next, we carry out the triangular decomposition of J̃ , that is to make ⎣ .. Im bs−1 ⎦ xs−1 s−1

xs bs

I m + bs

U

J̃ = L (19)

and its recursion formula is

and

⎡ ⎤ xs = (I m + bs )−1 bs

Im . (28)

x j−1 = b j−1 − b j−1 xs , j [ (2, s)

⎢ −hB Im ⎥

⎢ ⎥

⎢ ⎥

⎢ h .. ⎥ Finally, the variable value at internal point can be calculated by

⎢ − B . ⎥

=⎢

L 2 ⎥,

⎢ ⎥ ⎡⎤ ⎡ ⎤

⎢ .. ⎥ x̃1 x1

⎢ . Im ⎥

⎢ ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥ ⎢ . ⎥

⎣ h ⎦ X = ⎣ .. ⎦ = (V ⊗ I m )⎣ .. ⎦ (29)

− B Im

s−1 (20) x̃s xs

⎡ ⎤

Im b1

⎢ ⎥ and the variable value at next integration point is

⎢ Im b2 ⎥

⎢ ⎥

=⎢ .. .. ⎥

U ⎢ . . ⎥ xn+1 = x̃s . (30)

⎢ ⎥

⎢

⎣ Im bs−1 ⎥ ⎦

I m + bs For a better illustration of the EMT simulation by high order Radau

IIA method and V-transformation, we give out the main calculation

steps of this method:

where

⎧ (i) Form the standard equation for EMT simulation as formula

⎨ b1 = −a1 hB (10).

1 (21) (ii) Discretise the ordinary differential equation as formula (11); set

⎩ bj = −aj hB + hBb j−1 , j [ (2, s).

j−1 the integration stage and step, then form the integration scheme.

(iii) Calculate the constant matrixes L, U by formula (20) and (21).

Thus (iv) Calculate F, b by formula (15) and (23), and solve the equation

x = b based on formulas (25)–(28).

U

L

U(V

J = (V ⊗ I m )L −1 ⊗ I m ) (22) (v) Calculate the variable value at next integration point by formula

(29) and (30).

Deﬁne (vi) If B is a constant matrix, return to step iv and go on calculating

till the end of total simulation; B varies with time, regard it as a

constant matrix in one integration step, and return to step iii

(V −1 ⊗ I m )X = x, (V −1 ⊗ I m )F = b (23) update L, U, then go on calculating till the end of total simulation.

then (13) is converted into the following form As is stated above, in every integration step, the algorithm

presented in this paper only involves once triangular

U

L x = b. (24) decomposition of m-dimensional matrix I m + bs , and the rest of

the calculation is completed by m-dimensional block recursive

The solution to (24) is mainly related to the forward-backward sweep calculations. For the s-stage method, we need 2s recursive

algorithm, and the process of it is based on block matrix calculation. calculations totally. On this basis, when the s-stage method adopts

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 3641

s times integration step as single-stage method, they will be equal in where

computational efﬁciency.

T

x = v0 v1 ··· vN i1/2 · · · iN −1/2 (37)

4 EMT simulations of transmission line ⎡ ⎤

A4 A1

⎢ .. ⎥

4.1 Time-domain simulating model of transmission line ⎢A . ⎥

⎢ 1 A2 ⎥

⎢ .. .. .. ⎥

⎢ ⎥

The telegraph equation used for describing the transmission line is ⎢ . . . 0 ⎥

⎢ .. ⎥

⎧ ⎢ ⎥

∂v(z, t) ∂i(z, t) ⎢ . A2 A1 ⎥

⎪

⎨ ⎢ ⎥

= −L0 − R0 i(z, t) P=⎢ ⎥,

∂z ∂t ⎢ A1 A4 ⎥

(31) ⎢ ⎥

⎩ ∂i(z, t) = −C ∂u(z, t) − G v(z, t)

⎪ ⎢

⎢

B3 B1 ⎥

⎥

∂z 0

∂t 0

⎢ .. ⎥

⎢ . ⎥

⎢ B1 B2 ⎥

⎢ .. .. ⎥

where, L0, R0, C0, G0 are the unit parameters of inductance, resistance, ⎢ ⎥

capacitance, and susceptance; z is the spatial variable about the length, ⎣ 0 . . B1 ⎦

and t is the time variable; v(z, t) and i(z, t) represent that the voltage B1 B3

and current variables change with the space and time. ⎡ ⎤ (38)

There are two kinds of methods used for solving the telegraph C4 C1 1

⎢ .. ⎥

equation (31), one is the frequency domain method, and the other ⎢C . −1 ⎥

⎢ 1 C2 1 ⎥

is time domain method. Since the frequency domain method ⎢ .. .. .. .. .. ⎥

involves in complex calculations about Laplace or Fourier ⎢ ⎥

⎢ . . . . . ⎥

transformation, we prefer to use the time domain method to do ⎢ .. ⎥

⎢ ⎥

EMT simulation of high voltage transmission line in this paper. ⎢ . C2 C1 −1 1 ⎥

⎢ ⎥

To acquire the voltage and current variables along the line, we Q=⎢

⎢ C1 C4 −1 ⎥

⎥

divide the whole transmission line into N sections uniformly as is ⎢ ⎥

⎢ −1 1 D3 D1 ⎥

described in Fig. 1. Suppose the length of transmission line is L, ⎢ ⎥

then the length of every small section is Δz = L/N. Let vk represent ⎢ .. ⎥

⎢ −1 1 . ⎥

the voltage at the place where z = k(Dz), k [ (0, N ); ik−1/2 is the ⎢ D1 D2 ⎥

⎢ .. .. .. ⎥

current at the place where z = (k − 1/2)(Dz), k [ (1, N ), besides, ⎢ ⎥

⎣ . . . D1 ⎦

i0 and iN are the currents of two terminals.

Here, we use the fourth order accuracy interpolation formula to do −1 1 D1 D3

spatial discretisation of the telegraph equation [21]
T

m(t) = −i0 0 ··· 0 iN 0 ··· 0 (39)

∂g(z) ∂g(z) ∂g(z) gk+1/2 − gk−1/2

g1 +g2 + g = (32)

∂z k−1 ∂z

k

1

∂z k+1 Dz and

by the interpolation formula, and g1 = 1/24, g2 = 1 − 2g1. (40)

Substitute (32) into (31), we can easily deduce that (see (33)) Dj = R0 · Dz · gj , (j = 1, 2, 3, 4).

As to the head-end and the tail-end of the line, we use the second Obviously, (36) can be converted into the ordinary differential

order accuracy interpolation formula to do spatial discretisation equation as (10), where B = −P −1 Q and w(t) = −P −1 m(t).

⎧

⎪ i − i1/2

⎨ g4 (G0 v0 + C0 v̇0 ) + g1 (G0 v1 + C0 v̇1 ) = 0 4.2 Example simulations for over-voltages of

Dz (34) transmission line

⎩ g3 (R0 i1/2 + L0 i̇1/2 ) + g1 (R0 i3/2 + L0 i̇3/2 ) = v0 − v1

⎪

Dz 4.2.1 Numerical stability test: Fig. 2 shows the breaker of a

single-phase high-voltage transmission line is switched-in at t = 0 s

and with the terminal of the line being no-load, and the parameters of

⎧ this testing system are given in Fig. 2.

⎪ i −i When the switch is closed, two terminals of the transmission line

⎨ g4 (G0 vN + C0 v̇N ) + g1 (G0 vN −1 + C0 v̇N −1 ) = N−1/2 N

Dz satisfy

⎩ g3 (R0 iN−1/2 + L0 i̇N −1/2 ) + g1 (R0 iN−3/2 + L0 i̇N −3/2 ) = vN −1 − vN

⎪

⎧

Dz ⎨ i = es − v0

0

(35) R . (41)

⎩i = 0 s

N

where, g3 = 1 − g1 and g4 = 1/2 − g1.

Adding the constraint condition of both ends of transmission line, In this situation, we divide the whole transmission line into 50

we can get 2N + 1 equations in total, and the matrix form can be sections, that is N = 50. Besides, the initial phase angle of input

described as signal is j = 90°. For comparison, we would give out the results of

both Radau IIA method, CDA, and implicit trapezoidal method.

P ẋ + Qx + m(t) = 0 (36) The integration step of CDA and implicit trapezoidal method is

⎧

⎪ i − ik+1/2

⎨ g1 (G0 vk−1 + Cv̇k−1 ) + g2 (G0 vk + C0 v̇k ) + g1 (G0 vk+1 + C0 vk+1 ) = k−1/2 , k [ (1, N − 1)

Dz (33)

⎩ g1 (R0 ik−1/2 + L0 i̇k−1/2 ) + g2 (R0 ik+1/2 + L0 i̇k+1/2 ) + g1 (R0 ik+3/2 + L0 i̇k+3/2 ) = vk − vk+1 , k [ (1, N − 2)

⎪

Dz

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

3642 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016

Fig. 1 Piecewise model of transmission line

h = 10 μs, while the integration step of Radau IIA method is 2 s × 10 As has been stated previously, the circuit equations of boundary

μs. condition also should be listed besides the telegraph equation. In

Figs. 3 and 4 give out the results of terminal voltage calculated by this simulation, the inductance current iL is regarded as additional

Radau IIA method of s = 3 and s = 5, respectively, while Figs. 5 and state variable. The transmission line l12 and l34 are connected by

6 are the results calculated by CDA and implicit trapezoidal method. the non-linear resistance R(t). While, as R(t) varies with time, B

From Figs. 3–6, we can conﬁrm that Radau IIA method performs will also vary with time. In every integration step, we regard R(t)

more outstanding quality in numerical stability, which can make as constant since the integration step is quite small, thus the matrix

this EMT simulation free of numerical oscillation effectively. B in formula (10) would be constant for each integration step. The

Being different from that, the result calculated by CDA produces segment amount of l12 is N1 = 20, and l34 is N2 = 7. We choose the

‘ﬁctitious’ sustained numerical oscillation for not being able to integration step of CDA as h = 0.1 ns, and the integration step of

detect a sudden change of a variable. Besides, the result calculated s-stage Radau IIA method as 2 s × 0.1 ns.

by implicit trapezoidal method also produces numerical oscillation In this situation, we have calculated the voltage of point 4 by both

since this method is not L-stable. Since CDA is not able to detect multi-stage high-order Radau IIA method and CDA. Since the

sudden changes, the back Euler method has no effect on avoiding voltage increase gradually rather than abrupt at the initial stage,

numerical oscillation, and the result would be the same as implicit numerical oscillation would not happen by both these two

trapezoidal method as is shown in Figs. 5 and 6. methods. Figs. 8 and 9 are the computational results of this

simulation test calculated by both Radau IIA method (h3 = 0.6 ns,

h5 = 1.0 ns) and CDA (h = 0.1 ns), and the curve of difference

values by these two methods are also given. It is not hard to ﬁnd

4.2.2. Computational efﬁciency test: In this section, we that the results of these two methods are quite close and almost

simulate a situation when the disconnector of 550 kV gas insulated indistinguishable, though bigger integration step is selected by

switchgear (GIS) acts on the no-load bus. During this process, multi-stage high-order Radau IIA method. The maximum peak

very fast transient overvoltage (VFTO) is caused by slow contact value of over voltage by CDA is 1326.3 kV, and it appears at the

action and poor arc-extinguishing performance of switch. Fig. 7 is moment of t = 0.1207 μs; the maximum peak value of voltage by

a simulation test of VFTO. three-stage Radau method is 1325.8 kV, and it appears at the

In this test, U (t) is the AC power supply; LT and CT are the moment of t = 0.1206 μs; the maximum peak value of voltage by

additional lumped inductance and capacitance used for simulating ﬁve-stage Radau method is 1326.1 kV, and it appears at the

transformer and so on; DS is the disconnector to be operated, moment of t = 0.1209 μs.

which can be approximately represented as a non-linear resistance Deﬁne the ratio of computational time of CDA and high order

during the transient process Radau IIA method as speedup ratio, and it is clear that the higher

acceleration ratio means the quicker computational speed of Radau

R(t) = R1 e−t/t1 + R2 et/t2 (42) IIA method. Table 1 gives out the speedup ratios of high order

Radau IIA method compared with CDA for the situation above. It

where, R1 approximately represents the resistance of DS before is obvious that the Radau IIA method is of higher computational

breakdown and R1 = 1012 Ω; R2 is the resistance of DS during speed compared with CDA.

arcing time and R2 = 0.5 Ω; t1 is the time constant of breakdown Actually, since the implicit trapezoidal method has a second-order

period with t1 = 1 ns, while t2 is the time constant of arc accuracy, when the integration step of CDA is h, the local truncation

extinguishing period with t2 = 1 μs. Other parameters in this error of it will be O(h3 ); while the local truncation error of s-stage

simulation are L0 = 2.5 × 10−7 H/m, C0 = 4.45 × 10−11 F/m, LT = 20 (2s-1)-order Radau IIA method is about O(h2s s ) when its

mH, CT = 3000 pF, l12 = 10 m, and l34 = 3.5 m. At the initial integration step is hs. Therefore, when the computational accuracy

of these two methods is almost the same, namely, O(h2s s ) ≃ O(h ),

3

moment, DS was in a state of disconnection, and the voltage of

power side was 1.0 p.u. (449 kV). Besides, there was residual it can be derived that hs ≃ h . When the integration step of CDA

3/2s

voltage of load side with the value of −1.0 p.u. (−449 kV). In

EMT simulation, we usually use a lumped ground capacitance

with initial voltage to simulate the residual charge. Here, we place

this capacitance at point 3 with the value of 240 pF, i.e. CR = 240

pF, which is just the equivalent ground capacitance of disconnector.

Fig. 2 Simulation 1: a transmission line without load being switched-in Fig. 3 Terminal voltage of transmission line calculated by 3-stage Radau

suddenly IIA method

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 3643

Fig. 7 Simulation 2: a simpliﬁed GIS system for VFTO simulation

IIA method

10h. From this point of view, bigger integration step can be

adopted further when using high order Radau IIA method.

Furthermore, Figs. 10 and 11 are the computational results of this

simulation test calculated by both Radau IIA method (h3 = 1 ns, h5 =

1.5 ns) and CDA (h = 0.1 ns), and the difference values of these two

kinds of methods are also given. The maximum peak value of

voltage by 3-stage Radau method is 1326.1 kV, and it appears at

the moment of t = 0.1209 μs; the maximum peak value of voltage Fig. 9 Computational result of VFTO by 5-stage Radau IIA method

by 5-stage Radau method is 1325.6 kV, and it appears at the

moment of t = 0.121 μs. Although bigger integration step is used,

the results are still very close. On this basis, the multi-stage 4.3 Result analysis

high-order Radau IIA method can adopt more than 2s times

integration step as CDA, which will lead to its higher Firstly, in simulation 1, the result calculated by Radau IIA method is

computational efﬁciency. free of ‘ﬁctitious’ sustained numerical oscillation since this method

is both L-stable and non-linear B-stable. On the contrary, the

result calculated by CDA produces numerical oscillation for not

being able to detect sudden changes of voltage and current

transmitted by the distributed parameter line. Besides, the result

calculated by implicit trapezoidal method also produces numerical

oscillation since this method is not L-stable or B-stable.

Second, we have studied the computational efﬁciency of high

order Radau IIA in simulation 2. From Fig. 8, Fig. 9, and Table 1,

we can conﬁrm that when the results of Radau IIA method and

CDA are approximate, the high order Radau IIA method is of

faster computational speed compared with CDA. In additional,

when the s-stage Radau IIA method adopts larger than 2s times

CDA

Fig. 6 Terminal voltage of transmission line calculated by implicit acceleration ratio 1.9353 1.5328

trapezoidal method

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

3644 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016

high order Radau IIA method to acquire faster computational

speed in EMT simulations.

6 Acknowledgments

Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) through its grant no.

51377098.

7 References

Fig. 10 Computational result of VFTO by 3-stage Radau IIA method 1 Dommel, H.: ‘Electromagnetic transient program reference manual (EMTP theory

book)’ (BPA, Portland, Oregon, USA, 1986)

2 Watson, N., Irwin, G.: ‘Electromagnetic transient simulation of power systems

using root-matching techniques’, IET Proc. – Gener. Transm. Distrib., 1998,

145, (5), pp. 481–486

3 Mahseredjian, J., Dinavahi, V., Martinez, J.: ‘Simulation tools for electromagnetic

transients in power systems: overview and challenges’, IEEE Trans. Power Deliv.,

2009, 24, (3), pp. 1657–1669

4 Xue, H., Popov, M.: ‘Analysis of switching transient overvoltages in the power

system of ﬂoating production storage and ofﬂoading vessel’, Electr. Power Syst.

Res., 2014, 115, pp. 3–10

5 Wang, F.: ‘Numerical method for transient stability computation of large-scale

power system’ (Science Press, Beijing, China, 2013)

6 Marti, J., Lin, J.: ‘Suppression of numerical oscillations in the EMTP’, IEEE Power

Eng. Rev., 1989, 9, (5), pp. 71–72

7 Alvarado, F., Lasseter, R., Sanchez, J.: ‘Testing of trapezoidal integration with

damping for the solution of power transient problems’, IEEE Trans. Power

Appar. Syst., 1983, PAS-102, (12), pp. 3783–3790

8 Lin, J., Marti, J.: ‘Implementation of the CDA procedure in the EMTP’, IEEE

Trans. Power Syst., 1990, 5, (2), pp. 394–402

9 Balda, J., Olejniczak, K., Low, S.: ‘The Electromagnetic Transients Program

(EMTP) as an effective tool to evaluate active power ﬁlters for harmonic

Fig. 11 Computational result of VFTO by 5-stage Radau IIA method compensation’, Electr. Power Syst. Res., 1994, 30, (3), pp. 269–277

10 Fan, S., Ding, H.: ‘Time domain transformation method for accelerating EMTP

simulation of power system dynamics’, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 2012, 27, (27),

pp. 1778–1787

integration step as CDA, their results are also quite close. On this 11 Vilchis-Rodriguez, S., Acha, E.: ‘Nodal reduced induction machine modeling for

basis, the high order Radau IIA method can improve EMTP-type simulations’, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 2012, 27, (3), pp. 1158–1169

computational efﬁciency further by adopting bigger integration step. 12 Noda, T., Takenaka, K., Inoue, T.: ‘Numerical integration by the 2-stage diagonally

implicit Runge-Kutta method for electromagnetic transient simulations’, IEEE

Trans. Power Deliv., 2009, 24, (1), pp. 390–399

13 Mahseredjian, J., Dube, L., Zou, M., Dennetiere, S., Joos, G.: ‘Simultaneous

5 Conclusions solution of control system equations in EMTP’, IEEE Trans. Power Syst., 2006,

21, (1), pp. 117–124

In this paper, with the help of V-transformation feature of the high 14 Qin, M., Zhu, W.: ‘Construction of higher order symplectic schemes by

composition’, Computing, 1992, 47, (47), pp. 309–321

order Radau IIA method, a kind of multi-stage block recursive 15 Butcher, J.: ‘Diagonally implicit multisage integration methods’, Appl. Numer.

method has been proposed for EMT simulation in power system. Math., 1993, 11, (3), pp. 347–363

As has been analysed previously, the following conclusions can be 16 Farhan, M., Gad, E., Nakhla, M., et al.: ‘New method for fast transient simulation

made. of large linear circuits using high-order stable methods’, IEEE Trans. Compon.

Packag. Manuf. Technol., 2013, 3, (4), pp. 661–669

17 Butcher, J.: ‘Coefﬁcient for the study of Runge-Kutta integration process’, Aust.

(i) Because the Radau IIA method is both L-stable and non-linear Math. Soc., 1963, 3, (2), pp. 185–201

B-stable, the numerical oscillation can be avoided effectively 18 Butcher, J.: ‘The numerical analysis of ordinary differential equations’ (Jone Wiley

& Sons Ltd., New York, 1987)

without any extra detection for sudden changes of variables, which 19 Hairer, E., Wanner, G.: ‘Solving ordinary differential equation II: stiff and

is quite different from traditional numerical integration algorithm. differential- algebraic problems’ (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1991)

(ii) Taking advantage of the important V-transformation feature of 20 Wang, F., Liao, X., Xie, X.: ‘Stability analysis and order improvement for time

high order Radau IIA method, the discrete high-dimension domain differential quadrature method’, Adv. Appl. Math. Mech., 2016, 8, (1),

pp. 128–144

algebraic equation used for solving differential equation can be 21 Cangellaris, A., Pasha, S., Prince, J., et al.: ‘A new discrete transmission line model

decoupled into blocks, thus the multi-stage block recursive method for passive model order reduction and macromodeling of high-speed

can be formed. In this way, we can adopt larger integration step of interconnections’, IEEE Trans. Adv. Packag., 1999, 22, (3), pp. 356–364

IET Gener. Transm. Distrib., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 14, pp. 3639–3645

& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 3645

- Nth UE Selection Algorithm ModificationDiunggah olehKUnal
- OR ASGMT 236Diunggah olehPuja Sharma
- age probDiunggah olehJC Tolentino
- dDiunggah olehNitesh Agarwal
- webquest rubricDiunggah olehapi-337402661
- Model Predictive Control of Van de Vusse ReactorDiunggah olehSatyajeet Bhonsale
- Modelo de FisherDiunggah olehEdson Arturo Quispe Sánchez
- MainDiunggah olehmohammedtaskeen9898
- 2stepsDiunggah olehapi-310503032
- Artificial Intelligence in MISDiunggah olehVidushi Rastogi
- Algorithm(3)Diunggah olehlashiya
- Supper Clocks Presentation Aos 5Diunggah olehBoon Bordoloi
- 1Diunggah olehkannanchammy
- 10309779.xlsxDiunggah olehMikey Panya Wazimu
- Full Text 01Diunggah olehandy2011p
- 05-A Efremov DGLR Manching 081112Diunggah olehMartin Schweighart Moya
- Paper 2 SolutionDiunggah olehFeng Zhaolun
- Hardy Cr 327Diunggah olehMartin Darmasetiawan
- DistributionsDiunggah olehsrinu27
- Some Problems of aiDiunggah olehShrangi Tandon
- 8 Maths NCERT Chapter 2 Split 10Diunggah olehLokendra
- Differentiation Dominoes 3 – Chain, Product and Quotient RulesDiunggah olehStella Seremetaki Pure Mathematician
- modeling utah population dataDiunggah olehapi-268294441
- computer lab for pdc( chemical engineering)Diunggah olehHelena Francis
- tvpp lab3Diunggah olehIrina Ungureanu
- 3429ibt Jalandhar Schedule 28 April- 03 May 14Diunggah olehSushant Sharma
- Input Output ControllabilityDiunggah olehZulfansyah Muchtar
- ijaerDiunggah olehAnonymous WtjVcZCg
- hw4solDiunggah olehJuan Carlos Chávez Cruz
- Energy Conversion and ManagementDiunggah olehKarthik Nagarajan

- 00973798Diunggah olehDebojyoti Mukherjee
- Seminar on Characteritics of Dielectric & Polarization InDiunggah olehrakesh das
- Hvdc TransmissionDiunggah olehrakesh das
- Sources of Over Voltages goodDiunggah olehqais652002
- Dissolved Gas AnalysisDiunggah olehrakesh das
- 1-s2.0-S0141391011002424-mainDiunggah olehrakesh das
- 1-s2.0-S037704279900134X-main.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- havriliak1967.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- Akd Thesis (Repaired)Diunggah olehrakesh das
- SECE411_04_OvervoltagesDiunggah olehreh223
- A New Algorithm for Wire Fault Location UsingDiunggah olehrakesh das
- dielctrics.pdfDiunggah olehBHARATH KUMAR REDDY.Y
- 39efb3783116b8305f0bb7eedaad72fb3553Diunggah olehademarrohregger
- 2012 Modeling of Partial Discharge Mechanisms in Solid Dielectric Material HV3Diunggah olehrakesh das
- 2018EEConConditionMonitoringSystemforOutdoorInsulators.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- 2015-07-16_M-M-HussainDiunggah olehrakesh das
- MeasurementofLeakageCurrentforMonitoringthePerformanceofOutdoorInsulators2012Diunggah olehrakesh das
- Walu Yo 2006Diunggah olehrakesh das
- PE-38Diunggah olehrakesh das
- p68Diunggah olehrakesh das
- docs-179627632350fcf7c4a7b9c.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- docs-17922250284b44498900d74Diunggah olehjyothi_n_2
- energies-10-01661Diunggah olehrakesh das
- 05254748Diunggah olehrakesh das
- 05252488.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- 04062725.pdfDiunggah olehrakesh das
- 08 Chapter 3Diunggah olehrakesh das

- noah merksamer resumeDiunggah olehapi-404421746
- Chapter 07 Equations and Logarithms.pdfDiunggah olehHelloPirr
- United States v. Carl Simon, Robert Kaiser and Melvin Fishman, and Harold Roth, Irving L. Wharton, 373 F.2d 649, 2d Cir. (1967)Diunggah olehScribd Government Docs
- lesson 2Diunggah olehapi-324016785
- OM Test Bank _Chapte3Diunggah olehHossam Shemait
- Katya YaniDiunggah olehsharathVEM
- Studi Evaluasi Data Logging Dan SifatDiunggah olehFaishal Mahdy
- Summit Pointe 2014 vendorsDiunggah olehJennifer Bowman
- hearts on a wire newsletter 21Diunggah olehHearts on a Wire
- A Dictionary of the Ugaritic Language in the Alphabetic Tradition by GREGORIO DEL OLMO LETE AND JOAQUÍN SAN MARTÍN Translated by Wilfred G. E. WatsonDiunggah olehAdyghe Tamar Chabadi
- Kent Berghuis-Christian Fasting-A Theological Approach,2002,p265Diunggah olehYooxanaa Ali
- Guide-to-German-culture_-costums-and-etiquette.pdfDiunggah olehAW Africa Wild
- 1800 TOEFL Essential VocabularyDiunggah olehlilcactus
- Exercises - Simple Past 1 (1)Diunggah olehmarcoscat1
- boy scouts caseDiunggah olehMax Deng
- About the BibleDiunggah olehkyron
- Case Study Handbook 2013Diunggah olehPablo Cardona
- BP080 Future Process AWCCS Inventroy V2.2Diunggah olehraman_200
- conversation-corner-where-in-the-world-6-landmarks-fun-activities-games_5747.docDiunggah olehkatzemau
- United States v. Darwin Cue, 4th Cir. (2011)Diunggah olehScribd Government Docs
- Legacy of Hrant Dink - BrochureDiunggah olehfriendsofhrantdink
- Sacrifice of Hinduism and ChristDiunggah olehgobitristen
- COLREGS 72 Amended to 03 (2)Diunggah olehAghie Mubarack
- Emcee ScriptDiunggah olehMay Joie Jayme Alcaraz
- Mcq's With Key Surgery - bDiunggah olehSiraj Ul Islam
- OET Writing TipsDiunggah olehLinguasoft123
- 12 Chapter 1Diunggah olehJJMuthukattil
- IA for Condonation of DelayDiunggah olehBar & Bench
- SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION.docxDiunggah olehCrystal Biru
- bladder cancerDiunggah olehCrystal Leigh Malunes Dagting

## Lebih dari sekadar dokumen.

Temukan segala yang ditawarkan Scribd, termasuk buku dan buku audio dari penerbit-penerbit terkemuka.

Batalkan kapan saja.