Three stereo miking secrets guaranteed to make your acoustic guitar tracks shine
Ask five engineers how they approach recording acoustic guitar, and you may very well get five
different answers, if you get any at all, that is. While many factors influence an engineer's
choice of recording techniques -- the character of the instrument, the style of music, the
player's personal tonal and dynamic signature, and the recording environment -- some
engineers prefer to keep their approaches a trade secret. But despite all the possible
permutations of instrument, style, player, room, and ego, for most seasoned engineers the real
secret to recording an acoustic guitar is stereo miking -- plain and simple.
Sure, if it's just "spaciousness" you're after, you could record an acoustic guitar in mono and
fold in some enthusiastic stereo processing. Or if you're hankering for a dramatically textured
sound, you could try combining a microphone with an acoustic guitar pickup. If depth and
accuracy are what matter most, however, you'll find that stereo recording with two
microphones is an exceptionally reliable way to record full-bodied, realistic-sounding acoustic
guitar tracks.
Let's take a look at three of the most popular techniques, and also examine the questions of
microphone choice and mono-compatibility. As you'll find, stereo recording can be a complex
art, since the interaction between the two mics will determine many aspects of the sound --
including tone, image, and mono-compatibility. But like any art, you'll also find that practice
makes perfect. So whip out those mics, pull out that guitar, and give these tips a try: You'll hear
the difference.
Two mics are placed apart from each other at the same approximate height, one pointing at the
12th fret of the guitar and the other at the bridge.
With this approach -- as with any miking technique that uses two or more mics that are spaced
apart from one another -- always be sure to follow the "3-to-1 rule." According to this rule, the
distance between two mics should be at least three times the distance between each mic and
the sound source. This keeps phase cancellations to a minimum, resulting in a smoother sound
that also translates well to mono. So, for instance, if you've got each mic seven inches from the
guitar, the 3-to-1 rule mandates that you spread the two mics at least 21 inches apart from
each other. (One of a few exceptions to the 3-to-1 rule is with the X-Y technique, as described
below.)
Spaced Pair, Version B
Our second technique is a variation on the spaced pair. As in the setup above, one mic points
to the 12th fret. The second mic, however, is hung from a mic stand at the performer's ear
level, pointing down at either the bridge or at the strings just behind the soundhole. For
example, if the performer is right-handed, this second mic would be placed over her right
shoulder. (Once again, be sure to follow the 3-to-1 rule.)
You can also move this ear-level mic slightly out in front of the performer and angle it back
towards the guitar (versus pointing straight down at the floor), for a brighter sound. This
technique usually yields a more open -- but thinner -- sound than the simple spaced pair on a
horizontal plane. Check out the links to hear the difference.
If you're not getting the sound you want with a spaced pair placement, try moving one or both
microphones slightly to improve the timbre. Because spaced pair placement is subject to phase
interference, moving one mic only an inch or two can dramatically change the sound. To learn
more about how phase affects the timbre of stereo guitar tracks, go to the mono-compatibility
link below.
The X-Y Technique
X-Y, or coincident-pair, is the no-brainer approach to stereo miking. If you follow these steps
precisely, and are willing to move the mics around a bit to find the sweet spot, you'll find it's
hard to make a bad recording. (That's assuming, of course, that your room, your mics, and the
instrument -- and, while we're making a checklist, the guitarist -- are half-way decent.)
Place the two mics close together so that their capsules are almost touching. The rear ends of
each mic are spread apart at an angle of a roughly 90 to 120 degrees. The result looks like a
wide V shape, with one mic's capsule positioned directly above the other.
(The 3-to-1 rule doesn't apply to the X-Y technique because the two capsules are so close that
sound waves arrive at both at essentially the same time, minimizing objectionable phase
cancellations.)
To start, try placing the two mics opposite the 12th fret of the guitar. If you have a really nice
sounding room to record in, try backing the mics up to a distance of one to two feet from the
guitar. This will capture more room tone and yield a more natural sound. While the
best-sounding position can depend upon the guitar, the room, or the mics, typically, placing the
mics around seven inches in front of the guitar's 12th fret will tend to de-emphasize midrange
frequencies. That's because one mic will be pointing in the direction of the bassy soundhole,
and the other towards the top of the neck, an area rich in high frequencies.
As you experiment, you'll find that the X-Y miking produces a much narrower stereo image than
the spaced-pair techniques. But you'll also hear how X-Y lends a smoother, warmer, and more
natural sound to acoustic guitar.