INTRODUCTION
activities for human lifes to interact and show theirs feelings or ideas. Human
languages produce a message which has thought, suggestion, idea, comment and
commerce, business, trade and education. In English language skills, there are
fours skills to be mastered. They are Listening, Reading, Speaking, and Writing.
Writing is the last part of the language skills beside listening, speaking and
reading, must be taught maximally by the teacher to the student. Students must
convey their feelings, thought, and ideas to communicate each other. So, it
with others. Therefore, English must be taught and learnt at school as academic
Writing is one of language skills aspect that has activities in written form
1
2
their ideas perfectly and understanding able to catch the meaning it.Writing is an
product. According to Nunan state that writing is the process of thinking to invent
ideas, thinking about how to express into good writing, and arranging the ideas
Schools it is mentioned that students are quire to be able write some kind of genre
in writing, they are narrative, recount, procedure, and descriptive text. Based on
the explanation above, the narrative text is one of writing genre that must be
mastered by students in learning English. However, not all students were able to
write narrative text properly and know about understanding in the narrative text.
The result of the pre-observation which had been conducted in SMP Amal
Luhur Medan found that students have some difficulties to write a narrative text.
how to make a text especially in narrative text. It causes they difficult to convey
their ideas in writing and don’t have enough basic knowledge such lacks of
vocabularies and tense. Many students have lack of interest and motivation in
writing narrative text. Lacking of media learning is one of factors the students
seemed boring and it made them could not develop their knowledge and ability to
techniques. Through that way, the students will be interested in studying English.
grades. The teachers should be able to use some media of teaching. Media is a tool
for teaching and learning process. Media in language teaching can be classified
into three groups, they are: audio visual, visual, and audio. According to
Shabiralyani et.al state that media visual aids are those devices which are used in
interesting.2
There are several kinds of media visual aids, one of them which is comic
strip. Manga comic strips is interesting media used in Englsih learning process to
necessary to have an interesting, easy to understand, students get actives, and not
boring media that can foster their creative ideas in learning process. Through
manga comic strips in English subject make studentsfeel something new and
skills inwriting narrative text of the eighth grade students in SMP Amal Luhur
Medan. Manga Strips were chosen because manga is popular comic japan among
young, which contain some pictures and some dialogues which are put into
several panels, so that the picture can stimulate the students’ interest and find out
the ideas and inspiration about what they are going to write easily.
identified as follows:
1. Students still confused and don’t understand how to make a text especially in
narrative text.
3. Lacking of media learning is one of factors the students seemed boring and it
made them could not develop their knowledge and ability to learn English
within limited in the study. The research is only focus on specific one that is
improving students’ skills in writing narrative text through manga strips at grade
Based on what has been mentioned earlier in the identification of the study
5
1. How can Manga Strip get able to improve students skills in writing narattive
text of the eight grade students of SMP Amal Luhur Medan in the academic
year 2018/2019?
2. How does the Manga Strips improve students skills in writing recount text of
the eighth grade students of SMP Amal Luhur Medan in the academic year
2018/2019?
The objective of the study based on the formulation of the study as follow:
1. To find out the improvement of Manga strip towards students skill in writing
narrative text at grade VIII SMP Amal Luhur Medan in academic 2018/2019.
2. To know Manga strip improve students skills in writing narrative text at grade
The findings of this study are expected to be useful theoretical and practical
perspectives:
1. Theoretically
The result of this study can be useful information to support the way of
2. Practically
a. For the students, this study can be useful for students in learning English
6
to improve their writing skills and can make them understand well in how
learning writing and to find the most appropriate for improving student’s
c. For other researchers, the result of this study will present useful
LITERATURE REVIEW
A. Theoritical Review
a. Definition of Writing
way of study. There is verse that state the existence of writing that be stated in Al-
Reviewed from the content of the verse has the meaning that ﷲSWT
swears two things namelypen and what is written. This verse explains that
encouraging people to learn and write. The sheets do not work if they are not
This verse explains that writing is important. In learning from early age
to adulthood requires writing and in small to large business writing must also
tool.
encourage people to learn and bind the knowledge in writing starting from small
and large things. Writing requires knowledge and processes such as the use of
product. It means that writing takes study and practice to develop it, not only
stuck in a one stop action, and must be produce creative act, it is always possible
to be reviewed and revised many times. According to Brown said that writing skill
make a best product, started consider some aspect content and organization to
In addition, Harmer statethat writing is the only skill that can produce a
real product that canbe touched, be read, and can be kept for long time.5 In
for readers.
and means used to communication in writen text. As stated by Nunan defines that
how to express and organize them into statements andparagraphs that enable a
1) Permanence
When written down and delivered are final to intended audience, most
2) Production time
3) Distance
4) Orthography
moreover are non native language, students must be reading and writing first
5) Complexity
6) Vocabulary
writers have to learn English vocabulary to produce wirtten text more the
richness.
7) Formality
For students, the most difficult and complex conventios occur rules of wiritng
language.
micro skills and macro skill writing. According to Brown state that has several
1) Microskill
patterns.
2) Macroskill
text.
with fluency in the first drafts, using paraphrases and synonyms, soliciting
peer and instructor feedback, and using feedback for revising and editing.
In conclusion the microskill focus on the writing mechanical apply and the
pattern of word, such as cohesive devices, tenses, etc. Meanwhile the macroskill
12
covers wider of writing areas, more mastery in responsive ans extensive writing
such as use rhetorical forms, the communicative functions as connect as forms and
purpose, the main idea, the supporting idea of a text, information, generalization,
the literal and implied meaning writing, references, and writing strategies.
Therefore, based on the micro and macro skills had determined, writing
for students needed to construct their ideas effectively and making easier to guide
d. Writing Process
1) Planning
write. It stimulates thoughts for getting started idea through using kinds of
2) Drafting
The students can focused fluency of writing and not preoccupied with
3) Revising
The students can revise and reexamine their texts to know how effectively the
content have communicated with meaning to the reader. Revising is not only
checking for language errors. It is done to improve global content and the
organisation of ideas so that the students’ intent is made clearer to the reader.
4) Editing
Students can prepare the final draft for evaluation by teacher. This stage their
final draft should be edit for some aspect errors such grammar, spelling,
material.
The students are not always to expected to know where their work errors
or how to know what are mistakes and correct, but editing is process of writing to
According to Harmer state that the task of teacher writing proposes had
done before, during and after the process of writing they are (1) demonstrating,
(2) motivating and provoking, (3) supporting, (4) responding and (5) evaluating.10
genre constraits in specific types of writing, in here teachers have to able to draw
motivating and provoking. In motivation and provoking, where the teacher can
help by provoking the studenst into having ideas, enthuasing them with the value
of the task, and persuading them what fun it can be. For several students writing
is big problem, because there isn’t motivation into theirselves do writing, and
students writers often find ‘lost for words’ epecially in creative writing task. This
situation can be solved with teacher asking to students and walk around calss with
prepared suggestions and when students get stuck they can immediately get help
supporting. Students need a lot of help and reassurance once with the means to
carry them out. Teachers extremely supportive when students are writing in the
process always available. Otherwise, students sometimes face bored and lacking
motivation in the process of writing. In this situation, the teacher must be ready to
take a amusing and engaging ways to getting students be interest and comfortable
After the students finished task of writing, the teacher performed of four
task is responding. In responding, the teacher react to how students’ writing work.
Have a completly the task , the teacher evaluating students’ work, telling
them how well they are, to know what standart they have reached. It can be
students writing mistakes, what they wrote well, errors of writing, and grades
a. Teaching Writing
and the vocabulary choices, syntactic patterns, and cohesive devices that
This focus has an important principle here is to relate structures meanings, and
paragraphs.
This focus here explained that writing is a way of sharing personal meanings
and writing courses emphasize the power of the individual to construct his or
her own views on a topic. This can help generate self-awareness of the writer’s
This focus explained that the writer as an independent producer of texts has
intoduces can be reviewed, evaluated, and revised, even before any text has
been produced at all, but it goes further to address the issue of what teachers
5) Focus on Content
content: what students are required to write about. The students get select a set
of topic or themes of interest that establish a coherence and and purpose for
the course or that set out the sequence of key areas of subject matter that
This focus has orientation that context of writing instruction consider subject
occur towards students in the class had impact to teacher teach. Therefore, the
of writing. According to Brown stated that there are some principles for designing
The goal writing for writers do is technique to writing practice. Good writers
must focus on a main idea in writing, know gauge his orh her audience, spend
quality planning to write, easily let his or her first ideas flow onto paper,
needed.
Teacher must be using a familiar English language to teach for students as non
native, try to help students to understand, and bring them to the use acceptable
English.
get learnt variaety types of text, can know important insight how they should
Sharing writing with other students in the class is one way to add authenticity.
Writing for display is authentic to get clear of audience convey the meaning.
instructor question and probes, and freewriting. In drfating and revising are
stated that capture and range about writing production are considered. Each
category resembles the categories defined for the other three skills, but these
1) Imitative
The students must know a basic of writing concept such letters, words,
2) Intensive (controlled)
The students next with context are fundamentals of imitative writing skills
writing skills.
3) Responsive.
In here, the students require learned a perform context writing level, such
make a outline and some genres of writing like brief narratives and
descriptions, short reports, lab reports, and etc. The students also mastered of
4) Extensive.
The students will be into aextensive writing or high level implies to make a
context of writing more successful. In here students can write for all purposes
students are asked to write. Acording to Harmer stated that the teacher has the
1) Motivator
The teacher has principal roles that is motivate the students when they do
writing task. The teacher can motivated to them that creating, generating,
much efforts as posiible for maximum benefit in writing activity. The teacher
also get buildto students perception that learn writing are easily and enjoying.
2) Resource
give to the students need. The teacher should ensure to tell students that
teachers are available and ready to look at their works as advising to students.
3) Feedback provide
are fours reasons for teaching writing to students of English as a foreign language
a) Refinforcement
Students more acquire languages in a purely oral, but most of them more
language needed construct students understanding how it all fits and aid to
b) Language development
The actual process of writing can help the students learn through construct
c) Language style
Many students need time to think to produce language, it may take a little
language.
d) Writing as a skill
The important of reason for teaching writing is basic language skills besides
writing. students need to know how to write letters, put written reports, reply
advertisement, write using electronic media, and know some writing’s special
conventions.
writing must to convey. Teacher needs helping students to have a confident selves
Speaking Countries who cannot write well. So, teachers should be preparing
1) focus on the process of writing that leads to the final written products
rewriting
6) give students feedback throughout the composing process (not just on the final
product) as they attempt to bring their expression closer and closer to intention
7) include individual conferences between teacher and student during the process
of composition.
teacher and students intensively needed. Media is visual aids which is can brought
students interest into the classroom for teachers help to do his or her job better.
According to Donn stated that visual aids has various media to teach in the
classroom, divided into such groups as wall charts, book illustration, realia
16Brown, H.D. (2001). Teaching by Principles: An Interactive Approach Language
Pedagogy 2nd Edition. New York: Pearson Education.
22
There are at least three functions that move together in existence media18.
1) Stimulation function
interest to learn and find out more everything that is on the media.
2) Mediation of function
a) Information function
teacher wants to convey. These cassifications are natural and often helpful,
media visual aids, that is comic strip of classifying visual aids which may
b) Manga Strip
among young adults in Asian, America, and Europe. Manga were directly
has impact to share elements of Japanese popular culture which has been
series and able to printed several hunderd pages long include many topic
of story inside.
horror, romance, humor, science fiction and non-fictional genres such as essay,
biography, journalism, and so on.19 Manga has many characters, topic, subject,
and costums. The target of manga readers usually classyfing by age range and
backgrounds.
potential material in teaching process in generating ideas and finding words for
theirs writing narrative text.Manga strip can stimulate students ideas to create a
inspiration about what they are going to write. Manga strip more popular and
3. Narrative Texts
that exactly to tell the activities or events in the past, that show problematic
experience and resolution means to amuse oftentimes meant to give moral lesson
to the readers.20 Narrative is the most common of writing because the writer just
tells his/her story without any purposes. Narrative places acts in times and tells
According to Knapp and Watkins stated that there are General Elements of
2) Plot is a meaningful and dramatic series of events that form the story.
3) Characterization is the way the writers make and describes all characters in the
5) Setting is the information about when and where the events of the story take
place.
6) Point of view is the way of establishing the person and position of the writers.
If the writers uses “I” and “We” it means that the writer writesin the person
point of view, while the uses “He” and “She” it means that the writer in the
1) Abstract
story is about to be told and establishes the point of the text. so abstract is
2) Orientation
The purpose of orientation is to orient the listener with respect to place, time
3) Complication
4) Evaluation
The purpose of evaluation is to reveal the attitude of the narrator towards the
narrative.
5) Resolution
22Ibid.p.104
26
process.
B. Previous Study
and subject of the research consist of 26 students. The study showed that
Moreover, using manga strips in apply teaching learning the students also
students’ writing recount text can be seen from the improvement of the
mean score of pre-test, first post-test and second post-test. The pre-test
mean score was 53.92 increasing to 61.80 in the first post-test and
increasing to 65.16 in the final pos-test.The collecting data using test and
observations .The result of research state in Cycle I got 73% and Cycle II
got 92.3%.
Writing Ability In SMP Negeri 1 Pandak. The study showed that there was
could generate ideas easily and they could write narrative texts in the
correct form. The subjects of the research were26 students of VIII G class.
interviews, while the quantitative data were gained from tests.There were
two tests in this research namely Pre-test and Post-test.The result of the
to the students’ narrative writing ability. The students’mean score was 1.5
Pre-test, while in the Post-test, the students’ mean score was 3.192
C. Conceptual Framework
writing skill is still far from being satisfactory. These problems happen cause most
towards those problems. Based on previous study by used Manga strip can
manga strip student writing will be interesed, and the material focused to generate
ideas what they write. Manga strip conduct to students stimulate more active and
Then within using Manga strip in writing narrative text it will be break of
strip is a way of learning process which make students participately explore ideas
Beside it, Manga strip can be used to improve students language use, and
29
vocabulary. They can take and choice words it more acceptable to fulfill according
them. In this stage, grammar also being exercise to encourage students writing
learning processto solving include all of those problems. This is kind of effective
D. Hypothesis
the hypothesis in this research is: “The implementation of Manga strips can
improve students skills in writing narrative text of eight grade school at SMP
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
A. Types of Research
This study is classified into action research. According to Burns states that
situation that undertaken by partipants who the teacher as researcher to see gaps
improvement in practice.24
This research was supported by quantitative data and qualitative data. The
quantitaive data were through gained by a test. Meanwhile, the qualitative data
Grade VIII at SMP Amal Luhur Medan in the academic 2018/2019 by Manga
Strip.
This action research was located in SMP Amal Luhur Medan. The reseacrh
was conducted in Class VIII 1 SMP Amal Luhur Medan in the second semester
academic year of 2018/2019 of .The action was conducted from March until April
2019. The reseacrher carried out the actions based on the school schedule,
especially the English schedule of VIII 1 class of SMP Amal Luhur Medan.
C. Subject of Reseacrh
The subject of the research was the eight grade students of SMP Amal
D. Procedure of Research
following chart:
1. Cyle I
25Ibid.p.8
32
The procedure of action research in the first cycle are shown as follows:
a. Planning
In this phase, the problems had been identify and refers to solve
problems. In this phase, everything needed was prepared related to the action
b. Action
The planning was systematically arrenged and next to in the action play.
researcher. The action was conducted flexibly to see the possible changes
1) Pre Activity
by: 1) the teacher greets students with a tone of enthusiasm and joy
c) The teacher conveys the learning objectives that will be achieved after
students learn the learning material that will be taught by the teacher.
33
2) Main Activity
a) Before the teacher explains the material to be taught, the teacher gives
4-5 students.
b) The teacher explains and tells the Manga strip media to students.
d) The teacher explains and discusses narrative text material using Manga
learning material.
f) The teacher assigns the task of identifying the generic structure and
write narrative text to each student in the group to discuss with the
group.
h) The teacher asks one of the students to read the results of the narrative
text material.
3) Closing Activity
a) The teacher and students together conclude the subject matter that has
been learned.
At the end of this action a learning outcome test is carried out to determine
34
the extent to which students' ability to understand the material that has been
taught after students are given the action of learning using the Manga strip
media.
c. Observation
learning action steps taken during the teaching and learning activities. The
observation aims to determine the suitability of the action with the plan
that has been prepared and to determine the extent to which the action can
produce changes that are in accordance with the desired. This observation
have been carried out in accordance with the plans that have been
prepared.
d. Reflection
the research. The successful actions then were continued in the teaching
Manga strip media in Narrative texts material. The researcher do collecting data
1. Observation
activities and changes that occur at the time of action. Observations sheet
carried out in the form of observing all the teaching learning process activities
and aims to determine the changes that occur during the action.
2. Test
study, pre-test and post-test were used as research instruments to determine the
3. Interview
using guided interview to bring out the complete and detailed questions that
According to Hughes stated that there are five points for assessment writing,
they are:
or word order.
5 Some errors of grammar or word order
comprehension.
4 Errors of grammar of word order fairly
interpretation
1 Errors of grammar or word order so severe
as to make comprehension
virtually impossible.
Score Level Criteria
Vocabulary 6 The use of vocabulary and idiom is
interpretation
1 Vocabulary limitations so extreme as to
punctuation or spelling.
5 Occasional lapses in punctuation or
with comprehension.
4 Errors in punctuation or spelling fairly
consistently appropriate.
5 Occasional lack of consistency in choice
communication.
4 Patchy with some structures or vocabulary
style.
3 Structures and vocabulary items
communication
2 Communication often impaired by
impossible.
Score Level Criteria
Form 6 Highly organized; clear progression of
ideas well-linked.
5 Material well-organized; links could
not impaired.
4 Some lack of organization; re-reading
them.
1 Lack of organization so severe that
and quantitative data. According to Koshy stated that quantitative data can be
of data – for example a large number of questionnaires, surveys, tests results. But
descriptions and documents for analysis.30 The quantitative data result will be
R
P= × 100
T
Where:
for seeing result of the mean of students score the researcher using a formula:
X = Ʃx
N
Learning, Vol.2.
PearsonEducation Ltd
CambridgeUniversity Press.
University Press
42
Knapp and Watkin. 2005, Genre, Text, Grammar: Technologies for Teaching and
Nunan, D. 2003. Practical English Language Teaching. New York: The McGraw
Hill.
Oshima and Hogue, 2007, Introduction Writing Academic (3rd.ed). United State
Valsa Koshy. 2005. Action Research for Improving Practice A Practical Guide.