Anda di halaman 1dari 13

Application of the Occupational Therapy Practice Framework and

Evidence-based Practice in a Clinical Situation

Joseph K. Wells
BOT (India), OTD (USA), OTR/L (USA) AmeriCare Health Services, LLC, USA

Abstract her physician.


Occupational Therapy has a unique focus on The Domain and Process of Occupational
human functioning and views human function Therapy Applied to My Client
not merely as a physiological/ physically The practice of occupational therapy is guided
observable occurrence. It also acknowledges by core concepts and constructs. These
function as the resultant of interactions of several constitute the ‘domain’ of the profession.
internal factors present within the person, and American Occupational Therapy Association
external factors such as the environment and (AOTA) states, “The domain frames the arena
socio-cultural constructs. In 2002, the American in which occupational therapy evaluations and
Occupational Therapy Association published a interventions occur” (2002, pp. 609- 610) 1 . The
document called the Occupational Therapy occupational therapy service delivery process
Practice Framework: Domain and Process. It includes evaluation, intervention and outcomes.
detailed the profession’s unique focus on human
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

occupation as it relates to all activities of daily As discussed below, we applied the


living and its core values, beliefs and processes Occupational Therapy Practice Framework:
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

to facilitate optimal human occupation. This Domain and Process (AOTA, 2002) 1 to the
www.IndianJournals.com

article explores the applicability of the clinical scenario through the various stages of
Occupational Therapy Practice Framework and the service delivery process. We will refer to this
principles of evidence-based practice in a clinical document as the ‘Framework’ for future
scenario. Although, the article is based against discussions.
the backdrop of the United States healthcare The Evaluation
system (only as applied to insurance policies and The process begins with the evaluation of
payment for services), one may easily generalize needs, problems, and concerns. It is aimed at
the applicability of the Occupational Therapy generating an occupational profile based upon
Practice Framework, and evidenced-based the client’s history, experiences, patterns of daily
principles in their practice globally. living, interests, values and needs and, the
Keywords inability/ difficulties to perform in appropriate
Occupational Therapy, Practice Framework, occupational roles as desired and/or applicable
Evidence-based Practice to the client as identified via an analysis of
occupational performance. The analysis looks at
The Clinical Scenario factors effecting occupational functioning
The client is a white, 67-year-old female, who (AOTA, 2002). 1
suffered an ischemic cerebro-vascular accident On the day of admission to the swing-bed
(CVA) due to left middle cerebral artery facility, the client was first seen in her room for
blockage. Medical history was significant for an occupational therapy initial evaluation. The
diabetes and hypertension. She was admitted evaluation focused on developing an
to the swing bed facility from the hospital with occupational profile of the client, analyzed her
a request for occupational therapy consult from ability to function in her occupational role based
Reprint requests : Joseph K. Wells upon the stage of her life span (age) and socio-
President, AmeriCare Health Services, LLC cultural construct (gender, familial, societal roles)
1132 E. Second Street, Defiance, OH 43512. at baseline, and identified her needs, problems
Fax: (419) 782 0105. and priorities for intervention as defined by the
E-Mail: joewells@americare-health.com scope of the profession (AOTA, 2004) 2 . The

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 1
initial evaluation was coded as 97003 per the individually tested and verified. A study by
common procedural terminology (CPT TM ) codes Mathiowetz, Weber, Volland and Kashman
(American Medical Association [AMA], 2004)3 . (1984) 6 demonstrated adequate reliability and
CPT codes are used to depict interventions/ validity of grip and pinch strength evaluations.
procedures by healthcare providers. These are Studies by Bogle Thorbahn and Newton (1996)
7
coded numerically (example: 97003 for OT initial ; Riddle & Stratford (1999) 8 ; and Shumway-
evaluation) or may have numbers in association Cook, Baldwin , Plissar and Gueber (1997)9 have
with letters (example: G0283 for manual found the BBT to be a valid test to determine
electrical stimulation). CPT codes are used risk for falls.
specifically to bill certain insurance companies While the initial assessment based on UT III
including the United States government run discussed above was more a tool of observance
policy commonly called Medicare. by the evaluating therapist on how the client
Re-evaluations were technically carried-out was performing, I chose the COPM to rate the
with each subsequent visit in order to monitor client’s self- perceived baseline status and future
progress and response to the intervention/s, and changes in occupational performance and
to determine the need for future modifications satisfaction on her status. The assessment based
and interventions in the intervention/s. on UT III provides clinicians the basis to
The evaluation tools I used included a general understand the relationships between the
formatted assessment geared toward clients person’s development structure and the
with adult- neurological conditions, and the occupational form in which the person finds
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

Canadian Occupational Performance Measure himself or herself (Nelson & Jepson-Thomas,


(COPM) scale. The COPM is based on the 2003, p. 100) 10 . This assessment involves items
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

definition of occupational performance as given that often apply population-based standards in


www.IndianJournals.com

in Enabling Occupation: an Occupational performance such as grip strength by a hand


Therapy Perspective (Canadian Association of dynamometer or a 9-hole peg test for hand
Occupational Therapists [CAOT], 1997) 4 . The dexterity. In contrast, the COPM describes
initial evaluation for adult- neurological occupational performance as an individual
conditions comprised several standardized and subjective experience. The COPM has exhibited
non-standardized tests mainly based on the a test-retest reliability of >0.80 via three studies
Uniform Terminology 3 rd edition (UT III) format (Cup, Scholte op Reimer, Thijssen and van Kuyk-
(AOTA, 1994) 5 and reflective of the HCFA-700 Minis, 2003; Pan, Chung, and Hsin-Hwei, 2003;
form recommended by the Center for Medicare and Sewell and Singh, 2001) 11,12,13 . Studies by
and Medicaid Services for evaluations by Chan and Lee, 1997; 1 4 Chen, Roger, and
physical and occupational therapists. This Polatajko, 2002; 15 and Simmons, Crepeau, and
evaluation tool documented client White, 2000, 16 with samples similar to my client
demographics, prior level of functioning, reason verify the validity of the COPM. The COPM was
for referral to occupational therapy, significant found to positively correlate for content, criterion
medical history, client’s living condition and and construct with the Functional Independence
support system, client’s functional abilities in Measure (FIM TM ), Life Satisfaction Scale (LSS),
terms of ability to perform basic activities daily the Satisfaction with Performance Scaled
living (BADL) and instrumental activities of daily Questionnaire (SPSQ) and the Reintegration to
living (IADL) customary to client, the client’s Normal Living Scale (RNL). Utility of the COPM
performance skills involving strength, range of as it relates to responsiveness to change, ease of
motion, coordination, balance, endurance/ administration, time to completion, and ability
activity tolerance, sensory functions, muscle tone to communicate aspects of occupation were
and, social interactions and cognition. This found to be significant across various clinical
evaluation based on UT III as one whole tool, settings, populations, and also in different
has not been tested for reliability or validity but languages and cultures (Chen et al. 2002; 15 Pan
components comprising of individual tests such et al. 2003; 12 Simmons et al. 2000; 16 and Wressle,
as the grip strength/ dynamometer test, pinch Marcusson, and Henricksson, 2002). 17
test and, the Berg Balance Test (BBT), have been
2 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
I also chose the FIM TM as an extension of my went to the local church to attend mass every
assessment and as an outcome tool and thus, Sunday morning. Since the client was a retiree,
incorporated results from my initial evaluation play and work as identified in the Framework,
using data produced by both assessment tools were not directly applicable in this case. The
into the FIM TM scale. The scale originally client did not participate in any organized
developed by the American Congress of volunteer tasks and did not state any future
Rehabilitation Medicine and the American interests in the same. Information on
Academy of Physical Medicine and educational level and previous employment
Rehabilitation and, supported by 11 national were sought for demographic purposes and to
professional organizations was found to have gain an insight on the client’s possible aptitudes
adequate reliability, validity, and responsiveness and interests in life, including reading and leisure
(Deutsch, Fiedler, Iwanenko, Granger and habits.
Russell, 2003) 18 . Intra-class correlation coefficient The client’s initial status in areas of occupation
was found to be 0.96 - 0.99 for motor as related to the clients functioning in BADL and
components on the FIM TM scale, and 0.91- 0.97 IADL tasks and, the clients self-rating per the
for the cognitive components of the FIM TM scale COPM has been summarized in Table 1.
(Hamilton, Laughlin, Fiedler and Granger, 1994)
19
. Assessing concurrent validity, Deutsch et al.
(2003) 18 also found a strong relationship between
FIM TM scores and scores on the Barthel Index, a
functional assessment tool that was commonly
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

used in rehabilitation facilities in the United


States before the development of the FIM T M
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
www.IndianJournals.com

instrument. The predictive validity of FIM T M


scores has also been shown using various
dependent variables, including minutes of
assistance needed by the person who is disabled,
discharge functional status, length of
rehabilitation stay, and likelihood of discharge
to the community. (p. 705).
Occupational Performance Deficits
Using the Framework the client’s ability to
engage in occupation to support participation
in context/s was evaluated as discussed below.
Performance in areas of occupation. As a part As identified in the Framework, occupational
of the evaluation, during the process of performance, that is, the ability to engage in
formulating an occupational profile, the client areas of true occupations is not an independent
was asked about her prior level of functioning, factor but rather a synthesis/ outcome of other
home environment, caregiver/support systems continually interacting aspects such as
and her interests/ leisure. This was helpful to performance skills, performance patterns,
gain an insight to the extent of dysfunction/ context, activity demands and client factors
morbidity caused by her current condition (AOTA, 2002) 1 . Kindly refer to figure-1 for a
beyond just physiological implications of the schematic representation of the various
disease/ condition. interdependent factors relating to occupational
The client’s ability to perform BADL and IADL performance and the service delivery model as
tasks including interests and participation in highlighted by the Framework (AOTA, 2002) 1
leisure and social activities were evaluated. The .The various factors as applicable to my client
client stated that prior to her stroke she had are discussed below.
played cards with a small group of ladies that Performance skills. The client was tested for
met twice a week at her apartment complex and motor, processing and communication/

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 3
interaction skills. The client demonstrated institutionalized.
minimal hypertonicity of the right upper Context. The evaluation further studied the
extremity distally and hypotonicity of the right client’s current performance and how it was
lower extremity, and lack of gross and fine motor impacted by factors such as her personal beliefs
coordination. Postural instability was caused due and values, culture, spirituality, physical and
to the client’s inability to bear weight adequately virtual environment, social obligations/ status
through her right side and thus, her mobility and based upon dimensions defined by time
and ability to participate in ADL was affected. (example: the need to shower every morning
The client’s voluntary control for the right upper after breakfast).
extremity was grossly poor+ on a descriptive scale
parallel to late stage 2 of the six recovery stages The client based on her culture as an
of the arm, with synergic patterns of movement American, strived for her independence versus
(Brunnstorm, 1970) 2 0 . The client needed dependence on her family. As a devoted catholic,
moderate assistance with mobility needs such she believed in going to the church every Sunday.
as getting in/out of the bed, functional transfers, Her physical and virtual environments at the
etc. The client fatigued easily and performed all facility were not like she was used to at home,
functions in a considerably slow pace taking and stated she missed her big- screen TV the
frequent rest breaks due to decreased endurance most. She wanted to be as independent as
and strength. Motor praxis was intact. possible, and was generally bashful to seek help
from the staff. She felt that she was somewhat
Overall, process skills involving task initiation, of a burden on her friends and family now due
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

attention to tasks, and modification of actions to her condition.


during task execution, temporal and spatial
Activity demands. The client demonstrated
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

organization were fairly intact. The client


www.IndianJournals.com

demonstrated minimal perceptual deficits and good use of tools, materials, and items routinely
needed minimal cues to compensate/ adapt for used for ADL. The space demands (the client’s
right-sided neglect. Cognitive skills for room) at the facility was adequate although, the
orientation, short term and long-term memory, client realized that her apartment was larger and
sequencing and following instructions were differently set-up. From a physical context
fairly intact. The client showed good knowledge standpoint, the bathroom in the facility was
and ability to follow-through learnt tasks. more accessible with a roll-in/ walk-in shower
versus a tub in the client’s apartment. The social
Communication/ interaction skills were demands from a recovery standpoint may be
minimally affected due to expressive aphasia viewed per the client’s own personal and
with occasional substitution of words or letters. cultural values to be independent, serve in her
The client was able to correct herself most of the established role as a spouse, and as a member of
times after misspeaking. Due to her low a church and a social group to which she
endurance level, she could only meet visitors for belonged. These social demands were obviously
short periods during which she preferred sitting unsatisfied by her institutionalization. Actions,
in a chair with a backrest. The client’s social/ body functions and body structures required to
interactive behavior and demeanor was perform human occupations were assessed using
appropriate at all times. standardized and non-standardized tests.
Performance patterns. This aspect of the Physiological functions such as mobility,
domain per the Framework is important to cognition, level of consciousness, strength,
understand the habits, routines, and roles that processing skills, status of anatomical structures
are central to occupational performance (AOTA, (body parts such as hands, legs, etc.) were
2002) 1 . The condition/ physical impairments assessed. Due to the right-sided weakness and
and change in environment due to lack of coordination, the client was unable to
institutionalization caused a change in the meet the activity demands to function
client’s sleep pattern. Her traditional role as a independently. The client was pre-morbidly right
spouse with her set responsibilities was, at least hand dominant. Circulation, skin condition,
temporarily, interrupted with her being blood pressure, blood oxygen saturation, heart

4 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
and respiratory rate were all within normal formalizing a plan (along with outcomes desired)
limits. Anatomical structures were intact. to guide actions based on theories, frames of
Client factors. As a part of the evaluation, a references and evidence, secondly, implementing
brief review of organ- systems to determine body the plan and finally, reviewing the intervention
functions and structures (client factors) affecting to determine its effectiveness and need for
occupational performance was done. The client changes (AOTA, 2002, p. 614). 1
demonstrated good mental functions overall, The intervention plan with our client involved
except need for minimal cues due to minimal setting-up occupational therapy goals and
right-sided neglect. The client also needed further treating the client for 3 weeks with possible
education on the condition (CVA) itself. Gross/ discharge plans to continue OT at a local skilled
discriminatory sensations were within nursing facility. Targeted performance deficits
functional limits. Cardiovascular, hematological, and corresponding intervention approaches and
immunological and respiratory functions were types are discussed below.
within normal limits as evidenced by the vital Intervention approaches
signs and lab reports. No digestive or urino-
genital concerns were reported by the client or, Several approaches as identified in the
marked on the physician’s progress notes. No Framework were used. Our intervention
external abnormalities were found associating primarily utilized remediation and restoration
the integumetary system. Neuro-musculoskeletal techniques targeting deficits in performance
and movement related functions were affected (mainly motor) skills due to decreased right-sided
strength, postural imbalance, minimal right-
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

due to right-sided weakness and lack of


coordination. The client also demonstrated sided neglect and right-sided lack of
coordination. The approach targeted skills
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

minimal hypotonia of the right extremities.


www.IndianJournals.com

While active ranges of motion were affected due required to restore prior roles and functions
to weakness in the extremities, all passive ranges performed by the client. The client was also
of motion were well preserved. The client was encouraged to attend recreational activities to
unable to take more than 2 steps while walking. improve interaction/ communication skills, in
Deep tendon jerks were diminished in the addition to group OT treatments. Client factors
affected extremities and no primitive reflexes such as strength, voluntary control/
were present. The client’s voluntary control was coordination, and postural balance and, mobility
grossly at a poor + level for the right upper (neuromusculoskeletal and movement related
extremity and fair- for the lower extremity. The functions) were targeted via remediation/
client needed moderate assistance with mobility restoration techniques to obtain normal function
needs such as getting in/out of the bed, per prior level of functioning.
functional transfers, etc. The client fatigued Another intervention approach also sought to
easily and performed all functions in a modify the physical context in the facility via
considerably slower pace taking frequent rest compensatory strategies to facilitate
breaks due to decreased endurance and strength. independence (example: bed rails to assist with
Postural instability was noticed due to the client’s bed mobility, standard walker and manual
inability to adequately weight bear on the right wheelchair to assist with transfers and mobility
side. needs respectively), and/or via adaptations to
The Therapeutic Intervention simulate similarities to the client’s actual context/
s (example: a non-functional tub for tub transfer
After generating an occupational profile and training with the use of a extended tub bench).
thorough analysis of occupational performance, These modifications/ compensatory strategies
several deficit areas were identified as discussed were aimed at meeting activity demands via use
above. The process of service delivery was then of adaptive/ supportive equipments. The client’s
focused on addressing these deficit areas, within performance patterns were also modified.
the scope of occupational therapy (OT). This Although, all attempts to maintain the client’s
phase of the process constitutes the intervention. actual routines were made, changes in routines
The interventional phase involves firstly, and deviations from habitual ways of functioning

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 5
were inevitable due to the physical activities (Walker, Drummond & Lincoln, 1996)
22
manifestations of the condition and changes in , or, may focus on remediation/ restoration of
physical context due to institutionalization. The deficit areas that cause the occupational
client’s socialization habits were compromised deprivation or dysfunction. Edmans, Webster
and, were modified within the confines of the and Lincoln (2000) 23 were unable to find clinical
facility and so were her spiritual obligations. She or statistical difference between transfer of
was invited to go to mass in the facility’s chapel training or functional training outcomes.
on Sundays. Trombly and Ma (2002, p. 258) 2 4 have also
The intervention approaches also involved suggested that perhaps, at times, strategy
prevention of disabilities, maladaptive patterns training is more effective than task specific
and functions, abnormal tone/ structural training for some clients; or treatments of
deformities via ensuring optimal postural underlying abilities required for functional
balance, bed and seating positioning, preventing performance may be most appropriate.
unsafe fatigue, and preventing risk for injury The Framework categorically states,
with proper transferring and lifting techniques “Occupational therapists are trained to assess
as applicable. Positioning of extremities in bed all aspects (of the Domain) and to apply that
where achieved with use of pillows or towel rolls. knowledge to an intervention process that leads
Appropriate positioning on wheelchair was to engagement in occupations to support
achieved with a transparent half-lap tray on the participation in context or contexts” (AOTA,
right and foot rests. As passive ranges of motion 2002, p. 611) 1 . Our intervention thus, included
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

(PROM) were well preserved on the affected a variety of tools aimed at improving/ restoring
side, we did not apply any hand/ wrist splints the client’s performance in occupational areas.
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

at this stage. Ma and Trombly (2002) 21 via a The types of interventions used were as follows:
www.IndianJournals.com

meta-analysis of 36 studies (29 were finally Therapeutic use of self. Our (OT staff involved
included) suggested that splinting might be an with the care) personal insights, perceptions and
ineffective approach used by occupational judgments along with our personal interactions
therapists to treat spasticity in persons with were ensured to be conducive to the client’s
stroke. However, as also recommended by them, therapeutic milieu. This was also required as an
definitive studies to verify their findings are still active part of therapy to elicit appropriate
needed. We founded our clinical approach responses along with neuro-physiological
mainly based on the fact that PROM was techniques (NPT), neuro-developmental
normal, and the tone was minimally hypertonic. techniques (NDT) and proprioceptive
To a lesser degree our approaches also neuromuscular facilitation (PNF) techniques.
involved maintenance techniques. This involved Preparatory methods
ensuring that strength of the unaffected side (left)
was optimal and the client’s performance Our interventions included several techniques
patterns/ routines were followed as much as aimed at remediation/ restoration of
possible. performance skills in preparation for purposeful
and occupation-based activities (Pedretti & Early,
A health promotion approach via client 2001) 2 5 . This included NPT, NDT and PNF
education on healthy lifestyle was also techniques to facilitate voluntary control, tone
incorporated in the treatment plan to help the regulation in the affected extremities of the right
client identify and prevent risk factors involving side; and use of physical agent modalities (ice,
strokes water, heat, electrical stimulation, etc. as a part
Types of Interventions of NPT and NDT techniques). We also used
Human occupational performance is not an exercises/ movement therapy based upon
independent factor but rather the resultant of Brunnstrom’s principles (Brunnstrom, 1970;
different aspects identified under the Domain Pedretti, 1990) 2 0 , 2 6 . In conjunction to
of Occupational Therapy (AOTA, 2002) 1 . OT Brunnstorm’s principles, we used modified
intervention may either be directed on task- constraint induced movement (m-CIM) therapy.
specific (functional) practice of client-identified We chose a m-CIM technique as it would have

6 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
been difficult to implement a complete suggested by Phillips, et al. (2001) 28 . Studenski
Constraint Induced Movement (CIM) therapy et al. (2005) 30 studied the use of therapeutic
due to client and staff compliance issues as well exercises in subacute stroke survivors (mean age=
as due to the operational policies at our swing- 70 years) and concluded that rehabilitation
bed facility pertaining to physical restraints. We exercises caused quicker improvements in
restrained the non-affected (left) upper- physical, social, and role functions than usual
extremity with a hemi-sling and a padded hand- care in persons with subacute stroke.
mitt, and thus, forced use of the affected upper Dromerick et al. (2000) 27 ; Page et.al. (2002) 29 ;
limb. This was done no more than an hour each and, Studenski et al. (2005) 30 , thus, provide
day under direct supervision of a treating relevant evidence supporting the use of CIM
therapist and 3-4 hours every morning under therapy or a modified version of the technique
nursing supervision. Dromerick, Edwards and at different stages and time lapse after a stroke.
Hahn (2000) 27 have demonstrated via a pilot
study on 23 subjects (mean age= 66.4 years) that We also believe that preparatory techniques
use of CIM therapy during acute rehabilitation (as used in our case) for remediation of
helps reduce arm impairments after ischemic neuromusculoskeletal body functions are
stroke. This study provided evidence via a single- aassociated and interdependent, and
blinded, randomized control trial (RCT), a level combination of techniques (example- Rood’s
1b study based on the Oxford Center for technique along with PNF, electrical stimulation
Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence of postural muscles with weight-bearing NDT)
(Phillips et al., 2001) 28 . Subjects of this study in is usually practiced versus the use of an isolated
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

the experimental (CIM) group wore padded technique since the underlying physiological
mittens on their unaffected hand preventing its impact by these techniques are ideologically
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

similar. The interventional procedures and their


www.IndianJournals.com

use for at least 6 hours per day during their 14-


day treatment period. corresponding CPT TM codes used for the
preparatory methods were therapeutic exercises
Other studies were also referenced. A case- (97110), neuromuscular re-education (97112),
study by Page, Sisto and Levine (2002) 2 9 manual electrical stimulation (G0283) and,
specifically studied the effect of m-CIM in a 67- manual therapy (97140) (AMA, 2004) 3 .
year old, white, left handed man who
demonstrated left hemiparesis after sustaining Purposeful activities. These activities generally
a right occipital infarct approximately two years address a sub-goal or midpoint goal toward
and four months prior to the study. The subject engagement in actual occupations. We used
received m-CIM therapy over a period of 10 activities/ tasks to improve on performance
weeks. The study revealed that even in the components such as sitting and standing
chronic stages, the use of m-CIM provided balance, activity tolerance, functional transfers,
beneficial results as evidenced by improvements proper use of body mechanics, use of adaptive/
on the Fugl-Meyer Assessment of Motor supportive devices and other modifications
Recovery, Action Research Arm test, Amount made to the therapeutically designed context/
of Use (of affected arm) Scale and Motor Activity s. The procedures/ CPT TM codes used for the
Log. Although ranking low (a level 4 study) based purposeful activities were therapeutic activities
upon the hierarchy of evidence suggested by (97530) and group therapy (97150) when tasks
Phillips et al. (2001) 28 . This study was highly were completed in a group of two or more clients
relevant to my case because of the same age of (AMA, 2004) 3 .
the subject in the study and similar fashion of Occupation based activities
modification of the CIM therapy as in my case True occupations were incorporated both as
(approximately 5 hours of application per day, short-term and long-term goals to facilitate the
the same duration as of my client). client’s independence in her occupational role/
Another study of significance was one s. This involved practicing of actual occupations
conducted by Studenski et al. (2005) 30 . This was such as grooming tasks involving brushing teeth,
a prospective, single-blinded RCT, a level 1 b combing and dressing/ bathing upper body in
study based upon the hierarchy of evidence the earlier stages, to lower body dressing and

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 7
bathing, toileting and light IADL such as meal for stroke survivors. As stated in the study
preparation, household tasks, money performed by Trombly and Ma (2002) 2 4 on
management, etc. as the client progressed. Group restoration of roles, tasks and activities after
activities were used to improve social interactions stroke, we, too, were unable to find studies that
and involvement in leisure tasks. The client specifically manipulated context or addressed
participated in several occupation-based and studied habit formations (essential
therapeutic tasks some more personal such as components of occupation-based practices) as
BADL, to social tasks (as components of IADL ) specific therapeutic interventions for stroke
such as planning and organizing a “mostly survivors. We speculate that the lack of directed
decaffeinated” group over a “coffee and a TV” research on occupation-based activities as the
activity or, a card game with other clients of the sole therapeutic agent (intervention type) for
facility. The client, as we found, was particularly stroke survivors is also because occupational
fond of television soaps and the “E!” channel. therapists often use it in conjunction with other
We would, at times, also incorporate post- types of interventions such as
telecast quizzes addressing her communication/ neurodevelopmental therapy, movement
interaction skills complementing the other social therapy, orthotic management based on
occupational tasks performed by the client. biomechanical principles, etc., versus just as an
The procedures/ CPT TM codes used for the isolated tool.
intervention with occupation-based activities A meta-analysis (level-1a study based upon
were self-care management training (97535), the hierarchy of evidence suggested by Phillips
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

community reintegration training (97537) and et al. 2001) 28 by Walker et al. (2004) 31 studied 8
group therapy (97150) when tasks were single-blinded randomized controlled trials
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

completed in a group of 2 or more clients (AMA, (RCTs) incorporating 1143 patients. The meta-
www.IndianJournals.com

2004) 3 . analysis involved 655 patients that received


Occupation-based activities must address the community OT (481 ADL therapy, 174 leisure
environmental context and must be meaningful therapy) and the remaining 488 received routine
to the client. Our interventions adhered to the care. The study indicated that patients receiving
principles laid in the Framework as we used community OT that emphasized on ADL had
occupations as our goals (the “end”) and also higher scores on the Nothingham Extended ADL
as therapeutic media (“means”) by (NEADL) scale and the Personal ADL (PADL)
incorporating occupation-based activities as a scale but not on the Nottingham Leisure
part of our intervention (AOTA, 2002) 1 . The Questionnaire (NLQ). Those that received
end/ goal was to enable to client perform BADL leisure-based OT demonstrated a higher NLQ
and IADL tasks per her prior level of functioning. score but not NEADL or PADL. Hence, the study
To seek the evidence on occupation-based demonstrated that targeted interventions caused
activities on occupational performance, we better-targeted outcomes.
searched the Internet databases of Medline, Another meta-analysis of 15 studies including
Cochrane, Cumulative Index to Nursing & some RCTs (a level 2a study based upon the
Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) and ACP hierarchy of evidence suggested by Phillips, et.
Journal Club. We used the keywords al. 2001) conducted by Trombly and Ma (2002)
24
Occupation-based activities, Therapy, on the restoration of roles, tasks and activities
Occupation Centered Practice, ADL and synthesized research findings involving 895
Outcomes. Several studies that included participants (mean age= 70.3 years). Trombly
occupation-based approaches such as task- and Ma (2002) 24 state that out of the 15 studies,
specific practices of true occupations 11 (7 randomized controlled trials) found that
incorporated along with other occupational “role participation and instrumental and basic
therapy modalities were found. However, we activities of daily living performance improved
were unable to find any study that specifically significantly more with training than with the
discussed the effectiveness of occupation-based control conditions” (p.250). However, the two
activities as the only (or isolated) tool of therapy researchers also acknowledged that empirical

8 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
research was needed to verify these findings and an outcome tool to compare the client’s progress
to characterize the key therapeutic mechanisms toward all set goals (that were tailored directly
associated with desired outcomes. In their toward the client’s needs) as identified during
research article, they also recommend therapists the evaluation process. The client had shown
to use structured instructions, client-identified progress toward set goals and was grossly at a
activities, and appropriate adaptations to enable minimal assistance level for all BADL and IADL.
performance. They also suggest that therapists Driving was not attempted as was not identified
should ask clients to practice within a familiar as a target outcome at this stage.
context, and for therapists to provide feedback Complementing this ‘therapist- measured’
to clients to improve performance. outcome tool, the COPM was used to detect the
In addition to the discussed types of OT client’s self-perception on changes in
interventions, the process of consultation was occupational performance. At discharge, her self-
followed to collaborate with the client to identify rated COPM scores for occupational
problems and problem solve as appropriate with performance problems (as identified during the
client and her family’s participation. Imparting initial evaluation) were 6.0 for performance and
information to the client and her family in 7.0 for satisfaction. The client demonstrated an
reference to resources available, handouts improvement on the COPM with an average
pertaining to the condition, also followed the score of 3 and 3.5 in performance and satisfaction
educational process. respectively as compared to the initial rating.
Based upon her current condition needing
Outcomes
ongoing occupational and physical therapy
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

The focus on outcome begins with the intervention, the client was discharged to a
evaluation phase when targeted outcomes are skilled nursing facility on day 21 of her stay at
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
www.IndianJournals.com

identified and undergoes adjustments/ the swing-bed facility. The outcome documented
modifications throughout the interventional for our client was thus, achieved in 20 days.
phase. The outcome of the occupational therapy
Discussion
process is directed toward “engagement in
occupation to support participation” (AOTA, On the Use of Evidence-Based Practice (EBP)
2002, p. 618) 1 . We chose several methods to Benefits to skilled health care can no longer be
target, monitor and track outcomes in order to based on subjective feelings of its worth. Services
test the effectiveness of the OT intervention. The provided should be scientifically based,
outcome tools we chose were traditional compliment your expertise (that is your skilled
discharge assessment for comparison between art), and be of value to your client. EBP is just
baseline status and client’s progress toward set that. It may be simply defined as “integrating
goals, the COPM, and the FIM TM scale. individual clinical expertise and the best external
evidence” (Sackett, Rosenberg, Gray, Haynes
The FIM TM scale was applied to track and Richardson, 1996) 3 2 . It is a process to
outcomes relating mainly to occupational
ethically, conscientiously and discriminatively
performance and to a lesser degree may also be
apply the best research- based evidence to
seen as an indicator of overall health and decisions regarding client care (Lloyd- Smith,
wellness, and role competence. The average
1997) 33 . Studies in the past have shown that
score for our client on the18-item FIM TM scale OT practitioners engage in modest amount of
was at a 3.0 (that is, the client needed moderate
EBP (Dysart and Tomlin, 2002) 34 . This may be
assistance, collectively, with all occupational
due to several factors including the paucity of
performance areas) at the start of care. On the research in occupational therapy particularly
date of discharge, the client scored an average
related to specific interventions, difficulty to
of 4.0 per test item demonstrating increased access applicable research and, overall under-
independence and now requiring only
subscription to the EBP movement by
minimum assistance with BADL and IADL
practitioners (Alsop, 1997; Brown and Rodger,
tasks identified on the FIM TM scale. 1999; Lloyd- Smith, 1997) 35,36,33. Clients have a
The OT discharge assessment also served as right to proven, effective and efficient services.

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 9
The medical community in general, and several impairments/ pathological features. It is the
insurance programs including Medicare and focus on ‘context/s’ that drives the true essence
Medicaid are increasingly subscribing to EBP. of human performance from merely being a
Many insurance companies are now planning result of internal client factors such as body
and a few have begun basing payments and functions and structures to rather the synthesis
incentives to healthcare practitioners based on of both internal mechanisms and external
EBP as well. OT practitioners owing it to their aspects (reasons, needs) of functioning.
social responsibility and for reimbursement The Framework clearly exemplifies OT’s
purposes as well will have to deliver care that is holistic approach to human functioning and
evidenced-based. The centennial vision of AOTA complements the profession’s wide scope of
rightly encompasses this focus to envision practice (AOTA, 2004) 2 . It is applicable in
occupational therapy as a powerful, widely- traditional setting such as hospitals, nursing
recognized, science-driven, and evidence-based homes and clinics, as well as in non-traditional
profession with a globally connected and diverse settings such as day-care centers, sheltered
work force that meets society’s occupational workshops, driver education programs, etc.
needs (AOTA, 2006) 37 . Also, the intervention approaches mentioned in
On the Use of the Framework in Service the Framework, clearly positions the OT
Delivery practitioners to function in a pan-health mode
Strengths of the Framework. The Framework including in areas such as, health promotion and
(AOTA, 2002) 1 is an excellent bridge between disability prevention versus intervening in
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

the various theories, frames of references and customary roles only after a pathological
practices in Occupational Therapy and is easily condition/ dysfunction has occurred.
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

applicable in both traditional and non- The Framework has skillfully assimilated the
www.IndianJournals.com

traditional settings. areas identified in the UT III (AOTA, 1994) 5 to


It provides the OT community with all its reflect the growth of the profession in non-
diversity in practice methods and settings, a traditional settings as well. It also articulates
commonality based upon core beliefs and OT’s focus on addressing the virtual
processes that binds us together as a profession. environment, thus adopting a pro-technology
It can be used as an effective tool to guide our focus that is in keeping with the futuristic view
practice as well as to educate external audiences of an ever changing, technologically savvy
about the focus and scope of occupational world. The Framework is thus timely and
therapy. Modifications based on the target sensitive to the world healthcare trends. As
audience may be required. identified by AOTA (2002) 1 , the domain of OT
complements the World Health Organization’s
The Framework helps with clearly identifying (WHO) conceptualization of participation and
the domain of the profession, with its emphasis health articulated in the International
on occupation and daily life activities and the Classification of Functioning, Disability and
application of an intervention process that Health (ICF) (WHO, 2001) 38 . The ICF is intended
facilitates engagement in occupation to support to become an operational method to classify
participation in life (AOTA, 2002, p. 609) 1 . health conditions globally. This provides the OT
The Framework supports the client-centered community not only a common language for
model fostering a collaborative process between professional interaction with other health care
the practitioners and clients throughout the professionals across the world but also
process of service delivery. It especially showcases OT’s holistic approach to health and
highlights the relationship of the context to the wellness. The Framework certainly has the
client’s performance and process of delivering potential to be a precursor to the profession’s
services (AOTA, 2002, p. 614) 1 . The context is future growth and expansion.
an often-missed aspect of our domain especially Weaknesses of the Framework. The
in the medical model where the emphasis is Framework is relatively new and needs to be
primarily on remediation/ restoration of further assimilated into the academic curricula.

10 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
Practitioners need to be trained in the the medical community in general and insurance
understanding and use of the Framework. companies/ payer sources are vastly
AOTA must continue marketing the Framework contributing to this movement. This could be,
to ensure that all practitioners are once again, because of generality of the
knowledgeable about the document. AOTA and Framework as applied to OT practice versus
the OT community in general, must also be able being directed to any particular OT setting and
to communicate the domain and scope of OT other reasons as discussed under the topic “On
based on the Framework to all external evidence-based practice”. And also, the
audiences and gain acceptance for the same. The Framework was published before AOTA’s
major drawback currently facing its application Centennial Vision (AOTA, 2006). 37 The lack of
would be from the fact that in the medical emphasis on EBP in the framework was clearly
model, almost all insurance programs including rectified in the latter document (AOTA, 2006). 37
Medicare and Medicaid (the US government’s The Framework does not emphasize on the
insurance policies) do not use the ICF model profession’s autonomy or access to service
(WHO, 2001) 3 8 for operational or payment delivery. I believe that, a profession that wishes
purposes as yet. to clarify its domain, and process, must also
The Framework per its intent is comprehensive clarify the process of referrals or access to its
and concise. The scope of the Framework is service. AOTA has, however, separately and
limited to generalization of OT practice versus previously stated that a referral is not required
specificities based on practice settings. This may in the provision of occupational therapy services
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

cause confusion and drawing of camps based (AOTA, 1994, p.1034). 40 This should be included
upon interpretations. It fails to clearly specify in the Framework as a reference for the process
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

the requirements for entry-level OT education of service delivery.


www.IndianJournals.com

and practice. Also, although both the scope of Conclusion


practice (AOTA, 2004) 2 and the Framework
(AOTA, 2002) 1 has identified several areas A client- centered approach as identified in
within the OT process, inconsistencies of the Framework (AOTA, 2002) 1 empowered with
educational standards amongst OT schools and evidence-based practices can facilitate optimal
certain state practice acts prohibit certain client benefits, and demonstrates the scientific
elements of practice stated within its scope. and holistic approach in OT practice.
Example: Use of physical agent modalities (a As stated by, Abreu and Peloquin, (2004) 41 ,
preparatory method as a type of intervention). the OT community, needs to get over the
Not all OT schools train their students adequately “otherisms” that divide the profession into
in the use of these modalities and the state of camps- such as, the academia versus the
California categorically prohibits its use by OT practitioners, the shelter-workshop OT versus
practitioners unless they have documented the hospital OT, etc. Coppolla (2005) 42 rightly
special training in its use in addition to their basic states, “The heart, mind, and soul of
OT/OTA education (California Board of occupational therapy come to us in many ways”
Occupational Therapy, 2003) 39 . The same may (p. 479). The Framework is a commendable
be stated in reference to the lack of uniform foundation to embrace this diversity and stand
standards for basic science education, although unified as one community.
the Framework asserts that “Occupational Acknowledgements
therapists and occupational therapy assistants
have knowledge of…. body functions” (AOTA, I thank Neeti Wells, OTR/L; Jeffrey Crabtree,
2002, pp. 625-626). 1 OTD, OTR/L, FAOTA, and Martha Hartgraves,
Ph.D., OTR/L, CLT, for their valued inputs.
The Framework fails to explicitly emphasize
its support to evidence-based principles, while

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 11
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale
www.IndianJournals.com

Figure 1.
6. Mathiowetz V, Weber K, Volland G, Kashman N.
Process of Service Delivery and Domain of
Reliability and validity of grip and pinch strength
Occupational Therapy (AOTA, 2002). This evaluations. J Hand Surg [Am] 1984; 9 (A): 22-6.
figure represents the interactive relationships
7. Bogle Thorbahn JD, Newton RA. Use of Berg Balance
amongst the stages of the process of service Test to predict falls in elderly persons. Phys Ther 1996;
delivery, and the various aspects of the domain 76: 576-83.
of occupational therapy. 8. Riddle DL, Stratford PW. Interpreting validity indexes
References for diagnostic test: an illustration using the Berg
Balance Test. Phys Ther 1999; 79: 939-48.
1. American Occupational Therapy Association.
9. Shumway-Cook A, Baldwin M, Plissar NJ, Gueber W.
Occupational therapy practice framework: Domain and
Predicting the probability for falls in community-
process. Am J Occup Ther 2002; 56: 609-39.
dwelling older adults. Phys Ther 1997; 71: 589-622.
2. American Occupational Therapy Association. Scope of
10. Nelson DL, Jepson- Thomas J. Occupational form,
practice [online] 2004[cited 2005 July 19]. Available
occupational performance and a conceptual framework
from: URL: http://www.aota.org/members/area2/
for therapeutic occupation. In: Kramer P, Hinojosa J,
docs/scope.pdf .
Royeen CB, editors. Perspectives in human occupation
3. American Medical Association. CPT ® (Common participation in life. Baltimore, MD: Lippincott
Procedural Terminology) [online] 2004[cited 2005 July Williams & Wilkins; 2003.p. 87-155.
19]. Available from: URL: http://www.ama-assn.org/
11. Cup EH, Scholte op Reimer WJ, Thijssen MC, & van
ama/pub/category/3113.html
Kuyk-Minis MA. Reliability and validity of the
4. Canadian Association of Occupational Therapy. Canadian Occupational Performance Measure in stroke
Enabling occupation: an occupational therapy patients. Clin Rehabil 2003; 17: 402-9.
perspective. Ottawa, ON: CAOT Publications ACE;
12. Pan A, Chung L, Hsin- Hwei G. Reliability and validity
1997.
of the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure
5. American Occupational Therapy Association. Uniform in psychiatric disorders in Taiwan. Occup Ther Int 2003;
terminology for occupational therapy- third edition. 10: 269-77.
Am J Occup Ther 1994; 48: 1047-54.

12 Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1
13. Sewell L, Singh SJ. The Canadian Occupational during acute rehabilitation reduce arm impairment
Performance Measure and the Health Assessment after ischemic stroke? Stroke 2000; 31: 2984-8.
Questionnaire. Can J Occup Ther 2001; 68: 247-53. 28. Phillips B, Ball C, Sackett D et al. Levels of evidence
14. Chan CCH, Lee TMC. Validity of the Canadian and grades of recommendations -Oxford Center for
Occupational Performance Measure. Occup Ther Int Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence [online]
1997; 4:229-47. 2001 May [cited 2005 Jul 20]. Available from: URL: http:/
/www.cebm.net/levels_of_evidence.asp.
15. Chen Y- H, Rodger S, Polaajko H. Experiences with the
COPM and the client-centered practice in adult 29. Page SJ, Sisto SA, Levine P. Modified constraint- induced
neurorehabilitation in Taiwan. Occup Ther Int 2002; therapy in chronic stroke. Am J Phys Med Rehabil 2002;
9:167-84. 81 (11): 870-5.
16. Simmons DC, Crepeau EB, White P. The predictive 30. Studenski S, Duncan P, Perera S et al. Daily functioning
power of narrative data in occupational therapy and quality of life in a randomized controlled trial of
evaluation. Am J Occup Ther 2000; 54: 471- 6. therapeutic exercise for subacute stroke survivors.
Stroke 2005; 36 (8): 1764-70.
17. Wressle E, Marcusson J, Henriksson C. Clinical utility
of the Canadian Occupational Performance Measure- 31. Walker MF, Leonardi-Bee J, Bath P et al. Individual
Swedish version. Can J Occup Ther 2002; 69: 40-8. patient data meta-analysis of randomized controlled
trials of community occupational therapy for stroke
18. Deutsch A, Fiedler R, Iwanenko W, Granger C, Russell
C. The Uniform Data System for Medical Rehabilitation patients. Stroke 2004; 35 (9): 2226-32.
report: patients discharged from sub-acute 32. Sackett DL, Rosenberg WMC, Gray JAM, Haynes RB,
rehabilitation programs in 1999. Am J Phys Med Richardson WS. Editorials: evidence based medicine:
Rehabil 2003; 82 (9): 703-11. what it is and what it is not. Br Med J 1996; 312: 71-2.
19. Hamilton BB, Laughlin JA, Fiedler RC, Granger CV. 33. Lloyd- Smith W. Evidence- based practice and
Inter-rater reliability of the 7-level Functional occupational therapy. Br J Occup Ther 1997; 60: 474- 8.
Downloaded From IP - 72.240.163.43 on dated 8-May-2016

Independence Measure (FIM). Scand J Rehabil Med 34. Dysart AM, Tomlin GS. (2002). Factors related to
1994; 26 (3): 115–9. evidence-based practice among U.S. occupational
Members Copy, Not for Commercial Sale

20. Brunnstorm S. Movement therapy in hemiplegia. New therapy clinicians. Am J Occup Ther 2002; 56: 275- 84.
www.IndianJournals.com

York: Harper and Row; 1970. 35. Alsop A. Evidence- based practice and continuing
21. Ma H, Trombly CA. A synthesis of the effects of professional development. Br J Occup Ther 1997; 60:
occupational therapy for person with stroke, part II: 503-8.
remediation of impairments. Am J Occup Ther 2002; 36. Brown GT, Rodger S. Research utilization models:
56: 260-74. frameworks for implementing evidence-based
22. Walker MF, Drummond AER, Lincoln NB. Evaluation occupational therapy practice. Occup Ther Int 1999; 6(1),
of dressing practice for stroke patients after discharge 1-23.
from hospital: a crossover design. Clin Rehabil 1996; 37. American Occupational Therapy Association. AOTA’s
10: 23-31. centennial vision [online]. 2006 [cited 2006 Oct 20].
23. Edmans JA,Webster J, Lincoln NB. A comparison of Available from: URL: http://www.aota.org/
two approaches in the treatment of perceptual nonmembers/area16/docs/vision.pdf.
problems after stroke. Clin Rehabil 2000; 14: 230-43. 38. World Health Organization. International classification
24. Trombly, CA, Ma H. A synthesis of the effects of of functioning, disability and health (ICF). Geneva,
occupational therapy for person with stroke, part I: Switzerland: The Organization; 2001.
restoration of roles, tasks, and activities. Amer J Occup 39. California Board of Occupational Therapy. Advance
Ther 2002; 56: 250-9. practice certification information/ instruction sheets
25. Pedretti LW, Early MB. Occupational performance and [online] 2003[cited on 2005 Jul 19]. Available from: URL:
model of practice for physical dysfunction. In: Pedretti http://www.bot.ca.gov/apc_app.pdf .
LW, Early MB, editors. Occupational therapy practice 40. American Occupational Therapy Association.
skills for physical dysfunction. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Statement of occupational therapy referral. Am J Occup
Company; 2001.p.7-9. Ther 1994; 48: 1034.
26. Pedretti LW. Movement therapy: the Brunnstrom 41. Abreu BC, Peloquin SM. The issue is- embracing
approach to treatment of hemiplegia. In:Pedretti LW, diversity in our profession. Am J Occup Ther 2004;
B. Zolton B, editors. Occupational therapy practice skills 58(3): 353-9.
for physical dysfunction.3 rd ed. St. Louis, MO: CV
Mosby Company; 1990. p.334-49. 42. Coppola S. A firm persuasion in our work: a journey
to see the whole of things. Am J Occup Ther 2005; 59
27. Dromerick AW, Edwards DF, Hahn M. Does the
(4): 479.
application of constraint-induced movement therapy

Joseph K. Wells/Indian Journal of Physiotherapy and Occupational Therapy. Jan-March, 2007, Vol.1, No. 1 13

Anda mungkin juga menyukai