Scientific paper
Abstract
The methylene blue value (MBV) is an important index that reflects the quality of manufactured sand (MS). The relation
between MBV of MS and its limestone fines content, clay content and clay characteristics was investigated and the effects
of MBV ranging from 0.35 to 2.5 on the performance of MS concrete were tested. Results showed that MBV of MS is
affected not by the limestone fines content, but by the clay content and the liquid limit index of clay. With an increase in
MBV, the workability, flexural strength and 7d compressive strength of the MS concrete decreased, while the 28d com-
pressive strength was not affected. Moreover, the increase of MBV promoted plastic shrinkage and drying shrinkage
cracking of the concrete, and remarkably accelerated freeze-thaw damage and abrasion loss. It was concluded that the
critical MBV was 1.4, a value below which MS concrete performances are not significantly diminished.
chemical properties are listed in Table 1. A polycarbox- the four sides of the rigid frame, was used to restrict
ylic-acid type superplasticizer commercially branded as possible drying shrinkage of concrete. Concrete was
JK-180 was used in concrete mixtures. The solid content, placed in the steel form and cured with a cover of acrylic
pH, and specific gravity of the superplasticizer were 35%, board for 2 hours under a constant temperature of 30°C
6.7, and 1.05 g/cm3, respectively. and relative humidity of 60%. Subsequently, it was ex-
posed to an air flow with a velocity of 8 m/s under a
2.2 Concrete mixture constant temperature of 30°C and relative humidity of
The reference mixture proportion of concrete used in this 60%. Then, the age of crack initiation, number of cracks,
study consisted of 430 kg/m3 cement, 70 kg/m3 fly ash, crack length and crack width were measured up to the
760 kg/m3 MS with a fixed amount of particles finer than age of 24 hours. Parameters representing crack propaga-
75 μm of 7% (namely the sum of limestone fines and tion characteristics at the age of 24 hours may be the
clay fines), 1110 kg/m3 crushed stone, and 2.25 kg/m3 average crack area, number of cracks per unit area and
superplasticizer. MBV was adjusted by changing the total crack area per unit area. The test apparatus used and
ratio of the mass of clay to limestone fines in MS. the details of crack parameter calculation and evaluation
methods are shown in the Chinese standard (CCES
2.3 Experimental methods 01-2004).
MBV of MS with limestone or clay fine particles (< 75 Drying shrinkage was tested according to Chinese
μm) replacements was determined by the methylene blue Standard for Test Methods of Cement and Concrete for
value test for fine aggregate according to Chinese Stan- Highway Engineering (JTG E30-2005). The dimensions
dard for Test Method of Aggregate for Highway Engi- of concrete specimens are 100 mm × 100 mm × 515 mm.
neering (JTG E 42-2005). Clay materials replaced 1% to After 1 day of wet curing, the demolded specimens were
6% of MS by weight, and limestone fines replaced 5% to stored at constant temperature (20±2°C) and constant
20% of the sand by weight. This test is a measure of the relative humidity (60±5%). A micrometer was applied to
capacity of fine aggregate to adsorb methylene blue dye monitor the drying shrinkage of specimens at 1, 3, 7, 14,
and can be used to indicate the presence or absence of 28, 60, 90, and 180 d.
clay in a fine aggregate sample. Abrasion loss of mortar specimens (150 mm × 150
To test the effects of MBV on concrete or mortar mm × 50 mm) was tested in accordance with JTG
properties, the MBV was adjusted from 0.35 to 2.5, by E30-2005, with the ratio of cement, MS and water as 1:
changing the weight ratio of clay B to limestone fines 2.5: 0.44. Chloride ion permeability was measured using
when the sum of limestone and clay fines content in MS 100 mm × 100 mm × 50 mm concrete specimens by the
is fixed to 7% by weight. NEL method based on the Nernst-Einstein equation ac-
Fresh concrete properties were tested according to the cording to CCES 01-2004. The freeze-thaw resistance of
Chinese Standard for Test Method of Performance on concrete prisms (100 mm × 100 mm × 400 mm) was
Ordinary Fresh Concrete (GB/T50080-2002). Compres- conducted in accordance with JTG E30-2005.
sive strength, flexural strength and elastic modulus were
determined by testing 150 mm × 150 mm × 150 mm 3. Results and discussion
cubes, 100 mm × 100 mm × 400 mm prisms and 150 mm
× 150 mm × 300 mm prisms, respectively, according to 3.1 Relation between MBV and limestone fines
the Chinese Standard for Test Method of Mechanical content and clays content in MS
Properties on Ordinary Fresh Concrete (GB/ Figure 1 illustrates effect of limestone fines content on
T50081-2002). MBV. For every 5% increase of limestone fines content
Plastic shrinkage crack tests were conducted accord- in MS, MBV increased no more than 0.05 g/kg. The
ing to Chinese Standard for Guide of Design and Con- effect of the three kinds of clays, A, B and C, on MBV
struction to Durability of Concrete Structure (CCES was shown in Fig. 2. With an increase in clay content in
01-2004). In order to initiate cracks in the concrete, a MS, MBV of the MS increased rapidly in a linear manner.
steel mold of 600 mm × 600 mm × 63 mm with 14 bolts, Clay C and Clay B replacement results in much higher
10mm in diameter, mounted regularly at each at each of MBVs than Clay A, and the MBVs are significantly
B. Li, M. Zhou and J. Wang / Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology Vol. 9, No. 2, 127-132, 2011 129
1.4 5
1.2
4 Clay C y = 0.6964x + 0.3464
1 R2 = 0.9998
Clay B
MBV (g/kg)
MBV (g/kg)
5
clay 1% clay 2% clay 3% 10
3
6
2
4
1 y = 101251x -2.7824
2
R2 = 0.9968
0 0
25 35 45 55 25 35 45 55
W L (%) W L (%)
Fig. 3 Effect of liquid limit index (W L) of clay on MBV of Fig. 4 Clay content required with liquid limit index (W L)
MS. when MBV is up to 1.4 g/kg.
larger than that of the MS with limestone fines. This bility and mechanical properties of concrete. For the
indicates much higher absorption of methylene blue by concrete mixtures with a constant water-binder ratio,
clays than by limestone fines. From Fig. 3 and Fig. 4, it with the increase of MBV, the slump and slump flow of
can be found by further analysis that when the clay fresh concrete marked a slight reduction when the MBV
content in MS is fixed, the MBV of MS is proportional to was less than 1.1, but the workability decreased dra-
the liquid limit index (WL) of clay, and when the clay in matically when the MBV surpassed 1.45, as expected.
MS has a high WL, a small amount of clay can cause The mechanisms for clay decreasing workability of
MBV of over 1.4. concrete are: (1) clay particles are very small, resulting in
It can be perceived that MBV of MS is affected not by high specific surface areas and potentially increasing
limestone fines content but by the content and character water demand, clay minerals absorb additional water into
of clay fines. Increasing WL of clay and the percentage of a layered structure, increasing water demand further. (2)
clay in the MS increases the MBV, as expected. MS the cations in the clay can be exchanged with the organic
containing distinctive clays differs in MBV, which is due compounds comprising the superplasticizer (Sakai et al.
to the differences of the mineral characteristics, surface 2006). This results in adsorption of the water-reducing
area and number of cation exchange sites among clays, admixture into the clay structure, leaving less available
which also influence concrete performances. Thus, the for the cement paste. Thus it is clear that the workability
MBV can more exactly reflect the effect of clays on of concrete with clay will decrease when the amount of
concrete performances than clay content. water and dosage of superplasticizer are both held con-
stant.
3.2 Effect of MBV of MS on the workability and With an increase in MBV of MS, the 7d compressive
mechanical properties of concrete strength and 28d flexural strength were lower, but 28d
Table 2 shows the effect of MBV of MS on the worka- compressive strength was not affected, as shown in Ta-
130 B. Li, M. Zhou and J. Wang / Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology Vol. 9, No. 2, 127-132, 2011
70
fected by the MBV with less than 1.10, when MBV was ≥
1.45, the crack width, the average crack area and the total
60
crack area per square meter increased rapidly. Compared
7d
with concrete with MBV of 0.35, increases of 88% and
50
133% were obtained in the total cracking area per square
28d meter for concretes with MBV of 1.8 and 2.5, respec-
40
tively.
Plastic shrinkage cracks occur when the surface
30 moisture loss of concrete exceeds the transport of inter-
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 nal moisture to the surface, leading to negative capillary
MBV (g/kg) pressures and plastic shrinkage in paste. Owing to the
high moisture absorption of porous clays, the moisture
Fig.5 Effect of MBV of MS on compressive strength of
retention of fresh concrete containing clays is improved
concrete.
and the transport of internal moisture to the surface is
reduced, causing an increase in the plastic shrinkage of
ble 2 and Fig. 5. When the MBV increased to 2.5, the 7d concrete surface and the occurrence of plastic cracks.
compressive strength and 28d flexural strength of con- The effect of MBV of MS on the drying shrinkage of
crete were respectively reduced by 14% and 15%, com- concrete is shown in Fig. 6. With increasing MBV, es-
pared with those when MBV was 0.35. For MBV ≤ 1.8, pecially when MBV exceeds 1.45, the drying shrinkage
the elastic modulus of concrete was hardly changed, of concrete increased. This result has been observed
while it began to decrease when MBV exceeded 1.8. previously (Seleem and El-Hefnawy 2003). There are
In general, the presence of clays in aggregates is con- two primary reasons for the increasing degree of drying
sidered harmful to concrete. The extremely fine particu- shrinkage. One reason is that the clay particles them-
late nature of clay minerals and their surface activity selves have a loose and porous layer structure. When
generally increase the mix-water required to provide a they are scattered in concrete, the clay particles can ad-
concrete of given workability, as well as restrain the sorb mixing water and then swell. Once the concrete is in
hydration of cement, and hinder the interfacial bonding a dry environment, the loss of surface moisture of con-
between cement and aggregate (Zhao Shangchuan et al. crete causes the adsorbed water in the layers of the clay
2007). This has implications for the strength of the particles to be released by diffusion and migrate to the
hardened concrete. However, the 28 d compressive concrete surface, resulting in a decrease of the internal
strength results shown in Fig. 5 were widely divergent humidity of concrete. The other reason is that clays with
with the usual views. The main reason may be that clay B high specific surface area in MS also increase the volume
used in these tests mainly consists of kaolinite and quartz of paste.
and contains a small amount of montmorillonite. Seleem
and El-Hefnawy (2003) also observed that when w/c is 3.4 Effect of MBV of MS on durability of con-
held constant, kaolinite and illite had no effect on com- crete
pressive strength, and only montmorillonite clay Abrasion resistance is one of the important performances
significantly decreased compressive strength. of pavement concrete. Figure 7 shows the effect of MBV
on the abrasion resistance of cement mortar. Abrasion
3.3 Effect of MBV of MS on the plastic shrinkage mass loss of mortar increased with the increase of MBV.
crack and dry shrinkage of concrete Especially when MBV was larger than 0.7, the abrasion
It can be seen from the results in Table 3 that the age of resistance of mortar decreased noticeably. This is be-
cause that clay is weaker, and the incorporation of clay
B. Li, M. Zhou and J. Wang / Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology Vol. 9, No. 2, 127-132, 2011 131
Table 3 Effect of MBV of MS on plastic shrinkage crack propagation of fresh concrete at the age of 24 hours.
550 4.5
450 90d
60d 3.5
350
(kg/m2 )
28d 3
14d
250 2.5
7d
150 3d 2
1d
1.5
50 0 0.35 0.7 1.05 1.4 1.75 2.1 2.45 2.8
0.35 0.7 1.05 1.4 1.75 2.1 2.45 2.8
MBV (g/kg)
MBV (g/kg)
Fig. 7 Effect of MBV of MS on abrasion resistance of ce-
Fig. 6 Effect of MBV of MS on dry shrinkage of concrete. ment mortar cured for 28 days.
increases the volume of paste as well as hinders the mixtures will exceeded F250. The RDM for the concrete
bonding between the cement matrix and aggregates. mixtures with MBV ≥ 1.45 was slightly reduced up to
Table 4 shows the effect of MBV on the chloride ion 150 cycles, but it dropped suddenly at 200 cycles. For the
permeability and freeze-thaw resistance of concretes. two concrete mixtures with MBV of 2.15 and 2.5, the
Only a slight increase in the chloride ion diffusion coef- RDM decreased to less than 60% at 200 cycles. These
ficient (DNEL) was seen with the increase of MBV, which results indicate that increasing MBV of MS aggravates
indicates that the increase of MBV had no obvious the deterioration of concrete exposed to the freeze-thaw
harmful influence on the impermeability of MS concrete. environment, and reduces freeze-thaw resistance. The
Table 4 indicates that the influence of MBV on reason is that the high moisture absorption of porous clay
freeze-thaw resistance is significant. The relative dy- particles decreases the strength of the capillary pore wall
namic elastic modulus (RDM) for the two concrete in the cement matrix dispersed with clays, causing the
mixtures with MBV of 0.35 and 0.7 hardly decreased destruction of capillary pores and a decrease of relative
when lasting 250 cycles in freeze-thaw testing. It is pre- dynamic elastic modulus of concrete when exposed to
dicted that the freeze-thaw durability grade of the two the freeze-thaw environment.
Table 4 Effect of MBV of MS on chloride ion permeability and freeze-thaw resistance of concretes cured for 28 days.
Chloride diffusion Relative dynamic modulus after exposure to Freeze-thaw
MBV
No. coefficient DNEL freezing and thawing cycles (%) durability
(g/kg)
(×10-12 m2/s) 50 cycles 100 cycles 150 cycles 200 cycles 250 cycles grade
1 0.35 2.03 99.5 98.8 98.6 98.5 98.3 ≥F250
2 0.70 2.08 98.9 97.2 99.1 96.5 97.3 ≥F250
3 1.10 2.05 99.1 98.7 98.1 85.2 67.2 F250
4 1.45 2.19 96.8 97.5 96.0 76.9 53.4 F200
5 1.80 2.25 97.3 96.5 93.2 63.2 31.8 F200
6 2.15 2.41 96.6 97.0 91.1 48.7 — F150
7 2.50 2.40 97.3 95.2 73.2 32.1 — F150
132 B. Li, M. Zhou and J. Wang / Journal of Advanced Concrete Technology Vol. 9, No. 2, 127-132, 2011