visualNastran enterprise
Virtual Manufacturing
The Next Revolution
in Global Manufacturing.
"Industries throughout the world rely on MSC.Software as
the leading source for critical design software and services
in demanding environments."
Case Studies:
Virtual manufacturing significantly reduces fuel costs for Boeing 5
Perhaps one of the most interesting and important At the core of virtual manufacturing lies nonlinear
of these recent developments is called "Virtual FEA technology. This technology has enabled
Manufacturing." Often termed "The Next companies to simulate fabrication and testing in
Revolution in Global Manufacturing," virtual a more realistic manner than ever before.
manufacturing involves the simulation of a product
and the processes involved in its fabrication.
Simulation technology enables companies to
optimize key factors directly affecting the profitability
of their manufactured products. These include
manufacturability, final shape, residual stress
levels, and product durability. They directly affect
profitability by reducing the cost of production,
material usage, and warranty liabilities.
1
At the Cor e is Nonlinear Finite Element Analysis
FEA Analysis Nonlinear FEA Analysis
Finite Element Analysis is a very powerful Nonlinear FEA uses an incremental solution
engineering design tool that enables engineers procedure to step through the analysis. In contrast
and designers to simulate structural behavior, to linear FEA, where a solution is achieved in
make design changes, and see the effects of one step, nonlinear FEA may require hundreds,
these changes. even thousands of steps. There are three major
types of nonlinearites:
The finite element method works by breaking
the geometry of a real object down into a large · Material - plasticity, creep, viscoelasticity
number (1000's or 100,000's) of elements (e.g. · Geometric - large deformations, large
cubes). These elements form the mesh and the strains, snap-through buckling
connecting points are the nodes. The behavior of · Boundary - contact, friction, gaps,
each little element, which is regular in shape, is follower force
readily predicted by set mathematical equations.
A nonlinear analysis can include any combination
The summation of the individual element
of these. In the case studies to follow, you will
behavior produces the expected behavior of
encounter examples including all of these
the actual object.
solution types.
The mesh contains the material and structural
FEA Applications
properties that define how the part reacts to
certain load conditions. In essence, FEA is a In theory, there are no limits to the types of
numerical method used to solve a variety of applications that FEA can be used for. FEA
engineering problems that involve stress analysis, was born and nurtured in the automotive and
heat transfer, electromagnetism, and fluid flow. aerospace industries but has since spread to
encompass all other sectors of industry, from
FEA is in effect a computer simulation of the medical instruments and car design to plastic
whole process in which a physical prototype is mouldings and watch springs. If it can be designed,
built and tested, and then rebuilt and retested it can be modeled using FEA technology.
until an acceptable design is created.
2
In this section, we present some of the costs you "get it right the first time."
and benefits to consider when incorporating
virtual manufacturing into your product Improved quality
lifecycle management.
We have repeatedly seen our customers
Return improve their part quality by utilizing virtual
manufacturing techniques. There are numerous
MSC.Software customers around the world examples throughout this paper, and almost all
have seen their profits rise and costs decrease of them result in a part with quality produced at
dramatically in just months. Our technology has lower cost than previously attained through
helped increase efficiency from small projects to traditional prototyping techniques.
large and complex manufacturing processes.
Reduced time to market
Fewer prototypes
Time to market is becoming increasingly critical
The more trials you can simulate in a virtual in an age where information can be transmitted
environment, the less physical prototypes you and shared readily. Although virtual manufacturing
need to perfect your design. This means you may translate into spending more resources in
spend more time up front in engineering and the design and engineering phases, the resulting
design, and less resources running physical product will need much less rework downstream.
trials. Virtual prototyping is cheaper than building This saves enormously in unforeseen redesign
physical models and optimizing your design by and reengineering efforts.
trial-and-error. It is not a complete replacement
for physical testing, but it can minimize the effort Lower overall manufacturing cost
and enable the resulting physical tests to be
more successful. The bottom line is that our customers have had
success incorporating virtual manufacturing
Less material waste techniques into their processes, and none have
gone back to the traditional product design
If you build fewer physical models, you waste cycle. We are confident that you will also share
less material in the form of prototypes as well as in this success.
the tooling used to create them.
3
Costs
4
Virtual manufacturing significantly reduces fuel costs for Boeing
Problem
5
Shimming was minimized and waviness was
reduced resulting in exceptional skin quality.
Return on investment
6
Vir tual manufacturing optimizes r oll forming pr ocess
Problem
7
Deep drawing simulation r eveals manufacturing defect
Problem
8
Rubber boot r edesign lessens r epair costs
Problem
Solution
9
Side impact analysis of a car door r educes injuries
Problem
10
Connecting r od forging pr ocess developed vir tually
Problem
11
Vir tual pr ototyping impr oves buckle performance
Problem
In designing a snap buckle, several objectives
must be addressed including load required to
open and close, fatigue life of the clasp, acoustic
profile, weight, and cost. For this design, the
fatigue life was a critical component to provide
maximum customer satisfaction. In many
consumer products, the prevention of failure is
important to minimize warranty costs. By adjusting
the geometry in the design phase, one can
insure that the product is both reliable and has
the correct “feel” to the user.
Solution
12
Impr oved stent design saves lives
Problem
13
Why Vir tual Manufacturing Now?
Why virtual manufacturing now? Perhaps the Parallel Processing
best answer to this question is that the very
nature of simulation is the search for more Parallel Processing involves combining the
information. Every simulation acts as the resources of many CPU's or entire machines
vantage point from which one can better view and applying them to the solution of a single
the possibilities and then ask the next question. virtual manufacturing simulation.
That question generally requires a finer simulation,
or more of them, and as soon as that is available, The appeal of parallel processing is that it offers
someone will ask for the "optimum" solution. a means of simultaneously capitalizing on the
growth of chip performance and the potential
The primary limitation today in reaching this performance benefits of multiple chips.
optimum solution is problem size. The needs of
companies for faster solutions, for better and At the moment, there are two fundamental
better simulations, for more refined and accurate problems associated with parallel processing: the
simulations, and now for virtual manufacturing first is that most existing algorithms can derive
simulations leads to the unquenchable demand only limited benefits from the use of multiple
for more computational power. The computer CPUs; the second is Amdahl's Law, which
industry is delivering on that demand. loosely states that you can't parallelize a portion
of an algorithm and make a significant impact on
Computer Industry Maturing the total clock time.
In the past, simulations such as these were The solution to these two problems is to
limited to the largest of companies possessing redesign the algorithm to provide scalable
the largest of computers. That is no longer the performance across multiple CPUs for all
case. Today, all of our analysis and graphical aspects of the problem. At MSC.Marc, we saw
products operate on workstations that are readily the coming requirement for such a capability
available from a number of manufacturers running years ago when we started the parallel processing
any of the popular operating systems. project. It has been a long road with occasional
dead ends, but we are very pleased with the
Increasingly, the single most important factor in results of the research.
determining which computer you choose is
simply "How fast do you want your answers?"
14
The Key is Domain Decomposition
MSC.Marc DDM Software
Overall, the objective was to permit the user
Pioneered by MSC.Marc, the Domain to define the model without worrying about
Decomposition Method or DDM, involves parallel considerations.
dividing up the virtual manufacturing simulation The simulation is defined and the
into pieces, and feeding each piece separately analysis is ready to begin. The user is
to its own CPU. As the simulation progresses, asked one additional question: How
some steps of the simulation allow all the CPUs many CPUs are to be involved in the
to work by themselves. In other steps, all of the calculation? The GUI will then subdivide
CPUs have to come to an agreement about the model into as many domains as
results before continuing. This inter-domain there are CPUs, either interactively or
communication between CPUs is done with automatically. Then the analysis is
message-passing interface or MPI. submitted and monitored automatically.
When done, the user can view the
The challenge was to provide scalability for the results in any domain or the entire
broadest possible range of nonlinear simulations model graphically.
for a sizable number of CPUs. The result is our
implementation of Domain Decomposition. This The concept of Domain Decomposition is
was a substantial challenge but now we are able straightforward. There is a mapping between the
to provide scalable performance for virtually all finite element model and the hardware. Each
of the linear and nonlinear analysis capabilities domain is handled by an individual CPU while
of MSC.Marc as well as our Vertical products. the interaction between domains is handled
This includes capabilities such as large deformation, using message passing between processors.
plasticity, viscoplastic effects, thermal effects,
and automated 3-D contact. Analysis using 4 CPUs
15
The Advanced Technology of MSC.Softwar e
MSC.Software offers a variety of products and MSC.Patran
services to help you build your Virtual
Manufacturing facility. From advanced FEA tools, MSC.Patran provides a complete software
to experts and consultants, a total solution, environment for companies performing simulation
enabling you to get started today leveraging the of mechanical products. MSC.Patran enables the
latest in virtual manufacturing technology. user to conceptualize, develop and test a product
using computer-based simulation prior to making
MSC.Marc and MSC.Marc Mentat manufacturing and material commitments. Major
manufacturers around the world use MSC.Patran
MSC.Marc allows the user to perform a wide as the basis for their product improvement
variety of structural, fluid, and coupled analyses process, reducing or eliminating costly physical
using the finite element method. These procedures prototyping and testing.
provide solutions for simple to complex linear
and nonlinear engineering problems. Analysts MSC.SuperForge
can graphically access all features via MSC.Marc
Mentat or the MSC.Patran interfaces. Also MSC.SuperForge provides a fast and easy to use
included in MSC.Marc is the parallel processing tool for forging engineers to analyze industrial
of large problems using Domain Decomposition. forging processes. Using MSC.SuperForge in
every day forging practice allows for the reduction
MSC.SuperForm of shop floor trials by optimizing the forging
process, using more economical and faster
MSC.SuperForm provides solutions to computer simulations. As a result, product
manufacturing problems including Hot and development time is shortened and product
Cold (Open or Closed) Forging, Extrusion, Axial quality is increased.
and Ring Rolling, Blanking, Cogging, Clading,
Thick Sheet Bending, and Cutting. MSC.SuperForm Backed by MSC.Software
uses the finite element method with a wealth of
material and process models to support your tool MSC.Software is the established information
design requirements. technology software and services provider
helping companies worldwide develop better
MSC.Nastran products faster. MSC.Software’s software and
services are used to enhance and automate the
MSC.Nastran is the premier computer aided product design and manufacturing process. The
engineering (CAE) tool that major manufacturers ability to model and test software prototypes has
worldwide rely on for their critical engineering cost effectively enabled manufacturers to design
computing needs to produce safe, reliable, faster and build everything from sophisticated aircraft
and optimized designs. and automobiles to electronic products.
Corporate:
MSC.Software Corporation
2 MacArthur Place
Santa Ana, California 92707 USA
+1 714 540.8900
Fax: +1 714 784.4056
Information Center:
1 800 642.7437 ext. 2500 (U.S. only)
1 978 453.5310 ext. 2500 (International)
Europe:
MSC.Software GmbH
Am Moosfeld 13
81829 Munich, Germany
+49 89 43 19 87 0
Fax: +49 89 43 61 71 6
Asia-Pacific:
MSC Japan Ltd.
Entsuji-Gadelius Bldg.
2-39, Akasaka 5-chome
Minato-ku, Tokyo 107-0052 Japan
+81 3 3505 0266
Fax: +81 3 3505 0914
MSC, Marc and Patran are registered trademarks of MSC.Software Corporation. Nastran is a
registered trademark of NASA.MSC.Nastran, MSC.Patran, MSC.Dytran, MSC.Marc
Mentat, MSC.SuperForm, MSC.SuperForge, MSC.Fatigue, are trademarks of MSC.Software
Corporation. All other trademarks are the property of their registered owners. All specifications
are subject to change without notice.