a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The effects of pre-swelling treatment of Shenhua coal at mild temperatures (less than 160 °C) on its hydro-
Received 8 August 2008 liquefaction properties were determined in this paper. It was found that with the increase of pre-swelling
Received in revised form 27 March 2009 temperature in tetralin (THN) up to 120 °C, the liquefaction conversions of swollen coals increased. However,
Accepted 30 March 2009
when N-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone (NMP) was used as swelling solvent, the liquefaction conversion decreased
with the increase of pre-swelling temperature. The liquefied product distributions were very much
Keywords:
dependent on the pre-swelling pretreatment conditions, and the mechanism was discussed. Based on the
Pre-swelling treatment
Mild temperature
results obtained, a new swelling-liquefaction combining technology (SLCT) was advanced, in which the
Liquefaction liquefaction conversion and oil + gas yield were enhanced.
Coal © 2009 Published by Elsevier B.V.
coal at mild temperatures (less than 160 °C) on its liquefaction have
not been reported.
2. Experimental
Table 2
Swelling ratios of Shenhua coal in THN and NMP at different temperatures.
Table 3
Solubility of Shenhua Coal in THN and NMP at different temperatures (wt.%).
The CS2/NMP mixed solvent (1:1 by volume) was found to give higher
extraction yield for some bituminous coals and the synergistic effect
was attributed to the lowered viscosity of the system [23,24]. The
viscosity of NMP obviously decreases with the increase of tempera-
ture; therefore the solubility of coal in NMP will be greatly increased
during pre-swelling treatment at higher temperatures. This will cause
a stronger aggregation among swollen coal molecules [25,26],
resulting in the decrease in liquefaction conversions. Fig. 4 shows
the FTIR spectra of swollen coals pre-swelling treated at 120 °C in THN
and NMP respectively, comparing with that of raw coal. An increase in
intensity of band near 2920 cm− 1 assigned to CH3 stretch vibration for
the swollen coal pre-swelling treated in THN at 120 °C was observed. Fig. 5. Effect of swelling pre-treatment in THN at different temperatures on the
The increase in intensity of band near 2920 cm− 1 shows the increase liquefaction product distributions of Shenhua coal.
in the aliphatic hydrogen content of the pre-swelling treated coal. This
may suggest that hydrogen transfer from swelling solvent THN to coal
occurs during the pre-swelling process due to the good hydrogen the relaxing structure or expanded pore structure of swollen coal by
donating ability of THN. That is to say another mechanism of pre- pre-swelling treatment. On the other hand, higher solubility of coal in
swelling of coal in THN is H transferring from THN to coal, thus the swelling solvent at higher temperature may lead to strong
offering advantages for the further liquefaction of the swollen coal, aggregates formed in the swollen coal [19], thus decreases the
resulting in a great enhancement of liquefaction conversion for the porosity resulting in worse catalyst dispersion. In addition, the
pre-swelling treated coal in THN at this temperature. swelling solvent permeating the pores of swollen coal may also lead
to a worse dispersion of catalyst on the surface of coal pores. Further
related research work about catalyst dispersion is being carried out in
3.3. Effect of pre-swelling at mild temperatures on the liquefaction our group.
product distribution It is very interesting that pre-swelling of coal in THN at 120 °C
greatly increases the liquefaction conversion mentioned above. Based
The effects of pre-swelling treatment at different temperatures on on this result, a swelling-liquefaction combining technology (SLCT)
the hydro-liquefaction product distribution are shown in Figs. 5 and 6. was designed to check the pre-swelling effects again. The autoclave
Oil is of the most economically valuable fraction and more beneficial with coal, catalyst, hydrogen donation solvent THN and 4.0 MPa H2
for coal liquefaction. The yields of oil + gas decreased for all THN pressure charged was kept at 120 °C or 160 °C for 4 h. Then the
swollen coals except for 80 °C pre-swelling treated one compared to autoclave was heated to 400 °C at stirring and maintained at 400 °C for
that of raw coal. Pre-swelling in THN at 80 °C gave the highest yield of 30 min. The SLCT liquefaction result was compared with those of pre-
oil + gas 23.8%. It is interesting that the oil + gas yields of NMP swelling treatment in THN at 120 °C or 160 °C and raw coal as shown in
swollen coals pre-swelling treated from 40 °C to 120 °C are similar Table 4. Table 4 shows that the SLCT at 120 °C gives 67.6% of
with that of raw coal. However it dramatically decreased for the pre- conversion, which is a little lower than that of pre-swelling treatment
swelling in NMP at 160 °C. This is probably due to the worse catalyst at the temperature 70.0%, but is much higher than that of raw coal
dispersion [9,20] owing to the strong aggregation of swollen coal after 55.5%. In addition, SLCT also gives much higher of oil + gas yield 26.8%.
much of solubles dissolving in NMP during pre-swelling at this This is probably due to the better catalyst dispersion on the pore
temperature. surface of coal promoted by the first stage of swelling, which is
The dispersion of catalyst on the pore surface of coal may influence different from the case of pre-swelling in THN at 120 °C, where
the liquefaction product distribution. Pinto et al. [9] believed that catalyst was not added. Table 4 also shows that the SLCT at 160 °C gives
catalyst action on coal surface would lead to higher yield of lighter 63.6% of conversion, which is a little higher than that of pre-swelling
fractions, while a more internal catalyst action might lead to higher treatment at the temperature 57.6%, but is a little lower than that of
yield of asphaltene or preasphaltene. The effect of pre-swelling of coal SLCT at 120 °C. The oil + gas yields for the SLCTs at 120 °C and 160 °C
on the dispersion of catalyst may include two sides. On the one hand it are similar. The result further supports that the SLCT at 120 °C is an
is beneficial for the dispersion of catalyst on coal pore surface due to optimal pre-swelling condition, and it has great advantages compared
to the traditional single-stage liquefaction. It can also be speculated
that the operation cost of the SLCT is lower than that of the multi-
liquefaction mentioned above because of the lower pre-swelling
temperature in the SLCT. Therefore, this SLCT is a new and a very
Fig. 4. FTIR spectra of raw coal and its swollen coals pre-swelling in NMP and THN at Fig. 6. Effect of swelling pre-treatment in NMP at different temperatures on the
120 °C. liquefaction product distributions of Shenhua coal.
H. Shui et al. / Fuel Processing Technology 90 (2009) 1047–1051 1051
Table 4 References
Liquefaction comparison between pre-swelling treatment in THN at different
temperatures and SLCT. [1] J.G. Speight, The Chemistry and Technology of Coal, Second edition, Marcel Dekker,
Inc., New York, 1994, p. 439, revised and expanded.
Liquefaction Conversion,% Oil + gas,% Asphaltene,% Preasphaltene,% [2] R.A. Graff, S.D. Brandes, Modification of coal by subcritical steam: pyrolysis and
Raw coal 55.5 20.8 12.0 22.8 extraction yields, Energy Fuels 1 (1987) 84–86.
Pre-swelling (120 °C) 70.0 13.2 27.2 29.6 [3] S.D. Brandes, R.A. Graff, M.L. Gorbaty, M. Siskin, Modification of coal by subcritical
steam: an examination of modified Illinois No. 6 coal, Energy Fuels 3 (1989)
Pre-swelling (160 °C) 57.6 14.9 14.2 28.4
494–499.
SLCT (120 °C) 67.6 26.8 17.5 23.3
[4] P.R. Bienkowski, R. Narayan, R.A. Greenkorn, K. Chao, Enhanced coal liquefaction
SLCT (160 °C) 63.6 26.5 17.5 19.6
with steam pretreatment, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 26 (1987) 202–209.
[5] M. Iino, T. Takanohashi, C. Li, H. Kumagai, Increase in extraction yields of coals by
water treatment, Energy Fuels 18 (2004) 1414–1418.
attractive hydro-liquefaction technology, it can greatly increase the [6] H. Shui, Z. Wang, G. Wang, Effect of hydrothermal treatment on the extraction of
coal in the CS2/NMP mixed solvent, Fuel 12–13 (85) (2006) 1798–1802.
liquefaction conversion and oil + gas yield.
[7] Z. Wang, H. Shui, Z. Pei, J. Gao, Study on the hydrothermal treatment of Shenhua
coal, Fuel 87 (2008) 527–533.
4. Conclusions [8] H. Hu, G. Sha, G. Chen, Effect of solvent swelling on liquefaction of Xinglong coal at
less sever conditions, Fuel Process. Technol. 68 (2000) 33–43.
[9] F. Pinto, L.S. Gulyurtlu, L.S. Lobo, I. Cabrita, Effect of coal pre-treatment with
Pre-swelling treatment at mild temperatures can modify the swelling solvents on coal liquefaction, Fuel 78 (1999) 629–634.
liquefaction behavior of Shenhua coal. Pre-swelling temperature and [10] F. Derbyshire, A. Davis, M. Epstein, P. Stansberry, Temperature-staged catalytic coal
solvent used have great effects on the liquefaction. When THN is used liquefaction, Fuel 65 (1986) 1233–1239.
[11] P.J. Hall, H. Marsh, K.M. Thomas, Solvent induced swelling of coals to study
as swelling solvent, with the pre-swelling temperature increasing up macromolecular structure, Fuel 67 (1988) 863–866.
to 120 °C, the liquefaction conversions of the swollen coals increase, [12] L.M. Lucht, N.A. Peppas, Macromolecular structure of coals: 2. Molecular weight
then decrease with the increase of temperature to 160 °C. This is between crosslinks from pyridine swelling experiments, Fuel 66 (1987) 803–809.
[13] G.D. Cody, S. Eser, P. Hatcher, Temperature dependence of the swelling of coals in
consistent with the changing of swelling ratio. The maximal liquefac- pyridine, Energy Fuels 6 (1992) 716–719.
tion conversion of 70.0% is obtained at 120 °C pre-swelling treatment. [14] Y. Otake, E.M. Suuberg, Temperature dependence of solvent swelling and diffusion
When NMP is used as swelling solvent, the maximal liquefaction processes in coals, Energy Fuels 11 (1997) 1155–1164.
[15] T. Takanohshi, X. Fengjuan, I. Sanokawa, M. Iino, Effect of lighter constituents on
conversion of 61.2% is obtained for the swollen coal pre-swelling at
the solubility of heavy constituents of coals, Fuel 79 (2000) 955–960.
room temperature. Then the conversions decrease with the increasing [16] T. Suzuki, Development of highly dispersed coal liquefaction catalysts, Energy
of pre-swelling temperature, although the swelling ratios increase Fuel 8 (1994) 341–347.
[17] H. Shui, Z. Wang, M. Cao, Effect of pre-swelling of coal on its solvent extraction and
with the increase of temperature. The different effects between the
liquefaction properties, Fuel 87 (2008) 1908–2913.
two swelling solvents on the liquefaction conversion maybe related to [18] I. Mochida, K. Sakanishi, N. Suzuki, M. Sakurai, Y. Tsukui, T. Kaneko, Catal. Surv.
the further aggregation of coal macromolecular structure due to Jpn. 2 (1998) 17–24.
dissolving of solubles in the solvent during pre-swelling treatment [19] H. Hasuo, K. Sakanishi, H. Taniguchi, K. Kishino, I. Mochida, Effects of catalytic
activity and solvent composition on two-stage coal liquefaction, Ind. Eng. Chem.
and hydrogen transfer from THN to swollen coal. Res. 36 (1997) 1453–1457.
Pre-swelling treatments at mild temperatures have disadvantage [20] U. Priyanto, K. Sakanishi, O. Okuma, S.D.S. Murti, I. Watanabe, Y. Korai, I. Mochida,
to the oil + gas yield for the liquefaction of swollen coals compared to Optimization of two-stage liquefaction of Tanito Harum coal with FeNi catalyst
supported on carbon black, Energy Fuels 15 (2001) 856–862.
that of raw coal. A SLCT is designed and it shows that the SLCT at 120 °C [21] Y. Inukai, S. Arita, H. Hirosue, Effect of preheat treatment on coal liquefaction,
gives 67.6% of conversion and 26.8% of oil + gas yield, which are much Energy Fuel 9 (1995) 67–70.
higher than corresponding values of raw coal 55.5% and 20.8% [22] M. Fujiwara, H. Ohsuga, T. Takanohashi, M. Iino, Swelling of the extracts and
residues from carbon disulfide-N-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone mixed solvent extrac-
respectively, suggesting that it is a feasible coal liquefaction tion, Energy Fuels 6 (1992) 859–862.
technology. [23] M. Iino, T. Takanohashi, H. Ohsuga, Extraction of coals with CS2-N-methyl-2-
pyrrolidinone mixed solvent at room temperature/effect of coal bank and
synergism of the mixed solvent, Fuel 67 (1988) 1639–1647.
Acknowledgments [24] H. Shui, Z. Wang, Examination of the role of CS2 in the CS2/NMP mixed solvents to
coal extraction, Fuel Process. Technol. 87 (2006) 185–190.
This work was supported by the Natural Scientific Foundation of [25] T. Takanohashi, T. Yanagida, M. Iino, Extraction and swelling of low-rank coals with
various solvents at room temperature, Energy Fuel 10 (1996) 1128–1132.
China (20676001,20876001), the International Cooperative Project of
[26] H. Shui, Effect of coal extracted with NMP on its aggregation, Fuel 84 (2005)
Anhui Province (07080703001) and the National High Technology 939–941.
Research and Development Program of China (863 Program
2007AA06Z113). Authors are also appreciative for the financial
support from the Provincial Innovative Group for Processing & Clean
Utilization of Coal Resource.