Technical Approach
and Methodology
15 95% 14.25 15 75% 11.25 15 80% 12 15 80% 12
Work Plan 5 90% 4.5 5 75% 3.75 5 80% 4 5 80% 4
Organization and
Staffing 5 95% 4.75 5 70% 3.5 5 80% 4 5 60% 3
TOTAL Scores 25 23.5 25 18.5 25 20 25 19
TOTAL Scores 3 71% 2.14 3 35% 1.05 3 53% 1.60 3 60% 1.81
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Consultant's Name: ELC Electroconsult S.p.A.Italian 0
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Consultant's Name: Power Grid Corporation of India Limited,Indian
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 kV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Consultant's Name: JV of Roeng T.E.C and Intec-GOPA Internatinal Energy Consultants,Germany
General Qualifications Adequacy for the Assignment
(30%) (60%) Experience in Region
and Language (10%)
Rating Score (P x Points (P) Rating Score (P x Points (P) Rating
Points (P) Score (P x R)
S/No. Key Staff/Experts Point (R)% R) (R)% R) (R)%
0 1 2 3 4 5.00 6 7 8 9 10 11
1. Electrical Engineers 5
Melaku Mamo-Electrical Engineer- 1 1.5 80% 1.20 3 70% 2.1 0.5 80% 0.4
G/hiywot Wondwosen-Electrical Engineer- 2 1.5 75% 1.13 3 65% 1.95 0.5 80% 0.4
Tesfaye Delessa -Electrical Engineer -3 1.5 75% 1.13 3 75% 2.25 0.5 80% 0.4
Alemayehu Teklearegai -Electrical Engineer -4 1.5 75% 1.13 3 75% 2.25 0.5 80% 0.4
Samson Tesfaye -Electrical Engineer -5 1.5 70% 1.05 3 70% 2.1 0.5 80% 0.4
Demissie Asfaw -Electrical Engineer -6 1.5 70% 1.05 3 70% 2.1 0.5 80% 0.4
Avevraged sub-Total 1.11 2.13 0.40
2. Civil Engineer 3
Stefan SISU-Civil Engineer -1 0.9 65% 0.59 1.8 60% 1.08 0.3 80% 0.24
Terefe Andualem-Civil Engineer -2 0.9 90% 0.81 1.8 90% 1.62 0.3 80% 0.24
Abas Kedir oumer-Civil Engineer -3 0.9 75% 0.68 1.8 70% 1.26 0.3 80% 0.24
Marius Florin -Civil Engineer -4 0.9 80% 0.72 1.8 70% 1.26 0.3 60% 0.18
Kassahun Adera -Civil Engineer -5 0.9 75% 0.68 1.8 70% 1.26 0.3 80% 0.24
Serawit Reta -Civil Engineer -6 0.9 70% 0.63 1.8 70% 1.26 0.3 80% 0.24
Avevraged sub-Total 0.68 1.29 0.23
3. Sr. Environmentalist 2
Zeleke Chafamo-Sr. Environmentalist -1 0.6 80% 0.48 1.2 80% 0.96 0.2 80% 0.16
Silviu Harabagiu -Sr. Environmentalist -2 0.6 75% 0.45 1.2 75% 0.9 0.2 75% 0.15
Avevraged sub-Total 0.47 0.93 0.16
4. Sr. Social specialist 2
Jane Mugano-Sr. Social specialist -1 0.6 75% 0.45 1.2 75% 0.9 0.2 75% 0.15
Sr. Social specialist -2 0.6 80% 0.48 1.2 75% 0.9 0.2 75% 0.15
Avevraged sub-Total 0.47 0.90 0.15
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Evaluator Seble Masresha
Consultant's Name: WSP UK Limited,UK
1 Michael Allison-Resident Project Manager 10 3 80% 2.40 6 85% 5.1 1 85% 0.85 8.35
2 Allan Burns-Substation Equipment Design Engineer 7 2.1 80% 1.68 4.2 90% 3.78 0.7 80% 0.56 6.02
3 Peter Watson-Protection and Contro Design Engineer 5 1.5 85% 1.28 3 85% 2.55 0.5 80% 0.40 4.23
Michael Thomas Feasey-Communication and SCADA Design
4 Engineer 3 0.9 85% 0.77 1.8 90% 1.62 0.3 80% 0.24 2.63
5 Jim Yare-Transformer specialist 2 0.6 80% 0.48 1.2 90% 1.08 0.2 80% 0.16 1.72
6 Martin Safranek-Transmission Line Design Engineer 5 1.5 85% 1.28 3 80% 2.4 0.5 85% 0.43 4.1
7 Nair Purushothaman-Civil Design Engineer 5 1.5 85% 1.28 3 80% 2.4 0.5 85% 0.43 4.10
9 Zewdu Gebreyohannes -Protection and Control Engineer 4 1.2 80% 0.96 2.4 80% 1.92 0.4 80% 0.32 3.2
10 KH Mak-Communication and SCADA Engineer 4 1.2 90% 1.08 2.4 90% 2.16 0.4 80% 0.32 3.56
Total 45.93
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Evaluator Seble Masresha
Consultant's Name: ELC Electro consult SPA, Italian
3 Roberto Rebuffoni-Protection and Contro Design Engineer 5 2 95% 1 3 90% 3 1 90% 0.5 4.58
4 Egidio Mangioni-Communication and SCADA Design Engineer 3 1 95% 1 2 95% 2 0.3 90% 0.3 2.84
5 Gabrieli Oggioni-Transformer specialist 2 1 95% 1 1 90% 1 0 90% 0 1.83
10 Vincenzo Maugeri-Communication and SCADA Engineer 4 1 85% 1 2 80% 2 0.40 90% 0.4 3.30
11 Civil Engineers 3 1 2 0.3 2.71
12 Antonio Komelli-Procurement and Contracts Engineer/ Expert 3 1 90% 1 2 80% 1 0.30 80% 0.24 2.49
13 Sr. Environmentalists 2 0.6 0.5 1.2 1.1 0.20 0.2
14 Sr. Social specialists 2 0.6 0.5 1.2 1.1 0.20 0.17 1.7
Total 50.41
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Evaluator Seble Masresha
Consultant's Name: Power Grid Corporation India Limited,Indian
4 Santosh Kumar-Communication and SCADA Design Engineer 3 1 85% 0.8 1.8 85% 1.53 0 80% 0.24 2.54
5 Gunjan Agrawal-Transformer specialist 2 1 70% 0.4 1.2 75% 0.9 0 80% 0.16 1.48
6 Chandra Kant-Transmission Line Design Engineer 5 2 80% 1.2 3 80% 2.4 1 80% 0.40 4.00
7 Sanjay Shama-Civil Design Engineer 5 2 75% 1.1 3 80% 2 1 50% 0.25 3.775
8 Electrical Engineers 5 1.1 2.18 0.34 3.63
9 Mahendra Singh -Protection and Control Engineer 4 1 80% 1.0 2.4 80% 1.92 0.4 80% 0.32 3.2
10 Furkan Ahmad -Communication and SCADA Engineer 4 1 80% 1.0 2.4 80% 1.92 0.4 80% 0.32 3.2
11 Civil Engineers 3 0.5 1.02 0.23 1.79
Kaushalendra Singh -Procurement and Contracts Engineer/
12 Expert 3 1 80% 0.7 1.8 80% 1.44 0.3 85% 0.26 2.42
13 Sr. Environmentalists 2 0.5 1.02 0.14
14 Sr. Social specialists 2 0.5 1.11 0.2 0.16 1.81
Total 45.75
Consultancy service for LOT-1: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Substations
LOT-2: Azezo-Chilga, Fincha II-Shambu and Metu-Masha 230 KV Transmission Lines
Assignment
Country Ethiopia
Project Electricity Network Reinforcement and Expansion Project- Additional Finance
Evaluator Seble Masresha
Consultant's Name: JV of Roeng T.E.C and Intec-GOPA Internatinal Energy Consultants,Germany
4 Alain WALLISER-Communication and SCADA Design Engineer 3 0.9 80% 0.72 1.8 75% 1.35 0.3 75% 0.23 2.30
5 Jerzy Kossowski-Transformer specialist 2 0.6 70% 0.42 1.2 70% 0.84 0.2 70% 0.14 1.40
6 Henry-Silviu Wechsler-Transmission Line Design Engineer 5 1.5 70% 1.05 3 70% 2.10 0.5 75% 0.38 3.53
7 George Adrian Copoiu-Civil Design Engineer 5 1.5 70% 1.05 3 75% 2.250 0.5 70% 0.35 3.65
8 Electrical Engineers 5 1.5 1.05 3 2.00 0.5 0.40 3.45
9 Sorin Toma-Protection and Control Engineer 4 1.2 75% 0.90 2.4 70% 1.68 0.4 75% 0.30 2.88
10 Horia Petric- Communication and SCADA Engineer 4 1.2 75% 0.90 2.4 70% 1.68 0.4 75% 0.30 2.88
11 Civil Engineers 3 0.9 0.65 1.8 1.08 0.3 0.23 1.96
12 Matthias SPATZ-Procurement and Contracts Engineer/ Expert 3 0.9 70% 0.63 1.8 75% 1.35 0.3 70% 0.21 2.19
13 Sr. Environmentalists 2 0.6 0.47 1.2 0.93 0.2 0.16
14 Sr. Social specialists 2 0.6 0.47 1.20 0.90 0.15 1.52
Total 43.97