Anda di halaman 1dari 85

Community Health Assessment for Pima County

Health Education Council B

University of Arizona

October 25, 2018


2
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Contributors to the Community Health Assessment

Learning Team 6: Richelle Ainza, Sandra Gorayeb, Lily Jaeger, Peter Ma, Gabby Vosburgh,
Corelle Wickramasekera
Learning Team 7: Yasmine Arias, Cassandra Corrington, ToniAnne Gray, Carly Knolles,
Kiara Lopez, Lindsey Murphy, Carlye Robertson
Learning Team 8: Olivia Bucho, Chandler Everett, Diana Grijalva, Brittney Milnor, Calista
Rocha, Ciara Walden
Learning Team 9: Jaylene Arvizu, Kelsey Camps, Alison Johnson, Sarah Leahy, Ashleigh
Pendleton, Francesca Scardino
Learning Team 10: Ibtihal Amailou, Saby Castillo, Lauren Krebs, Taylor McQuillin, Luke
Roberts, Jayati Sharma
3
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Table of Contents

List of Tables ..................................................................................................................................4

List of Figures .................................................................................................................................5

Introduction ....................................................................................................................................6

Geography and Environment of Pima County ...........................................................................7

Demographic Information...........................................................................................................12

Socioeconomic Stratification .......................................................................................................14

Health Statistics ............................................................................................................................19

Local Health Resources ...............................................................................................................24

Cultural Factors ...........................................................................................................................27

The County’s Governmental Organization/Function...............................................................30

Housing .........................................................................................................................................34

Food Supply ..................................................................................................................................38

Education ......................................................................................................................................40

School Health and Nutrition Programs .....................................................................................47

Social Welfare Programs .............................................................................................................51

Transportation .............................................................................................................................54

Occupational Data .......................................................................................................................59

Other Community Factors Impacting Health ...........................................................................61

Summary .......................................................................................................................................66

References .....................................................................................................................................70
4
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

List of Tables

Table 1. Pima County Population Demographics. .........................................................................13


Table 2. Leading Causes of Morbidity in Pima County. ...............................................................20
Table 3. Cancer Incidence Rates in Pima County by Race. ..........................................................21
Table 4. Yearly Cost of Housing in Pima County ........................................................................35
Table 5. Educational Attainment in Pima County by Race, Gender, and Level of Education. .....41
Table 6. Student Meal Prices for the 2017-2018 School Year. ....................................................47
Table 7. After School Meal & Snack Programs: Meal Sites. ........................................................49
Table 8. After School Meal & Snack Programs: Snack Sites. .....................................................50
Table 9. After School Meal & Snack Programs: Snack Sites. .......................................................1
5
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

List of Figures

Figure 1. Map of Pima County. .......................................................................................................7

Figure 2. TCE Contamination ..........................................................................................................9

Figure 3. Pima County Demographics ...........................................................................................13

Figure 4. Poverty Statistics ............................................................................................................15

Figure 5. Poverty Rate by Age (2016).. .........................................................................................16

Figure 6. Poverty Rate by Race & Ethnicity (2016). .....................................................................16

Figure 7. Poverty Rate Comparisons between Tucson, Arizona, and the U.S. (2016). .................17

Figure 8. Pima County Employment Statistics ..............................................................................17

Figure 9. Median Household Income. ...........................................................................................18

Figure 10. Pima County Occupations. ...........................................................................................19

Figure 11. Percent of Reported Cases of Communicable Diseases. ..............................................20

Figure 12. Total Mortality Rates from All Causes. .......................................................................23

Figure 13. Health Reports for Arizona, by County.. ......................................................................24

Figure 14. Poverty by Age and Gender in Pima County. ..............................................................29

Figure 15. Pima County Organizational Chart. .............................................................................30

Figure 16. Monthly Cost of Housing in Pima County. ..................................................................36

Figure 17. Zip Code Project Data. .................................................................................................44

Figure 18. Increasing Diversity in Arizona Charter Schools Over Time. .....................................44

Figure 19. Common Methods of Transportation in Pima County .................................................55


6
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Introduction

A Community Health Assessment (often known as a community health needs assessment

or a CHA) is a thorough assessment of a community’s health status, needs, and issues “through

systematic, comprehensive data collection and analysis,” according to the Centers for Disease

Control and Prevention (CDC, 2015). A CHA allows for a deep and all-inclusive evaluation of a

community’s strengths and weaknesses and characterizes areas in which the community can

improve its ability to promote individual and population health. The publication of the CHA

allows for the development and eventual implementation of policies, laws, and regulations that

promote public health awareness and improve or establish health promotion initiatives in the

community of interest.

Pima County is the second largest population in Arizona, and is home to unique

dynamics in that it borders Mexico and is home to a large Latino population. Within the

following document is a holistic examination of several factors influencing the general health

status of Pima County, these including: geography, demographic information, socioeconomic

stratification, health statistics, local health resources, housing, food supply, transportation, and

many other such factors represented throughout the CHA. Through the assessment, this

document seeks to identify subpopulations that face significant health challenges in Pima

County, and how these disparities can be mitigated.


7
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Geography and Environment of Pima County


Pima County is located in the southern part of Arizona and north of the Sonora, Mexico

border. Pima is one of fifteen current counties and one of four original counties in the state of

Arizona. The county expands roughly 9,200 square miles and the elevation ranges from

approximately 1,200 feet to 9,185 feet, the peak of Mount Lemmon (Pima County, 2016a).

Within Pima County, there is the Coronado National Forest, Catalina State Park, Organ Pipe

Cactus National Monument, Ironwood National Monument, Buenos Aires National Wildlife

Refuge and Saguaro National Park (Pima County, 2016a). Also, there are two Native tribe

reservations: the Tohono O’odham Nation and the Pascua Yaqui Nation.

Figure 1. Map of Pima County.


Image retrieved from:
https://pimamaps.pima.gov/Html5Viewer/index.html?configBase=https://pimamaps.pima.gov/G
eocortex/Essentials/REST/sites/mainsite/viewers/mainmap/virtualdirectory/Resources/Config/De
fault
The environment of Pima County includes a number of mountain ranges including Puerto

Blanco Mountains, Sonoyta Mountains, Sikort Chuapo Mountains, Santa Rosa Mountains,
8
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Comobart Mountains, Coyote Mountains, Alvarez Mountains, Tortolita Mountains, Tucson

Mountains, Santa Rita Mountains, and Santa Catalina Mountains (Pima County, 2016a). Pima

County determines air quality by using the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) National

Ambient Air Quality Standards, which uses two standards, Primary Standard, which provides

public health protections, and Secondary Standard, which provides public welfare protections

(EPA, 2017). The current air quality usually ranges in the “good” condition meaning it meets

both of the standards. (Pima County, 2018a). Pima County has mainly a desert environment that

affects its climates with average high summer temperatures of 100 degrees Fahrenheit and

average low summer temperatures of 72 degrees Fahrenheit and average high winter

temperatures of 73 degrees Fahrenheit and average low winter temperatures of 50 degrees

Fahrenheit. Annually, Pima County gets around 12 inches of rain (U.S Climate Data, 2017).

The residents of Pima County face numerous issues in regards to the threats posed by the

environment and geography. The primary concern that has become the forefront of many

campaigns is the issue of water quality and safety. Since the early 1940s, the chemical

Trichlorethylene (TCE), has been continually dumped into groundwater supplies of the south

side of Tucson by the company, Hughes Aircraft, as well as the city of Tucson. This industrial

solvent caused a multitude of health issues seen within the residents of south Tucson, such issues

include: cancer, lupus, central nervous disorders, and birth defects (Davis, 2017). In 1981,

lawsuits were brought forward by south Tucson’s residents claiming that TCE can be linked to

the health issues that have arisen since the contamination began. However, it was not until 1987

that the city of Tucson worked to clean the contaminated wells and provide residents with clean

drinking water (Trichlorethylene, 2014). Through continued inaction and negligence, the

residents of south Tucson are extremely hesitant to drink the water provided to them from the
9
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

city of Tucson. Unfortunately, the health issues that arose from the chemical, TCE, affected

certain populations within the city of Tucson. In 2016, the poverty rate of south Tucson was

48.9%, with a population of 5,627 (South, 2016), indicating that many individuals who were

primarily lower socioeconomic status in south Tucson were disproportionately affected by the

contaminated water compared to their wealthier counterparts.

Figure 2. TCE Contamination.


Image retrieved from: http://coep.pharmacy.arizona.edu/tce/tce_plume_large.html
Another issue that affects a different population within Pima County surrounds the

problem of air quality. Southern Arizona faces numerous dust storms throughout the year, and

with that comes unexpected health consequences that primarily affect those who have breathing

problems as well as the elderly. Such health problems include asthma attacks, cause or aggravate

bronchitis and other lung diseases, as well as impacting the body’s ability to withstand infections

(Dust, n.d.). In 2016, the number of inpatient discharges for asthma in Pima County was 10,481

with 3,558 being male and 7,283 being female. The demographics included 6,971 White Non-

Hispanic, 2,549 Hispanic or Latino, 628 Black or African-American, 484 American Indian or
10
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Alaska Native, 121 Asian or Pacific Islander, and 86 Refused (Arizona Department of Health

Services, 2017). Also noted in the 2016 report was the third leading cause of death in the elderly

(65+) being chronic lower respiratory diseases, which can be greatly impacted by the air quality.

The number of deaths in the elderly due to chronic lower respiratory diseases for Pima County

was 493 in 2016. (Pima County, 2018a). The demographics for the total number of cases for

chronic lower respiratory diseases in the year 2016 include 3,432 for White non-Hispanic, 211

for Hispanic or Latino, 87 for Black or African-American, 38 for American Indian or Alaska

Native, and 20 for Asian or Pacific Islander (Pima County, 2016a).

Extreme heat is also another concern that many residents face during the summer months.

Pima County’s average temperature for the month of July is 104 degrees Fahrenheit, with many

of those days reaching temperatures in the 105-110 degree Fahrenheit range (Pima County,

2018s). Through continued exposure to extreme heat and the body’s limited ability to retain

homeostasis, many residents of Pima County face dehydration, heat strokes, and even death.

From 2006-2016, Pima County accounted for 40% of deaths in the state of Arizona due to

exposure to natural heat (Sagna et al., 2018). A group that is substantially impacted by the

extreme heat is undocumented immigrants. In 2016, 26% of the deaths of undocumented

immigrant remains identified by the Pima County medical examiner were caused by exposure to

extreme heat combined with dehydration (Pima County Office, 2017). Also, to be noted is that

with this extreme heat and overexposure to the sun and UV rays comes the potential health

concern of skin cancer. It was found that, in 2015, Pima County’s incidence rate for melanoma

of the skin was 25.8 cases per 100,000 individuals, the highest rate out of any county in the state

(State Cancer Profiles, 2015).


11
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Invasive species of vegetation that are causing a substantial impact in the environment in

Pima County include brome, buffelgrass, Lehmann’s lovegrass, Boer’s lovegrass, and Johnson

grass. These various types of grasses have led to extreme fire hazards, the crowding out of

natural plants, and changing the current biome of the Sonoran Desert (Buffelgrass, n.d.). These

types of grasses can burn at over 1000 degrees and almost three times hotter than the natural

vegetation that burns in the Sonoran Desert, thus resulting in the destruction of the natural flora

in Pima County (Buffelgrass, n.d.). Different weeds that are also causing problems within Pima

County include various varieties of mustard and Malta starthistle and Centaurea melitensis

(Invasive, n.d.). Because of the various threats posed by these vegetation species, Pima County

has enlisted the help of volunteers and organizations to combat the constantly growing problem

of proliferating non-native grasses and weeds. Despite unanimous consensus that not only the

native vegetation but homes and communities may be threatened, these grasses and weeds

continue to prove financially difficult as well as time-consuming to deal with. Until a financially

feasible and time-friendly solution can be found, the problem with the vegetation in Pima County

will continue.

The health risks that affect any population or group of individuals related to the county’s

geography and population primarily surround the individuals who may be disproportionately

affected by their surroundings because of a lack of resources to meet required needs. Such

groups include the elderly, homeless, and lower socioeconomic status individuals, children,

immigrants, and minorities. These populations are affected by their environment and geography

due to the lack of access to much needed resources that stems from inadequate health care

systems in place, negligent education in regards to all aspects of an individual, and a lack of
12
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

services that can work to limit the illnesses, diseases, and complications that affect at-risk

populations.

However, Pima County is working diligently to place resources within reach for at-risk

populations. To address overexposure to heat in Pima County, for example, many organizations

such as the Salvation Army, Frontera, Pima County Libraries and others provide resources to the

homeless in regards to ‘cooling off’ during the summer months. Other resources that are being

applied to combat the mentioned asthma and other breathing problems include the University of

Arizona partnership with the Tucson Unified School District to implement an asthma-based

program that works to educate children about asthma (Kelly, 2018). A Pima County initiative

that aims to address the heat-related deaths is through educating communities on how to stay safe

during the extreme heat. Pima County officials have released tips and information regarding the

signs and symptoms of heat-related illnesses as well as how to prepare and care for your body

during outside activities (Long, 2018). Resources that focus on enabling each and every single

individual to reach their full potential regardless of the environment and geography that

surrounds a county will be required to limit health care costs while allowing individuals to

participate fully in the community.

Demographic Information

Out of the 6,728,577 residents of Arizona, 1,003,338 reside in Pima County (US Census,

2017). The greater part of Pima’s population (78.1%) consists of those who are 18 years or older,

followed by those who are 65 years or older (17.8%) and children under 5 years old (5.9%).

Females make up 50.8% of the population in Pima County whereas males make up 49.2%. These

sex demographics are similar to those of the state of Arizona where females make up 50.3% and

males make up 49.7% of the total population.


13
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The majority of residents in Pima County are White (95.9%), followed by Black (3.5%),

American Indian or Alaskan Native (3.2%), Asian (2.7%), and Native Hawaiian or Pacific

Islander (0.1%). A total of 36.1% of Pima County residents identify as Hispanic or Latino

ethnicity (any race). White individuals make up the majority of each age cohort, followed closely

behind Hispanics. The age group 0-4 shows very similar levels of both White and Hispanic

individuals (Pima County, 2016a).

Figure 3. Pima County Demographics


Image retrieved from: https://statisticalatlas.com/county/Arizona/Pima-County/Race-and-
Ethnicity#figure/relative-ethno-racial-composition-by-age

Table 1. Pima County Population Demographics.


Pima County Arizona

Population (2016 estimate) 1,003,338 6,728,577


% Male 49.2 49.7
% Female 50.8 50.3
% under 5 years old 5.9 6.5
% 18 years or older 78.1 75.9
% 65 years or older 17.8 15.9
% of race White 95.9 96.7
% of race Black 3.5 4.3
14
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

% race American Indian or 3.2 4.4


Alaskan Native
% race Asian 2.7 3.1
% Native Hawaiian or Pacific 0.1 0.2
Islander
% Hispanic or Latino 36.1 30.5
ethnicity (any race)
(Pima County Population Demographics, 2016)

Socioeconomic Stratification

Socioeconomic stratification is when a society categorizes people based on factors such

as income, wealth, race, education, and power. The system could be thought of as a ranking or

hierarchy. For example, in the United States it is apparent that the government and society in

general takes status into consideration when determining power and wealth (Lumen, 2018).

Socioeconomic status on the other hand is a combination of a person's work experience and

social position compared to others income, education, and occupation. In regards to

socioeconomic stratification and socioeconomic status, it is important to fully understand the

term poverty and all of its aspects. Poverty is the condition of not meeting the basic needs to get

by on a day to day basis. There are two different forms of poverty, one being absolute poverty

meaning that the individual does not have enough resources to maintain adequate physical

health. The second classification of poverty is relative poverty, which refers to when people do

not enjoy a level of living according to the government. In addition to the proposed poverty line,

Pima County is now ranked to be number two in poverty. A study conducted by the Bureau of

Economic Analysis concluded that the average Arizonan earns far less compared to numerous

states. The average annual income in Pima County in particular was calculated to be $33,259

even with multiple assistance such as the Recovery Act and other programs providing aide with

tax relief and support on multiple levels; Americans were barely kept out of poverty.
15
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 4. Poverty Statistics of Pima County.


Image retrieved from: https://tucson.com/news/local/arizona-is-now-no-in-
poverty/article_551a7372-415a-5dc5-a27d-ab19a1171e81.html

In terms of how poverty is measured and reported, the United States determine the

official poverty is measured by comparing approximately 100,000 addresses in the course of

three months (February, March, and April). The estimates are collected through the Current

Population Survey Annual Social and Economic Supplement (CPS ASEC). Poverty in

comparison to the official poverty measure has a similar process. The main difference is the

United States compares a person's income to the set poverty threshold and all those who earn less

are then considered poor. The same process takes effect when creating the family's income

(University of Wisconsin-Madison, 2018). The individual median household income in Pima

County was calculated to $47,560 and the individual income was then calculated to about half at

a total of $26,204.
16
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 5. Poverty Rate by Age (2016).


Image retrieved from: https://mapazdashboard.arizona.edu/health-social-well-being/poverty-rate

Figure 6. Poverty Rate by Race & Ethnicity (2016).


Image retrieved from:https://mapazdashboard.arizona.edu/health-social-well-being/poverty-rate
17
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 7. Poverty Rate Comparisons between Tucson, Arizona, and the U.S. (2016).
Image retrieved from: https://mapazdashboard.arizona.edu/health-social-well-being/poverty-rate

When comparing the multiple graphs, it is crucial to take into consideration the

relationship of educational attainment level to the individual and family income, race/ ethnicity,

family household and sex. Throughout Pima County, the average male salary is $59,876 in

comparison to female, the female average salary is $45,805. In 2016, it was calculated that a

male earned 1.31% more than a female regardless of their occupation. In the graph below, it

shows the five most common occupations and a comparison of the wages earned by a male or

female as a full-time employee.

Figure 8. Pima County Employment Statistics.


Image retrieved from: https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/
18
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Similar to the female average salary, the household income is less than the average

median annual income. The United States is slightly over $55,000 while Pima County is

averaged at an approximate of $47,560.

Figure 9. Median Household Income.


Image retrieved from: https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/

In addition to gender differences, race and ethnicity have become an important factor in

determining wages. Asians earn the highest wages in Pima County (averaging $61,346),

followed by Caucasian earning $48,799. In addition, Figure X (shown below) is constructed of

nine different colors each representing a race; light blue is American Indian, turquoise is Asian,

orange represents White, light orange is African-American, purple is Pacific Islander, dark blue

is two or more races, navy blue is unknown, yellow represents American Indian, and finally red

is Alaskan Native. For four of the common occupations, every race/ethnicity is within a close

proximity of the average salary. It is in the miscellaneous managers section in which Asians

exceed the average salary by triple the average amount.


19
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 10. Pima County Occupations.


Image retrieved from: https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/

Health Statistics
Pima County has a total population of 1,022,769 people (U.S. Census Bureau, 2016).

Pima County has a diverse population that experiences a variety of health outcomes. These

health outcomes are influenced by several factors, including race, gender, ethnicity and age. The

incidence of communicable diseases is depicted in Figure 11. It is apparent that influenza is the

most prominent infectious disease among the residents of Pima County and that valley fever

follows as a close second. This figure depicts the morbidity among communicable diseases in

Pima County, it is obvious that a majority of these communicable diseases could be avoided and

prevented.
20
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 11. Percent of Reported Cases of Communicable Diseases


Infectious Disease Epidemiology. (2013)
The most common causes of morbidity in Pima County are included the figure below.

Table 2 shows the behaviors and preventative actions that influence morbidity in Pima County

and Arizona as a whole. For example, Pima County as a whole has a higher binge drinking

average than the rest of Arizona (Healthy Pima, 2018).

Table 2. Leading Causes of Morbidity in Pima County.


Cause of Morbidity Pima County Arizona
Binge Drinking 17.5% 13.4%
Smoking 16.4% 16.3%
Overweight/Obese 59.5% 61.9%
Colon Cancer Screening 15.0% 15.0%
Pap Test History 78.7% 73.3%
Mammogram 75.5% 69.5%
Diabetic Monitoring 81% 79%
Physical Inactivity 30% 21%
(Healthy Pima, 2018)

The leading cases of noncommunicable diseases in Pima County are obesity, diabetes,

asthma, and cancer, each of these diseases affect all demographics independently (Healthy Pima,

2018). Diabetes has the highest rates among American Indian/Alaska Native individuals; this

group’s average morbidity rate from diabetes in the population in 2015 was 18.4%. The
21
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Black/African-American group followed with 13.1% of the population being burdened by

diabetes. 11.2% of Hispanics and 9.5% of Whites were affected by diabetes in Pima County. The

group with the lowest morbidity due to diabetes was the Asian/Pacific Islander group at 4.0%.

Diabetes specifically affects the following age groups: ages 65+ (20.1%), 55-65 (17.7%), and 45-

54 (12%). The younger groups, 35-44 (5.2%), 25-34 (2.4%), and 18-24 (1.4%), are generally not

as burdened with diabetes as are the older groups (Sagna et al., 2017). Men, on average, have

greater morbidity rates of diabetes (10.9%) when compared to females (9.7%) (Sagna et al.,

2017).

Cancer is also a leading morbidity in Arizona; this disease takes many lives and affects

all ethnicities, genders and groups differently. The table below demonstrates the incidence of

cancer among all ethnicities, it is apparent that non-white Hispanics are the most affected by

cancer in Pima County, followed by Blacks, White Hispanics, American Indians, and Asian &

Pacific Islander. The cancer statistics for Pima County indicate that men (381.5 cases of cancer

per 100,000 men) have higher rates of cancer than women (342.9 cases of cancer per 100,000

women) (Humble, 2010). Pima County’s most prevalent cancer is breast cancer, shortly followed

by lung/bronchial cancer (Synergy: Lifestyle Medicine, 2018).

Table 3. Cancer Incidence Rates in Pima County by Race.


Race Incidence Rate per 100,000 persons
White Non-Hispanic 408.0
White Hispanic 271.2
Black 316.9
American Indian 256.5
Asian & Pacific Islander 234.5
All Races 379.78
(ADHS, 2018)

There are different mortality rates for people living in Pima County of different age

groups, sex, and racial/ethnic groups. According to the Arizona Department of Health Services
22
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

(AZDHS), The leading cause of death in infants is related to low birth weight, and the leading

cause of death in children (age 1-14 years) is congenital brain malfunction (AZDHS, 2018). The

most deaths in adolescents (15-19 years) are caused by motor vehicle accidents, while the main

cause of death in young adults (20-44 years) is “assault by other and unspecified firearm

discharge”. The main cause of death in both mid age (45-64) and aged (85+) is chronic ischemic

heart disease (AZDHS, 2018). Lastly, the main cause of death in the elderly (65-84) is also

chronic ischemic heart disease (Infectious Disease Epidemiology 2013).

Men and women in Pima County have different mortality rates and statistics. Deaths for

both genders in Pima County in 2017 reached 9,527 (Kemp et al., 2018). Men made up 52.7% of

these deaths, and women made up 47.3% of these total deaths (Kemp et al., 2018). Major

cardiovascular diseases were the leading cause of death in both males and females in Pima

County, with the second leading cause of death in men and women being malignant neoplasms

(Kemp et al., 2018).

Cardiovascular disease also was the leading cause of death in all racial and ethnic groups

in Arizona, with African-Americans having a higher death rate from this disease, at 266.8 deaths

per 100,000 cases. Malignant neoplasm was the second leading cause of death in all racial and

ethnic groups (Sagna et al., 2017).

As far as mortality goes for all racial and ethnic groups in Arizona, American Indians

have the highest rates of mortality and Asians have the lowest rates. In a count of per 100,000

individuals, 0.97% of American Indians died, followed by African-Americans at 0.83%, then

white non-Hispanics at 0.7%, then Hispanics at 0.6%, and lastly Asians at 0.41% (Sagna et al.,

2017).
23
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 12. Total Mortality Rates from All Causes


Image retrieved from: https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-stats
Within Arizona, people have perceptions and ideas of health status within genders,

racial/ethnic groups, and age groups. In Arizona, 81% of the population reported having good

health status, and 80% of Pima County residents reported good to excellent health (Bass et al.,

2014).
24
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 13. Health Reports for Arizona, by County.


Image retrieved from: https://azdhs.gov/preparedness/public-health-statistics/behavioral-risk-
factor-surveillance/index.php
A slightly higher rate of men than women reported good to excellent health, at 81.8%, as

opposed to women at 80.2% (Bass et al., 2014). The rate of people who reported good to

excellent health varied among age groups, at 91.3% for those 18-24, 85.5% for those 25-35,

84.4% for those 35-44, 77.7% for those 45-54, 73.6 for those 55-64, and finally 76% for those

65+ (Bass et al., 2014). Within racial and ethnic groups, Asian/Pacific islanders reported good

health at the highest rate at 91.4%, followed by white non-Hispanics at 83.7%, African-

Americans at 78.5%, Hispanics at 75.1%, and American Indians at 73.4% (Bass et al., 2014).

Local Health Resources

Residents of Pima County rely on multiple resources for their health service needs. With

the county’s population exceeding 1 million people, certain services need to be offered to take
25
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

action in providing healthcare for individuals across the area. A few governmental agencies that

provide health services are Pima County Health Department and Pima County Department of

Environmental Quality (PDEQ).

The Pima County Health Department is dedicated to helping residents of the county

maintain and achieve the highest level of wellness. This department offers a wide spectrum of

services. Their areas of services include advisories and alerts, preventative health, clinics and

maps, consumer health and food safety, behavioral health, education and outreach, resources for

professionals, sexual health, and personal records (Pima County, 2018j). Specific health services

from these categories include policies and procedures, immunizations, food recalls, prescription

medicine disposal, communicable disease reporting, treatment for HIV and sexually transmitted

diseases, and birth/death certificates. Environmental health is just as important as physical and

overall health. The PDEQ serves to protect the long-term benefits of the residents of Pima

County. This department is responsible for identifying and responding to environmental issues.

Their main areas of services include services in water, air, and waste and recycling. Specific

services include air quality monitoring, sewage collection systems, and the waste program

(Environmental Quality, 2018).

Community-based organizations that offer health services include Casa de los Niños and

United Way of Tucson and Southern Arizona. Casa de los Niños is a community-based

organization that was founded to protect children from child abuse and neglect. Specific services

include behavioral and mental health treatment, immediate crisis medication, and child abuse

prevention programs. Their main health service focus is on behavioral health, which includes

individual, family, and group therapy and psychiatric services (Urizar-Faught, 2018). The United

Way of Tucson and Southern Arizona (UWTSA) focuses on four main services for a healthy
26
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

community. The ELDER Alliance strives to ensure that adults stay healthy and active and

independent in the community. The End of Life Care Partnership is committed to ensuring

quality of life at every stage through education, support, sound policy and choices. UWTSA also

provides Affordable Care Act navigation services to those who need them so every Southern

Arizonan can have access to quality, affordable health insurance. UWTSA also works with

parent educators, childcare centers, and homes throughout the community to implement healthy

nutrition to decrease obesity among young children (Gray-Emmer, n.d.).

Faith-based organizations in Pima County include the Tucson Interfaith HIV/AIDS

Network or TIHAN, which is a non-profit organization that allows individuals and faith

communities to come together to reduce stigma and sustain hope for those living with

HIV/AIDS. This foundation has a program called “Living Well with HIV” that provides a

variety of classes, presentations, and discussions that support individuals with HIV in becoming

more active participants in their own physical, emotional, and spiritual health and wellbeing. Poz

Cafe is also a monthly lunch service for people living with HIV. It is a great opportunity for

people to get out of the house, take a break, meet other positive people, and enjoy great food.

TIHAN also provides a monthly care package filled with toiletries such as toilet paper, paper

towels, shampoo, soap, toothpaste/toothbrushes, deodorant, and feminine hygiene products.

Individuals with HIV/AIDS are eligible for one Care Package a month (TIHAN, 2017). Teen

Challenge Arizona or TCAZ is a Christian Faith-based solution on the drug epidemic. TCAZ

strives to help people become mentally sound, emotionally balanced, socially adjusted,

physically well and spiritually alive (TCAZ, 2018). Outreach services include church

presentations, school drug-prevention presentations, and health fairs and community

involvement.
27
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Pima County has many great resources for the general population. They also provide

great resources for special populations that are in need of specific resources. The Pima County

provides special resources for the disability population like DIRECT disability resource center,

Pima Council on Aging (PCOA), Southern Arizona AIDS Foundation (SAAF), Southwest Fair

Housing Council (SWFHC). DIRECT is a center that promotes independent living with variety

of housing options that are equipped with assisting agents for people who are disabled. PCOA

provides aging services like advocacy programs and information to the elderly population to

improve the aging experience for people. SAAF is an organization that provides a range of

housing services like programs, meetings, and skill-building workshops to help prevent the

spread of HIV/AIDS. SWFHC was designed to create equal access for housing and housing

services by removing forms that have relations to illegal discrimination or discouraging practices

that deny access to housing for certain people.

Cultural Factors

Pima County is an extremely diverse community that is home to people of all ethnicities,

races, and cultures. Of the 1,022,769 people in the community 51.8% identify as White, 37.3%

as Hispanic or Latino, 4.1% as African-American, 4.3% as American Indian, and 3.3% as Asian.

For more than 200 centuries, American Indians have maintained Tucson as their home. In 2000,

Tucson became the 8th largest city in terms of how many American Indians lived there. In 1990

the metro area became the 23rd largest place where Hispanics reside (Tucson Update – Ethnicity,

2015). A majority of Pima County’s residents, regardless of their race or ethnicity, are living in

Health Professional Shortage Areas (Healthy People, 2016). There is a higher percentage of

Hispanics that reside in Pima county than any other county in Arizona that speak a language

other than English at home. The most prevalent diseases among all the ethnicities throughout the
28
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

county include cardiovascular disease, hypertension, diabetes (especially in the American Indian

community), obesity, and HIV/AIDS. Communities of low socioeconomic status and ethnic

minority communities are more likely to experience a shortage in food in the physical

environments around them. With that being said Latinos and African-Americans are more likely

to live in food deserts which makes them eat foods that aren’t good for them causing them to

become overweight and their health to decline (Pima County, 2018j). Another issue that

communities with health disparities suffer with is the little access they have to outdoor or

recreational facilities to get physical activity, which is another cause for minorities in Pima

County to be overweight. Neighborhoods that are known to have a low socioeconomic status,

ethnic segregation, undesirable commercial establishments, and poverty are known to suffer

from a social disorder that can be associated with negative outcomes (Target Area Report, 2012).

There are many cultural factors that impact each cultural environment of one’s health

status. Socio-economic status of an individual happens to be one of the main influences on health

in a specific cultural population (Hernandez, et al., 2006). Debating on one’s socioeconomic

status, whether it is poverty or wealth, it defines how an individual’s lifestyle affects specific

health situations. In Pima County, it is recorded to have more than 18% of the population claim

to be living below the poverty line (Pima County, 2018j) Socioeconomic status is based on many

varieties like race/ethnicity, gender, immigration status, etc. (Hernandez, et al., 2006). The

leading group living on or below the poverty line is females aged 18 to 24, followed by men

aged 18 to 24 (Pima County, 2016j). Pima County’s proximity to the Mexican border can

indirectly contribute to poor nutrition, heating and health insurance, which are risk factors that

lower health status in a socioeconomic figure (Hernandez, et al., 2006). There are many cultural

factors that impact each cultural environment of one’s health status. Socioeconomic status of an
29
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

individual happens to be one of the main health factors in a specific cultural population

(Hernandez, et al., 2006). Debating on one’s socioeconomic status, whether it is poverty or

wealth, it defines how an individual’s lifestyle affects specific health situations. Pima County is

recorded to have more than 18% of the population claim to be living below the poverty line

(Pima County, 2018j). Socioeconomic status is based on many varieties like race/ethnicity,

gender, immigration status, etc. (Hernandez, et al., 2006). The leading gender living on the

poverty line or below it is females from ages 18 to 24, and then men within the same age group

(Pima County, 2018j). Pima County’s proximity to the border can lead to poor nutrition, heating

and health insurance, which are risk factors that lower residents’ health status in a socioeconomic

figure (Hernandez, et al., 2006).

Figure 14. Poverty by Age and Gender in Pima County.


Image retrieved from: https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/.
30
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The County’s Governmental Organization and Functions

Figure 15. Pima County Organizational Chart.


Image retrieved from: http://webcms.pima.gov/
Pima County is composed of diverse and growing bodies of governmental leadership in

the form of organizations, agencies, and individuals. Pima County is consistently governed by

the Board of Supervisors, followed by the County Administrators. According to Figure 15, The

realm of organization for these governing bodies fall within five categories: Administration,

Community and Economic Development, Justice and Law Enforcement, Health Services, and

Public Works. There are five members on the Pima County Board of Supervisors that are divided

by district; these supervisors are responsible for guiding public policy in their region. The locally

elected supervisors work with other districts to ensure safe communities, oversee municipal

services, review and enforce taxation, manage revenues, create and manage the county’s budget,

and, most generally, protect the public health of the entire county (Pima County, 2018e).
31
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

As seen in Figure 15, under the Board of Supervisors are the County Administrators.

County Administrators work to provide management, coordination, and communication of the

goals, information, and legislation set forth by the Board of Supervisors (Pima County,

2018g). The five district supervisors and the County Administrators collaborate to boost the

Community and Economic Developmental status of the county. In this sector, there are five

department divisions: Community Development and Neighborhood Conservation, Community

Services, Employment, Training, Attraction and Tourism, Pima County Public Library, and

Stadium District. These departments work together to improve the standard of living for low-

income and rural populations and promote the economic development of a community (Pima

County, 2018h). These community services are overseen by the Community Action Agency

Board, which includes 15 members from various county districts. There are 5 members from the

Pima County Board of Supervisors, 5 elected low-income representatives, and 5 representatives

from the private sectors. Together, these individuals serve to advise and empower community

service programs (Pima County, 2018f).

The promotion of a healthy and safe community is also the responsibility of the Board of

Supervisors within the Justice and Law Enforcement sector of Pima County. The Pima County

Sheriff’s Department is responsible for a plethora of services available to the communities of

Pima County. They uphold a number of duties, such as reports, neighborhood watch, orders of

protection, to promote and protect the safety of citizens (Pima County Sheriff’s Department,

2018). In addition to Pima County Sheriff’s Department, there is the Arizona Supreme Court of

Pima County; which works with the administrations and execution of justice under the law. The

Arizona Supreme Court of Pima County contributes to the timely, fair, and efficient manner of

the judicial system in the county and boosts the confidence of justice and safety for the people
32
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

(Arizona Supreme Court, 2018).

To keep everyone in Pima County healthy, the Pima County Health Department dedicates

their resources to promoting and maintaining optimal levels of health and wellness. Services

provided by this organization are: preventative health, education and outreach, sexual health,

personal records, behavioral health, consumer health and food safety, and volunteerism (Pima

County, 2018j). For the people of Pima County, the Health Department provides comprehensive

and professional networks for enhancing community health and wellness. Public Works, another

sector under the Board of Supervisors, allows employees to increase the quality of life for the

benefit of present and future citizens of Pima County. The Public Works department includes

several sub-departments that promote the safety of the community and environmental health

(Pima County, 2018q).

The sections of Public Works are: Development Services, Environmental Quality, Flood

Control, Natural Resources, Parks, and Recreation, Office of Sustainability and Conservation,

Real Property Services (Real Estate), Transportation, and Wastewater Reclamation (Pima

County, 2018q).

Within Pima County’s Organizational Chart, there are a few departments that consist of

maintaining the health and safety of the county/ or state. The organizations that provide health

and safety to the county/ or state are Health Services and Sheriffs that fall under Justice & Law

Enforcement. Within the Health services are the following:

• Attractions and Tourism: Helps in increasing economic stability through businesses such as

Old Tucson, Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum, Pima Air and Space Museum, etc. (Pima

County, 2018c).

• Behavioral Health: Provide better accessibility and availability for those that need behavioral
33
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

health services (Pima County, 2018d).

• Community and Economic Development: Has 5 departments that contribute in improving

standards of living in low-income and rural areas (Pima County, 2018e).

• Community Development and Neighborhood Conversion: Allows to have more livable and

viable county for residents to help improve their quality of life (Pima County, 2018f).

• Community Services, Employment and Training: Have programs that improve economic and

social sustainability of Pima County by:

o Developing skilled workers for quality jobs;

o Assisting employers to address workforce and recruitment needs; Mitigating the

impact of layoffs;

o Assisting households in financial crisis;

o Helping persons with barriers, such as homelessness and lack of literacy, to

transition into our economic talent pool (Pima County, 2018g).

• Health Department: Help residents in maintaining optimal level of wellness in Pima County

(Pima County, 2018j).

• Medical Examiner: Provide accurate, timely, compassionate and professional death

investigation services for the citizens (Pima County, 2018k).

• Office of Emergency Management: Establishes a comprehensive countywide, all-hazards

structure to provide for successful and well-organized coordination of Pima County

regional emergency management activities (Pima County, 2018l).

• Pima Animal Care Center: Rescue pets in need, protect the community and save lives (Pima

County, 2018m).

• Pima County Wireless Integrated Network (PCWIN): Allows for public services to reach out
34
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

and talk to each other by radio in real time on a single system, regardless of their

jurisdiction boundaries (Pima County, 2018n).

• Public Health Emergency Preparedness: This department engages in collaborative,

community-focused emergency health planning to address biological, chemical,

radiological, or natural disaster events that result in public health threats or emergencies

(Pima County, 2018).

The safety in the county is provided by the Pima County Sheriff Department. They offer

a multitude of services such as police reports, neighborhood watch, crime report maps, orders of

protection, sex offenders, and a list of State of Arizona Sex Offenders (Pima County, 2018p).

The Pima County Board of Supervisors is responsible for how the organizations influence

the decision-making regarding the county’s health and quality of life. The Board of Supervisors

duties are to establish policies and direction for all the departments that also includes Health

Services and Justice & Law Enforcement. The Board of Supervisors appoints these specific

departments to the County Administrators. The County Administrator has the responsibilities of

implementing board policy and creating an annual County Budget; which is to be submitted to

the Board of Supervisors for further consideration. Most of the organizations are influenced by

whether there is enough money in order to be provided into the county. In that regard, funding

has a significant on the county’s overall health and county residents’ quality of life.

Housing

There were 459,915 total housing units in the Pima County in the year of 2017 with

19.1% of individuals below poverty levels in Pima County (Data Access and Dissemination

Systems, 2010). Pima County provides housing programs to help low-income individuals and

those in need of special care. The Home Repair and Weatherization program is for low-income
35
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

housing in Pima County, which provides repair services to homes where the residents may not be

able to afford it (Home Repair Assistance, 2018). Pima County evaluates the needs and cost of

the home damage and pays to fix it depending on individuals’ income and housing status. Other

resources to help low-income housing with repair damage is the City of Tucson Housing and

Community Development Department (Home Repair Assistance, 2018). The resource for

disabled housing necessities in Pima County is the Community Home Repair Projects of Arizona

(CHRPA), a resource that provides wheelchair-access home additions. Direct Center for

Independence Inc, provides assistance in creating safer homes for the elderly to accommodate

their needs in Pima County (Home Repair Assistance, 2018). Habitat for Humanity Tucson and

Old Pueblo Community Services helps fund and creates rehabilitation homes for disabled

veterans in Southern Arizona (Home Repair Assistance, 2018).

In Pima County, the estimated median cost per month for occupied housing units was

$874 in 2016. The estimated median cost per month for owner occupied housing units was $924

in 2016. In Pima County, the estimated median cost per month for renter occupied housing units

was $831 in 2016 (Data Access and Dissemination, 2010).

Table 4. Yearly Cost of Housing in Pima County.


Year Estimated Estimated Estimated for renter
Median cost median cost occupied housing
per month for per month for units.
occupied owner
housing unit. occupied
housing unit.
2010 $880 $1,056 $737
2011 $906 $1,076 $769
2012 $906 $1,059 $782
2013 $896 $982 $798
2014 $889 $945 $813
2015 $874 $945 $816
2016 $874 $924 $831
(Data Access and Dissemination, 2010)
36
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 16. Monthly Cost of Housing in Pima County.


Image retrieved from: https://factfinder.census.gov/

According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and U.S. Federal

Bureau of Investigation, “severe housing problems is the percentage of the households with at

least one or more of the following housing problems: lacks complete kitchen facilities, lacks

complete plumbing facilities, is severely overcrowded or severely cost burdened.” Poor housing

is defined by the presence of “infectious and chronic diseases, infestations, and poor childhood

development” (Affordable Housing Development, 2018). Many aspects contribute to the poor

conditions of housing, and Pima County provides resources to help those in need.

It is stated that in Pima County, 19% of the population has severe housing problems.

Violent Crimes have a damaging effect on the populations’ residence health. According to the

U.S Department of Housing and Urban Development, per 100,000 individuals, Pima County has

a 434 Violent Crime Rate. In Pima County, 19% of people stated that they get Inadequate Social

Support; which diminishes the physical and mental health of the county residents (Recovery
37
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Tracker, 2018).

The housing available for the low-income populations has been changing dramatically in

the past years. In 2014, Pima County voted for $10,000,000 to be funded to the Pima County

Affordable Housing Bond Program, which is a non-profit organization that licensed builders can

apply to for bond funds for affordable housing developments. Their mission includes the

opportunity to increase the amount of affordable housing for low-and median-income families

(Affordable Housing Development, 2018.). There is also affordable housing for people with

disabilities. DIRECT (Disability Resource Center) is a program that helps and promotes

independent living for elders and offers affordable assistance for people with disabilities. Some

services that they provide are wheelchair accessibility ramps and bathroom safety features for the

tenants (Pima County, 2018r). Pima County also has workbooks available for foreclosure

prevention, emergency mortgage help, financial planning, and utility assistance. These

workbooks hold helpful tips and information necessary for low-income homeowners

(Foreclosure Prevention, 2018).

The TPCH (Tucson/Pima Coalition to End Homelessness) reported 1,762 homeless

people on January 26, 2016. When calculated, 211 were chronically homeless (experienced

homelessness more than 4 time in the past 3 years), 479 had mental illnesses, 460 were substance

abusers, 90 had HIV/AIDS, 333 were victims of domestic violence abuse, and 281 were

veterans. These people are also the highest users of emergency rooms and hospital services. Most

homeless people go to the emergency room due to hyponatremia, which occurs when lower

sodium levels (salt) are detected in the blood. Symptoms include fatigue nausea, headaches, and

disturbance of memory and/or concentration, this can also lead to severe dehydration (Hope of

Glory Ministries, 2016). Pima County is currently in a 10-year plan to end homelessness. The
38
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

plan is to create “permanent supportive housing” by building or buying a house for 20 or so

individuals with serious mental health illnesses, along with building or buying “transitional

housing” for families who need some time to re-establish themselves. To get the money to build

or buy these homes, Pima County plans on increasing funds from Arizona State Department of

Housing for Emergency and Utility Assistance by $250,000 a year (Homelessness, 2018).

Food Supply

In Pima County, there are many different ways that food is provided to all of the

population. There is a wide variety of options that residents of Pima County can choose from to

fulfill their nutritional needs. In 2007, data was provided to show people the distribution of food

resources throughout Pima County. A way people get food is at grocery stores, these stores give

people the choice of what ingredients and produce they want to eat. Grocery stores offer a wide

array of fresh and processed foods. Farmers’ markets are a way for residents to pick up fruits,

vegetables, cheeses, and baked goods from local farmers. There are 15 farmers’ markets in Pima

County. They are not distributed evenly, making them non-accessible to some of the population.

Convenience stores are comparable to mini-grocery stores that carry mostly processed food made

available for people who are on-the-go or cannot afford a traditional grocery store. Despite the

high amount of processed foods offered in convenience stores, there has been an increase in

fruits made available to consumers in convenience stores (The Packer, 2013). There are 278

convenience stores in Pima County. Restaurants are an alternative to at home cooking where

people can enjoy food made by chefs. There are 615 full-service restaurants in Pima County.

Another alternative for people to receive a meal quickly is through fast-food. This is the

unhealthiest option and often leads to people becoming malnourished. There are 594 fast-food

restaurants in Pima County. Food banks and food pantries offer a resource for those who cannot
39
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

afford food. There are 31 food banks and food pantries in Pima County (Food Pantries,

2018). These are all very diverse ways that Pima County provides food to its population.

Businesses such as grocery stores, convenience stores, restaurants, fast food restaurants, farmers’

markets, and food banks allow residents to have a variety of different options for food.

Community agencies work with community partners to provide people who face food

insecurity with food boxes and to make unpurchased produce available. Community

organizations have been utilizing gardens to educate residents on growing and preparing their

own food. By educating residents about gardens, the county attempts to ameliorate food security.

The Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona focuses on making it accessible for residents to

have access to food banks by offering an array of food pantry locations throughout Pima County

(Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona, 2018). Although Pima County manages to provide

food and resources to its residents, increasing the number of people who use these available

resources remains a challenge.

As of 2016, there are approximately 1,016,206 individuals living in Pima County in

Tucson, AZ (Data Access, 2016). Out of this total population, around 15% of people live in a

food desert, which can be defined as an area with no grocery stores or access to healthy foods

within one mile in which a majority of individuals live at a status 20% below the federal poverty

line (Data Access, 2016). Data shows that 43% of people living in food deserts identify as Latino

(Data Access, 2016). Geographically, these food deserts are primarily located in the downtown

area or South Tucson (García, 2014).

In Pima County, there are many individuals who do not have the opportunity to have

access to healthy foods which is detrimental to a healthy lifestyle. For these people, there are

many resources available to them so that they can gain access to healthy foods and fresh
40
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

produce. To begin, non-profit organizations as well as independently owned companies are

reaching out to individuals with inadequate food supply. Desert Survival Inc. is an organization

that provides over 70 species of edible fruit trees which make up the majority of the Mission

Garden fruit trees (Nabhan, 2018). Also, Civano Nursery provides food to neighboring

businesses that have no access to healthy food. Along with organizations, school gardens provide

a source of healthy food for people in Pima County that do not already have access. For example,

Manzo Elementary school garden offers over 35 seasonal crop species that provide people with

healthy fruits and vegetables (Nabhan, 2018). Additionally, Robert Naylor’s school garden

became a major source of food for children and refugees in that geographical area for less

fortunate individuals. Lastly, food banks are vital to providing food to those who cannot provide

it for themselves.

Education
According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Pima County’s overall educational attainment

among residents is relatively high: 87.7% of Pima County residents graduated from at least high

school with a high school diploma. This is a higher percentage of educational attainment in

comparison to the state of Arizona: 86.2% of all Arizonans have at least a high school diploma.

Additionally, 30.8% of Pima County residents received at least a bachelor’s degree, which is 2%

higher than the same statistic for the state of Arizona (U.S. Census, 2016). Overall, Pima County

has a higher percentage of education attainment when compared to Arizona’s average percentage

of educational attainment.

Segmenting these statistics further by race allows for an assessment of the influence of

race on educational attainment. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, Native Hawaiian and
41
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

other Pacific Islander have the highest percentage of individuals who graduated high school or

higher at 93.1%. Closely behind them are non-Hispanic Whites at 90.1% and following are

Blacks at 88% (U.S. Census, 2010). Only falling 2% behind Blacks are Asians at 86.6% and

Hispanics have the lowest percentage of individuals who graduated from high school at 73.3%.

Asians have the highest percentage of individuals that earned a Bachelor’s Degree or higher at

50.3% and American Indian or Alaska Native have the lowest percentage at 11.8%. Whites have

the next highest percentage at 33.2% and following them are Native Hawaiian and other Pacific

Islanders at 25.9%. The differences in percentages between race/ethnic groups can be attributed

to the resources and opportunities that each group is presented throughout their lifetime. When

dividing the educational attainment by sex, one can see that there isn’t a significant difference.

Most of the percent's differ by less that 1% and the biggest difference is seen between Asian

males and females obtaining a bachelor’s degree or higher. Table 5 demonstrates the percentages

of educational attainment separated by race, gender, and the level of education received.

Table 5. Educational Attainment in Pima County by Race, Gender, and Level of Education.
Race High Bachelor’s
school Degree or
graduate Higher
or higher
Total (%) Male (%) Female Total (%) Male (%) Female
(%) (%)
White 90.1% 90.3% 90% 33.2% 34.2% 32.2%

Black 88% 86.8% 89.5% 21.9% 21.3% 22.6%


American 76.3% 76.2% 76.3% 11.8% 11.9% 11.8%
Indian or
Alaska
Native
Asian 86.6% 88.5% 85.2% 50.3% 55.5% 46.5%
Native 93.1% 90.2% 96.4% 25.9% 27.8% 23.7%
Hawaiian
42
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

and Other
Pacific
Islander
Hispanic 73.7% 73.5 73.8 14.4 13.4 15.2
or Latino
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2010)
Dropout rates are important representations of schools’ success in maintaining student

retention from the first day of the academic year to the last (Arizona Department of Education,

2018). These dropout rates can influence educational reform to greater prioritize performance

measures. Pima County accounts for 12% of individuals who dropped out of school and has one

of the lowest dropout rates in Arizona (Arizona Department of Education, 2018). Santa Cruz

County has the highest dropout rate at 25% which is about twice as large as the percentage noted

within Pima County.

According to the Arizona Department of Education (2018), dropout rates in Pima County

are shown to be highest amongst American Indian or Alaskan Native at 9.3%. However, these

dropout rates continue to decrease with African-Americans following at 7% and Hispanic or

Latino closely behind at 6%. Following Hispanics or Latino with a 0.7% decrease are Native

Hawaiian or Pacific Islander at 5.3%. Whites have the lowest dropout rates of 4.4% in

comparison to all other races. This is a dramatic 5-point decrease from American Indian or

Alaskan Native. Along with ethnicity differences, males and females also tend to have different

dropout rates. Overall, females are shown to have a lower dropout rate of 4.8% than males with a

rate of 6.1% (Arizona Department of Education, 2018).

The Pima County graduation rate in comparison to the rest of the counties located in

Arizona is relatively low. Pima County’s graduation rate is 77.6% and is the third lowest county

in Arizona . Just below Pima County is Apache County at 74.2% and Pinal County at 71.7%. As

seen Pima County is not too far from the lowest county and is 20% away from Greenlee County
43
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

which has the highest graduation rate at 92.2%. Although Pima County is one of the lowest, it is

not too far from the Arizona State average graduation rate of 79.5% (High School Graduation,

2018).

According to the Arizona Department of Education (2017), the ethnicity presented with

the highest graduation rate is Asians at 87.5% and following them with 79% are Whites (Arizona

Department of Education, 2017). Hispanics graduation rates are at 71%, which is not far from

Whites. At a 4% decrease from Hispanics, African-Americans are seen to have a graduation rate

of 67.6%. The race shown with the lowest graduation rate in Pima County however, are Native

Hawaiian or Pacific Islander at 60%. The difference between the highest racial group, Asians,

and the lowest racial group, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, comes at over a 20% decrease.

The overall percentage of females graduating from high school is 77.6% and males 70.3%

(Arizona Department of Education, 2017). This coincides with the high school dropout rates as

females had a lower rate than males. Therefore, it appears evident why females have a higher

graduation rate than males within the county.

Pima County offers a wide variety of educational resources targeted for specific

populations. Pima County offers educational resources with a focus in: dropout prevention,

English learners, education for the homeless, foster, gifted, migrant, and special learners. With

over 160,000 students enrolled in one of the 17 Pima County school districts, there is a resource

for every intellectual (Pima County School Superintendent, 2014).

The Zip Code Project is a resource concerning youth who are not attending school or

employed. With a focus on ages 16-24, the Zip Code Project targets disengaged youth. This

project offers student resources, opportunities, referrals, and grant funding in hopes of reducing

dropouts and improving quality of life. Within the Ajo community, 65% are unemployed and
44
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

55% are not enrolled in school. These high statistics make Ajo one of the four zip codes selected

as a critical area of focus (Dickenson, 2016).

Figure 17. Zip Code Project Data.


Image retrieved from: http://www.azed.gov/
The Migrant Education Program (MEP) is a source for migrant students (ages 3-21) and

parents to better prepare academically. Home visits, summer school, interpreting for migrant

parents, home academic support for preschoolers, and parent meetings are provided. Options can

be combined depending on what the student adapts best to (Migrant Education, 2017).
45
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Figure 18. Increasing Diversity in Arizona Charter Schools Over Time.


Image retrieved from: https://azcharters.org/
Arizona charter schools are high quality public schools accessible to Pima County

students. Charter schools offer a driven and dedicated support system to students to improve

academic achievements with high results. Pima County offers dozens of charter schools: Satori

Charter School, Math & Science Success Academy, BASIS Tucson Primary, Arizona College

Prep Academy, etc. Academic results depict how math passing rates have increased by 35% and

how there has been a 99% increase in the English Language Arts program over the past few

years. According to the 2015 National Assessment of Educational Progress, Arizona Charter

students have scored the greatest improvement, along with Massachusetts, among all 50 states.

Also, charter schools involve all different races. A total of 55% of all charter school students

identify with a racial/ethnic group different than white (Our Impact, 2015).

Pima Accommodation District provides an academic curriculum for juvenile court and

detention students. The Court Alternative Program of Education (CAPE) works with the Pima

County Juvenile Detention Center as well as the Pima County Adult Detention Center to teach

daily subjects: reading, literature, writing, math, science, social studies, and Spanish (Pima

County Annual Report, 2015). In 2015, five youths, who were detained, received a GED. Two

CAPE schools are located in Pima County: CAPE School and CAPE-Detention School. Not only

does CAPE serve as an educational resource for students, but it also serves to assist parents of

the juveniles. (Pima County School Superintendent, 2018).

Pima County offers several homeschool resources. Christian Home Educators of Tucson-

Southeast, Faith Home Educators, and Quest for Education and Arts are some of the many

homeschools’ within the area that involve hands-on work. Within the home-schools, early

education through high school honors education is covered while providing substantial
46
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

knowledge in: math, foreign languages, history, government etc. Furthermore, many homeschool

resources dictate an emphasis on religion. Biblical standards as well as social settings are

focused on throughout the process of properly educating the youth. Almost all homeschool

resource centers are offered online but some (listed above) have in-person addresses (Guest

Guidelines, 2018).

Within Pima County, one of the main concerns is the shortage of teachers available for

students. It’s shown that 24% of first year teachers and 20% of second year Arizona teachers

resigned from the profession in the years 2014 and 2015. In the years of 2016-2017, the average

salary for an Arizona teacher was around $47,218. However, the average U.S teacher salary was

$57,611; a noticeable $10,00 difference is seen between the two. Yet, the AZ Kids Can’t Wait

Plan of 2018 has big hopes with improving teachers’ salaries. This organization promotes

Proposition 301: Extend and Expand teacher salaries and Capital Funding. The campaign is still

in progress but the goal is to generate over $400 million to improve this concern (Arizona

Department of Education, 2018). Furthermore, children/families also struggle financially. The

Arizona Voucher Program pays partial or full tuition for private school children who can’t afford

to pay. This money is sourced from public schools and their additional money. The money is

saved from when a student was supposed to attend that school but never did (Afford Private

School, 2018).

Road repair is directly linked to educational concerns within Pima County. Road

concerns are an educational concern because it affects the students ability to get to and from

school. Pima County has come up with a 10-year Road Repair Plan in hopes of preserving and

reconstructing the “bad” roads. The Sun Tran, Link, Shuttle, and Van all contain different transit

fares. With cleaner and safer roads, students in Pima County, especially Tucson, can rely more
47
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

on the new and improved roads. The 10-year Road Plan is in the process of making money spent

worth its while (Pima County Road Repair Plan, 2018).

School Health and Nutrition Programs

The state of Arizona utilizes The National School Lunch Program and the School

Breakfast Program in order to provide a reduced or free breakfast or lunch. Students are eligible

based off parent’s income and size of their household (National School Lunch Programs, 2018).

The Tucson Unified School District utilizes this national program and they have also set up a

“Together Every Kid Eats” program. This program allows students to eat free through the

funding of donations.. The program also has an online portal for those looking to donate money

towards students school lunches. Donators can go to the Together Every Kid Eats webpage to

locate average prices of meals for students based on age division. Food services will ensure that

each eligible student will be given the proper nutritional service and will work with families to

help manage their meal account (School Meal Programs, 2018).

Table 6. Student Meal Prices for the 2017-2018 School Year.


Breakfast, PreK-5 $1.25 Lunch, PreK-5 Grade $2.30
Grade
Breakfast, 6-8 Grade $1.50 Lunch, 6-8 Grade $2.80
Students in K-8 Students in K-8
Schools Schools
Breakfast, Middle & $1.50 Lunch, Middle & $2.80
High Schools High Schools
Reduced Price $ .25 Reduced Price $ .40
Breakfast, K-12 Lunch, K-12
Milk, K-12 $ .30 Milk, K-12 $ .30
Second Student $1.75 Second Student $2.85
Meal/Unenrolled Meal/Unenrolled
Student Meal/Adult Student Meal/Adult
Meals, without milk Meals, without milk
Second Student $2.00 Second Student $3.10
Meal/Unenrolled Meal/Unenrolled
Student Meal/Adult Student Meal/Adult
Meals, with milk Meals, with milk
48
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Note. Data for School Meal Programs in Tucson, Arizona is under the National School Lunch
program and Tucson Unified School District (School Meal Programs, 2018).
Pima County Food Alliance is a system that was developed in Pima County to allow low-

income families and children to receive fresh foods from local farmers. This system supports

economic development along with our local farmers. Pima County Food Alliance has created

projects such as School Gardening and the National Farm to School Network that allows schools

to implement programs that encompasses gardening and learning about sustainability as well as

growing their own food. These schools have the opportunity to create their own garden and the

outside community can participate as well. Students will grow their own produce and learn how

to make healthy lifestyle choices through nutrition and agriculture education (School Gardening,

2018).

Another program offered is “Summer Lunch Buddies - Helping Kids Eat Healthy,” which

networks with different organizations like Tucson Unified School District, the University of

Arizona, Food Banks, American Indian Tribes, and non-profit organizations that offer food

assistance to students within Arizona (AZ Health Zone, 2018). This program is a federally-

funded program that is offered during the summer breaks and provides children 18 years and

younger the opportunity to get free food. Proof of income or a filled out application is not

needed, using the available mapping tool on the website allows you access to finding the nearest

participation location.

The Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona partners with school programs. The

resources offered through the Nutrition Education program include Farm to Child, School

Pantries, and After School Meals & Snacks (Community Food Bank, 2017). For each program,

the goal for the Nutrition Education program is to educate students and their parents on the

importance of healthy eating. The Farm to Child program was created for low-income schools
49
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

within Tucson and there are currently 35 schools in Tucson that are a part of the Farm to Child.

The program’s focus is educating both students and their teachers about their having a healthy

diet and how a garden offers fresh foods. Of the 35 schools, 10 schools are certified in serving

the foods grown from the garden in the school cafeteria.

The second program that the Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona partners with

is, “School Pantries,” which offers food distributions to students and their families, as well as

educating students on Nutrition Education and recipes for healthy foods that they can take home

to share with their families. Aside from the 9 school pantries in Tucson, there are also 3 mobile

pantries and 2 family resource centers that are located throughout the Pima County.

The third program that the Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona partners with is

the “After School Meals & Snacks program.” There are a total of 14 locations including Parks

and Recreation centers, libraries, and other youth centers. This program establishes better access

to healthier foods, especially in “at-risk youth” in low-income areas in Tucson. The after school

meals and snacks program is offered for anyone 18 years old and younger; they are allowed to go

to any school location and sign in with the facility before getting their snacks and meals.

Table 7. After School Meal & Snack Programs: Meal Sites.

Locations Address Time


Frank and Edith Morton 3155 E. Grant Rd 5:30 pm - 6:30 pm
Clubhouse
Marty Birdman Recreation 2536 N. Castro 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm
Center
Roy Drachman Clubhouse 5901 S. Santa Clara 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm
Wednesdays 4 pm - 5 pm
Steve Daru Clubhouse 1375 N. El Rio Dr. 4:00 pm - 5:00pm
Pascua Yaqui Clubhouse 5010 W. Calle Torim 5:30 pm - 6:30 pm
Holmes-Tuttle Clubhouse 2585 E. 36th St. 6 pm - 7 pm
Jim & Vicki Click Clubhouse 1935 S. Columbus Blvd. 5 pm - 6 pm
Wednesdays 4:00pm
Freedom Recreation Center 5000 E. 29th St 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm
50
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

John Valenzuela Youth 1550 S. 6th Ave. 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm Mon-


Center South Tucson Thurs
Note. Data for Meal Sites offered through Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona,
(Community Food Bank, 2017).

Table 8. After School Meal & Snack Programs: Snack Sites.


Locations Address Times
El Rio Neighborhood Center 1390 W. Speedway Blvd. 4 pm
Wednesdays 3:30 pm
Marty Birdman Recreation 2536 N. Castro Ave. 3:30 pm
Center Thursdays 3 pm
Santa Rosa Neighborhood 1080 S. 10th Ave. 4 pm
Center Wednesdays 3:30 pm
Cherry Avenue Recreation 5085 S. Cherry Ave. 3 pm
Center Wednesdays 2:30 pm
Archer Center 1665 S. La Cholla Blvd. 3 pm
Trinity Place Apartments 6240 S. Campbell Ave. 3:40 pm
Refugee Focus 55 N. 6th Ave., Suite 101 Tuesday - Thursday 3:30 pm
Eckstrom-Columbus Library 4350 E. 22nd St. Tuesdays & Wednesdays
3:30 pm only
Santa Rosa Library 1075 S. 10th Ave. Tuesdays & Thursdays 3:15
pm
Martha Cooper Library 1377 N. Catalina Ave. Tuesdays 4 pm
Wednesdays 3 pm
Thursdays 3 pm
Mission Library 3770 S. Mission Rd. Tuesdays 4 pm
Wednesdays 3 pm
Southwest Library 6855 S. Mark Rd. Wednesdays 3:30 pm
Quincie-Douglas Library 1585 E. 36th St. Wednesdays 3:30 pm
Valencia Library 202 W. Valencia Rd. Mondays 3 pm
Tuesdays 3 pm
Wednesdays 1:30-2:00 pm.
3pm
Thursdays 3pm
Woods Memorial Library 3455 N. First Ave. Tuesdays 3:30 pm
Note. Data for Snack Sites offered through Community Food Bank of Southern
Arizona,(Community Food Bank, 2017).

Overall, the Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona partners with these programs to

provide all children with better access to healthy foods by educating students within the Tucson

community on the importance of living a healthier lifestyle by making better food choices (for

the students and their families who may not be able to afford these nutritious foods that children
51
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

need), and reducing the risk of health-related diseases (diabetes, obesity, etc.) within Pima

County.

The AZDHS has created programs and policies community and school wide that can allow

children to maintain healthy lifestyle choices as well. Empower Schools is a policy that ensures

schools are maintaining a healthy environment for children. Health within schools stems beyond

making sure children are receiving the proper nutrition. Health within schools also means ensuring

that school counselors, social workers, nurses, and food service/directors are located in all schools.

School systems can seek advice from the School Health Advisory Councils on how to implement

school health programs and policies (ADHS, 2018)

Social Welfare Programs

Social welfare programs are a key provider for families and individuals in need in the

Southern Arizona community. For example, Tucson Electric and Power (TEP), a community

agency, offers a multitude of programs for low-income individuals to help them reduce the amount

of electricity they use within their home. With their program ‘Help with Emergency Energy Relief

Operation’ (HEERO), customers have the ability to anonymously donate to those who need

assistance paying their bills when in an emergency situation (TEP, 2016). Every year,

approximately 8,200 customers add between $1 or $5 to their monthly bill in order to help

contribute to around 600 low-income households in Tucson (TEP, 2016). The program overall has

proven to be extremely successful, generating approximately $150,000 every year. Along with the

HEERO program, TEP offers the ‘Home Energy Assistance Fund’ (HEAF), which utilizes

unclaimed utility deposits in order to help customers repair or replace their heating and cooling

units. Annually, $2 million in HEAF funds has gone towards low-income families in Arizona in

order to help contribute to their utility deposits (TEP, 2016). Another program within TEP that is
52
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

connected to the US government is the ‘Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program’. This

program supports families in paying their heating and cooling bills and accumulates approximately

4 billion to 5.2 billion dollars annually. Overall, through the use of these community as well as

governmental agencies, TEP is able to help low-income families afford power within their homes.

For individuals who need both utility as well as renters assistance, Tucson Urban League

helps those who are low-income or in a crisis situation within Pima County. The overall goal

behind this program is one that is community-based, focusing on limiting the amount of

homelessness within the county as a whole. The utility assistance within the program not only

focuses on gas and electric bills, but water and phone bills as well. Overall, the program’s mission

statement identifies with the fact that “every American has lives in a safe, decent, affordable and

energy efficient housing on fair terms”(Community Support Organization, 2016).

The Pima County community offers multiple social welfare programs that target specific

populations in financial need. Southern Arizona has a large population of Hispanic families who

fall under the category of low-income households. A program that is found in multiple states but

holds a large presence in Arizona is Chicanos por la Causa (CPLC). This program provides housing

for single and multiple family homes that are at a more affordable cost for lower income families.

CPLC has provided multiple housing homes to 3,471 residents and a single family home to 35

families (Chicanos Por La Causa, 2018). Housing counseling is offered as well as a resource to aid

families in financial struggle surrounding their living situation. They offer housing assistance

which helps families when in conflict with landlords, or with any pending foreclosures that they

have on their property. Along with assistance, families and individuals can receive counseling at

CPLC. The counselors help families create a financial plan and help prepare them for

homeownership. Last year alone Chicanos por la Causa “helped 333 families avoid foreclosure or
53
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

eviction” (Chicanos Por La Causa, 2018). They also serve “3,057 clients across all housing

counseling services” (Chicanos Por La Causa, 2018). Another social welfare program that focuses

on a target population is the Southern Arizona Aids Foundation (SAAF, 2018). They focus on

providing resources and support to the LGBTQ community who struggle financially. For residents

who already have a place to live but struggle to meet their rent can receive short term emergency

assistance from SAAF with their financial assistance that will help residents pay their bills and

avoid eviction. The Southern Arizona Aids Foundation supports over 100 families and individuals

through their direct housing and financial payment assistance (SAAF, 2018).

Southern Arizona offers multiple religiously based programs that provide financial

assistance to local community members. Interfaith Community Services (ICS) is a program

focused on bringing diverse faiths from the community together to help support those in need.

They were founded originally at the St. Andrew’s Presbyterian Church. ICS offers emergency

financial aid to all residents of the Pima County community, especially those who are struggling

with a financial crisis, whether that be long or short term. The program offers short term financial

assistance to help pay rent and utility bills that families may not be able to pay at the moment.

Financial aid counselors are also available to help individuals take a step by step approach to

address their troubles. Families and individuals are given the opportunity to work directly with the

counselor to create a plan of action and identify the problems that are instigating their financial

struggles. ICS states that, “this personal counseling makes a difference in helping struggling

individuals and families help themselves” (Emergency Financial Aid, 2018).

Catholic Community Services of Southern Arizona is another program that offers safe

housing, counseling, and adoption amongst other programs to better the community as a whole.

This program focuses on a variety of individuals from children to families to senior citizens.
54
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Overall this programs mission is to “touch lives every day in great and small ways” and help those

live with “independence and dignity”. Within CCS, specifically, is a program called Foster Family

Care which is where they recruit and assess families to welcome foster children into their homes.

This program is a great addition to the community and enables families to provide for children in

need with a good and fitting home life. Similarly, CCS has another program related to Domestic

Violence which is dedicated to emergency shelter. This emergency shelter serves to “provide a

welcoming and safe environment for those needing support to leave a harmful situation”. However,

this program is open to men and women who have experienced not only domestic violence, but

sexual assault, elder abuse, and even trafficking. Not only does this program provide resources on

its own, but it pairs with House of Hope and Nuestra Casa in order to provide transitional living

for those who need it. An essential program that falls under Catholic Community Services is their

‘basic services’ which provides food, clothing, and housewares to individuals and families. CCS

pairs with Pio Decimo’s food pantry and Clothing Closet in order to accomplish their goals.

Overall, CCS has contributed a lot to the community of Southern Arizona (Catholic Community

Services, 2014).

Transportation
The primary means of transportation within Pima County include driving, biking,

walking, and public transit (DADS, 2010a). While there are multiple means of transportation in

Pima County, driving is the most commonly used mode of transportation within this community.

According to the American Community Survey from 2012-2016, 86.5% of the population within

Pima County use their own private form of transportation (car, truck, van, motorcycle). Biking

accounts for 1.8%, while walking accounts for 2.3% of transportation throughout Pima County.
55
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Lastly, 2.8% of the population in Pima County uses some form of public transportation as a way

to get around (DADS, 2010a).

Figure 19. Common methods of Transportation in Pima County.


Image retrieved from: https://datausa.io/profile/geo/01000US/#mode_transport
This chart compares the primary modes of transportation within Pima County (orange) to

the overall percentages of these transportation methods within the United States (grey). As is the

case in Pima County, driving is the most commonly used method of transportation throughout the

U.S. as well.

In Pima County, a high proportion of residents have access to reliable methods of

transportation in one way or another. For those who do not own private vehicles, the other

methods of transportation (biking, walking, carpooling, public transit) are just as reliable within

the community. In Pima County, 9.9% of the population carpools daily. Carpooling statistics

differentiated by sex show that 10.6% of the female population carpools while 9.4% of the male

population carpools in Pima County (DADS, 2010b).

Biking is another reliable method of transportation available to the residents of Pima

County. Programs such as The Loop and Bike Buddy exist to help residents who use bikes to
56
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

commute throughout the community. These programs encourage biking as a beneficial and

healthy source of transportation within Pima County in hopes to promote the use of this cost-

effective transportation method. The Loop is a primary bike route offered as a systematic means

to transport around Pima County. This system connects over 120 miles of paved pathways from

Rillito, Santa Cruz and Pantano River Parks to the Julian Wash and Harrison Road Greenways

(Chuck, 2018).

Public transit is an additional method of transportation throughout Pima County. The rates

for public transit, although not nearly as high as the rates for driving and carpooling, are greater

than those of biking and walking. Forms of public transit offered throughout Pima County include

the Sun Tran, SunLink, Sun Shuttle, and Sun Van (Sun Van, 2018). Table 9 depicts the fares of

public transit in Pima County that became effective on the 1st of January of 2018. Fares fluctuate

based on whether or not individuals have a SunGO Card and ID. Options to purchase these cards

are available on their website (Sun Van, 2018). Despite the variety of options offered through Pima

County’s transportation services, there are many challenges facing the transportation systems in

Pima County (The Road to Recovery, 2018).

Table 9. New Fares on Sun Tran, Sun Link and Sun Shuttle.

Note. Data for Pima County Public Transportation Cost. (Sun Van, 2018).
57
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The Pima County Transportation Department is tasked with the maintenance, design,

construction, and operations of all unincorporated Pima County. This includes about 2,200 miles

of roadways along with street lights, street signs, traffic signals, bridges, and drainage systems

(The Road to Recovery, 2018). Due to a lack of funding, the Pima County Health Department

has been unable to properly manage and maintain the roads and infrastructure in Pima County.

Subsequently, nearly 60% of the county’s roads are in poor or failing condition (The Road to

Recovery, 2018). It would cost the Pima County Health department 250 million to repair the

roadways with an additional 30 million a year, for 10 years, in order to prevent the problem from

getting worse (The Road to Recovery, 2018). In order to meet these costs, Pima County would

need to pass a countywide half-cent sales tax for the repair and maintenance on county roads.

Currently, Pima County is the only county in Arizona that does not impose a countywide sales

tax, but enforcing one would generate enough funding for the Pima County Transportation

Department to properly maintain the roads and infrastructure for the county (The Road to

Recovery, 2018).

Transportation can be related to health problems in relation to quality of the environment

and air pollution. When it comes to the environment, the resident’s welfare, safety, and quality of

life is considered within the community’s population (Pima County, 2018s). Air pollution is

becoming an increasingly important issue, especially within Pima County. As of August 3, 2018,

the Pima Clean Air Program issued a high pollution advisory due to the elevation of ground-level

ozone air pollution (PDEQ, 2018). This is directly related to health problems because people

within the population could begin to experience shortness of breath or breathing discomfort,

coughing, wheezing, and throat irritation. The quality of air pollution could determine how long

people should be outside and what time of the day is safe to be outside (Pima County, 2018a).
58
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The only problem with this is that people are often not able to control when they are outdoors or

not. By limiting the amount of driving in motor vehicles, Pima County may be able to improve

its air quality. A way that Pima County limits the health problems related to transportation is by

encouraging residents to take a “Drive-Less Pledge.” According to the PDEQ’s Clean Air

Program, "skipping a trip in your motorized vehicle or taking a “no-drive” day each week can

reduce air pollution by more than 1,100 pounds a year, which will help clean the air for

everyone” (Drive-Less, 2018).

Since individuals within a community can control what method of transportation they

take, they are also able to control the quality of air within their community. Other methods of

transportation, like biking, carpooling, and public transportation are better than driving in order

to improve the overall quality of the environment and the health problems within Pima County.

The highest cost expenditures come from driving a car or motorized vehicle compared to other

methods of transportation. This is due to the amount of money spent on gas, car maintenance,

parking, registration, motor vehicle taxes, etc. Other forms of transportation such as shuttles,

buses, and trams are cheaper than driving because it is a public form of transportation. Though

the cost of time would be greater than driving, public transportation or bike use provides a more

economically and environmentally conscious alternative. Riding a bike does not diminish the

overall quality of air and the costs of biking is far favored over the cost of transportation via

motorized vehicle. Although the costs of driving are the most expensive in terms of

transportation throughout Pima County, the cost of time is minimal compared to other methods

of transportation.
59
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Occupational Data

The employment rate in the Arizona has increased because of the increase in the state

construction industry. The unemployment rate as of August 2018 in Pima county was 4.8%,

which shows a downward trend compared to other counties in Arizona. However there is rise in

the construction of residential buildings which will increase the employment levels.

Unemployment has a significant impact on health outcomes in a community and the high

unemployment in Pima County depicts the state of public health in the county.

Pima County has a workforce of 50.81% women and 49.19% men, based on the

population of the county. The population of the workforce in Pima County is made up of 436,074

people which is the population above 16 years of age. However, 4.6% of this population are

unemployed, according to unemployment data. Only 11.0% of the entire population in Pima

County is covered with health insurance among people 65 years or older. Regarding labor force

participation by race, the mixed color ethnic groups have a labor participation rate of 65%. The

Hispanic ethnic group follows with a labor force participation of 64%, the 2+ races group

follows with 63% labor force participation, the African-American group follows with 62%, and

the White non-Hispanics have the lowest labor participation of 53%. Regarding education, the

workforce with a bachelor’s degree or higher has the highest labor force participation of 78%

and those with below high school education have the lowest labor force participation at 60%

(Pima County, Arizona Population, 2018).

Categories of employment in Pima County are diverse, and healthcare and social

assistance have the highest number of the workforce standing at 15.1% as of 2016. The

employment categories in Pima Counties include; healthcare and social assistance (15.1%), retail

trade (12.3%), education services (9.8%), accommodation and food service (8.4%),
60
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

administration, support, waste management services (7%), professional, scientific, technology

(6.8%), construction (6.5%), manufacturing (6.2%), public administration (5.8%) among others

(Pima County, 2018e). These data show that health care and social assistance have the largest

workforce in Pima County, accounting for 40.3% of the total employment which can translate to

better public health services and outcomes in the county. Females make up 76.59% of the health

care industry and the men make up 23.41%. In the retail industry, the females make up 49.13%

of it while the men make up 50.87%. The education sector consist of 61.42% of females and

38.58% of men. In the administrative sector the men constitute of 62.66% and the females form

37.34%. Females make up 48.35% in the professional industry and the men form 51.65%. The

manufacturing industry constitute of 29.15% of the females and 70.85% of the men. Other

industries in the county host 55.76% of the females and 44.24% of the men. From this data, it is

seen that the working class interestingly consists of more women than men in Pima County.

Whites constitute 66% of the employed, Hispanic constitute 64.1%, the blacks consist of 60.6%,

the Asians make up 60% while the mixed race consist of 58% and other races consist of 59.9%

of the employed.

Pima County has many large businesses. The current largest employer is the University of

Arizona. Between faculty, staff, and student workers, the university employs over 10,800 people.

Raytheon Missile Systems is the second largest employer in Pima County, with roughly 10,300

employees. Raytheon Missile Systems produce many missile systems for the U.S and our allied

forces, and their headquarter is located here in Tucson. The Davis-Monthan Air Force Base is

home to 9,100 employees. Other large employers are the State of Arizona with over 8,800

employees, Wal-Mart Stores Inc. employing 7,450 people, Tucson Unified School district with

7,688 workers, and U.S. Border Patrol with 6,500 employees (ARG Publications, 2018).
61
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The health risks associated with working in Pima County depends upon the job that is being

performed. A desk assistant at the University of Arizona has a lower health risk than someone

working a forklift for Wal-Mart, or someone putting together missiles and chemicals at Raytheon

Missile Systems. The health risks depend on the line of work and hazards associated with it.

However, these companies have policies in place to do their best to protect their workers. For

workers at the University of Arizona, they are at an increased risk of catching infectious diseases,

such as a cold or flu due to being around so many different people. Employees also face work-

place stress and legal considerations to accommodate everyone, which can be stressful on a person

(Morgan, 2017). Those employed with the U.S. Border Patrol are at an increased health risk of

violence, car chases, guns, and drugs. They are exposed to harsh temperatures of the Arizona desert

and may suffer from sunburn, skin cancer, and heat stroke (SafeGuard, 2018). Due to the nature

of the desert landscape, they also may encounter more breathing challenges due to the dirt. Their

encounters with dangerous and violent situations, such as seeing people die while trying to cross

over illegally or holding their dead infant, may cause them to have psychological troubles later on

such as PTSD (Soular, 2017).

Other Community Factors Impacting Health

Beyond the transportation and occupation aspects of the community health, a variety of

miscellaneous community factors have also significantly impacted the health of Pima County.

Specifically, such community factors have helped to increase the health awareness and health

literacy of the Pima County population. For examples, Pima County Employee Wellness offers a

variety of “quality programs and activities to encourage and support healthy, active lifestyles”

(Pima County, 2018b). These programs emphasize the importance of education, awareness, self-

care and behavioral changes to make meaningful strides towards improved health. The programs
62
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

that are offered with Pima County Employee Wellness are split into six different sections: Current

Programs and Activities, On-site Programs & Activities, Gym Subsidies & Discounts, Wellness

Challenges, Health Management Support Programs, and Resources & Events. These benefits,

which are made accessible to Pima County employees year-round, are designed to improve

participants’ quality of life (Pima County, 2018).

Current Programs and Activities include Flu Shots, Mobile Onsite Mammography and Fit

& Lean Team Challenge. Flu shots are offered this year from September-October and “El Rio

has partnered with Pima County to offer free on-site flu shots for all Pima County employees,

spouses, domestic partners and any dependents 18 years or older” (Pima County, 2018b). There

are also over 20 locations available for convenience and if anyone isn’t under the Pima County

medical plan, fees can be covered by using other insurance carriers. The Mobile Onsite

Mammography is a program available during the months of February and August and is

beneficial to help detect any abnormalities in women’s breasts. The Fit & Lean Team Challenge

is a 9-week summer program that encourages employees to “rejuvenate their motivation to

practice healthy behaviors to support their weight loss and maintenance goals” (Pima County,

2018b). The challenge consists of tracking workouts throughout the week, having weekly

challenges and participating in weigh-in/outs. These activities add up to points for prizes and

there are also grand prizes awarded to the top three winning teams/ individuals.

On-site Programs & Activities are “available for all employees to attend, are held at

various worksites and are typically available during the lunch break” (Pima County, 2018g).

Some activities include fitness classes like Zumba, health coaching, mindful meditation, weight

watchers, walking activities and wellness workshops that focus on living healthy through fitness,

nutrition and stress management. The on-site programs and activities are managed by “Employee
63
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Wellness, volunteers and the Wellness Council of Arizona,” and depending on the program

selected there is selected fees that apply (Pima County, 2018).

Gym Subsidies & Discounts allows Pima County employees and any family member that

lives in the same household to receive subsidized “membership rates at local fitness facilities”

(Pima County, 2018b). Additional amenities such as personal training or onsite child care would

require the payment of extra service fees at participating facilities such as LA fitness or the

YMCA. Another program that welcomes all employees to participate is Wellness Challenges.

Eight unique challenges are designed to get employees to participate in healthy lifestyles and no

matter where one works or what challenge is chosen, all materials needed to complete the

challenge are provided. These challenges can also be completed whenever is most convenient to

the employee because there are no designated classes to attend.

The next set of wellness programs provided are Health Management Support Programs.

This program teaches Pima County employees how one “can prevent health-related medical

conditions and/or manage your current health condition” (Pima County, 2018b). This program

provides particular immediate benefit given the high prevalence for diabetes, young pregnancies

and tobacco use in the Pima County population. Under this program, there are services provided

to raise awareness and focus on prevention. For example, Pima County has partnered up with

Aetna’s Beginning Right Maternity Program to help mothers achieve a healthier pregnancy and

baby. The diabetes prevention group is a support group that helps people “who are prediabetic or

diabetic eat healthier, increase their physical activity, and lose weight” (Pima County, 2018b).

Finally, tobacco cessation support is offered under this program to help individuals quit tobacco

by attending counseling to increase their rates of abstinence.


64
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Other initiatives have also promoted health and wellness within Pima County. The

University of Arizona’s College of Medicine (Tucson campus) held a Health & Wellness Fair for

all Pima County/City of Tucson employees in order to shed light on the number of resources

Pima County offers its employees. In addition to the opportunities that Pima County presents its

employees, commercial and non-profit vendors were also present at the Health & Wellness Fair

in order to promote opportunities for employees to better their own health and wellness through

“information, screenings, demonstrations, and more…” (University of Arizona Department of

Medicine, 2016). This event actively promoted public health awareness on a broad scale by

introducing the population to tangible opportunities to better their personal health.

The University of Arizona Eller Business School established a Social Media Monitoring

and Surveillance for Vector Borne Disease program that allowed for the spread of awareness of

public health issues related to vector borne diseases. This system works to track social media

trends and screen key public health topics popular among the online community, to “elicit public

feedback and reporting” on topics relevant to public health, and to measure the effectiveness

(through reach and impact) of social media campaigns promoting positive public health

practices, especially in relation to vector-borne diseases such as Zika Virus, West Nile Virus,

Dengue Fever, and the Chikungunya Virus (Social Media Monitoring, 2018). The Pima County

Health Department also encouraged the awareness of vector-borne (specifically mosquito-borne)

illnesses in the community through community-level programs such as “Fight the Bite! Day and

Night,” which was a 2016 program that shed light on the importance of adopting a preventative

approach to mosquito-borne diseases (the use of repellant, long-sleeve clothing, etc.) (The

University of Arizona, 2017).


65
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Apart from the previously categorized factors impacting community health in Pima

County, these community factors also greatly influence the health of the county. Through health

education and awareness programs, these other community factors not only educate the public on

relevant public health issues in the community, but also encourage the upholding of public health

principles and individual positive health practices.


66
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Summary
Part 1
As of 2017, Pima County has a population of 1,003,338 individuals. Out of this

population, around 95.9% is White, 3.5% is Black, 3.2% is American Indian or Alaskan Native,

2.7% is Asian, and 0.1% is Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander. Furthermore, 36.1% of all Pima

County residents identify as being Hispanic or Latino (US Census, 2017). However, with the

race classification and statistics, there are socioeconomic factors that are also shown in Pima

County. As an overall county with an average income of $33,259, Pima is ranked as the 2nd most

poverty-stricken county in Arizona. Asians are shown to have the highest average income of

$65,469, followed by Caucasians earning $54,461, and the lowest income race is African-

Americans with a median income of $32,584. As an extension of their low-income status,

African-Americans also have the highest poverty rate at 25.8% (Pima County, 2016a). The large

gaps in socioeconomic status also translate to disparities in health quality and health status.

Socioeconomic status, location, race distribution, and population size all have direct

effects on health status, health needs, and quality of life. The three most prominent causes of

death in Pima County are heart disease, cancer, and diabetes. In Arizona as a whole,

cardiovascular disease remains a leading cause of death. In 2010, Pima County had an average

CVD mortality rate of 191.8 deaths per 100,000 residents, compared to the 188.6 deaths per

100,000 residents of Arizona. Out of the 15 counties, Pima ranked 10th in terms of number of

deaths. Cancer is also a large cause of death in Pima County. When looking at cancers, in terms

of race, non-white Hispanics and Blacks have shown to have the highest rates of cancer, an

incident rate of 408.0 deaths/100,000 persons and 316.9 deaths / 100,000 persons respectively.

When looking at each race individually, each group is affected by specific health

problems and health needs that may not be relevant to other races. Generally, Asians tend to be
67
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

affected by the fewest health problems. They have the lowest morbidity from diabetes, cases of

cancer, and cardiovascular disease. On the other hand, Blacks/African-Americans and

Hispanic/Latinos have very high percentages of mortality from diseases. Blacks and Hispanics

have diabetes mortality rates of 13.1% and 11.2%, respectively. Hispanics and Blacks are also

shown to have the highest rates of cancer, per 100,000 cases (AZDHS, 2018). By extension, we

can say that Hispanics, Blacks, and American Indians generally experience a lower quality of life

as compared to White and Asian populations.

Not only do the different races demonstrate vastly different areas of the spectrum, they

also show how socioeconomic status impacts health status and health needs. Groups that tend to

have higher incomes are able to access healthier foods, afford hospital visits, pay for better

insurance, and other superior health needs. However, there is a group that is often misunderstood

and underrepresented: American Indians. American Indians have been a part of US history for a

very long time; however, their health concerns and proper health judgement have often been

biased due to public opinion. It should be a primary public health focus to give American Indians

a holistic assessment of their health needs and health status, as well as give them fair treatment

when these health issues are identified.


68
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Part 2
American Indians comprise 3.2% of the population of Pima County (Pima County

Population Demographics, 2016). Though this is a relatively small proportion of the population

of the entire Pima County, the subpopulation is affected by significant health challenges and

burdens. When comparing the total mortality from all causes for multiple racial/ethnic groups in

Pima County, the mortality of American Indians was found to be the highest (0.97%) in

comparison to all other racial/ethnic groups (Population Health and Vital Statistics, 2018). In a

comparison of health reports from multiple racial groups, American Indians reported “good

health” in the lowest numbers (Bass et al., 2014). American Indians also suffer from the lowest

level of educational attainment; they have demonstrated consistently elevated high school

dropout rates, and only 11.8% of Pima County American Indians hold at least a Bachelor’s

degree. The number and extent of these health disparities among the American Indian population

puts the group at an aggregate health risk that is incommensurate with the size and proportion of

the population in comparison to the total population of Pima County.

The American Indian population in Pima County suffers disproportionately from type 2

diabetes when compared to other subgroups of the population. In particular, 18.1% of Pima

County’s American Indian population was documented as suffering from morbidity due to

diabetes in 2015. This health disparity in Pima County’s American Indian population is seen

among all American Indian groups, but is especially pronounced in members of the Tohono

O’odham Nation, which is geographically localized almost entirely in Pima County. According

to the AZDHS’s Tohono O’odham Nation Statistical Profile for 2017, “unspecified diabetes

mellitus” is the leading cause of death among Tohono O’odham individuals between the ages of

65 and 84, classifying type 2 diabetes as a major health issue plaguing the Tohono O’odham
69
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

people (Tohono O’odham Nation Primary Care Area, 2017). The incidence and effects of type 2

diabetes among members of the Tohono O’odham Nation can be attributed to food insecurity

that American Indians have faced since the colonial beginnings of American history. The actions

and unfair treatment of American Indians by White European colonists not only drove them off

their land, but also placed them in areas where they suffered from a lack of access to health

resources.

Since a major risk factor for type 2 diabetes is poor diet quality, food insecurity is a key

determinant of diabetes status. Food insecurity is also an issue of particular significance to the

Tohono O’odham Nation. According to the Department of Planning & Economic Development

of the Tohono O’odham Nation Tribe (DPED), households on the Tohono O’odham Nation are

35% more likely to receive SNAP benefits when compared to other households in Pima County

(DPED, 2010). Further, the unavailability and inconvenience of access to traditional, more

healthful American Indian foods have exacerbated food insecurity in the Tohono O’odham

population.

For improved health and quality of life, we believe that the Tohono O’odham people

need active public health awareness and education initiatives that promote positive health

behaviors, especially in diet quality. These could include the use of Community Health Workers

(CHWs) who would work with the population to educate them on the health risks and

consequences associated with type 2 diabetes, and then build positive health and eating habits

through workshops and intervention programs in which individuals would learn how to access

and prepare healthier foods.


70
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

References

ADHS (2018). Arizona Cancer Registry. Retrieved September 30, 2018, from:

https://www.azdhs.gov/preparedness/public-health-statistics/cancer-registry/index.php

Affordable Housing Development. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/cms/one.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=24388

Air. (2018). Retrieved October 4, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/environmental_quality/air/

ARG Publications. (2018). Top 25 Tucson Employers and Businesses. Retrieved October 1,

2018, from http://www.phoenixrelocationguide.com/Top-25-Tucson-Employers-and-

Businesses/

Arizona Charter Schools Association, 2015, Increasing Diversity in Arizona Charter Schools

Over Time, Image retrieved October, 9, 2018, from: https://azcharters.org/

Arizona Department of Education. Data-Cohort 2017 Four Year Grad Rate Data. (2017).

Retrieved October 3, 2018 from https://www.azed.gov/accountability-research/data/

Arizona Department of Education. Data-Dropout Rates 2018. (2018). Retrieved October 9, 2018

from https://www.azed.gov/accountability-research/data/

Arizona Superior Court in Pima County. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://www.sc.pima.gov/default.aspx

Asthma In Arizona. (n.d.). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://www.azasthma.org/asthma-in-arizona/

AZDHS | Vital Records. (2018). Retrieved October 5, 2018 from

https://azdhs.gov/licensing/vital-records/index.php
71
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

AZDHS | Nutrition and Physical Activity and Obesity Program (NUPAO). (2018). Retrieved

September 30, 2018, from https://www.azdhs.gov/prevention/nutrition-physical-

activity/nutrition-physical-activity-obesity/index.php#empower-schools

AZ Health Zone Summer Lunch Buddies: Helping Kids Eat Healthy (2018). Retrieved October

10, 2018, from https://www.azhealthzone.org/summerfood

Bass, J., Bailey R., & Gieszl S. (2014). Arizona Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance Survey

2014. Retrieved October 2, 2018, from https://azdhs.gov/preparedness/public-health-

statistics/ behavioral-risk-factor-surveillance/index.php

Buffelgrass and Other Grassy Desert Invaders. (2018). Retrieved October 11, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/one.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=61835

Catholic Community Services of Southern Arizona | Social Services. (2014). Retrieved October

6, 2018, from https://www.ccs-soaz.org/

CHET-SE Dress Code, Conduct, & Guest Guidelines. (2018). Retrieved September 27, 2018,

from https://www.homeschool-life.com/121/custom/64076

Chicanos Por La Causa. (2018). Retrieved October 5, 2018, from

https://cplc.org/housing/housing.php

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2015). Community Health Assessments and Health

Improvement Plans. Retrieved October 2, 2018, from

https://www.cdc.gov/stltpublichealth/cha/plan.html

Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://www.communityfoodbank.org/Locations/Tucson
72
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona. (2018) Meal Sites offered through Community

Food Bank of Southern Arizona. Image retrieved October 7, 2018, from:

https://www.communityfoodbank.org/

Community Support Organization Tucson | Financial Empowerment Center Tucson. (2016).

Retrieved from https://tucsonurbanleague.org/

Data Access and Dissemination Systems (DADS). (2010). United States Census

Bureau. Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?src=CF

Data Access and Dissemination Systems (DADS). (2010a). Pima County, American Factfinder.

Retrieved October 10, 2018 from

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/community_facts.xhtml?src=bkmk

Data Access and Dissemination Systems (DADS). (2010b). Pima County, Financial

Characteristics. Retrieved from

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?src=CF

Data Access and Dissemination Systems (DADS). (2016). Your Geography Selections.

Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_

16_1YR_B01003&prodType=table

Davis, T. (2017). South-side Tucsonans mobilize for another water-pollution struggle.

Retrieved September 30, 2018, from https://tucson.com/news/local/south-side-tucsonans-

mobilize-for-another-water-pollution-struggle/article_25aafd92-3a5a-5550-bbd6-

9fc0d02cd0dd.html
73
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Department of Planning & Economic Development Tohono O’odham Nation Tribe. (2010).

Demographic Analysis of the Tohono O’odham Nation. Retrieved October 25, 2018,

from file:///T:/Temp/Downloads/tohono_oodham_nation_0.pdf

Dickenson, C. (2016). Zip Code Project Data. Arizona Department of education. Retrieved

September 30, 2018, from

http://www.azed.gov/zipcode/files/2016/12/zipcodeproject_toolkit_final-v2.pdf

Drive-Less Pledge. (2018). Retrieved October 4, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/cms/one.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=192695

Dust Storms - Pinal County. (n.d.). Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

http://www.pinalcountyaz.gov/AirQuality/Dust/Pages/DustStorms.aspx

Emergency Financial Aid. (2018). Retrieved October 3, 2018, from

https://www.icstucson.org/emergency-financial-aid

Environmental Protection Agency. (2017). Reviewing National Ambient Air Quality Standards

(NAAQS): Scientific and Technical Information. EPA. Retrieved October 4, 2018 from:

https://www.epa.gov/naaqs

Fazzino, David V. (2008) Traditional Food Security: Tohono O’odham Traditional Foods in

Transition. University of Florida. Retrieved October 25, 2018 from

http://etd.fcla.edu/UF/UFE0021669/fazzino_d.pdf

Fischer, H. (2017). As employment rises across Arizona, Pima County trends

downward. Capitol Media Services. Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

https://tucson.com/business/as-employment-rises-across-arizona-pima-county-trends-

downward/article_16952953-992b-5b3b-9837-81b79652ed43.html.

Food Pantries. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from


74
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

https://www.foodpantries.org/ci/az-tucson

Foreclosure Prevention. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/community/help_now/foreclosure_prevention/

García, F. (2014). State of the County’s Health. Pima County Health Department. Retrieved

October 10, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Health/Health%20Data,%20St

atistics%20and%20Reports/StateCountyHealth2014.pdf

G.P. Nabhan., J. Mabry., D. Johnson., C. Ferrales. (2018). State of Tucson’s Food System.

Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://foodstudies.arizona.edu/sites/default/files/publications/TucsonFoodSystems2017_l

ow.pdf

Gray-Emmer, J. (n.d.). Healthy Communities. Retrieved October 8, 2018 from:

https://www.unitedwaytucson.org/healthy_communities

Healthy People, (2016.).40 Years of Increasing Access to Health Services through Mobile Health

in Tucson, AZ. Retrieved October 24, 2018, from

https://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/healthy-people-in-action/story/40-years-of-

increasing-access-to-health-services-through-mobile

Healthy Pima. (2018). Community Wellbeing. Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

https://www.healthypima.com/

Helping our Community. (2013). Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from https://www.cdoassemblyofgod.com/helping-our-community/

Hernandez, Blazer, Hernandez, Lyla M, Blazer, Dan G., & Institute of Medicine . Committee on

Assessing Interactions, Among Social, Behavioral, Genetic Factors in Health. (2006).


75
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Genes, behavior, and the social environment moving beyond the nature/nurture debate.

Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

High School Graduation Rates. (2018). Retrieved September 25, 2018, from

https://mapazdashboard.arizona.edu/education/high-school-graduation-rates

Homelessness. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/community/help_now/homelessness

Home Page. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from http://thegardenkitchen.org/

Home Repair Assistance. (2018.). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/community/housing/home_repair_assistance/

Hope of Glory Ministries. (2016). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

http://www.tucsonhope.org/homeless-facts/

Housing Services. (n.d.). Retrieved October 4, 2018, from https://saaf.org/care-services/housing-

services/

Howard Fischer Capitol Media Services. (2010). Arizona is now No. 2 in poverty. Retrieved

October 5, 2018, from https://tucson.com/news/local/arizona-is-now-no-in-

poverty/article_551a7372-415a-5dc5-a27d-ab19a1171e81.html

How is poverty measured? (2018). Retrieved September 30, 2018 from

https://www.irp.wisc.edu/resources/how-is-poverty-measured/

Humble, W. (2010). Pima County Cancer Report 2001-2010. Retrieved October 22, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Health/Health Data, Statistics

and Reports/Pima Cancer Data 2001-10 - FINAL - 8-1-14.pdf

Infectious Disease Epidemiology. (2013). Retrieved October 10, 2018 from:


76
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

https://www.azdhs.gov/documents/preparedness/epidemiology-disease-control/disease-

data-statistics-reports/annual-reports-archive/infectious-disease-epidemiology-report-

2008-2013.pdf

Invasive Species E.I.S. Issue Paper: Sonoran Desert Conservation Plan. (n.d.). Retrieved

October 11, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Government/Office%20of%20

Sustainability%20and%20Conservation/Conservation%20Sciece/The%20Sonoran%20De

sert%20Conservation%20Plan/Accomplishments/Timeline%20reports/Invasive%20Speci

es%20Issue%20Paper.pdf

Kelly, G. (2018). UA Leads Asthma Program With Tucson Unified School District

and American Lung Association. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://uanews.arizona.edu/story/ua-leads-asthma-program-with-tucson-unified-school-

district-and-american-lung-association

Kemp, M.S., Gupta, S., Torres, C. (2018). Advances Vital Statistics by County of Residence

Arizona, 2017. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-

stats/report/avs/index.php

Links & FAQs. (2018). Retrieved October 7, 2018, from http://www.schools.pima.gov/links-faqs

Long, B. (2018). Pima County releases tips on how to "Beat the Heat". Retrieved

October 10, 2018, from https://www.kgun9.com/news/local-news/pima-county-releases-

tips-on-how-to-beat-the-heat

Lumen Learning. (n.d.). Introduction to Sociology. Retrieved from

https://courses.lumenlearning.com/sociology/chapter/what-is-social-stratification/

Make a real change in someone's life. (2017). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from
77
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

https://www.communityfoodbank.org/

McShane, M. Q., & National Research. (2018). How to Tell If You Can Afford Private

School. Retrieved September 30, 2018, from https://www.edchoice.org/blog/how-to-tell-

if-you-can-afford-private-school/

Migrant Education / Migrant Education Homepage. (2017). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://www.maranausd.org/migrant

Morgan, L. A. (2017). The Hazards of Being a Teacher. Retrieved from

https://work.chron.com/hazards-being-teacher-9309.html

National School Lunch Program. (2018). Retrieved October 7, 2018, from

http://www.azed.gov/hns/nslp/

Nutrition Education Community Food Bank of Southern Arizona (2017). Retrieved October 1,

2018 from https://www.communityfoodbank.org/Our-Work/Programs/Nutrition

Our Impact. (2015.). Retrieved October 4, 2018, from https://azcharters.org/our-impact/

PDEQ issues another High Pollution Advisory. (2018). Retrieved October 4, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=440964

Pima Accommodation. (2018). Retrieved October 7, 2018, from

http://www.schools.pima.gov/pima-accommodation

Pima County. (2016a). DATA USA. Retrieved September 25, 2018, from

https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/

Pima County. (2016b). Mosquitoes. Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/health/preventive_health/disease_control/mosquitoes

Pima County. (2016c). Transportation. Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

https://datausa.io/profile/geo/pima-county-az/#category_transportation
78
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Pima County. (2018a). Air Quality. Retrieved October 5, 2018 from:

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/environmental_quality/air/air_monitoring/

Pima County. (2018b). Employee Wellness Programs. Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/government/human_resources/employee_wellness_programs/

Pima County. (2018c). Attractions & Tourism. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=18639

Pima County. (2018d). Behavioral Health. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/behavioral_health/

Pima County. (2018e). Community and Economic Development. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/community_and_economic_development/

Pima County. (2018f). Community Development and Neighborhood Conservation. Retrieved

October 10, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/community_development_neighborhood_conservati

on/

Pima County. (2018g). Community Services, Employment and Training. Retrieved October 10,

2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/community_services_employment_and_training/

Pima County. (2018h). County Administrator. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from https://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=551

Pima County. (2018i). Food Environment Statistics. Retrieved October 10,

2018, from http://www.city-data.com/food/food-Pima-Arizona.html

Pima County. (2018j). Health Department. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/health_department/
79
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Pima County. (2018k). Medical Examiner. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/medical_examiner/

Pima County. (2018l). Office of Emergency Management. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=18529

Pima County. (2018m). Pima Animal Care Center. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/pima_animal_care_center/

Pima County. (2018n). Pima County Wireless Integrated Network (PCWIN). Retrieved October

10, 2018, from http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=82043

Pima County. (2018o). Public Health Emergency Preparedness. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/public_health_emergency_preparedness

Pima County. (2018p). Law Enforcement Agencies and Links. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/government/law_enforcement/

Pima County. (2018q). Public Works. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from https://webcms.pima.gov/government/public_works

Pima County. (2018r). Special Needs. Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from https://webcms.pima.gov/community/housing/special_needs/

Pima County. (2018s). Environmental Quality. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/government/environmental_quality/

Pima County, Arizona Population 2018. (2018). World Population Review. Retrieved October

1, 2018, from http://worldpopulationreview.com/us-counties/az/pima-county-population/.

Pima County AZ Education Data. (2017). Retrieved September 28, 2018, from

http://www.towncharts.com/Arizona/Education/Pima-County-AZ-Education-data.html

Pima County Sheriff's Department. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from
80
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

https://www.pimasheriff.org/

Pima County Office of the Medical Examiner Annual Report 2016. (2017). Retrieved

October 11, 2018, from

https://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Government/Medical

Examiner/Resources/Annual-Report-2016.pdf

Pima County, This Land Is Your Land, 40 Years of Voters Conservation Support. (n.d-a).

Retrieved from:

http://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Government/Natural%20Resour

ces%20Parks%20and%20Recreation/Natural%20Resources/FINAL%20This%20Land%

20is%20your%20Land.pdf

Pima County Transportation. (2015). The Roads to Recovery [Brochure]. Retrieved

October 1, 2018 from

http://webcms.pima.gov/UserFiles/Servers/Server_6/File/Government/Transportationr

nsportation%20Funds/RevisedMarch2015-1613-TransportationFUndingBasicsbrochu.

df

Population Health and Vital Statistics: Arizona Health Status and Vital Statistics 2016 Annual

Report for the Elderly Mortality. (2018). Retrieved October 11, 2018, from

https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-stats/report/ahs/ahs2016/index.php?pg=state

Population Health and Vital Statistics: Hospital Inpatient Discharges & Emergency Room Visits

Statistics for Asthma. (2018). Retrieved October 11, 2018, from

https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-stats/hip/index.php?pg=asthma

Population Health and Vital Statistics: Vital Statistics Trends in Arizona. (2018). Retrieved
81
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

October 11, 2018, from https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-

stats/menu/info/trend/index.php?pg=deaths

Poverty Rate. (2017). Retrieved October 3, 2018

from https://mapazdashboard.arizona.edu/health-social-well-being/poverty-rate

Recovery Tracker. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018 from

https://projects.propublica.org/recovery/locale/arizona/pima/dept/8600

SAAF. (2018). Retrieved September 28, 2018 from https://saaf.org/

SafeGuard. (2018). The Dangers of Being a Border Patrol Agent. Retrieved from

https://www.safeguardclothing.com/articles/dangers-that-come-with-being-a-border-p

trol-agent/

Sagna, M., Gupta, S., & Torres, C. (2018). Mortality and Morbidity From Exposure to

Excessive Natural Heat in Arizona, 2006-2016. Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://pub.azdhs.gov/health-stats/report/heat/heat-2016.pdf

School Gardening. (2018). Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

http://www.pimafoodalliance.org/resources/school-gardening/

School Meal Programs, Student Meal Prices for the 2017-2018 School Year. Image retrieved

October 10, 2018, from: http://www.tusd1.org/Departments/Food-Services/School-Meal-

Programs

School Meal Programs. (2018). Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

http://www.tusd1.org/Departments/Food-Services/School-Meal-Programs

Some convenience stores fill up on fruit, vegetables. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018, from

https://www.thepacker.com/article/some-convenience-stores-fill-fruit-vegetables

Soular, D. A. (2017). Border agents, and the risks at the edge of the line. Retrieved from
82
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

https://www.usatoday.com/border-wall/story/us-border-patrol-control-

mexico/633139001/

South Tucson, AZ. (2016). Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

https://datausa.io/profile/geo/south-tucson-az/z

State Cancer Profiles. (2015). Retrieved September 30, 2018, from

https://statecancerprofiles.cancer.gov/incidencerates/index.php?stateFIPS=04&cancer=05

3&race=00&sex=0&age=001&type=incd&sortVariableName=rate&sortOrder=desc#resu

lts

Sun Van. (2018). Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

http://www.sunvan.com/files/17_Dec_8_2018TransitFares.pdf

Synergy: Lifestyle Medicine (2018). Arizona Cancer Statistics by County, Age, Race and More.

Retrieved October 3, 2018, from:

https://www.synergylifestylemedicine.com/blog/arizona-cancer-statistics-county-age-

race-gender/

Target Area Report. (2012). Retrieved October 25, 2018, from

https://azprc.arizona.edu/sites/default/files/Pima County CPPW Target Area Final

Report.pdf

TCAZ. (2018). Retrieved September 30, 2018, from https://tcaz.org/about-us/

TIHAN. (2017.). Retrieved October 3, 2018, from https://tihan.org/services/

The Chuck Huckelberry Loop. (2018). Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/one.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=35827
83
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

The Pima County School Superintendent's Office Promotes Educational Excellence Through

LEADERSHIP, SERVICE, & COLLABORATION. (2018). Retrieved September 30,

2018, from http://www.schools.pima.gov/

The University of Arizona. (2017). Fight the Bite! Day and Night Campaign – Prevention of

West Nile Virus and other mosquito-transmitted illnesses. Retrieved October 25, 2018,

from https://uaatwork.arizona.edu/node/35846

Tohono O’odham Nation Primary Care Area Statistical Profile – 2017. (2017). Retrieved

October 25, 2018, from https://azdhs.gov/documents/prevention/health-systems-

development/data-reports-maps/primary-care/pima/82.pdf

Trichlorethylene (TCE) Pollution in Tucson Water. (2014). Retrieved September

30, 2018, from https://www.library.pima.gov/blogs/post/trichlorethylene-tce-pollution-in-

tucson-water/

Tucson Electric Power. (2016) Retrieved October 3, 2018, from https://www.tep.com/

Tucson Update - Ethnicity. (2015). Retrieved September 28, 2018, from

https://www.tucsonaz.gov/hcd/tucson-update-ethnicity

Tucson South Primary Care Area (PCA) Statistical Profile. (2018). Retrieved October 10, 2018,

from https://azdhs.gov/documents/prevention/health-systems-development/data-reports-

maps/primary-care/pima/111.pdf

University of Arizona Department of Medicine. (2016). 2016 Health & Wellness Fair for Pima

County/City of Tucson Employees. Retrieved October 2, 2018, from

http://deptmedicine.arizona.edu/event/2016/2016-health-wellness-fair-pima-countycity-

tucson-employees

University of Arizona Eller INSITE. (2018). Social Media Monitoring and Surveillance for
84
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Vector-Borne Diseases. Retrieved October 1, 2018, from

https://insiteua.org/research/social-media-vector-borne-diseases

Urizar-Faught, C. (2018). Behavioral Health Services. Retrieved October 5, 2018, from

https://www.casadelosninos.org/programs-resources/behavioral-health-treatment-

programs/behavioral-health-services/

U.S. Bureau. (2010). Your Geography Selections. Retrieved October 4, 2018, from

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?pid=ACS_

16_5YR

U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: Pima County, Arizona. (n.d.). Retrieved September 29, 2018,

from https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/pimacountyarizona/PST045217

U.S Census Bureau, 2012-2016 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates.

Retrieved October 7, 2018, from:

https://factfinder.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/productview.xhtml?src=CF

U.S Census, 2010, Educational Attainment in Pima County by Race. Image retrieved September

30, 2018, from: https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/decennial-

census/decade.2010.html

What Is Poverty? Definition and Measurement. (n.d.). Retrieved September 30, 2018,

from https://poverty.ucdavis.edu/what-poverty-definition-and-measurement

10-year Pima County Road Repair Plan. (2018). Retrieved September 28, 2018,

from http://webcms.pima.gov/cms/One.aspx?portalId=169&pageId=345232
85
COMMUNITY HEALTH ASSESSMENT FOR PIMA COUNTY

Anda mungkin juga menyukai