Anda di halaman 1dari 129

Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 24

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS

RAZ Imports, Inc., )


)
Plaintiff, ) Case No.
)
v. ) COMPLAINT
)
The Gerson Companies, ) JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
)
Defendant. )

COMPLAINT

NOW COMES Plaintiff, RAZ Imports, Inc. and respectfully files this Complaint for

Design Patent Infringement against Defendant, The Gerson Companies, alleging as follows:

NATURE OF LAWSUIT

1. This is an action for copyright infringement and arises under the United States
Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. § 101, et seq., based on acts of copyright infringement in the United

States.

2. This is also an action for design patent infringement and arises under the United
States Patent Act, 35 U.S.C. § 101 et seq. based on acts of design patent infringement in the

United States.

3. This is also an action for fraudulent misrepresentation arising under Kansas law.
THE PARTIES

4. Plaintiff RAZ Imports, Inc. (hereinafter “RAZ”) is a business incorporated in the

State of Texas and having its principal place of business at 1020 Eden Road, Arlington, Texas
76001.

5. RAZ was established in 1979 and is a wholesale importer of seasonal holiday

decorations and home accents. RAZ sells Christmas, Easter, Spring, Halloween, Thanksgiving
and Fall décor as well as floral items.

6. RAZ maintains a website, www.razimports.com, where registered retailers can


Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 24

view items offered for sale by RAZ for purchase, request and download catalogs and perform
other actions. Additionally, RAZ maintains several show-rooms across the country, including a

showroom at the “Dallas Market Center,” Dallas World Trade Center, 2050 N. Stemmons

Freeway, Suite 340, Dallas, TX 75207, where many of RAZ’s current products are on display
and available for order.

7. Defendant, The Gerson Companies (hereinafter “Gerson”), is a Kansas Company

that maintains its headquarters and principal place of business at 1450 S. Lone Elm Rd., Olathe,
KS 66061.

8. Gerson is also a wholesale importer of seasonal merchandise and sells and offers

seasonal and holiday merchandise. Accordingly, Defendant Gerson is a direct competitor to


RAZ.

9. Gerson maintains a website at www.gersoncompanies.com where registered

retailers may order items that Gerson offers for sale. Gerson also utilizes space at the Keith
Smith Ltd. showroom at the “Dallas Market Center,” Dallas World Trade Center, 2050 N.

Stemmons Freeway, Showroom 200-WTC, 2nd Floor, Dallas, TX 75207, where many of

Gerson’s products are on display and available for order.


JURISDICTION AND VENUE

10. As an action for copyright infringement under the Copyright Act and for design

patent infringement under the Patent Act, this Court has exclusive jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. §
1331 and § 1338.

11. Further, as an action for fraudulent misrepresentation under Kansas law, this

Court has supplemental jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1367.


12. This Court has personal jurisdiction over Defendant because Defendant is located

and resides in the State of Kansas. This Court also has personal jurisdiction over Defendant

because it committed and continues to commit acts of infringement in violation of 28 U.S.C. §


271 and places infringing products into the stream of commerce, with the knowledge or

understanding that such products are sold in the State of Kansas. Accordingly, the acts by

Defendant Gerson cause injury to Plaintiff RAZ within this District. Upon information and

2
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 24

belief, Defendant Gerson derives substantial revenue from the sale of infringing products within
this District, expects its actions to have consequences within this District and derives substantial

revenue from interstate commerce.

13. Venue is proper within this District under 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b) and (c) as well as
1400(a) and (b). Defendant Gerson is located in this judicial district and because a substantial

part of the acts and omissions giving rise to the claims outlined herein occurred in this judicial

district.
BACKGROUND

14. Plaintiff RAZ is a wholesale importer of seasonal merchandise. The products that

RAZ develops are sold to retailers nationwide. RAZ’s direct customers range from small gift
shops to large “big box retailers.” RAZ products can also be purchased from online retailers

such as Amazon.com.

15. In part, RAZ competes in the marketplace through its innovation of new products.
A prime example of RAZ’s innovative approach to design is embodied in its series of water

lanterns. Water lanterns are RAZ’s unique twist on the classic snow-globe, which combine a

central scene – for example, a Christmas Tree and Snowman – placed within an ornamental shell
that is often designed to evoke an old-fashioned oil lantern. Different central scenes are offered,

such as other Christmas themes (such as Santas, Sleighs, Nativities, Christmas trees, etc.),

Halloween themes or Spring/Easter themes. Similarly, the ornamental lantern shell is offered in
various shapes, styles, finish colors, textures or scroll work.

16. RAZ has taken steps to protect its innovative water lantern products by registering

certain designs with the United States Copyright Office and applying for and receiving design
patents from the United States Patent and Trademark Office.

17. In that regard, RAZ now brings the instant case alleging infringement of one

copyright and two design patents owned by RAZ against Defendant Gerson.
RAZ’s Copyright and Design Patents

18. Effective December 8, 2017 Plaintiff RAZ obtained Copyright Registration VA 2-

106-034, entitled “Lantern Santa” from the United States Copyright Office. A true and correct

3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 24

copy of the Copyright Registration for VA 2-106-034 is attached hereto as Exhibit A


(hereinafter “RAZ’s Copyrighted Design”).

19. In conjunction with the registration of RAZ’s Copyrighted Design, RAZ

submitted a sample to the United States Copyright Office in the form of an image of the design.
A copy of that image is reproduced below:

RAZ’s Copyrighted Design VA 2-106-03

20. On January 29, 2019, United States Design Patent No. D839,463 was duly and
legally issued by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (the “`463 patent”). The `463

patent has remained in force since that time and continues to be in force. A true and correct copy

of the `463 patent is attached hereto as Exhibit B.


21. Plaintiff RAZ is the owner of all right, title and interest in the `463 patent,

including the right to bring this action for any past or present infringement of the `463 patent,

collect past damages and obtain injunctions. RAZ is the owner by assignment from the inventor,
Mr. Chen Kong Fu, and is listed as the owner/assignee on the front face of the issued `463

patent.

22. The `463 patent is entitled “Snow Globe Lantern,” another common name for
water lanterns in the industry. The `463 patent covers an ornamental design for a water lantern

into which various scenes can be placed for viewing within the central window area. For

4
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 24

example, Figure 1 of the `463 patent shows a perspective view of this ornamental design:

RAZ’s `463 Design Patent, Exhibit B, Figure 1

The `463 patent includes sixteen separate figures that are directed to different views or

perspectives of RAZ’s ornamental design. As the `463 patent explains: “Dashed broken lines are
for illustrating unclaimed portions of the snow globe lantern and/or for illustrating an

environment related to the claimed design. Dashed-dot broken lines are for illustrating …

unclaimed areas of the snow globe lantern; the dashed-dot line forms no part of the claimed
design.” Exhibit B, page 1.

23. On November 5, 2019, United States Design Patent No. D866,033 was duly and

legally issued by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (the “`033 patent”). The `033
patent has remained in force since that time and continues to be in force. A true and correct copy

of the `033 patent is attached hereto as Exhibit C. The`033 patent is a continuation of the `463

patent.
24. Plaintiff RAZ is the owner of all right, title and interest in the `033 patent,

including the right to bring this action for any past or present infringement of the `033 patent,

collect past damages and obtain injunctions. RAZ is the owner by assignment from the inventor,
Mr. Chen Kong Fu, and is listed as the owner/assignee on the front face of the issued `033

patent.

5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 24

25. The `033 patent is entitled “Snow Globe Lantern” and covers an ornamental
design for a water lantern into which various scenes can be placed for viewing within the central

window area. For example, Figure 1 of the `033 patent shows a perspective view of this

ornamental design:

RAZ’s `033 Design Patent, Exhibit C, Figure 1

The `033 patent includes eight separate figures showing differing views and perspectives of the
ornamental design. As the `033 patent explains: “Dashed broken lines are for illustrating

unclaimed portions of [the design] and/or for illustrating an environment related to the claimed

design; the broken lines form no part of the claimed design.” Exhibit C, page 1.
26. RAZ’s has extensively promoted and advertised the water lantern designs

embodied in the RAZ Copyrighted Design and the `463 and `033 patents. As a result, RAZ’s

products have been successful in the marketplace.


Gerson’s Infringing Activity

27. In December 2018, RAZ became aware of Defendant Gerson’s selling and

offering for sale unauthorized versions of designs protected by RAZ’s Copyright and then-
pending design patent applications.

28. Specifically, Defendant Gerson was importing, displaying, offering for sale and

selling unauthorized products covered by RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design Patents through
6
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 24

Defendant’s product number SKU # 3499030. A side-by-side comparison between Gerson’s


SKU #3499030 product and RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design Patents is presented below:

Gerson SKU # 3499030 RAZ `463 Design Patent, Figure 1

Gerson SKU # 3499030 RAZ `033 Design Patent, Figure 1

29. Additionally, Defendant Gerson was importing, displaying, offering for sale and
selling unauthorized products covered by RAZ’s Copyrighted Design through Defendant’s

Product Number, #2497460, which is reproduced side-by-side with the photographic sample

submitted by RAZ when registering for the RAZ Copyrighted Design:

7
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 24

Gerson SKU # 2497460 RAZ Copyright VA 2-106-034

30. Below, this same Gerson product, SKU # 2497460, is presented side-by-side next
to Figure 1 of RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design Patents:

Gerson SKU # 2497460 RAZ `463 Design Patent, Figure 1

8
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 24

Gerson SKU # 2497460 RAZ `033 Design Patent, Figure 1

31. Additionally, Gerson has been importing, displaying, offering for sale and selling

Gerson SKU # 2497500, which is presented side-by-side with RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design
Patents:

Gerson SKU # 2497500 RAZ `463 Design Patent, Figure 1

9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 24

Gerson SKU # 2497500 RAZ `033 Design Patent, Figure 1

32. Additionally, Gerson has been importing, displaying, offering for sale and selling
Gerson SKU # 249650 which is presented side-by-side with RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design

Patents:

Gerson SKU # 2497650 RAZ `463 Design Patent, Figure 1

10
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 24

Gerson SKU # 2497650 RAZ `033 Design Patent, Figure 1

33. Additionally, Gerson has been importing, displaying, offering for sale and selling

Gerson SKU # 2520830 which is presented side-by-side with RAZ’s `463 and `033 Design

Patents:
Gerson SKU # 25250830 RAZ `463 Design Patent, Figure 1

11
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 24

Gerson SKU # 2520830 RAZ `033 Design Patent, Figure 1

34. Importantly, Gerson appears to utilize the same SKU # for water lanterns having

the same ornamental construction, but including differing combinations of texturing, finishing
and various central scenes. For example, all of the images reproduced below are associated with

the SKU # 2497460 number:

Gerson SKU # 2497460 Variations

Examples of different finishes and textures utilizing the same ornamental design can been seen

12
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 24

below, which are alternative versions of Gerson SKU # 2497500:


Gerson SKU # 2497500 Variations

35. Gerson’s SKU # 2497460, 2497500, 2497650, 2520830, and 3499030 along with
any and all variations thereon and any other Gerson product exhibiting substantially identical

designs are collectively referred herein as the “Accused Products.”

36. Plaintiff RAZ provided Gerson with actual notice of RAZ’s Copyrighted Design
and then-pending design patent applications in a letter dated January 9, 2019. This letter

(excluding its exhibits) is attached hereto as Exhibit D. This letter provided Gerson with a copy

of the Copyright Registration, copies of the then-pending design patent application and side-by-
side comparisons of RAZ’s Copyrighted Design and design patent application against the

Accused Products that RAZ was then aware of – SKU # 2497460, # 2497500 and 3499030.

Other comparisons and notice to a third RAZ design application, which is still pending, was also
included. Additionally, the January 9, 2019 letter demanded that Gerson cease and desist from

infringing upon RAZ’s Copyright, provide information regarding the number of items sold and

an accounting. Finally, the letter warned that RAZ’s `463 design patent would soon issue.
37. In a letter dated January 22, 2019, Gerson responded. A copy of this latter is

attached hereto as Exhibit E. Therein, Gerson denied infringement of the copyright and the

soon-to-be-issued `463 design patent. Gerson also denied that any of the lanterns identified in
RAZ’s January 9, 2019 letter had shipped.

13
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 24

38. Additionally, in its response, Gerson represented that it would change its lanterns.
Gerson provided artwork representing the redesign, which is reproduced below:

Gerson-Proposed “Redesign”

39. RAZ replied in a letter dated January 24, 2019 that based on these Gerson

representations that RAZ believed the matter resolved. A copy of this letter is attached hereto as

Exhibit F. Specifically, RAZ understood and relied upon three key representations by Gerson,
all of which were outlined in the reply: (1) “Gerson has redesigned its lantern offerings for

Christmas 2019 based on the artwork attached to the January 22, 2019 letter;” (2) No shipments

have or will be made of the SKU # 2497460, 3499030, 2497350 and 2597500 lantern
products…. Further, no lanterns having those overall appearances will be sold or offered for sale

by Gerson going forward;” and (3) “Only the redesigned lanterns will be shipped (presumably

under some separate SKU #).” Moreover, RAZ agreed that Gerson’s proposed redesign was not
infringing either the RAZ Copyrighted Design or the then-pending design patent applications.

Provided that RAZ’s understanding of Gerson’s representations was correct, RAZ was willing to

forebear and not pursue the matter in litigation – a condition expressly set forth in the RAZ reply,
Exhibit F.

40. Gerson responded by email on January 30, 2019. A copy of this email is

attached hereto as Exhibit G. Therein, Gerson “confirm[ed] the understandings set forth in the

14
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 24

bullet points of [RAZ’s] letter with one exception. Although Gerson will change the lanterns
exactly as described in the letter, Gerson will still be shipping using the original SKU numbers.”

Exhibit G.

41. On February 8, 2019, RAZ was forced to write yet another letter to Gerson. A
copy of this letter is attached hereto as Exhibit H. Two problems with Gerson’s previous

representations had been discovered. First, it appeared based on a Gerson catalog available

online that Gerson was still displaying, offering for sale and selling the infringing designs and
was not offering for sale the Gerson Redesigned product. Second, these infringing products were

listed by the online catalog as “Top Sellers,” which seemed to contradict Gerson’s representation

that no product had actually shipped to customers.


42. On February 14, 2019 Gerson responded in a letter attached hereto as Exhibit I.

Gerson reiterated its belief that no Copyright or Design Patent infringement existed, reiterated

that no Accused Products have shipped and that the images would be removed from Gerson’s
website.

43. Gerson did not follow through with these representations to RAZ. On August 14,

2019 RAZ was forced to write yet another letter to Gerson demanding an explanation as to why
the products Gerson agreed to remove from its website and replace with the redesigned product

were still being offered for sale. A copy of this letter is attached hereto as Exhibit J.

44. Gerson’s subsequent response, dated August 23, 2019 and attached hereto as
Exhibit K, asserted that it was all a mistake: “Unfortunately, these items were mistakenly

included in that catalog…. In order to avoid a pointless dispute, Gerson will ship no lanterns of

this style in response to orders of these products from the Spring 2020 catalog, but instead will
substitute the previously communicated style of lanterns used for all Christmas orders for these

depicted lanterns.”

45. Despite these further representations, Accused Products remain featured on


Gerson’s website to this day and, upon information and belief, Gerson has never featured the

redesigned product on its on-line website. Moreover, Gerson has not replaced the Accused

Products with the redesigned product, but rather shipped and continues to ship the Accused

15
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 24

Products, despite its several representations to the contrary. Given the failure of Gerson to act in
accordance with its numerous representations to RAZ regarding implementing the redesigned

product and removing images of Accused Products from the Gerson website, RAZ is forced to

conclude that Gerson shipped Accused Products rather than the redesign products on all orders
taken for the SKU numbers associated with the Accused Products.

COUNT ONE
(Copyright Infringement)

46. Plaintiff RAZ re-alleges all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through

45, above, as though fully set forth herein.


47. Copyright Registration VA 2-106-034, entitled “Water Lantern” is registered to

RAZ and represents a work of authorship protectable under the Copyright Act 17 U.S.C. § 101 et

seq. A true and correct copy of the Copyright Registration for VA 2-106-034 is attached hereto
as Exhibit A. The effective date of this registration is December 8, 2017.

48. Plaintiff is the sole owner of all right, title and interest to the RAZ Copyrighted

Design, which is valid, subsisting and in full force and effect.


49. In early 2017 RAZ displayed the RAZ Copyrighted Design at the Dallas Market

Center showroom, and at other showrooms maintained by RAZ. Defendant Gerson also

displays, sells and offers for sale products – including upon information and belief the infringing
product – at another showroom at the same Dallas Market Center, and Gerson (or those acting on

Gerson’s behalf) had access to RAZ’s showroom at this same facility and would have had access

to the RAZ Copyrighted Design which was on display.


50. Additionally, or alternatively, upon information and belief, Defendant Gerson

would have also seen an image of the RAZ Copyrighted Design on the public portion of RAZ’s

website, www.razimports.com. For example, the RAZ Copyrighted design was displayed as part
of the “What’s Trending” feature of RAZ’s public website on or about June 27, 2017 as archived

by the Internet Archive organization,

https://web.archive.org/web/20171017053506/https:/razimports.com/.

16
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 24

51. Additionally, or alternatively, the RAZ Copyrighted Design was depicted in


RAZ’s “Fall and Winter Wholesale Catalog 2017,” shortly after its publication. Excerpts of

RAZ’s “Fall and Winter Wholesale Catalog 2017” including RAZ’s Copyrighted Design is

attached hereto as Exhibit L.


52. Accordingly, Defendant Gerson had several means by which to access RAZ’s

Copyrighted Design during the year 2017.

53. Defendant Gerson began to market its unauthorized copy of RAZ’s Copyrighted
Design sometime in 2018. Specifically, Defendant Gerson was importing, displaying, offering

for sale and selling unauthorized copies of RAZ’s Copyrighted Design through Defendant’s

Product Number, #2497460, which is reproduced side-by-side with the photographic sample
submitted by RAZ when registering for the RAZ Copyrighted Design:

Gerson SKU # 2497460 RAZ Copyright VA 2-106-034

54. As can be seen above, the Gerson SKU # 2497460 product is substantially similar
to the RAZ Copyrighted Design.

55. Therefore, Defendant Gerson has committed copyright infringement pursuant to

17 U.S.C. § 501 by importing, displaying, selling and offering for sell the unauthorized Gerson

17
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 24

SKU # 2497460, which represent unauthorized copies or derivative works based on the RAZ
Copyrighted Design.

56. Despite having been informed by RAZ on January 9, 2019 that it is engaging in

copyright infringement, Gerson persists and continues in its infringing activity. Further, given,
Gerson’s many broken representations to RAZ that products had not actually shipped, that a

redesigned product would be substituted for such orders and that images of Accused Products

would be removed from catalogs and websites, Gerson’s infringement of the RAZ Copyrighted
Design continues to this day and is willful.

57. As a result of Gerson’s infringement, Gerson has obtained direct and indirect

profits that it would not have realized but for its infringement. As such, RAZ is entitled to
disgorgement of Gerson’s profits that are directly and indirectly attributed to Gerson’s acts of

infringement.

58. Moreover, because RAZ’s Copyrighted Design was registered with the Copyright
Office prior to the commencement of infringement, RAZ is entitled to statutory copyright

damages in connection with Gerson’s infringing sales and attorneys’ fees.

59. Additionally, as a result of Gerson’s infringing behavior and acts, RAZ has
suffered substantially and requests that the Court issue an order impounding, seizing and/or

requiring forfeiture of all infringing designs including any copies, derivative works, molds or

other items relating to infringement to be turned over to RAZ or completely destroyed. Further,
RAZ requests that all infringing designs be removed from Gerson’s website and recalled from

Gerson’s retail level customers.

COUNT TWO

(Infringement of the `463 Patent)

60. Plaintiff RAZ re-alleges all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through
59, above, as though fully set forth herein.

61. Gerson has infringed and continues to infringe the claimed ornamental design of

the `463 patent by importing, providing, selling, offering to sell, distributing without authority

18
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 24

Gerson’s SKU # 2497460, 2497500, 2497650, 2520830, and 3499030 along with any and all
variations thereon and any other Gerson product exhibiting substantially identical designs, the

Accused Products.

62. Moreover, on information and belief, Gerson has induced, and is inducing the
infringement of the claimed design of the `463 patent. On information and belief, the direct

infringement induced by Gerson includes at least the unauthorized sales and offers for sale of the

Accused Products by Gerson’s retail level customers and websites, such as


www.batteryoperatedcandles.net, Amazon.com, and Kmart, where Gerson’s Accused Products

are sold and offered for sale.

63. Despite having been provided actual notice by RAZ on January 9, 2019 that it is
engaging in design patent infringement, Gerson persists and continues in its infringing activity.

Further, given, Gerson’s many broken representations to RAZ that products had not actually

shipped, that a redesigned product would be substituted for such orders, and that images of
Accused Products would be removed from catalogs and websites, Gerson’s infringement of the

`463 Design Patent continues to this day and is willful.

64. As a result of Gerson’s infringement, Gerson has obtained direct and indirect
profits that it would not have realized but for its infringement. As such, RAZ is entitled to its

lost profits, disgorgement of Gerson’s profits that are directly and indirectly attributed to

Gerson’s acts of infringement and in no instance compensation less than a reasonable royalty.

COUNT THREE

(Infringement of the `033 Patent)


65. Plaintiff RAZ re-alleges all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through

64, above, as though fully set forth herein.

66. Defendant has infringed and continues to infringe U.S. Design Patent D866,033 at
least by importing, selling and offering to sell in the United States water lantern products under

Gerson SKU# 2497460, 2497500, 2497650, 2520830, and 3499030, which embodies the design

covered by U.S. Design Patent D866,033.

19
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 20 of 24

67. Gerson has infringed and continues to infringe the claimed ornamental design of
the `033 patent by importing, providing, selling, offering to sell, distributing without authority

Gerson’s SKU # 2497460, 2497500, 2497650, 2520830, and 3499030 along with any and all

variations thereon and any other Gerson product exhibiting substantially identical designs, the
Accused Products.

68. Moreover, on information and belief, Gerson has induced, and is inducing the

infringement of the claimed design of the `033 patent. On information and belief, the direct
infringement induced by Gerson includes at least the unauthorized sales and offers for sale of the

Accused Products by Gerson’s retail level customers and websites, such as

www.batteryoperatedcandles.net, amazon.com and Kmart, where Gerson’s Accused Products are


sold and offered for sale.

69. Despite having been provided actual notice by RAZ on January 9, 2019 that it is

engaging in design patent infringement, Gerson persists and continues in its infringing activity.
Further, given, Gerson’s many broken representations to RAZ that products had not actually

shipped, that a redesigned product would be substituted for such orders and that images of

Accused Products would be removed from catalogs and websites, Gerson’s infringement of the
`463 Design Patent continues to this day and is willful.

70. As a result of Gerson’s infringement, Gerson has obtained direct and indirect

profits that it would not have realized but for its infringement. As such, RAZ is entitled to its
lost profits, disgorgement of Gerson’s profits that are directly and indirectly attributed to

Gerson’s acts of infringement and in no instance compensation less than a reasonable royalty.

COUNT FOUR

(Fraudulent Misrepresentation)

71. Plaintiff RAZ re-alleges all of the allegations contained in paragraphs 1 through
70, above, as though fully set forth herein.

72. RAZ provided Gerson with actual notice of infringement on January 9, 2019 by

letter. Exhibit D. In response, Gerson asserted while it believed (incorrectly) that the Accused

20
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 21 of 24

Products did not infringe RAZ’s Copyrights or then-pending design patent applications Gerson
made several representations to RAZ in order to avoid litigation with RAZ. Exhibit E.

73. Specifically, Gerson made three material representations: (1) “Gerson has

redesigned its lantern offerings for Christmas 2019 based on the artwork attached to the January
22, 2019 letter;” (2) No shipments have or will be made of the SKU # 2497460, 3499030,

2497350 and 2597500 lantern products…. Further, no lanterns having those overall appearances

will be sold or offered for sale by Gerson going forward;” and (3) “Only the redesigned lanterns
will be shipped (presumably under some separate SKU #).” Moreover, RAZ agreed that

Gerson’s proposed redesign was not infringing either the RAZ Copyrighted Design or the then-

pending design patent applications. RAZ accepted and relied upon these representations in a
letter dated January 24, 2019. Exhibit F. Gerson understood that RAZ believed these

representations to be material and understood that RAZ was relying on Gerson’s representations

as indicated by Gerson’s letter of January 30, 2019. Exhibit G.


74. Each of these three material representations by Gerson was false. The Accused

Products remain on sale at Gerson’s own website and through Gerson’s catalog and also through

the website of third party sellers such as www.batteryoperatedcandles.com and Amazon.com.


Rather than the redesign that RAZ agreed was non-infringing and Gerson agreed it would ship as

a replacement, Gerson continues to ship the Accused Products. RAZ purchased examples of

Accused Products through the www.batteryoperatedcandles.com website and received the


original Accused Products’ designs, rather than the redesigned products.

75. Gerson made additional material and false misrepresentations to dissuade RAZ

from pursuing litigation. On February 8, 2019, RAZ wrote to Gerson to alert Gerson to the fact
that the Accused Products were still being offered for sale on Gerson’s website, which

contradicted Gerson’s representation that the Accused Products would be taken off the market.

Exhibit H. Further, the Accused Products were listed by the online catalog as “Top Sellers,”
which contradicted Gerson’s representation that no product had actually shipped to customers.

Exhibit H. As noted above, Gerson’s Accused Products remain on sale and are currently being

shipped to customers.

21
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 22 of 24

76. Again, on August 14, 2019, RAZ was forced to write yet another letter to Gerson
demanding an explanation as to why the products Gerson agreed to remove from its website and

replace with the redesigned product were still being offered for sale. A copy of this letter is

attached hereto as Exhibit J. In Gerson’s response dated August 23, 2019 and attached hereto as
Exhibit K, asserted that it was all a mistake: “Unfortunately, these items were mistakenly

included in that catalog…. In order to avoid a pointless dispute, Gerson will ship no lanterns of

this style in response to orders of these products from the Spring 2020 catalog, but instead will
substitute the previously communicated style of lanterns used for all Christmas orders for these

depicted lanterns.” Gerson’s representation was again designed to encourage RAZ to forebear

from filing suit.


77. Importantly, Gerson knew that each of these several representations to be false

when they made or that they were made recklessly. Each instance that RAZ raised some

incongruity between Gerson’s representations and how Gerson was actually behaving, Gerson
offered excuses rather than implementing the promises it made to RAZ.

78. RAZ reasonably relied upon Gerson’s false representations. For example, RAZ

relied upon Gerson’s representation that it would cease selling and offering the Accused
Products for sale and that it would instead implement the redesigned product that Gerson. RAZ

further relied upon Gerson’s representations that it would only ship the redesigned product rather

than the Accused Product.


79. RAZ has been injured by Gerson’s false representations at least due to Gerson’s

additional eight months of infringing activity, the additional attorneys’ fees and costs associated

therewith and the loss of market share and sales.

JURY DEMAND

Plaintiff demands a trial by jury on all counts.


DESIGNATION OF PLACE OF TRIAL

Plaintiff designates Kansas City, Kansas as the place for trial in this matter.

22
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 23 of 24

PRAYER FOR RELIEF


WHEREFORE, Plaintiff RAZ Imports, Inc. prays for the following relief:

A. A judgement that Defendant Gerson has directly and indirectly (through

inducement) infringed claims of the `463 and `033 Design Patents pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 271
and 35 U.S.C. § 289.

B. An order and judgement permanently enjoining Defendant and its officers,

directors, agents, servants, employees, affiliates, attorneys and all other acting in privity or
concert with them, and their parents, subsidiaries, divisions, successors and assigns, from further

acts of infringement of the `463 and `033 Design Patents.

C. A judgement awarding Plaintiff RAZ all damages adequate to compensate for


Defendant Gerson’s infringement of the `463 and `033 Design Patents and particularly RAZ’s

lost profits pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 289, including pre-suit damages based on RAZ’s actual

notice to Defendant Gerson.


D. A finding that Gerson’s infringement of the `463 and `033 patent is willful and

accordingly award RAZ enhanced damages in accordance with 35 U.S.C. § 284.

E. Declare this case exceptional pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 285 and award to RAZ its
reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs in this action.

F. Declare the Defendant Gerson has committed copyright infringement pursuant to

17 U.S.C. § 501.
G. Declare that the Defendant Gerson has willfully infringed RAZ’s copyright under

17 U.S.C. § 504(c)(2).

H. Enter an injunction against Defendant Gerson prohibiting Defendant from any


further importation, advertisement, sale, display or distribution of the RAZ Copyrighted Design

under 17 U.S.C. § 502.

I. Enter an order to impound and destroy all copies of Defendant’s infringing design
under 17 U.S.C. § 503.

J. Award Plaintiff actual damages and any additional profits of Defendant under 17

U.S.C. § 504(a)(1) and (b).

23
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 24 of 24

K. Alternatively, Plaintiff seeks statutory damages of such amount as shall be


appropriate, under 17 U.S.C. § 504(a)(2) and (c)(1) and (2).

L. Award Plaintiff its full costs and a reasonable attorneys’ fee under 17 U.S.C. §

505.
M. Award Plaintiff both pre- and post-judgment interest.

N. Award Plaintiff any and all other such relief as the Court deems appropriate.

Respectfully submitted,

POLSINELLI PC

yBy:__s/ Jay E. Heidrick_ ___________________


Jay E. Heidrick KS #20770
900 W. 48th Place, Suite 900
Kansas City, MO 64112
(816) 753-1000
(816-753-1536 fax
jheidrick@polsinelli.com

ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF RAZ


IMPORTS, INC.

24
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 3

EXHIBIT A
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 19

EXHIBIT B
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 19

USOOD839463S

(12 ) FuUnited States Design Patent (10) Patent No.: US D839,463 S


(45) Date of Patent: * * Jan . 29, 2019
(54 ) SNOW GLOBE LANTERN (57 ) CLAIM
I claim the ornamental design for a snow globe lantern , as
(71) Applicant: RAZ Imports , Inc., Arlington , TX shown and described .
(US ) DESCRIPTION
(72 ) Inventor: Chen Kong Fu , Guangdong (CN ) FIG . 1 is a perspective view of a first embodimentof a snow
globe lantern , showing my/our new design ;
(73 ) Assignee: RAZ IMPORTS , INC ., Arlington , TX FIG . 2 is a front elevational view of the first embodiment;
FIG . 3 is a rear devotional view of the first embodiment;
(US ) FIG . 4 is a left side elevational view of the first embodiment;
FIG . 5 is a right side elevational view of the first embodi
(* * ) Term : 15 Years ment;
FIG . 6 is a top plan view of the first embodiment ;
(21) Appl. No.: 29/617,039 FIG . 7 is a bottom plan view of the first embodiment ; and
FIG . 8 is a perspective, environmental view of the first
embodiment illustrating an example where a scene is shown
(22 ) Filed : Sep . 11, 2017 inside the lantern but disclaimed ;
(51) LOC (11) CI. .... .... .. 26 -05 FIG . 9 is a perspective view of a second embodiment of the
snow globe lantern ;
(52 ) U .S . CI. FIG . 10 is a front elevational view of the second embodi
USPC ........ .... .............. D26 /51 ; D26 /94 ment;
(58 ) Field of Classification Search FIG . 11 is a rear elevational view of the second embodiment;
USPC ............... D26 /24 , 40 , 41 , 93, 94 , 103 – 107 , FIG . 12 is a left side elevational view of the second
embodiment;
D26 / 110 - 112 , 85, 87 FIG . 13 is a right side elevational view of the second
(Continued ) embodiment;
FIG . 14 is a top plan view of the second embodiment;
(56 ) References Cited FIG . 15 is a bottom plan view of the second embodiment;
and ,
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS FIG . 16 is a perspective , environmental view of the second
embodiment illustrating an example where a scene is shown
D281,592 S * 12 / 1985 Grun D11/ 131 inside the lantern but disclaimed .
D309,796 S 8 / 1990 Koziol Dashed broken lines are for illustrating unclaimed portions
(Continued ) of the snow globe lantern and /or for illustrating an environ
ment related to the claimed design ; the broken lines form no
FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS part of the claimed design . Dashed -dot broken lines are for
illustrating an unclaimed area of the snow globe lantern ; the
CN 302652731 11 / 2013 dashed - dot line forms no part of the claimed design .
DE 40700511 5 /2007 In FIG . 8 and 16 , the interior of the snow globe lantern is
Primary Examiner — Lakiya G Rogers illustrated for environmental purposes and forms no part of
the claimed design .
Assistant Examiner — Carissa C Fitts
(74 ) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Polsinelli PC 1 Claim , 16 Drawing Sheets

NA

43
-

me . ??????????????
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 19

US D839 ,463 S
Page 2

(58 ) Field of Classification Search 6 ,675 ,513 B2 1/ 2004 Liao


CPC ... F21S 6 / 00 ; F21S 6 / 002; F21V 1 /00 ; F21V D495,084 S * 8 / 2004 Hon .. D26 /67
1 /02 ; F217 21/02 ; F21V 1/ 12 ; F21V D534,676 S 1/ 2007 Chen
1/22; F21V 1 / 18 ; F21W 2131/30 D563,016 S 2/ 2008 Ho et al.
See application file for complete search history . D563,585 S 3/ 2008 Lee et al.
D578 ,239 S * 10 /2008 Milicia D26 /68
7, 430 , 823 B1 * 10/ 2008 Chung .. .. . .. . . . . . .. .... GO9F 19 /02
(56 ) References Cited
D634, 242 S 3 /2011 Sicurelli
40 /409
U . S . PATENT DOCUMENTS D646 ,833 S 10 / 2011 Chen
D653, 379 S 1 /2012 Chen
5 ,131, 175 A * 7 / 1992 Liu ........................ GO9F 19 /12 D653 ,380 S 1 / 2012 Chen
40 /406 D663, 063 S * 7/ 2012 Yang D26 /67
5 ,442, 869 A * 8 / 1995 McDarren ............... GO9F 13/24 D684 ,293 S * 6 /2013 Lastimosa D26 /85
40 /406 D693,955 S * 11/2013 Yang D26 /67
5 ,711,099 A 1/ 1998 Nesbit et al. D694, 940 S * 12 / 2013 Dolan ............. D26 /87
D429 ,359 S 8 / 2000 Chen D695 ,444 S * 12 / 2013 D26 / 104
D439 , 361 S 3 / 2001 Berry D713 ,587 S * 9 / 2014 Clark D26 / 85
6 ,203 ,394 B1 * 3/ 2001 Lee GO9F 19/ 02 D756 ,545 S * 5 / 2016 Goodsell ............. D26 / 9
40 / 406 D766 ,489 S * 9 /2016 Moon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....... D26 / 87
6 , 269,566 B1 * 8 /2001 Lo . G09F 19 /08 D766 ,490 S * 9 / 2016 Moon ... . .. D26 /87
40 / 406 D815 ,334 S 4 /2018 Hu
D451,620 S 12 /2001 Chen 2003/0196357 A1 * 10 /2003 Knapp GO9F 19 / 02
6 , 345,457 B1 * 2 /2002 Bradley GO9F 19 /02 40 /410
40 /410 2010 /0149094 A1* 6 /2010 Barnes ........... GO1W 1/02
345 / 156
D466 ,243 S 11/2002 Chen
D470 ,968 S 2 /2003 Kuelbs et al.
D482,479 S 11/2003 Kuelbs et al. * cited by examiner
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 1 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

Y
X

XXA

Sito

ition 14

HM um
-

A
"

P
T

NA
NO
nec s
L

FIG . 1
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 2 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

???
??
???

???????????
??? ? ?? ???

?????????
???
??
???? ? ? ?
??????????????

?????

?? ? ? ?? ? ?? ???
3
T
,?

????

???????????

?? ??
???
?
???????????????????? ??

??????????? ??

?? ?
? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

FIG . 2
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 19

atent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 3 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

ya

??

YYY
I

? ?

FIG . 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 4 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

??

? ????????????

???
| | | 1

- . ?
=-
=
=
?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

?
-

? ??? ???????? S
8
??
????
????
|

?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????? ???????????????????????????????????? ????????????


??
???

??
? ? ??????? ?

FIG . 4
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 5 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

IL
+

?? ???

VRTK

FIG . 5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 19

Sin' fu?ed ues‘ 67‘ 6107 T??4S 9 JO 91 SN 6880‘ €9t S

** * N N ULULAULUNA * *** * * * * * * ** ***


Kiwi
* * * * * * * * *

w w
TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

- -
! - ! - ! - ! -1 -1 - 1 -1 -1 -1 -1 - - - - -

1999

0O
.

MARIN

913 9 w
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 7 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

- - = = - - - -

ooo
oooo

---
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -seemeeuwice
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
S ewe

FIG . 7
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 8 of 16 US D839 ,463 S


w

LE

- +

- -

AN
- -

- .
-

*
- .
-

-
* -
- .
-

- - .
-

:
=
- - -

- -

- - + -

* - + -

- + -

+
-

- +
-

V +
-

- -
-

- -

-
-

:-

WAN
-

w.
-

13
An

t
hu
b
TIP aletw ----

TI ! ??

TE

FIG . 8
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 9 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

1
$

-
Decrto

*** *

VIVA
.

Hr .

.
-

.
+

www.

Aw
.

. !

?
AP
.
U

JAS
.

PS29
FIG . 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 10 of 16 US D839,463 S

.
*
*

D
?

???????
?? ?

?
-

-
|

|
|

| |||

??????????????????????????????????????????????????????
?
???????????????????????????????????????????????????????

FA?

FIG .10
*
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 19

atent Jan .29, 2019 Sheet 11 of 16 SN 6880‘ €9t S

reversity , first their this is their iiiiiiiiiiii


THANNAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHmmwwmwwmwwmwwmwww woutubHubbbbbbbbbbb Aboutubtitutubunturber
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
ht

____ ___ ___ ___ __


FFFFF| |

11- FFFFFFFFFFFFF # + + +++ +++ +++ +W

?
4444444444444444444

-iFsrmt
Er
int

,????????????????????????????????????????????
1 .1ith?L1

? % F

FIG . 11
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 12 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

LS
--

-
-

OM
WA R IW

15

FIG . 12
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 13 of 16 US D839,463 S


?

?
?
????
?

?
?

?
???
???

??
?? ?4? ? ?

?
?

' --------------- --- ---

??? 1
11

FIG . 13
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 19

atent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 14 of 16 S3 9f6280? S

?
??
?????

?
?

??????????????

??
?

?? - -- -

? ???

?
| ?

?? ?? 1

??????????????
-- -

????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
- = = = = = = = = = = = =
: : ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": " : ": ": ": ": ": ": ": ": " : " : " : " : ": ": ": ":

?? ?

??????????????????????????????????????????????????? ??? ??. ???????????????


?? ?
FIG . 14
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 19

U . S . Patent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 15 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

-- - - - = = = - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

cocos e T

Coco *
E

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

FIG . 15
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-2 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 19

atent Jan . 29, 2019 Sheet 16 of 16 US D839 ,463 S

**

-- - Y

XU
OLT
*

ROS ED

- -

- -

- -

- -

.
-

.
=
-

242

SI
.
.

9
*

i
-

.
*

. -

m
.

USA -

-
ulti de !

111 111
.
127

IN =

>

FIG . 16
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 9

EXHIBIT C
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-3 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 9

EXHIBIT D
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-4 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 9
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-5 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 5

EXHIBIT E
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-5 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-5 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-5 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-5 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-6 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 3

EXHIBIT F
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-6 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-6 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-7 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 3

EXHIBIT G
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-7 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-7 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 3
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 33

EXHIBIT H
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 20 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 21 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 22 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 23 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 24 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 25 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 26 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 27 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 28 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 29 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 30 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 31 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 32 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-8 Filed 11/12/19 Page 33 of 33
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-9 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT I
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-9 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 2
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-10 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 4

EXHIBIT J
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-10 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 4
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-10 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 4
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-10 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 4
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-11 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT K
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-11 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 2
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 13

EXHIBIT L
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 13

678897

Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 13

345674897:
;<=;>?@?>ABCDEFG>CHIJKLKMN4OPQ74JR
S>SS>?T<=UCU?>>CHIKKVWIK4OPQ74JR
345P74X4835735
@>??YCGS?AYCHXIJNVLWJ4OPQ74KIR
TA?GDTAZZE[C;A?ZA=BHQIJKVKML4OPQ74KJR
Z<;DU>BCGA=UACA=BC=FU\?A\]>?C[AU>?CZA=U>?=CHIJNNJJJ4OPQ74WVR
\FSCE?=AT>=UCHIJNJNWJ4OPQ74K^R


 +(,!"#"$%&'(! )"'*
-"./0*,1(2,&

01 2223456789
4 3
833
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 13

!"
#$%%&'&()*+,-&./01
2345678569:8;854<

W =>==>?@ABC9DACEF>B
X. GHBCH9GI==JK9EL@=HBK
YZ EF?AGC@HG9C?>>9L?EFH?M
[. NABC>?9OL?>GC
\W NFA@GAEHJ9NLLMJHBMG
00Z FLJAMHK9M?>H@G
0X[ M>ED9CF>9GFL?>
0Y/ OA?GC9GBLN
0ZZ PLJM>B9QLCHBAEHJ
0\/ EL==>?9@LIBCHAB
.0. =L@>P?HBHC>9R9=AB>
..Z C?A@@>M9NACF9C?HMACALB
.YW PJHM9CAMABPG
.ZW FL@>G=IB99FLJAMHK
.1Z >S>?KCFABP9@>??K
.\Z ?HT9>U=?>GG
X0Z GDA9=HC?LJ
XX/ PH?M>B9FH?S>GC
XWZ EH@=9FH?S>GC
XY[ FHJJLN>>B
X[/ NHC>?9JHBC>?BG
X[W JAPFCG
X\/ @HPAE9=LN>?
X\. N?>HCFGV9PH?JHBMG9HBM9C?>>G
W/W EF?AGC@HG9C?>>9?>E>A=>G
W0. >H?JK9QIKV9MHCABPV9O?>APFC9=?LP?H@G
W0X L?M>?9OL?@
W0Y C>?@G
W0Z GFLN?LL@G9HBM9GFLNMHC>G
W01 ABM>U
CL9G>>9LI?9>BCA?>9JAB>9LO9
OHJJ9HBM9NABC>?9]^_`9ELJJ>ECALBG9
SAGAC9LI?9N>QGAC>9HC9?HTA@=L?CGaEL@9
J>CG9P>C9GLEAHJb

233455646753898

4  4 01
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 13
H 12342573518
789567894
5 D 67894
5123425
24
56234
3 E
2F 247385G

, -,

NOPQORNSTTUVRWXYTOPV
 <!B
., -.,+
!" #$%%&'( 9%:;!%<<<=%!%
)%%*%+ B?;$%"C!#)'*
9<IJ;K% ,.%/-%0
-+.,%/%0 ,+.%/%0
-,.%/+%0

1 12342512
3
5337424
55677228 0 12342567894
5
, 24
56234
3
9%' 
+ 
9%:;!%<<<=%!% 
&';>%?*'%)@%! !" #$%%&'(
A ;#%" '! )%%*%+,
B?;$%"C!#)'* -.%/%0
.%/-%0 +.,%/+%0
.%/%0

LMM
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 13

0123456774849

 45

!"#$%&'$" 42
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 13

0123456774849

 45

42 !"##$$%%&$#
E74F82^2GSX'5H5SX8
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 13

012345678
9
9
9 9 99  
9  9
9 99999
9  9
9  99 9 9!9"9# 9 $%
0012&4'748
9
9(9)9 9* +,, --. ./-,990199* +*2 .2/ 34,+ 95999+6.,9 99/6,,9 9 979( )9
8999:9 9
9  95 999;/,,9  9<=99;4/,9  9599;4/,9 999 
9  9>0999?990 990)9 9999 9 91 999
9 @ 97 099A9 999 9
9 B 9(9999 99=  )9 99C9 )9 99 )9 99 9)9  9 )9
9=  9 9>0999 9999909 D)99 9 9999
00012E74F8
9
9G47'5H2GI4'9=99 98
7(B<
<@)9J>7
)9
8B<>
K9BLM<B7799@>75JB<
9  9N7H2OP9=99 ?9
9  9N7Q2GR8HSF749=9M 909D?9#/%9099 99999  99$999$9
99#.,%99)999999 0999D9999999  999$
0T12UV5WW5XY

999 9: 5  9
 )9(L 9<
Z9 9 9999?9 99999 959
99"999999 ?9?9 9 97 999 9?"9 )999 9
9 9?9 999 999 9 999 9 9? 919;/,,999 9
"9 
(9  991999 9099099 
T12UVS4HIY782IX'2[IFIY78

9  909 9!9 999 999#*,%99909 909 999 9
7?9@  
T012\7HR4X8

9990 9 99999/]9$909909 9K99 99 99 9
" 9
999999 99999 = 
U_F`Sa8b
9c9>D9 9999 d9
9c9>D9 99 9 99909  99M 9 99$90999?999  9A 9# 09)99 ?9)9 %

9 9909?99 99 99 9M99 999 90 9?9 97 9
 9 9999909?9  )999999  959 9999 999
)90)99 99 9?99 )9 99" 9
(9  9 99 9 999 9999<
Z9> 9>)99 9990 9K9 9999
 99990 991 99  90 9<
Z9> 9>

ijjkllmkmnljopoqqqkrstuvwxryzk{xv efgh
0123422567801239
68 8 4 6 
 6
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 13


2424
8
!"#$%&'(
8 )9:)69;779;6+<#$
)9:**9;;=9=>;*
4 9 8 
4 5 
8 )9:**9;;=9=>;*
)*+*,-.'#/- ?)9:)69=6>97+*: ?)9:)69=6>97+*)
$01'2%#'34567**) @AAA9$/B1!"#$%&9(#!
C $/BD$/B1!"#$%&9(#!

801238
6
bZ\bQZb ~b\\b] \b]T[Rzb]
!.$1(/&i/$%3jI10-1'2) e/00/&i/$M.%l.'%.$ E#$0-i/$M.%l.'%.$€/&f.2/&
+;*P./(F%$..K%$..%gE3KI1%.):klk)> +*>*gK%.!!#'&$..A/H3KI1%.=;* ;>>K9m$/'-l.'%$/0P/$MA/H
%0/'%/3m=*=*= e/00/&3456>+*6 KI1%.lk*7)+
8 )9;*;9>+)9<=>> 8 )9+);96;>9)77) €/&f.2/&3gf:<)*7
?)9;*;9>+)9<=>6 ?)9+);96;69)7)* 8 )96*+9<*+9;+<;
C KF#A$##!D$/B1!"#$%&9(#! C eKF#A$##!D$/B1!"#$%&9(#! ?)96+>9+**9=:=)
C fKF#A$##!D$/B1!"#$%&9(#!
d".'i#'-/Hk4FI$&-/H3KF#A%1!.&/'- d".'i#'-/HkE.-'.&-/H)*/!k;"!3
NH/""#1'%!.'%9 KF#A%1!.&/'-NH/""#1'%!.'%9 d".'KF#A%1!.&d'0H  
n
418888 o8p8 n
418888 8p8v 00d%F.$e/H&l/00)9:**9;;=9=>;*
qrst8 8 8p8o qr 8 8 8p8 qrst8 8 8p8‚rƒ8
0  5u 48 v8p8w 0  5u 48 8p8w q
r
4t8„o…8o8p8† u8

cV\xyax]TYTbacTz`{ZT]VxWcR] yQ̀QRb‡V\`]TYT~VxzTZ_VW]VQT]b\R]
l#0I!NI&i/$M.%P0/(. i1''./"#01&i/$%
6**)e1&(#G.$Hj#I0.G/$-3KI1%.)*+ i/$(F)6k+) )*=*)j$.'#/-E3##!dk=>>  i/$(F)*k);
eIN01'3d|;=*)6   }I'. +>k+6 i1''.%#'M/3ig>>=;=   }I'. +>k+6
8 )9:**9=>)9):*+#$)9:><9+==9):*+ 8 )9:**96+79:<6<  
?)9:><9+==9):*+ ?)9:669=::9>:)>
C 21L%&#I$(.&D/#09(#! @AAA9-#I2%F#$&#'&/0.&9(#!
C gN$I'#6+)D/#09(#! C -%&D-#I2%F#$&#'&/0.&9(#!
d".'KF#A%1!.&/'-NH/""#1'%!.'%9 d".'i#'-/H&3KF#A%1!.&/'-NH/""#1'%!.'%9
QRSTRQz\bQ~TYTQV[bT]b\R]Tb]]Vcb̀ZR] QRSTUVWXTYTZR[R\]^_RàTb]]Vcb̀ZR]
g#$%F./&%i/$M.%l.'%.$ )*<:d/MA##-e$1G.
+l/N#%-3KI1%.))* f1(%#$3gh);>7;
|I-&#'3i*)6;<   "$10 +k; 8 )9>:>9<+;96+)=
8 )9:::9<)>9<)<)   }I0H +=k+7 ?)9>:>96;+9)=;)
?)9:7*9+=79;6=>   C -F.1ND$#(F.&%.$9$$9(#!#$OF.1ND$#(F.&%.$9$$9(#!
@AAA9'&/21L%&9(#! KF#A$##!#".'NH/""#1'%!.'%/'-#'&(F.-I0.-#".'
C &/0.&DgK21L%&9(#! F#I&.&9

E./0&#F/G.4.$$1%#$H."$.&.'%/%1G.&%F$#I2F#I%%F.J'1%.-K%/%.&9
LH#IA#I0-01M./."$.&.'%/%1G.%#(/00#'H#I$(#!"/'H"0./&.(#'%/(%I&/%)9:**9;;=9=>;*%#&(F.-I0./'/""#1'%!.'%9
KF#A-/%.&/$.&INO.(%%#(F/'2.9P0./&.(#'%/(%1'-1G1-I/0&F#A$##!&%#G.$1LH&F#A%1!.&9
ˆ‰Š‹ ŒŒŒŽ‘’“”Ž•–—”’˜™˜š››œœžœ›
01234
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 13

5 7999999  5 6999999 756999999



  7 56999999 6576999999

585999999 
5 999999
75999999
 7 78999999
 6575999999 
588999999 5 999999
7587999999
 7 65999999  6578999999 
588999999 5 999999  7586999999
 7 6999999
 657 999999 
57 999999
 5 8999999
75 8999999 
7 6999999
 656999999

577999999
 588999999
 756999999

 7 6 999999  675999999

5567678999999
75999999  5856999999  756 999999
7 56999999  67999999

556767 999999
999999 585 999999  757999999 7 5999999
 67999999

5567667999999
999999 58587999999  756999999 7 58999999  67 999999 
57 77999999
 77999999  585 999999  75999999 7 999999
 66999999

57 6999999
 77999999
 58 77999999  756999999 7 8999999 66999999

57588999999
 7677999999  58 76999999  75999999    7 8999999 668999999 
57866999999
 7666999999
55999999  75 999999 
7 8999999
 66 999999

58667999999  7665999999
55999999
 7587999999  7 8999999
 657999999

5857999999
 766999999
 55999999  7588999999  7 87999999 656999999 
5 666999999
 766999999
 557999999  75 6999999 7 86999999
655999999

77 999999
 766999999
 55999999

 75 5999999 6767999999
 65999999

768999999
 7656999999
 55 999999
 75 999999  67678999999
 667999999


6766999999
 76999999
  75999999
 75 999999
 6767 999999
 667999999


675 999999 76999999
  66999999 75 999999
 67667999999  6667999999

6666 999999
7555999999
 75999999  75 8999999
 67666999999  6666999999

6665999999 7555999999
 765999999

75 999999
 67665999999  6655999999

6656999999 755999999 76999999
 757999999
 6766999999  6658999999 
6658999999

7558999999 775999999  757999999


 6766999999  666999999

66 77999999  755 999999
67999999
 756999999
6766999999  66999999 
66 76999999  7557999999
67999999  7568999999
6766999999
 66999999

66 75999999  75999999


  999999
 755999999

 6766999999
 66999999 
65 999999
 755999999 66999999
 75 999999 67668999999

  66 999999 
6757999999  75999999 777999999
 75999999
 67999999 667999999 
6756999999  756999999  777999999
 75999999
  66 999999

57586999999  75 999999
 777999999
 7999999 67999999   666999999

57585999999  757999999
775999999 7999999 67999999   66999999

5667999999  7999999  77 999999
 7999999   67999999   66 5999999

567 999999
 7999999  77999999
 7999999   676999999 
 677999999

566 999999
 7999999  77999999  78999999  
 675999999
767999999 
78999999 77999999
 7999999  67999999
 67999999
76 6999999  7999999
77999999 7999999  667 5999999 67999999
7 8999999 
7999999
77999999

7999999 6667999999  67999999
666999999
777999999
778999999
 7677999999  66668999999  67 999999

5 68999999 777 999999

77 999999
7 6 999999 66655999999 667999999 
8676999999  7866 999999  7787999999
76 999999  6665999999 666999999

867999999  7 5 999999
 7786999999  767999999  6667999999 66999999
 999999  7 7999999 778999999

765999999  6666999999 657999999

767999999
 7 6999999 77 999999  76999999  6665999999 
65999999
7678999999 67667999999  77 999999  76999999  666999999

 65999999
75999999
6756999999
 767999999 76999999  666999999  658999999
75 999999 67999999 767 999999 76999999
 
 666 999999 6999999

76999999 
67999999
 7665999999
768999999

 6665999999  68999999

76999999 67 999999 766999999 7656999999 666999999  66999999
768999999 
 667 999999 766 999999
 75999999 666999999  6999999 
7 58999999 
66677999999
 765999999
 75999999 666999999 
68999999

665999999 
666999999
 76999999 7 5999999   666999999 65999999

668999999
 667999999 76999999 787999999
 666999999 6999999

67999999  667 999999 768999999 787 999999
 6666999999  68999999 
66999999  6666999999 76 999999 7865999999
 666999999  67999999

66999999  6657999999 766999999 786999999
 6668999999

 6876999999



66999999  656999999
 76999999  7858999999 666999999  6875999999

66999999  667999999


 76999999     666999999 
6 999999
668999999  67999999  76999999  78 999999
 666 999999 
6 999999
66 999999  657999999 766999999  78999999
 6667999999 
666999999 
668999999  67 999999
 765999999  788999999  6666999999  666 999999 
668999999 65999999 76999999  78 999999
 6665999999 
6657999999 
6 77999999  678999999 76876999999 78 999999
 666999999  6656999999
6 77999999
 667999999 7687999999 7 78999999
 
 666999999 
667999999 
558999999  658999999
 7687999999 7 68999999

 666999999 665999999

67 999999  67 999999  7687999999 7 6 999999
 
 6668999999 66999999

7766999999 667999999 76865999999  7 999999 666 999999 66999999
77999999
65999999
 7686999999 776999999  66687999999
 66999999
  
778999999

65999999
 7685999999  776 999999  66686999999
 66999999
767999999  67999999 768999999 7756999999
 66685999999
 66999999
767999999  66999999
 768999999 775999999 6667999999 66999999
7999999
 65999999
 7688999999 775999999
 666999999  66 999999

7 5999999
 67999999  768 999999 775999999

666999999
 66999999
7 58999999
 67 999999  7686999999   775999999 6668999999 666999999


76999999 667999999 7576999999 775999999   666 999999  668999999

767999999 6668999999 7555999999 775 999999 6657999999
 655999999


777999999
 6657999999
 755 999999  777999999 665999999
 65999999
78786999999

 6656999999
 75999999 776999999
667999999 657999999

78785999999

 6 768999999
 757999999 775999999
665999999 65999999
6665 999999  6 755999999

75999999  77999999
 
 66999999

 655999999
6666999999 6 758999999 756999999
 77999999

 66 999999
 65 999999
665999999 6 77999999 755999999
 77999999
666999999

656999999

66999999 6 7 999999


 758999999
778999999

66999999
 65999999
66999999 6 785999999

75 999999
 777999999 66999999
 658999999

66999999 6 78999999
7587999999
 787999999 6575999999  65 999999

66999999  57766999999
7586999999
 787999999 657999999  67999999

6 999999 577999999 758999999  7875999999  657999999 666999999

6999999  55887999999  758 999999     787 7999999 6557999999  66999999

6999999 57 8999999  7555999999 787 6999999 655999999
66999999

65999999  55999999  755999999 787 999999 65999999 65999999 
6 65999999
 55999999

7558999999 787 999999  65999999  658999999




6 6999999
 556999999 755 999999 7866999999
655999999
 66999999

6 6999999
56999999
 757999999 7866999999
65999999
 65999999

6 686999999

56999999  756999999

78655999999 65999999
 687999999
56 999999  56999999  755999999

7865999999 658999999 686999999
56 7999999  568999999  75999999
 
 7 7 999999
65 999999
6 5999999

557999999
 5 5 999999  75999999

  7 67999999 65 999999
6 999999

5 7999999  5 7999999 758999999
 7 57999999 65 999999 6 999999

3456789:6;<=7:>4?@=7A=?4B6CD6;6E;=?=75FG;BD6=B69=<>G?4B6A9
3456789:6;<=75;667=7A=?4B6CD6;6BD6=B69=<4><G<DGC79 !!"##$"$%#!&'&(((")*+,-./)01"2/- 
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 13

0123045666666789 0124236666669 01 14666666


 0132266666677 0101566666698 9
88 01 226666667

012304366666678
0124236666667
01 266666677 013666666

010116666668
9 01 24666666

0123041666666789 01242356666667
01 3666666

0136666669 
 

01532666666
012304 666666789 78
01242336666667 01 426666667 013026666667
0101466666679 01530666666
012304466666678
01242 6666667 01 4666666

01306666667 010 06666667 01526666669


0123266666678
010666666
01 4 66666679 0130566666677 010 6666667 01536666669
012366666678
013666666
014066666677 013 26666669 010 366666688 015306666669
0123066666678
0120666666
9 01436666667 013 6666667 010 16666668 01536666669
012356666667
 0121666666 014226666667 013 5666666 010 46666669 01531666666
0123206666669 0124666666 01426666669 013 666666
9 99 010426666668
015 526666667

012326666667
79  01666666 014216666667 8 8

7 01046666668
015 56666669
0123246666669 0101666666
9 0142 6666667 0134666666

0104066666698 015 56666667

012366666689 0104666666
9 0144666666777 013426666669 01046666669 015 36666667

0123266666699 0152666666 01404666666

013466666689 010456666669
89 015 326666669
012306666669 015666666 014666666
9 98 0116666668 010436666669
015 3666666
0123666666
0155666666 9 8 01116666668 0104 6666668 015 3366666678
0123566666699 0151666666  0143566666677 011206666667 0100266666698 015 3 6666667
0123 666666 0135666666
01416666669 0112366666679 010066666698 015 16666668
01230666666 01166666679 014166666677 7 01124666666 01006666667 015 1666666
012300666666  01166666679
0141566666677 0112666666
 0103000666666 015 13666666799
012304666666 01166666679 014146666668 01106666668 0103006666669 015 1 6666667
9 7
01235666666
0126666667 014 2666666 011666666
 010300166666699 015 146666667

012353666666
 01206666669 014 0666666
0113666666799 01030666666
015 26666667
9
01231 666666
012666666 014 666666
011166666677 01030666666
015 6666667
9 7
012314666666 012256666667
 7 014 166666677 011 666666 01030 6666668 015 66666677
0123 666666 012666666797 01440666666777 01106666667 7 010303666666
015 466666677
0123 26666667
0121666666 0144166666679 01100666666 0103526666667 015 4266666677
0123 666666 01205666666 0144 666666 01105666666
 0103506666667 015 46666667
0123 666666 01204666666 0144466666679 01542066666677 01035566666679 015 446666667
01234666666 0120666666 01026666668 015425666666 010352666666 01545666666
0121 666666 01236666667 0106666669 01542 666666 010352666666787 01543666666
01213666666 01216666669 01056666668 015424666666 010352 666666798 015416666667
01213666666 012526666669 01036666669 015456666668 010150666666
8 0154 666666
012130666666 0125666666 01016666668 01543666666 01015666666
8 015446666667
01213666666 012506666667
 010 6666668 015406666669
01015666666

015420666666
01213366666679 01256666667 010226666667 7 0154026666669
010 366666679 01546666667 79
01213 66666679 0125566666689 01026666667 015406666669
010 466666679 015456666669
01213466666679 0125 6666668 010666666
 0154006666669
010 266666679 0154026666667
0121166666679 0123666666 0103666666

01540666666 010 25666666 01540666666


012116666669 012326666667 010166666679 015403666666 010 23666666 015400666666
01215 666666 01236666667 01046666667 01540 666666 010 2466666678 01540666666
01215 1666666
 012356666669 0100666666 0154046666668 010 666666 015401666666

01215 666666
 01233666666 01001666666
01546666668 010 2666666 015404666666
9
01215 46666668 01231666666
01004666666
9 0135 6666668
010 666666 01546666667

0121546666668 0123 666666
0100666666
 99 8 013326666667 77 010 66666678 015406666667

01215426666668 01234666666
0105666666
 8
0134666666 010 02666666 015452666666
0121546666669  012106666667 0103666666

01312 66666677 010 1 6666667 0154556666669


01215406666669  0121 666666 010 666666
 01316666668
01043666666 01545466666677
0121546666669 0121466666679
0104666666
8 01315666666
0104166666689 015436666667
0121545666666 012066666679
010526666667 011 4666666 0104 6666667 0154306666668
0121543666666 0120566666677 0105566666677 01 06666667 010446666667 01543566666689
0121541666666 012026666668 0105366666677 01 6666667 010422666666 015416666668

01213166666697 0120166666699 010516666667 01 166666677 77 01042666666 0154106666668


01213 66666697 0120 6666669 7 010326666669 01  66666677 0104206666667 0154116666667
01213466666697 012046666667 01036666668 01 466666677 0104666666 01541 6666667
0124666666 012002666666 010306666669 01 56666667 01042666666 0154 26666667
01243666666787 01200666666
01036666669 01 506666667 01046666667 0154 6666667
0124266666679 0120006666668 010356666669 01 53666666
01045666666

0154426666669
012466666679 012006666668 0101066666679 01 566666689 01043666666 015002666666
0124 6666667
 7 0120666666 9 01011666666797 01 36666669 97 88 01041666666 0150023666666

012446666667
 01202666666 0101466666679 01 4466666687 0104 666666

0150021666666

01245666666797 01201666666
 010 566666678 01 46666668 010446666669 015002 666666

012432666666 01204666666
 010 16666667 01 456666668 01040266666677 0150046666667
0124316666667 012056666667
0104666666 01 416666668  010400666666 0150006666667
01243 6666667 0120516666667 01042666666 01 4226666668 01040666666 015000 6666669
01241266666679 01205466666677 01046666667 01 4266666689 010405666666 01500526666668
0124 6666669 012035666666798 010406666667 01 4256666669 01040366666677 01500566666677
0124 56666667 0120116666668 010416666669 01 4666666

 0156666668 015005066666677
0124 36666667 01201 6666669 010446666669 01 4366666679 0116666668 0155106666669
012446666667 0120 5666666
 015666666 01 41666666 01 6666668 01551666666
012446666667 0120 36666668 0150666666 01 4 666666 01066666677 01551466666677
0124456666667 0120 46666667
0155666666

01 44666666 010266666677 0155 66666677


0124436666667 0120426666668 0151666666
 01 406666668 010066666679 0155 06666667 

01244 6666667 01204666666 015226666667 01 4026666668 016666668 0155 16666667

0124446666667 0120416666667 01526666667 9 7 01 406666668 016666668 0155 46666667

01242 6666667
 7 01204 6666667 0152566666677 7 01 400666666
7 01066666688 0155566666679
0124226666669 0123666666 0152366666677 01 40666666 0156666667 01510466666679
0124225666666 012356666667 0152 6666667 01 405666666798 0152666666
0151006666667
01242236666667 0123366666677 0156666667 01 40 6666668 015666666 
 0151 566666699
01242216666667 012316666667 0150666666
9 01 46666668 0150666666

 0151 5266666699
0124224666666 7 012326666668 01536666669 01 45666666 015666666 
 0151 566666699
01242666666787 01232666666 01516666667 014536666667
 01556666667 
7 0151 5066666699
012426666668 01232566666687 01501666666
9 0141666666 0153666666 
 0151 556666667
012426666667 01232166666687 0150666666
0141266666699 015 6666667 
 0151 15666666
0124246666667 01232 66666687 01556666669 0141466666689 01526666667 
 0151 13666666
012420666666 012324666666 015536666668 014 666666 01522666666 
7 0151 666666
0124200666666 01232666666787 015516666669 014 0666666 015266666677 
 0151 1666666
01242056666667 012366666687 015546666667 01442666666 01520666666 
 0151 6666667
01242036666668 0123566666687 0153666666
 98 0144666666
01225666666797 79 7
0151 46666667
012422666666 01 066666677 0151066666679 01440666666
01223666666797 79 0151 46666667
012426666669 01 566666677 01515666666 0105466666689 01201666666 7 0151 42666666
0124236666668 01 5166666677 0151 666666 010366666688 012666666 0151 41666666
0124216666668 01 36666667 01514666666 0103066666688 01206666667  0151 44666666
0124246666668
01 3266666677 015 6666669 01031666666 012666666 
015146666667
0124256666668 01 36666667 015 1666666799 79 0103 666666 013236666667 015145666666
01242526666668 01 16666667 0154666666

01034666666 
0132 666666
 015141666666
0124256666667 7 01 10666666

98 8 01545666666799 79 010126666667 01 204666666 015144666666

01242366666697 01 1566666679 013166666677 0101066666679 01 2666666 01514666666

 !"#$%&#!'(')**++,,-+*
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 13

0121340555555677 0140
555556  01
355555 01400 55558 01244455558 01 1
5555577
0121302555555689 01403 555556 6 9 01
330555559 6 014 35555 01244055558 01 115555577
012130
5555556  6 6668 01

555556 6 014 155556 0 14555558  01 15555577
01213035555556 7 0140345555566  01
3 55555 01421555598999 04 141555558  01 1 0555558 8
01213 555555989 01403555556 01 12135555586  9799 0 11555558 7 01 14 555558 7
01213 0555555676 014033555556 6 0144
255555999698  999 0 1555558 7 01 142555558
01213 55555568  6 7696 0144

0555559 0142 555586987 0 44 1 5555587 0124555558 


01213 3555555669 014 0555556 0144

55555687 0142 15555878 0



1
555558 6 01240555558 
012132555555  014 2555556 0144
15555596 0142 5555 9 7 0

1
0555558 6 0124 4555558
012132 555555987 014 35555566 0144
1555559 0142 15555 0

1
555558 6 0124 0555558
0121322555555987 014 555556 014
0 5555566 014
4555599 0
30 35555587 0124 555558
01213235555559879 014 5555568 014
 455555 014
0 5555 0
3045555587 0124 2555558
01213
05555558  014 455555 014
 55555989 014
455556 02 555579 4 4155558867
0121311555555987 014 4 55555 014
 35555599 014
555586 024555579 4 405555888
012135555556 014 025555599 014
2 555556 01
0555566897 020555579  6769
01213 55555569 014
55555997 014
245555599 01
255556669 0442 55558  969 
01224555555 014
355555997 014

5555599 01
1 25555 044
55558  97989
011 5555556 014 155555998 014

45555568 01
1
55558 044
55558 44
555599
011 15555556 014 105555597 014

05555569 01
123555597 04
2555586 0
403555587
011 5555556 014 115555597 014


5555569 01
1
555567 04
23555586 0
15555979
011 5555556 014  5555597 014

1555559 01
155559 0 3 555569 0
0
55556
011 5555556 014 5555597 014
14555556 01
 15555999799 0 3 255558689 0
44

0555589
011 45555556 01420555556 014
15555586 01
4055558787 86 0 3
555569 014555588 
011 22555555 0142 555556 014
13555559 01
0
555568 0 3 1555569 010 55558
011 21555555 014235555587 014
05555599 01
 55556 0 3 555569 01 25555698
011 2555555 0142 455555869 014
25555567 01
1
555566 669 0 341555569 0142255558889
011 23555555 0142 055555876 014
3 5555567 01
3 555599 99  02244555579 011555596
011
555555 01424 55555 014
4255555  01
30
555589 0224 55558 0144325555886
011 1 555555 01424155555 014
4155555 01
3205555999 0
4255558 0140 555587
011 1455555599 0142 455555  014
34
5555568 01
3
4555567 0
42 55558 01400455558
011 1 555555 0142 055555  014
3015555599 01
3
3555566966 0
42455558 01400055558
011 12555555 014223555557 014
303555559989699 01
32555586 0
24455558 0140 55556
011 1
55555586687 0142
2555556 014
3 5555596896 01
3325555898 0
241555577 01422
5555
011 15555559 01421 555556 66  96997 01 220 555588 0
24555577 014
155558 8
011 1 5555559 0142455555676767 014
3 55555998 01
2
5555 0
243555577 01
2 555589
011 1 5555558 0142
55555678 7 010 5555599  01
2355556 6 0
24 555576 012
55558866696
011 1 05555557 014215555567 010  5555599  01
42555589 0
24 4555576 01
555588
011 1 5555559 014235555567 010 4555559 79 01
005555868 0
24 0555579 011555588
011 1 255555589897899 014
5555588 010 0555559 6 01 12 5555869  0
24
55558 01 55556 6
011 1
555555 014
0055555 010 1555558  8787 0
24 155558 0132555588
042
555556999 014
025555566 010  55555699 01 3 20555566 0
24 55558 01 4 55556
000 35555569 01
1 15555567 010  155555999  01 3 2555568 0
24 355558 01 4555588
0 42145555597 01
143555558  9998 01 3 3555579 0
1 123555559997 0144
55559
0 045555569 01
10
55555879 010  35555599 01413555596 01 405555588 8  014
 5555
0 44
55555696 01
1 45555588 010 45555599 01440555588 01 40255555 67 014

555599 99
024404555557 01
1 05555589 010 4 5555597  8   9 9  96
02 0005555567 01
1 2555558 010 445555597 0144 55559 97 01 40
55555 7 014
23555596999
024
 1555558787 01
12 555556 010 0 5555569 0144555598987 01 4035555587 014
 5555669
0
 45555597 01
12055555979 010 04555558 0140 455559 01 4 0555556 014
3
555568
0
44
055555996 01
12
55555979 010 025555569 014
 5555 01 4 55555686 01 141555588
0
40
555558986 01
125555597 010 0
5555569 014
 1555599 01 4
5555589897 004134155555 9
0
4035555587 01
1
055555   0100 55555877879 014

55556 01 4 155555878867 0  2 5555569
0
403 55555898 01
10555556  87867869 014
3155556866 01 425555566866 0  23555556
0

1
5555589 01
11555556 0100 455555667 014
33555599 01 42 555556 68 024 135555596
0

2
5555597 01
13555556  666 014
55558 9 01 4205555599 02423055555
0
0235555597 01
13
555556 0100 5555588889 014
455558 9 01 42 5555599 0
42455555
0
12 55555687 01

5555599 01034255555 7 014
25555979 01 422555559997 0
044
5555596
0
44
225555566 01
555559997 01034 35555599 014345555679 01 421555559 0
0444 555556
0
44

555559969699 01
 5555599 010344455555989 010 4355556 8 01 42555558 010 41555556
0
4
1 55555 8 01

5555599 010344
5555586897 0104 455559 9899 01 4
555558 01 1
5555567
0
4
35555596 01
 55555999698 010340555559  999 01 4
25555568696 01 1
35555566
0
044255555997 01
445555587 0103404555559  0104 0555566 01 4

5555568 014 1 455555999


0
2
405555568 01
4 55555877 01034025555569 010425555696 01 4
15555567  99
01 555558 01
4
5555587 010340
555556 01042 5555696 01 4
5555567 014 14 5555588
01 1555558769 879 01
055555879 87 4 4
355558987 0101255558 014115555596896 014 1 25555568
01 35555599987 01
045555566 044
45555969 01014455558  9696 014
115555566
 989 01
025555568 04
135555996 01014 55558 014115555589 0144355555
0145555568 01
2555558786  9 879 01010255558 01411 5555587 014055555
014 55555666 01
245555588 0 12555587 0101 055558 014114155555 7 01044225555569
 696 01
205555588 0
00
555589 0101 255558 014110 55555 0
42225558887
010555559 01

55555997 0
 55558787 0101 55558 0141104555556 014
 555
010 5555589 01
1 555556 0 44
1055559987 01012155558 011 11255555669
010
5555599696896 01
12555556  6899 0101255558  6
0103555559 01
1555556  9898 0101235555889 011 11
555559996
01 555556666 01
455555888  999 0101
55558 011 105555599 9
01
555559997 01
25555589  969  0101
55558 011 155555979
01 5555597 01

555558 7  9 869 0101
455558 011 13 555556977
01443
55555889 01
3 5555569 024
 555598 0101
055558 011 1305555566
0140 05555589 01
325555568 024
 55559 0101
255558 011 45555596896
014045555588 01
3555559 6 024

0555566769 0101
155558 011  555556
01404 55555878 01
34555559 0


4555589 0101
355558 011 2555556
01404
55555889 01
30555559 0


0555586686 0101155558 011 3555558
0140415555589 01
33555559 6 0
02555597 01011 55558 011  555558769
01400 555558 01
3 0555559 0
4
155559 0101255558 011 
555556
0140025555588 01
3455555 0
4
 55559 01012 55558 011  3555559
0140015555589 01
3415555568 0
4
 055559 01012455558  2331555555687
014005555589 01
34355555699 0
24055558 01012055558   11555555687
0140 45555587 01
3005555589989 0
24 55558 01012255558 0
3255555588
0140 05555588 01
30255555899 0
24
55558 01012155558 0
5555557
01402 555558 7 01
3035555589 012555588 0101255558 0
 555555687
0140215555569 01
3 4555558  8 98   66  0
455555569
0140255555687 01
3225555599 01 55559 01012 55558 0
05555557

56789
0140
55555699689 01
32
5555598998 01 5555667 01012 55558 0
555555687
01401555559 01
3215555597  696 01012 055558 0
255555569
014010555559 01
3235555599 014205555889 01012455558 0142555558
01401 555559 01
3
5555599 011 55557 010124 55558 0142 555558
014025555566 01
3155555 0140 555589 010340 55559 01 4
555558
 6668 01
34555559 0140055558 01 14
55558 01 415555576
!"#$%&'#()*$'+!,-*$.*,!/#01#(#2(*,*$"34(/1#*/#&*)+4,!/#.5
!"#$%&'#()*$"(##$*$.*,!/#01#(#/1#*/#&*)!+)4)140$5
Case 2:19-cv-02699 Document 1-12 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 13