LEADERSHIP
The Solution
Use a combination substitution, engineering
controls, and administrative controls to reduce
the exposure to lifting and carrying heavy sacks
Ensuring Accountability
• Tough-Caring Leadership
• Tough-Coercive Leadership
• Tough-Controlling Leadership
Safety Leadership cont..
What Works: Tough-Caring Leadership
• The tough-caring leader is tough because
he cares about the employee's safety
• This leadership approach is also called the
"servant-leader" model because the leader
serves those he or leads
Safety Leadership cont..
What Works: Tough-Caring Leadership cont.
• Positive reinforcement - "If you comply
with safety rules, report injuries and
hazards, I will personally recognize you.“
• Positive reinforcement - "If you get
involved in the safety committee, you will
be more promotable."
• Positive reinforcement - "If you suggest
and help make improvements, I will
personally recognize and reward you."
Safety Leadership cont..
What Doesn't Work: Tough-Coercive
Leadership
• In this leadership approach, managers are
tough on safety to protect themselves: to
avoid penalties
• The manager's approach to controlling
performance may primarily rely on the
threat of punishment
• The culture is fear-driven
Safety Leadership cont..
What Doesn't Work: Tough-Coercive
Leadership cont..
• Punishment - "If I go down...I'm taking you
all with me!" (I've heard this myself!)
• Punishment - "If you violate this safety
rule, you will be fired."
• Punishment - "If you report hazards, you
will be labeled a complainer."
• Negative reinforcement - "If you work
accident free, you won't be fired."
Safety Leadership cont..
What Doesn't Work: Tough-Controlling
Leadership
• Managers primarily using this approach are
tough on safety to control losses
• They have high standards for behavior and
performance, and they control all aspects of
work to ensure compliance
Safety Leadership cont..
What Doesn't Work: Tough-Controlling
Leadership
• Negative reinforcement - "If you have an
accident, you'll be disciplined."
• Negative reinforcement - "If you don't have an
accident, you won't lose your bonus."
• Positive reinforcement - "If you comply with
safety rules, you will be recognized."
Safety Leadership cont..
What Leadership is NOT
• Leadership is not power
• Leadership is not status
• Leadership is not authority
• Leadership is not management
Safety Leadership cont..
The Five Levels of Leadership
• Level One - The Boss
• Level Two - The Coach
• Level Three - The Producer
• Level Four - The Provider
• Level Five - The Champion
Safety Leadership cont..