Living Standard
U.S. Public Research
Report
Issue 01
Spring 2019
STANDARD
The first in a series focusing on
the power of storytelling
for sustainability.
Presented by the
U.S. Green Building Council
ISSUE 001
U.S. PUBLIC
RESEARCH
REPORT
2 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 3
CONTENTS
4 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 5
Letter From The CEO Introduction A Matter of Time And Space Personal Stakes Are We There Yet? The Cost of Living (Better) Role to Play
6 14 18 26 40 44 48
What Can We Do? LEED The Way Words Matter Everybody Means Everybody Walk the Talk Summary of Findings What’s Next?
56 58 62 68 70 74 76
6 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 7
LETTER FROM
They rarely think about buildings. community’s efforts must go beyond
construction or efficiency. Instead, our
For some people, buildings are merely focus must be on people.
aesthetically fulfilling. They’re something
to marvel at. And for others, they, of course, In the pages that follow, you will see some
have an important daily purpose—as a place of Living Standard’s in-depth qualitative
THE CEO
to live and work. and quantitative research on people’s views
of the environment. This new research
But while the look and logic of buildings questions our conventional wisdom
tend to be at the forefront of our minds, and experience.
their long-term impact on our well-being is
not. And until that becomes our reality, we For too long, most of us in the green
still have a messaging mountain to climb. building community have simply been
talking to ourselves. We are not reaching
That’s because you can’t solve a problem the broader population effectively enough
that isn’t on your radar. to change their behavior or decisions
on the scale necessary to combat
Dear Friends, The IPCC report further crystallized for me And if you don’t understand or know what climate related risks.
the impact and timing of our own public a LEED-certified building is, let alone what
A month before opinion research initiative. When the report it can do for you and the people you love, But we can. If we listen and learn.
last year’s was released last fall, we were midway then you definitely don’t know that it’s And if we ask the right questions.
Greenbuild, through our own Living Standard research an advantage in the face of the daunting
the UN’s IPCC initiative. Across five regions of the U.S., global challenges ahead of us. In the coming months, we will be speaking
released its we convened focus groups among a wide with you and listening to your stories.
findings, issuing range of communities with two primary For over a quarter century now, USGBC We look forward to hearing your thoughts
a dire warning about an immediate need for goals in mind: to better understand the has worked to prove that buildings are on this report. And, by this year’s Greenbuild
the world to drastically reduce greenhouse disconnect between the story of green very much living entities that, if created 2019 in Atlanta, we plan to have a new
emissions by 2030. building and the average American, and to with forethought and compassion, can direction for USGBC, shaped by the
learn whether telling a better story could mitigate climate-related risks. people whose perspectives we are sharing
The report attracted international headlines provide the sense of urgency needed to in this report, and by all of you. Our goal is
— and it was, of course, at the top of my improve every human being’s quality of life. But we need to do more. And I believe for USGBC to be known not only for the
mind when speaking to USGBC’s global using this research to inform our strategy plaques we place on buildings, but for the
community this past November in Chicago. What we’ve just begun to understand—and I is the best first step we can take. people who experience them—the ones
can tell we’ve barely scratched the surface— leading longer, healthier, and happier lives.
How could it not be? 2030 is only is how many people out there have a unique The first in a series from USGBC’s
eleven years from now. That’s less than perspective on sustainability, and how many Living Standard campaign, this report Sincerely,
half the time that USGBC has existed. people we still have yet to reach. demonstrates the power of storytelling to
It means that children born today will further our work in sustainability.
only make it to elementary school before What we’ve also learned from leaders like
having to deal with the inevitability of LK Policy Lab President Laurie Kerr is We know that green buildings are only part Mahesh Ramanujam
catastrophic conditions. that when people think about emissions, of the solution to lengthening and bettering President and CEO
they think about cars, power plants, the lives of every person on the planet. USGBC
and industries. That’s why the heart of the green building
PROLOGUE
8 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 9
The U.S. Green Building Council young parents aged under 35 years old,
commissioned ClearPath Strategies, a with a child aged 10 years or younger.
global public opinion research company, to In Phoenix, Arizona, we conducted groups
conduct in-depth national qualitative and with young parents and commercial
quantitative research on people’s views of developers. And in San Francisco,
the environment. This independent study California, we conducted groups with
goes well beyond the familiar audience millennials and commercial developers.
for LEED, to include focus groups with
millennials, community opinion formers, The quantitative portion of the research
young parents, and a survey of the general consisted of a broad-based sample
public at large. reflecting the general population of the
United States. The survey was comprised
This is Living Standard’s first U.S. Public of 1606 adults aged 18 years old and
Opinion Research Report of a year-long older from across the country. We set
series where USGBC set out to better regional, gender, age, and race quotas
understand how the public feels about the to ensure a representative sample. After
issues at the core of the green building we fielded the survey, to further ensure
community’s mission—sustainability, green our sample matched the demographics
buildings, and the environment. Following and regional distribution of the United
are the firm’s methodology notes for States, we conducted post-stratification
this line of research. weighting by region, gender, age, race,
education level, and political party
The qualitative portion of the Living affiliation. Margin of sampling error for
Standard Research Report intended the study is +/- 2.33%. Respondents are
to explore a broad and diverse set of sourced from a leading global online panel
key voices concerned about these provider. They are selected from the panel
issues. This portion of the research based on geographic and demographic-
was comprised of 10 focus groups based quota.
conducted between September 24th
and October 3rd, 2018. It is easy for respondents to speed
through surveys or not pay enough
In Alexandria, Virginia, one group focused attention to provide useful data.
on community opinion formers (based We use a mechanism that automatically
on education level, awareness of current removes “speeders” from the final data
events, and income level) while the set. We define “speeders” as anyone who
second was comprised of residential completes the survey in a third of the
real estate developers and construction time taken by the average respondent.
firms. In Atlanta, Georgia, we conducted While speed is not a 1:1 proxy for
research among young millennials aged awareness, we can safely assume that if
18-25, and residential developers. In you are rushing through the survey, you
Chicago, Illinois, we conducted research are likely not taking the proper time to
among community opinion formers and thoughtfully respond.
10 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 11
Research Groups An important finding from our Living from cancer-causing electromagnetic
and Locations nts
Standard research to date—both fields, like power lines or energy plants.
e
ar qualitative and quantitative—is the
P
Co public has different understandings LEED: Leadership in Energy and
ng
m
You
of environmental problems, a healthy Environmental Design, is the most widely
m
environment, and LEED certification. used green building rating system in the
un
ity O pinion Fo
Therefore, in the context of the survey, world. Available for virtually all building,
Chicago we provide respondents with the following community and home project types, LEED
definitions to gauge their impressions of provides a framework to create healthy,
M these ideas and level-set the knowledge highly efficient, and cost-saving green
ille
n
r
m
nials s
er base across the sample: buildings, communities, and cities. LEED
certification is a globally recognized
C om mercia
ev
p ers
e lo A healthy environment: A healthy air be directed to David Bluestone, lead researcher
for ClearPath Strategies on this project, at
orm ers quality index of under 100, safe drinking
on F
david@clearpath-strategies.com
i
p in water clean from chemicals, toxins, and
yO
other industrial run-off, and safe distance
C o m m u n it
Alexandria
Com merc
ia l
De
v el
o p ers
s
er p
Phoenix elo v
ential De
Resid
ts
en r
Pa
ng n ni a l s
Mille
u
Re
Yo
sid
enti
al Developers
Atlanta
Independently-directed, national research
Representing diverse voices inside and outside of the green
building community
Nationally representative survey and national focus groups
For the average person, the specter When asked why, they say it simply
of environmental degradation and its feels like too daunting a task. And,
impact on humanity raises a series in a wake-up call for our community,
of contradictions. People say climate they still rank green buildings quite
change is one of their most urgent low as a viable avenue for improving
concerns about the future, but only a the environment.
passing concern right now. People say
it is going to impact everyone, yet hold In other words, there is a real gap
out hope that it will not affect people between the conceptual enormity of
like them. People say it is going to the problem and how people seek to
have an impact everywhere, but not in address it in their daily lives.
their community. People say we are all
responsible to solve these problems, Understanding this gap and learning
but take no personal responsibility for how to close it will be the subject of
addressing them. the first public opinion research report
from the U.S. Green Building Council’s
By and large, respondents are deeply Living Standard campaign.
concerned about the health of our
environment over the long-term —
but do very little to address the
problem in their daily lives.
16 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 17
01
Public overwhelmingly agrees
the environment is an urgent
concern for humanity.
02
People want to live in a
healthy environment, but
there are blockers for taking
03
For people to do more
and create big, lasting change,
conversations need to center
04
The green building community can
mobilize and inspire this change by
connecting messaging to health
meaningful action. around human terms, not just outcomes for human beings, by continuing
about humanity and to prove that LEED has a role to play
global stakes. and can evolve to best meet public
demands, and by using inclusive words
and phrasing. This last note is especially
important for expanding the reach of the
OVERVIEW
Living Standard campaign.
18 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 19
A MATTER
While 40% of respondents say the Generation Z respondents care most
environment is one of their biggest across time frames. Meanwhile, we
concerns for the future, less than a see the biggest increase from today
quarter of survey respondents say the to the future among baby boomers
environment is one of their biggest (particularly 55-64 year olds) and
concerns today. parents.”
OF TIME
This present-future dichotomy is Different markets have different
consistent across all regions of the starting out points and relative growth
& SPACE
U.S. There are differences between across the time horizons, with the
age groups, with younger respondents West region being the most concerned
caring more both now and in the about the environment, followed by the
future than older generations — and Northeast, South, and Central regions.
20 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 21
59
47
43 44
41 40
39 39 37
30 29 30
26
23 21
20 18 20
Gen Z Millennials Gen X Baby Boomers Silent Generation Northeast Central South West
PERSONAL
Which statement comes closer to your opinion, even if not exactly right?
Strongly Agree
Somewhat Agree
STAKES
58
22
13
Damage to the environment Damage to the environment is
will dramatically and negatively a problem for people around
impact all people’s ability to live the world, but tends to be
long and healthy lives. overstated.
28 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 29
MOST PEOPLE
BELIEVE IN
EXISTENTIAL
A strong majority sees the urgency of We also see the naysayers: just over
the problem—44% of people say that a quarter of respondents who want to
we should have already taken action, wait it out and don’t see environmental
and only 21% say action must be taken problems as big as a threat.
immediately. This represents two-thirds
of our sample. But another 30% see But here we see an important target.
the timeline for action as in the next Just under a quarter of respondents
year, couple years, within the decade, believe the problem is urgent, but are
or wait and see. reticent to act. The problem is not
part of their day-to-day struggle or
Turning concern into action presents a considerations. This is a key
challenge for this community. We want demographic the green community
to help people across the world go “all can bring on board.
in” on making the necessary change in
reversing the damage being done to It also corresponds to what we heard
our environment. To do that, we look at in focus groups. In subsequent pages,
how urgency combines with how willing you will see quotes that give voice to
someone says they are to act or make a people who did not feel empowered to
decision to create a better environment. make change or felt their impact was
minor compared to the problem and
We see a strong plurality who believes the possibility of solving it—as well as
it is a problem and are willing to act on one showing fatalism and an outright
it, and a slight majority (51%) who are unwillingness to act.
extremely or very likely to do something
to create an environment that leads
to healthier lives. This also includes
8% who are activists willing to make
changes, even if they don’t see the
environment as that big of a threat.
32 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 33
A
Saving the planet is too overwhelming, like me” are responsible. The problem is
too abstract, and too distant from peoples’ everyone’s and therefore no individual
realities. person’s problem.
When respondents were asked to select These questions were “Select all that
all options for who is impacted, where apply”, meaning that they could have
PERSONAL
is impacted, and who is responsible, chosen answers that identify themselves
most respondents choose the “catch-all” as impacted.
option—45% everyone impacted, 41%
everywhere impacted, and 50% all of But they didn’t.
us responsible.
In each instance, most respondents
They did not choose their individual choose the “catch-all” option and they
option—10% said “people like me” would themselves rank low in the terms
be impacted, 5% said “my community” of both who is impacted, where is
would be impacted, and 11% said “people impacted, and who is responsible.
PROBLEM
34 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 35
60 Recycle
48 Reduce Waste
44 Conserve Water
11 Compost
A PROBLEM
TOO BIG
TOO ABSTRACT
TOO DISTANT
FROM THEIR REALITIES
38 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 39
41 Everywhere
45 Everyone
50 All
26 Coastal areas
19
Disadvantaged countries
Low income communities
11 People like me
16 Islands
10 My local government
11 People from other countries
10 People like me
13 The United States 10 The United Nations
ARE WE
THERE YET?
To close both the time horizon gap for
how concerning the environment is or will
Only 11% say green buildings.
be and the distance between individuals It is worth noting that the outcomes
and the problem, research suggests it from green buildings, resource efficiency
is important to bring the problem into and water conservation, rank much
people’s day-to-day life by shining a light higher and are quadruple and almost
on the local environmental impacts if triple the relevance than green buildings
status quo of inaction continues. respectively. This suggests we need to
speak more about outcomes and impacts,
Consumers make an effort to be as green rather than physical structures.
as they can. A 51% majority says they
would be willing to spend more money People already give the green building
on food, products, and rent if that meant community credit for their role in
living in an environment that set them up improving the planet.
for a longer, healthier life. (Only 31%, by
contrast, wouldn’t make that trade-off.) But planet doesn’t necessarily mean
65% of respondents don’t believe their people. In fact, the results are very
environment is very healthy — and almost different when speaking about humans—
a third say they have direct, personal as people are ambivalent about whether
experience with bad health associated with the green building community plays a
poor environments or living situations, like large role in helping their communities.
asthma (18%), dirty drinking water (12%),
asbestos (9%), and sick buildings (5%). This is the problem we need to solve.
42 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 43
Which statement comes closer to your point of view? “The whole breathing thing with the asthma is
important because with my youngest son that is so
Strongly Agree severe, that’s going to stick with me. Improving the
51 Somewhat Agree air quality could help his breathing.”
Young Parent, Chicago
30
31
11
65% Give less than an “8” on a
scale of 1-10 when asked to
rate how healthy their local
environment is.
21 20
32%
Say they have direct, personal
experience with bad health
associated with poor environments
or living situations.
I would spend more money on food, I would not increase my spending on food, products,
products, and rent in exchange for living and rent in exchange for living in a different
in an environment that might lead environment, even if that might lead to a longer,
to a longer, healthier life. healthier life.
44 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 45
THE COST
Getting the public to act is showing But, interestingly, 36% believe it will
how the choices they make can become easier to take environmental
directly impact their own health today. actions and 37% believe technology
become more advanced and will allow
At the beginning of the survey, we them to do more.
asked whether respondents would
OF LIVING
do more, the same, or less to create This suggests that mobilizing the
a healthier environment, and the public to take action is not just about
public was split—43% - 44%. But, waiting until things get bad, but about
over the course of the survey, after empowering them with the tools to
being exposed to reasons why it is make those choices and actions
important to take action, we asked easier, and specifically leaning into
the respondents the same question technology to do so.
and saw a net +8% shift towards “Do
More.” This suggests, if we can deliver
In the next couple of years, do you think you will do on their expectations and frame our
more, the same, or less to create an environment that Initial (Pre-Messaging) initiatives in human terms, we inspire
lets you live a longer and healthier life? them to do even more.
Net +8% “More” vs. “Same/Less” Final (Post-Messaging)
When people who said they will
do more in the future were asked
why they chose that response, not
surprisingly, 43% say for existential
reasons, as preserving our planet
will require it.
43 48
Do More
44 41
Do The Same
3
Do Less
3 11 9
Don’t Know
(BETTER)
46 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 47
Why will you do more (than you do today) in the next couple of years
to create an environment that lets you live a longer and happier life?
36 It will be easier
THE GREEN
Despite some real gains over the last several years,
it’s clear this community has some work to do.
Green buildings are not central to the day-to-day
human story. Only 11% of respondents associate
words like “green building” and “green space” with
creating an environment in which people live longer
BUILDING
and healthier lives. This is far below other phrases,
which people do associate with the environment
— like recycling (45%), water conservation (40%),
and climate change (32%).
COMMUNITY’S
of the planet. Yet people are ambivalent about
whether the green building community plays a
large role in helping their communities with a lower
percentage, 39%, who believe they have an effect
on their personal health and happiness.
ROLE TO PLAY
50 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 51
Here is a list of different words and phrases associated with the environment and being green. Which THREE words or phrases are
MOST STRONGLY / LEAST related to creating an environment that lets you live a longer and healthier life?
Recycling -17 45
Water Conservation -14 40
Climate Change -22 32
Resource Efficiency -14 29
Nature Conservation -14 28
Sustainable Development -14 23
Sustainable Food -16 23
Organic Food Movement -31 14
Green Space -16 11
Green Buildings -17 11 Today green buildings are not relevant
to people’s view of the environment.
50
41
39
28
30 15
“I think a lot of the public has
yet to realize the full scope of
how building can impact their
23
health and happiness. I think
WHAT
How much of an impact do green buildings
Very Big
have on the following criteria?
68 69 67 Some
64 61
56 54 55
WE DO?
Cleaner Air Helping Less Cleaner Living a Cost Happiness Bringing Visual More jobs
the Planet Exposure Water Longer/ Savings the Future Aesthetic
Community Opinion Former, Chicago to Toxins Healtier Life Closer
When asked, the public believes green who say green buildings only play a
communities are not just about helping small role in their overall health and
the environment, but can have a very happiness. Emphasizing the top tier
big impact on things they care about in benefits helps us expand our support.
their local communities.
We need to place less emphasis on
When making our promise to people, creating green jobs, or representing
we need to emphasize the most the future, or cost savings, or even
credible, tangible benefits, like cleaner something abstract like “happiness.”
air, less exposure to toxins, and In other words, we need to think
cleaner water. For each of these, we of this as “What’s in it for us, the
easily surpass the number of people human beings?”
LEED
58 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 59
THE
WAY
60 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 61
LEED has a big role and can evolve to meet market demands
Do you think LEED plays a role in creating an evironment Here are some possible changes to LEED in the future.
that lets you live a longer and healthier life? Which TWO of these changes do you think would create
an environment that leads to longer and healthier lives?
38 Some role
19 Don’t know
17 Don’t know
1 Negative impact
12 Different types of green certification
62 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 63
WORDS
MATTER
Mahesh Ramanujam, President
and CEO of USGBC, says, “Talking
Promote Healthy Outcomes
Sustainable cities improve people’s
generations deserve to live, work,
learn, and play in a healthy, thriving
to human beings in terms of how lives and better designed spaces environment.
our decision making impacts their help people live longer, healthier, and
everyday lives shouldn’t only be part happier lives. Toxin-free materials, With this message, 51% of
of the conversation. It should be the good air ventilation, and air-purifying respondents were extremely
heart of it.” plants, altogether in your house or or very likely to take action.
workplace, really can improve physical
Our survey suggests three health and comfort by reducing Planetary Stakes
messages were most powerful symptoms of allergies and respiratory- With more natural disasters,
amongst those target groups who related illnesses like asthma. drought, fires, and hunger, our global
shifted toward saying they would environment is getting worse every
“do more” to create a healthier With this message, 51% of day. Now UN climate scientists report
environment in the next couple respondents were extremely that if we do not make dramatic
of years. or very likely to take action. changes in how we live and the
fuel we consume, we will have an
Here is the summary of the most Future Generations environmental catastrophe by 2030.
effective ways to talk about how At the rate the planet is warming, The time to act is now.
green buildings can help, who they catastrophe is almost certain. If we
help, and why they are necessary. continue to do nothing, our children With this message, 49% of
will ask, “How could you do this to us?” respondents were extremely or very
And they will be right. Our future likely to take action.
64 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 65
MESSAGING HOW?
Connect green buildings to healthy outcomes
by explaining how living in green buildings and
communities generates cleaner air and water,
which improves physical health and reduces
symptoms of allergies and exposure to toxins.
INSPIRE WHO?
Connect environmental problems to individuals,
local communities, and specifically to the
concept that future generations deserve to
live, work, learn, and play in a healthy, thriving
environment.
MORE
ACTION
66 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 67
EVERYBODY
Rate your feelings toward various people/organizations/things
Favorable
from 0 to 10, with 10 meaning very favorable; 0 meaning very
unfavorable; and 5 meaning neutral.
Unfavorable/
Neutral
65
58 62 55
MEANS
51 54 54 45
Mother Nature
Sustainability
Planet Earth
Environmentalism
Green Buildings
Green Communities
Green Movement
36
LEED
Built Environment
EVERYBODY 26 28 28 35 34 30 32 32 32
9% 14%
WALK THE
TALK
As the green building community
embraces a deeper connection to
promoting personal health and well-
being and a commitment to being
inclusive in how it speaks, it also
must walk the talk.
SUMMARY
Environment is an urgent concern Research suggests the green building
for the public, but it has not yet led community can tap into the public’s
to corresponding levels of lasting, desire for better local environments
big actions. with the following approach:
OF
sidelines requires speaking about outcomes, not just physical outputs.
benefits of green buildings and
communities in local, human terms, Evolve LEED to play a bigger role
not just in terms of humanity and in communities where people live,
planetary stakes. not just work.
FINDINGS
messaging and language.
76 Living Standard U.S. Public Research Report Spring 2019 77
WHAT’S
NEXT?
This is the first research report for the Living Of important note: Since launching the Living
Standard campaign in mid-November 2018,
Standard campaign in what will be a regular series USGBC’s online community has already
over the course of 2019, each with a particular issue demonstrated that this type of messaging
and regional focus. resonates. From the date of launch to a month
later, USGBC Facebook content featuring Living
Standard messaging saw a 79% increase in
Our research plan will continue to take the pulse of engagements and a 50% increase in reach from
its regular content. And on Twitter, USGBC
the U.S. and socialize findings with the community
content that featured Living Standard messaging
with public-focused events and activation tool-kits saw a 31% increase in engagements and a
for our grassroots. 150% increase in reach. USGBC and its allies
recognize the need to be much more visible,
public, and vocal about how green buildings
We will prepare research presentations for stakeholder have local, tangible, and positive impacts on
partners, community members, and the public at large, consumers’ lives. This is how the green building
community can reach the broader population
to share general trends, regional insights, and a tool-kit effectively enough to change their behavior
of messaging to take action in local communities. and decisions on the scale necessary to begin
reversing the effects of climate change.
livingstandard.org