'1ll'lal.JLL1JlJhuJ'lIM1il(1l'l'll<1n'l'nilo.a ~L~tJul";1~rh5il6'l'll'tJ!'l'1u'l'lq1tiit11'niith! LL'IJ'UriTvIUliliWtllM6'l3-llJ'Srn (purely deterministic theory of politics) d'IL~acll\)lV1
tll-.llt."flJ.J bLliI:::bfT;;l?!jn'l~biiu 1tJ€lcll~'n<'lt 1.«1.1 n~\lthiM';'~ iNti a fl'l 'In b~Utll." "!IeJ"'"j-:1JtJ'1'n,ml'bi'ieJ·\I~b ii~N1Vl~\llJ~1 rfUn1-rn~.ul1J.rtmnTni-'l eN ~ L 1i EJ u It ~;J tl1:::biiulVib;;w:i1 b-wtl\Jb~tl\J "1'I113-lUJiiI-.!".!t1W1U" 1I€1\J 3 tlr.:L~u'l:;t.b'll.lBiI'l111-l
''1l'.i:;·Yp!l-ntJtlliI:~b il'll'th:'J11'11U'lm '1 '!'ItJ b ~f1aj..j~l\1t:pr:i"'!j.J'tQJ"Ib.n~~al3JflU«u nlJnrun!-l usen n~'il ~htGl\l t'Yll~-oill'1 n t~tJfilk-.j"ll tl\l~~'I'll n b "lll \1~nill1rl'ttl1~\1 Ml u
( man of prowess) Lm:::ii'o:JL'llUrl'Yl1lui1'u\il[)).nll nT'nLflnLbtlm:'Yl+:J~n~~V<lm~Elu niln~m1'1'1l'i'ui'lr:u,::nh'{]~~lI. "1'lJfhl~b£Jn~3-l'Y1'1'11l1fiLth.whtlflleJ1J.fl1t1~';hLmu-.j rr17L~'lM4'J.l1'YI1~fl11~eJ~
u ~~ L 1U[)~1 U~U!19;.1.'IJ a~ "tJ'::'lIl~t1tl'ltl?1~~l1J" t W~::U1J'V'I momti13-l (u Ul?111'j.j~(il 'lI B\I n11iit 1!lil-a:::'1fl1itJ'[1'I rn V1rJ\I?1~\I ,11 vi1-,mtl flfllll."'n:l-ll'hl'Yl!ll~·;h L 10 u vi \I"JI1~ 6ildrh-t-l bb~m~rJ \I~~\I b~tn b thttu ~\ln b'Yhn1J'hbu'U,n11'nill'Yl"'~ Elfm'l!-l~ t11:::'1fl~1.l'l(!lm~:I.Il1J 'VI~ill.J"!:::'Jjl1itlll'1t1~bb'n"11~) 'I'I~mLl1\b";luu "'''ILlU~ .ttu
,
"f:rtJ1~" lm::ul..I'l1nMlli ~ L ~rJu tll·b l1u~ 1fl~fl u Ulfr:n :I.I1'l<;l L~1l1nutl1:::'l.l1n1.lL(i\}£1
~ ~
a cil~ IiiI(1I ~t1 '.:::'1flTIuL<;ltl l'YlrJbi:hmr1ulL 'I11uill~"'LB.;j 1!-l~\bht'l11unil ~~5u ')
~~~L ';il1~ L ,:,,.mN ... :h tm\la11-1l 1 'I'l,.hJD~ U U1J IJ.N'l-ltJ1::"II1li1J1\flEJ'l'YlfJen5m'l'a-:l«u
LLfl::~mj.J dJu 11Jl~'lJEl~m'i'1J ·:nn(J~U2-Jl'IJEl~~ldrn\lm'i'L~ehl~.\I1'1'1~ G'<H-IJ'l:; 'LL1'I\Pl.~ 1 Vi \ 'I1U 5-l5mtO-l::1J1-IJ tI,: n 1.'lJ a \I n Tn uuilu 1 L iJ2-J U 1j ~ rill ,~a1J tn 1:J..I51 L 1'1
3. Oliver Wolter, History, Culture, and Region in Southeast Asian
Pe~peclives, revised edition (Singapore: Southeast Asia program Publications. Cornell University in cooperation wilh Institute 01 Southeast Asian Studies, 1999).
4. Thongchai Winichakul, Siam Mapped: A History of the Geo·body of a
Nation (Honolulu· University of Hawaii Press, 1994).
5. Robert J. Muscat, The Filt/) Tiger: A Study of Thai Development
Po/icy (Helsinki, Finland: United Na~ons University Press. 1994).
lJtl1qJq!lq)7Lntf~iiilm.j~lU Foreign Service -onn University of the Philippines ~rlillJ 1965/2508 ~t!'l::U 1968/2511 "I1JtI'i'l!QJ11-Yl~h'\.l. Diplomacy and World Affairs vm Occidental College, Los Angeles "I1J11'iqjqplymc1::tJ1QJQ.J1Lilmlhu. Government "lln Cornell University ldtlU 1971/2514 u;;d~1974/25t 7 ~l1:wcil~1J il1tnii'W~Lfili1Q.JQ.Jli,ami8~ "The Sarit Regime, 1957·1963"
~,"nl';f'fl1~l~L : 1:i:i'Utml,thJ:"n:oiltil'lrn::f:mfll?l~ 'j.J'I'l1~11£J1;£J n1l-JTllfll?ll'J::vr:hI'JU 1974/2517-1980/2523 lWl£JiiilLl'l'lU'>l1"l11nl'LtJu lENl'lla\;rn"ll'J~ 1'li,r;nmtu l(ii1'ild]'I-I'ra-Jl'tl1:m7:'l.J1~ lYltf"Jil-3#U"l riel\.l~"I::thtl 'ttJ'l'ilI'J1U.li':::-;!'1~ Cornell Southeast Asia Program ~~tl~n 1980/2523 1-11 "IU~.,jU "I 'I !lU k~ uwiu 1998/2541 ~.,j U"I "Iu'l-l!1h ,"'~1 u 'YIu\n~uN Bl111 !:Jn1'
, ,~
trl':!~nTi\Ol\In~l1
lli7~V\·h{j!U'UU1"l1,.6~J.l,'1'111'Ylm~£J1i1'J'j.Jl'flo!l?lnuil1978!25211~!1l~~ Visiting Professor, guest of the PRC National Academy LLm:ll 1978·19791 2521-2523 ~tJ"L Visiting Research Scholar, Center lor Southeast Asian Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto,Japan
~"~lU1'l!lm'j: 'I'I,r~Nfl::i'l!lm'S~lil~qj~<J Thajland: the Politics of Despotic Paternalism (Bangkok: Tharnrnasat University Press "and Social Science Assooiation of Thailand, 1979). ~1@(1iJ'm-rill the Ohira Prize LdllU
hu~n ll-1U'IltJ u!.J\'lUU<l't "'!J;,)~f.:lU1i'1''II~ iill;,);,) n 11.l" bI.<l:flllllln11rn ~ L tJj.I1J'~!:I <ili Qj~;,) "nul'l!l!-l~lilflWil,J)flnl'l1!.JtJ,n 'I1l'lll1 t.l1lcil~ mIL W
\It'Wl~ L ifl\lm"~11 ~ 'J~1I1J "i1'1ln'l'HliT E1t 'YI~ bl.i'1 en fl~'I1'WaiT[j 1,.,!J
tl-Ji1 i!l::: t '''1:::~~'Ii molt Vi L ~'J,Iii~«n'ltru:'lJ as rn 'Jlil~h-.ltl,.~ L'I1I'l'l ,Ji";'UliliTti L'lItlrl1~~ltJn'hm'J~n'),l1LMrnnIJ11(;)mlmTI'l1\l1.l .. ::-N\I'nMI~'lJfl\lm"'i'I'YI11"t'l'lti LijEl1Jilll£J'J'jVlj)I'l~1n'),l~ 24 «Q1'l~-lL~mll\l1h::L 'YIl'llunl-l,!'J,I(lnr;' 1~'J11J~11J
qi1U'I.".t\l~(Il,"~11\1£l~lwli1':i1'llrn1li'liill7<ltllu W.t'l.2449 L~.rr&1~th::::c,,'!I'11:1J1n1ni '1:rT\lfl\l0,miTl.mtUfl!1'lJtJlvnflnl'1'l n\$Hin1'l!..l~1J'l.Jl-lntln1':ltub1hL~!.I\.1 lut 1\lL 12.1 U '1.11 tJ ~1) El L ~ !l-)1 ~ mil'f11 b oil1', 1£J '\..1,'1 ~~ 1) e L tJU1J~ 1'!J o ~ t1~iJ~!l b~ £I.:)
"l::vfl3.mil~lI":: L~hdl "l fH.J'I'lM9l:ftL~ UlJ fI fliII~hit 113-Jl::Sl3-I n1Hl~[J'I'I"1!J hi b 'V'! 11:::bi~lub'i!J~ li '# "~wlulibb~if"l'iuU d;;'1::'l$(fiu~h1l'il nHi'l11m 11 t:ll1 ~ hi
Visi~ing Fellow ~ Center for Southeast Asian Studies b!.vl-33-1'V111'Yl!11~£J LnrnL@1 ~lh~.L~h~;]I<lmt.'ld'lm1Jflm Larry Sliffel, David Wyatt, 111:'1::: Shinichi
1. J11El~1Wlh~ David A. Wilson, Polilics in Thailand (Ithaca . Cornell
University Press, 1962) ,Frank C. Darling, Thai/and and the United States (Washington : Public Affairs Press, 1965) ; Fred W. Riggs, Thailand: The Modernization of a Bureaucratic Polity (Honolulu: East·West Center Press, 1966); and William J. Siffin, Tile Thai Bureaucracy: Institutional Change and Development (Honolulu : East-West Center Press, 1966).
2. n-:rntlmill ~ Norman Jacobs, Modernization Without Development
Thailand as an Asian Case Study, (New York: Praeger, 1971).
'I'Ul.2475 lV1~ Wil,"',1J~;~l mmmfll "n1·atl~I.IUu1.li:Hm,ml1Iilil~ ~.1'I.2475" 1\.1 Thak Ohaleornnarana, ed., Thai Politics, 1932-1957 (Bangkok: Social Science Association of Thailand. 1978), pp. 36-50. Also note Rama VII's detailed criticisms of Pridi's Economic Development Plan in Ibid., pp. 193-236. t'l'lmCl~ 7 l17~tl7:nmmm-l,111 tJrfuiiYliw!I·ftfltlibilOl'l1 ~~n'l1V;'LI1u1J~~ii'1N~.ntlil!ln'llflntl1:L"'l'I.a-'fl11'
1 O. ~nT''ilm1~'h:L~u~11.1 Benedict Anderson, "Studies of the Thai Slale, • a paper submitted 10 the Conlerence on the State of Thai Siudies, (Chicago, March
12. ~h'i"'l1'riil~tJ1nutl1linTIUlil~fi"'1"n.r1./h.l~lIlJ1Ii~Lii~l,fu Toru Vano L;;tmLil\.1 "Sarit and Thailand's Pro-American Policy," The Oeveloping Economies, VI (September 1963), pp. 284-299,
13. 111.1<l~t1iI.l~t1lfllt1 ~ Thak Chaloemliarana, "The Evolution 01 the Monarchy and Government : Institutional Conflicts and Change," in laurislan Sharp, ed., Asia (Asia Society, N.V), (Spring 1976), pp. 41-56.
14. Ibid,
Ilmi, 19
15. Noel Baltye, "The Military, Government and Society in Siam, 1868-
Inl0," (Ph.D. Dissertation, Cornell Untversity, 1974}, pp. 20-21.
'1l1IJ1u" tJ':~Ylfl;nnn·hr\'l~l.h~0l~t\111~tlVl11 "{l1Hl-IElnjJ"-::ll'lfl" Ibid., p. 226.I~il ~ In~~~1Jl1tJl'11rn[J 1'!.11h:Ltlfl'llf)~tlVll1 Ben Anderson Eh~fI~ Battye and Benjamin Batson, "Ilia End of the Absolute Monarchy in Siam," (Ph.D. Dissertation, Cornell University, 1077), 11 1utJm.f1m'l1fl1 .. ')"~rt 2423-2433 untJ~~tJ,.,~'-I ~ fi1n1Jn1.l>1ml1lJ1'11n 'l \11.I1.~,I'i.tu ,n~ ~Ln1"ia=il en il~;;~ 1"";YI~\ilIlrtJ<l'~1~LL~~"2i'tL ;1tutJum1t ~~ n11U~ ~Ull11l1 u tlm'l'lfll;;l!l(O]f)~m~1!J~h'\.l~Lij'l-l~1[J!l~-rn~ii!J:J.J LLI1::{\!'I'Ilqj~1~ 'J 'lIru::I~~1n'W.l'r".lmJ~~tJ mill ~ L"'~1itn\'l1~'I'I'linii>l'111:J.JhlilL'f'I~r:.laWillum'l'rill~~nEJ~..r'W~~\tillil!H~mJnillEl~ llm'l'lfillf-wtmmh!Jq}:1Uo/ln (Battye, pp .. 2631.) Battye n~n'b Batson (p. 202) t~L\hl.lh:;t\ilU~""':l~h-;rn~~Ll;tl vn:il~flL~hU11U'l1 n;ltnT~~l-J'tJi'i1'lfm<l~ 7 ':h n l11il'l!l1ll'1 L ~!l'iljJ ~h ~ ·n:1Jf)un l;U nfl"JEI ~ Ell'1Yil1 11lL1!l'fl I'll 'iiln~Ul i'ltL~@I·:;iriJ 'I'I?:l-IVil
.. - - 'iJ
Illr~i'16:l@i L~~~itl?iI.in110tiu11!Jn\-lmnht YUl.2471 .;j~ul~y\·LJ,ihfn'l~:1'im.ittJ~~ II1~nl'J:tiLdti Vtfl 2454 nlfi ~ Anderson, "Studies of the Thai State," footnote 23. 19. L~~1n1JL~<J~'I1""1\l"£1 ~ David Wilson, ''The Military in Thai Po'litics," in
'"
IIol1n J. Johnson, ed., The Role of the Mililary in Underdeveloped Countties lJitlnceton : Princeton University Press, 1962), pp. 253-276; Claude E. Welch Jr. and Al1hur K. Smith, Military Role and Rule (North Scituate: Duxbury Press. 1974) ; Moahe Lissak, Military Role in Modernization: Civil-Military Relations in Thailand and {lamIa (Beverly Hills .: Sage Publications, 1976); and Fred von der Mehden, 'The Military and Development in Thailand," Journal of Comparative Administration, II (NOvelT1ber 1970), pp, 323-340.
21 TOfU Yano, "Political Structure of a 'Rice Growing State'," in Voneo I~IIU, ed., Thailand: A Rice Growing Society, Monographs of the Center for Southeast
Asian Studies, Kyoto University, English-language Series, No 12, 1978, pp. 221 and II ...
22. Yano ;;iHht'hdlt1.::IEI'!1ti'IJi!Nfl nfif'\1:mi\lhi1~ n 1: ~ltJ 1tJ~~l.h:'lfl'l1~ t1cl1~L~Il~hL!~EI~~h~ 'l L'lIlmh'lLt[j~1II1j.fmlllL~'U"h~ 'J +1 "l'llf11'<lh~lJmti'ifl-;''t'i'mfJttJ\r
- .
tJ.: LYI tiL 'Illl 311?iliil1: LL i!,~ n'l: ~~r1J m\\un'\1~u ~ LID nl U1:Ul.I n1.d~u~ !iVl'\11 '1~~ lJl
~1l-1fl11l-JL1iU~'i~ Lb£.i, m1tJ~~1J'IIil n''!I1~;lj~n ~riOll iii In$l~1J1J~tL ~~ ll-b\L\>l<l~.h'iji1 a'~f1 ;jLl1JUu~wrn~lill'll.l)nj.lnll~ 'l 'lJa~~'lLfl~tl~ .rllii,r~rWJUli'!"lj"'1~m~liltl~u~" LL1JUbI~\.Im~Iii1L';l·L'i'i~B~~h!J" lbid., p. 123.
• LI'llIhnh:::L 'Y11'!a.!ln:ilu H1uiinurJ'VIii{l f1l1a.J1lI1Lmll'1Jfl\lul tJ1.I1~iLn<i)'11 n
II 11rn:'I'i'TYhihih~r-)lU~l-I~Ujj:i'l~'J LIGl::m'ltJ~nilElfln'llnI'l11a.11lJ~~"1lflU II I 'In'm~flI11~tlm,nn1lJ~hbL'I'IU~~&hI1't"il"lH11'l6b'Yll-lV'l'l:fl-.:Jti m'H6'IN'llU
l'YIf1Jmnilmul1~tt'Ylwn~Q':m~::l'lrn::f~j.J'U'1I~Nh£J fL:«Ut'1ltl'l'\1oJtlQ'VI3-Il£J u 1~"LtJ'Ul1.J\Wl~~-;::lu'U~lTru'l!1n11'Yl't'l11unua:::U1tJnf:jj.J'U(i}~luna1L~tJ1n'U
Ii I \1 1f11IjJ'Ul1b\W:n 1~biJu7~"U(fI1'1il~-.ilm,m:;m"l\lm'Ii1;r~luilI~~r'lmm1'i1 tl. 1\~,I\~!mih'1fll-l 2485 "iU~~b~D1.I(ilCllli1l.Jlu;hlmn 'I'Ia,\lnl'l'Jl(llCllDiln