Saint Paul - constantly refers to the triad of faith, hope and love in reference to
Christian behavior and also applicable to Christian ethics.
Faith - according to the Scripture, is being able to see Life from a different
perspective.
- It is recognizing that our greatest joy comes from God through our
relationship with Him.
- It demonstrate that we are willing to root our lives in Him-to play the
game, as it were, by His rules and to give up any claim to run our
lives our ourselves.
- is rooted in the past-in who God is and has been for all eternity and
in what He did for us 2000 years ago when Jesus died and
rose again.
Love - The life we live today is to be lived by giving ourselves to God and
to others.
- This love for God and for others is to be one of the driving motivations of all that
we do.
Hope - the hope that I have in His provision of strength and grace for each
day that we live.
- We are able to make plans for the future, trusting that He will be there to give
grace sufficient to carry out those plans.
- We can extend our self now beyond our ordinary limits of strength for we know
that eternal rest awaits us when we will be totally fulfilled in His presence.
Our hope is that the injustices in this world that we are unable to
address will be taken care of in the proper time and place. We are able to truly
love others and put their needs above those of ourselves.
We do not live exclusively for comfort in the here and now, but
are able to extend ourselves beyond our comfort level with the expectation that
God will provide grace for each day and a future eternal rest.
Historical Perspective
Fr. Richard McCormick and lawyer Wesley Smith - bioethics pioneers, arguing that
the field as conducted today too often has done moral harm
to medicine and society.
Bioethics
BIOETHICS
- Prof. Richard Oliver of the Vandebilt University has announced that “The
Bioterials Age will complete the triumph of economics over politics, which
began during the Information Age.
Benefits of biotechnologies:
genetic engineering
cloning
cybernetics
nanotechnology
a loss of human
Sober questions for Christians who are witnesses to the dawn of the biotech age.
2. Does the Church have anything to say to biotechnology? If so, what? If not, why
not?
3. Can we afford not to speak to these issues? Can we afford to misspeak on these
issues?
One of the challenges which we will increasingly face us new technologies arise is
the determination of what it means to be human.
Katherine Hayles - argues that mortal human beings are rapidly becoming an
endangered species.
Han’s Morevec’s - vision of the future is realized, human beings as we know them
will have to fight for their own survival, but with an unlikely
enemy.
- Quoted,
Bill Joy - w co-founder and chief scientist at Sun Microsystems, does not think these
are ludicrous ideas.
Latest Developments
Several years ago it appeared the main roadblock to using pig organs for
xenotransplantation was the presence of galactosyl (GAL) moeties linked to the cell
surfaces of animal tissues, and produced by the enzyme alpha-galactosyl transferase.
Primates, including humans, do not have GAL-linkages on their cell surfaces and
produce antibodies against them, causing the rejection of transplanted animal organs. It
has since been established that the causes for organ rejection are more complicated
than that, and additional antigens have been implicated in the human immune system
response. However, immunological issues remain the main roadblocks to
xenotransplantation, according to Dr. Muhammad Mohiuddin of the NIH Cardiothoracic
Surgery Research Program, National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute.
In addition to the immunological issues, there are safety concerns for whole
populations, due to the possibility of infection of an organ recipient by an animal virus,
and animal rights issues, that result in ethical debate over the topic of
xenotransplantation. As a result, there are also many regulatory hurdles to overcome,
before xenotransplantation becomes everyday practice.
What's at Stake?
Transplants of animal organs to humans are obviously performed at the expense of the
animal in question. Animal rights advocates believe that it is not morally acceptable to
sacrifice animals for the benefit of human lives, whether for the use of their organs or for
research necessary to study the immunological factors causing organ rejection.
Humans are not without risk in this issue either. The effects latent animal viruses will
have on human organ recipients are still unknown. Opponents of xenotransplantation
fear that these viruses, when introduced into a human system might cause epidemics of
diseases for which we have no immunity and no cure. Pigs, for example, currently the
best candidate animal species for culturing organs for humans, carry a retrovirus called
PERV (Porcine Enogenous Retrovirus). This virus has been shown to infect human
cells and the consequences of infection have not yet been determined.
Some opponents of xenotransplantation believe that animals are not the solution but
that biotech companies are just looking to make money from their ability to clone animal
cells and create GMOs, specifically GM pigs (knockouts lacking the alpha-galactosyl
transferase enzyme).
Why It Works
Using animal organs would reduce the length of time many people have to wait for a
suitable organ, and would allow transplants to occur while the recipient is still strong and
somewhat healthy and better able to tolerate surgery. According to statistics quoted by
the Lincoln Journal Star, the current number of 20,000 transplants per year in America
could be increased to over 100,000, if animal organs were used, and 12 out of 73,000
Americans waiting for transplants die each day.
It is hoped that current practices of injecting donor cells into pig embryos, in utero, will
eliminate the need for immunosuppressant drugs as this has been shown to make the
donor and recipient compatible when tested between pigs and other animals. This
means using molecular genetics techniques to create GM animals, specifically altered
to be a match for an individual human recipient. The knockout species would be
conceived and raised for the sole purpose of being sacrificed for medicine.
Pigs are a good choice of organ donor because of their short gestation period, rapid
growth rate and size of organs (matching those of humans). Hyperacute rejection (HAR)
of organs from Gal-knockout pigs transplanted into baboons was prevented due to the
absence of expression of the 1,3-galactosyltransferase gene. Although other immune
responses are present, there is hope that similar genetic alterations will be possible, to
address the issue of HAR in humans.
Arguments Against
Ethical issues surrounding the use of animal organs for human transplants appear to be
threefold. There is the issue of animal rights and the breeding of animals simply for
human consumption and medical benefit. Secondly, there are some who believe that
xenotransplant technology is just another way for biotech companies to make money,
and they are not concerned with the welfare of the animals or truly concerned with the
welfare of mankind, due to their perceived disregard for the third issue, which is the
unknown impact on the human race, should a new infection be introduced for which we
have no cure.
Where it stands
Ethicist Dr. Andrew Jameton, from the Nebraska Medical Center in Omaha, pointed out
that this issue is no different from research in any medical field. Although the desire for
recognition and compensation for the cost of research is always a temptation, especailly
where venture capitalists are involved, "scientists in all fields must guard against letting
profit get ahead of scientific method and accuracy". That is, the issue of integrity is no
greater in this than in any other field of science and should not necessarily be viewed as
a reason to hold back the technology to save lives.
Scientists involved in xenotransplant research say their research is highly regulated and
that the animals involved are treated with the greatest respect, in addition to being given
any painkillers or anesthetics required making them comfortable. In many experiments,
nerve cells are not connected to transplanted organs, so the animals cannot feel pain
from the organ being rejected. Realistically, it must be acknowledged that none of the
medical advances of mankind could have been accomplished without animal
experimentation. However, the fact remains that xenotransplantation is ethically on a
whole different level, as even after the technology is established, animals’ lives will
continuously need to be sacrificed for the lives of human beneficiaries.
There are two basic kinds of stem cells: those found in certain adult tissues and those
found in the cells of three- to five-day-old embryos. Adult stem cells, found in brain,
bone marrow, muscle, skin, blood and liver tissue, can change into a limited number of
cell types. The stem cells found in embryos, on the other hand, are pluripotent, that is,
they have the unique ability to develop into any of the 220 cell types in the human body.
In addition to their versatility, embryonic stem cells are easier to grow in the laboratory
than adult stem cells. Adult stem cell lines proliferate only for a limited time, while
embryonic stem cells potentially can continue dividing forever.
The first and best-known success in adult stem cell research is the bone marrow
transplant, in which stem cells from a donor's bone marrow are used to regenerate
healthy bone marrow in patients with leukemia and other blood diseases. This therapy
is still used today.
Embryonic, or pluripotent, stem cells offer even more dramatic prospects for new
treatments and cures for conditions such as spinal cord injuries, blindness and juvenile
diabetes, as well as Parkinson's disease, Lou Gehrig's disease and Alzheimer's
disease. In addition, some scientists say research using pluripotent cells could
ultimately result in treatments for certain types of cancer, new methods of rapidly testing
drugs and a basic understanding of human development and genetic abnormalities.
In the early 1980s, scientists began studying embryonic stem cells, first in mice. But
because mouse embryos develop very differently than human embryos, researchers
soon sought a way to isolate human embryonic stem cells. In 1998, a team lead by
James Thomson at the University of Wisconsin was the first to successfully harvest
stem cells from human embryos donated by fertility clinics. Since then, scientists have
developed some 400 stem cell lines using private and public funds.
Embryonic stem cells are harvested in two ways: from existing human embryos and
from embryos that have been created using a cloning process known as somatic cell
nuclear transfer (SCNT). In both cases, the embryo is ultimately destroyed, which
opponents of embryonic stem cell research argue is immoral.
The SCNT process was developed by the Scottish scientist Ian Wilmut, who cloned
Dolly the sheep in 1996. During the process, the nucleus of a human egg cell is
removed and replaced with the nucleus of a donor's adult cell, which contains the
person's DNA. The egg is then stimulated to begin subdividing, eventually growing into
an embryo with stem cells that can be harvested. Many scientists consider SCNT very
promising because it creates an embryo with stem cells that have the same DNA code
as the person who donated the cell nucleus. These stem cells can then be used to
create therapies that potentially would be compatible with that donor's immune system.
In other words, if doctors grew new heart tissue to treat someone with heart disease,
the use of the patient's DNA could greatly reduce the likelihood of the patient's body
rejecting the new tissue.
A Potential Breakthrough
In 2007, Thomson and his team at the University of Wisconsin, along with scientists in
Tokyo, created what appear to be pluripotent cells from adult human skin cells rather
than from embryonic cells. The new technique coaxes skin cells to revert to an
embryonic stem cell state by inserting a tiny DNA-containing virus.
Even though the new skin cell technique begins with an adult cell, the resulting stem
cells appear to have the same makeup and properties as embryonic stem cells,
potentially allowing scientists to create pluripotent cells without destroying embryos. If
perfected, it also could eliminate the need to create embryos using SCNT. Some say
this could eventually end the controversy surrounding stem cell research.
Like SCNT, the new skin cell technique would produce compatible stem cells. Some
scientists say the skin cell technique may be more efficient than using embryos because
it would eliminate the cumbersome process of acquiring donated eggs and embryos.
While the skin cell discovery has been hailed as a major breakthrough, many scientists
caution that these new cells are not yet ready for therapeutic use. For instance, the
virus used to coax regular cells into pluripotent stem cells could lead to cellular
mutations that could, in turn, cause cancer in patients. Furthermore, Thomson and
others contend that this possible breakthrough has by no means eliminated the need for
continued research on embryonic stem cells, at least for now. Adult stem cells that have
been altered to what appear to be pluripotent cells need to be tested in comparison with
human embryonic cells, researchers say, to determine whether they do, indeed, have
the same pluripotent qualities.
Tracy also studied In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF) at Kings College Hospital in London
in 1995. In 1997, she underwent training on ICSI (intracytoplasmic sperm injection)
manipulation technology at the Reproductive Medicine Laboratory at Queen Elizabeth
Hospital in Adelaide, Australia; and Brussels, Belgium. Developed in 1992, ICSI is a
new fertility technology that specifically helps improve male fertility.
The key to helping couples conceive, Tracy related, is positive thinking. Also,
physical and emotional stress brings negative effects on fertility.
She advises couples who have difficulty getting pregnant after a year of natural
intercourse, to come forward and seek treatment. Tracy provides free counseling to
couples. This way, questions are answered clearly before they decide to undergo any
assisted reproductive technique (A.R.T.).
Victory A.R.T. Lab features state-of-the-art facilities, rivaling those found abroad.
That’s why couples need not travel overseas to seek A.R.T. procedures or IVF
anymore. A core team of specialists provides quality service that patients are treated
with utmost respect and privacy to make them feel comfortable while undergoing the
process.
Intra-Uterine Insemination (IUI)
For IUI, sperm are first washed and placed into a sterile medium. The sperm are then concentrated
in a small volume of medium and are injected directly
Definition
Intra-uterine Insemination (IUI) is the placement of sperm directly into the uterus of the
woman, bypassing the cervix.
Indications
This procedure is performed for patients with a cervical factor (cervicitis, cervical
stenosis, inadequate mucus or hostile mucus), unexplained infertility, male factor
infertility or immunological infertility.
Procedure
The female's ovaries are stimulated hormonally to produce follicles containing the eggs.
An ultrasound scan is performed to determine the number and size of the follicles and
also the thickness of the endometrium, lining the uterus, to see whether it is ready for
implantation. Also, blood hormone levels will be measured. Ovulation will be induced
by an injection of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG), and the egg will be released
36-48hr later. The male partner's semen is processed to select the highest quality
sperm. The physician will then inject this sperm via a catheter through the vagina and
cervix, into the uterus.
Therapeutic Insemination with Donor Sperm (TID)
Through the process IUI, sperm are placed high in the female reproductive tract to enhance the
chance of successful fertilization.
Definition
TID is the placement of donor sperm directly into the uterus of the patient.
Indications
In cases of severe male factor infertility, i.e., very low sperm count and/or motility, or no
sperm at all, TID may be indicated. TID may also be used if the male partner carries a
genetic disorder.
Procedure
The procedure is the same as for IUI, but with the use of donor sperm. Donor sperm are
frozen and stored for 6 months, to enable adequate screening and help prevent
communicable diseases from being transmitted. Frozen donor sperm will be thawed
and processed to isolate the highest quality sperm and then placed directly into the
uterus via a catheter.
In-Vitro Fertilization (IVF)
Definition
In-vitro fertilization (IVF) is the process whereby the female partner's ovaries are
stimulated to produce eggs. These are then removed and placed together with her
partner's sperm in a petri dish and allowed to fertilize. The resulting embryos are then
transferred into her uterus after 2-3 days.
Indications
IVF is used in cases of tubal blockage, male factor infertility or previously failed IUI
cycles.
Procedure
The oocytes will be retrieved via transvaginal ultrasound. Ultrasound allows the
physician to visualize the follicles and can then push a needle into each of them and
aspirate the fluid inside the follicle containing the oocyte. The follicular fluid is examined
by laboratory personnel for the presence of the egg and if found, is placed in an
incubator. This is done for all the follicles. At the time of oocyte retrieval or immediately
thereafter, the male partner's perm will be processed to isolate the highest quality
sperm. Approximately 5hrs after the oocyte retrieval, the oocytes and sperm are put
together in a petri dish and placed in an incubator.
The next day, the oocytes are observed to see whether normal fertilization has
occurred. The fertilized oocytes are then left in the incubator to develop into embryos.
After 2-3days after oocyte retrieval, the embryos are transferred into the uterus of the
woman using a special catheter. Hormonal treatments are given for the following 3
weeks, after which a pregnancy test is scheduled. Any excess embryos not
transferred may be cryopreserved for later use.
Embryo transfer
Embryo transfer refers to a step in the process of in vitro fertilization (IVF) whereby
one or several embryos are placed into the uterus of the female with the intent to
establish a pregnancy.
Embryos can be either "fresh" from fertilized egg cells of the same menstrual cycle, or
"frozen", that is they have been generated in a preceding cycle, cryopreserved - see
Controlled-Rate and Slow Freezing in Cryopreservation, - and are thawed just prior to
the transfer. Babies born from frozen IVF embryos are less likely to be born prematurely
or underweight than are those conceived during fresh treatment cycles, three
independent teams of scientists have found. One of the studies also recorded lower
rates of stillbirth and early death among frozen-embryo babies. The results, from
researchers based in the United States, Australia and Finland, suggest that far from
being riskier than conventional IVF, as is generally thought, cycles using frozen
embryos may actually be safer, Mark Henderson of the Times London reported in
November 2008.
Gamete Intra-Fallopian Transfer (GIFT)
Definition
GIFT is the direct placement of eggs and sperm into the fallopian tube.
Indications
Procedure
The oocytes/eggs are removed from the woman's ovaries and the sperm is processed
in the same manner as for IVF. The difference is that instead of allowing the oocytes to
be fertilized in a petri dish, the sperm and up to 3 eggs are injected directly into the
fallopian tube and allowed to fertilize there. Hormones are given for the next 2 weeks to
help maintain a pregnancy. Any extra eggs may be fertilized in vitro (IVF),
cryopreserved, or donated.
Definition
The process whereby a single sperm is injected directly into the cytoplasm of the egg.
Indications
ICSI is the method of choice for patients with severe male factor infertility, and for
patients who have had previously failed or poor fertilization resulting from conventional
IVF.
Procedure
The eggs are retrieved from the woman's ovaries in the same way as for IVF. The eggs
are then stripped of all surrounding cells and placed in a droplet and the male partner's
sperm placed in another droplet. The sperm can be obtained via ejaculation or in severe
cases, directly from the testis or epididymis using microsurgical sperm retrieval
techniques.
The fertilized eggs are then allowed to develop for another 24-48hr, after which they are
transferred into the uterus via a thin catheter. Hormonal treatment to help maintain a
pregnancy is given for the next 2 weeks.
Definition
MESA is the retrieval of sperm from the epididymis by means of aspiration. TESE is the
retrieval of sperm from the testis by means of testicular biopsy. ROSI is the injection of
round spermatid (immature spermatozoa) when no mature sperm can be found in the
testis.
Indications
When sperm are unable to move through the genital tract due to uncorrectable damage,
sperm can be extracted directly from the epididymis or testes via microsurgical
techniques. Congenital absence of the vas deferens (CAVD) or failed sterilization
reversal are other indications.
Procedure
Around the time that the woman has her eggs retrieved, the husband/male partner will
undergo a surgical procedure that will either take a very small piece of testicular tissue
(TESE) or aspirate the fluid from the epididymis (MESA). For TESE/MESA the
testicular tissue/epididymal fluid will be examined for the presence of sperm cells.
These can then be injected into the oocyte via ICSI. In cases where no sperm are seen,
round spermatids (immature sperm seen on right) can be used for ICSI (ROSI).
We at the Kentucky Center for Reproductive Medicine and IVF in cooperation with the
Andrology Institute of America and Dr. Zavos, along with other Scientists and
Physicians from Japan, Greece and France, have been successful in developing and
employing the new ROSI Technique. This method enables the micro-injection of round
spermatids (immature spermatozoa), recovered from the testes or from post-ejaculated
fractions into retrieved oocytes via ICSI techniques and achievement of fertilization and
pregnancies. This technique will assist a great number of azoospermic males with
round "spermatid-type" arrest in their testes and other male infertility patients with other
severe spermatogenic deficiencies to achieve pregnancies, throughout the World.
Definition
The process of preserving sperm by means of freezing for use at a later time.
Indications
Sperm can be cryopreserved in cases where the male might have difficulty in producing
a specimen at a given time. If sperm were retrieved microsurgically, excess sperm may
be stored to avoid having to repeat the invasive surgical procedure. Also, for patients
planning to undergo chemotherapy or radiotherapy (for cancer), sperm may be
cryopreserved as the therapy may diminish their sperm production. Sperm can also be
frozen for persons wishing to donate their sperm to infertile couples.
Procedure
Definition
The process of preserving sperm by means of freezing for use at a later time.
Indications
Sperm can be cryopreserved in cases where the male might have difficulty in producing
a specimen at a given time. If sperm were retrieved microsurgically, excess sperm may
be stored to avoid having to repeat the invasive surgical procedure. Also, for patients
planning to undergo chemotherapy or radiotherapy (for cancer), sperm may be
cryopreserved as the therapy may diminish their sperm production. Sperm can also be
frozen for persons wishing to donate their sperm to infertile couples.
Procedure
Definition
The process of storing embryos by means of freezing in liquid nitrogen for use at a later
time.
Indications
When excess embryos are present after an embryo transfer, these can be frozen and
then transferred in subsequent cycles, if the patient does not become pregnant. This
would save her from undergoing another oocyte retrieval procedure. She may also elect
to have her embryos donated to another infertile couple.
Procedure
Excess embryos are place with a cryoprotectant and aspirated into cryostraws, and then
gradually frozen to a temperature of -196°C, and placed in liquid nitrogen. Storage can
be indefinite but KCRM requires written approval/consent from the parents every 3
years.
When the patient wants to transfer embryos that are in cryostorage, these can be
thawed prior to or on the day of transfer, assessed for survival and development, and
then transferred.
Assisted Hatching
Definition
Assisted hatching is the opening of the zona pellucida , surrounding the embryo, to help
the embryo/blastocyst "hatch" or emerge from the zona and implant in the uterus.
Indications
Assisted hatching is usually indicated in older women, and those with failed implantation
in previous cycles.
Procedure
Prior to embryo transfer, a small opening is made in the zona pellucida using
microdissection tools. The embryos are then transferred normally.