Food
Classic Chemical Demonstrations 185
185
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Timing
About 1 h.
Level
Pre-16.
Description
The reactions of lithium, sodium and potassium with air, water and chlorine are
demonstrated along with some of the physical properties of the metals: density,
softness and melting temperatures.
Apparatus
▼ Three gas jars with lids.
▼ Three glass troughs of capacity about 5 dm3. (It is possible to manage with just
one.)
▼ Sheet of glass or perspex to act as a lid to cover the troughs.
▼ Filter paper.
▼ Three tin lids – for example the lids from old sweet tins. Ensure that any plastic
seals have been removed from inside the rims and that any paint has also been
removed. This can be done by heating strongly in a fume cupboard. Clean the
lids with emery paper.
▼ Three petri dishes with lids.
▼ Scalpel or other sharp knife.
▼ Tweezers.
▼ Three deflagrating spoons.
▼ Circuit board (or similar) with batteries, leads and bulb to show electrical
conduction.
▼ Disposable plastic gloves.
▼ Three boiling tubes.
▼ Wooden spills.
▼ Bunsen burner.
▼ Heat-proof mat.
▼ Safety screen.
If the chlorine is to be generated chemically:
▼ One 250 cm3 conical flask with a two holed stopper to fit.
▼ A tap funnel.
▼ One piece of glass tubing with a right angled bend.
▼ Access to fume cupboard.
186 Classic Chemical Demonstrations
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Chemicals
The quantities given are for one demonstration.
▼ One piece of lithium, sodium and potassium, each about 1 cm3 in volume.
These are stored under paraffin oil.
▼ Access to a source of chlorine – either a cylinder or a chemical generator (use
a tap funnel to drip concentrated hydrochloric acid onto solid potassium
manganate(VII) (potassium permanganate)). If chlorine generated chemically is
to be used, about 10 g of potassium manganate(VII) (potassium permanganate,
KMnO4) and 100 cm3 of concentrated hydrochloric acid will be needed.
▼ Universal indicator solution and paper with appropriate colour charts.
▼ A few cm3 of hexane or other solvent for the paraffin oil.
Method
Before the demonstration
Working in a fume cupboard, fill the three gas jars with chlorine by upward
displacement of air and close each one with a lightly greased lid. The contents of the
jars should be noticeably green. Well sealed jars will keep for a few hours.
Set up a series circuit consisting of a bulb, suitable number of batteries and two
flying leads to be used to test electrical conductivity. A circuit board is a convenient
way to do this.
The demonstration
This is in four parts: physical properties; heating in air; reaction with chlorine; and
reaction with water. It is suggested that each of these is done for all three metals in
the above order so that the metals can be compared easily in each category and so
that the demonstration builds up to a climax. Within each part, do the metals in the
order lithium, sodium, potassium to stress the Periodic Table order and also to leave
the most reactive until last.
1. Physical properties
Do the following for each metal:
Using tweezers remove a piece about 5 mm x 5 mm x 5 mm from the paraffin oil
(explaining why it is stored in this way and pointing out that lithium floats on the oil).
Do not bother to remove the oil at this stage as a thin film will continue to protect the
metal. Wearing plastic gloves, cut off a small piece (which can be used later) to
demonstrate the ease with which the metals can be cut. Point out the differences in
ease of cutting between the metals themselves and compare them with a more typical
metal such as iron. All three alkali metals can be cut with a sharp knife, lithium being
the hardest and potassium being the softest. At this point is also possible to show that
potassium can be moulded easily by squeezing between gloved fingers, sodium is
harder to mould and lithium can barely be moulded at all. If desired, place a piece of
each metal in a petri dish and pass it round the class for the students to look at
closely and to feel its lightness. Warn the class not to touch the metals and tape the
lids closed if you have any doubts about their reliability.
Drop each metal from a height of a few cm onto the bench; the gentle impacts
indicate their low density. Compare with a similar sized piece of a typical metal such
as iron. If desired, each metal could be weighed to give a very rough estimate of
density, again comparing with a similar sized lump of, say, iron.
Use the circuit board to show that each metal conducts electricity well.
1. Food
Classic Chemical Demonstrations 187
187
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Piece of alkali
metal about half
Tin lid the size of a pea
2. Heating in air
Do the following for each metal:
Cut a piece about 2 mm x 2 mm. Show how shiny the freshly cut face is and how
rapidly it tarnishes. It may be necessary to do this two or three times to small groups
of the class as it will be difficult to see from a distance. Using tweezers, rinse the
piece in hexane to remove the oil and wave it around in the air to dry. Place it on an
inverted tin lid standing on a heatproof mat and heat from above with a roaring
Bunsen flame using the part of the flame about 1 cm beyond the tip of the blue cone
(Fig. 1). Point out that the metal melts into a ball and begins to burn. Potassium will
melt most rapidly and lithium will take longest to melt. Remove the Bunsen burner
and allow the metal to burn away and note the colours of the flames – red for
lithium, orange for sodium and lilac for potassium. Note the greyish colour of the
residue and, when it is cool, test the residue by touching it with moist indicator
paper. It will be very alkaline. There will not appear to be a great deal of difference in
reactivity between the metals in this reaction.
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Whichever method is used, it will be possible to see that the order of reactivity is
potassium > sodium > lithium.
Visual tips
The reaction with water can be demonstrated on an OHP. Place the trough on the
OHP and focus on a matchstick floating on the water. Remove the matchstick and
add a few drops of suitable indicator (universal indicator, or another indicator
familiar to the students). If necessary, add a few drops of dilute acid so that the
indicator is in its acid form. Drop in the metal and the fizzing will be seen, as well as
trails of colour which form behind the metals as they float around. These trails will be
in the alkaline colour of the indicator.
Teaching tips
Younger students might enjoy writing a mock newspaper account of the
consequences of reacting francium with water (if it was possible to obtain enough of
it).
In each case, there is sufficient information to identify the products of the reaction
and it can be a useful exercise to build up word and then balanced symbol equations
with the students.
It is a good idea if students have ready a prepared table in which to fill in their
observations as they watch the demonstration.
A data book exercise could be set in which the students look up and tabulate data
such as density and melting point to support the estimates made in the
demonstration. They could plot graphs of the data to show up trends.
Theory
The reactions are as follows (using M to represent any of the alkali metals).
With oxygen:
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Conc HCl
Gas jar
KMnO4
Heat
In the case of sodium, some peroxide (Na2O2) will also be formed and in the case of
potassium and other Group I metals, superoxides (MO2) will be formed too.
Superoxides are unusual for compounds of Group I elements because they are
coloured. They are more likely to form with the larger Group I metal ions since there
is more room for the large superoxide ion in the crystal lattice.
With chlorine:
With water:
The usual explanation given for the reactivity of Group I metals increasing on
going down the Group is that the outer electron is further away from the nucleus and
is therefore more easily removed (ie that the first ionisation energy gets lower). This is
true, but it is only one of many factors involved in determining ∆H for the reactions.
It should also be remembered that what is being observed in these reactions is often
related to the rate of the reaction while the ionisation energy is related to ∆H. These
two parameters are not linked except that a strongly exothermic reaction, once
started, will give out heat which will then speed up the reaction. The clearly
observed relationship between position in the Group and reactivity is therefore partly
fortuitous.
Extensions
Videos are available that show the reactions of alkali metals including those of
rubidium and caesium with water, for example Elements organised from the Open
University. One of these could be shown after the demonstration to reinforce the
reactivity trend. The reaction of caesium with water is violent enough to shatter the
trough.
190 Classic Chemical Demonstrations
THE ROYAL
SOCIETY OF
CHEMISTRY
Further details
One teacher reports that adding a few drops of washing up liquid to the water
prevents the metal piece sticking to the side of the trough when the reactions with
water are being shown.
For more details about the reactions of alkali metals and a discussion of safety
issues, see the article entitled ‘The exploding metals’ by Gareth D John in Sch. Sci.
Rev., 1980, 62 (219), 279.
Safety
Wear eye protection.
The alkali metals are flammable solids that react with water to produce alkaline
solutions and hydrogen. Excess metals should be disposed of by reacting with
propan-2-ol (isopropanol).
It is the responsibility of teachers doing this demonstration to carry out an
appropriate risk assessment.