BALANCE OF PAYMENTS
AND ITS ASSOCIATED FACTORS
IN LIGHT OF
PAKISTAN ECONOMY
Submitted by:
Submitted to:
1
LETTER OF ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
23 August 2008
Dear Sir,
It is acknowledged that this report on ‘Balance Of Payments And Its Associated Factors In
Light Of Pakistan Economy’ is compiled under the guidance of Mr. Najam Altaf who
imparted upon us the basic understanding of the subject and its minor intricacies which
are the basis for the compilation of this report.
Furthermore, the assistance provided by the State Bank of Pakistan website is also a
great source for the authenticity of the data compilation for analysis.
Sincerely
i
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
23 August 2008
Dear Sir,
It is submitted that this report on ‘Balance of Payments And Its Associated Factors In
Light Of Pakistan Economy’ is compiled as per the instructions of our teacher Mr. Najam
Altaf as a term report.
Sincerely
ii
Macroeconomics Term Report
Balance of Payments and its Associated Factors in light of Pakistan Economy
Table of Contents
Executive Summary...................................................................iv
1. Balance of payments...............................................................1
0.1 IMF definition...........................................................................................................................1
2. Components of BOP...............................................................1
2.1 Current account....................................................................1
2.1.1 Components of Current Account..........................................................................................2
2.1.1.1 Balance of Trade............................................................................................................2
2.1.1.2 Income Account.............................................................................................................2
2.1.1.3 Unilateral Transfers.......................................................................................................2
2.1.2 Reducing current account deficits.........................................................................................3
2.2 Capital account......................................................................3
2.3 Financial account..................................................................4
3. Balance of Payment Equilibrium..........................................4
4. Balance of trade.......................................................................5
4.1 Factors affecting Balance of Trade..........................................................................................5
5. Exchange rate..........................................................................6
5.1 Free or pegged Exchange rate..................................................................................................6
5.2 Relationship With Balance of Payments..................................................................................6
6. Foreign Exchange Reserves...................................................6
6.1 Relationship with exchange rate..............................................................................................7
7. Pakistan’s Balance of Payments............................................7
7.1 Current Account Situation of Pakistan....................................................................................7
7.1.1 Balance of Trade...............................................................................................................8
7.1.2 Net Factor Income from Abroad.......................................................................................8
7.2 Capital Account Situation of Pakistan.....................................................................................9
7.3 Performance of Other Factors related to BOP of Pakistan
10
7.3.1 Exchange Rate....................................................................................................................10
7.3.1.1 Affect of exchange rate on Exports/Imports................................................................10
7.3.1.2 Conclusion of Analysis................................................................................................11
8. Comparison of Pakistan’s BOP with India and China.....12
8.1 China:.....................................................................................................................................12
8.2 India:......................................................................................................................................13
8.3 Pakistan:.................................................................................................................................13
9. Conclusion.............................................................................13
Pakistan's Balance of Payments............................................17
1 Pakistan's Balance of Payments..........................................21
Executive Summary
In this report we will discuss the concept of balance of payments in detail. The contributing factors
of balance of payments such as Current Account, Capital Account, Trade Balance, Exchange Rate,
Foreign Exchange Reserves, Foreign Investments etc. will also be discussed in details.
An analysis of the existing state of Pakistan’s Balance of payments will be done in order to find
out the current situation of Pakistan’s balance of payments problems and its associated factors.
The source of data in this report are the websites of State Bank of Pakistan, IMF, Wikipedia,
Reserve Bank of India, Central Bank of China and the BOP manual of IMF.
We will also analyze the relation of Pakistan’s growth and exchange rate with its balance of
payments by analyzing the data of last three years.
A comparison with two of the regional economies i.e. China and India will also be drawn to find
out the gap that is existing between the economy of Pakistan and the economies of these two
countries.
In the end we conclude the report with the salient points being analyzed about the Pakistan’s
balance of payments along with some suggestions.
1.Balance of payments
In economics, the balance of payments, (or BOP) measures the payments that flow between any
individual country and all other countries. It is used to summarize all international economic
transactions for that country during a specific time period, usually a year. The BOP is determined
by the country's exports and imports of goods, services, and financial capital, as well as financial
transfers. It reflects all payments and liabilities to foreigners (debits) and all payments and
obligations received from foreigners (credits). Balance of payments is one of the major indicators
of a country's status in international trade, with net capital outflow.
The balance, like other accounting statements, is prepared in a single currency, usually the
domestic. Foreign assets and flows are valued at the exchange rate of the time of transaction.
The IMF definition: "The balance of payments is a statistical statement that summarizes
transactions between residents and nonresidents during a period."[1] The balance of payments
comprises the current account, the capital account, and the financial account. "Together, these
accounts balance in the sense the sum of the entries is conceptually zero."[1]
• The current account consists of the goods and services account, the primary income
account and the secondary income account.
• The financial account records transactions that involve financial assets and liabilities and
that take place between residents and nonresidents.
• The capital account in the international accounts shows (1) capital transfers receivable and
payable; and (2) the acquisition and disposal of nonproduced nonfinancial assets.
2.Components of BOP
The Balance of Payments for a country is the sum of the current account, the capital account,
the financial account.
Page 1 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
The current account balance is one of two major metrics of the nature of a country's foreign trade
(the other being the net capital outflow). A current account surplus increases a country's net
foreign assets by the corresponding amount, and a current account deficit does the reverse. Both
government and private payments are included in the calculation.
The balance of trade is typically the most important part of the current account. This means that
changes in the patterns of trade are key drivers in the current accounts of most of the world's
economies. However, for the few countries with substantial overseas assets or liabilities, net factor
payments may be significant.
Positive net sales to abroad generally contributes to a current account surplus; negative net sales to
abroad generally contributes to a current account deficit. Because exports generate positive net
sales, and because the trade balance is typically the largest component of the current account, a
current account surplus is usually associated with positive net exports. The net factor income or
income account, a sub-account of the current account, is usually presented under the headings
income payments as outflows, and income receipts as inflows. Income refers not only to the money
received from investments made abroad (note: investments are recorded in the capital account but
income from investments is recorded in the current account) but also to the money sent by
individuals working abroad, known as remittances, to their families back home. If the income
account is negative, the country is paying more than it is taking in interest, dividends, etc. For
example, the United States' net income has been declining exponentially since it has allowed the
dollar's price relative to other currencies to be determined by the market to a point where income
payments and receipts are roughly equal. The difference between Canada's income payments and
receipts have been declining exponentially as well since its central bank in 1998 began its strict
policy not to intervene in the Canadian Dollar's foreign exchange. The various subcategories in the
income account are linked to specific respective subcategories in the capital account, as income is
often composed of factor payments from the ownership of capital (assets) or the negative capital
(debts) abroad. From the capital account, economists and central banks determine implied rates of
return on the different types of capital. The United States, for example, gleans a substantially
larger rate of return from foreign capital than foreigners do from owning United States capital.
The income account accounts mostly for investment income from dividends and interest on credit
and payments on foreign taxes.
Strangely, the net of the income account of the United States has been negligible as a percentage of
total debits or credits for decades, an extremely outlying instance.
Unilateral transfers are usually conducted between private parties. For example, Mexico has a
large surplus of remittances from the United States sent by emigrant workers to loved ones back
home. India has the world's largest surplus of remittances.
Page 2 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
Action to reduce a substantial current account deficit usually involves increasing exports or
decreasing imports. This is generally accomplished directly through import restrictions, quotas, or
duties (though these may indirectly limit exports as well), or subsidizing exports. Influencing the
exchange rate to make exports cheaper for foreign buyers will indirectly increase the balance of
payments. This can be accomplished by increasing domestic inflation (e.g. by cutting interest
rates), loosening monetary policy (making more money available), or adjusting government
spending to favor domestic suppliers.
Less obvious but more effective methods to reduce a current account deficit include measures that
increase domestic savings (or reduced domestic borrowing), including a reduction in borrowing by
the national government.
The capital account records all transactions between a domestic and foreign resident that involves
a change of ownership of an asset. It is the net result of public and private international investment
flowing in and out of a country. This includes foreign direct investment, portfolio investment (such
as changes in holdings of stocks and bonds) and other investments (such as changes in holdings in
loans, bank accounts, and currencies).
From a domestic point of view, a foreign investor acquiring a domestic asset is considered a capital
inflow, while a domestic resident acquiring a foreign asset is considered a capital outflow.
Along with transactions pertaining to non-financial and non-produced assets, the capital account
may also include debt forgiveness, the transfer of goods and financial assets by migrants leaving or
entering a country, the transfer of ownership on fixed assets, the transfer of funds received to the
sale or acquisition of fixed assets, gift and inheritance taxes, death levies, patents, copyrights,
royalties, and uninsured damage to fixed assets.
(http://www.investopedia.com/articles/03/070203.asp).
Countries can impose capital controls to control the flows into and out of their capital accounts.
Countries without capital controls are said to have full capital account convertibility.
Page 3 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
The accounting entries in the financial account record the purchase and sale of domestic and
foreign investment assets. These assets are divided into categories such as foreign direct
investment (FDI), portfolio investment (which includes trade in stocks and bonds), and other
investment (which includes transactions in currency and bank deposits).
If foreign ownership of domestic financial assets has increased more quickly than domestic
ownership of foreign assets in a given year, then the domestic country has a financial account
surplus. On the other hand, if domestic ownership of foreign financial assets has increased more
quickly than foreign ownership of domestic assets, then the domestic country has a financial
account deficit.
The United States persistently has the largest capital (and financial) surplus in the world.
The United States receives roughly twice the rate of return on all foreign investment than domestic
investment by foreigners.
This is a condition where there are no changes in Official Reserves. When there is no change in
Official Reserves, the balance of payments may also be stated as follows:
or:
Page 4 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
Canada's Balance of Payments currently satisfies this criterion. It is the only large monetary
authority with no Changes in Reserves.
4.Balance of trade
The balance of trade forms part of the current account, which also includes other transactions such
as income from the international investment position as well as international aid. If the current
account is in surplus, the country's net international asset position increases correspondingly.
Equally, a deficit decreases the net international asset position.
The trade balance is identical to the difference between a country's output and its domestic demand
(the difference between what goods a country produces and how many goods it buys from abroad;
this does not include money re-spent on foreign stocks, nor does it factor the concept of importing
goods to produce for the domestic market).
Measuring the balance of payments can be problematic because of problems with recording and
collecting data. As an illustration of this problem, when official data for all the world's countries
are added up, exports exceed imports by a few percent; it appears the world is running a positive
balance of trade with itself. This cannot be true, because all transactions involve an equal credit or
debit in the account of each nation. The discrepancy is widely believed to be explained by
transactions intended to launder money or evade taxes, smuggling and other visibility problems.
However, especially for developed countries, accuracy is likely.
The balance of trade is likely to differ across the business cycle. In export led growth (such as oil
and early industrial goods), the balance of trade will improve during an economic expansion.
However, with domestic demand led growth (as in the United States and Australia) the trade
balance will worsen at the same stage in the business cycle.
Strong GDP growth economies such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia and
Hong Kong run consistent trade deficits, as well as poorer countries also experiencing a lot of
investment.
Developed nations such as Canada, Japan, and Germany typically run trade surpluses. China also
has a trade surplus. A higher savings rate generally corresponds with a trade surplus.
Correspondingly, the United States with its negative savings rate consistently has high trade
deficits.
Page 5 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
5.Exchange rate
In finance, the exchange rates (also known as the foreign-exchange rate, forex rate or FX rate)
between two currencies specifies how much one currency is worth in terms of the other. For
example an exchange rate of 102 Japanese yen (JPY, ¥) to the United States dollar (USD, $) means
that JPY 102 is worth the same as USD 1. The foreign exchange market is one of the largest
markets in the world. By some estimates, about 2 trillion USD worth of currency changes hands
every day.
The spot exchange rate refers to the current exchange rate. The forward exchange rate refers to
an exchange rate that is quoted and traded today but for delivery and payment on a specific future
date.
If a currency is free-floating, its exchange rate is allowed to vary against that of other currencies
and is determined by the market forces of supply and demand. Exchange rates for such currencies
are likely to change almost constantly as quoted on financial markets, mainly by banks, around the
world. A movable or adjustable peg system is a system of fixed exchange rates, but with a
provision for the devaluation of a currency. For example, between 1994 and 2005, the Chinese
yuan renminbi (RMB) was pegged to the United States dollar at RMB 8.2768 to $1. China was not
the only country to do this; from the end of World War II until 1966, Western European countries
all maintained fixed exchange rates with the US dollar based on the Bretton Woods system.
The foreign exchange rate must be at its equilibrium level - the rate which produces a stable
current account balance. A nation with a trade deficit will experience reduction in its foreign
exchange reserves which ultimately lowers (depreciates) the value of its currency. The cheaper
currency renders the nation's goods (exports) more affordable in the global market place while
making imports more expensive. After an intermediate period, imports are forced down and
exports rise, thus stabilizing the trade balance and the currency towards equilibrium.
Page 6 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
In a non fixed exchange rate system, reserves allow a central bank to purchase the issued currency,
exchanging its assets to reduce its liability. The purpose of reserves is to allow central banks an
additional means to stabilise the issued currency from excessive volatility, and protect the
monetary system from shock, such as from currency traders engaged in flipping. Large reserves
are often seen as a strength, as it indicates the backing a currency has. Low or falling reserves may
be indicative of an imminent bank run on the currency or default, such as in a currency crisis.
Central banks sometimes claim that holding large reserves is a security measure. This is true to the
extent that a central bank can prop up its own currency by spending reserves.
A central bank that implements a fixed exchange rate policy may face a situation where supply and
demand would tend to push the value of the currency lower or higher (an increase in demand for
the currency would tend to push its value higher, and a decrease lower). In a fixed exchange rate
regime, these operations occur automatically, with the central bank clearing any excess demand or
supply by purchasing or selling the foreign currency. Mixed exchange rate regimes ('dirty floats',
target bands or similar variations) may require the use of foreign exchange operations (sterilized or
unspecialized) to maintain the targeted exchange rate within the prescribed limits.
Where,
Current Account = Balance of Trade + Net Factor Income from Abroad + Net unilateral Transfers
from Abroad.
This clearly shows that Pakistan is having a consistent current account deficit. Now we will look at
the performance of factors affecting this imbalance.
Page 7 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
The balance of trade for Pakistan is one of the main factor for the current account imbalance. The
same is appended below:
The above table clearly shows that the exports of Pakistan are not increased at a pace comparable
to its imports. Therefore, the imbalance of trade has rapidly increased in the last 3 years where the
last year is the worst for the balance of trade. This has a very severe impact on the current account.
This situation requires the govt. to take actions to improve exports and reduce the exports to curtail
this increasing trend in trade imbalance.
Now we analyze the trend of Net Factor Income from Abroad which is the main source to stabilize
the current account. This include income from direct investments as well as income from portfolio
investments:
Although the figures of Q4 of 07-08 are not available but still we can easily say that the deficit in
Net Factor Income from Abroad is not going to be less than the previous year. This shows that The
income foreign firms are getting from their investments (both Direct and Portfolio) in Pakistan are
much higher then the Pakistani firms get from their investments abroad.
This also indicates the flight of capital from Pakistan through these multinationals and investors.
The stock market crisis of 2005 is also one such example.
Page 8 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
The remittances from expatriates is a major component of current transfers which is the major
source of stabilization of current account of Pakistan. Following is the status of the same for the
last three years:
This indicates that it is the only stabilizing sector for the current account balance. The trend also
shows that the remittance are increasing which is very helpful for the country’s economy.
The capital account situation of Pakistan for the last three years is appended below:
This is a major factor for the current account of a country. FDI have played a major role in the
economy of Pakistan. The trend of FDI for the last three years is appended below:
The above table clearly shows that the FDI for the 07-08 will be less than that of the previous year
because of the poor law and order situation of Pakistan which is a caution sign for Pakistan’s
economy.
Page 9 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
This is also a major component of capital account but it is not good for the economy because it is
not long term and can fly very rapidly. The trend of last three years is appended below:
FDI Inflow FDI Outflow Net
2005-06 US $ 986 million US $ - million US $ 986 million
2006-07 US $ 3301 million US $ 18 million US $ 3283 million
2007-08 (US $ 55 million)
(Jul – Mar)
The table clearly shows that the portfolio investment can be very un-predictable. It can be flown
out very easily. The reason for the lower value of 05-06 is the stock market crisis of 2005. The
performance of portfolio investments for the year 07-08 is negative because of volatile law and
order and political uncertainty.
The trend of exchange rate for last 5 years of Pak Rupee to US $ is appended below:
The above mentioned table clearly shows that there is a gradual decline in the value of Pak Rupee.
Now we analyze that whether the decline in the exchange rate has any affect on the imports and
exports of Pakistan.
As a rule it should have a negative impact on imports and a positive impact on exports. We will
analyze the trend of exports and imports of the last four years. The same are appended below:
Exports
Imports
Page 10 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
US $ million
The above data indicates that the trend of both the imports and exports is that of increasing.
Whereas the imports are increasing more rapidly than exports.
In order to conclude on any statement regarding the affect of exchange rate reduction on the
balance of payment we must have to see the base of Pakistan’s imports and exports.
Export Base
The export base of Pakistan can be easily divided into three broad categories:
a. Textile Products includes raw cotton, cotton yarn, nit wear, bead wear etc.
b. Agriculture include rice, sugar, fruits, vegetables, dairy products etc.
c. Manufacturing includes sports goods, leather goods, surgical goods etc.
The contribution of each category for the last three years is appended below:
Import Base
a. Petroleum Products
b. Food items includes tea, pulses, palm oil, spices etc.
c. Machinery includes power plants, textile machinery, CNC machines etc.
d. Motor Vehicles includes cars, buses, ships, air crafts and their spares etc.
e. Agro-chemicals includes fertilizers, insecticides etc.
f. Metals includes iron/steel products, Aluminum sheets etc.
The contribution of these products for the last three years is appended below:
From the above figures we can easily conclude that the export base of Pakistan is highly dependent
on agriculture and manufacturing sectors whose inputs are petroleum, machinery, chemicals,
metals.
Page 11 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
Therefore, if the exchange rate of Pakistan was decreased that will also increase the cost of
imported raw materials which will indirectly increase the cost of output products. So the
impact on exports in case of decrease in exchange rate is minimal.
Furthermore, we can see that more than 80% of Pakistan’s exports are of essential goods
which are directly or indirectly related to the production. If the exchange rate is decreased
than in that case the prices of essential goods like petroleum, chemicals, edible oil etc. will
increase which will not only affect the growth but also affect the export goods indirectly.
Intern. reserves (excl. gold) USD bn 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
China 618.20 825.70 1072.60 1530.30 1959.50
India 136.50 145.90 192.40 299.60 358.40
Pakistan 10.60 9.80 10.80 13.30 10.16
1190.00
990.00 China
790.00 China
590.00 India
Curre
390.00 India
190.00 Pakistan Pakistan
-10.00
08
04
05
06
07
20
20
20
20
20
8.1 China:
• China's current accounts surplus is nearly 10% of GDP.
• This surplus is entirely due to its trade surplus of $281 billion.
• It is argued by many, that the Chinese Yuan is undervalued making Chinese exports relatively more
competitive and cheaper. This is a significant factor in making the terms of trade favor a surplus.
11.00 Page 12 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
• China's elastic supply of labor has enabled wage rates to remain low, giving China an advantage in
the producing goods at a low cost.
• Despite the high rates of Chinese growth. The Chinese economy has a very high savings rate of
40%.
• This means consumers are saving rather than spending on foreign imports. Rather than buy
consumer goods, the Chinese prefer to invest in foreign securities. E.g. buy US securities and
bonds.
• This outflow of Capital has financed the US current account deficit; in the process China has built
up an impressive amount of external assets.
• China finance more than 50% of USA $ 800 billion current account deficit (6.2% of GDP)
8.2 India:
• Since independence, India's balance of payments on its current account has been negative.
• Since liberalization in the 1990s (precipitated by a balance of payment crisis), India's exports have
been consistently rising, covering 80.3% of its imports in 2002–03, up from 66.2% in 1990–91.
• Although India is still a net importer, since 1996–97, its overall balance of payments (i.e., including
the capital account balance), has been positive, largely on account of increased foreign direct
investment and deposits from non-resident Indians.
• As a result, India's foreign currency reserves stood at $360 billion in 2008, which can be used in
infrastructural development of the country if used effectively.
8.3 Pakistan:
• Unprecedented rise in the prices of oil and food items have contributed to the widening of both
trade and current account deficits.
• The current account deficit during the fiscal year amounted to $ 12 billion – up by 78 percent over
period last year.
• The impact of the rising current account deficit on the country’s overall balance of payments was
further compounded due to a decline in financial and capital account flows on account of a drop in
net portfolio investment, delays in the planned floatation of a sovereign bond and Global
Depository receipts (GDRs) and putting on hold the floatation of an Exchangeable Bond.
• These developments, along with imports of wheat and fertilizer, worsened the trade deficit as well
as current account deficit.
• Accordingly, the overall balance of payments is in deficit which is partly financed through reserves
draw-down.
• Even when compared to the size of the economy, the current account deficit was substantially high
at 6.9 percent of GDP during Jul-April FY08 as against 4.6 percent for the same period last year.
9.Conclusion
From the above mentioned analysis following points can be concluded about the balance of
payment problems of Pakistan:
a. Pakistan’s current account is under severe imbalance and government has to take
measures to stabilize it. These measures includes:
Page 13 of 16
Comparison & Analysis of Economic Indicators
b. The remittances from expatriates is a major source for balancing of current account.
Government has to encourage people to send their money through legal channels instead of
‘Hundi’ system.
c. Pakistan is currently not an attractive place for foreign direct investments (FDI) due
to obvious reasons of law and order, security risks, political turmoil etc. This needs to be
addressed very seriously to attract FDI.
d. Pakistan’s stock market is also not consistent due to above mentioned reasons.
Therefore, Portfolio Investment in Pakistan is also very fluctuating and flight of capital
from stock market is not impossible.
• Export base is very thin and mainly dependant upon the raw materials which
are imported such as machinery, fertilizers, chemicals, petroleum etc.
Therefore, the decrease in exchange rate will increase the cost of imported
raw materials which will indirectly affect the exports.
• Imports are more than 80% of essential items whose cost will increase upon
the decline of exchange rate. That will affect the production as well as
inflation negatively.
f. The balance of payments is partially been covered through foreign reserves which is
depleting the reserves.
Page 14 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
(Million US Dollars)
2005-06 2006-07
I T E M
Credit Debit Net Credit Debit Net
Page 15 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
Page 16 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
Page 17 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
Page 18 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
2006-07p 2007-08 p
I T E M Jan.-Mar. Jul.-Sep. Oct.-Dec.. Jan.-Mar
Net Net Net Credit Debit Net
Page 19 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
Page 20 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
(Million US Dollars)
2006-07p 2007-08 p
I T E M Jan.-Mar. Jul.-Sep. Oct.-Dec.. Jan.-Mar
Net Net Net Credit Debit Net
Page 21 of 16
Annex A – Pakistan’s Balance of Payments
Page 22 of 16
Annex B – Pakistan’s Reserves
Page 23 of 16
Annex C – Pakistan’s Workers Remittances
Page 24 of 16
Annex E – Exports
Page 25 of 16
Annex E – Exports
(Thousand US Dollars)
Page 26 of 16
Annex F – Imports
Page 27 of 16