F
In technical skills development alone, we face a
or three eras in a row, the state has advised growing obstacle to meet anything near the projected
that they are to spend large amounts on infrastructure spend. Government is able to find
projects to support infrastructure. The first R140 million for fancy ministerial cars and many
in about 2003 was R400 billion to be spent other millions for parties and trips, but try to get a
in three years, the second R787 billion announced few million to train Engineers for municipalities.
in February 2009 to be spent in four years, and
Perhaps one plus will emerge from our misplaced
now we have another even greater sum to be spent
and misused empowerment monster; those are
starting 2010. The problem I have with these
currently disempowered and have to struggle to
enormous projections which sound very admirable
make the grade will eventually, when the free
is that do we ever get a reconciliation of the actual
handouts are no longer possible and the energy
spend, and what has been created for it?
in the flywheel has been depleted, have gained
If one surveys the likes of the municipal infrastruc- street-wise skills and survival mechanisms to have
ture, for example, it appears more evident that the actually benefitted from the policy.
assets have deteriorated significantly, and this is
It may just be that such characteristics become
showing its effects with service delivery violence,
engrained in the genes. And those who lived by
shocking water status reports with video evidence
entitlement will have regretted not understanding
of the state of the rivers, wet lands, water and
the implications of the second law of thermody-
sewage plants.
namics.
When the free handouts are no longer possible
Concealed from the public
The extent of breakdowns and accidents in the
distribution network is generally concealed from
the public as the safety investigation routines have
also declined. The recent 250MVA transformer fire
in De Aar was too big however to avoid the email
rounds.
The great pothole saga is of course very evident
to the public, with the consequent damage to
suspensions and noticeable increase in new tyre
sales. Low cost housing has not done much with
the need to destroy and rebuild R3 billion worth
of previously “built” houses. It is not as though
the current building technology is rocket science
– they are simple constructs that any reasonable
contractor should be able to build to last.
Produced by:
Official Publication of
PROMECH PUBLISHING, THE SA INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING
P O Box 373, Pinegowrie, 2123 and endorsed by:
Republic of South Africa
Tel: (011) 781-1401, Fax: (011) 781-1403 CORROSION INSTITUTE OF SA
Email: editorial@promech.co.za SA PUMP MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION
Website: www.promech.co.za SA VALVE AND ACTUATORS MANUFACTURERS ASSOCIATION
Managing Editor Susan Custers THE SA INSTITUTE OF TRIBOLOGY
Editor Kowie Hamman NUCLEAR INSTITUTE
Advertising Pauline Bouwer SA INSTITUTE FOR NON-DESTRUCTIVE TESTING
Circulation Catherine Macdiva
NATIONAL SOCIETY OF BLACK ENGINEERS
DTP Zinobia Docrat/Sanette Lehanie
INSTITUTE FOR CERTIFICATED MECHANICAL AND
Disclaimer ELECTRICAL ENGINEERS
PROMECH Publishing and The South African Institution of Mechanical
SOUTH AFRICAN ASSOCIATION OF CONSULTING ENGINEERS
Engineering as well as any other body do not take responsibility for
the opinions expressed by individuals. ASSOCIATION OF SOCIETIES FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY
Printed by: Typo Colour Printing, Tel: (011) 402-3468/9 AND HEALTH
What’s Happening?
Council 2009/2010
SAIMechE Boardroom for hire
Office Bearers The comfortable and spacious boardroom
President .................................................. G Barbic (George) at our Bruma offices is currently under-
President Elect ............................................. D Findeis (Dirk) utilised, and offers an opportunity to provide
National Treasurer ................................. K Nyangoni (Kudzai) a service to both Institute members and the
greater mechanical engineering community.
Branch Chairpersons The newly-renovated and air-conditioned
Central ...................................................... M Cramer (Mike) boardroom with modern furniture can com-
Eastern Cape ............................. Prof Dr DG Hattingh (Danie)
fortably seat 12, and has abundant power
KwaZulu/Natal ........................................... AG Fileczki (Alex)
outlets for laptops. A remote-controlled
Western Cape ......................... Prof B Collier-Reed (Brandon)
ceiling-mounted data projector as well as
Portfolios: a flip-chart with pens are provided.
Communications .............................................. CD Reay (Chris) This facility would suit those looking for a
Education - Universities................... Prof JL van Niekerk (Wikus)
centrally-located professional meeting venue,
Education: Universities of Technology............... E Zawilska (Ewa)
easily accessible from OR Tambo International
Membership .................................................... E Zawilska (Ewa)
Airport and Gillooly’s Interchange.
Seminars and Workshops.................................. D Findeis (Dirk)
Technology Programme ................................. SZ Hrabar (Steve)
Company Affiliates
Ainsworth Engineering (Pty) Ltd Hire rates (excl. VAT):
Alstom Power Service SA
Babcock Africa Limited Members
Bateman Engineered Technologies • Brief ad-hoc meetings (depending on
Fluor SA availability): no charge.
GEA Air-cooled Systems
• Booked meetings: R100 for morning/
Hansen Transmissions SA
Hatch Africa afternoon; R150 for the whole day.
Howden Power Non-members
Industrial Water Cooling • Brief ad-hoc meetings: not offered to
Megchem Eng & Drafting Services non-members
Osborn Engineered Products SA
Rotek Engineering • R400 for morning or afternoon; R700
RSD a division of DCD-Dorbyl for whole day
S.A.M.E Water
Tea, coffee and biscuits will be provided as
Sasol Technologies
well as water and mints.
SEW Eurodrive
Siemens Ltd Free wireless secured internet access also
SNC-Lavalin SA available.
Spicer Axle SA
Spirax Sarco SA
We do not provide other snacks and drinks
Thyssenkrupp Engineering and these would be for own account and
Transvaal Pressed Nuts & Bolts arrangement.
Vital Engineering Anisa, Tel: (011) 615-5660, Email: info@saimeche.
Weir Warman Africa org.za.
Winder Controls
Captivated delegates at a recent Cape Town workshop led by Geoff Alder on “Psychrometrics and Psychrometric
Principles”
W
but wake boarders also have a trick whereby they
elcome to cable skiing! Cable skiing is ‘load the line’ by putting tension on the rope and,
a way to water ski or ride a wakeboard, using the water as a spring, fling themselves into
where the skier’s rope and handle are the air in order to carry out somersaults or similar
pulled by an electrically-driven cable, routines.
whereas traditionally a water skier is pulled by a Though it is possible to do this behind a boat,
motorboat. The ski mechanism consists of two the higher angle of pull and the slight jerk on the
cables running parallel to one another with carri- corners of the course, allows good riders to attain
ers between them, allowing several skiers on the much higher jumps. We speak to Nic Malton who
water at the same time. regularly goes on the cable ski. “I do it for fun and
You have to create momentum from the cable that’s depending on the mood I’ll either use a surfboard
running at a constant speed or the wakeboard,” he says.
“The main difference between skiing behind a boat
The carriers are metal plates with hooks on and the cable ski is that the you don’t have the
them which allow the tow rope to be attached boat’s wake on the cable. Behind a boat you can
and detached easily without shutting the system use the wake to launch and get into the air for a
down. The cable is generally suspended above trick, but on the cable you have to create momen-
Skiing on a cable ski is only slightly different from skiing behind a boat
www.weirminerals.com
Performance
Not promises
A Bulk Filtration
Donaldson Filtration
Systems (Pty) Ltd
(DFSPL) has signed
contracts with
Solutions Offering
numerous oil
companies to provide
bulk filtration for
mining sites.
D
FSPL designs and sells bulk filtration A set of filters was installed on the downloading
systems. Currently, their focus is in side with a water separator and particle removal
Africa, having provided solutions for filters. The same set of filters, were installed on
clients in over 15 countries, including the transfer pump to the day tanks and to the dis-
South Africa, Mali, Ghana, Niger, Guinea, Cote pensing hose reels for the dump trucks and small
D’Ivoire and Zambia. In the near future, three ad- vehicles respectively. Breathers were also installed
ditional regions will be supported: South America, to complete the process.
the Carribean and Asia.
Two samples
Once an inquiry is received, Donaldson’s bulk A sample was taken before the filters on down
filtration technical division evaluates the project, loading and one from the hose reel for the dump
informs the client of what is required and designs trucks. These two samples were compared.
and sells the filtration system. This system is then
• Sample from down loading: ISO 26/23/18
installed on site by a local engineering company,
after which, a Donaldson technician travels to • Sample from hose reel: ISO 16/14/11
commission the site.
W
ith key international and local plenary Oil & Gas Africa 2010 is sponsored by Sasol
speakers in the line-up, the 2010 SPI (Gold sponsor) and the Petroleum Agency
conference retains its ranking as one South Africa (Bronze sponsor). The event is
of the top events on the African Oil endorsed by Provincial Government Western
and Gas calendar and Southern Africa’s leading Cape, City of Cape Town, the South African
industry interface globally. Oil and Gas Alliance (SAOGA), the Western
With a wide range of topics covering everything Cape Investment & Trade Promotion Agency
from Upstream Developments in Africa to Technical (WESGRO), the South African Supplier De-
Papers on Rig & Platform Design, the mix of plenary velopment Agency (SASDA), the South Africa
conference, seminars, briefings and workshops is – Angola Chamber of Commerce, Offshore
expected to attract in the region of 750 delegates Petroleum Association of South Africa, SA
from throughout the African continent. Capital Equipment Export Council, the South
African Petroleum Industry Association (SA-
Opportunity to interact with African national PIA), and the Cape Town Regional Chamber
independent oil companies from Ghana, Nigeria and of Commerce and Industry.
elsewhere
Fabrication in Saldanha
The port of Saldanha is best known for “SA Mechanical Engineer”
its iron export facilities, but over the past speaks to Steve Hrabar,
couple of years, long-term infrastructure immediate Past President
developments have progressed to include of SAIMechE and director
the establishment of a fabrication facility to of the South African Oil &
serve the oil and gas industry off the African Gas Alliance, who has for
west coast. This steel fabrication facility is many years been actively
built on the same site where the fabrication involved in promoting the
development of such a
and construction of the 14 500 tonne fixed-
facility at Saldanha. “Gri-
leg platform jacket for the Mossgas offshore
naker LTA has now been
platform took place in the 1980’s.
appointed as the operator Steve Hrabar
of this facility and they
hope to get the ball rolling with projects this year,”
he says. “The company is familiar with this type
of heavy fabrication work as they had a similar
yard in Nigeria.”
Offshore projects
The fabrication site is well equipped for the con-
struction of offshore oil and gas projects with the
first phase of the centre consisting of a fabrication
yard of 220 000 m2 that includes an open weld-
ing area, high bay fabrication workshops with 15
and 25 tonne capacity gantry cranes, a blasting
and priming workshop, a pipe spool fabrication
workshop and an electrical and instrumentation
workshop.
Other facilities include material warehouses, cus-
Background
“Originally, after the Mossgas project, it was hoped
that future offshore projects would be available in
South Africa and internationally, however this was
not possible and the site lay fallow until 2006,” ex-
plains Steve. “Due to the offshore activity on the West
Coast of Africa, the National Ports Authority formed
a committee to see what infrastructure changes they
would have to implement to support the oil and gas
activities on the West Coast.”
The committee was made up of representatives of
businesses in engineering and project management,
fabrication and construction, ship repair, upstream
development and logistics.
Base to operate from
Joining this committee was the Provincial Government
of the Western Cape, National Ports Authority, Industrial
Development Corporation, the Department of Trade
and Industry, South African Revenue Service, Chamber
of Commerce, Petroleum Agency of South Africa and
the West Coast Business Development Centre.
“An interim report was issued in August 2003 and a
final report in September 2004,” adds Steve. “The
report recommended that the Saldanha fabrication
facility be re-commissioned and a dry-dock be con-
structed to support the activities in Saldanha Bay. In
addition, a dedicated berth should be allocated for
repairs to rigs and oil and gas vessels in Cape Town
so that the ship repair industry would have a base
to operate from.
Offset
“MAN Ferrostaal, who supplied three submarines
S
A Mechanical Engineer” speaks to Chris Eibl, in the seventies, low moisture electrode coating,
the managing director of Esab Africa Welding bulk pack of wire and high speed cored wire in the
& Cutting, who elaborates on the company’s 80’s. In the nineties they brought out friction stir
history and the advantages of the product welding technology called SuperStir and in 2001
range offered to the local market. “Esab is a world introduced the first modular platform for welding
leader in advanced welding and cutting solutions equipment.
Most recently they came up with AristoRod, and
Seventy years of cutting experience and a constant keen advanced surface coating wire which was followed
ear for our customers’ needs by the Qset function in 2005. In 2008 Esab was
the recipient of the Frost & Sullivan Global Welding
with a product and geographical spread that is Consumables Customer Excellence Award.
unrivalled in the majority of the world’s markets,”
Services
he says. “Our global representation covers
The company’s services and product range is ex-
five continents and has 35 manufacturing
tensive, ranging from cutting systems, to welding
locations to serve customers throughout
equipment, accessories and consumables. “Seventy
the world.
“From the company’s
foundation in
Sweden
years of cutting experience and a constant keen most products. “Our range includes covered elec-
ear for our customers’ needs have resulted in an trodes, cored wires, solid wires, TIG rods, strips
extensive range of products, from thermal cutting and fluxes, covering all customers’ needs for every
technologies such as plasma, oxy-fuel and laser type of welding,” says Chris. “The company has
cutting systems, to new waterjet cutting technolo- tailored its range of consumables to the requirements
gies,” says Chris. of the South African market with the introduction
“One of our specialities, welding automation, has of consumables that conform to ASME II, Part C
advantages such as high quality, capacity and SFA 5.01, Schedule H, I, J, K, Class S3, C3, C5
much better productivity. We develop and produce and T3.”
a wide range of mechanised and automated welding Replace the old technology of copper-coated wires
systems to meet any need, tailored specifically to within the next decade
each user’s special requirements and needs.”
As far as welding equipment is concerned, Esab’s The invention of advanced surface coating (ASC) on
systems are based on solid-state technology. “The MIG wires has proved to deliver significant savings
latest generation of welding equipment can be to welders across the globe. “This next generation
programmed with specific process preferences for of MIG wires will replace the old technology of
individual needs or for the actual welding processes,” copper-coated wires within the next decade,” Chris
explains Chris. “State-of-the-art plasma cutting predicts. “Already over 50% of Europe has moved
equipment is available in manual, mechanised away from old copper-coated wires.”
and precision mechanised formats. This range is Esab packaging solutions for consumables combine
rounded off with our highest quality welding PPE production efficiency with environmental responsi-
and accessories.” bility. The Marathon Pac wire delivery system can
offer truly non-stop production in robot applica-
Consumables
tions, meaning zero downtime for spool changes
Esab is one of the world’s leading manufacturers
and zero downtime for drum changes when using
of consumables with a vast array of approvals on
the endless wire set-up.
J
a cyclic variation of the volume enclosed by the
ust because the pump is turning does not
vanes and the ring, creating a vacuum at the inlet
mean it’s actually pumping effectively,”
port of the pump. Gas, often air, is drawn into the
he says. “The gap between the vanes and
pump via the inlet port and is trapped in the com-
the housing gets bigger over time due too
pression chambers formed by the impeller vanes
wear which reduces the pump’s performance
and the liquid ring. The reduction in volume caused
significantly.”
by the impeller rotation compresses the gas before
it goes to the discharge port at the other end of
the pump casing.
Doing it right
“Although the principle of a vacuum pump is simple,
many don’t fully understand its workings and they
just don’t get it right,” Ryan says. “Calls come in
regularly for us to help out in such instances. We go
to site, do a complete test of all the vacuum pump
systems and draw up a comprehensive report to
indicate the performance of each pump and whether
it needs to be serviced, repaired or replaced.”
Apart from repairs and service to all makes of
vacuum pumps, Horma Pumps also locally manu-
factures their own series used in the sugar, mining,
pulp and paper and petrochemical industries. “We
service the platinum mining industry extensively
and therefore Rustenburg is the one area where we
have appointed an agency,” adds Ryan. “The fact
that we manufacture locally allows a delivery time
for a new pump, built from scratch, of six weeks
as opposed to an import that usually takes around
three months to deliver.”
André Vorster, director of Horma Pumps (left) and sales manager, Ryan Testing
Baptista “We’ve also invested in an in-house test facility
in order to apply the necessary ISO certification
We apply a Monarch coating on all the wet-end standards as well as the different specifications
components to reduce wear that are required by each client,” says André. “Our
door is always open for customers to come in and
A simple vacuum test will immediately reveal this
witness the tests we do on their specific pumps.
or other faults such as an air leak in the system
This gives them the confidence that they’re getting
which forms part of the service that Horma Pumps
what they’re paying for,” he adds.
offers vacuum pump users. “We don’t charge to
test a vacuum pump system, provided the pump “In addition, we keep data packs for our regular
comes to us for repair,” says sales manager, Ryan customers containing site inspection reports,
Baptista. “Sometimes it’s not the pump itself, but specification and repair records,” says André.
rather a poor installation which causes the system “Through this we can see when a trend develops
to leak air.” and be prepared with the necessary stock when a
pump has to be replaced instead of waiting for it parts, regular maintenance and supervision by a
to break down.” properly trained operator is crucial for a full pump
life. “The first thing that usually fails on a vacuum
Bearings and chemicals
pump is the bearing,” explains André. “The seal
Although vacuum pumps do not have many moving
starts leaking due to a lack of maintenance and
Overloading
Another unique feature found only on Horma pumps
is a vacuum relief valve. “Through plant design, or
ignorance, operators often feed too much water into
the system which creates a very high vacuum that
either breaks the shaft or the second stage impeller,”
explains André. “We’ve come up with a vacuum relief
valve that will open in such a case to suck more air
and not water, thereby preventing the shaft of the
pump from being overloaded. Since fitting these, we’ve
had no failures due to overloading of the system.
“Vacuum pumping is not a complex concept, but if
you don’t know enough about it, mistakes can cost
you a lot of money,” says André in a final comment.
“Make use of reputable companies that are certified
to provide you with the right equipment from the start
and then it’s simply a matter of proper maintenance
to get the optimum life out of your pump.”
Ryan Baptista, Horma Pumps, Tel: (011) 452-4300, Email:
sales@horma.co.za
What’s in a
As much as everyone wants a premium
brand along with the technology, service and
longevity associated with it, not everyone
can afford it. However, if the premium brand
incorporates its technology and support into
Name?
lower end products, end-users can rest as-
sured they’re getting value for money.
T
his is what the company Multibrands is
all about. It offers a range of compressor
products that complement the high-end
range of compressors of its mother company,
Atlas Copco. “SA Mechanical Engineer” meets
with Chris Makume, manager of Multibrands in
South Africa, to talk about the Worthington and
Ceccato range of compressor products that are
now available on the local market.
of a process to allow waste to flow in freely and they are less than satisfactory for sump applications
therefore it is also the place where other items due to the challenging conditions.
will inevitably end their journey,” Nico adds. “The “In fact, they are particularly ill-suited to the task
liquid in the sump therefore often contains grit, oil, as the dust and grit causes wear in all three pump
rags and various items of debris. For many pump types, while debris can build up on the impeller
types, such abrasive effluent causes severe wear of the submersible and on the valves of the dia-
on the pump, while certain debris may block it phragm pump, obstructing the flow and causing
altogether and has the potential to cause the sump the pumps to block.”
to overflow.”
A solution
Has no difficulty handling thickened slurries up to An increasingly popular solution to the problem
concentrates of 80 percent solids is the peristaltic pump, due to its reliability and
capacity to cope with debris without blocking.
Equally vulnerable “Peristaltic technology is designed to handle dif-
Many site managers have overcome this issue by ficult applications where its non-contacting pump
installing secondary pumps that can take over op- mechanism wins over other pump types,” says
eration should the primary pump become disabled. Nico. “Where conventional pumps use valves to
The secondary pump can also run in unison during push liquid through them, peristaltic technology
peak times. However, as these pumps are usually employs pressing shoes to compress and release
of the same type, they are equally vulnerable to a hose. This means there is an absolutely clear
blocking and therefore can’t provide a long- term path of flow with no valves, seals or glands, and
solution to the issue. therefore nowhere for debris such as rags and
stones to get stuck.”
“The submersible is just one type of pump that can
be used for this application,” explains Nico. “Other Watson-Marlow Bredel SPX peristaltic hose pumps
types include diaphragm pumps and progressive are increasingly finding favour in demanding effluent
cavity pumps. These are often the first choice simply disposal applications. Unlike the submersible pump,
because operators know how to handle them, but the peristaltic self-primes and can be mounted at
C
ustomers in the fluid power and hydraulics
industry can soon expect a major upgrade
in the quality of hose assembly and hose
products. For several years, the industry has
been plagued with sub-standard materials
and inadequate knowledge of assembly and maintenance
techniques by poorly qualified staff.
Considering the negative consequences that affect numerous
applications in which hose and couplings are an integral formal guidelines. In future, all customers serviced by accred-
part, the council of the South African Fluid Power Associa- ited and certified SAFPA members will be assured of quality
tion (SAFPA) has resolved to remedy the situation by issuing components and assemblies that meet the standards set by
the SAFPA Hose Assembly Accreditation Scheme.
Approved products
The comprehensive guidelines
based on Standards set by the
British Fluid Power Association
cover a number of relevant issues
in hydraulic engineering, includ-
ing safety, especially relating to
compatibility of components used
in hydraulics systems. Specifica-
tions for assembly, testing and use
of recognised, approved products
will prevent the use of unmatched
hose and end couplings, the mixing
of inserts and ferrules from differ-
ent or unknown manufacturers,
and unbranded or reworked hose
end couplings – all potentially
dangerous.
Come on board
Further specifications relating to
health, training, quality control,
testing, storage, maintenance etc.
are contained in the guidelines and
are expected to streamline plant
operations and reduce excessive
downtime.
It is anticipated that the majority
of manufacturers and hydraulics
suppliers will come on board.
This scheme is a long-awaited
development and will bring South
Africa up to standard with global
operations.
Brian Rogers, SAFPA, Tel: (011) 888-
7163, Fax: 086-503-4524, Email:
ctr@safpa.org.za, Website: www.
safpa.org.za
Riding Out
the Storm
I
Equipment manufac- n addition to the recent major economic
turers really have a downturn, equipment manufacturer,
rough ride during a Weir Minerals Africa, had to cope with
recession. Raw materi- the long-term merger of CH Warman
als cost more, labour and Weir Envirotech to establish the
wants their usual company’s new identity while retaining
increases, utilities go customer confidence in their products.
up, customers want Also, the extensive product range result-
ing from the merger brought its own set
better prices because
of challenges. “SA Mechanical Engineer”
they’re struggling, yet
speaks to Rob Fawcett, operations director
manufacturers have to
of Weir Minerals Africa, about the chal- Rob Fawcett, operations director, Weir Minerals
remain competitive in lenges of the past 18 months. Africa
a market that gener-
ally has less money to Trends
spread around. “It’s been a very difficult time for us because “Although we’ve sold fewer pump units, the trend
we’re caught between our customers who is toward bigger ones and therefore we’ve made
need price relief and the market inflationary the necessary changes to extend our range of pump
pressures on our business,” he says. “We’ve had products to cater for this development. We have
to look very hard at our businesses and how we undertaken an unprecedented number of product
can assist customers by absorbing price increases. developments over the last 18 months which has
Looking ahead, there may be tougher challenges in required significant capital investment. We’ve also
terms of increased labour and utility costs. invested heavily in our manufacturing facilities to
“In spite of this we have not really experienced a ensure that the required efficiencies are achieved
downturn in business over the past year,” Rob adds. to remain competitive in a global market.
Issues
Although we’ve sold fewer pump units, the trend is
“Apart from extending certain equipment ranges and
toward bigger ones improving designs, we’ve also
looked at total cost of ownership
on some of the products out in
the field,” says Rob. “Customer
requirements are changing in
terms of labour becoming more
expensive and it being difficult to
secure skilled labour to operate
equipment. Therefore custom-
ers are expecting equipment to
last longer with fewer service
intervals.
Upgrades
“We’ve made a conscious deci-
sion to change the rubber com-
pound used in our products to
R55, a premium brand rubber
which dramatically increases
wear characteristics and avail-
ability in pumps and cyclones.
The R55 material is particularly
suitable for large particle erosive
View of new pump assembly facility with its in-line spray capability slurry applications such as mill
H
German-led Desertec scheme.
e addresses the question of how the
UK is to support itself energy-wise with He comes up with five alternative plans for provid-
minimal recourse to fossil fuels. He says ing the 1,1 million GWh per year needed. That’s
he’s not necessarily pro-nuclear but he about four times the current South African usage.
is vigorously pro arithmetic. The various plans cater respectively for those who
don’t like the idea of importing energy, for those who
He’s not necessarily pro-nuclear but he is vigorously pro object to renewables sources cluttering the English
arithmetic countryside, for those who don’t like nuclear, for
those who don’t want either nuclear or coal, and
The book is full of revealing back-of-
for those who just want cheap energy.
envelope calculations. Did you know,
for example, that the ‘embedded’ ‘Rough costs’
energy of an average motor car is Nuclear looms largest in the last of these provid-
around 76 000 kWh, perhaps 14 ing over 60% of electricity generation. Finally, for
kWh for every day that you own a brief discussion of ‘rough costs’, he produces a
it? Goods imported into Britain median Plan M and an astonishing diagram show-
have an energy content of around ing how much of the British Isles would have to be
48 kWh per day for every man, given over to biomass and other energy generation
woman and child – plus 12 kWh activities to meet it.
for transportation into the UK. Plan M foresees respectively 23 and 29GW of
The three main primary energy on- and off-shore wind backed up by 30GW of
gobblers in Britain are indeed pumped storage. We also have 48GW of photovol-
transportation and space heating taic panels, 40GW of imported solar energy and
John Walmsley (both estimated at 40 kWh/d per 45GW of nuclear.
person) and electricity generation
Move the debate forward
(18 kWh/d per person). The author begins by
The numbers he uses for nuclear capex translate to
insisting that energy consumption must be cut,
about $2300 per kW installed which, after recent
transportation being a prime target. He calculates
escalation, is probably too low by a factor of two.
that with widespread electrification, principally the
That said, his capex estimate per unit delivered for
use of battery-power, the transportation energy bill
wind power (including pumped-storage back-up as
could be halved.
per Plan M) is 2,7 times greater than nuclear, im-
Heat pumps ported solar is six times more expensive and PV 25
Space heating energy use could be reduced by 25% times. The small contribution of clean coal in Plan
by better insulation and, particularly, by replacing M comes in at 1,4 times the estimated nuclear cost
conventional heaters with heat pumps. He is much – but subsequent fuel costs would militate heavily
more interested at this stage of the book in techni- against using coal, clean or otherwise.
cal feasibility than in cost implications. This is an entirely inadequate account of a mar-
He then sets out to discover where the required vellously informative effort to move the debate
energy is to come from - concentrating on UK re- forward. The hope must be that someone will have
newables, “clean” coal (perhaps), nuclear (perhaps) the energy to produce something similar for this
and on solar energy from the Sahara. He defines a country – and quickly.
sustainable energy source as one that will last at John Walmsley
What is a
Configuration Item?
A configuration item is defined as a deliverable item in terms of a development or a manufacturing contract.
There are additional criteria for designating an item as a configuration item. To continue with the previous ex-
ample: the customer has contracted a prime contractor to develop and construct a Spacecraft, and the Space-
craft is the configuration item in terms of that contract. One of the lower-assemblies is a Battery that is to be
reused in another spacecraft. That means that the customer, who has contracted to receive the Spacecraft,
needs to keep specification control over the Battery. The Battery is thus designated as a configuration item
even though it is not a deliverable. Similarly, items that have been standardised, or that need to be operation-
ally reprogrammed, or that are likely to be changed after initial deployment, should also become configuration
items.
I
s the concept of a configura- ration item is a contractor, since
tion item still valid once the • different items from a single contractor potentially
item is in operation? During form a single configuration item, and
the operations and support
phase, a configuration item • items from different contractors are by defini-
is determined by the selected tion different configuration items.
level of management. It is that A configuration item should be designable and
level where the user organises, producible by one contractor, and should be test-
assigns responsibility for and able as an entity — not as part of its next-higher
controls maintenance, supply, assembly.
procurement and modification
The selection of configuration items is a crucial
activities.
trade-off decision. Dividing a complex item into
Any item needing maintenance, separate configuration items to create more vis-
or that has been designated for ibility and easier control is self defeating. It results
separate procurement, is by in more management effort, more paperwork and
Ad Sparrius definition a configuration item. more coordination problems. It is similar to break-
Note that this is the same concept ing down a large contract into a few smaller ones.
as used during development and production, but Neither size nor visibility is a valid criterion for
the nature of the contract is of course completely selecting a configuration item. In general, fewer
different. configuration items are better.
Configuration items are the basic building blocks for The limit of resolution
configuration management A configuration item is not the level where configu-
ration management starts, neither is it the level
During development and production, all deliverable where it stops. Configuration management occurs
items contractually referred to are configuration throughout the product breakdown structure right
items. During operations and support, an end item down to the lowest level. But at the configuration
and all its subassemblies right down to items of item level the customer transfers configuration
supply (those items that populate the supply sys- management implementation responsibility to the
tem), are configuration items. Management occurs contractor. The customer controls lower-level items
at the level of items of supply, but it would not be indirectly, since their specifications are derived
possible to contract development and production from the configuration item’s specification, and
for those items of supply since they will only be configuration management responsibility is recur-
identified late in development. sively enforced by contract.
Computer software, since it controls functionality, Configuration items are the basic building blocks
is almost always designated a configuration item. for configuration management. A configuration item
Operational software should always be designated may be viewed as “the limit of resolution” since
as a configuration item but separate from support it is the lowest level of assembly that is visible to
software. the customer.
Fewer is better Ad Sparrius, 082-574-0266, Email: ad_sparr@iafrica.
The essential starting point for selecting a configu- com
Catching
Not all that glitters is gold. For centuries chrome plating
has given vehicles that extra bit of sparkle. Bumpers, door
handles, side mirrors, trimmings, rims and exhaust tail pipes
are the parts that are usually chromed on standard cars while
hobbyists go a bit further to chrome tappet covers, gear le-
vers, oil caps and engine nuts and bolts.
the Eye
We found a DIY kit to give your Hummer a chrome-
look for just over R10 000. Another option is to
polish the raw aluminium panels on your Audi TT
until it has the shine of a chrome finish and then
lacquer it to protect it from the elements.
The real thing
To do the real thing by chrome plating all the panels
on a car is by far the most expensive and tedious of
all. To find out whether it’s possible and how you’d
go about it, we speak to Laurence Segal director
of Edison Electroplating in Johannesburg. “It can
be done, but it will cost an arm and leg,” he says.
“If you can get the car in its raw metal state all
the better because then you forego the huge task
of stripping off the paint first, then smoothing the
metal surfaces of the various metals on the car to
a highly polished state before chrome plating.
“You’d need special tanks and anodes to accom-
modate the size of body panels over and above the
Mario Beltrame (left) and Laurence Segal of Edison Electroplating fact that the different metals making up a car have
to go through different processes for chrome plating,”
O
adds Mario Beltrame, the automotive specialist at
f course, there are always the extrem- Edison. “In electroplating, the preparation of the
ists. “SA Mechanical Engineer” found surface is crucial as even the slightest scratch can-
a Bugatti, a Lamborghini, Mercedes not be filled with electroplating, it’s just too thin.
and BMW’s on the internet that have So all surfaces would have to be polished to a very
been chrome plated completely, from the grille right smooth finish before you even start plating.”
through to the tailpipe including all the body panels.
The all-chrome 2009 Bugatti Veyron is the only Polishing
one in the world, but no word on how much it cost The process consists of first plating the polished
for the whole chrome treatment,
considering the car itself costs
about twenty million rand.
A chromed Lexus
Even something for the ladies which they would not chrome plating onto the layer of nickel. “Considering
elaborate on that you’re doing an expensive sports car the final
surface of the raw metal with a layer of copper about finish can’t have any flaws, so all the layers, one at
as thick as a human hair, then it’s polished before a time, have to be well-polished.This would take a
it’s covered with a layer of nickel plating. In turn lot of time and very special care, but for the right
this layer is polished to a fine finish before finally money, I’d do it,” says gung-ho Laurence.
Plating
The actual plating isn’t long, however.
The base coat of copper acts as a
primer for the nickel metal to follow
and fills any minor imperfections in
the part. Generally, depending on the
size of the part, it will remain in the
copper tank anywhere from 20 to 45
minutes. Next is the nickel tank. This
is the beginning of a bright, quality
chrome job. Depending on the size
and shape of the part, a stay of around 30 min- people don’t mind the expense, they simply want to
utes in the nickel tank results in about a 1/1000 preserve the item,” says Laurence in conclusion.
to 1/2000 of an inch thick coating. Then finally Laurence Segal, Edison Electroplating, Tel: (011) 607-2011,
it goes to the chrome tank where it takes under a Email: laurencesegal@edisonsa.co.za
minute for a layer of chrome to deposit.
S
outh Africa’s biggest supplier of Unmanned extensive. The availability of capable and affordable South
Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) systems, Denel (the African UAVs of various sizes will trigger the enhancement of
other being ATE) is respected for developing not only national security, but crime fighting, disaster man-
and producing some of the most rugged and agement, election monitoring and search and rescue. UAVs
reliable tactical UAV surveillance systems even provide benefits to the agricultural, mining, health and
in the world. While the US and Israel dominate the global environmental sectors.
market, there is scope for South Africa to use local skills Within the next five years UAVs will be used by a diversity of
to create market-leading UAVs to developing nations - a industries from policing poachers on coastlines, carrying test
market estimated at R2bn per annum. The South African specimens from remote clinics to laboratories for analysis, to
UAV industry aims to capture in excess of 20% of this end keeping an eye on livestock on farms, and will prove to be a
of the market at an estimated value of R400m a year. lucrative parallel market for international UAV players.
The global increase in operational use of UAVs is a direct South Africa has an enviable edge in comparison with the
result of lessons learnt by allied forces in Iraq and Afghanistan. many international (including European) countries intending
The surveillance benefits in the defence world of being able to enter the booming world-wide UAV market which is at-
to survey borders and enter war zones without a pilot are tracting an estimated R50 billion a year.
UAVs are not generally allowed to access civilian airspace
because current regulations were originally drafted for manned
flight. This is changing, with regulatory bodies across the globe,
including SA’s Civil Aviation Authority driving the process of
drafting internationally compliant, UAV friendly regulations.
International competition is fierce to master what is termed
‘sense and avoid’ technology aimed at enhancing the safe
use of UAVs in controlled airspace. Once this capability has
been perfected, the opportunities will lead to an explosion
in UAV demand.
Denel Dynamics, Shantall Tshoshane, Tel: (012) 671-1555, Email:
market@deneldynamics.co.za, www.deneldynamics.co.za
SKUA, High-speed Target Drone
To exacting standards
The latest in round separation design from
Sweco, available from Chamdor-based Lockers
Engineers, is the new generation MX Separator. Currently
available in 76-, 101-, 122- and 152-inch diameters, the The unit separates solids from liquids or segregates dry
separator is designed to increase safety, provide stronger materials into various sizes. Particles as fine as 400 mesh
construction and allow for a more sanitary process. (37 microns) can be screened, with up to 4 screen decks
Subscription
Index to Advertisers
Please fax us if you wish to subscribe to “SA Mechanical En-
gineer” at R400,00 (incl postage and VAT) per year; R945,00 Artic Driers 37
per year for Africa/Overseas. We will post you an invoice on AST Inside Front Cover
receipt of your fax. Atlas Copco Outside Back Cover
Bonfiglioli Inside Back Cover
PROMECH PUBLISHING Fax No: (011) 781-1403
Ceccato 23
From:...................................................................................... CerAdvance 38
Chorus Call 45
(insert your name)
Donaldson Outside Front Cover
Title: ...................................................................................... ESAB 4
Engen 22
Company: .............................................................................. ILS 24
Address: ............................................................................... Messer 16
Multi Alloys 26
............................................................................................... Multotec 28
Oil & Gas Africa 2010 14
...................................................................Code: ..................
SAID 36
Telephone: ( ) .................................................................... Spirax Sarco 30
Tegnon 20
Fax: ( ) ................................................................................
Voith Turbo 41
Email:..................................................................................... Weir Minerals 10
Atlas Copco is a leading manufacturer of fully comprehensive, technologically advanced air packages
as well as their own range of fully compatible filters and dryers. The right solution for every application.
Legendary customer care & after sales service. Full range of generators with super silent options also available.
•Compressors (oil-free & oil-injected) •Scroll •Portable Air Compressors •Dryers •Filters •After Coolers
•Tooth •Rotary Screw •Centrifugal •Power Generators •Water Separators •Automatic Drains