English version was prepared by T. Sugano, one of the authors, May 2005.
Though there are indications of tsunami wave force for use in the design of embankments and other revetments,
not much research has been conducted regarding the impact on structures of the inland incursion of tsunamis. It is
thought based on past experience that reinforced concrete buildings would probably be safe, though quantitative
assessments have not been implemented. The study was carried out on literature survey of previous studies on tsunami
wave pressure and forces. The outline of structural design for Tsunami refuge buildings is proposed.
When calculating wave pressure and force, they are determined as a function of maximum inundation depth based
on an equation2) for the wave pressure of tsunamis that flow over perpendicular revetments without soliton break up and
cause inland inundation. Since the tests were conducted under conditions of flat land with no obstacles subsequent to
revetment overflow, the assessed values of wave pressure and force may be somewhat large. In addition, since much
remains unknown about the effects on wave force when breaking window glass, etc., on pressure-exposed surfaces of
structures, we decided to use wave pressure and force with sound pressure-exposed surfaces for our assessments to be
on the safe side. Unconfirmed elements will have to wait for research to be conducted later.
<Comments>
The Central Disaster Prevention Council, chaired by the Prime Minister with a membership consisting of the
entire Cabinet including ministers in charge of disaster prevention, the heads of designated public institutions and
persons of experience or academic standing, is to “promptly secure refuge facilities through the utilization of
solidly-constructed buildings, etc.,” as provided for in the Framework for Tokai Earthquake Measures, and “promote
the utilization, of so-called tsunami refuge buildings using the mid- to high-level stories of solidly-constructed high-rise
buildings for refuge purposes,” as provided for in the Framework for Tonankai and Nankai Earthquake Measures.
This design method treats tsunami load quantitatively and provides procedures for the structural design of
buildings for tsunami resistance in order to enable the utilization of the tsunami refuge buildings. Equations for
assessing tsunami load are usually considered to be a function of inundation depth. Inundation depth is known
beforehand by numerical simulations, etc. Numerical simulations are explained in detail in the Tsunami and Tidal
Wave Hazard Map Manual 1) edited by the Cabinet Office and others.
The structural design flow indicated in Fig. 1-1 is assumed with this design method. In the case of new
construction, a structural design is implemented in compliance with the Building Standards Law, which is then followed
by the calculation of load and the design of pressure-exposed surfaces and the structural framework. In the case of
application to existing structures, this design method is applicable to buildings with earthquake-proof safety that has
been confirmed through Seismic Evaluation Standard for Existing Buildings or buildings that are in compliance with
the current Building Standards Law in order to verify earthquake-proof safety for the earthquakes that occur prior to
tsunamis.
Though concrete buildings are suitable as tsunami refuge buildings taking into account the size of the load and the
weight of the building, this design method does not necessarily place limits on the type of structure. The ultimate
strength of the members and other items not specifically defined in this design method are to comply with the standards,
guidelines, etc., of architectural institutions and organizations.
Start
NO
Available information of design ① Numerical simulation and past experience.
inundation depth
YES
③ Structural Design
NG
judgment
strengthen
⑥ Design of pressure-exposed ⑥ Design of pressure-exposed
surface. Design of structural frame surface. Design of structural frame
etc. etc.
NG judgment NG
judgment
OK OK
End
The terminology used in this design method are defined as indicated below.
Design inundation depth : Design-use tsunami depth conjectured on the site. Depth of flood not run up height (m)
Tsunami load : Tsunami-induced pressure and force that acts on buildings. This is a general term for
tsunami wave pressure, force and buoyancy.
Tsunami wave pressure : Tsunami-induced pressure in the horizontal direction that acts on pressure-exposed
surfaces of buildings (kN/m2)
Tsunami wave force : Tsunami-induced force in the horizontal direction that acts on buildings (kN)
Buoyancy : Tsunami-induced force in the vertical upward direction that acts on buildings (kN)
Pressure-exposed surface : Surface that is directly exposed to tsunami pressure
Pressure-resistance member : Member that is directly exposed to and designed to withstand tsunami pressure
Non-pressure-resistant member:Member that is directly exposed to and yields to
breakage by tsunami pressure, including glass windows, window frames, light-weight
partitions, etc.
Structural framework : Frame that conveys the force received by pressure-exposed surfaces to the structure
overall and the foundation
<Comments>
The terms given in this section are a compilation of terms used in the following description of the design method
that are not in general use or that need to be explicitly defined.
Inundation depth is conjectured based on the results of numerical simulations, etc., and is the design inundation
depth used in design. There are cases when hazard maps are produced that predict inundation depth based on the
result of numerical simulations and it may be possible to obtain them on websites depending on the local government.
If a hazard map indicating estimated inundation depths such as that shown in Fig. 2-1 is used, it is possible to set the
design inundation depth by multiplying the inundation depth by the margin of safety ratio taking the importance, etc., of
the buildings into account.
The equation for the calculation of tsunami load in this design method is proposed based on tests of tsunami
flowing over perpendicular revetments2), the configuration of which is illustrated in Fig. 2-2. In the tests, the building
is positioned at a distance from the perpendicular revetment that is 2.5 – 20 times greater than the wave height. There
are no obstacles in front of the building and it is exposed directly to the impact of the tsunami. The inundation depth is
greatest at the leading edge of the inland incursion of the tsunami.
The inundation depths indicated on the hazard map are the maximum estimated values. The inundation depths
indicated in the tests, which serve as the basis for the load equations used in the design method, are not necessarily the
same as the inundation depths shown on the hazard map; however, they are treated as equal for the purposes of the
design method. Little research has been conducted regarding the quantitative assessment of the load exerted by inland
incursions of tsunamis on buildings and a clearly defined correlation of design inundation depth with hazard maps or
other easily obtainable resources remains an issue requiring further research in the future.
Pressure-exposed surface and structural framework are defined and pressure-resistant member and
non-pressure-resistant member in the pressure-exposed surface are defined as well in the design method. The
relationship between the pressure-exposed surface and structural framework is indicated in Fig. 2-3. Since the load
differs depending on the inundation depth or direction, even if it is the same member, a member can become either a
pressure-resistant or non-pressure-resistant member.
map of the inundation
depth prediction
building
Inundation depth
for design Tsunami
Perpendicular
revetment
Pressure-exposed Structural
surface framework
Non-pressure-resistant Pressure-resistant
member member
・Columns
・ Walls other than ・Girders
seismic-resistant walls ・Seismic-resistant walls
(including partitions) *Columns ・Footing beams
・Windows, etc.
・Seismic-resistant
walls
・*Walls other than
seismic-resistant
walls(including
partitions)
・*Windows, etc.
In the structural design of buildings to withstand tsunami load, the positioning of pressure-resistant and
non-pressure-resistant members is clearly differentiated.
<Comments>
Tsunami load increases as the design inundation depth increases and pressure-exposed surfaces area increase. In
addition, the load may also be greater than wind load or seismic load depending on the design inundation depth.
Pressure-resistant walls bear an in-plane force when an earthquake occurs but also bear a out of plane force
when a tsunami occurs. In the structural design of buildings to withstand tsunami load, pressure-resistant and
non-pressure-resistant members must be clearly differentiated according to the load direction. The tsunami load
generated throughout the entire structural framework of the building may be reduced depending on the placement of
pressure-resistant members.
For example, the building with piloti is one in which tsunami load is reduced, though earthquake-resistant
performance is generally not favorable. It is necessary to design tsunami refuge buildings with design method taking
both earthquake-resistant and tsunami-resistant design into account.
qx building
3h
x 3ρgh
z1
… (4.2.)
1
{( )(
= pgB 6hz 2 − z2 2 − 6hz1 − z12
2
)
Where,
Qx is tsunami wave force in direction of advance for structural design (kN)
B is width of part of interest (m)
z1 is the minimum height of pressure-exposed surfaces (0 ≦z1 ≦z2) (m)
z2 is the maximum height of pressure-exposed surfaces (z1 ≦z2 ≦3h) (m)
Qx
building
3h
z1
x 3ρgh
<Comments>
Though tsunami wave force relating to seaport facilities is indicated in Port Facility Technological Standards and
Commentary3), it generally does not indicate anything regarding the inland incursion of tsunamis. Tsunami Assessment
Technology for Nuclear Power Plants4) introduces the results of existing research2), 5)-7) relating to the load of tsunami
inland incursion, which can be summarized as indicated below.
(1) There are two types of assessment equations, one for assessing tsunami wave pressure and the other for assessing
tsunami wave force.
(2) The equation for assessing tsunami pressure has been proposed as a linear function for inundation depths.
(3) The equation for tsunami wave force has been proposed as an equation that includes drag force only or drag,
inertia, impact and hydraulic gradient force.
(4) Drag force is derived as a function by multiplying flow velocity squared times inundation depth.
There is also a study8) that states that flow velocity is proportional to the square root of inundation depth and the
following can be determined based on item (4) above.
(5) Drag force is a quadratic function of inundation depth.
Based on the above, tsunami wave force can approximately be judged to be a quadratic function of inundation
depth.
With this design method, tsunami wave pressure is calculated according to equation 4.1. Tsunami wave force is
calculated based on equation 4.2, integrated as the tsunami wave pressure of equation 4.1, generated simultaneously.
Fig. 4-1 shows tsunami wave pressure based on equation 4.1 and Fig. 4-2 shows tsunami wave force based on equation
4.2.; however, since actual buildings have complex shapes, Fig. 4-3 shows a method taking tsunami wave load based on
building shape into account reflecting tsunami wave pressure distribution. Equations 4.1 and 4.2 can also be thought
to implicitly include the effects of normal hydrostatic pressure and flow velocity and the wave pressure distribution
gradient is the same as when under normal hydrostatic pressure.
Fig. 4-3(d) shows a case in which water depth h’ of pressure-exposed surfaces is less than design inundation depth
h. Since the horizontal load of the tsunami is based on the design inundation depth, it may seem possible to determine
if h were replaced by h’ in equations 4.1 and 4.2. However, there is a study8) indicating that the flow velocity referred
to above is proportional to the square root of the inundation depth and h cannot simply be replaced by h’. In the
design method, wave force in the case of (a) in which h’ = h and the case of (e) in which h’ = 0 is linearly interpolated
and indicates wave pressure distribution as the same as that of equation 4.1 or when under normal hydrostatic pressure.
z Tsunami wave pressure distribution z Load of the lost portion is disregarded.
based on equation 4.1.
x Building x
3h
3h
Design inundation depth Design inundation depth Building
h
h
3ρgh 3ρgh
(a) When pressure-resistant members are all positioned (b) When the building is 3h or lower
from 0 to 3h in direction z
1/2
3h
3(hh’)
Design inundation depth Design inundation depth
h’
h
3 ρg(hh’)
1/2
3ρgh
3ρgh
(c) When pressure-resistant members shift in direction x (d) When pressure-resistant members are missing
between 0 and h in direction z
3ρgh
Equation 4.12) is proposed based on tests targeting structures with a distance from perpendicular revetments of 2.5
– 20 times the height of the wave. In addition, since there are no obstacles between the perpendicular revetments and
the structures, the structures are directly exposed to the effects of tsunami wave pressure. There are also studies9),10)
indicating that, once over the revetments, force is reduced by trees, structures, etc., and it is thought that flow velocity
also decrease. In this design method, it is considered possible to reduce the load according to the state of obstacles in
the area of inland incursion based on special surveys.
Topography is especially complex in the vicinity of river estuaries, ports and harbors that tsunami load is
conjectured to be generated from all directions. On flat topography, etc., however, it is thought to be possible to
conjecture the direction of tsunami advance through the appropriate use of numerical simulation results, etc. However,
since it is conceivable even in such case that the direction of tsunami advance may differ from the assumed direction
based on the analysis assumptions of numerical simulations, distribution of structures in the surroundings and other
factors, it would be preferable to assume that the load in the perpendicular direction will be half or more of the load in
the direction of advance as indicated in Fig. 4-4.
qy >0.5qx … (4.4.)
Qy >0.5Qx … (4.4’)
Where,
qy is tsunami wave pressure in the direction perpendicular to the direction of advance (kN/m2)
Qy is tsunami wave force in the direction perpendicular to the direction of advance (kN)
In addition, since there are reports that greater damage to residences, etc., is inflicted by wave backwash, it would
be preferable to assume, unless a special study is conducted, that the load is the same as that in the direction of advance.
y
Perpendicular direction
more than 0.5qx、or
more than 0.5Qx
Direction of advance Wave backwash
qx or Qx qx or Qx
x
building
Perpendicular direction
more than 0.5qx、or
more than 0.5Qx
A combination of loads as indicated below is taken into account in the design of structures to withstand tsunami
load.
G + P + 0.35S + T (regions of heavy snowfall) … (5.1.)
G + P + T (regions other than regions of heavy snowfall)
Where,
G is force generated by dead load
P is force generated by live load
S is force generated by snow cover load
T is force generated by tsunami load
Unless a special study, etc., is conducted, regions of heavy snow are those regions designated by specified
government agencies as provided for in Article 86, Paragraph 2 Proviso, Enforcement Regulations of the Building
Standards Law.
<Comments>
A combination with dead load, etc., is taken into account in this design method, rather than a combination of
tsunami load and seismic load.
<Comments>
Tsunami load increases as design inundation depth increases. For example, if design inundation depth is 1m,
based on equation 4.1, the maximum tsunami wave pressure is 29.4kN/m2, on the order of 10 times greater than wind
pressure. It would be difficult in both technological and economical terms to design all pressure-exposed surfaces as
pressure-resistant members. In addition, if pressure-exposed members are broken and the structure is inundated,
problems would arise with its usage. Accordingly, in this design method, a clearly defined distinction is made between
pressure-resistant and non-pressure-resistant members.
Section 7. Structural framework design
It is confirmed by the following equation that the horizontal load carrying capacity of the structural framework is
equal to or greater than the horizontal load of the tsunami in all directions at each story.
<Comments>
Shear force carrying capacity is based on the same approach as the shear force carrying capacity due to seismic
load provided for in Article 82-4, Item 1, of the Building Standards Law. It is necessary to be aware of the following
cautions, however, due to the differences between tsunami load and seismic load.
(1) Tsunami wave load concentrates in pressure-exposed surfaces.
(2) It is necessary to make a judgment regarding a rigid floor assumption if there are stairwells or other openings
near pressure-exposed surfaces, etc.
<Comments>
Seismic load is ordinarily greater in the upper stories and tsunami load is greater in the lower stories. This means
that, if the same shear force is generated in the building, the overturning moment due to the tsunami load becomes
smaller than that of seismic load. In this design method, the overturning moment due to tsunami load is compared to
the resistance moment of the structure in accordance with Building Foundation Structural Design Guidelines11). The
examination is carried out taking buoyancy into account if necessary.
Qk <µ(W − Qz ) … (8.2.)
Where,
Qk is horizontal tsunami load generated in the foundation (kN)
Qz is buoyancy (kN)
µ is the friction coefficient of the reinforced concrete foundation and the ground
W is the total weight of the building (kN)
<Acknowledgement>
In conducting this research, the Building Center of Japan (BCJ) surveyed the results of existing research,
requested experts at the forefront of tsunami research to provide lectures and study sessions were held twice. The first
time, Mr. Tetsuya Hiraishi of the Port and Airport Research Institute gave a lecture entitled Tsunami wave force acting
on coastal structures. The second time, Prof. Fumihiko Imamura of the Disaster Control Research Center, Graduate
School of Engineering, Tohoku University, gave a lecture on Tsunami occurrence and damage, Prof. Koji Fujima of the
Department of Architectural Environment Engineering, School of Systems Engineering, National Defense Academy of
Japan, on Tsunami wave action theory and numerical analysis, and Mr. Masashi Matsuyama of the Abiko Research
Institute Department of Fluid Science of the Central Research Institute for Electric Power Industry on Tsunami wave
force experiments. In addition, we also received valuable opinions from members of the Tsunami Damage Estimate
and Alleviation Research Subcommittee (Japan Society of Civil Engineers) and reflected this advice in the present
design method. We would like to take this opportunity to express our appreciation to all of them.
<Appendix>
A1. Literature survey of previous studies on tsunami wave pressures and forces.
Here in , previous experimental studies of wave pressures and forces on structures of the inland incursion of
tsunami are reviewed. Tsunami Assessment Technology for Nuclear Power Plants Civil Engineering Institute of
Japan(In Japanese), Feb.2002.introduces the results of existing research.
A1) Equation for tsunami wave pressure without soliton break up ( Asakura et.al. 20002))
The following Eq.(A-1) and (A-2) are proposed empirical formula based on tests of tsunami wave flowing
over perpendicular revetments.
pm ( z ) = (3ηmax − z ) ρg ・・・・・・・(A-1)
in case of hc /h=0.73
pm : maximum tsunami wave pressure by Eq.(A-1)(0 ≦ z/ηmax ≦ 3)
z : height of the relevant portion from ground level.
g : gravitational acceleration
ηmax : maximum inundation depth
ρ : mass per unit volume of water
h : static water depth at revetment
hc : height of revetment from static water level
A2) Equation for tsunami wave pressure with soliton break up ( Asakura et.al. 20002))
2.2ηmax
3ηmax
3ηmax
Building Building
0.8ηmax
ηmax
Fig.1 Tsunami wave pressure based on Eq.A-1 Fig.2 Tsunami wave pressure based on Eq.A-2
A3) Equation for tsunami wave pressure without soliton break up ( Ikeno et.al. 20015))
( )
pm ( z ) = 2.2 a H − z αρg
3 ・・・・・・・(A-3)
pm : maximum tsunami wave pressure by Eq.(A-3)(0≦z/aH≦3:above the surface of the static water)
z : height above the ground
aH : tsunami wave amplitude
a : impact coefficient ( = 1.36)
ρ,g are indicated in Eq.(A-1)
in case of hc /h=0.73
FH: tsunami force by Eq.(A-4)
B : width of structure
L : length of structure
CD: drag coefficient ( = 2.05) CM : mass coefficient ( = 2.19)
Cθ: impact coefficient ( = 3.6tanθ) θ : angle of wave
u.
: velocity of tsunami wave in the direction of advance
u: acceleration of tsunami wave in the direction of advance
η : inundation depth
g,ρ ,h ,hc are indicated in Eq.(A-1)
A5) Equation for tsunami force to house (Iizuka and Matsutomi 20007))
This studies were perfomed in order to make the relationship between drag forces and damage degrees of
houses. Drag forces are evaluated based on damages of houses due to recent earthquakes occurred in Japan.
1 ・・・・・・・(A-5)
FHD = ρC D u 2 h f Bh
2
FHD : Horizontal force by Eq.(A-5)
CD : drag coefficient ( = 1.1∼2.0)
u : velocity in inland
hf : inundation depth in front of the house