Anda di halaman 1dari 11

1

ISABE-2007-1282

Advanced Technologies for Next Generation Regional Jets


- Survey of Research Activities at MTU Aero Engines

Martin Engber, Klaus Rüd,


Sabine Ardey, Jochen Gier, Walter Waschka

MTU Aero Engines, Germany

Abstract LPTs, typical for geared turbofans. It is well known


that MTU together with Partners Pratt & Whitney
This paper will address current demands and devel- and Fiat Avio have been intensively working on the
opments in advanced compressor and turbine design geared turbofan concept to provide a step change
at MTU. Latest highlights achieved on new HP com- improvement to the aircraft customer. MTU has been
pressor and LP turbine technologies will be pre- dedicated to take responsibilities in the high speed
sented. Both components constitute key competences LPT and the HPC components.
for MTUs civil aero engine business.

The paper will start with an overview on engine key


Abbreviations
requirements for the next generation of regional air-
craft expected for the years 2013-2015. Engine con-
ACARE Advisory Council of Aeronautical
cepts include conventional high bypass turbofans and
Research in Europe
more advanced new concepts such as geared turbo-
ADP Advanced Ducted Propfan
fans. Subsequent compressor and turbine design re-
ATE Aerospace Technology Enterprise
quirements have been derived from detailed configu-
ATFI Advanced Technology Fan Integrator
ration analysis and competitive assessment among
BPR Bypass Ratio
the aero engine industry. Strong emphasize will be
CLEAN Component Validator of
put on both high performance and economic im-
Environmentally Friendly Aero Engine
provements compared to existing engine families in
ECMS Engine Control & Monitoring Systems
service. Fuel burn reductions in the range of 15%
EEFAE Efficient Environmental Friendly
and maintenance cost reductions of more than 30%
Aero Engine
are the most prominent challenges.
6th FRP EU 6thFramework Program
HPC High Pressure Compressor
Subsequent to the requirements the paper will illus-
LPC Low Pressure Compressor
trate the MTU technology and conceptual approach
LLP Life Limited Parts
to satisfy the demands. Highly innovative world class
LPT Low Pressure Turbine
compressor concept will be presented which are pres-
MEMS Micro Electronic Mechanical Systems
ently under test validation. The main characteristics
MTU MTU Aero Engines GmbH
of the new compressor concepts are full 3D Aero
OPR Overall Pressure Ratio
including casing treatment, all blisk light weight tie
PAX Passengers
shaft rotor and advanced thermal management and
PR Pressure Ratio
radial gapping concepts. In addition, dedicated tech-
TET Turbine Entry Temperature
nology activities to further support significant im-
TF (GTF) Turbofan (Geared Turbofan)
provements in efficiency, weight and costs will be
highlighted, also including potential benefits from
advanced control, monitoring and design methodolo-
gies.

Similarly for turbines, latest developments and efforts


at MTU will be described. Apart from conventional
turbines special focus will be attributed to high speed
2

Introduction
- further improving existing engine types
The application of turbofan propulsion to subsonic - new engine concepts
transport aircraft has gone through an evolutionary - and significantly further advanced component tech-
process during the past 40 years, which substantially nologies for compressors turbines and combustors ,
has contributed to the success of commercial avia- including efficiency increase, weight reduction and
tion. This process, driven by the market needs, pro- life extensions.
duced numerous technical innovations to the engine
yielding significant improvements in engine perform- In addition,
ance economics, in safety and reliability and also in - smart control of overall engine and component op-
terms of noise and emissions. eration as well as
- power optimized engine accessories and systems
With respect to the future, the replacement of existing will supplement the improvements from the turbo
100-200 PAX aircraft will be a next opportunity for machinery components.
introducing a new generation of aircraft and engines.
In preparing the transition into a new generation of In preparation of the new engine generation for re-
aircraft the aero industry is facing fierce headwinds gional transport, extensive configuration and installa-
in terms increasing fuel prices, noise restrictions, tion studies are under way. Similar studies should
limiting exhaust gas emissions, not only in Europe, help to align airframe and market needs with the en-
but within the entire globe. gine manufacturers capabilities. As shown in Fig 1,
significant improvements in engine economics, envi-
ronmental capabilities and reliability are being ex-
pected. Translated to a more general set data, the fol-
lowing engine requirements were evaluated relative
to existing engines

- 5-10% improved propulsive and thermal


efficiency, via increased BPR, OPR and turbine
inlet temperature
- 0,5-1% increased efficiencies per component
- 20% reduced cooling air consumptions
- 50-100% increased LLP life
- 20-30% manufacturing cost reductions
across the entire engine.
Fig. 1: Commercial requirements for next genera-
tion Aircraft impose significant challenges Similar requirements call for extensive new tech-
nologies and new configurational answers. Present
Fig. 1 illustrates the future demands and indicates the Paper will specify such answers from MTU perspec-
principle approach for the engine manufacturer. Fur- tive. Prime emphasize will be put on engine architec-
ther advanced engine components and new engine tural options and on dedicated MTU key components
concepts are compelled to provide fuel burn reduc- such as HPC and LPT.
tions up to 50 % combined with extensive noise and
emission reductions up to -40dB cum and -80% NOx
respectively. Half of the fuel burn reductions are at- Advanced Engine Concepts
tributed to the engine; the remainder will be supplied
from the aircraft manufacturer. Correspondingly cost Future advanced engine concepts will in general con-
constraints are expected to drop maintenance and tinue to aim at further improving thermal and propul-
manufacturing costs of the engine by up to 30% and sive efficiency (reducing specific thrust) and devel-
more. The targets shown in Fig. 1 are specified into oping low noise, fuel and cost efficient components.
short to mean term customer needs and longterm vi- Fig. 2 shows this trend as applied to the further de-
sions as projected by European aeronautic agencies velopment of existing engine types. Further increas-
ACARE. Similar requirements have also been pub- ing the bypass ratio (BPR) up to 10-11 will enhance
lished by US organizations such as ATE. In conse- propulsive efficiency and further reduce the engine
quence of the aggressive demands, the development noise due to reducing jet velocities and reducing fan
of future engines will require to comprehensively tip speeds.
deploying the potentials from
3

small and large thrust class applications. In 1992 the


partners successfully run the Advanced Ducted Prop-
fan (ADP) demonstrator engine for bypass ratios up
to 14 to demonstrate the technology for fuel efficient
long range applications. More recently they intro-
duced the Advanced Technology Fan Integrator
(ATFI) representative to smaller thrust class engines
(Fig. 4). Latest Efforts aim at a new PW6000 based
GTF demonstrator to support the development of 20-
30 klb new engine generation for regional aircraft.
The GTF bears the advantage to separate the low
speed Fan component from the LPC and the LPT.
Thus both component categories, i.e. Fan on the one
side and LPC/LPT on the other side can run at their
optimum speeds allowing uncompromised maximum
Fig. 2: Future advanced Turbofans will continue the benefit in terms of component efficiencies, stage
trends of recent designs count (weight, cost) and noise (low fan speed for
minimum noise).
Increasing of overall pressure ratio (OPR) and turbine
entry temperature (TET) will enhance thermal cycle So far, geared systems were confined to demonstrator
efficiency and need even more powerful and compact applications only, but within the scope of new chal-
engine cores which should counteract the weight lenges from environmental and commercial con-
penalties from enlarging BPR and Fan diameters. For straints, studies have confirmed that the GTF will
regional application OPR and TET are expected become a highly attractive alternative for the new
climb towards and beyond 40 and 1900 K respec- generation of aircraft. The emerging demonstrator
tively. On the component level, further increase of program will demonstrate this to the public.
efficiency has to come along with enhanced stage
loadings. Enhanced stage loading throughout com-
pressors and turbines should allow to reducing stage
count for minimizing manufacturing costs. For the
HPT cooling air consumption has to be limited by
introducing advanced cooling concepts including new
aspects such as cooling air cooling.

Fig. 4: MTU/PW support the new concept by


extensive GTF demonstrator programs

In addition, latest considerations also include counter


rotating Fans again, both ducted and unducted (Fig.
5). Similar concepts have already been studied during
the eighties and nineties but in those times they were
rejected due to strong weight and noise penalties
from the big two stage fan propulsion system. Mean-
Fig. 3: The Geared Turbofan for maximum while new approaches obviously have been generated
propulsive efficiency and minimum noise to overcome such hurdles and to start new technology
initiatives to generate technical maturity within ac-
The geared turbofan features a new engine concept, ceptable timeframes (e.g. GenY).
aiming at very high Bypass ratios and OPRs (Fig. 3).
Since more than 15 years, Pratt and Whitney America
(P&WA), Pratt & Whitney Canada (P&WC), Fiat
Avio and MTU are jointly working on the develop-
ment of geared turbofan engine technologies for
4

For the high pressure system, there are two major


HPC categories, addressing the different range appli-
cation:

Fig. 5: Counter rotating Fans designed by MTU

Future HPC Compressor and LPT design


requirements

The HPC is one of MTU’s prime competence com- Fig. 7: Pressure Ratios for engine concepts with
ponents within its civil and military aero engine de- 1 stage HPT and 2 stage HPT
velopment activities (Fig. 6).
1. Axial compressors for big core engines with a two
EJ200 LPC/HPC
PW6000 New Bizjet Engines NGPF stage HPT, dedicated primarily to long range applica-
PW6000 HPC tions. In this class the trend towards highest OPRs
IGT HPC
leads to HPC pressure ratios around 18-22 whilst the
PW8XX
stage count will be not higher than 8-10. Correspond-
RB199 IPC/HPC ing efficiencies will need to reach the 90% polytropic
efficiency goal.
NEWAC
FNDV
Rig 250

ATFI 2 JTDP03-
NGSA Rig
Engine Programm
2. Axial compressors (Fig 7) for core engines with
Demo
Rig 234
Rig 248/02
Demo-Engine one stage HPT for short and medium range applica-
Rig 251
tions. The HPC pressure ratio will increase consid-
1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 erably beyond 12 while keeping the stage count
lower than 7. A typical example constitutes the MTU
Fig. 6: HPC development at MTU HDV12 for the PW6000 engine (18-25 klb thrust
range): 6 compressor stages are generating a PR of
MTU developed the HPC for the RB199, which is about 11, offering high efficiency, outstanding per-
used in the Tornado aircraft and more recently the formance, operability and durability to competitive
HPC for the new EJ200 which is the propulsion sys- costs.
tem for the Eurofighter. By providing the HPC for
the PW6000, MTU started to supply the regional Independent of the application, the new compressor
civil aircraft market. Presently MTU prepares for generation will need world class efficiency levels in
developing highly advanced axial compressors for the range of 90% and despite the requirement for
engines for the next generation of midsize regional nearly double the life of existing systems, the weight
jets and for future mid and large size business jets. As will have to be minimized to levels that are 10-20%
shown in Fig. 6, extensive technology and demon- lower than known from existing engines for similar
strator programs have been accompanying the prod- thrust classes. Cost wise a challenge, as indicated
uct developments. For the anticipated future applica- above, in the order of 20% and more will have to be
tions, corresponding activities are already underway. fulfilled.

Fig. 7 illustrates the current trends in compressor On the LPT side, MTU has a strong history on both
development towards higher stage loading, both for developing conventional low speed turbines for con-
HPC and LPC. The High-speed low pressure com- ventional turbofan engines and also high speed LPTs
pressors (LPC) – as used for geared turbofans will for Geared turbofans (Fig. 8).
adopt stage loadings similar to the HPC. The pressure
ratios needed, will be accomplished by only half the
stage count of conventional LPCs.
5

and secondary flow losses. Especially the hub and the


tip region of the blades have to be designed very
carefully. The interaction of near wall leakages, tip
clearance flow, secondary flow vortices and profile
boundary layers are a big challenge for the design
engineer due to different behavior at different engine
operating points.

Especially at part speed the airfoils have to work un-


der bad inflow conditions and tend to flow separa-
Fig. 8: LPT development at MTU tion. For these flow conditions the flow in the tip
region can be stabilized by the use of so called casing
Similar to the HPC, a perpetual strive for simultane- treatments (Fig. 10).
ously increasing stage loadings, reducing stage count
and further increasing efficiencies will be mandatory.
Efficiency levels will have to increase up to 93% .
For GTF typical loadings will be in the range of PR 7
in 3 stages or PR 5 in 2 stages respectively yielding
stage pressure ratios up to 2.2. The correspondingly
very high wheel speeds needed claim for new design
concepts to minimize blade and disc weights such as
to maximize the benefit from significantly lower
stage counts.

The conventional LPT will have to strive for lower


stage count as well without loosing efficiency. This
drives high flow path radii and very high specific
loadings. The subsequent weight challenge results
rather from the big geometric size of the LPT than Fig. 10: HPC with Casing Treatment
from the high speed levels for GTFs.
Casing treatments suck in the low energetic flow di-
rectly over the blade tip and inject it in front of the
blade leading edge. Through this the weak end wall
boundary layer gets energized and stabilized and the
tip leakage vortex is reduced. That leads to a much
higher compressor stability primarily at low engine
speed (Fig. 11).

Surge Line with Casing Treatment


Surge Line w/o Casing Treatment
Total Pressure Ratio

Fig. 9: Advanced LPT design


Speed-Lines

Advanced Compressor design

Fuel burn and maintenance costs reduction of future


advanced engine concepts require a new compressor Massflow
generation with world class efficiencies. Future HPC Fig. 11: HPC map with / without CT
designs will feature high efficiency levels in the
range of 90% while weight and part count have to Similar geometric modifications can also improve the
decrease further. This results in a higher loading of stability of the hub flow. Well designed fillet radii
the compressor blading with very high requirements can avoid flow separation on the airfoil suction side
on the aerodynamics of blade profiles and blade behind the leading edge (Fig. 12 and 13).
shape in order to avoid flow separation, shock losses
6

compressor. With this method the designer can de-


termine the areas of maximum attack of erosion in
the compressor blading which have to be coated for
longer maintenance rates.

Fig. 12: Streamlines close to end wall for blade with


optimized fillet radius Fig. 14: Particle trajectories in a three stage LPC

MTU Aero Engines has developed a new innovative


nanostructured multilayer coating ERCoatnt for a bet-
ter protection of the compressor blades and vanes.
The coating consists of several hard ceramic and soft
metallic single layers (Fig. 15) which are evaporated
on the blades in a special coating facility. The whole
coating is just some twenty to fifty nanometers thick.
Therefore the influence on aerodynamics and me-
chanical behavior of the blades is negligible.

Fig. 13: Streamlines close to end wall for blade


without fillet radius

The high incidence swirl of the near wall streamlines


reduce the secondary cross flow in the cascade pas-
sage. Thus the corner stall can be avoided and the
compressor airfoils can operate at high efficiency in a
much bigger range. Additional leading edge bulb
modification can strengthen this flow effect and re-
duce the secondary flow losses in the end wall region
of compressor blades significantly. Fig. 15: Nanostructured multi layer coating with
hard ceramic and soft metallic single layers
In addition to the reduction in fuel burn the second
big challenge for future engines is the reduction in The findings gained from specimen tests with two
maintenance costs. The required durability of com- different coatings showed very good results. Espe-
pressors demands to keep the running properties of a cially in the first test ours in erosive environment the
compressor on a very high level even after many coated specimens had nearly no mass loss (Fig. 16).
hours of operation. Deterioration due to particle ero- In order to reach a given maximum mass loss the
sion can cause an extensive decrease in efficiency time of erosion could be doubled for version 1 coat-
and stability. The operation of the engine in a sandy ing and even tripled for the new improved version 2
environment can decrease the time on wing between coating.
overhaul by 70%. Fig. 14 shows a 3D Navier Stokes
simulation of particle trajectories in a low pressure
7

the altitude test facility in Stuttgart for detailed aero-


dynamic evaluation. In Fig. 17 the rig test turbine is
shown. One can see the thick discs and the tapered
rotor airfoils.

Fig. 16: Erosion test results on specimens

In high erosive environment like in Afghanistan or


Middle East Countries ERCoatnt can double the time
on wing for compressor blades and increase opera-
tional readiness and decrease maintenance costs for
the customer.

High Speed LP Turbine Technology Development

Generally the LP turbine faces special challenges in a


geared turbofan architecture. Especially the optimiza-
tion of efficiency and weight becomes important.
Due to the high turning speed the number of stages
has to drop resulting in a significant stage pressure
ratio increase and leading to a high Mach numbers
level in the blading. Thus, the aerodynamic challenge
is primarily the combination of high Mach numbers
in combination with moderate low Reynolds num-
Fig. 17: Test-Rig with Measurement Positions
bers.
The second very important issue is the module
In Fig. 18 the measured turbine map is displayed in
weight. Due to the high rotational speeds the me-
terms of efficiency as a function of the specific work
chanical load on the airfoils is very significant. The
and speed. As can be obtained from this figure, the
weight of a high speed LPT is considerably driven by
maximum efficiency is located exactly at the aero
the allowable blade stresses, the disc loads and con-
design point. The characteristics for higher pressure
tainment. Due to this intensive interaction is needed
ratios shows no dramatic drop. Hence, despite the
between mechanical and aerodynamic optimization.
high Mach number levels the turbine is characterized
MTU has gathered a considerable amount of experi-
by a well conditioned operating map.
ence with these challenges in the past years through
For deeper understanding of the turbine behavior and
the three technology programs with high speed LP
of course improvement of the CFD validation base
turbines. Already about 15 years ago a three stage
local measurements are included inside the rig. This
high speed turbine has been developed and tested
is absolutely necessary for technological advance-
within the ADP Demo program. This turbine featured
ment.
high efficiency levels of the order of 93% isentropic.

In the ATFI program, which was the second high


speed LP turbine program, the concept of high speed
turbine was driven to extremely high design parame-
ters like the characteristic mechanical load parameter
A*n2, which exceeded a value of 6.5 (inch*rpm)2 in
the last stage. This was combined with a stage pres-
sure ratio of more than 2.3. Like in the ADP demo
program a turbine was tested within a demonstrator
engine and additionally a cold flow rig was tested in
8

the leakage are captured. This provides a significant


improvement especially in the prediction of the end
wall regions (Fig. 21).

Aero Design Point

Specific Work (J/(kg*K))

Fig. 18: Turbine Characteristic for Several Speeds

As an example a detailed comparison between ex-


periment and CFD is done using flow visualization.
This reveals interesting details on the flow structure
in terms of separation size as well as 3D structures
(figure 19). This provides also a good basis for com- Fig. 20: LP Turbine 3D-CFD Model including
parison with CFD. The flow in the second vane is Cavities
fully attached at this operating point with moderate
three-dimensional flow structure extend. The CFD
prediction was able to compute all main structures
with a small tendency for a conservative separation
bubble prediction.

Fig. 21: LP Turbine Component Radial Efficiency


Distribution with and without Cavities
Fig. 19: Flow Visualization for Second Vane, Com-
parison of Color Injection and Numerical The third high speed turbine was developed and
Simulation tested in the frame of the European CLEAN project.
This turbine was designed for the CLEAN engine
In order to further push limits in the design of high demonstrator. It is a three stage turbine with a cooled
speed LPT’s the numerical representation of the real first stage.
geometry has to be improved. One step ahead was the
inclusion of the cavity geometry into the CFD model The high speed, transonic, highly loaded 3-stage low
with full representation of the rim at tip cavities (Fig. pressure turbine uses novel technologies and features
20). By this the leakage flow and the mixing effect of developed at MTU Aero Engines (Fig. 22 and 23).
9

The LPT applies attributes like blade attachment for to now many electronic components could not stand
high An² and over speed protection without inter- the hot and harsh environment conditions with high
mesh. A new low weight rotor with slotted flanges temperature and vibration levels typical to aero en-
and a new sealing concept has been designed for the gines. Electronics had therefore to be placed at a lo-
turbine. cation with moderate environmental conditions –
centralized in the ECMS unit.

Driven by the demand from a wide range of applica-


tions high temperature electronics are now becoming
available on the market. This allows the design of
new control architectures which are characterized by
having a partitioned software (e.g. logic) running on
distributed hardware elements (e.g. processors). The
compartmentalization will be adapted to the required
functionality meaning for example that the interpreta-
tion of a sensor signal will be carried out in an elec-
tronic unit located directly next to the sensor.

In addition future aero engines will have to handle an


increasing number of electronic accessories. These
are bound to stepwise replace the classic hydro-
Fig. 22: High speed LPT vanes and blades mechanical systems as the power density and reliabil-
ity of electromechanical devices and the respective
The LPT has been laid out for a high inlet tempera- power electronics are now reaching aerospace stan-
ture with cooled first stage vane and blade. High lift dards.
blading and optimized gas path geometry have been
realized using a 3D-CFD. Thus, the demonstrator Consequently centralized ECMS will be gradually
engine test provides valuable validation for the hard- replaced by distributed architecture control systems
ware as well as for the underlying design methods. (Fig. 25), which are already quite common in Auto-
motive control and on their way for other Aerospace
applications (e.g. automatic pilot systems).

The advantages of a distributed control system are:


- Development cost reduction by:
modular standardized software
modular standardized hardware
standardized interlinks
simplified validation
- Maintenance cost reduction by:
eased fault localization
eased replacement of modules
- Increased safety by:
complexity reduction of wiring
increased redundancy
Fig. 23: High speed LPT module
With regard to engine control and monitoring MTU
Aero Engines holds a key position with European
Control System – progressing towards a distrib- military aircraft engines contributing to the Eu-
uted architecture rofighter (Typhoon), Tornado, Tiger and A400 M.
This high degree of experience is the stock from
Current Engine Control and Monitoring Systems which MTU Aero Engines is currently supporting
(ECMS) for aero engines possess a centralized archi- technological activities for the new central control
tecture: One single unit contains the central proces- unit and feasible components of a first generation
sor(s)- every sensor and actuator is linked directly to distributed control system. In addition MTU Aero
the central unit by dedicated electrical and power Engines supports the joint activities of the European
connections (Fig. 24). This is due to the fact that up aero engine industry to set up a research project on
10

distributed architectures within the 7th framework of hub and the tip of the blades were presented, which
the European Community. allow a high performance level over the whole range
of operation. For keeping the running properties of a
compressor on a very high level even after many
hours of operation MTU has developed a new inno-
vative nanostructured multi-layer coating ERCoatnt.
This coating protects the blades and vanes from ero-
sion and doubles the time between overhaul for these
parts in erosive environment.

In order to support the geared turbofan engine very


efficient high speed LPT’s were developed and
Fig. 24: Centralized control architecture tested. The design tools were optimized and cali-
brated and new aerodynamic features have been in-
cluded in the CFD tools. For achieving the weight
targets increased stage loadings and reduced stage
counts were realized.

The increased number of electronic accessories for


future engines can be handled by a distributed control
system. The modular configuration of software and
hardware leads to reduced manufacturing and main-
tenance costs while increasing the safety of each
Fig. 25: Distributed control architecture component.

The already performed demonstrator tests of the new


Summary geared turbofan design showed very good results and
obvious advantages versus the conventional turbofan
Significant fuel burn, noise, emission and mainte- engine. This technology will help to make a big step
nance cost reduction will be required for engines for forward for the next generation aircraft engines.
the next generation of regional aircraft. In order to
achieve this targets a further improvement of existing
engine types will not be satisfactory. A big technol- References
ogy step has to be done with new engine concepts
1
and considerable advanced component technologies W. Waschka, K. Rüd, W. Humhauser,
for compressors turbines and combustors. M. Metscher, A. Michel
“ATFI-HDV: Design of a new 7 stage innovative
The geared turbofan features a new engine concept, compressor for 10-18 klbf thrust”, ISABE-2005-1266
aiming at very high bypass ratios and overall pressure
2
ratios. By separating the low speed fan from the LPC P. Krammer, K. Rued, J. Trübenbach
and LPT each component can run in their optimum “Technology Preparation for green Aero Engines”
speed. That results in best component efficiencies AIAA, July 2003
(fuel burn), low stage count (weight, cost) and low
3
noise (low fan speed for minimum noise). Since K. Rued, E. Henrich, V. Westphal, K. Hain
many years MTU participates in geared turbofan “Entwicklung und Bereitstellung einer hochbe-
demonstrator programs like Advanced Ducted Prop- lasteten schnelllaufenden Niederdruckturbine fuer die
fan (ADP), Advanced Technology Fan Integrator Erprobung in einem Demonstratortriebwerk” Pro-
(ATFI) and the EVNERT program. Additional stud- ceedings DGLR Tagung, Sept. 2001, Hamburg Ger-
ies confirm, that the geared turbofan concept repre- many
sents a very attractive alternative with a lot of evident
4
advantages versus the conventional turbofan design. M. Engber, R. Selmeier, J. Truebenbach, E.
Steinhardt, “Fortschrittliche Verdichtertechnologie”
Besides the overall engine concept also the compo- Proc. DGLR Tagung, Sept. 2001, Hamburg, Ger-
nents have to be improved by new technologies. many
Main focus for the compressor are efficiency and
maintenance costs. New design modifications at the
11

5
R. Niehuis, K. Rued
“Entwicklung schnelllaufender Niederdruckturbinen
für künftige wirtschaftliche und umweltschonende
ADP Triebwerke”, Proc. DGLR-Tagung, Sept. 1997,
Munich, Germany
6
H. Sauer, R. Mueller, K. Vogeler, M. Hoeger, 2004
“Influencing the Secondary Losses in Compressor
Cascades by a Leading Edge Bulb Modification at
the Endwall”, ASME-Paper No. 2004-GT-473
7
T.I-P. Shih, Y.-L. Lin, 2003, “Controlling Secon-
dary Flow Structure by Leading Edge Airfoil Fillet
and Inlet Swirl to Reduce Aerodynamic Loss and
Surface Heat Transfer, Transactions of the ASME,
Vol. 125, Jan. 2003, pp. 48-56
8
M. Hoeger, R-D. Baier, R. Mueller, M. Engber,
2006, “Impact of a fillet on diffusing vane endwall
flow structure”, ISROMAC 2006-057
9
F. Malzacher, F., J. Gier, F. Lippl, , 2006
„Aerodesign and Testing of an Aero-mechanically
Highly Loaded LP Turbine”, J. of Turbomachinery,
Vol. 128, pp. 643 - 649
10
G. Wilfert, B. Kriegl, L. Wald, O. Johanssen,
2005,"CLEAN - Validation of a GTF High Speed
Turbine and Integration of Heat Exchanger Technol-
ogy in an Environmental Friendly Engine Concept",
ISABE-2005-1156, Munich

Anda mungkin juga menyukai