ON
PROJECT REPORT
ON
“Banking Requirements of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in the
IT Industry in Bangalore, and the ways in which SBI can tap this market”
BY
Kavitha Aruldass
Roll No. 40, PGDBM, 11th Batch (2005-2007)
Mr. S. Narayanswamy
DGM (SME, State Bank of India)
Local Head Office, Bangalore
XIME
XIME
3
CERTIFICATE
Bangalore
Date: Kavitha Aruldass
Forwarded By
XIME
XIME
4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This project report on SME Banking was a very rich learning experience in understanding
the whole business of SME Banking, especially the fast emerging IT SME (SMEs in the
Information Technology Industry) market. We offer our sincere gratitude to State Bank of
India, Local Head Office, Bangalore in general and Mr. S. Narayanswamy, Deputy
General Manager, SME in particular for giving us an opportunity to conduct a study in
this sector which has got so much potential. Also, we thank him for his continuous
guidance throughout the project.
We take this opportunity to also thank all the senior officials of SBI, Local Head Office
for listening to our presentation patiently and thus giving us a platform to showcase our
research findings and recommendations.
We thank all our batch mates who helped us with their suggestions at different times
during the project. We also thank all the Finance Managers of the IT SMEs who took the
pain of filling the questionnaire and thus contributing with vital inputs. We also thank the
banks who gave us access to interview their SME managers.
At last but not at all the least, we express our sincere gratitude to the Director and the
Dean, XIME for giving us an opportunity to undertake this two month long project. A
special mention has to be made at this point of time about our internal guides, Prof. Aram
Valarthan and Prof. S.P.Srinivasan who were a source of continuous guidance and
encouragement throughout the project. Without their apt comments and suggestions this
project wouldn’t have been successful. We express our sincere gratitude to them.
Kavitha Aruldass
XIME
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sl. Title Page No.
No
.
1 List of Tables 06
2 List of Figures/Charts 07
3 Executive Summary 08 - 15
4 Introduction
Introduction to SMEs
Overview of the Indian IT Industry 16 - 28
SMEs in the IT Industry
State Bank of India (SBI)
5 Problem Formulation
Need for the Study
Problem Definition 29 – 32
Research Objectives
List of Information Required
6 Research Methodology
Research Design
Sources of Data 33 – 35
Instruments of Data Collection
Sampling Design
7 Analysis, Findings and Interpretation
Demographic Profile of IT SMEs
Findings from IT SMEs 36 – 60
Findings from Banks
8 Conclusions 61 – 64
9 Recommendations 65 – 68
10 Limitations 69 – 70
11 Annexure
Annexure-A
Annexure-B 71 - 79
Annexure-C
12 Bibliography 80
XIME
6
List of Tables
Sl No Title Page No
1. Highlights of the Indian IT Industry : NASSCOM McKinsey Report 2005 20
2. India based service provider landscape : NASSCOM McKinsey Report
2005 22
3 Percentage of Turnover of IT SMEs coming from Exports 44
4. Expectation of Growth Rates by IT SMEs 45
5. Ranking of top demands of IT SMEs from the Commercial Banks 47
6. Ranking of Factors Important while selecting a bank: By prevailing IT 48
SME customers of SBI
7. Evaluation of SBI by its prevailing customers 49
8. Ranking of Factors Important while selecting a bank: By IT SME 49
customers of Other Banks only
9. Evaluation of Other Banks apart from SBI by IT SMEs 50
10 Ranking of Factors Important while selecting a bank: By IT SME 50
companies transacting with both SBI and other Banks
11 Overall Ranking of Factors perceived important while selecting a bank by 52
an IT SME
12 Ranking of Things that a Bank looks for in an SME before lending 56
13 Other Services provided by Banks to SMEs 58
List of Figures
Sl No Title Page no
XIME
7
XIME
8
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
XIME
9
Objective :
SMEs stand for Small and Medium Enterprises. GOI/RBI has taken several initiatives to
support the SME sector by formulating various schemes and policy guidelines for
promotion and development of SME units. The Union Finance Minister, Mr. P.
Chidambaram announced certain measures in Parliament on Aug.10, 2005 for stepping
up credit to small and medium enterprises, which is required to be implemented by all
public sector banks. The objective is to double the credit flow to SME sector from Rs.
6,76,000 million in 2004-05 to Rs. 13,52,000 million by 2009-10. The banks are
required to achieve a minimum of 20% growth year-on-year basis to SMEs.
In that regard, SBI (State Bank of India) is looking for markets with great SME potential.
Now, the IT industry has been doing very well and SMEs in the IT industry too are doing
very well. Karnataka, especially Bangalore, being the hub of IT related activities,
contributes a major share. According to the findings of UBS-Asia Business Monitor
(UBS-ABM II) latest survey, Indian SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises) leaders
consider the most important industry sectors to be IT&T (93 percent), building and
construction (89 percent), and financing, utilities and energy (82 percent each). The
survey also pointed out that 70 percent of Indian SMEs have said that their companies
have credit and finance needs on an ongoing basis. This is the highest percentage in
the Asia-Pacific region. Also, according to NASSCOM estimates, approximately 50-60
percent of the industry revenues will be from SME segment by 2008. Currently this
figure is less than 10-15 per cent.
As the future growth story of India is going to be scripted in a big way by these SMEs,
and IT (Information Technology) is expected to be the most important industrial sector,
with the prevailing credit and finance needs of these SMEs a need was felt to undergo a
study to find the Banking requirements of SMEs in the IT industry in Bangalore, for
Bangalore is the hub of all the IT related activities. Also, the scope of the study entails the
ways in which State Bank of India (SBI) can tap this potential market by fulfilling the
requirements of these SMEs, with due consideration to ever growing competition in the
Banking sector. The research work done thus had the following objectives to be attained :
XIME
10
Conclusions/Results :
1. IT SME is a big and fast growing potential market. NASSCOM
expects them to form 50 to 60% of the IT Industry by 2008 from
the current figure of 10 to 15%. Also, their own expectation of
growth is approximately 58% year on year, as found from the
research. There is a big market potential in Salary A/Cs and FOREX.
2. There are different Banking Requirements for different market
segments in IT SMEs
3. In terms of being the main lenders to IT SMEs, SBI has a good market
share of 33%. It is the joint market leader with State Bank of Mysore.
4. The market leader in the Salary A/C market is Citibank with 40%
market share followed by ICICI Bank at 22%. SBI has 6%.
XIME
11
8. The most important factors for IT SMEs while selecting a bank are :
Time Taken in Settlement of Transactions, Quickness of Decision
Making, Understanding and appreciation of the problems of the
company, Customization of Products and Past Relationship with the
Bank.
9. SBI has an excellent Brand Name and Image but it loses heavily to the
Private Banks on the important performance parameters mentioned in
the previous point. It has to be noted though that Brand Image was
rated as the least important parameter.
10. Customer awareness about SBI is low. Many SMEs are not aware of
the FOREX products offered by it and that it has Online banking
Facility.
11. Acceptance of SBI among these SMEs is around 66%. But the
alarming thing is that only 43% of its existing customers are willing to
continue with it and 57% are not sure about it, which is a negative shift
for SBI and thus it has to take care of retaining its customers.
12. Almost all the banks are focusing on SMEs and view IT SMEs as
potential target market.
XIME
12
14. Private Banks are already doing what this research has come out with.
They are already targeting only FOREX and Salary A/Cs of Software
and BPO SMEs.
18. USPs of private banks are based on the performance parameters while
those of nationalized bank on their Size, Status and Social
Commitment.
19. Banks are not providing enough advisory and Project Consultancy
Services while IT SMEs really need them.
XIME
13
Recommendations :
1. SBI should target Software and BPO SMEs for their Forex and Personal banking
of employees. They should target Hardware companies for Working capital and
Long-term loans primarily but see this market segment in totality and take care of
their all the banking needs.
2. SBI should adopt a strategy of “Challenger” to Citibank in the FOREX and Salary
A/C markets. They should also first of all carefully study the products, services
and delivery model of Citibank.
3. Ways of fulfilling top requirements of IT SMEs :
a. Infrastructure : Infrastructure requirements are in terms of office
premises & space and computer& equipments. SBI can collaborate with
Builders and developers to design an easy repayment product called
Infrastructure loan. It can also collaborate with companies like IBM and
HCL Technologies to provide and computer peripherals. SBI should
provide instant loan for the same.
b. People : SBI can take care of funding the training expenses of IT SMEs.
Also, it can design a way of encouraging students availing Student
Education Loans from SBI to think of IT SMEs as a career option. This
way it will be satisfying the needs of both the clients and as a mediator it
can charge commission.
c. Marketing : Hardware companies are mostly focusing on the domestic
market and even NASSCOM has suggested them to get hold of domestic
market first. Now, SBI can act as an interface between these hardware
SMEs and its other clients who will be interested in those products. This
way these SMEs will get a way to showcase their products. SBI can also
provide Marketing/Selling Consultancy services in the form of Market
Support Groups. They can also use their website to showcase the products
on the lines of E-bay. For software companies, same thing can be done
through overseas branches of SBI.
d. Funds : SBI has interest rates which is less than most other banks if not
all. In terms of products and terms and conditions also it is quite good, but
XIME
14
it needs to improve upon the delivery quite a lot. Also, it can come out
with customized products for IT SMEs depending upon the market
segment they are targeting. SBI can even think of Performance based
interest rates.
4. Before acting on all this though, to manage risk, SBI should pick companies on
the recommendations of its risk management group and credit rating by SMERA (
SME Rating Agency of India). SBI can even look to pay the nominal charges of
getting SMEs credit rated. And once it decides that this is the company to go for,
it should take care of all the banking needs of the company, like a business partner
sharing the risk, i.e. it should act as a venture capitalist with long-term investment
plan and outlook.
5. SBI needs to improve quite a lot on its delivery process. It should train its staff for
being more customer focused and customer friendly. They must show urgency in
solving problems of the customers. SBI can have a separate one point contacts in
terms of Relationship Managers. Also, it can have a dedicated webpage for faster
action on problems of IT SMEs on a high priority basis.
6. SBI should conduct a study on applying Lean Management Principles in its
operations and services. That study should come out with recommendations as to
how SBI can reduce its delivery or service time by doing away with steps that are
wasting time.
7. SBI should benchmark its Online Banking capabilities with banks like Citibank as
only Online banking is very important for IT SMEs.
8. SBI should create awareness about its technological upgradations, changing
attitude towards customers and should position itself more as “The Problem
Solver” on the performance parameters rather than the size and history of the
organization. It means it should couple its Brand name with performance.
9. It can even think of applying Customer Relationship Management software to
focus in a better way on its customers. It can use its website for taking feedbacks
and suggestions from the existing customers.
XIME
15
10. Private banks are providing Cheque Bounce Protection Facility which SBI is not.
To strengthen relationship, it should also provide this. Also, what it can do is that
they can have SMS alarming service to intimate the company that they are
running out of cash and they should hurry up to credit their account before the
bank closes for the day.
11. At last, SBI needs to bring a drastic change in attitude towards its customers. It
has shown its interest in doing so, now it needs to act quickly, again time is the
key.
XIME
16
INTRODUCTION
XIME
17
Introduction to SMEs :
SMEs stand for Small and Medium Enterprises. With the advent of planned economy
from 1951 and the subsequent industrial policy followed by Government of India, both
planners and Government earmarked a special role for small-scale industries and medium
scale industries in the Indian economy. Due protection was accorded to both sectors, and
particularly for small scale industries from 1951 to 1991, till the nation adopted a policy
of liberalization and globalization. SMEs always represented the model of socio-
economic policies of Government of India which emphasized judicious use of foreign
exchange for import of capital goods and inputs; labour intensive mode of production;
employment generation; non-concentration of diffusion of economic power in the hands
of few (as in the case of big houses); discouraging monopolistic practices of production
and marketing; and finally effective contribution to foreign exchange earning of the
nation with low import-intensive operations. It was also coupled with the policy of de-
concentration of industrial activities in few geographical centers.
It can be observed that by and large, SMEs in India met the expectations of the
Government in this respect. SMEs developed in a manner, which made it possible for
them to achieve the following objectives:
• High contribution to domestic production
• Significant export earnings
• Low investment requirements
• Operational flexibility
• Location wise mobility
• Low intensive imports
• Capacities to develop appropriate indigenous technology
• Import substitution
• Contribution towards defense production
• Technology – oriented industries
• Competitiveness in domestic and export markets
XIME
18
At the same time one has to understand the limitations of SMEs, which are as follows :
• Small and medium enterprises (SME), particularly the tiny segment of the
small enterprises, have inadequate access to finance due to lack of
financial information and non-formal business practices. SMEs also lack
access to private equity and venture capital and have a very limited access
to secondary market instruments.
• SMEs face fragmented markets in respect of their inputs as well as
products and are vulnerable to market fluctuations.
• SMEs lack easy inter-State or international market access.
• The access of SMEs to technology and product innovations is also limited.
There is lack of awareness of global best practices.
• SMEs face considerable delays in the settlement of dues/payment of bills
by the large buyers.
In spite of these limitations, the SMEs have made significant contribution towards
technological development and exports. SMEs have been established in almost all-major
sectors in the Indian industry such as:
•
Food Processing
•
Agricultural Inputs
•
Chemicals & Pharmaceuticals
•
Engineering; Electricals; Electronics
•
Electro-medical equipment
•
Textiles and Garments
•
Leather and leather goods
XIME
19
•
Meat products
•
Bio-engineering
•
Sports goods
•
Plastics products
•
Computer Software, etc.
GOI/RBI has taken several initiatives to support the SME sector by formulating various
schemes and policy guidelines for promotion and development of SME units. The Union
Finance Minister, Mr. P.Chidambaram announced certain measures in Parliament on
Aug.10, 2005 for stepping up credit to small and medium enterprises, which is required
to be implemented by all public sector banks. The objective is to double the credit flow
to SME sector from Rs. 6,76,000 million in 2004-05 to Rs. 13,52,000 million by 2009-
10. The banks are required to achieve a minimum of 20% growth year-on-year basis
to SMEs.
XIME
20
XIME
21
Increasing Exports
Export earnings accounted for 64 per cent of the total IT-ITES aggregate
in FY 2004-05. Strong fundamentals including a large base of skilled talent,
demonstrated quality and service delivery expertise at a significant cost advantage
and an enabling environment have ensured that India attracts a disproportionately
XIME
22
larger share of the global IT-ITES demand for off shored services – and continues to
drive India’s export-led growth.
IT-ITES exports from India grew from USD 13.3 billion in FY 2003-04 to
USD 18.2 billion in FY 2004-05. It is estimated that total IT-ITES exports from India
will exceed USD 23.9 billion in the current fiscal (FY 2005-06).
Software and services exports (excluding hardware) are projected to grow
at 32 per cent in the current fiscal.
India’s stock of foreign exchange earnings is amongst the highest in the
world, with reserves having risen from USD 5.8 billion in FY1990-91 to USD139
billion in January 2006.
XIME
23
The Indian software and services industry turned the recent slowdown into an opportunity
by positioning itself as the ideal outsourcing destination. Clearly, the winners in this
competitive environment were those companies that were able to segment the market by
predetermined parameters like size, verticals and geography. Companies, who were able
to align their offerings according to the market demands and establish a brand with
attributes that were relevant to these segments, emerged successful. This has been
particularly true in the case SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises). There are great
success stories to prove that despite the challenging market environment, niche SME
players with sound business models grew.
The SME sector will be a key ingredient for sustaining future growth of the Indian
software and services industry. However, SMEs will have to align their offerings
according to the demands of the industry to emerge successful in the long run.
Huge growth opportunities exist for Indian SMEs. To tap the potential that exists in the
domestic and export markets, SMEs in India would have to prepare themselves for the
following challenges:
Tap the domestic market, as it will act as a test bed for innovation and new
service lines and help in rapid accumulation of higher value-added skills through
development of low cost, tailored solutions for domestic companies and the
government.
Identify a defensible niche in nascent verticals such as healthcare, education,
transportation, utilities, e-governance, and technology areas like GIS,
embedded software or web services and product area.
XIME
24
The challenge that the Indian software and services industry faces is that despite its rather
large size, the SME market continues to remain low-key in terms of revenues and global
reach. However, according to NASSCOM estimates, approximately 50-60 percent of
the industry revenues will be from SME segment by 2008. Currently this figure is
less than 10-15 per cent.
Source: NASSCOM
Each branch of SBI takes care of businesses of very large corporations, medium
corporations, small business units, agriculture, government business and retail loans
including mortgages. It has a branch network of 9,000 and if the branches of its associate
banks are taken into considerations then the number of branches would increase to
14,000. State Bank has over 2 lakh employees on its payroll and including its associates
XIME
25
it’s 3 lakhs. State Bank is keen on positioning itself as a global bank. It has been trying to
increase its global footprint through overseas acquisitions.
• Foreign Subsidiaries: State bank of India International (Mauritius) Ltd, State Bank
of India (California), State bank of India (Canada).
XIME
26
State Bank of India has been playing a vital role in the development of small scale
industries. The bank has financed over 8 lakh SSI (Small Scale Industries) units in the
country; it has 55 specialized SSI branches, 99 branches in industrial estates and more
than 400 branches with SIB divisions. The Bank finances for Small Business activities
which are of special significance to a large number of people as many of these activities
can be started with relatively lower investment and with no special skills on the part of
the entrepreneurs. The following are the various products and services offered to Small
and Medium Enterprises:
PROJECT UPTECH :
SBI extends consultancy services through PROJECT UPTECH for technology up
gradation of small-scale industries. The bank's Consultancy Cells are trained for
comprehensive techno-managerial studies and the bank offers financial packages as
follow-up support for implementation of the up gradation ventures.
XIME
27
SSI LOANS:
General purpose term loans:
SBI grants term loans to small scale industries for meeting general commercial purposes
like substitution of high cost debt, research and development, shoring up net worth and
funding business expansion. The tenor of the loan is normally is 3 years, and the pricing
is fine-tuned to suit the risk profile of the borrower. The repayment is structured in
monthly or quarterly installments, according to the cash generation cycle.
XIME
28
Composite term loans can be sanctioned up to Rs.25 lakhs combining term loan and
working capital.
Entrepreneurship scheme:
SBI grants financial assistance to technically qualified, trained and experienced
entrepreneurs for setting up new viable industrial projects
Stree Shakti Package: the Stree Shakti Package is aimed at supporting entrepreneurship
among women by providing certain concessions, such as the margin will be lowered by 5
% as applicable to separate categories, the interest rate will be lowered by 0.5 % in case
the loan exceeds Rs.2 lakhs. No security is required for loans up to Rs.5 lakhs in case of
tiny sector units.
BUSINESS ENTERPRISE:
Assistance is provided for firm who has established a business venture for the purpose of
providing any services whose cost does not exceed Rs.10 lakhs. Extent of assistance is
normally capped at Rs 10 lakhs out of which working capital limit sanctioned can be up
to Rs 5 lakhs
XIME
29
XIME
30
PROBLEM FORMULATION
that their companies have credit and finance needs on an ongoing basis . This is the
highest percentage in the Asia-Pacific region. Also, according to NASSCOM estimates,
approximately 50-60 percent of the industry revenues will be from SME segment by
2008. Currently this figure is less than 10-15 per cent.
As the future growth story of India is going to be scripted in a big way by these SMEs,
and IT (Information Technology) is expected to be the most important industrial sector,
with the prevailing credit and finance needs of these SMEs a need was felt to undergo a
study to find the Banking requirements of SMEs in the IT industry in Bangalore, for
Bangalore is the hub of all the IT related activities. Also, the scope of the study entails the
ways in which State Bank of India (SBI) can tap this potential market by fulfilling the
requirements of these SMEs, with due consideration to ever growing competition in the
Banking sector.
Source: UBS-Asia Business Monitor (UBS-ABM II) survey 2006 and NASSCOM
Problem Definition :
“Banking Requirements of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) in the IT
Industry in Bangalore, and the ways in which SBI can tap this market”
Research Objectives :
o To study the market potential of IT SMEs
o To find the different market segments in this IT SME market
o To study the main requirements of IT SMEs
o To study the FOREX requirements
o To study the requirements of other value added services
o To study the market perception of SBI, market being the SMEs
o To study the SME products & services offered or planned to be offered by
other banks with special focus on IT Industry
XIME
32
o To study what performance factors in case of Banks are important for the
SMEs
o To do a comparative study of the Banks
o To recommend ways in which SBI can tap this market
XIME
33
XIME
34
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research Design :
1. Exploratory Research :- This form of research was used at two different
stages of the project :-
Firstly, it was used in the problem formulation stage to get insight
into the whole business of SME banking, and also to get
information regarding the SMEs in the IT industry in Bangalore.
Secondly, it was used while finding the products and services
offered to SMEs by banks apart from SBI. Websites of the banks
were studied.
2. Conclusive Research :-
Descriptive research :-
XIME
35
Cross-sectional Research :-
Survey Research :- After properly defining the
research problem, the type of research used was
conclusive to find out the possible solutions, by
getting the information required to achieve
research objectives. It was descriptive and not
experimental because of time and cost factors. It
was a cross-sectional one due to time constraint,
and survey research was used to add
effectiveness to it, but due to time and cost
constraints, sample survey was used in case of
SMEs while a few selected Banks were
surveyed to find answers to some very specific
research questions.
Sources of Data :
1. Secondary Sources :
a. Websites of : Reserve Bank of India, SIDBI, NASSCOM and
some commercial banks.
b. Some published articles related to SME banking, given by SBI
c. A book on “Marketing of SME products” published by State Bank
Staff College, Hyderabad.
2. Primary Sources :
a. IT SMEs of Bangalore
b. Some Commercial Banks in Bangalore
XIME
36
Sampling Design :
a. Population Definition : The population for sampling is the list of all the
STPI (Software Technology Parks of India) members in the Karnataka IT
Directory 2005 designated as SME, with their office being in Bangalore City.
b. Sampling Technique :
“Non-probability sampling through
Convenience Sampling”
IT SMEs were called up to get appointments with their Finance
Managers. All those companies which gave access, form the
sample pool of the study irrespective of their locations. The
companies are from Jayanagar, J.P.Nagar, BTM Layout,
Koramangala, Elecronics City, Airport Road etc.
c. Sample Size : The sample size is 32
d. Apart from this a few selected banks were surveyed like SBI, Union Bank of
India, State Bank of Saurashtra, ICICI Bank and HSBC.
XIME
37
XIME
38
All the companies surveyed were Private Limited Enterprises
XIME After
39
5 to 10 crores
XIME
40
9
The one company shown to be established before 1990 was listed as an SME in the
Karnataka IT Directory 2005, but when its Finance Manager was interviewed, he said
that its turnover stood above Rs.25 crores. It’s amazing to see that about 58% of the
companies started after 2000 have their turnover between Rs.5 to 10 crores while those
started between 1996 and 2000 have not been able to cross the Rs.5 crore mark. This may
be attributed to the dotcom crash of 2000. And, thereafter the companies coming up learnt
from other’s mistakes and did very well. Thus, the newest startups have performed the
best if turnover is considered to be a parameter. It will be interesting though to see which
8
type of companies came up during these periods See the following graph:
XIME
6
41
It is quite clear that mostly software companies came up, though BPOs are also in good
number. So, it can be interpreted that Software and BPO start-ups after 2000 have grown
very fast. They have been able to achieve what the companies started between 1991-95
9
have achieved, in just a span of about 4 to 5 years.
8
XIME
5
42
Relati
7
Here also, considering the number of employees as a parameter for gauging growth, it can
be seen that the newest start-ups are at par with those started 10 to 14 years ago.
Sources of Working Capital Financing
It is quite clear that of the total amount required to finance their working capital, a large
number of SMEs depend upon banks. To get more insight into it, let’s see the same thing 5
for each area of operation. For the sake of simplicity, wherever Retained Earnings were
used along with Banks or Parent Company, they have been clubbed together accordingly.
4P
XIME
43
Op
It can be seen that although Banks are the only source of Working Capital Financing for
Hardware and BPO companies, for Software companies it’s their Parent Companies from
where they get their funds, though Banks also come into the picture with about 45%
software companies getting funds from banks. 1
Sources of Long-term Financing
XIME
44
It can be seen that for Long term source of finance, share of banks decrease as compared
to that of Working Capital while the share of Parent Companies increases.
So here again it can be seen that software companies cannot be said to be a very lucrative
market for Long-term loans. In fact, in case of long-term funds they depend more on their
parent companies. Also, following is the market share of the different banks in financing
both the Long-term and Working Capital requirements of these IT SMEs. 1
1
XIME
45
It is quite evident that State Bank of India and State Bank of Mysore have a good holding
over the SME financing market. But do they have the firepower to sustain and better it?
That can be seen from the market perception of SBI, which will be discussed later.
So, in the stark contrast to the previous chart, SBI finds itself with only 6% of the IT
SMEs Salary A/C market. The leader is Citibank with 40% market share followed by a
distant second in ICICI Bank with about 20% market share. Also, one point to be noted
here is that Public Sector Banks led by SBI were ruling the roost in case of Working
Capital and Long-term Financing, but in case of Salary A/Cs, it’s the Private Banks led
by Citibank. The reasons for all this will be dealt with while comparing different banks
which will come later.
XIME
46
Here again, it can be seen that Citibank is the market leader by a long way in terms of
FOREX market with SBI coming a far distant second with 16% market share. So, it is
clear that SBI is losing out in Salary A/C and FOREX markets.
As the respondents were more confident and comfortable in telling about the growth rates
of their own companies, the figures for IT Industry and SME sector be considered as their
perception only. The focus should be on the Company column. To analyze it further, take
a look at the following charts:
ABN
XIME
47
Ex
It can be seen that although NASSCOM expects a YoY growth of 30% for the IT industry
as a whole (though it predicts SMEs to form 50-60% of the total industry by 2008, from
the current figure of 10-15%), SMEs expect very high growth for their companies in the
coming 5 years. Software companies have the highest expectations. Also, the figure is
above 50% for companies formed after 1995. One important thing is that if they grow as
per the expectations, then within 5 years they will be having annual turnover more than
Rs.40 crores, and bigger and expanding business means more business for banks
XIME
48
associated with them. Also, the number of employees will increase with the growth which
can translate into more Salary A/Cs for the banks. Thus, one thing is very sure that it is a
very big market which is tapped sooner, the better.
It is quite clear that Poor Infrastructure, Lack of Skilled People, Problems in Marketing
and Scarcity of Funds are the biggest obstacles for these IT SMEs. There is a very slight
difference in the ranking points. It has to be pointed here though that the Hardware
companies had a lots of problem with the Marketing of their products. They needed help
in terms of Market Support Groups. Also, these hardware companies had lack of funds
for training of the new recruits. They also felt that they have become like Training
SME
Institutes for the bigger companies. Some similar points that IT SMEs raised were Lack
of Recognition in the Market and Lack of Resources to take up large Projects.
Infrastructure still remained the number one problem. “Lack of Funds” comes a very
XIME
49
close fourth. IT SMEs didn’t feel that their SME status created any specific problems for
them.
There is hardly any significant difference among the three points above. Thus the three
top demands are viz. More Affordable Interest Rates, More Customer focused Behaviour
and Online Banking. Apart from these, some interesting demands raised are:
Performance based Interest Rates
Investments in IT SMEs should be considered as long term investments
Banks should be partners in the business like a Venture Capitalist
Promptness in Decision Making
Same bank for Salary A/Cs; Transfer from Corporate A/Cs to Salary A/Cs
Factors important while IT SMEs select their Bank, Market Perception of SBI
and its comparison with other banks
The sample size distribution in terms of with which Banks these IT SMEs have transacted
in whichever way is as follows:
XIME
50
Now just watch out for the ranking that these coloured factors get when evaluated for
SBI.
XIME
5 Quickness 5
5 Terms 5
6 Diversified 4.71
6 Time Taken 4.71
7 Understanding 4.57
8 Friendliness 4.42
8 Hassle 4.42
9 Customization 3.42
It can be seen that SBI matches the importance assigned with Past Relationship only
while considering the first rank. On the performance parameters like Quickness of
Decision Making and Time taken in settlement of Transactions, it is not able to meet the
expectations. It meets the expectations in terms of Transparency a little bit but the score is
too less to be considered a good one. It scores very low in terms of important factors like
Diversified Portfolio of Products, Understanding and appreciation of the problems of the
company and Hassle-free formalities also. It is an irony though that it scores the highest
in the least important factor Brand Image. Also, the total average cumulative score it gets
is 79.42 out of a possible maximum of 260.
Analyzing customers of other banks only :
Ranking Factors Important Points out of 2
1 Hassle-free formalities 2
1 Quickness of Decision Making 2
1 Time Taken in Settlement of Transactions 2
2 Customization of Products & Services 1.77
2 Friendliness of Personnel 1.77
2 Past Relationship with the Bank 1.77
3 Transparency 1.55
3 Understanding of the problems of the Company 1.55
4 Terms and Conditions 1.33
5 Brand Image of the Bank 1.22
5 Diversified 1.22
5 Flexibility 1.22
6 Location 1
XIME
52
5 Brand 7.2
6 Quickness 7
7 Flexibility 6.6
7 Terms 6.6
8 Transparency 6.2
9 Understanding 5.2
10 Customization 4.8
11 Diversified 4.2
In case of customers of other banks only, it can be seen that they are doing quite well in
terms of meeting the expectations of their customers. The points that they have got is also
on higher side. They have Hassle-Free Formalities and take lesser time in settlement of
transactions. The personnel are friendly and they also value past relationship quite a lot.
But even they have to improve upon Quickness of Decision Making, Customization,
Transparency and Understanding of the problems of the company. The average
cumulative score they have got out of 260 is 131.2 out of which Private Banks score129.6
while Public Sector Banks (PSBs) score 133.5. It will be interesting now to see what
happens with customers who have transacted both with SBI and other Banks
Analyzing those transacting with both SBI and other Banks :
Ranking Factors Important Points out of 2
1 Understanding the problems of company 2
2 Time Taken 1.87
3 Quickness 1.72
4 Customization 1.56
4 Transparency 1.56
5 Friendliness 1.44
6 Past Relationship with the bank 1.31
6 Terms and Conditions 1.31
7 Diversified Portfolio 1.13
7 Location 1.13
8 Hassle-free formalities 1.12
9 Flexibility 1
10 Brand Image 0.6
It can be seen that Time taken and Quickness are consistently being given high rankings.
Now for analyzing it further, comparison has been made between SBI and Private banks,
and SBI and PSBs.
XIME
53
Brand
Customisation
Past Relship
It can be seen that SBI is rated very low on the important factors when compared with
Location
Private Banks. It’s losing on Understanding, Time Taken and Quickness of Decision
Making in a big way while it has comparable scores for Terms & Conditions and
XIME Brand
Diversified
54
Transparency. It betters Private banks only in terms of Brand Image. So, it’s clear which
areas SBI needs to improve upon. While comparing with other PSBs, it can be seen that
things are neck to neck, and therein the advantage SBI has got because of its Brand Image
can help it win over other PSBs competing for the IT SME market. Also, the average
cumulative scores for SBI, Private Banks and PSBs stood at 111, 155 and 95.2
respectively out of a maximum possible 260 for 13 factors being studied.
The Overall Importance assigned and overall comparison :
Ranking Factors Important Points out of 2
1 Time Taken in settlement of Transactions 1.86
2 Quickness of Decision Making 1.79
3 Understanding of the Problems of company 1.71
4 Customization of Products & Services 1.50
4 Past Relationship with the Bank 1.50
5 Transparency 1.43
5 Friendliness of Personnel 1.36
6 Diversified Portfolio of Products 1.29
6 Hassle-free formalities 1.29
7 Flexibility 1.21
8 Terms & Conditions 1.07
9 Location 0.93
10 Brand Image 0.56
Apart from all these factors some factors important for a few companies were Better
Communication from the Banks and Online Banking. Let’s have a look as to how SBI,
Private Banks and PSBs stand in overall comparison.
XIME
55
So, it’s very important that SBI makes its delivery process and the whole approach more
customer focused and customer friendly. There is hardly any difference in the Terms and
Brand
Conditions being offered as perceived by the market. The deciding and the vital factors
are Time Taken in the Settlement of Transactions, Quickness of decision Making and
Understanding & Appreciation of the problems of the Company. The net average
cumulative score stood at 101.5, 142.3 and 106.1 for SBI, Private Banks and PSBs
respectively.
Customisation
Suggestions to SBI from IT SMEs; Things that would make them to bank with
SBI.
Some of the suggestions received are as under :
Faster clearance of Cheques
Past Relship
Online Banking with FOREX
Salary A/C with all the facilities
Customer approach like Multi-national Banks
XIME
Location
56
Long-term orientation
Flexibility
Better customer relationship management
Acceptance of SBI as a banker coming forward as a problem solver for IT SMEs
There is positive shift in the attitude if SBI improves its delivery. The only negative shift
is in case of prevailing customers where more than 50% customers said they Can’t Say,
while in all other cases respondents said that they would accept SBI as their banker.
Ac
XIME
57
Advances made to SMEs forms what percentage of the total advances made by
your bank?
Private Banks gave answers like Negligible and Not sure while the nationalized banks
had an average of 31.6%. It means that when it comes to lending as the main bankers,
nationalized banks are contributing more to the SMEs. This can be attributed to the social
commitment associated with them. Also, private banks are not that old in the Indian
market and may be that is why they don’t have a large percentage coming from SMEs.
Where do you want this percentage formed by IT SMEs to grow to after 5 years?
XIME
58
The private banks didn’t respond to that while the average for nationalized banks is 11%.
That is growth of over 600% percent in a space of 5 years. That shows their inclination
towards this potential market.
XIME
59
The responses of ICICI Bank and HSBC were: FOREX Remittances, Excellent
Customer Service, Personal Banking, Home loans for Employees and Corporate
credit cards. The responses from Nationalised banks were: Working Capital Loans,
Term Loans for Infrastructure, Remittances, Cash Management and Funds. From
the findings we had from IT SMEs, it is clear that Private Banks are more focused and
have a better understanding of the market as compared to the nationalized banks.
All the banks are providing Online Banking facilities. But it is amazing that all
the IT SMEs were demanding for Online Banking facility from the commercial
banks. It might be because they are not even aware of the services provided by their
banks and only the banks can blame themselves for not highlighting it.
The interest rates for most of the banks hovers around 10 to 11%.
Most of the banks said that they simply needed the financial statements of the
companies.
XIME
60
So banks are missing on providing Consultancy and Advisory Services, which actually
these IT SMEs need for they are having problems with Marketing and Human Resources.
HSBC, it seems has already done a study on SME Business Banking, as it can be found
out from it’s website. They know the obstacles faced by SMEs, and they are marketing
themselves as “We focus on your banking, so you focus on your business”. They have
separate facilities for small SMEs and large SMEs known as BusinessVantage and
Business Select respectively. They are providing things like Free Demand drafts, Free
Cheques payable at par, Free ATM card and Free Phone Banking and Internet
Banking. They have Dedicated Relationship Managers, Priority processing of
account related requests at their processing centre and Preferential rates and terms
on HSBC banking products for their SME customers. They also propose to provide
Factoring services for SMEs with 100% credit management and protection. Also,
XIME
61
they talk of something called Open Account Sales which allows SMEs to increase their
sales. What it exactly means is not known but what one can take from this is that they are
designing ways in which SMEs can be helped in marketing and selling of their products.
Now the main bank which we have to focus upon is Citibank for it emerged as the market
leader among the banks taking care of FOREX needs of IT SMEs as well as market
leader among the banks taking care of Salary Accounts of Employees of IT SMEs.
Citibank offers Suvidha Account to the employees/salaried people, which benefits both
Employers as well as Employees. The benefits for Employers are:
Online Salary Transfer
Paperless Reimbursement
Foreign Exchange Solutions
Corporate Credit Cards
Salary Alerts
Free drafts at over 700 locations
Benefits to Employees:
Anytime, Anywhere Savings Account
Value added Debit Cards that offer discounts on shopping,
fuel, grocery and other purchases
Free Investment and Insurance Advice
Free Bill Payment on the net
Relationship pricing on other products like Home Loans and
Personal Loans
In case of FOREX services, they are providing things like:
Remittance across 100 countries
Traveler’s Cheques
Foreign Currency drafts issued in very less time
Trade Remittances
In terms of Business Loans, Citibank is providing the following different types of loans:
XIME
62
XIME
63
1. IT SMEs are growing in a very big way. Even NASSCOM expects them to
form 50 to 60% of the IT Industry by 2008 from the current figure of 10 to
XIME
64
3. In terms of being the main lenders to IT SMEs, SBI has a good market share
of 33%. It is the joint market leader with State Bank of Mysore.
4. The market leader in the Salary A/C market is Citibank with 40% market
share followed by ICICI Bank at 22%. SBI has 6%.
XIME
65
5. The market leader in FOREX IT SME market is Citibank with 45% market
share. SBI has 16%.
8. The most important factors for IT SMEs while selecting a bank are : Time
Taken in Settlement of Transactions, Quickness of Decision Making,
Understanding and appreciation of the problems of the company,
Customization of Products and Past Relationship with the Bank.
9. SBI has an excellent Brand Name and Image but it loses heavily to the
Private Banks on the important performance parameters mentioned in the
previous point. It has to be noted though that Brand Image was rated as the
least important parameter.
10. Customer awareness about SBI is low. Many SMEs are not aware of the
FOREX products offered by it and that it has Online banking Facility.
11. Acceptance of SBI among these SMEs is around 66%. But the alarming thing
is that only 43% of its existing customers are willing to continue with it and
57% are not sure about it, which is a negative shift for SBI and thus it has to
take care of retaining its customers.
12. Almost all the banks are focusing on SMEs and view IT SMEs as potential
target market.
XIME
66
14. Private Banks are already doing what this research has come out with. They
are already targeting only FOREX and Salary A/Cs of Software and BPO
SMEs.
15. Nationalised Banks including SBI are underestimating the growth potential
of IT SMEs for they expect an annual growth of 5 to 7% in them. Private
banks are more optimistic with HSBC expecting 25% growth per annum.
The reality though is that SMEs themselves expect an average figure of 58%
year on year.
16. Important factors for banks before lending to IT SMEs are : Performance in
the past three years, Infrastructure, The Promoter and Purpose of loan in
that order of ranking for Nationalised banks. Private banks depend upon the
recommendation of their Risk Management Group.
18. USPs of private banks are based on the performance parameters while those
of nationalized bank on their Size, Status and Social Commitment.
19. Banks are not providing enough advisory and Project Consultancy Services
while IT SMEs really need them.
XIME
67
RECOMMENDATIONS
1. SBI should target Software and BPO SMEs for their Forex and Personal
banking of employees. They should target Hardware companies for Working
XIME
68
capital and Long-term loans primarily but see this market segment in totality
and take care of their all the banking needs.
2. SBI should adopt a strategy of “Challenger” to Citibank in the FOREX and
Salary A/C markets. They should also first of all carefully study the products,
services and delivery model of Citibank.
3. Ways of fulfilling top requirements of IT SMEs :
a. Infrastructure : Infrastructure requirements are in terms of office
premises & space and computer& equipments. SBI can collaborate with
Builders and developers to design an easy repayment product called
Infrastructure loan. It can also collaborate with companies like IBM and
HCL Technologies to provide and computer peripherals. SBI should
provide instant loan for the same.
b. People : SBI can take care of funding the training expenses of IT SMEs.
Also, it can design a way of encouraging students availing Student
Education Loans from SBI to think of IT SMEs as a career option. This
way it will be satisfying the needs of both the clients and as a mediator it
can charge commission.
c. Marketing : Hardware companies are mostly focusing on the domestic
market and even NASSCOM has suggested them to get hold of domestic
market first. Now, SBI can act as an interface between these hardware
SMEs and its other clients who will be interested in those products. This
way these SMEs will get a way to showcase their products. SBI can also
provide Marketing/Selling Consultancy services in the form of Market
Support Groups. They can also use their website to showcase the products
on the lines of E-bay. For software companies, same thing can be done
through overseas branches of SBI.
d. Funds : SBI has interest rates which is less than most other banks if not
all. In terms of products and terms and conditions also it is quite good, but
it needs to improve upon the delivery quite a lot. Also, it can come out
with customized products for IT SMEs depending upon the market
XIME
69
segment they are targeting. SBI can even think of Performance based
interest rates.
4. Before acting on all this though, to manage risk, SBI should pick companies
on the recommendations of its risk management group and credit rating by
SMERA ( SME Rating Agency of India). SBI can even look to pay the
nominal charges of getting SMEs credit rated. And once it decides that this
is the company to go for, it should take care of all the banking needs of the
company, like a business partner sharing the risk, i.e. it should act as a
venture capitalist with long-term investment plan and outlook.
5. SBI needs to improve quite a lot on its delivery process. It should train its
staff for being more customer focused and customer friendly. They must
show urgency in solving problems of the customers. SBI can have a separate
one point contacts in terms of Relationship Managers. Also, it can have a
dedicated webpage for faster action on problems of IT SMEs on a high
priority basis.
6. SBI should conduct a study on applying Lean Management Principles in its
operations and services. That study should come out with recommendations
as to how SBI can reduce its delivery or service time by doing away with
steps that are wasting time.
7. SBI should benchmark its Online Banking capabilities with banks like
Citibank as only Online banking is very important for IT SMEs.
8. SBI should create awareness about its technological upgradations, changing
attitude towards customers and should position itself more as “The Problem
Solver” on the performance parameters rather than the size and history of
the organization. It means it should couple its Brand name with
performance.
9. It can even think of applying Customer Relationship Management software
to focus in a better way on its customers. It can use its website for taking
feedbacks and suggestions from the existing customers.
XIME
70
10. Private banks are providing Cheque Bounce Protection Facility which SBI is
not. To strengthen relationship, it should also provide this. Also, what it can
do is that they can have SMS alarming service to intimate the company that
they are running out of cash and they should hurry up to credit their account
before the bank closes for the day.
11. At last, SBI needs to bring a drastic change in attitude towards its
customers. It has shown its interest in doing so, now it needs to act quickly,
again time is the key.
XIME
71
LIMITATIONS
XIME
72
1. Due to non-access to many IT SMEs because they were very busy with their
auditing work, and also because of other company specific problems, the sample
size is 32 only.
3. It was really difficult to get information from the banks through personal
interview for they feared that this was a study conducted as part of Summer
Project for a bank and company specific information will be revealed to their
banks.
4. Some of the areas couldn’t be explored for the time period was only 2 months.
Things like specific requirements were not revealed from the study.
XIME
73
ANNEXURE
ANNEXURE-‘A’
QUESTIONNAIRE FOR SMEs
XIME
74
3. Type of Organisation :
Sole Proprietorship Partnership
Private Limited Public Limited
4. Area of Operation : ( Can tick √ more than one as per the case )
Hardware Software BPO
Any Other, Please Specify ……………………………………………
6. What are your current sources of working-capital financing? ( Can √ more than
one )
Banks ( Please list few of them : …………………………………….)
Retained Earnings
Other Non-banking institutions
Contribution from friends and relatives
Others, please specify ………………………………………………..
7. What are your current sources of Long -term financing? ( Can √ more than one )
Banks ( Please list few of them : …………………………………….)
Retained Earnings
Other Non-banking institutions
Contribution from friends and relatives
Others, please specify ………………………………………………..
8. With which banks do you keep the Salary Accounts of your employees?
…………………………………………………………………………………
Reasons : a) ………………………………………………………………….
b) ………………………………………………………………….
XIME
75
12. What according to you are some of the biggest obstacles in getting the expected
growth rates? (Rank them: 1 for the biggest problem and so on)
Poor Infrastructure Scarcity of Funds
Lack of Skilled people Problems in Marketing
Your SME status Govt. Rules and regulations
Any Other ………………………………………………………………
Any Other ………………………………………………………………
13. What specific problems are being faced by you because of the SME status?
a. ………………………………………………………………………………
b. ………………………………………………………………………………
c. ………………………………………………………………………………
15. How can commercial banks help you in operating efficiently and achieving your
targets? Your top 5 needs/demands !!
More affordable interest rates Online Banking
More customer focused behaviour Any Other………………
Any Other…………………………………………………………………..
16. While selecting your bank, how important are the following factors for you? Give
a ‘√’ mark in the preferred box against each factor.
FACTORS V.Imp Imp Neither Not Not at
Imp nor Imp All
UnImp Imp
a) Terms and conditions
b) Hassle-free formalities
c) Friendliness of Personnel
d) Understanding and appreciation of
problems of the company
e) Flexibility
f) Transparency (In terms of costs
XIME
76
involved)
g) Quickness of decision making
h) Time taken in the settlement of
transactions
i) Diversified portfolio of products
( One Bank All Solutions)
j) Location No. of Branches
k) Past relationship with the bank
l) Customization of Products & Services
m) Brand Name of the Bank
b) ………………………………………………………………………..
17. Evaluate the banks on the factors mentioned below. (Assign marks out of 10, 1
being the lowest and 10 being the highest. )
Name of the Banks with which you are Your Your Your SBI
currently transacting Bank 1 Bank 2 Bank 3
18. What would really make you to bank with SBI ? Suggestions to SBI !!
XIME
77
a. ………………………………………………………………………………
b. ………………………………………………………………………………
c. ………………………………………………………………………………
19. If SBI comes forward as a solution provider to your problems, would you accept it
as your banker?
Yes No Can’t Say
XIME
78
ANNEXURE-‘B’
QUESTIONNAIRE FOR BANKS
5. Advances made to the SMEs forms what percentage of the total advances made
by your bank?
………………………………………………………………………………………
7. Where do you want this percentage formed by IT SMEs to grow to after 5 years?
………………………………………………………………………………………
8. What growth rate (in %) do you expect in the IT SMEs in the coming 5 years?
………………………………………………………………………………………
9. What are the things that you look for in an IT SME when approached for loans?
(Rank them: 1 for the most important thing and so on)
Its Infrastructure
Performance(Profit and Turnover) in the last 3 years
Who’s the Promoter?
The type and amount of collateral security it can give
The purpose for which the loan is needed
Any Other ……………………………………………………………….
10. Which are the areas in which you are providing products and services to IT
SMEs?
Working Capital Loans Long-term loans
FOREX Personal Banking for employees
Any other………………………………………………………………
11. What according to you are the top 3 requirements/demands of these IT SMEs
from Commercial Banks?
XIME
79
a. ........................................................................................................................
.
b. ………………………………………………………………………………
.
c. ………………………………………………………………………………
.
12. What steps are you taking to fulfill these requirements?
a. ………………………………………………………………………………
.
b. ………………………………………………………………………………
.
13. Do you provide online banking facilities?
Yes No
16. What are some of the necessary formalities required by the Bank when an SME
approaches for loans?
a. ………………………………………………………………………………
b. ………………………………………………………………………………
c. ………………………………………………………………………………
d. ………………………………………………………………………………
e. ………………………………………………………………………………
XIME
80
ANNEXURE-‘C’
Methodology used for Data Analysis
1. Question numbers 2,3,4 and 5 were meant to get the demographic profile of the IT
SMEs. The filled questionnaires were tabulated in terms of calculating the
frequencies for each category and thereby getting the corresponding pie chart
showing the percentage distribution.
2. Some questions were cross-tabulated with the required demographic categories to
get a clearer picture. For example, working capital sources of financing with Area
of Operation and The Year of Establishment.
3. Different market shares were calculated by simply getting the frequencies and
getting the corresponding pie chart.
4. Averages calculated are simple arithmetic averages.
5. For getting the rankings for Q.Nos. 12 and 15, the scores were calculated for each
option given by adding all the ranks given by different SMEs for that particular
option and getting the simple arithmetic average. After this the final scores were
sorted in an ascending order to get the final ranking.
6. For Q.No.16, different importance levels were given points ranging from -2 to +2
from Not at all Important to Very Important respectively. Now for getting the
cumulative score for each factor, frequencies with each importance level were
multiplied with their corresponding weights, i.e. +2 for V.Imp, +1 for Imp and so
on. Then all these weighted scores for each importance level were added to get the
final cumulative score for that particular factor. This score was then divided by
the sample size, i.e. 32 to get an average score which was then sorted in
descending order to get the ranking of the different factors considered while
selecting a bank.
7. Q.No.17 was analyzed by getting the scores out of 10 from the respondents and
then multiplying them with the weights of the importance level assigned to those
factors by that respondent. Only difference was that weights for Neither Important
Nor Unimportant, Not Important and Not at All important were all taken zero to
do away with any negative values that would have come up that way.
XIME
81
8. The respondents were categorized as customers of SBI only, Other Public Sector
Banks and Private Banks so as to compare the three on the evaluation and
importance parameters. Also, that way only, acceptance level of SBI was found .
XIME
82
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Hyderabad
2. SBI internal report on FOREX in software industry and the role of Banks
3. Websites :
a. www.rbi.org.in
b. www.sidbi.com
c. www.statebankofindia.com
d. www.hsbc.co.in
e. www.online.citibank.co.in
XIME