Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
1
Session 1 – Why do TQM Efforts Fail?
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
2
Session 1 – The Cost of Un-quality
• Overquality
Session 2
Redefining Quality & Total Quality
P19-26
6
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
3
Session 2
Defining Product Quality
P26-28
7
Session 2
Intrinsic & Extrinsic Quality
• Intrinsic characteristics
– Suitability, durability, reliability, uniformity etc.
• Extrinsic quality
– Perceived quality
P29
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
4
Session 2
QVALITY
• Quality – product quality
• Volume – delivery in required
qty,size,etc.
• Administration – systems and
procedures to facilitate all customer
experiences.
• Location – suitable to the customer.
• Interrelationships – treat customer well..
• Image – good corporate citizen,
reputation, etc.
• Timely delivery
• Yield – maximum value for money
• QVALITY – customer focused,
measurable,
• Who defines value??
Session 2
Delighting the Customer
P39-40
10
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
5
Session 2
TQ Triad
• Shareholders
– Quality return on investment
• Employees
– Quality of life
• Customers
– QVALITY, Delight
P41
11
Session 3
TQM – an Extraversive Approach
OBJECTIVES
12
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
6
Session 3
Traditional Management and Total
Quality
P49
13
Session 3
From QC to TQM
• Quality Control
– Quality limited to product or service
– Quality is a technical function – quality staff
are responsible for quality
– Quality cops or watchdogs trying to catch the
guilty
– After the fact.
• Total Quality Management
– Participatory management and teamwork
– Individuals responsible for their own QC
– Quality department supports and assists other
departments
– Satisfy the needs of the TQ Triad
– Collaboration in Supply Chain
• Total quality is achieved through TQM,
practiced everywhere, by everyone, at all
times.
P52
14
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
7
Session 3
TQM
• Quality does not happen by chance
– It has to be managed like other aspects of the
business.
– TQM includes all activities required to achieve
desired quality, on time, at best possible price.
• Planning – defining quality and means of
achieving it.
• Organization – administrative structure,
systems, resources
• Direction – human aspects of
management.
• QC – to detect errors or defects
• QA – preventative activities
– Ensure planning, organization, direction
carried out efficiently
– Verifying activities are being carried out by
auditing systems, procedures, and products
P55 15
Session 3
TQM
• Clear distinction required between
QM,QA, QC
• Quality Management – required quality
can be attained.
• TQM – total quality can be achieved and
maintained
• TQM must balance and satisfy the needs
of the three stakeholders.
P56
16
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
8
Session 3
Defining TQM
Session 3
PDCA
• Plan – review current performance,
gather data on key problems, devise
potential solutions
• Do – Implement the planned solution
(pilot)
• Check – Measure the results
• Act – Based on pilot, refine and expand
18
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
9
Session 3
DMAIC–Six Sigma PDCA
19
The SIX SIGMA WAY, Pande,Neuman,Cavanagh
20
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
10
Session 4 – Implementing TQM
Pitfalls to Avoid
10 Essential Conditions
1. Top Management
– Will to implement
– Conviction that TQM is critical to company
success
– Personal commitment to C.I.
P122
21
22
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
11
Session 4 – Implementing TQM
Program for Implementing
P133 24
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
12
Session 4 – Implementing TQM
Program for Implementing
Starting the Process
8. The Launch
– 75% of success change in attitude, 25%
procedures and techniques
– Gradual implementation – initial small project in
each area.
– Fine tune carried out during implementation
9. Monitoring and Evaluating Start-up
– Start-up must be carefully monitored
– Don’t get caught up in mechanics
– Halt process if more training required
– Reinforce motivation for participants
– Gradually introduce into all departments
10. Setting up Continuous Improvement Processes
– Reinforcement fuels continuous progress
– Emphasizes pride in a job well done
– Must be constant and unending from all levels of
the organization.
25
26
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
13
Session 5 CI & Re-engineering
TQ or Business Re-engineering?
P71-74
27
P74-76
28
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
14
Session 5 CI & Re-engineering
Levels of Re-engineering
P76
29
• Characteristics
– Measurable, might be automated, different
levels, must have customers.
• Process Enablers
– Workflow design
– Technology
– Motivation and Measurement
– Human Resources
– Policies and Rules
– Facilities
P76
30
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
15
Session 5 CI & Re-engineering
Details of the Mainstream Process
31
• Phase 1
– Specifications = Need, the product developed
will meet the needs for which it was designed
• Phase 2
– Qualification of workforce, equipment, and
suppliers
• Phase 3
– Product = specification, product conforms to
spec.
• Phase 4
– Product = needs, suitable for intended use.
P84
32
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
16
Session 5 CI & Re-engineering
Details of the Mainstream Process
Causes of Unquality
P86
33
P87
34
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
17
Session 5 CI & Re-engineering
Shareholder & People Satisfaction
• Finance Processes
– Shareholder oriented
– Objective to optimize returns
– Financial policies
– Measured in ROI, dividends, ROE
• People Management
– Employees more than a resource that can
be used such as financial and physical
resources
– Process must help to achieve a quality of
life for people within and outside work
• Integration of Product Quality, A1,
Financial, and People Mgt. processes
that allow achievement and
maintenance of TQ
P88
35
36
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
18
Session 6 TQM Practices
OBJECTIVES
37
P345-348
38
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
19
Session 6 TQM Practices
TQM Practices
• Identifying customers needs (QVALITY) and
evaluating their satisfaction
• Policy Development
• Benchmarking
• Cross functional teams
• Quality function deployment
– Translate customers requirements into company
terms.
• Failure Mode and Effect Analysis
– Identify all possible failures that could occur in
product life
– Types of failures, probability of occurrence,
degree of severity
• Poka-Yoka concept
– Engineering in safeguards to reduce or eliminate
human error.
• Concurrent Engineering
• Horizontal organization
• SPC
• ABC / ABM
P353
39
40
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
20
Session 6 TQM Practices
41
42
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
21
Session 7 TQ in Services
OBJECTIVES
43
Session 7 TQ in Services
Categorizing Services
• Internal Services
• External Services
• Main Services
– Central Activity – reason for existence
• Ancillary services
– Support main service
Un-quality in Services
• Why is there more unquality in services
than goods??
• Harder to define or measure.
• Customers tolerant attitude
• Has much changed since the text was
written? (1996)
44
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
22
Session 7 TQ in Services
Characteristics of Quality in Services
• What is different
– Services not always tangible
– Cannot be stocked
– Cannot be inspected or repaired before
delivery
– Service quality harder to precisely specify
and measure
45
Session 7 TQ in Services
Product Quality Cycle in Services
46
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
23
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
Objectives
47
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
P158
48
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
24
Session 9
Human Aspects of TQ
STRENGTHS
49
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
Participative Management
• Move from authoritarian – consultative
– participative.
• Principles
– Generates motivation
– Teamwork
– The team as a decision making unit
– Requires proper coordination
– Collaboration between all levels
– Relationships of trust vs authority
– Free circulation of information
– Self control vs mgt by domination
– Individual responsible for aligned specific
objectives.
P 165
50
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
25
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
P 166 -169
51
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
Team Spirit in TQ
• Must be customer focused
• Must have a common cause / objective
• How many companies can generate common
cause without a crisis?
Building Teams
• Employees must learn how to work as a team
• Collaboration and Participation a must
• Focused tasks and deliverables
• Copes with disagreement – does not avoid
conflict
– Avoids Group Think
• Decision by Consensus
• Extremely difficult for people without team
experience.
P 174
52
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
26
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
53
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
P 179
54
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
27
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
55
Session 9
Human Aspect of TQ
56
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
28
Session 10
Planning For TQ
Objectives
57
Session 10
Planning For TQ
58
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
29
Session 10
Launching the Planning Process
1. Diagnosis
2. Objectives
3. Strategy
4. Plan of Action
59
Session 10
Total Quality Diagnosis – Where are We?
60
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
30
Session 10
Total Quality Diagnosis – Where are We?
61
Session 10
Total Quality Objectives – Where Do We
Want to Go?
• Benchmarking
– Measuring your performance against best in
class companies
– Determining how the BIC achieves their
performance levels
– Using the information as a basis for you own
targets, strategies, implementation.
• Focusing
– You cannot do everything at once!
– Choose 1 – 3 characteristics to chase
– Do not totally neglect the others
• Backtracking
– Very similar to reverse engineering
– Look outward at what the customer /
shareholder wants and work backwards
identifying the wrong turns.
62
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
31
Session 10
Total Quality Objectives – Where Do We
Want to Go?
Internal Customers or Internal Partners?
• Many people in company do not have
direct contact with end customer
• The internal customer concept can
work against teamwork.
– One works for a customer vs a team works
in partnership
• Internal Partner a better approach
– Stresses the importance of collaboration,
and working towards a common goal.
63
Session 10
Total Quality Objectives – The Strategy
64
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
32
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
Objectives
65
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
33
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
• Responsibility Grid
– Text used Decision Maker, Participation, Consult,
Inform
– RACI - Responsible, Accountable, Consults,
Informs
– RASCI – adds Supervises
• From Quality to TQ
– Traditional organization functionally based,
vertical hierarchy
– TQ companies organize around business
processes
• Sequential / Cascade approach
– Companies operate in a sequential process
– Increase risk of communication distortion
– Very departmentalized
• Parallel Approach
– Work happens concurrently
– All departments in direct contact with customer.
– Utilizes cross functional teams
P217
67
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
• Pyramidal Organization
– Based on Cascade approach
– Departmentalized
– Managers for each department
– Multiple org levels
– Communication tends to be vertical
– Functional authority over counterpart line
departments
– No one department in charge of a process
• Matrix Organization
– Product or Project Mgr. Place in charge of
the whole process
– Employees could have two bosses
– Employees typically more loyal to functional
boss vs project boss
P218-20
68
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
34
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
P226-27
69
Session 11
Organizing for Total Quality
• Consensus Management
– Decisions made by groups instead of
individuals
– Management by consensus
– Organizations networked teams of educated
knowledge workers.
– Authority shifting from positions of power to
those having the knowledge and ability to
apply
70
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
35
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
Objectives
• To understand the necessity and
means to assess and control total
quality
P246
71
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
36
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
73
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
74
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
37
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
75
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
76
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
38
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
The TQ Curve
77
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
78
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
39
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
• Frequency distributions
– Use example of marks
– Normal or bell curve
– 68% of results will be +/- 1 SD
– 95% of results will be +/- 2 SD
– 99.7% of results will be +/- 3 SD
• Processes with common cause variations will
have a distribution similar to a normal curve.
• GO / NO GO and SPC
– Product falls within specified tolerance range
– Different concept than Acceptable Quality Level!
– SPC – to check if variations of a process are due
to common cause or unique ones.
79
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
• Control Charts
– Central axis and two control limits
– UCL – upper control limit
– LCL – lower control limit
– Most common charts are mean or x bar and
range.
• Steps in building charts
– Calculate the average value of each sample
– Calculate the range of each sample
– Add up the sample averages and calculate the
average of averages x bar bar
– Calculate the average of all ranges
– Calculate the LCL and UCL for the mean
– Calculate the UCL and LCL for the range
– Create a Mean chart and a range chart with UCL
and LCL’s
– Plot data
– Interpret
80
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
40
Session 12
Total Quality Assessment and Control
• Process capability
– Capability index
– CP should be greater than 1
ToleranceSpan
CP =
Pr ocessSpread
Process Spread =
6R
d2
81
82
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
41
83
Mean of averages X
Mean of Ranges R
84
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
42
85
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Objectives
86
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
43
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Quality Assurance – Concept and
Definition
• Setting up a system that can give the customer
the assurance that no poor quality will occur in
design, production, or delivery of the product
• External QA – require you suppliers to set up a
system
• Internal QA – company sets up for own use (or
required by their customer)
• Advantages of one over the other??
• Total Quality Assurance is much more than just
product quality
– Touches on all activities within company and with
upstream and downstream partners
– QA aims to ensure customer get the right
product, on time and at the lease cost
– TQA aims at ensuring customers
• Quality return for investors
• QVALITY and ACE for customers
• Quality of life for employees
P275-6
87
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Philosophy behind QA
• No system can act as a 100% guarantee of
quality
• Quality Assurance based on a cooperative
attitude between customer and supplier
– Supplier must be perceived as a responsible
partner.
– Often gets used inappropriately
P277-8
88
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
44
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
89
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
P282
90
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
45
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Purchasing Departments
Responsibility for Quality
• Who is responsible for the quality of
good purchased?
– Division of responsibility not always clear
• Technical Quality
– Potential users have exclusive responsibility
– Purchasing dept generally must influence
• Economic Quality
– Purchasing department has responsibility
– Often technical quality issues have an
economic quality impact
P282
91
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
From Definition of Needs to
Satisfaction
92
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
46
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Supplier Evaluation
• Important element in QA
• Must know what to evaluate, who will
do the evaluation, and when it should
be done.
• Some methods of evaluation
– Examination of products
– Reference checks from other customers
– Financial checks
– Trial batches
– Conditional orders
• Major factors that influence quality are:
– The workforce
– The equipment
– The quality management systems
P288
93
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt
Supplier Evaluation
• Before submitting an order the buyer
must clearly identify the form of control
required.
– The characteristics that will be evaluated
– How frequently
– Who is responsible for the controlling
– Where control activities take place
– The quantity to be controlled
• Prior agreement on what actions will be
taken if products are refused:
– Returned to supplier at its own expense
– Scrapped
– Temporarily accepted
– Accepted at discount price
– Accepted but modified at the suppliers
expense
P288
94
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
47
Session 13
TQ Assurance and Purchasing Mgt.
Standardization Development
• Why standardize?
• Standardization process can be set in
motion by users, producers, or
standards body.
– Existing standards studied
– Gather good understanding of mfg
procedures and materials
– Consult the applicable laws and regulations
• Committee Method
• Canvass Method
P288
95
Session 14
TQ And ISO 9000
Objectives
Principles of Quality
Instructor: Peter Churchill
48
Session 14
Total Quality & ISO9000
Objectives
• To get a good understanding
of ISO Standards
• To understand the steps in
implementing a quality
system according to
ISO9000
• To understand the purpose
and process of registration
and certification
ISO is =
1
ISO9000
ISO9001-2000
2
ISO9001-2000
Process Model for
Quality Management
4. Quality Management System
5. Management Responsibility
6. Resource Management
7. Product Realization
8. Measurement, Analysis, and
Improvement
3
• New requirements
– Communicate with customers (7.2.3).
– Identify customer requirements (5.2, 7.2.1).
– Meet customer requirements (5.2).
– Monitor and measure customer satisfaction
(8.2.1).
– Meet regulatory requirements (5.1).
– Meet statutory requirements (5.1).
– Support internal communication (5.5.3).
– Provide quality infrastructure (6.3).
– Provide a quality work environment (6.4).
– Evaluate the effectiveness of training (6.2.2).
– Monitor and measure processes (8.2.3).
– Evaluate the suitability of quality management
system (8.4).
– Evaluate the effectiveness of quality
management system (8.4).
– Identify quality management system
improvements (5.1, 8.4).
– Improve quality management system (5.1, 8.5).
ISO Process
Flowchart
Identify your
customer needs
and improve if
necessary
Do what you
say
Prove it
Improve it!
4
ISO Documentation
Level 1
Defines Approaches and
Responsibility
Quality
Manual
Level 2
Defines Who, What,
When
Procedures
Level 3
Answers How
Work/Job Instructions
Level 4
Provides a Record
Other Documentation
10
5
Evaluation &
Registration
• Evaluation
– Self Audits – internally
– Second Party Evaluations – typically by
customers
– Third Party Evaluations – independent
• Compliance
– Organizations will follow the program to
point of compliance but not seek
registration.
• Registration / Certification
– Certification generally applies to product
– Registration - assessment and approval of
quality system
• Assessment and periodic audit of quality
system by third party
• Accreditation
– Accredits people or organizations for
certifying and registering others.
11
Implementing
ISO9000
• Determine why you want to implement
ISO
– Part of a TQ program
– Customer demand
– Open up new markets
• Seek outside help
– Implementation Consultants
– Government subsidies
• Commitment from Management –
Remember the 10 conditions
12
6
Implementing
ISO9000
Organizing for Registration
• Obtain Mgt. Commitment
• Establish a Steering team
– Plan the project
• Train team members
• Begin internal auditing
– Gap Analysis – lots of third party tools
available
13
Implementing
ISO9000
Preparing for Registration
• Document existing processes
– procedures and job/work instructions
• Identify areas needing improvement
• Adopt improved procedures and work
instructions
• Prepare Quality Manual
• Apply to Registrar for Assessment -
$$$$$
• Pre Assessment
• Modify and finalize practices
• Train staff
14
7
Implementing
ISO9000
Registration Audit
• Registrar conducts assessment and
identifies discrepancies
• Resolve discrepancies
• Submit to registrar corrective actions
• Certification awarded
15
Implementing
ISO9000
Maintain and Improve
• Maintain Quality Practices
– Internal Audits, Measurement etc.
• Regular external Audits
• Continuous Improvement
16
8
ISO 9000 and Total
Quality
• Most ISO registered companies are
not Total Quality companies
• ISO is a good first step towards TQ
• ISO9000-2000 comes much closer a
TQ philosophy than previous versions.
• Many companies will be really
challenged living up to the spirit of ISO
9000-2000 when they convert from
earlier versions
• Not all ISO Experts embrace a TQ
philosophy
17
ISO Resources
www.qcbinc.com
ISO Courses, Registration
Services
www.qmi.com
ISO courses, Registration
Services, Handbooks and
Standards– Division of CSA
http://praxiom.com/
Free information, ISO tools &
Books
18