DOI: 10.1093/ije/dyg023
METHODOLOGY
Conclusions A wide range of important analytes, including lipids, change by only a few per
cent in whole blood during storage at room temperature for several days. Mailed
transport of whole blood samples may, therefore, be a simple and cost-effective
option for large-scale epidemiological studies.
Observational epidemiological studies can often be greatly epidemiological studies to be informative, they often need to be
enhanced by the inclusion of biochemical analyses in stored large (perhaps involving tens or hundreds of thousands of indi-
blood samples collected from the population being studied. viduals), which in turn requires methods for blood collection
Biochemical analyses can be used to assess risk factor exposure, that are practical and cost-effective. Standard guidelines for
to control for confounding, or to measure the effects of bias. blood sample handling state that plasma or serum should be
In randomized trials, biochemical analyses can be used to separated from cells as soon as possible and certainly within
monitor the safety and biochemical efficacy of treatment. For 2 hours.1 Whilst this is necessary for particular analytes, it
might be assumed that many blood analytes deteriorate within
1 Clinical Trial Service Unit & Epidemiological Studies Unit, Nuffield Depart- a matter of hours in unseparated samples kept at ambient
ment of Clinical Medicine, University of Oxford, UK. temperature. This perceived need for either immediate local
2 Current affiliation: FDA Office of Research, Laurel, MD 20708, USA.
separation of blood samples or their rapid chilled transfer to
125
126 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY
a central laboratory, which increases complexity and cost, can low density lipoprotein (LDL), total cholesterol, total protein
prevent blood collection from being included in large-scale (by the rate biuret method), and triglycerides. Measurements
epidemiological studies. were performed on a Synchron LX20 autoanalyser (Beckman
Particularly when blood samples are being collected in a large Coulter UK Limited, High Wycombe, England), using Beckman
number of separate sites within a study, mailing of whole blood Coulter reagents, calibrators, and controls for all assays, except
samples to a central laboratory for separation may be more for HDL and LDL which were analysed using N-geneous reagents,
convenient and cost-effective than making arrangements for calibrators, and controls (Bio-Stat Limited, Stockport, England).
local separation or for courier transport of chilled samples. Saliva These direct methods for quantification of HDL and LDL were
samples have been successfully collected by mail for measure- fully automated, involving chemical isolation of the lipoprotein
ment of hepatitis B virus seropositivity2 and the potential advant- and enzymatic measurement of cholesterol. The Synchron
ages of collecting blood samples by mail in epidemiological LX20 autoanalyser monitors absorbance readings at multiple
studies have been noted.3 There is limited evidence to suggest wavelengths and was programmed to subtract a sample blank
that some biochemical analytes (such as total cholesterol) may absorbance reading from the final reaction absorbance where
be stable in whole blood for several days at ambient temperature.4–6 possible.7 This helps to correct for interference from colour in
If confirmed for a wider range of analytes of interest, use of plasma due to haemolysis, which was a significant problem in
mailed whole blood samples might allow blood collection to be samples from the later time-points. The intra-assay coefficient
included in studies where it would not otherwise be considered of variation (CV) for ALT was 4% at a quality control level of
feasible. We have evaluated the use of mailed whole blood 24.0 U/l and 1% at a quality control level of 84.3 U/l; for albumin
samples and of chilled samples (compared with immediate plasma was 1% at 29.3 g/l and 2% at 47.2 g/l; for apoA1 was 3% both
separation) by simulating these two collection methods in the at 83.9 mg/dl and 279.7 mg/dl; for apoB was 4% both at
Table 1 Assay values in samples separated immediately after collection from 12 healthy volunteers aged 25–60 years (with reference intervals)
Table 2 Percentage change in analyte concentration over time in samples stored at 21°C and 4°C
Figure 1 Percentage change per day (95% CI) for analytes in whole blood samples stored at 21°C or 4°C
for up to 7 days
concentrations of albumin, apoA1, apoB, total cholesterol, HDL, than 1%. With the exception of total cholesterol, the change
total protein, and triglycerides differed by less than 4% from the over time did not differ significantly between samples stored at
fresh value up to 7 days after blood collection, while the con- 21°C or 4°C. For total cholesterol, there was a significant difference
centration of LDL differed by less than 7%. The mean percent- (P = 0.0003) between the values in samples kept at the different
age change per day at room temperature was less than 0.5% for temperatures, but it was small and did not become apparent
all of those analytes, except for HDL and LDL where it was less until 7 days.
PLASMA ANALYTE STABILITY AFTER DELAYED SEPARATION OF WHOLE BLOOD 129
By contrast, concentrations of ALT, CK, creatinine, and GGT a Styrofoam mailer with a frozen gel pack (which maintained
changed more markedly at 21°C: for example, creatinine a temperature of 4°C for 20 hours) for up to 48 hours. The study
increased by more than 20% in whole blood after 3 days. Under design was similar to that of the present study, with whole blood
chilled conditions at 4°C, however, these analytes were more samples stored under each temperature condition up to the appro-
stable, and changed by less than 4% in whole blood after 7 days priate time-point, then centrifuged, the plasma aliquoted and
(P 0.0001 for 21°C versus 4°C). The mean percentage change frozen at –80°C. Samples from all time-points were analysed in
per day for these analytes under chilled conditions was less than one analytical run. The concentrations of all of the lipids were
0.7%. Although a significant trend (P = 0.0008) towards an found to change non-significantly in chilled blood. However, at
increase in CK values was observed over time in samples kept room temperature, although total cholesterol and apoA1 changed
at 4°C, the change was small. Of the analytes measured, only only non-significantly, HDL and apoB increased by 3.0% and
AST was found to change substantially under both temperature 5.2% per day respectively. By contrast, in the present study,
conditions. The concentration of AST increased by more than HDL and apoB changed by –0.6% and +0.4% per day respectively
7% after 3 days at 4°C, and by more than 15% after just one at room temperature. The discrepancies between the results of
day at 21°C. The percentage changes in ALT and AST appeared the two studies may also reflect differences in the analytical
to be somewhat greater in the samples with lower baseline methods. Hankinson et al. measured HDL by precipitation of very
levels compared with higher baseline levels, but more indi- low density lipoprotein (VLDL) and LDL with dextran sulphate
viduals with a wider range of baseline values would need to be and magnesium chloride, apoA1 was measured in the HDL and
studied to assess this reliably. HDL3 fractions by radial immunodiffusion and apoB measured
in whole plasma by radial immunodiffusion. By contrast, in the
present study, the analytes were measured directly in plasma by
rather than freezing the samples and analysing them all in ISIS-3. Unpublished manuscript). It should also be noted that
the same run, as in the present study, so that day-to-day assay ‘room temperature’ in the present study was defined as 21°C,
variability may have affected results. which may not be realistic for studies in hotter climates (and
Many analytes considered in the present study did exhibit a further stability studies under such conditions need to be con-
slight increase in concentration over time, which agrees with a ducted). However, since many analytes were found to change
previous study.7 This is contrary to what one might expect to by only a few per cent over at least 7 days at 21°C, it might be
observe from analyte degradation, and seems likely to be due to supposed that any change at higher temperatures may remain
leakage of water from the plasma into the red cells (following in this range for at least 3 to 4 days, which might still be a
failure of the sodium/potassium pump to maintain osmotic feasible time-frame within which to transport whole blood
balance) resulting in swelling of red cells, increase in the samples to a central facility.
haematocrit, decrease in the plasma volume and, therefore, In conclusion, we have shown that the concentrations of
increased concentration of plasma analytes. It has also been many analytes change by only a few per cent in whole blood
reported that certain analytes, particularly AST, have a much stored at room temperature for up to 7 days, and may therefore
higher activity in red blood cells than plasma, causing an in- be measured reliably in mailed blood samples. These results
creased concentration in haemolysed plasma.8,9 Furthermore, it are relevant for planning blood-based epidemiological studies.
has been suggested that the increase in creatinine concentration Depending upon the analytes to be measured, blood collection
during storage is due to non-specific formation of pseudo- methods could be greatly simplified and, hence, the costs vastly
creatinines.6 Recording the length of time from collection to reduced, enabling blood collection to be included in studies
separation of each sample might allow appropriate adjustment where it would not otherwise be considered feasible.
to be made for the slight increase in concentration of these
KEY MESSAGES
• Simple blood collection methods could help make large blood-based epidemiological studies feasible.
• The concentrations of a wide range of analytes (including lipids) may be measured reliably in whole blood stored
at room temperature for up to 7 days.
• Collection of whole blood samples by mail is a simple and cost-effective way to facilitate the inclusion of blood
assays in large-scale epidemiological studies.