SUBMITTED TO:
Variables on the Stock Market Volatility” submitted for the degree of Master
of Business Administration, is my original work and the project report has
not formed the basis for the award of any diploma, degree, associate ship,
fellowship or similar other titles. It has not been submitted to any other
university or institution for the award of any degree or diploma.
This is to certify that Mr. Ujjwal Goyal of MBA fourth semester of FMS,
Udaipur has completed her project report on the topic of “Impact of
To best of my knowledge the report is original and has not been copied or
submitted anywhere else. It is an independent work done by him
I would like to thank Dr. Hanuman Parsad who was always there to help
and guide me when I needed help. Working under him was an extremely
knowledgeable and enriching experience for me. I am very thankful to him
for all the value addition and enhancement done to me.
DECLARATION II
CERTIFICATE III
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT IV
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY V
The modern financial theory focuses upon that securities market must have
a significant relationship with real and financial sectors of the economy. This
relationship generally viewed in two ways. The first relationship views the
stock market as the leading indicator of the economic activity in the country,
whereas the second focuses on the possible impact the stock market may
have on aggregate demand, particularly through aggregate consumption and
investment. The former case implies that stock market leads economic
activity, whereas the latter suggests that it lags economic activity.
Knowledge of the sensitivity of stock market to macroeconomic behavior of
key variables and vice-versa is important in many areas of investments and
finance. This research may be useful to understand this relationship.
From the beginning of the 1990s in India, a number of measures have been
taken for economic liberalization. At the same time, large number of steps
has been taken to strengthen the stock market such as opening of the stock
markets to international investors, regulatory power of SEBI, trading in
derivatives, etc. These measures have resulted in significant improvements
in the size and depth of stock markets in India and they are beginning to
play their due role. Presently, the movement in stock market in India is
viewed and analyzed carefully by large number of global players.
Understanding macro dynamics of Indian stock market may be useful for
policy makers, traders and investors. Results may reveal whether the
movement of stock prices is the outcome of something else or it is one of
the causes of movement in other macro dimension in the economy. The
study also expects to explore whether the movement of stock market are
associated with economy. In this context, the objective of this paper is to
explore such causal relations for India.
There is lot work has been done so far in this regard. I have overview some
of economist works and some text books in this section of the paper as
review literature. The hypothesis the change in economics variable has got
strong impact on stock prices as subject extensive research.
Shahid Ahmed (2003) has worked on SENSEX index price effects by real
and financial sector performance in economy. This study investigates the
nature of the causal relationships between stock prices and the key macro
economic variables representing real and financial sector of the Indian
economy for the period March, 1995 to March, 2007 using quarterly data.
These variables are the index of industrial production, exports, foreign direct
investment, money supply, exchange rate, interest rate, NSE Nifty and BSE
Sensex in India. Johansen`s approach of co-integration and Toda and
Yamamoto Granger causality test have been applied to explore the long-run
relationships while BVAR modeling for variance decomposition and impulse
response functions has been applied to examine short run relationships. The
results of the study reveal differential causal links between aggregate macro
economic variables and stock indices in the long run. However, the revealed
causal pattern is similar in both markets in the short run. The study indicates
that stock prices in India lead economic activity except movement in interest
rate. Interest rate seems to lead the stock prices. The study indicates that
Indian stock market seems to be driven not only by actual performance but
also by expected potential performances. The study reveals that the
movement of stock prices is not only the outcome of behavior of key macro
economic variables but it is also one of the causes of movement in other
macro dimension in the economy.
Suliaman D. Mohammad, Adnan Hussain and Adnan Ali (2009) have
worked in the context of Pakistan. Their paper was to find the relationship
between macroeconomic variables and prices of shares in Karachi stock
exchange in Pakistan context. They considers the quarterly data of several
economic variables such as foreign exchange rate, foreign exchange reserve,
industrial production index, whole sale price index, gross fixed capital
formation, and broad money M2 , these variables are obtain from 1986 to
2008 period . They try to make link these macroeconomics variables to stock
prices. Compared to earlier work we have used multiple regression analysis
and compare the results. The results shows that after the reforms in 1991
the influence of foreign exchange rate and reserve effects significantly to
stock market whiles other variables like IIP and GFCF are not effects
significantly to stock prices. So their result shows that internal factors of
firms like increase production and capital formation not effects significantly
while external factors like exchange rate and reserve are effects significantly
the stock prices. So the after post reforms period is positively effects stock
prices.
Objectives
In this study the major objective is to find out the correlation and causal
relationship, if any, between the stock market and real economic variables.
It will shed light on the degree of integration of the two markets and how
they affect each other. The specific sets of objectives of the study are as
follows:
(1) To calculate correlation and check the dependency, if any, between the
stock market index SENSEX and economic variables.
(2) To explore that to what degree the two, stock market and real economic
variables cause each other.
Methodology Adopted
T-test
The test of hypothesis for the existence of a linear relationship between two
variables x and y involves the determination of sample correlation
coefficient. This test of linear relationship between x and y is the same as
determining whether there is any significant correlation between them. The
null hypothesis and alternative hypothesis are expressed as:
F-test
To understand whether all independent variables xi taken together
significantly explain the variability observed in the dependent variable y. to
apply f-test, the null hypothesis is defined as:
f-Test is performed to test the dependency of the variables more than two. If
the calculated f-value is greater than its critical value at degree of the
freedom and level of significance then the null hypothesis will we rejected
otherwise it will we accepted.
ANALYSES & INTERPRETATION OF DATA
In this study monthly data from JAN2007 onwards to DEC2009 has been
used in case of all the variables like, INTEREST RATE, GOVT.BOND 10 YEAR
YIELD RATE, INFLATION (WPI), IIP (INDEX OF INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTION),
FII(FORIGEN INSTIUTIONAL INVESTOR) for debt and equity has taken
separately, MF(MUTTUAL FUNDS), SENSEX (SEBI). The major source of data
of all the above economic variables is www.tradingeconomics.com and on-
line data source of SEBI. The major macro economic variables used in this
study are briefly explained below.
1. Interest Rate: In our banking system we have various rate of interest
but for the purpose of the study I have taken CRR.
2. Govt. Bond: This is the yield rate of the govt. bonds for the 10 years
period on the annually basis.
3. Inflation (WPI): For any country’s economy to grow low rate inflation
serves as an inducing tonic. Slow rise in prices are supposed to induce the
producers to increase the production which in turn ensure more and more
employment opportunities in the country. But uncontrolled inflation or even
deflation has serious repercussions for the economy. To measure this
inflation Government of India (GoI) has various indices, amongst which WPI
is the one which is believed to be a very comprehensible and lucid measure.
It is the only general index capturing price movements in a comprehensive
way. It is an indicator of movement in prices of commodities in all trade and
transactions. The new series of WPI has about 435 items in its commodity
basket. In its new series ‘Primary Articles’ contribute 98 items, ‘Fuel, Power,
Light and Lubricants’ 19 items and ‘Manufactured Products’ provide 318
items.
4. IIP:
5. FII:
6. MF:
7. BOT:
t- test table
f-test table
CONCLUSION
The study shows that Indian equity markets are not having relationship with
economic variables. Which employs that economic news cannot be used to
predict stock exchange prices. These findings answer our research
questions.
TABLES
SENSE MF(E
Time X IR GB IIP INF BOT MF(D) ) FII(D) FII(E)
-
7.7 1022.
Jan-07 14096 6 6 11.6 6.72 -2850 2217.2 6 351.1 351.1
Feb- 7.8 -
07 14233 6 8 11 7.56 -3620 2669 273.4 955.5 7239.6
-
Mar- 7.9 1805. -
07 12872 6 9 14.8 6.72 -4275 4287.5 4 1613.8 1243.2
8.1
Apr-07 13424 6 1 11.3 6.67 -7044 3485 960.6 1091 6874
May- 8.1 1432.
07 14093 6 5 10.6 6.61 -8694 6915.4 9 1740.9 3175.2
8.1 1025.
Jun-07 14316 6 4 8.9 5.69 -7915 8592.8 2 -670.3 2084.9
7.8 11347. 24244.
Jul-07 15137 6 9 8.3 6.45 -8615 2 -1610 -299 8
Aug- 7.9 2844. -
07 14643 6 5 10.9 7.26 -7725 918.3 1 -479.6 7279.5
Sep- - 16132.
07 16074 6 7.9 7 6.4 -5696 9713.6 763.7 2655.8 6
-
7.8 12314. 1591. 20103.
Oct-07 18249 6 9 12.2 5.51 -7158 1 6 2618.4 6
Nov- 7.8 1105. -
07 19359 6 9 4.9 5.51 -9195 -7074.3 6 -526.6 4422.3
Dec- 7.8 3202.
07 19746 6 8 8 5.51 -5491 1082.9 8 3070.3 4438.2
-
7.7 5269. 10625.
Jan-08 19722 6 5 6.2 5.51 -7955 -4269 4 1962.4 8
Feb- 7.5 11407.
08 17793 6 5 9.5 5.47 -5688 7 57.5 2925 2262.2
Mar- 7.7 12265.
08 16136 6 3 5.5 7.87 -6320 1 -1881 -849 -16.1
8.0 14894. -
Apr-08 16189 6 9 6.2 7.81 -11857 3 220.8 -1257.1 648.2
-
May- 7.9 - 13193.
08 17105 6 8 4.4 7.75 -10757 6272.6 388.5 -162.9 7
8.4 2888. -
Jun-08 15110 6 8 5.4 7.69 -9770 3072.7 5 -737 9349.6
9.1
Jul-08 13709 6 6 6.4 8.33 -12595 4580.7 782.4 3782.5 -503.5
Aug- 9.0 - -
08 14703 6 7 1.7 9.02 -15764 7050.4 767.1 1110.1 1355.5
Sep- 1925. 32196.
08 13907 6 8.4 6 9.77 -15347 6070 4 6 -8061
- -
7.8 10.4 23490. 13261.
Oct-08 10433 6 9 0.1 5 -11738 8 854.5 -1827.7 5
Nov- 7.3 10.4 - -
08 9429 6 8 2.5 5 -12325 -3598.5 372.6 4215 2598.3
Dec- 5.2 13223. -
08 9521 4 6 -0.2 9.7 -6088 9 490.4 1187.3 1895.3
-
4.0 5.9 10.4 16701. 1979. -
Jan-09 9341 5 7 1 5 -5359 6 1 807.5 4545.6
-
Feb- 5.9 16642. 1495. -
09 9301 4 3 0.2 9.63 -3121 9 5 -687.8 2436.6
Mar- 3.5 6.7 17488. 1070.
09 8998 5 1 0.3 8.03 -3680 3 4 -6738 1265.6
3.3 6.5 26007.
Apr-09 10876 9 6 1.1 8.7 -7012 3 18 1611.3 6682.1
May- 3.2 6.4 10181. 1602. 17988.
09 12793 5 2 2.1 8.63 -7974 9 6 -242.3 1
3.2 6.8 12820.
Jun-09 14907 5 4 8.3 9.29 -9630 3 944.1 4625.7 2759.9
3.2 6.9 11.8 27883.
Jul-09 14635 5 7 7.2 9 -7796 6 1496 4253.5 9005.1
Aug- 3.2 7.1 11.7
09 15481 5 9 10.6 2 -8471 8422.4 657.6 -459.4 3810
-
Sep- 3.2 7.2 11.6 2241. 13929.
09 16347 5 6 9.3 4 -6707 7655.2 1 4317.1 9
-
3.2 7.3 11.4 32501. 5766. 10643.
Oct-09 16979 5 3 10.2 9 -8801 2 8 6853.1 9
-
Nov- 3.2 7.2 13.5 15754. 1070.
09 16511 5 6 12 1 -9690 4 5 936.4 6227.3
-
Dec- 3.2 7.5 14.9 1716.
09 17075 5 8 17.6 7 -10147 8056 5 -588.2 8683.4
BOT is in millions, MF and FII is monthly flow of rupees in crores, SENSEX is in points
and others are in percentage.
SENSE
TIME X IR GB IIP INF BOT MF(D) MF(E) FII(D) FII(E)
Feb-07 1.37 0 0.12 -0.6 0.84 -7.7 4.518 7.492 6.044 68.885
-
Mar-07 -13.61 0 0.11 3.8 -0.84 -6.55 16.185 -15.32 6.583 84.828
-
27.6
Apr-07 5.52 0 0.12 -3.5 -0.05 9 -8.025 27.66 -5.228 81.172
-
May-07 6.69 0 0.04 -0.7 -0.06 -16.5 34.304 4.723 6.499 36.988
-
Jun-07 2.23 0 -0.01 -1.7 -0.92 7.79 16.774 -4.077 -24.112 10.903
- 221.59
Jul-07 8.21 0 -0.25 -0.6 0.76 -7 27.544 26.352 3.713 9
Aug-07 -4.94 0 0.06 2.6 0.81 8.9 - 44.541 -1.806 -
104.28 315.24
9 3
20.2 - 234.12
Sep-07 14.31 0 -0.05 -3.9 -0.86 9 87.953 36.078 31.354 1
-
14.6
Oct-07 21.75 0 -0.01 5.2 -0.89 2 26.005 -8.279 -0.374 39.71
- - -
20.3 193.88 245.25
Nov-07 11.1 0 0 -7.3 0 7 4 26.972 -31.45 9
37.0
Dec-07 3.87 0 -0.01 3.1 0 4 81.572 20.972 35.969 88.605
-
24.6 - -
Jan-08 -0.24 0 -0.13 -1.8 0 4 53.519 20.666 -11.079 150.64
22.6 156.76 -
Feb-08 -19.29 0 -0.2 3.3 -0.04 7 7 52.119 9.626 128.88
- -
Mar-08 -16.57 0 0.18 -4 2.4 -6.32 8.574 19.385 -37.74 22.783
-
55.3
Apr-08 0.53 0 0.36 0.7 -0.06 7 26.292 16.602 -4.081 6.643
-
- 138.41
May-08 9.16 0 -0.11 -1.8 -0.06 11 86.217 -1.677 10.942 9
-
Jun-08 -19.95 0 0.5 1 -0.06 9.87 31.999 32.77 -5.741 38.441
-
28.2 -
Jul-08 -14.01 0 0.68 1 0.64 5 15.08 21.061 45.195 88.461
-
31.6 -
Aug-08 9.94 0 -0.09 -4.7 0.69 9 24.697 15.495 -26.724 -8.52
310.86 -
Sep-08 -7.96 0 -0.67 4.3 0.75 4.17 -9.804 26.925 5 67.055
- -
36.0 295.60 - 340.24 -
Oct-08 -34.74 0 -0.51 -5.9 0.68 9 8 10.709 3 52.005
198.92 - 106.63
Nov-08 -10.04 0 -0.51 2.4 0 -5.87 3 12.271 60.427 2
62.3 168.22
Dec-08 0.92 -0.76 -1.38 -2.7 -0.75 7 4 -1.178 -30.277 44.936
- -
Jan-09 -1.8 -1.19 -0.03 1.2 0.75 7.29 34.777 14.887 -3.798 64.409
22.3
Feb-09 -0.4 -0.05 -0.04 -0.8 -0.82 8 -0.587 4.836 -14.953 21.09
Mar-09 -3.03 -0.45 0.78 0.1 -1.6 -5.59 8.454 25.659 -60.502 37.022
-
33.3 -
Apr-09 18.78 -0.16 -0.15 0.8 0.67 2 85.19 10.524 83.493 54.165
-
158.25
May-09 19.17 -0.14 -0.14 1 -0.07 -9.62 4 15.846 -18.536 113.06
- -
16.5 152.28
Jun-09 21.14 0 0.42 6.2 0.66 6 26.384 -6.585 48.68 2
18.3 150.63
Jul-09 -2.72 0 0.13 -1.1 2.6 4 3 5.519 -3.722 62.452
-
194.61 -
Aug-09 8.46 0 0.22 3.4 -0.17 -6.75 2 -8.384 -47.129 51.951
17.6 - 101.19
Sep-09 8.66 0 0.07 -1.3 -0.08 4 -7.672 28.987 47.765 9
-
20.9 -
Oct-09 6.32 0 0.07 0.9 -0.15 4 248.46 35.257 25.36 -32.86
-
167.46 -
Nov-09 -4.68 0 -0.07 1.8 2.02 -8.89 8 46.963 -59.167 44.166
-
Dec-09 5.64 0 0.32 5.6 1.46 -4.57 76.984 -6.46 -15.246 24.561
% change on the monthly basis for the all variables
BIBLIOGRAPHY
WEB LINK
1. www.google.com
2. www.wikipedia.com
3. www.tradingeconomics.com
4. www.sebi.com
5. www.academicjournals.org
6. www.eurojournals.com
7. www.informaworld.com
Books
1. Business Statics (J.K.SHARMA)
Soft wares
Microsoft Excel