Anda di halaman 1dari 22

Where to Invest in 2011

Featured in this booklet


The Error-Proof Portfolio 3
Core Anchors for Any Portfolio 5
Steady-Eddie Stock Funds 8
Tips and Traps for Short-Term Income-Oriented Investors 10
Create a Paycheck in Retirement With a Total-Return Approach 12
Topnotch Bargain-Hunting Funds 15
Our Picks for Inflation Protection 17
Ideas in Emerging Markets Beyond the Broad Indexes 20

Compliments of Morningstar
Where to Invest in 2011:
Morningstar’s Top Ideas for the New Year and Beyond

Although we’ve come a long way from the abyss of 2008, most investors would be hard-pressed to say
we’re completely out of the woods just yet. Lingering European debt concerns, a possible slowdown in
China, a still-high unemployment rate, a troublesome low-yield environment, and a cloudy outlook for fixed
income are casting some shadows on the path ahead.

In this special report, Morningstar’s own strategists, directors, and analysts will tackle the major concerns
going into 2011 with actionable tips, insights, and investment picks. You’ll also hear from Morningstar’s
director of personal finance Christine Benz on how to deal with today’s bigger-picture portfolio dilemmas,
including the possibility for rising rates and inflation.

In addition to the ideas in this report, I hope you’ll check out “Three Takes on Today’s Market,” our first-ever
roundtable webcast, http://www.morningstar.com/goto/webcast2010. Morningstar director of equity
research Pat Dorsey sat down with Ariel’s vice chairman, director of research and Ariel Focus (ARFFX) co-
manager Charlie Bobrinskoy; Tom Forester of Forester Value Fund (FVALX); and Leuthold director of research
and Leuthold Global (GLBLX) co-manager Doug Ramsey to discuss the opportunities and risks in the stock
and bond markets today.

Thanks again for subscribing, and here’s to many happy returns.

Best Regards,

Jason Stipp
Site Editor
Morningstar.com

Where to Invest in 2011 2


The Error-Proof Portfolio:
How to Hedge Against the Market’s Many Wild Cards

By Christine Benz Although it’s shaping up to be a pretty decent year Avoid long-term bonds: If you’re looking at
Morningstar.com Director of
for stocks and bonds, it’s hard to blame investors for returns during the past decade, long-term bonds,
Personal Finance
feeling like they’re walking a tightrope. Current especially Treasuries, look like a slam-dunk missed
stock prices are factoring in continued economic investment. (The long-term bond fund category
expansion, and if it fails to materialize, things could has gained about 8% on average during the past
get very ugly very fast. On the other hand, if the decade, versus 6% for intermediate-term bond
economy grows too spritely, rising inflation or rising funds.) If the economy continues to sputter along in
interest rates could quickly shoot to the top of fits and starts, long-term bonds could continue to
investors’ worry lists. prosper. But the volatility in long-term bonds has
also been nearly twice as high as has been the case
True, investors have no power to control those for intermediate-term bonds. For that reason, I think
macroeconomic risk factors, but it’s also possible to it makes sense to downplay long-term bonds if the
inoculate your portfolio against some of them in goal of your fixed-income portfolio is income and
case they materialize. capital preservation. Esteemed investors such as
Jack Bogle and Bill Bernstein are on the same page.
There are some of the biggest wild cards currently
facing the economy and the market, along with Stress-test your bond portfolio: Even if you
some concrete ways to hedge against them. The don’t own long-term bonds, it’s still a good idea to
good news is that if you’ve done a good job of investigate just how sensitive your portfolio would
diversifying, you probably already have some of be to an increase in interest rates. This article
these hedges in place. outlines a concrete way to simulate how much your
portfolio could lose if interest rates bumped up by 1
The Wild Card or 2 percentage points.
Continued economic growth could lead to a spike
in interest rates, crushing bonds. The Wild Card
Inflation takes off, cutting into the future purchas-
How to Seize Control ing power of invested dollars.
Keep risk in perspective: Even if we do see a
calamitous rise in interest rates, the magnitude How to Seize Control
of losses for bond and bond-fund investors would Check to see whether you already have some
very likely be much less than stock investors have protection: Yes, there are direct ways to inflation-
faced during large equity-market sell-offs. This proof your portfolio (more on these in a second).
article discusses how to keep worries about rising But before you layer on any investments dedicated to
rates in perspective, and it links to a Fidelity inflation control, use Morningstar’s Instant X-Ray
study chronicling how bonds have performed during tool, http://portfolio.morningstar.com/RtPort/Free/
sustained periods of rising rates. InstantXRayDEntry.aspx?dt=0.7055475, to see

Where to Invest in 2011 3


The Error-Proof Portfolio

whether you’re already holding investments that an inflation-adjustment feature, but it could be
may indirectly benefit from inflation. For example, well worth it in a sustained period of rising prices.
emerging markets tend to be heavy on basic-
materials producers, and they in turn are beneficia- The Wild Card
ries of higher demand and prices; check your Stocks will take a breather (or worse) if economy
portfolio’s exposure to Latin America and developing doesn’t continue to grow.
Asian markets.
How to Seize Control
Include inflation protection in your portfolio: Make sure your investment mix include stable,
Regardless of the current inflation rate, a position non-economically sensitive companies: Investors
in Treasury Inflation Protected Securities helps appear to be betting that the economy will continue
provide insurance against an unexpected spike in to do well, given the highly economically sensitive
inflation. This article, http://news.morningstar. firms (retail, basic materials, industrial companies)
com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=330149, discusses that have recently fared best. But if the economy
some simple ways to add explicit inflation protection takes a timeout, those more cyclical firms will hand
to your portfolio, including TIPS and commodities. the baton to stable companies that do well in myriad
economic environments; think consumer staples and
Include inflation when making return pharmaceuticals, whose products consumers will buy
assumptions: I recently wrote about the dangers regardless of what the economy’s doing. The good
of having overly rosy expectations for stocks, news is that you probably already have plenty of
http://news.morningstar.com/articlenet/article. exposure to such names if you own a well-diversified
aspx?id=361242. A related pitfall is failing to factor large-cap U.S. stock fund.
taxes and inflation into those return assumptions.
If you’re using a Dribble new money into the market: In
calculator to help estimate whether you’re on track contrast with two years ago, few consider stocks a
to meet your financial goals, make sure it’s giving screaming buy right now. To help hedge against the
your returns a realistic haircut to account for risk of putting a lot of new money into the market
inflation. Factoring in a long-term inflation rate of just in time to see stocks sell off, plan to add to your
2.5% or 3% is realistic. positions during a period of several months or even
more. Yes, such a strategy will mute your gains
Add inflation protection when purchasing if stocks take off from here, but it will also greatly
products such as annuities and long-term reduce your downside risk if stocks see a perfor-
care insurance: If you’re purchasing annuities or mance hiccup in the months ahead.
long-term care insurance, don’t just settle for a
fixed benefit, which will be worth less and less if
inflation takes off. Yes, you’ll pay extra for adding

Where to Invest in 2011 4


Core Anchors for Any Portfolio

By Christine Benz Question: I have been trying to streamline Target-date funds are the ideal vehicles for set-
Director of Personal Finance
and upgrade my portfolio. Can you name some it-and-forget-it types, in that they aim to deliver an
Morningstar.com
favorites? age-appropriate asset-allocation mix that gradually
gets more conservative as the investor nears
Answer: As I noted in my recent article, http:// retirement. Of course, not all of these funds are
news.morningstar.com/articlenet/article. worthwhile: Some featured too-aggressive asset
aspx?id=351716, there’s no clear-cut definition of allocations coming into the bear market, which led
what constitutes a core holding. An investment to outsized losses for shareholders who were
that may be a perfectly legitimate linchpin holding nearing retirement. Others, meanwhile, simply
for one investor, such as the aggressive bond don’t have the raw materials necessary to be top-
fund Loomis Sayles Bond (LSBRX), might be far notch all-in-one offerings; namely, they lack
too volatile, and decidedly noncore, for another. standout offerings in all of the major asset classes.
But a few target-date series tick all the boxes:
A key first step, then, in finding the right core Vanguard’s target retirement funds (middle-of-the-
holding for you is to consider what type of investor road stock/bond mixes) and T. Rowe Price’s Target
you are. Do you like to get your hands dirty Retirement offerings (more equity-heavy asset
overseeing your investments, or are you comfort- allocations) are Morningstar analysts’ favorites.
able outsourcing your asset management to a
professional? Are you a believer in the long-term The Asset Allocator
benefits of an indexing approach, or do you believe Would you like more hands-on oversight of your
that hands-on security selection has the power to asset allocation than a target-date fund affords?
beat passive management? Are you seeking to assemble a portfolio of very
low-cost investments?
What follows are a few key investor profiles, fol-
lowed by appropriate core holding ideas for each. If so, broad-market index funds and exchange-
Many investors may choose to mix and match traded funds make ideal core-holding building
investments from each of these bins. blocks for your portfolio; you can then customize
your allocations to suit your own needs. (I’ve often
The Delegator recommended using Morningstar’s Lifetime
Are you looking to create a sane investment mix with Allocation Indexes as a starting point for that
few moving parts to oversee on an ongoing basis? important part of the investment decision-making
Is your ideal holding period, like Warren Buffett’s, process.) Index funds and ETFs give investors a
“forever”? If so, the right core holding for you is apt high level of control over their asset mixes. There’s
to be an investment that includes a lot of diversifica- no chance that a domestic-stock ETF will suddenly
tion—in terms of asset class, geography, and show up with 20% in cash, and a small-cap index
investment style—under the hood of a single fund. fund won’t begin buying large-cap stocks. And

Where to Invest in 2011 5


Core Anchors for Any Portfolio

thanks in part to the advent of very low-cost ETFs, Oakmark (OAKMX) and Oakmark Select (OAKLX),
index-fund and ETF purveyors have been vying for Fairholme (FAIRX), and T. Rowe Price Equity-
cheapest index-fund rights for the past several Income (PRFDX). Active international offerings can
years, slashing expense ratios and also cutting out also serve as worthwhile core holdings; Dodge &
brokerage charges for ETF trades. Cox International (DODFX), Scout International
(UMBWX), and Harbor International (HAINX) rate
On the domestic-stock front, Morningstar’s large- among the analysts’ “best ideas.” On the fixed-
blend category is the place to go for broadly income side, the teams at PIMCO Total Return
diversified total stock-market index funds and ETFs; (PTTRX), Harbor Bond (HABDX), Dodge & Cox
our analysts’ core index pick is Vanguard Total Income (DODIX), and Metropolitan West Total
Stock Market, available in both conventional Return (MWTRX) have all demonstrated a strong
mutual fund (VTSAX) and ETF (VTI) format. For broad aptitude for beating their benchmarks over time.
international-stock exposure via index funds,
Fidelity Spartan International Index (FSIIX), The Taxable Investor
Vanguard Total International Stock Market If you’re building a portfolio for a taxable account,
Index (VGTSX), and Vanguard FTSE All-World you’ll need to be more choosey than when you’re
ex-US (VEU), an ETF, are the favorite index funds selecting investments for an IRA or other tax-shel-
of Morningstar’s analysts. For core fixed-income tered vehicle. You’ll be on the hook for dividend
exposure, Morningstar’s analysts recommend and capital gains taxes on an ongoing basis, so it
Vanguard Total Bond Market Index, available in pays to focus on funds that have the ability to
both conventional mutual fund (VBMFX) and ETF reduce the tax collector’s cut of their returns on an
(BND) formats, as well as iShares Barclays ongoing basis.
Aggregate Bond (AGG).
My recent article series that highlighted tax-effi-
The Active Management Enthusiast cient model portfolios for retirees, http://news.
Do you believe in the power of active managers to morningstar.com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=361184,
beat their benchmarks? Do you have the patience featured core tax-efficient holdings. My model
to stick with truly active managers through what portfolios featured tax-managed funds such as
will be inevitable weak patches? Are you comfort- Vanguard Capital Appreciation (VMCAX) and
able with the fact that your portfolio—and in turn Tax-Managed International (VTMGX) on the
its performance—will at times be out of step with equity side, primarily because of their ability to
the broad market? adjust their strategies to adapt to current tax
Morningstar’s Fund Analyst Picks feature a number policy. But broad-market index funds and ETFs are
of the aforementioned index funds, but they also also solid core options with a history of good tax
include many topnotch active funds. Among our efficiency (see the “Asset Allocator” section above
team’s longtime favorites are Sequoia (SEQUX), for a few favorites). On the fixed-income side,

Where to Invest in 2011 6


Core Anchors for Any Portfolio

Morningstar’s Fund Analyst Picks in the short- and


intermediate-term municipal national categories
make worthwhile core holdings; the muni lineups
from Fidelity and Vanguard are hard to beat.

Disclosure: Christine Benz has a position in the fol-


lowing securities mentioned above: OAKLX

Where to Invest in 2011 7


Steady-Eddie Stock Funds

By Esther Pak When the market looks anemic and the economic star ratings and risk ratings are quantitative mea-
Assistant Site Editor
outlook uncertain, you want to make sure the sures based on a backward-looking view of risk
Morningstar.com
investments in your portfolio don’t follow suit. So and return.)
what are some dependable, high-conviction stock
funds that investors can rely on to hold steady We also required that managers have at least a
even when the going gets tough? decade of experience at the helm. Finally, we
called up distinct portfolios and funds that were
Using the Premium Fund Screener, http://screen. open to new money. When we ran the screen in
morningstar.com/AdvFunds/Selector.html, we early December, it yielded six funds, three of which
featured our tool’s newest screenable data point— we highlight below.
Average Moat Rating—to home in on funds that
emphasize companies with competitive advantages. Amana Trust Income (AMANX)
(Currently, this data point is only available in our the This fund is geared toward Muslim investors, and
Premium Fund Screener tool, but we are working on as such, it must follow the tenets of Islam. For
adding it to our individual report pages soon.) example, it can’t engage in excessive stock trading
or invest in financial stocks as well as debt-ridden
Investors should note that while wide-moat compa- companies. That may sound exceedingly restrictive,
nies won’t necessarily outperform narrow-moat but in the hands of a talented and experienced
firms during periods of market euphoria, they tend manager, the fund has managed to soar above its
to hold up well during storms. For example, more flexible peers. Half of the most recently
Morningstar’s calculations revealed that domestic available portfolio’s 10 top holdings were wide-
large-cap stock funds with the highest average moat stocks, with familiar names such as Procter
moat ratings were the best category performers in & Gamble (PG), Nike (NKE), and ExxonMobil
2008, whereas the reverse held true in 2009 with (XOM) leading the way. And the fund’s strictures
the widest-moat funds largely underperforming the have actually worked in investors’ favor in the past.
narrow-moat funds by a long shot. The microscopic turnover promotes tax efficiency,
and the fund held up extremely well in the bear
For this screener, we kept the focus on domestic market of 2008 when financials, which it avoids,
stock funds with below-average expenses and at were hit. While these same restrictions held this
least a moderately wide average moat rating. And fund back during the 2009 rally, the fund didn’t trail
to keep a lid on risk, we eliminated any funds with its large-value peers. For the buy-and-hold investor
a Morningstar Risk rating higher than “below aver- with a long-term investing approach, this fund
age” and with a Morningstar Rating for funds of comfortably fits the bill.
less than 4. (It’s important to note that in contrast
with Morningstar’s moat ratings for stocks, which Aston/Montag & Caldwell Growth (MCGFX)
are qualitative and forward-looking, Morningstar’s Investors should not be deterred by this fund’s

Where to Invest in 2011 8


Steady-Eddie Stock Funds

recent slip in performance. While it tends to under-


perform during the early stages of market rallies,
its performance has been exceptional over full
market cycles. Manager Ron Canakaris and his
investment team employ a combination of
top-down analysis and fundamental bottom-up
research. And they keep a fairly concentrated
portfolio of just more than 30 large-cap names
with earnings-growth rates of at least 10%. At the
same time, the team keeps price in the picture;
they will consider selling a stock when it reaches a
20% premium to their calculation of fair value.
Its top seven holdings were recently wide-moat,
low-uncertainty stocks such as Coca-Cola (KO) and
Google (GOOG). All in all, this fund merits
consideration as a core holding in a portfolio.

T. Rowe Price Dividend Growth (PRDGX)


Manager Tom Huber takes a measured approach to
stock selection and portfolio management. Rather
than solely reaching for yield, Huber focuses on
a company’s ability to increase its dividend and kick
off free cash flow. He also considers a stock’s
valuation before making purchases or trimming
shares. Although the portfolio’s top holdings are not
as heavy on wide-moat companies as the preceding
two funds, this offering has still managed to
effectively temper risk in comparison to its rivals.
It has beaten 86% of its peers and the S&P 500
index during Huber’s 10-year watch. His confidence
in his stock selection and long-term outlook is
evident in the fund’s low turnover rate. With its
diversified portfolio of large-cap stocks, this fund is
a solid option for conservative investors.

Where to Invest in 2011 9


Tips and Traps for Short-Term Income-
Oriented Investors

Christine Benz Talk about a rock and a hard place. That’s where better off being patient, even though CD and
Director of Personal Finance
investors in search of a modicum of income from money market yields are unattractive right now. If
Morningstar.com
their cash and other short-term assets have found and when
themselves during the past few years. prevailing yields trend up, you’ll get your chance to
pick up extra income without sacrificing the safe-
On the one hand, you’ve been lucky to earn 1% from guards that come with true cash investments.
true cash. On the other, by venturing into riskier
assets in search of a bit of extra yield, you risk Build a Two-Part Emergency Fund
getting singed by rising interest rates or faltering While it’s a mistake to venture beyond true cash
credits in a still-shaky economic environment. if you’re investing money you can’t afford to lose,
it’s also unwise to hold more in cash instruments
So what’s a yield-starved, safety-loving investor to than you need to cover your emergency fund or
do? And just as important, what shouldn’t they do? meet your household’s near-term cash needs if
Here are some tips. you’re retired.

Beware of Interest-Rate Risk As I discussed in this article, http://news.morning-


In years past, one layup move for cash investors star.com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=351318, I
looking to pick up a bit of extra yield was to like the idea of building a two-part safety fund that
venture beyond true cash and into short-term consists of true cash as well as a high-quality
bonds and bond funds. With the exception of a few short-term bond fund. T. Rowe Price Short-Term
big blowups, as when credit-sensitive ultrashort Bond (PRWBX) is a favorite for the second part
funds imploded during the 2008 credit crisis, of a two-part emergency fund.
venturing beyond certificates of deposit and money
market funds has worked out pretty well, as Don’t Reflexively Avoid CDs, Even Those With
interest rates have trended lower for the better Longer Terms
part of two decades. That tailwind has provided for Certificates of deposit typically offer higher yields
stable or even increasing principal levels. than money market funds because of the liquidity
you give up. If you need to break the CD, either
At this point, however, the risks of getting too because you need your money sooner or you want
aggressive in search of extra yield far outweigh the to take advantage of newly issued CDs with higher
opportunity cost of sticking with relatively safe rates, you’ll pay a penalty that might amount to 90
investments. While it’s possible that interest rates or 180 days’ worth of interest.
could go even lower from here, it’s not especially
probable. As I outlined in this article, http://news. That seems like an unattractive stricture, but do
morningstar.com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=351733, the math before settling for a money market fund
investors for whom capital preservation is key are rather than a CD. If you’re able to pick up a higher

Where to Invest in 2011 10


Tips and Traps for Short-Term Income-Oriented Investors

yield with a longer-term CD, that may offset the cash, you’re better off using a just-in-time
penalty you’ll pay to tap your money prematurely. approach, Keep your cash elsewhere and move it in
The same holds true for longer-term CDs. Even only when you plan to put it to work in longer-term
if you plan to need your money in a short period of investments.
time, the yield pickup may warrant opting for a
longer-term CD versus one that matches your time
horizon perfectly.

Investigate Credit Unions


Morningstar.com users love their credit unions, as
the many enthusiastic comments below this article
illustrate. Although yields everywhere have been
compressed during the past few years, short-term
savings vehicles available through credit unions
may deliver a yield pickup of 0.25% or even more
relative to comparable savings instruments offered
through banks. How are credit unions able to
deliver relatively high payouts? First, they’re non-
profit entities owned and controlled by their
members; they don’t have to deliver a slice of
profits to their shareholders. Nor do credit unions
typically advertise, and they may not provide all
of the amenities available to individuals who use
traditional bank. Both attributes further boost take-
home yields.

Put Your Dead Money to Work


Last but not least, with cash yields as low as they
are, it pays to cull your investment accounts for
extra cash that may not be yielding much at all,
once fees are factored in. The default cash option
may not be the most attractive option at your
brokerage firm or mutual fund company, or that
particular firm may not be a good option for your
cash, period. If your brokerage firm or fund
company can’t offer you a competitive yield on your

Where to Invest in 2011 11


Create a Paycheck in Retirement With a
Total-Return Approach

Christine Benz We’ve frequently debated income versus total- tough to give a ringing endorsement to any one
Director of Personal Finance
return approaches on Morningstar.com during the option within this relatively untested group.
Morningstar.com
past few years, with partisans weighing in on both Moreover, many investors are satisfied with their
sides of the debate, http://news.morningstar.com/ current investment portfolios; they’re just not sure
articlenet/article.aspx?id=344236. I’ve made no where to turn for cash when they need it.
secret of my own “totalnik” leanings, noting that
investors who are fixated on generating current That’s where the bucket approach to retirement
income from their portfolios are often taking on planning can be so effective. Retirement theoreti-
disproportionate risks, http://news.morningstar. cians often consider bucket strategies as too
com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=360790. simplistic, but the concept resonates with many
real-life retirees and the financial advisors who
But there’s an area in which “incomeniks” have it work with them. The basic idea is that you create a
all over the totalniks, and that’s in ease of dedicated pool of assets, composed of cash and
implementation in retirement. By using an income- other very liquid holdings, to meet your near-term
oriented approach, you can create the equivalent of income needs. Once you’ve done that, you can hold
a steady paycheck in retirement (or attempt to, those assets that you don’t need to fulfill near-term
anyway). But tapping your principal periodically, as living expenses in progressively more aggressive
you’re required to do with a total-return approach, investment vehicles.
isn’t just psychologically difficult. It’s also a
logistical headache. You have to figure out which Such a strategy helps ensure that you’re taking
accounts to tap for cash, which in turn affects money from your most stable pool of assets first,
where you’re holding liquid assets, and you also and therefore you won’t have to withdraw from
have to figure out how to tap your accounts in the your higher-risk/higher-return accounts (for
most tax-efficient manner possible. Given that, it’s example, those that hold stocks or more-risky
no wonder that so many retirees are attracted to bonds) when your account is at a low ebb. That
investments that kick off current income. strategy also gives your stock assets, which have
the potential for the highest long-term returns,
Of course, annuities have long held appeal to those more time to grow.
seeking to generate a paycheck in retirement. But
with interest rates as low as they are now, annuity Here’s how to use a total return “bucket” approach
payouts are also depressed. Financial-services to meet your own in-retirement cash needs.
firms have been busy cooking up new investment
products to help retirees generate a paycheck in 1. Determine the Paycheck You Need From
retirement; many of them combine investments Your Portfolio
with insurance features. It’s early days for most of If you’re attempting to create the equivalent of a
these vehicles, however, and at this point, it’s paycheck from your portfolio, the first step is to

Where to Invest in 2011 12


Create a Paycheck in Retirement With a Total-Return Approach

gauge your income needs during retirement, either article provides more detail on sequencing
on an annual or a monthly basis. Start by tallying withdrawals to maximize your long-term tax
your total expenditures, then subtract steady savings, but here’s a quick overview:
sources of income that you can rely on, including
Social Security and pension income. What’s left u If you’re older than 70 1/2 and taking required
over is the amount that you’ll need to extract from minimum distributions from your IRA or the
your portfolio each month or each year. retirement plan of your former employer, some
or all of your near-term paycheck should come
2. Make Sure Your Withdrawal Rate Is from those accounts. (Bear in mind that the
Sustainable amount of your RMD will vary from year to year,
The next step is to evaluate whether your desired based on your account balances as well as your
portfolio withdrawal amount is too large or just age.)
about right. Most financial planners consider a 4% u If you’re not 70 1/2 or your RMDs won’t cover

annual withdrawal rate, combined with annual your cash needs, turn to your taxable accounts
upward adjustments to accommodate inflation, a to see if they will cover your cash needs during
safe withdrawal amount. For another check, the next two years.
Morningstar’s Asset Allocator tool can help you u If your RMDs and taxable accounts won’t cover

determine whether your current portfolio puts you at least two years’ worth of living expenses,
on track to meet your retirement-income needs. carve out any additional amount of living
(Just bear in mind that it’s using fairly rosy return expenses from your IRA or company retirement
expectations for stocks.) plan assets using the sequence outlined above.
Save Roth accounts for last because they offer
3. Put in Place a Short-Term Bucket Holding the most flexibility and long-term tax-savings
of at Least Two Years’ Worth of Living benefits.
Expenses
Assuming your desired withdrawal rate is sustain- 4. Put It on Autopilot
able, set up a short-term bucket consisting of at Once you’ve identified where your cash will be
least two years’ worth of living expenses set aside coming from during the next few years, contact
in highly liquid (that is, checking, savings, money your financial-service provider to see if it can help
market, and certificate of deposit) investments. automate your withdrawals, sending you the
Where you hold these assets depends on where equivalent of a paycheck at preset intervals. (Better
you are in retirement as well as where you’re yet, your firm should be able to deposit the
holding the bulk of your retirement savings. paycheck directly into your account.) The larger
Being strategic about where you take withdrawals your fund company or brokerage firm, the more
from can help you stretch out the tax-savings likely it is to offer such an option.
benefits from your tax-sheltered accounts. This

Where to Invest in 2011 13


Create a Paycheck in Retirement With a Total-Return Approach

5. Other Important Tasks


In addition to getting your paycheck plan up and
running, it’s important to periodically replenish your
cash assets as they become depleted. Once you’ve
set aside your cash position, put in place a plan to
periodically refill your cash stake so that it always
will cover at least two years’ worth of living
expenses. Plan to incorporate this step into your
rebalancing process. Ideally, you’d fill up your most
liquid bucket with proceeds from rebalancing-
related sales or with money from your next most
liquid pool of assets (for example, intermediate-
term bonds).

Where to Invest in 2011 14


Topnotch Bargain-Hunting Funds

By Esther Pak Uncertain market conditions drive some investment below their estimate of fair value as a result of
Assistant Site Editor
managers to amp up their cash stakes and wait by short-term concerns. For example, they bought
Morningstar.com
the sidelines. Other managers, meanwhile, use peri- asset-management companies that investors found
ods of market uncertainty as an impetus to go shop- unattractive because of market conditions. They
ping, buying what other investors are dropping. also hung on to top holding Johnson & Johnson
(JNJ), noting that its recent string of product
To help identify truly active bargain-hunting man- recalls doesn’t diminish the company’s core
agers who have successfully found opportunities strengths. Armed with this strategy, the managers
amid market turbulence and company-specific strive to achieve a moderate return in rising mar-
problems, we turned to our Premium Fund kets while limiting downside losses, a balance that
Screener, http://screen.morningstar.com/AdvFunds/ they have achieved successfully. During the bear
Selector.html. We homed in on both the domestic market from late 2007 through early 2009, the fund
and foreign value fund categories with underlying held up much better than its category peers, and it
stocks of small, medium, and large market capital- went on to post respectable absolute returns dur-
izations. To winnow our list to funds run by the ing 2009’s rally.
most talented and veteran managers, we required
that managers have more than a decade of experi- Oakmark International (OAKIX)
ence at the helm and that their funds rank in the Manager David Herro subscribes to a decidedly
top quartile of their categories for the trailing contrarian style. He invests in beaten-up stocks that
10-year period. trade at discounts of at least 40% to his
estimates of their intrinsic value; this strategy is
On the fees front, we eliminated load funds with based on his belief that over the long haul, these
expense ratios above the category average. And to stocks are bound to recover. Investors should keep
further weed out funds that move in lock step with in mind that Herro does not shy away from
their indexes, we called up funds with lower-than- emerging markets and some smaller-cap names;
average R-squared figures. (R-squared measures an he’ll also make sizable sector and country bets
investment’s correlation with an index or other when they seem profitable. All of these qualities
investment.) Finally, to whittle the list down even fur- have the potential to court additional risk, but Herro
ther, we screened for distinct portfolios of each fund. has managed this fund’s risks successfully. Due in
part to his standout results here, Oakmark
This screen yielded seven bargain-hunting funds, International ranks as one of Morningstar’s Analyst
three of which we highlight below. Picks, and the analyst team also named him
Morningstar’s International Manager of the Decade
American Century Value (TWVLX) for 2000-09, http://news.morningstar.com/arti-
Managers Phil Davidson, Michael Liss, and Kevin clenet/article.aspx?id=321713. This manager eats
Toney look for healthy companies that are trading his own cooking, too, with more than $1 million

Where to Invest in 2011 15


Topnotch Bargain-Hunting Funds

invested in this fund. Investors can therefore rest


assured that his incentives are aligned with those
of the shareholders.

Tweedy Browne Global Value (TBGVX)


Comanagers William Browne, John Spears, Tom
Shrager, and Bob Wyckoff are experienced
investors with an eye for value across the market-
cap spectrum and geographic borders. This foreign
large-cap value fund sticks to a value discipline,
investing in companies with healthy balance sheets
whose prices are below their estimates of fair
value. As Morningstar fund analyst Kevin McDevitt
notes, “[management] would rather pay a fair price
for a good business, than a low price for a
mediocre one.” Management hedges its foreign-
currency exposure back into U.S. dollars, and that
can hold the fund back during times that foreign
currencies gain an edge over the dollar. But for
low-risk exposure to global stocks, this fund merits
a place on investors’ radars.

Where to Invest in 2011 16


Our Picks for Inflation Protection

By Christine Benz If there’s a small silver lining amid the current inflation-protected bonds. The former are bonds
Director of Personal Finance
economic malaise, it’s that inflation has been for individual investors issued by the Treasury
Morningstar.com
pretty muted. Department; their yields adjust upward to reflect
changes in the Consumer Price Index. (This article
But investors ignore inflation at their own peril. provides more color on I-Bonds, http://news.morn-
Even if massive amounts of government stimulus ingstar.com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=341946.)
don’t prompt inflation, there’s still the possibility Inflation-protected bonds, such as TIPS, are simi-
of price spikes here in the United States as a lar, but the inflation adjustment comes at the
result of still-red-hot economic growth in emerg- principal level, not in the bond’s yield.
ing markets. Widespread rising prices, in turn,
could amount to erosion in the purchasing power Best Bets
of any assets you’ve managed to save or invest. There are no funds composed of I-Bonds, but
By the time you start tapping your portfolio to there are a number of offerings that focus on
meet your income needs, those dollars could be inflation-protected bonds. For plain-vanilla TIPS
worth a lot more than they are right now. exposure, it’s tough to beat the low-cost
Vanguard Inflation-Protected Securities
That’s why it’s so important to ensure that your (VIPSX); for ETF enthusiasts, iShares Barclays
portfolio is adequately protected against inflation. TIPS Bond (TIP) is another low-cost, no-nonsense
Some inflation-fighting vehicles have explicit choice. The PIMCO-managed Harbor Real Return
protection against rising prices, such as Treasury (HARRX), meanwhile, has successfully employed a
Inflation-Protected Securities. Others, such as broader toolkit that encompasses non-U.S. infla-
stocks, protect against inflation indirectly. tion-protected bonds and the use of forward con-
tracts to obtain TIPS exposure. While SPDR DB
Here’s an overview of the key vehicles with International Government Inflation-Protected
inflation-fighting attributes, as well as some of Bond (WIP) isn’t an official ETF Analyst Pick, but
Morningstar’s top picks within those groups. it provides both inflation protection and diversifi-
cation away from the U.S. dollar.
Inflation-Protected Bonds
The Thesis Bank Loans
For holders of nominal (that is, not inflation-pro- The Thesis
tected) bonds, inflation is a natural enemy, right Unlike inflation-protected bonds, bank loans don’t
up there with rising interest rates. If an invest- include an explicit mechanism to ward against
ment is delivering a fixed payout, inflation will inflation. But they stand to be fairly hardy when
reduce the value of that payout accordingly. inflation is on the move. That’s because bank-
That’s where inflation-protected bonds come into loan payouts fluctuate in line with the London
play. There are two main varieties: I-Bonds and Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR)—the rate that

Where to Invest in 2011 17


Our Picks for Inflation Protection

banks charge one another to borrow money. haven’t been perfect trackers of commodity prices
When the LIBOR heads up, which is often the as a result of a situation called contango. (Read
case during inflationary environments, so do this article for a discussion of the pros and cons
bank-loan coupon payments. of these investments, http://news.morningstar.
com/articlenet/article.aspx?id=354373.)
Best Bets Morningstar’s open-end fund team doesn’t cur-
Bank-loan funds might seem to have it all: rently include any commodities offerings among
imperviousness to rising interest rates plus some its Analyst Picks. Our exchange-traded fund team,
inflation-fighting characteristics. But investors meanwhile, has a few commodities picks,
should tread with caution in this varied category. including iPath DJ-UBS Commodity Index (DJP).
Due to credit sensitivity and forced bank-loan
selling from institutional investors, the average Stocks
bank-loan fund lost a shocking 29% in 2008. The Thesis
Morningstar’s favorite fund here is one of the Stocks are another indirect way to gird your
group’s slow and steady options, Fidelity portfolio against the threat of inflation. Their
Floating Rate High Income (FFRHX), where returns are variable, in contrast with fixed-rate
manager Christine McConnell assiduously avoids investments, giving them the potential for higher
the market’s riskiest loans. returns than bonds. That means that inflation
could take a smaller bite, in percentage terms,
Commodities/Metals Funds out of your future purchasing power.
The Thesis
The premise behind owning commodities invest- Best Bets
ments for inflation protection is straightforward: Not all stocks will thrive in an inflationary
If the prices of goods are going up, an investment environment, and some companies may even see
that captures price changes in food, energy, and their profitability flag. To help identify companies
basic-materials costs will thrive at the same time. with a strong history of profitability through a
variety of economic environments, screening for
Best Bets firms with high returns on equity is a good
Although the case for commodities for inflation starting point. Morningstar’s preset Wealth
protection is straightforward, the implementation Creators screen can help you identify such firms,
isn’t. Owning the stocks of commodities compa- and layering on an additional screen for wide
nies, as with an offering like T. Rowe Price New moats will further winnow down the universe
Era (PRNEX), provides indirect exposure to the to companies with long-term competitive
prices of stuff. And while commodities futures- advantages. Fund investors have a few top
based funds aim to provide broad, and direct, options, including Vanguard Dividend Growth
exposure to the prices of goods, in practice they (VDIGX) and T. Rowe Price Dividend Growth

Where to Invest in 2011 18


Our Picks for Inflation Protection

(PRDGX) (traditional actively managed funds) and


the index fund Vanguard Dividend Appreciation
(available as a conventional mutual fund (VDAIX)
and ETF (VIG).

Where to Invest in 2011 19


Ideas in Emerging Markets Beyond the
Broad Indexes

Timothy Strauts Many investors today have some exposure to the through the worst of the crisis in 2009, these
ETF Analyst
emerging-markets asset class, often through one of economies as a whole still posted positive GDP
Morningstar.com
the broad index funds like iShares MSCI growth, whereas every major developed market
Emerging Markets (EEM) or Vanguard Emerging contracted dramatically.
Markets Stock ETF (VWO). Emerging markets have
seen tremendous inflows in the past few years, but With these fundamental economic drivers
most of the investment has gone to the major explained, let’s look at two promising investments
large-cap-focused indexes. The emerging world is in the emerging-markets space.
a very large and diverse asset class, and we think
investors willing to look a bit harder can find richer WisdomTree Emerging Markets SmallCap
opportunities beyond the largest exchange-traded Dividend (DGS)
funds. But before we get into the details of our With more than 30% of world consumption taking
recommendations, it is important to understand the place in emerging-markets countries, consumers in
macroeconomic factors that are driving interest in those countries are an underappreciated driver of
the emerging-markets space. growth. Most investors think of emerging markets
as the producers of cheap products that are later
Changes made by emerging markets in the 1990s bought by people in the developed world. While
set the stage for the phenomenal investment this is true, the accelerated growth of emerging
performance over the past 10 years. Many develop- countries has also rapidly increased the income of
ing countries abandoned fixed exchange rates, the emerging consumer. DGS is best positioned to
adopted inflation targeting, reduced external debt, take advantage of this growing trend because of its
and lowered fiscal deficits. Today, emerging focus on small-cap stocks. These small companies
economies make up one third of global GDP. On get most of their revenue from the local economy
average, they should grow by more than 6% in and have very little exposure to external demand.
2010 compared with the expected growth of only While the largest positions in VWO are global
2% in the United States. multinationals focused in the technology, energy,
and materials sector, DGS has increased exposure
These trends are not expected to reverse anytime to consumer and industrial sectors that are more
soon either. The developed world’s dramatically leveraged to domestic growth trends.
higher debt burden will constrain growth for years
to come, and emerging markets still have plenty of Over the past three years, returns to DGS had a
room for easy productivity gains from adopting standard deviation (a measure of risk) very close to
modern infrastructure and technology. The recent the large-cap-focused MSCI Emerging Markets
global financial crisis sparked even greater investor Index but still 50% higher than the S&P 500. The
interest in emerging-markets equities because it portfolio for DGS does not follow a typical market-
showed the strength of the emerging world. Even cap-weighting methodology but instead weights

Where to Invest in 2011 20


Ideas in Emerging Markets Beyond the Broad Indexes

the holdings by total dividend yield of the underly- but we think it will add incrementally to returns
ing company. Companies with higher dividend pay- over time.
outs get a higher weighting in the fund. This focus
on dividends ensures the companies in the fund With the sovereign-debt crisis in Europe, investors
have attained some minimal level of profitability are re-evaluating which countries are most
but tends to underallocate to some countries. For creditworthy. The emerging world has an average
example, Chinese companies have only a 6% public debt/GDP ratio of less than 50% while the
weighting in DGS, whereas the Emerging Markets United States has a ratio close to 100%. The credit
Index has 18% invested in China. Overall, we pre- ratings agencies continue to take note of the good
fer the dividend-weighting methodology because it fundamentals, as emerging markets have received
reduces risk and naturally focuses on companies 6 times more upgrades than downgrades in 2010.
that already have profitable businesses. There is growing belief that, despite emerging
markets’ lower credit ratings, they may actually be
WisdomTree Emerging Markets Local Debt (ELD) better credit risks than developed markets.
Emerging-markets debt historically has been very
volatile and prone to defaults. Most debt was ELD has a current yield of 4.8%, an average credit
issued in U.S. dollars until very recently because rating of A-, and a duration of only 4.0 years. The
investors refused to take the risk of currency expo- fund was launched in August 2010, but because it
sure as well as the credit exposure to these unsta- is one of the first ETFs to offer access to emerging-
ble countries. However, this exposed the govern- markets local currency bonds, it has seen strong
ments of developing markets to the volatile swings inflows and currently offers good liquidity. ELD
of their currencies in comparison to the U.S. dollar. implements a tiering strategy that attempts to put
In the past 10 years, emerging countries have more assets in countries that maintain strong fiscal
worked to reduce their reliance on external funding discipline. Currently, the fund has its highest
and the risks of issuing U.S. dollar debt. Their weightings in Brazil, Mexico, Malaysia, and
growing private pension systems, higher savings Indonesia. With ELD you’re getting an investment-
rates, sound fiscal policies, and more flexible cur- grade portfolio with an attractive yield, relatively
rency regimes have created internal demand for low interest-rate risk, and the potential for
the emerging countries’ government debt, and increased returns if the U.S. dollar weakens versus
macroeconomic changes over the past couple of emerging markets.
decades mean that many emerging markets have
investment-grade credit ratings today. With this Disclosure: Morningstar licenses its indexes to cer-
newfound stability, we feel that exposure to local tain ETF and ETN providers, including BlackRock
currency emerging-markets bonds can now act as Asset Management, First Trust, and ELEMENTS, for
a hedge on further U.S. dollar weakness. This use in exchange-traded funds and notes. These ETFs
foreign currency risk increases the volatility of ELD, and ETNs are not sponsored, issued, or sold by

Where to Invest in 2011 21


Ideas in Emerging Markets Beyond the Broad Indexes

Morningstar. Morningstar does not make any repre-


sentation regarding the advisability of investing in
ETFs or ETNs that are based on Morningstar
indexes.

Where to Invest in 2011 22

Anda mungkin juga menyukai