Abstract: - Among the ancillary services, the operating reserves are important researching aspects, which deal
with supplying way and selling-buying prices. Currently, distributed generation (DG) rises as a new participant
in providing ancillary services, therefore, it is of main importance in operating reserves subject. This work
shows some advantages and technical drawbacks by using DG when operating reserves are supplied. Different
sceneries were computed where the electric generation was performed in a centralized and non-centralized way
respectively. A methodology for identifying the maximum DG, which can be allocated, is proposed; this
maximum level can be assessed without carrying out a negative impact in the network. Diverse DG technologies,
which present better performance in supplying such reserves, are also presented.
different production profile, therefore, the load flows Micro-turbine øøø øøø
Steam Turbine øøø øøø
and losses impact depends on each technology.
Combined Cycle øøø øøø
Generally, the DG profile varies constantly. This
Electrochemical Devices øøø øøø
variation can be produced by the primary resource
Small hydro ▲▲▲ ▲
(wind, sun, water, etc) or due to the process features
Wind turbines ▲▲▲ ▲▲▲
(e.g. co-generation process).
Mini-Wind ▲▲▲ ▲▲▲
As the DG production profile is adapted to the
PhotoVoltaic ▲▲▲ ▲▲▲
demand profile of the buses where the DG is
PhotoThermal øø ▲
installed, the electric parameters will be better or
Fuel Cell øø ▲▲
worse. For instance, if the DG production in each bus
is exactly equal to the demand in each bus, the losses Table 4 DG technologies behaviors for
will be annulated since all the demand is supplied operating reserves supplying [17]
locally and there are no flows in the network. øøø: very good
Therefore, the GD more appropriate technologies for øø: good
supplying operating reserves are with constant ▲: normal
production profiles. ▲▲: bad
In this category can be classified the generators ▲▲▲: very bad
which supply almost constant power all the time
(higher utilization factor, generally classified from 0
up to 1, where 1 is the maximum value). In some
cases the DG production can be practically constant, 5 Conclusion
which is the case of combustible-cells, biomass plants Providing operating reserves by DG makes that the
and the gas micro-turbines. These technologies are large centralized generators reduces the schedule
well conditioned to the demand profile. In [7] was energy for delivering reserves. Therefore, these large
shown that the wind and photovoltaic generation are generators can have more available power for the
ill conditioned for the demand profile. Table 4 shows basic energy supplied to the system.
the technologies behavior related to the demand and By using DG, overvoltage levels can appear, mainly
the operating reserves delivery. in the distribution network and with less impact in the
sub transmission and transmission systems. An
As was explained earlier, the electricity markets in alternative for avoiding these overvoltages is
different countries are discriminated mainly in the increasing the DG penetration level with low power
methodologies or procedures in the operative reserve generators, it means with a greater DG dispersion.
management. In general, the maximum level of The DG contribution to the operating reserves
operating reserves and the time for the entry presents more advantages related with losses in sub
transmission and sub transmission systems, in the [10] C.W. Yu, X.S. Zhao, F.S. Wen, C.Y. Chung,
distribution systems the losses reduction is more T.S. Chung, M.X. Huang, Princing and
conservative since it depends on the technical system procurement of operating reserves in competitive
variables and can be manage with a major DG pool-based electricity markets, Electrical Power
dispersion. Systems Research, N° 73, 2005, pp. 37-43.
The DG impact on the system depends generally on [11] Kun-Yuan Huang, Yann-Chang Huang,
the production profile and how it is adaptable to the Integrating Direct Load Control With
demand profile. The DG technologies that can Interruptible Load Management to Provide
accomplish a better role in the operating reserves Instantaneous Reserves for Ancillary services,
delivery are those with a constant production profile IEEE Transactions on Power Systems, Vol. 19,
and also those that can begin to increase output No. 3, pp. 1626-1634, August 2004
delivery immediately in response to changes to [12] Power Systems, Test Case Archive,
interconnection frequency to correct for http://www.ee.washington.edu/research/pstca/pf3
generation/load imbalances caused by generation or 0/pg_tca30bus.htm
transmission outages. [13] Mesut E. Baran, Felix F. Wu, Optimal
Capacitor Placement On Radial Distribution
Systems, Copyright Material IEEE Transactions
References: on Power Delivery, Vol4, N°1, pp. 725-734.
[14] PSERC, Matpowe, A Matlab Power System
[1] L. Wang, C.W. Yu, F.S. Wen, Economic Theory Simulation Packege, V 3,
And The Aplication Of Incentive Contracts To www.pserc.edu/matpower/
Procure Operation Reserves”, Copyright [15] S. Conti, S. Raiti and G. Tina, Small-scale
Material Electric Power Systems Research, 2007, embedded generation effect on voltage profile: an
N°77, pp. 518-526. analytical method, IEE Proceedings Generation,
[2] Bayegan, M., A Vision of the Future Grid, IEEE Transmission and Distribution, Vol. 150, No. 1,
Power Engineering Review, Vol. 21, pp. 10-12, 2003, pp. 78-86.
December 2001. [16] C.L. Masters, Voltage rise, the big issue
[3] Fang Z, Editorial Special Issue on Distributed when connecting embedded generation to long 11
Power Generation, IEEE Transactions on Power kV overhead lines, Power Engineering Journal,
Electronics, V 19, N° 5, September 2004. February 2002, pp. 5-12
[4] Y. Xiaoyan, T. Leon, Ancillary Services Provided [17] V.H. Méndez, J. River, J.I. de la Fuente, T.
from DER with Power Electronics Interface, Gómez, J. Arceluz, J. Marín, Amadurga, Impac
IEEE Power Engineering Review, Vol. 21, of distributed generation on distribution
December 2006, pp. 10-12. investment deferral", Electrical Power and
[5] Pepermans G., Driesen J., Haeseldonckx D., Energy Systems, N° 28, 2006, pp. 244-252
Belmans R., D’haeseleer W., Distributed
generation: definition, benefits and issues,
Energy Policy, N° 33, 2005. Biographies
[6] S. Persaud, B. Fox and D. Flynn, Impact of Francisco D. Moya Ch received the P.E. in Electrical
Remotely Connected Wind Turbines on Steady Engineering from the National University of
State Operation of Radial Distribution Networks, Colombia and the M.S. in electrical Engineering
IEE Proceedings. Generation, Transmission and from University Los Andes, Colombia, in 2000 and
Distribution, Vol. 147, No. 3; pp. 157-163; 2000. 2005, respectively. He presently is a Ph.D. student in
[7] V.H. Méndez, J. River, J.I. de la Fuente, T. electrical engineering at UNICAMP (University of
Gómez, Assessment of Energy Distribution Campinas), Brazil. His main research interests are in
Losses for Increasing Penetration of Distributed power quality, distributed energy systems, energy
Generation, IEEE Transactions on Power efficiency and conservation, renewables, energy and
Electronics, V 21, N° 2, May 2006, pp. 533-540. environmental policy.
[8] T. Griffin, K. Tomsovic, D. Secrest and A. Law,
Placement of Dispersed Generations Systems for Duvier B. Bedoya areceived the P.E. in Electrical
Reduced Losses, 33rd Hawaii International Engineering with first class honours from the
Conference on System Sciences; 2000. National University of Colombia, Manizales,
[9] A. Naesh, M. Pukar, N. Mithulananthan, An Colombia, in 2004, the M.S. in Electrical Engineering
analytical approach for DG allocation in primary from UNICAMP (University of Campinas), in 2007,
distribution network, N° 28, 2006, pp. 669-678 where he is currently researcher. His main research
interests are in voltage stability, high voltaje and
embedded generation studies.