India’s Central
Business
Districts
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
Million sq ft
their property now as markets are improving.
These owners and investors, three of whom
have been profiled in this report, are attempting 1
to benefit from the recovering demand for office 0
space and thereby benefit from the ensuing higher Delhi Mumbai Chennai Hyderabad Kolkata
rental premiums expected post retrofitting. Total Grade A Stock Total Grade B Stock
The Potential of
Retrofitting Indian Table 4 : Office Building Grades
Grade Characteristics
CBDs Flexible and large floor plates; spacious, well-decorated lobbies and
The CBDs of most Indian cities have a huge circulation areas; effective central air-conditioning; professionally managed;
A
potential to retrofit their existing old stock. The 100% power back-up; parking facilities available in the basement; good
prime reasons for opting for this initiative are tenant profile; good facade.
lower grade stock and limited supply along with Flexible and mid-sized floor plates; adequate lobbies; no central air-
unlocking inherent land value B conditioning; less than 100% power back-up; adequate lift services;
Lower Grade Stock and Limited Supply average management; average tenant profile; average look/façade.
The existing building stock in any Indian CBD Plain with basic finishes; less flexible layout; small floor plates; basic
is about three to four decades old. Most of lobbies; no central air-conditioning; no power-up; barely adequate or
C
these buildings have small floor plates and are inadequate lift services; minimal to average management; barely adequate
not designed to accommodate newer building or inadequate parking; average tenant profile; poor facade.
operating equipment such as power generators,
modern fire safety equipment, and HVAC systems.
This reduces the building efficiency and increases
operational costs to occupiers (Table 3).
Cities have been selected based on the demand for Grade A office space in CBDs, availability of Grade A space in CBDs and high volume of Grade B buildings that can be retrofitted.
Stock as on 4Q10
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
Unlocking Inherent Land Value Figure 2: Rental Values For Grade A and Grade B Buildings Within India’s CBD
Land values are highest in CBD micro-markets
300
and tend to progressively decline as one moves
0
occupiers rises with diminishing building quality. Table 5: Potential Annual Revenue Gains From Retrofitting
Grade B rents are observed to be 20-38% less Revenue (INR million)
than Grade A rents in the CBDs of prime Indian City Conversion of All Grade B Office Conversion of Only 30% of Grade B
Space Office Space
cities (Figure 2). This highlights that poor building
Delhi 9,576 2,872
quality hinders the full realization of the high land
Mumbai 12,870 3,861
value found within CBDs. Yet, relatively lower
Chennai 3,469 1,040
rental values for Grade B buildings in CBDs are
Hyderabad 1,680 468
not enough to ensure high occupancy levels. Like
Kolkata 3,600 1,080
older Grade A CBD buildings, which are losing
tenants to cost-efficient, quality properties in other The full realization of high-priced CBD land value can be achieved through retrofitting
micro-markets, Grade B buildings are also seeing of existing Grade B office space into Grade A in order to increase the rents that a given
tenants leave due to a lack of quality space. property can command. Even if we conservatively assume that only 30% of the current
Collectively, this increases vacancy in the micro- Grade B stock in cities across India can potentially be retrofitted to Grade A space, an
market and increases pressure on rental values additional INR 2.9 billion of rental revenue can potentially be generated annually above
in CBDs. the current aggregate level of INR 6.4 billion, representing a nearly 45% increase.
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
A wide variety of implementation risks for ● Planned approach: each building were initially
retrofitting projects need to be accounted for studied and surveyed to strategise a master
through expert project planning and management. retrofitting plan. This included an intensive
These risks include schedule delays, most notably study of the property layout, performance and
in occupied buildings. Safety, an area of concern equipment to better understand the areas that
with any development project, is a heightened need revitalisation.
concern as the condition of older buildings can ● Financial implication: the market demand and
also pose additional risk. Technical risks involved valuation of properties was studied to determine
with retrofitting include inadequate structural their post-retrofitting financial feasibility. All three
load capacity along with redundant services retrofitting projects were found to be financially
and a legacy of ad-hoc repair, maintenance and feasible and all buildings are achieving,
alteration. Detailed site surveys by qualified or expected to achieve, higher rents post-
architects and contractors are often used as an retrofitting.
effective first step to assess overall project risk ● Risk mitigation: the risks faced and mitigation
and as a foundation for creating an initial project strategies employed varied greatly for each
design. project. Broadly speaking, however, all three
projects had to account for operational,
Our case studies mentioned later, illustrate that technical and financial risks while ensuring that
proper planning and efficient project management existing tenants were not inconvenienced.
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
● Enhanced valuation: as one of the earliest skyscrapers of New York, the building was to be repositioned as a Grade A office property and a
leader in efficient and sustainable building operations, leading to major operational savings and increased rental rates
● Green building status: sustainability was a driver as energy-efficient projects are more attractive for corporate occupiers who increasingly
look for sustainable buildings
Benefits
● Replacement of existing 6,500 windows with suspended coated film and glass fill
Major
● Project implementation by three different stakeholders over a five-year period using various implementation mechanisms
● A collaborative team was formed to develop the optimal retrofit solution through an iterative process that requires experience, energy,
Method /
Process
● Using energy performance contracting (EPC), a building retrofit generates guaranteed energy savings that, over a number of years, can be
equal to the cost of the project including financing costs
10 Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
Revenue Generation: HUL will retrofit their self-owned building in the Mumbai CBD for further leasing to corporate clients for revenue
Drivers
generation. The mentioned building has been vacated as HUL has moved its operations to their new facility in northern suburbs
● Quality Upgrade: the building needs to be retrofitted to meet the quality and infrastructure expectations of prospective occupiers
Benefits
● Facade facelift
Retrofits
● Studies were conducted to compare the building with surrounding buildings to understand the feasibility of the project
● Due consideration was given to international best practices, operational efficiency, amenities and services to ensure that the building is
better equipped to suit occupiers and beat the competition
Risk /
● Cumbersome construction work in a dense South Mumbai area amidst the presence of a high security state government headquarters
(Mantralaya) zone was a time-consuming process
Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District 11
Leasing to a good tenant mix for revenue generation purposes also remains a major objective.
● Understand profitability: to understand the profitability of retrofitting in India, as this was a new initiative by investors, so that it can be
replicated in other projects
● Good tenant mix, eying key corporate occupiers and brands
● Increase in rents on account of better quality facilities and services being offered to occupiers
Benefits
refurbishment, the developer planned the exercise in such a way that existing tenants did not have to vacate the premises during the
process.
● Parallel electrical systems and other technological support were used to allow existing tenants to continue to work in the building without
disturbing their businesses
Mitigation
Risk /
● Handling operational risk was a major challenge as the retrofitting works were being conducted while the building was occupied. However,
through efficient and planned project management this risk was mitigated and regular operations of the tenants were not affected
12 Advance - Retrofitting India’s Central Business District
An Idea Who’s Time retail demand and benefit from the experience of
shopping in heritage buildings with their striking
Has Come architectural features.
While the quantum of retrofitting projects in Kala Ghoda, Mumbai
India is currently small, it is an effective solution Kala Ghoda, Mumbai’s art district, has a skyline
for revitalizing individual properties and re- that is dotted with gothic style buildings. The
establishing the appeal of entire micro-markets. In precinct, famous for its art galleries and museums,
addition to Express Tower and the HUL Building, contains a large number of older Grade B office
other office buildings including One Forbes House buildings with retail space on the ground floor.
and Hoechst House in Mumbai’s CBD have been As the area witnesses strong demand for retail,
retrofitted into Grade A properties and put up for the ground floors of a few older buildings have
leasing. Similarly, in Delhi’s CBD, HT House on been renovated to accommodate modern retail
Kasturba Gandhi Marg was retrofitted and leased shops and restaurants. Major retailers such as
out as its market position has improved. Globus, Westside and Planet Fashion currently
Connaught Place, Delhi have operating stores in the precinct. The Kala
Connaught Place is a heritage site and the Ghoda area is ripe for further retrofitting projects
prime retail precinct of Delhi. The market was which will improve the economic life of existing
designed in British style architecture and laid older buildings and provide prime retail space in
out in a pattern of concentric circles for ease of a district where there are limited opportunities for
shopping. This preferred shopping districts of development.
Delhi is home to many prominent retailers such Mumbai and Delhi are bellwethers for India’s
as United Colors of Benetton, Wills Lifestyle and commercial office and retail real estate markets.
Van Heusen. It is always crowded by tourists and As two of India’s largest and most dynamic
the city dwellers as it has variety of restaurants cities, they are often where new trends take
and shops. In Connaught Place retailers have flight. Retrofitting, whether to improve Grade A
retrofitted existing older space into sophisticated properties or promote from Grade B to Grade
and stylish stores while retaining the original A, is something that is being witnessed with an
architectural characteristics of the building. As increasing regularity, a trend we expect to continue
the area was developed in the early twentieth as landlords become cognizant of the benefits of
century and needed an overall restoration, New this quality improvement option.
Delhi Municipal Corporation has started a project
to redevelop the entire precinct. NDMC is working
on facade restoration of the inner and outer circles
of Connaught Place and has planned to renovate
flooring and provide flood lighting to improve the
visual appeal of the market and improve facilities.
Authors
Trivita Roy, Manager, Research & REIS
trivita.roy@ap.jll.com
+91 40 4040 9100
Trivita Roy has joined Jones Lang LaSalle Meghraj Research team in 2007.Based out of Hyderabad;
she contributes to topical whitepapers, property market digest and research deliverables on industrial,
commercial, retail , and sustainable real estate markets in India. She is also responsible for Indian real
estate intelligence service (REIS). Trivita is trained as City Planner from Indian Institute of Technology
Kharagpur and has more than three years of experience in real estate research.
Abhishek Kiran Gupta leads the Jones Lang LaSalle India Research team and is based in Mumbai.
He manages research operations on a Pan-India level and is responsible for the team’s outputs,
including research reports such as topical white papers, property market digests and bespoke research
projects based on specific client requirements. Prior to joining Jones Lang LaSalle, he had seven
years of experience in market research, business analysis and market strategy consulting, servicing
diversified industries including pharmaceutical, software publishing and insurance.
Acknowlegement
We would like to acknowledge the support of ICICI Ventures and HUL. We would also like to acknowledge the contribution of
Jones Lang LaSalle New York and other team members.
About Jones Lang LaSalle
Jones Lang LaSalle (NYSE:JLL) is a financial and professional services firm specializing in real estate. The firm offers integrated services delivered by
expert teams worldwide to clients seeking increased value by owning, occupying or investing in real estate. With 2010 global revenue USD2.9 billion,
Jones Lang LaSalle serves clients in 60 countries from 750 locations worldwide, including 180 corporate offices. The firm is an industry leader in property
and corporate facility management services, with a portfolio of approximately 1.7 billion square feet worldwide. LaSalle Investment Management, the
company’s investment management business, is one of the world’s largest and most diverse in real estate with approximately USD41 billion of assets under
management. For further information, please visit our website, www.joneslanglasalle.com
Jones Lang LaSalle has over 50 years of experience in Asia Pacific, with over 19,400 employees operating in 77 offices in 13 countries across the region.
Real Estate Intelligence Service (REIS) India is a subscription based research service designed to provide you with cutting
edge insights into India’s diverse and challenging real estate markets through collation, analysis and forecasts of property market
indicators and trends across all major Indian markets across various real estate asset classes - office, retail, residential.
REIS empowers you with consistent and complete market data and analyses for all real estate indicators by specific micro markets.
It is supplemented by value added services including client briefings, presentations and rapid market updates.
COPYRIGHT © JONES LANG LASALLE All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be published without prior written permission from Jones Lang LaSalle. The information in this
publication should be regarded solely as a general guide. Whilst care has been taken in its preparation no representation is made or responsibility accepted for the accuracy of the whole or
any part. We stress that forecasting is a problematical exercise which at best should be regarded as an indicative assessment of possibilities rather than absolute certainties. The process
of making forward projections involves assumptions regarding numerous variables which are acutely sensitive to changing conditions, variations in any one of which may significantly affect
the outcome, and we draw your attention to this factor.