How British Airways reached for the skies by carving out back-office activities,
giving birth to the successful WNS Global Solutions
In this period of turbulent economic and capital market conditions, corporates are
increasingly faced with the challenge of how to focus on their core businesses,
reduce costs, avoid unnecessary capital expenditure and enhance the balance
sheet wherever possible, whilst at the same time avoiding large-scale layoffs and
destroying morale. The back office has generally not been looked upon as the
answer to these problems. However, as the example of British Airways shows, a
carve-out approach is one option.
Although the back office has not generally been looked upon as a solution to the
balance sheet problem described above, a “carve-out” approach may provide a
way out by creating a new entity with a promising future. In talking to a number
of large corporates in the late 1990s, it became clear that by selectively carving
out certain back-office activities, including customer facing ones, we could solve
corporations’ most pressing needs and at the same time create exciting new
platforms from which to build bigger businesses. If these assets had already been
merged into SSCs, then so much the better.
Benefits
Parent companies are also able to avoid difficult investor relations issues. Carve-
outs are often seen as a more attractive option than a redundancy program or
wholesale outsourcing operation. In some cases, the approach even serves as a
catalyst for culture change not otherwise imaginable.
Much has been said already concerning the morale-boosting effect of relaunching
a back-office support operation as a separate business. A carve-out takes this one
step further. By developing an independent growth-oriented company, solely
focused on providing excellent business services, employees are empowered,
benefiting from the cultural shift as well as the ability to own equity.
Corporate shareholders benefit from knowing that the new business begins with a
critical mass, and with already contracted revenue from the parent company. Add
to that the opportunity to develop best-of-breed processes and technologies
through capital infusions from an investor, and the ability to attract and retain the
best employees and management with equity incentives.
Carve-Outs in Practice
Carving out support services, whilst not widespread, is certainly not novel.
Successful examples include: Microsoft and Expedia, United Utilities and Vertex,
American Express and First Data, Cadbury Schweppes and ITNET, BP and Exult,
American Airlines and Sabre/Travel Network, and Lloyds TSB/Barclays and iPSL.
What is new, however, is that private equity firms are developing focused
programs and dedicated teams in this area, to act as both catalyst and driving
force.
Structural Models
In a joint venture scenario, the business is not really fully separated from the
parent, but a third party becomes a joint venture partner. Benefits include
transaction savings, third-party funding of investment costs, and shared risk and
reward. If the entity is ultimately carved out, there is an equity upside. This is the
model adopted by companies not really committed to separation. They tend to
retain more than 50 percent of the equity. However, the benefits of maintaining
more control are, in my opinion, largely negated by the fact that independence is
not achieved, so the full extent of the cost savings, positive culture change and
ability to grow through attracting other customers remains illusive.
The second model, at the other end of the spectrum, is when the assets are
sold outright. Benefits include total separation and an upfront payment, with the
acquiror taking on full responsibility and risk, under the terms of a tight SLA. This
model is often seen as “one step too far,” however, when the assets in question
still provide a critical service to the original owner. There is also no future equity
upside should the new entity become significantly more valuable in the future.
This model is common when traditional large IT outsourcers are the acquirors.
The result, however, tends to be that the carved-out assets are simply subsumed
and digested by the acquiror and the chance to create a new independent entity
are lost.
A carve-out will not deal with deep operational problems: poor quality should be
sorted out first. An overview check should include:
British Airways’ SSC operation in India went through almost one year of carve-out
negotiations before it emerged as what is now known as WNS Global Solutions.
BA’s operations were hidden within the airline and were underutilized when we
first began talking at the end of 2000. With 1,400 people, the unit had a critical
mass, however, and high credibility based on the quality and range of processes
already being performed for BA.
While BA knew they had done a good job of creating some real competence in the
center, they recognised that they had neither the capital nor the management
focus to take it forward themselves.
Today, WNS Global Solutions has made two acquisitions, is up to 3,000 people, is
growing at over 100 people per month and is the dominant, UK-headquartered
offshore BPO company. Additionally, the new organization gained an
independence that allowed it to attract both new senior management and new
customers.
Forming a partnership with a firm with a large balance sheet and a long-term
outlook provides a certain amount of flexibility on transaction structure and SLAs,
which a corporate outsourcer, given quarterly earnings constraints, cannot
accommodate.
Steve Dunning is Managing Director of WNS (UK) Ltd. He leads WNS' Global
Airline practice and is Managing Director responsible for WNS' UK operations.
Prior to joining WNS, Steve served as Managing Director at Speedwing (the
British Airways subsidiary that owned WNS).
More Articles: Want to receive more articles like this? Have a tip, learning
or case study you want to share?
Join our growing community of shared services and Outsourcing professionals.
Sign up to our eNewsletters and ensure you receive the latest news, articles and
features from our growing global community. For more information email
enquire@ssonetwork.com