#:4170
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 1 of 15
\r. i
:
ORLY 'IAtTtr, eL &1- . , :
:
:)efefids.nts. :
Hsl'lCRAl.ltUttt
r. IrfTRSDffiTf,OT{
-a-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 2 of 15 Page ID
#:4171
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 2 of 15
ryebei*e- llefend.a-*ts Sdg*r arrd Care* Hals, **d l{eil $ankey *r*
eEeentialiy accused of workS^ng with $x' Taits to defanle
Fla.i"ntiffs. T1re Ftale clefendanEs awrr an int*rnet radio sf.atlar: irr
Texas on which Dr. Talt,a appeared. NeiI Sankey is a private
inve*rigator in calif*rrria, atlege<3If hlred by *r. Taita *n h*r
q**$t to *deslray' PSaintiff* Berg *n* Lib*rl'
-4-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 6 of 15 Page ID
#:4175
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 6 of 15
rv- #xtRrg$:c*rolr
Jurisdictj.on for tkis acEion is predicated *porr
cliversiry of cicizenship" eB U.s.c. $ 1332. The. citiuenship of
all parei.es is as foll.r;rwp, For t*he Ftainhif f s r Eerg and Liberi
atre p€rr:ssylvania ciliz*:ns; Adaug ie an Gklahorsa citiz*n; *rrd
Csle}l* and Gc Global ar* ditizexts af l'[sr* Jereay, Far
Befends*ts: Taitz, nQFf, anti sankey are citizens of C*Lif*rni*;
SundEuict and Rock $at[ Publishirg are cit.ise::s oE ]isrrr J€]rsey;
and **l"cher and t.he Halsp are citizens of Texas-
-7-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 8 of 15 Page ID
#:4177
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 8 of 15
-8-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 9 of 15 Page ID
#:4178
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 9 of 15
testified thfr.b she had vrorked for Taif.z a# her web de*igner- she
evidence. the Court ffnds nhat the documents l"aeked any evidence
of arrthenliealisn anrfl f,hus, f inds rnuch of the dncuruentary
evidsnce to be unrel"l"able.
e. l"eq+3 sepq#rd
PreSimir:e.ry injur:cLlve relief is safi elciraordinary
remedy" and "should bs granted only ln limited circumstances.o
Kos pharmacesgtqalp",. Inc- v" Andrx Csrp,, 369 F-3d 70o, 708 (3d
Cir, ?*fr4) {citing *rexicae__1e.1=__&*-5e1**-g*--s.. Fixnact * Csnsery.$
.Pf*qgEgIB-- In€., 42 F.3d 1421" 3.427 {3d Cir, 1994}t.
*A party
-1"0-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 11 of 15 Page ID
#:4180
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Ftled 12123110 Page 11 of 15
succ*ed {::: the merit*- Th* evidence Fr<lf fr*r*d by the ?l*!r:tiffs,
bs,eh*s S**rnents and as t*i"tness test.irn**y. $a# notr f**nd *s) be
sredibl* or reliabie. SLaintiffs failed Co prove that named
Defendants Taitz and Bel.cher were dJ"rectJ"y connected to the
'*ehsit*. Plaintif fs provided r+as an
The orrly svidsnce
unsr.rbst,antialed aSlega*icn tlrat one Ge*ff Staples, reporteSly t-he
cparrrt*r of the webeit*, h*d a previou* rel.alionship rtit;h S*rg
and nor* has a connectinn tc TaiLz -
$econd, Slai.ntiffs also fail" ttl
thaf Uhey wnuj-d
show
suffe:: *rreparable hs,r:a unl*ss the Csurt *:*re t+ issrl@ a
Ee{apsrery Reetra.ining *rd*r.'the r.r*h**.i*, htgp#JiEgg:j&*.9..i t Lto:lCI*i!
S+gtraJ.ning or*g;
trr.rring Eh* hearing, $efenriarit ?*.itz ar:gued rF:at i* is
the Plai"nbif,f,s EhaE ars engagerl in harassing irer and t'hat tt is
she Lhat needs protecLion from them- Th€ eourt wj-ll treat this
-1:.-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 12 of 15 Page ID
#:4181
case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 1212311A Page 12 of 15
se**}r3* prcnE#, t'he Cc}lir* wi33 B*t c{i:}ti:r** Ltr* analy*i* es *hi$
is a *#nju$*tir.e te*t- Thus, Defenfls$t Sf,Iy f,aiLr"s FI$Li*n fsr a
* LA.
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 13 of 15 Page ID
#:4182
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 13 of 15
-l1-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 14 of 15 Page ID
#:4183
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Document 160 Filed 12123110 Page 14 of 15
-14-
Case 8:11-cv-00485-AG -AJW Document 178-6 Filed 04/25/11 Page 15 of 15 Page ID
#:4184
Case 2:09-cv-01898-ER Doeument 160 Filed 1212311O Page 15 of 15
rlias .#ne
l*ser - the s*arch ft>r tr:ith in an a:lvir+rxnerrh CIf
dec*r*xt- F*r tLis si=ruy *p$,*+de, b+th raita a::d aerg h*sr eru*]3
*f th* b}"*me.
- 15-