Wi8
by Al Messina
THE MALE MINORITY REPORT essence rearranging or transforming ideas When student radicals rise up j
The seminar or the discussion
in such a way as to go beyond by formu- actively protest an issue, the majoriJ
There is no doubt that the educa- group, which is now playing a secondary
lating new insights. This can only occur Americans are appalled. They consi (1
tional system of our country is presently role in education, will perhaps come to
when the student-teacher relationship is these dissentors as vile, despica a
under intensive review. Concerned stu- the-forefront in the near future. In this
one of cooperation, where the student traitors who are undoubtedly piom
dents and progressive educators, moder- type of atmosphere the student and pro- P
takes part in discussion and is able to against the country. That is, this disu si
ates and radicals alike, are actively pro- fessor will be able to establish a positive
express alternated ideas. The natural is more of a detrement to oui & i
testing many of the antiquated educa- dialogue. The emphasis will be put on
exploratory nature of man is unmistak- heritage than it is a great loyalty. R a
tional policies ^prevalent in our schools independent study! with professional
ably a great impetus to the learning only is this type of attitude narrow!
and colleges.! It is important to note, assistance and guidance from 3the
process. ;But the school in many cases subjective, but moreover it is the &S
however, that these people are not teacher. Only then will the student begin
disrupts the discovery behavior of the danger to America. Dissent, for a co
attempting to mitigate the importance or to play a viable role in his education.
student. Typically, learning takes place structive purpose, is the greatest loytf
integrity of our system, but rather initi- Not only will he listen to the ideas and
in an environment where the teacher one can perform for his country. In<W \ %
ate reforms forjjits progress and better- opinions, expressed' by his teachers and
decides the mode, pace, and style of the it holds the key to the future of ^ I
ment Although their tactics are extreme his peers,|but more important, he will
learning |experience. Consequently, the United States. It made;America a gnj j
and fanatical at times, their intentions begin to formulate conceptions of his
students' role is that of passive listener. democratic nation, and its perpetuate li
are, for the most part, genuine. Essential- own.
And by* the teacher's manipulation of will allow A merica theflexibilityto cq i
ly our educational system^is capable of The present reform movement in the content, the conceptual alternatives tinue to be a great nation.
being a motivating and inspiring facet of education-revolves basically around!the in the mind of the listener are usually
American life. But to let it stagnate and concept of discovery. Discovery is -in restricted. The activist, in particular, is m
refuse to change it is doing a great in- protesting that there is an element i t
justice to the people, to ourselves, and to authoritarianism in our system of edua g
the future of our country. tion. They contend this authority is a IT
characterized by the overt rigidity i it
The primary technique or method
in contemporary education is the,'lec-
ture. The important question one must
[FACULTY COMMENT]) former historical periods, but rather fe
benevolent authority where pedanti il
supersede genuine attempts to motivi ti
consider is whether it is the best method. students to learn. That does not mei
Thebasic objection to the lecture is that by Sr. Raymond
education harbors an irrational autho
it creates^ situation where the student is ity, but more often this authority *
relegated to the role of a passive listener. Anyone who writes for j publication, writes for the express purpose of being
heard. And one thing which is calculated to gain an audience is to comment on the rational and not repressive in natui w
In this type of atmosphere the student Yet, its presence even in a ration A
really doesn't have much time to think intended reader. So my topic will be students — of the young adult, or nearly so,
variety.. They include both the male and female of the species. These are the people degree is not the best environment i;.
and to express himself because his learn- which to develop intellectually. Also,} y
ing experience consists essentially of with whom I have worked some twenty-odd years. I can truthfully say that this work
has been so stimulating and rewarding that I would be loathe to give it up. This must label the teaching profession as pedantr* ^
listening, to other people. He becomes a in character is wholly unwarranted, k p
recorder of information not a thinker. It say, then, that students are essentially good and interesting people.
in many instances and in varying degree t
is, in effect, training not learning. Suffice i And why shouldn't they be good and interesting people? They are at the point this attitude exists. i
it to say, students spend an undue in their lives where they are realizing that they not only have existence, but a
amount of time memorizing recordings personal beingfto create and other lives to help build. As they go — so goes the It is evident that I have exaggel
le
for the sole purpose of reproducing future. So they study the humanities and the sciences to find the tools and the skills ated and oversimplified the arguments
lecture material to pass examinations. to do their creating and their building. History tells about the world man has made, this essay. But essentially, or at leastt °
So, in an exaggerated sense, the educator but leaves no doubt that it is man's to make — for better or for worse. Literature some degree, the ideas presented wei•
is doing nothing more than playing a reflects the personal struggles, with triumphs and defeats, that have pieced together valid and definitely need to be review I
rhetorical game, while-the student seeks the fabric of history and presents arguments that bid for the acceptance or rejection in the future. CertainlyrI did notjjresei k
clues on how he can more productively of particular philosophies of life. Art recalls some triumphs, some near triumphs, and all the arguments relative to the situatio n
play the game. some abortive fragments of human creation. Science,jin yielding up the secrets of and perhaps I didn't treat the subject: n
creation, testifies that man, though small in size, can encompass the universe with his objectively as I could have, but my bas j
mind. Technology offers the opportunity; to free man for a more fruitful life, but at intention was only to present some (J
BLACK the same time presents the temptation to lapse into indolence and the surrender of
the creative process. What a challenging thing it is to be a student!!
the inconsistencies in contemporaiI
education. To label teachers as pedant)!
to criticize the lecture as inhibiting, l |
AWARENESS 'But it is also a great deal of bother to try to fit it all together. It is so much say that the authority element in educ J
easier to concentrate upon a small portion of the picture and students of each decade tion is repressive, and to refer |
by Rochelle George seem prone to view some small part as the whole. Presently the portion which seems education in general as a rhetorical gam
to preoccupy some is the march of despair down the road f to Nihilism. They are is a grave injustice. However, all of thcj-
Why weren't there more candid succumbing to the somber, but fascinating tune of the piper and are joining the grim
pictures of blacks fraternizing together elements do exist in some degree and jl
procession rather than trying to divert it. Being caught in this lock-stop deprives them varying intensities. Hopefully the futuji
in the Mercyhurst college yearbook. The of the freedom to go where they will. varying intensities. Hopefully
only major attribute we received for the learning environment in America 1
Mercyhurst fall production w a s . . . THE True education must always try to break the spell which demands concen- schools will stress creativity not irniw
BLACKS . . . masks. Now what the ham tration on so small a part and recall the fuller picture to the attention of the student tion, individual humanism not autho) |
sandwich does that mean? I was in the so he may find where he truly fits into the whole. Building a life this way is an itarianism, and above all more thinki&l
play and this vague statement awed me. awesome thing, but not a fearful,^forbidding thing and its joys and sorrows alike and less listening. i
Why couldn't they have placed pictures contribute to the making of the real person. i
taken from the rehearsal in the yearbook
to "throw a little color on the situ-
ation." When I did inquire, I was told
that the staff did not accept "colored"
UAL'S VICISSITUDES _
Q
I
pictures only black and white. :Now you
This past summer I was partly liv-
can imagine how I took that statements |fori the holidays. Haven't you too, tfl
ing in a bookstore somewhere in Gren-
This production was the first attempt by wich Village, and I found something that Ginsberg, seen the cynical Red Ca| i
the Mercyhurst Little I Theatre and the was really living there. Howl and Other counting quarters? Maybe the Negi I
newly formed. Association of Black Poems by Allen Ginsberg, occupied a top Operating Clerk is not called Spade, bi o
Collegiates to bring the questionsijand shelf in a dark corner. As I^sat on the isn't he there all the same? Somewhei I
problems of blacks to the Erie com- floor and read the poem "In the Baggage near the vicinity of the men's room thai
munity. Room at Greyhound," I couldn't help will, no doubt, be a "fairy Sam." Ha' ^
Also, just for the record, we read but associate the terminal described witl you ever really stopped to look at all ^ J
books infthe library. We sleep in^class. the similar one I've known for the past ^baggage? Each suitcase is "full of traged j
We talk .with teachers. We participate in four years; a Greyhound terminal that rocking back and forth waiting to bjl
Italian Night, Polish Night, Halloween Mercyhurst students never escape. Gins- opened . . . " Buffalo, Cleveland, Kaflj]
Night. We lay on our beds in our rooms berg captured many of the feelings that St. Mary's, Unipntown, Pittsburgh, W*J
and study. We wear curlers in our hair. students call their own butt can never ren - no difference. You know so manfl^
We laugh - we cry. seem to adequately express; Before you but so few. Forty other people, all aloof]
depart from Erietthis month, try to like you. I A
Out of 312 pictures in the year- Whether you;, are preparing for
book, black girls were only in 3. And out your first departure from the city of Erie cure a copy of this poem and keep it in Not all of Ginsberg's feelings,
of eight of us on campus, at that time,] to the place you call home, or if home is mind while waiting for plane, bus, or apply, but many are inescapable:
only 4*rnanaged to qualify for "candid" now a mere pitstop of emotions, leaving train. Stare through your own eyeglasses . . . to hold the bags to send on tl*U
photos. via commercial transportation can^be a at millions of weeping relatives, harried roads, to carry our luggage from pl^B
terrifying but mind expanding experi- commuters, semi-paralyzed old folk, and to place looking for a bus to ride m
May the oblong thigh of Africa ence. those rushing off to see their loved ones back home to Eternity where the heajfl
raz your daz.
Page 3
C^f AN ACTOR'S OPINION
by Paul J. Clancey, Jr. Theatre is not for Drama Critics
AN EDITORIAL g
who play their games of "kill the show" Let your mind wander and focus injion a scene f.., 60% student
I The sensitive actor sometimes and "Pan the Actors^'.ibut it is for the vote is needed to pass the new constitution which underlies the entire
°*finds himself in a difficult position in people, the unknown, unseen individuals purpose and power of the student body and only a handful more than the
in the house who laugh and cry or think
* attempting to discuss his art, or, if you
along with the performers, the crew, and bare minimum vote is received ..J . . The Cultural Committee shells out a
*> prefer, his trade. There are those who
theatre is an educator only the writer. * few hundred dollars for a nationally known string quartet and not even
d>
Jwy that rJW ^.« two busloads from the entire school attend Newsletters on the new
u o n a universal
Ishedding Ugh* P ^"^ If it is wrong iforj people to have Student Government and the^relevancy of NSA areidiligently worked on
»-and there are those who hold that fun in the theatre then the medium
* theatre is an entertainer - a rather should be dying - for theatre is a repre-
by dedicated students only to be lost in the shuffle of hundreds of feet in
•* sophisticated song and dance; stand-up sentation of life, and if life is no fun, the cafeteria line don't let anything interfere with the needs of the
(comedy routine. These two positions are then no one has any right to take time stomach.... meetings^ publicized weeks in ^advance are attended by a
^generally found on the extreme outer out from the grisly and morbid struggle minimal amount of students (the workers) in a nation-wide
^periphery of the theatre world; the for survival only to enjoy himself. Moratorium for Peace, only about 50 out of 689 students take part in the
former, typically held by pseudo-
•lintellectual English J professors, and the One final word to all critics, actual march for peace.
blatter, generally by unthinking TV drama and otherwise, - "Those who
can, do, Those who can't, criticize." We Stop wandering now and come back to earth, that's* right, you
^ viewers.
in the cast can do, and we are doing'- haven't gone far, you're still at Mercyhurst. It's about time that people in
The theatre person, who is truely Join us in our fun at the Little Theatre, this institution began to realize that'about "5 per cent of the school
^dedicated to his art, holds neither** of for Barefoot on Nov. 13, 14 and 16.
ttfhese positions for he realizes thatf all: population is doing the actual behind-the scenes work for everything that
%ood art does not necessarilyIconvey a Remember, Life should be fun is going on in this School. After the work is complete, everyone else enjoys
fimessage of cosmic magnitude, nor does and happy and enjoyable - let yourself the results and then follows it up with complaints, gripes and all-around
Ht only *stimu late the audience to laugh- go and,ignore the fools who tell you to uninvolvement. •3' f
ter, but that good theatre art gives both: suffer.
tot least a pause for thought, and enter- What difference does it make? ^In all reality, it probably doesn't
tainment, in its broadest construction. to make any difference. Workers and dedicated students will come and go,
Well-done comedy is a most
LETTER the
Editor
somehow the institution will still thrive on the efforts of the few. Even
"Warding experience for a performer - though the apathetic pressuregfrom the majority is great, some mysterious
"there is an indescribable satisfaction, element will keep Mercyhurst moving. Unethical, unjust it may
To the Editor
"Which is not Ego gratification - ' in • •
l%>t for one college student to say, nor forthcoming plays. You have,j in your part asjan individual, even if you have contrary reactions. At least react, so
'J^ven for a Ph. D. in Dramatic Literature critical- position, declared that different
sides should be created. I trust you are
that your vitalness to society will not be wasted.
yko say. This is a judgement that must be,
)ftmd can only be, made by the audiences very happy in what you have done. Like Every human being has a part. Don't let anyone else do your^hingj
P*- the audiences of today and of fifty most people on campus tod ay. would However you feel, at least come out on the 14th and 15th andjtell those
drears from today. say: "Nothing like a little dissension to
make progress, is there?" affected by you what you feel.
it
Signed, Before it's your|ast chance, take this opportunity to speak for
A Diplomat our self.
I'NSA RELEVANCY ?
fi by Rosemary Blieszner DEAR DIPLOMATf1
In my sporatic visits to the Hurst We do not agree that
Wcampust during my student teaching we have destroyed)
xpenence, I caught bits and snatches of 1
*\ campus "crisis"
cnsis^ concerning S.G.A.- the director s right
*U.S.-N.S.A. - the main question being to freely choose
Whether or not our school should retain forthcoming plays*
membership in the National Student After allf we do not
Association. Jeanne Andraska, my sub- limit our reviewer's
stitute, capably organized a coffee hour
Jo grvefthe questioning* students an right |to freely cri- i
UP°uited out how they might help our for writing. KL>.
I F THE
*S?L STUDENTS TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THEM.
THE MERCIAD
As U8Ual t h e ef MERCYHURST COLLEGE
\tf ~ » fect of the whole
^tort was minimal, since less than 7% of ERIE, PA.
stud nt
IT « body bothered to come, Co-Editors £ . ( . . . L { i .Joanne Kleinhenz, Mary Horsington
W h did a t t e n d
G*t ° were neither the A ;-•- VAUL* ' " " T ' ^" . . . 3 . . Louise Durr, Valerie Mangin
the
Kafr « " P h h " I i I merely Associate Editors < * g * Christa Vaughen
f hterested
^ 1 ° indents. What t^i^.7 "::: AM* M AI Me**™,
happened to the issue? I Editorial staii . . . Lynda Brooks, Sheila Boss^Linda
Typictl
| Ll o tl l 'espon«?il would hope Marcinko, Kathy Madigan, Sue
°ut suppose so•
• •••••••Mi f wonder if things Willardson, Flo Golembeski,
ffou Brenda Frattlone^Linda Maley
nd»ef*will ever change?
t And no ni_ A .„ | George Hughes, Mike
answered m y
lue»tio„ M w hha T u Photography . . y - ^ | J | Moryc*Maiy A n n Pleak
t hap ens t0 N s A
*** win -f Ust P oi -- - A g. _ .. TinaGeorde
omfToPROVE
torn 2h " J *** vriffl it ever Business Editor . g . y ] .'.'.. Mr. Barry McAndrew
^ass?
t
Advisor . . . . - • • • *3 jM • • • - * *
Paste 4
f
PASS-FAIL : HOW WILL IT AFFECT YC
by Susan Willairdson she feels school distracts, gradual
schools, and other organizations woi
"A survey of the nations graduate not.accept it. She also feels that if
I
school deans indicates a widespread student were sure that he/she wol
reluctance to trust 'pass-fail' grading receive a good mark pass-fail should n
when! judging transcripts of student be used for it isn't computed onto yf
applicants."! (THE CHRONICLE OF index. A 'D' even counts something
HIGHER EDUCATION; June 16, 1969) your index. *
To d.s. in agony,
Well, lookie here chicks what I received This was an article of a survey conducted . Her advice to the student is J
the other day; Daphne Delight to the rescue! Well, at ^Indiana University, Indiana, Pa. What "Think it over carefully" before J
Darling, your letter consisted of eight does this have to do with Mercyhurst? decide. If the course will help y
Dear Daphne, questions and four statements of
We have just adopted a partial index, take the letter grade. |
Am I going to die? Have I worked for fact! Which leaves me to nojj other
almost four years only to be a college alternative but to answer 1/2 of every pass-fail system. Since we do have the Sr.v Maria's opinion is that $
option to select^ two of our courses as f
drop-out due to death? Am I doomed question and 1/200 of every fact. As pass-fail system % valid but with
to have an undignified death because to your first question: Yes, my dear, pass-fail, it is felt that more information limited purpose. "It is valid when DJ
of a cold? Should I start on LSD in statistics have shown that, for every is needed as a guide to the student. How for courses where the nature of
order to give some significance to my person born in the United States that does the faculty feel about this program? course makes the attempt to give a leijl
death? i \ $ person's chances of dying are 100%. Do they feel that pass-fail would make a grade a bit silly, not only courses
difference to employers and others view- involve experience abroad but;
Really, Daphne, how does oneffind Question No. 2: After four years at ing your grades? What is their advice?
any shape, form or type of medical courses calling for student participad
MHS, punkin,' death is a welcome in a corporate effort so that each indnj
assistance in this advanced institution relief. Some of the administration and
of higher learning? Have} you ever faculty were approached! with these ual's part is only a iface t of the whoA
tried to find our "keeper of the ^in- Question No. 3: Oh, my dear, sweet, questions. Each of their reactions are For other courses here at Mercy hurst [r
firmary"? It's always empty because pink pusseycat, dignity is merely rela- summarized: think it is academically indefensible."
no one is able to find the chief of tive to the suaveness with which you
Sr.j Janet feels that pass-fail As for the grades effecting i
admissions! Doesn't the Motherhouse handle- it! Nothing isjjmore elegant
affords advantages for the student who outside, she feels that employers want
have its own health healers? than taking a perfumed lace handker-
wants to broaden herself and adventure quality index.jThe P-F would make
chief in your b-s-m, withdrawing it at
In return fox an answer, Til give you into new fields. The student may want a difference if it appears too frequently
almost opportune time and gently
a word of caution: NEVER be on swabbing,,your nostrils to make the taste of other courses without the worry the transcript.
your death bed on a Wednesday! On "little hurty go bye-byes"! of jeopardizingther major index. It also Therefore, her advice to
that day, the man with the stetho- gives the student a breather course when student i s . . . "use it sparingly."
scope can't be found either! (He has Q u e s t i o n N o . |4 : heavily pressed in ?your other two
an answering service: "Is this an LSD . . . . hm-m-m-m! If it means cou rses. 11 is an advantage to the facu lty, In review of the four discussioi
emergency?" - "Yes, I am dead.") Luscious Sweet Daphne, by all means also, who find it extremely difficult to all were neither for nor against
indulge!!!!! 1 | grade their particular field of work. system, but did find advantages in
So just tell me one thing: should I
call the Rescue Squad for a cold pill Question No. 5: The only SHAPE, use. Each of their advantages,]
She felt that graduate schools
prescription? 2 FORM AND TYPE of medical assist- advantages, and adwee differed enouj
would look reluctantly at a transcript if
ance that is of any value is at Harvard to say 'be cautious', investigate
Yours in agony there was an over-abundance of pass-fail
Med School. specific effect the pass-fail would haj
A Doomed Senior marks. Employers, on the other!hand,
on you. To emphasis this diversity
Question No. 6: No my dear, I mail would prefer seeing a letter grade; they
opinions, the same article quoted at
BUSINESS DEPT. CLOSED my^j problems tojthe "Keeper! of the would look at a pass as a *C\
beginning of the report stated:
Harvard Med School"!
|On Mon.f NovJ 3 the She hopes that the student would " . . . When Tasked if they (I
Question No. 7: Why, of course, my take the pass-fail for a motive to do their
Board of Trustees voted graduate deans) would tend
charming chickadees, all* Mother- very best work without the added worry accept a student with g<
to close the Business houses have their healers! of the letter grade and competition. recommendations who had
Department primarily^ Mr. Sturm leaned toward the pro- 'pass' for every course he li
Question No. 8: I'm sure the boys at
because of the high Harvard Med School have the perfect pass-fail system. He was notf* for or completed- under a pass-fl
maintenance cost. Sr # remedy for your cold! (ahem!) against\ this system in particular but he system, the deans voted 121 to
Rita Pancieraf Depart- wast definitely for experimentation: in the affirmative."
Well, keep those cards and letters tc
The idea has many advantages that it
ment Head, has announ- comingteTill next time remember the should be experimented with on a wide
It seems the majority^opinion is do!
ced that the| current immortal words of | Daphne^ De- scale." If a student is honestly interested the middle.
Sophs, Jrs»f and Srs.f light If you're a foul-ball, you in learning not in Igrades, as many
will be able?to obtain best go somewhere and catch your- courses as possible should be put on
self!!!!!! '•There are many
their degree in busi- pass-fail. A pass-fail system has to be ways to move forward
ness ;or certification T.T.F.N. slowly oriented because of such a long
'grade' orientation! of present students. but only one way
for teaching* D.D. fl
I How do you get to graduate to stand s t i l l . j
school without grades? . . . He replied
that the majority of graduate schools
look at I Graduate Record Exams, and
other types of national testing programs. Burhenn's Pharmacy
They couldn't go byWour grade very Corner 38th St. and Pine Ave.
well to begin with because! of such a Phone 456-7762
1969 KALL EXAM SCHEDULE diversity in grading systems and indexes
throughout the nation. The teachers go Erie. Pa.
Class Time Exam Time by|the National Teachers Examination,
and employers go primarily by recom-
Sat. Nov. 22 8:00 8:00 A.M mendation and not by grade transcript. Colonial Bakery Shop
12:30 10:00 AiM He suggested using the pass-fail as Pasteries, Decorated Cakes
3:30 l|:30 P.M a^r device |to take the pressure off the ^ 3717 Pine Ave.
Mon. Nov. 24 course and let you enjoy it. He wants to
9:00 8:00 A.M see fthis system "turn grade 'hustlers'
•ft 456-08111
10:00 10:00 A#M into learners." For those who use it as an
4:30 1:30 P.M easy way through a course, he gives the
warning "Don't slide through, there is a Quality Dry Cleaning
Tues. Nov. 25 1:30 8:00 A.M dayjof reckoning." Some time in your Shirt Laundry Service
2:30 10:0CKA.M life after school there will be some situ- PARIS CLEANERS
ation where you will be quizzed on your 4025 Pine Ave.
All grades due Fridayf November 28 at knowledge, especially with the actual 'on I 866-7641
the job' knowledge.
12 o'clock noon, in the Office of the Sr. Angelica remarked that there
Registrar. are both advantages and disadvantages to Printing Arts of erie
the system. It would be much easier for
the teacher to give a P-F mark, but it 651 Cast 10th Street
wouldf be to the students advantage to Phone 528-7176
have a letter grade. Her reasoning is that