V".~
I..:..'·
\"!'
'II'
",iI,-~, ...: ""JLf~V'T......,~V"" 'f-~,~U";j.7,UlJ!'~"-7- ,"tfJ1~ £".;'~,.;:.J ."~ ",L ."""~d , ,"-" '~jl""'~' Ii'""v~"" '. "r'" -r,.. ~""':'~ - IW "j~'~-'" ~Ar.. ,2,dt.- . -!J1.1;!! !-"IL--j\!.IY'~~~
;Ii"~ .
n-a ." ,~,
,"
."
r-
J~
•
I"
~,!II!'
'=
-.
~W',Fv.!i}.,.1U~.J~_~),IJf~LJJ~)~'.IrJ:=,Jl#tJl~r~,;:~~JJY/~,t.itfV~~~Lfl~',;"J~~li,J~71J~J~r~.L~~:~jJ
-cd~~~.;'~,ctlr", r~fo~~LZiN-L.J"j~~f~~bL/'Jc;li.ljr~~tJlh~\Lf~11If(,m.Jj~Lf
;j\~~'ivi~C#~/~.IJr(~La ~r~J~:,L.~J~~~fr~~/~r~,ti;~Jtf)~~,;:~tI.lj~t..L~Y~,~v.;'rJ:r,t'
, I. 'IiI!~
..
U,
!!!Ill
.t1'~~~
"'~J(Yi}'
""r~,~,r:8 Jn~\~~r~g'('''JvJ~iJ.~Jt~JJi~~l;V~~,U
'·"r~1.,(i')" "',I" .)""~'.'
(j¥:'~l.'f-'J~~O.t~kJ{~~4-)j~ «(,"';:[...;r'~l,;',kJAJjli!I/~~)~L~j~
(~, •.t.;'I),;o~Lt1~L,j~Jf~~~L(L"j~
(r'l~'I:;JA},.,~~¥,-j-A'''J~,~J;;[/k JL-"jJa~}~~;f!"'JlJLL"",;J,,a.ll(·~1rL ~)~~;J~L,~L~~.....£~_J T !". ... ~,.. I
OI
;!l·
II.
...."
1_
!I
'!If.
"._
..
!!,.
'!'
","J~L~~Jj~,;,,J~d(~~'~~J~bj~:~1~ArL~,J'r~~v!L,J':L~lJr~J~LU~dW"~J({{~)LJti~-'LJ;'
("'iiQ;:'~~~)
d,Lo,j~~tJ~'{ub~~)jb~'i(;jji~frijlJtJr.d~JV'-.;'1~lI!-Gl~~,'~}L~.Ij~L(Gjd)/~)~~d1\Lr/JIY4~~J/'j~ LJ;...e;4-)l~
.4.1J~,t'i~1iJ~rJ!tJ1J'AdLVVJjwrt~wftllr.JJ.I' '21:,~;~'~~LLl&vr\~y'.h-:,'4fli"~{,L
~LJYLv1)jLbJ}~tJ~L~
(r(,i"';:J~l,Uj)"'r~J_;Artfl~
L~~'Ll~~~,a'L)~j~J~;,:~,-rG.,IVJMv1rlij;tt,Jf~J~~/h~+-~ ~ ;~\LJdJL~'~l,lljJ~L~,~Jy~vaLll/utu:J!j",
&~"ll,:.t~;::...ttJj~,/~lrV;)Jl"~ D~~"rJW.'",i~tt:ri:.."~jif:~L~L;i',t(~'~,~~j);"t,,",,J(i7{,~t~..2llJ.u:;J-'LLjJ,[ki.
(1~,L:'.;,JtnJJl,.,L1"lJV~~;lilJ-VL~j.[/t5~.G'
~~,~~~J?Af:W~j'm;)'~"'j~L~~v~ AvJ'~LVbi-;..(lJ.i~'i!L*LLL~J;~~ju~~n/~~tt.tJ.;/Ld;btJll~L-n
~~~~L.~~/~~?ij',thfl~ylJf~,~~~~u,r~~,J:.
JfJ11JblJ-tf~l~JIJ1 ... 'F[~~-U
rr~*
(r5 ;Ltll,~~;
~,tL~/(j~,li~~r~!"~'~~~'~~11)~3 .JMJy.lI[.t,L.reJ~~.~J~~~~j~.L1f~.~J~~
~~*,,~,~l~'Vj g(oJ:~hJyJif~JL\'J~~( I)
.r:~JJ'J~Jl~~,~~·~/v.~~/v-t(r)
(~{)-~~~I~ILr~~~~.1'f~~it,,[I)tJJfiLM;r;IJ~~~·~',LL~,,~~~r(r")r Z~{+·~lt»L:~:+~P~IL:,C)~it~V~;LJy# v,r~~j~fl,~~V'~#~,3J?L~7~)~if~Uj/~.~J~ftl~,~/~? lfJ/~Jbl~I~~JvUlb~;~lv~~L~.;~~,~~;.~~~~~~uJ~·~~.tf~YJ'~v!~~)L,.3
,~~)L$ J?~Jyt1..'~'~6JL)~c"~~i~sMW,h"LfoJt~i~~!V'f~~a
(Ad\...,.~~,~~;g... .• t
7r'~'~~~)J.n~fi{,3 ,~'jL~J~~j~rf
(Q#~6)~,£jrfA~~I('Jt)~.rv~W
,J'}~~'LJe'''.1rJ~ifJ,0~-~'viJl~~~,",~~J~'J~,'\t)f~~~vr.ff'~ ~~,£~~)~~rJ',!~~~u~.Jl.tf(p"~'r!1!';"kJ,"""~~
.:J;;;(,;;, -,~~{:~ - "U~~~"1t. ......fj:d~'.:L~" 1!Y)I:~
~t.W~-· r.»
IL ,~,rt!!l~
.J":J~~
-"-T
~~I'
ff1.:..,r~
I~~
Gj j~,.,r";,
'1t~
uk. ,#" "'~.).~'h..:..I'~ ~V ,'~ ~ .. "" .J'... I(_ t1'.~v.~ --;. '--'Il-
=-~G7V4J~~~'~ifJ~.lJ.£.iril1L~.j'~rlL~~~.i:,~\11'LlL~r~~t/~~~':1~<~/~J.F'J~~'~~~J'j,~;I)Y~ ,~~,,~~).~~-~V-t,VAv!cr"~·~~'fJL~\ljrT'-LcftLe'~~Jl
(('tf )~L~~'~~~".~.J;~~f~~~~JJ'L~
J1JYJ(~M)L~~LD.L/~,~JblJu~JL:~,?
, (rl)'
c' or,!' ,.
...
J~
I;:"~:.,'~"r
c.t" -,
-~~_.
J::_' ~~'.~'
='.;'
_-
_ """~, r
.,
"'-iIill
"'~',:,:,
hI'
-'-
..,¥~&~~~ f"" -
~,~~ttcJP~?~)f~~~ifl/~,~~~?L~}~f~v:'~'I~'II,~,L,~r~~,~~~"~tY~p~?L$ ArJY~h~~~'
(~~~,,)_.JJN~'~
.JijJ~~J~'(vJ~~~J~)~~t!L~~!~'
(r~:;J.'~~,~). Ju,;!U;,'~~~~~~LjJ~~~ ...~
i·~J~J~'~~'~~rl,.A#rtJ~
JtJJyJkif~J~Aft~~pJi~~?~~Jrt~ .f!lJ/~~ ~.rJ~;I),J~~Y$,.t,~~jLLI~,vvJ'JiM~~~!Jjlf41' ~~J~,VL7-~JA rt.vnJJ}J,~~t.tI2f)f;JjN~J')~ ~r~~A~t:J-~L.i ~flJ~#~~~Jv!~"~..L~jJ~L~J"sbJb1Jrj~~p~?~J~~I~~ ~)r~~'tf~j""h;~fl.'
~~~.i~~..w~)&wj~LnJb~~t~~J~~r\~~.A#~JP(~)L~~~"rra
(,~~~l.t4JL.--~,,~J.~y;j,~h rW~"!L);lJ.£fl;.t~.e '~
(,-1"" ~;i~}J,) ...
rJ~4,~~,~,e .I?r'~
~;I;,d~~
jJ'JY~"if'#~j)~yflif%~~U/
(,)~lfr~~l£;;L.;!1:',LJ.:GJll'~L.·~jj/Vl,L~A'i~!f$~~j~¥fLl)L,#~~~1>iJ~~.tt.-'r~?~~),~f~r{~iti~'I~~~
('Ft"'tJ;J)"'i-'-r~~k..../JlJ~,~~-;\r)!;~l~~ffLJ,~l;Jy.i'
1~'~;t.;~r~'J'~JtI~,L,~,~vL:,,"/"~~~f~/~~'~~'JIP:t:.~~~;~Jll~(")L~Ll~fJ~h~~Ir;l;~ru;r;~~~k:~p
(rl<~,~~)
-~J~~~
n(J.V.~=..d"lL.,~IJt )1"'IJ'" lfnA#~ttiW;.f~.~Il!J ~'~R ~ (' ,~~~~ L ~~ 1" t'-' ~ - rr: V: ..r: ~U\
til I.
.1
III!I
~;1\,tl,~tt'G~ U .,
I~
~Llif~,)~~ .~,...i~~ (~ - -.
.1
~·Wi
~.
Jlt ~l·-.'I~I~;;""'~.I'.~,~_",.()~I",~ -.()~,tILlJI4:i.~ .». ~V·,t;}R~t' ,JtIL"'~,"b~,r~~J~~)(~~~~:r.;:..·~*U~~~1J!_'.b,1!:'~~~'",-~~~,;"",dJI#1u ~:~~Wq,;g't·~~JJmrur~t.~~ .. , ~'r r ~-'.. . ,. .~.' ~. ..
If' _ ..·~,).;lt;dl;.j7,~''''jM_-"~'''~';.s...:-'.t' ~_ ¥,yl~ ,-=-,~ ~111 _.
·f.Ji/J;-~~,f~~,'r[!}r,Ll~n A~ ~ ,~, - - r
~ •• _
r'
II!
'7 !p'Ip."
~~r.!!!II
7'
;i'~'
.1'1•... ¥
I'~
I 7"
'.
'~.
''i! -
';I' ~
...
II )".,
.'
~'~~V1JJl~~\t6(~~~.~~~~~~J~tfa'~~IJ~W~~fjtt~t.'~~)~'J~~~V!JJ~~/~,,~tkLf~~'~1~~~~~J1Ji'i
~~.~#J~LS~
I··~.· (~~ .. L.. ..
}~~A~Jfi,v!~I}Je, ,~i~~~L!r.t~~v:-~J~Lb~~\~J~~T·~~.d~~!l.~ft'_ J',J:Y.i'l~!fJ»JI!n},~~i~t,rJ1~ '(~;?;"~)AN~,~~~;G;u~.-6t ~t3, ?~~.~J !l~.ilJ~~J"Jrf~;iJ'}'~s~fl'~ .(j....,~1.J:i'1': ~''": "'I";~t"· "' "rj..~,.--il,;.;'Il·I!rlf·U~iIol,.r4,.-r,,JJ.t.?·~~~~~T~':!-..I"f',_~W: ~'!;;l", ,n\rU ~,., ~L'~' ~ ....~. r. .... ~~ V-:-l_ IlJru~/ t".r..r,f.__~IrJ.,"~,~ ~ ~~~~:; ~'" j!__/f~_';~"."li'~J'~' [.,... ,.V"",WrL ... (.;I!',ti
~~ ,_f~ (' ••
~. )J'JY)f~~)~,~li'~~~fitnl~fi'¥-~/iJ,~~~~.;d~~v~r.JNv,~;W"Jl.L vt~~V!riY~~-J
~~'''r,;,MU~.AY~~w'L~~
(_); , I': .
G,jyl*J
tI_
(A'df
.....~ i!:HJI7~~~/II~r~'
'.'
J'Lntr)_J~~~J8
J~LV~jrj~1tJ~;JL~~Jte{~}~VV1'~~L)L_
.I~.fl)?~I~)f~f;l~~Lvt>'
~1~~~~Y~~?-r~jJ~~Y~V~j~rJ.._,VWf~ft~fJ~~;.~~~~}L4f;d:l_r.4~N~~Il,;iJ~~jJlJ!~f~?
rr~~~,~.'JJ~Vj"£vk£~~~~j"~'
w;j~'~Utk ):L.~
6)_~"'JV",.n'jl
,~f~~v£~'L'~, ~~J1JL.Lo'jJii, ~f~~'h~+-~~';!I,b'Lft:S'hJ'frY"~; ru~t/tS~~ ltJJY.l,.t~,l:.-~),,' _'fL'H~~~/L,4J, f~L;t..~,;~8 I. ~ ~i _;f'~fll,Mf~, _.1 Jf;f;Nlr ... {t/~nb.i,:~I_~L1l-~b'~lJ~9.~'.JJdm.i'~L~crli. ,~-.r'!: ~ .• ' I:,~ r~ - .-.
'y 'If
rII·
V.
...":/
T"f'~~,~ .. ~J~L8 ,
,=~~~'r\!\Jrr~
iJ
II'l .~.
iVI~L..-+-d-~~;1r~~~f(~~~1'~'r~;·tf~,~~J~r~'r,h,J4iiJ~~n,tS)~rtIJ~Jy:jL~v?~~L~)1P;).~J'~J~~w
~;tnJ~~~'L!IfJtWk~(rcAr'~rlf(~L/J~ -~~kJl1r.~~€tL.~'j;LJJY4~~'cSM'
L,~.n~~)cn'~~~1,#~J~!JJ;AI~h:~/~I~Lf,(~IJ~~J'1r;~wl~~~,~J'~r;}~',# (fi~.r~L~}~P~V~~ ,-J~.kivJLj7~;f~if¥~~~L~;.;J4~JJ'~JL~t!~fltl;.f:lJ~Jd,tL!ifJ.~j rjt;r~,~ ,Jy)ttL¢fif~,~ ,Jl~~J~~J't¥ J't~';~jt~J'~~~·,,~4j, (A~.l~.r41'L. tPv!iJ..J~g..tydr'~~f~rJ v -~~U"h~~tJJd+J.;t.rcJ~
,~;&"TL(.~~J~jj.t~~~b~~,~)~~~rV1~:Y';;j~'I.'L.~if~\
L~'JfJJf';:W~tr~j,{:JL,fLr~Vdt)~,t..~fi!.JLred~v1J}Wvj(~Jil~~r.~t..~(.e rJi'~/la;')t4~1,.A~'j\J;~t~U~~
-tL,_~~;.;iJ~~~~JJut
~JIF~~t';~~~f~'~~Y.!fJ~~,,"j~j[JJJW~~~,~~d~,if;~j;J'4J
(fi'~f~4"1JL.rtI~'~~~L~~/~,~/tJ~f~
't"r'
•• ( -.il."
.. "j
_'!"!':'.'
~,;#.=.o.....
~. ,,,' ~"\j
1. ""_
.-
'!i"
'f 1it:rJ r' EO' '.' .Ii! .. , - ,.. - _ ~I '~(.Af'" ~ ,"' ~1'&(;..,I~;.;I[J"""V1i~"~~V'·.tI'1
..;I' ,
~.
':..~,~:J!?~V~..!\I;I'>~VYIIJ~.,!'~-
" ..
- 8',J (0,;".,
?~I;~fi~f"""'/"lJUIiii.;w"J~'J!ffo.,~ ~V"'j.(~L1t,;::~ll'JtE
~1L,(IJ /O::'\\.r_I_~
~;~i~~J~tL4~/~~~6fi~-t'"~;;',L!rr~"~~~/~~IJI~",Ji_~L.'f1{~.J~~JLt~t"::,,~#~~;!T~'~1
I.
_I~
-..~
!I'
Lt.~",A..rftOl~~LLf/iJ~I;~f?~'~~~,~~Vl'~v!*"lfl~If~~~t:f~/C.;'trV1~il;£,~iq~~~;~I{J'V1 tJLvt~~r:}:'~L~~J1Ft~;~J.t1~~vt~I;.tL;:J~w:~~iffiJ!"~J2~~jrv!/'3~~'~~V~LW..ilitld;'~tf~
-'k~~U:'
1~~~~~J~a~r..Ji~~Jbi~'~):~~~~~A~£,~J}'~{)!~r;J,V~·J)~~~~W~~~~~~·ltJ.;Ir.;J£L.~'
'[..;('V,~~t".#.j,,~.i!J'~~'''~J<
, . ~ ~ . !III _
,~,
I'"
""'0;
,r-'
~'c .(i"'-'L
.:;:~
~r~~ ~tS,J;Y'·,L,u,...~~~;~~~~""",,,';~~Dr:(JJlr·ltV'(tJJY'1J1~~~~~Ir;fl&..~~j[j~.Lr~,~,~·
I
.,...r.,
.'
_1j
. ..-~,-
..
..
-
tif ,,. ..
.
I,;..
,~.
("_Jf:
-
~~
'!I!I
..
.-
IF
mI
...~.j~
~>
••
,._-
... ~r,~~'
_-_
,~~J'dl~JpJ'f~~~jl+t;:t~/L'fL~jl,~:ID!loc{p~~I~lf~R.~~JwJ!!J.d~'Ll~LnJf~L~~)~.rVl~~,L~
..J(~~~
'~'~~'
-JA~~:~;.;JI~~Jr~~[,"iJAVttJWtfr~rJ.tv~,JwI~J~ffi~fr-~~t~·uL4~~~"~~\Jf[jJ~ 1f~',~~'LJ~L'!i:~f-'~:"d
~fuJ\~~t),tJjj.I~JJ.:~l~iI~V'U·~I~~'Lf~J,;Ii_Q~~~\oo,L!J;~~Jo'f~~tJ'~~_.Iif;y't'W·~:ij'"~LjJ.t}V(~~,;f~J~~
~~ui~v+-L
'~ji/r
ht1p~i1.WWW.i~ni:tlidz.ahieJr.OO.tr!lqaf.9M Qutiticm:
1) 'CUiran;, '!IDI@ book ~f' G!(l-a. 2) SUnruanl ,of the last pooph8t
II
~riI'rI. ~ I;!I!~'~
""-;O'j;...,J;, """"'i~II!.I.,,","'Y
.~.c.,.......:
..,..n
II'y
re~~~~d
ILUS .~
Plroplt~t-MClhanilma;d
IUS 'tgrough
~ h~·.i\i:i;··-: ~w,G::- !l.I'!eiia". '--;-II!.f .........nt_ ......, ;a,-OIi:lBtj;"!l, Lt - G' --,.-.:-: :: - M !lpeLees EL_!5!!Y$ ~ - -!fijI ffii _)I.,~ !&I
- ~'l:iJ]~nk ~-;-; 'd' '\;0;, ! .... ::-";!'!in ca -mFii eLI ~. _' .. __ ~CI ~ i\C;U !.i'_" _.gu.' .... :: oj; ~E!i
~c
IIWlfltil'
Y-E!.~ro~_ I
~nr;e.i'oCIdw.i~~hiii1f1 m-: "'_-1_n1 I .ei(;:d ,eiie.I!.~'" ,",:!~~J'" __ . .-}11!"' ~~fni '!:.,!;1Il_, ~.:!I~'i.I
He ~(lJt,'folW~rda
Il-ia 0;:1
eonne. _""
V~J]
bas~c ari9 l!! m~n~ and I was .$-urpnsed ~tnad iI'iI(Ji~t1ilfilg ~y. t:o
r .ji~.-.;i, !I!II;::!I~
---:><li""1riI. f'il3l!:!1'"
~,i\'"
I/,;!li;;!I
c-1nl
t,- Ii m~ O.
<:!" !,Y
Q_
$iU[1ifilah~!nl 'Whatewr
·al~o re~~
1[;;1'$
Is also, lpritctici'd by pooJ:l~e·at ~iast, a group, off ~ea~~e). ~emm ~il,dElesl Ib:O;Qk;t 'were {
'U1i!€'
'Wlitt:en in hadees, looon firam ~i.!irllnah cat.eg;oty. 'The, OOii'ihM of I~adees, IbookS' lis ,a SL!l_b~;e,~, what came lo us' 1h~ugh 'th~ of
~rowd,: as ilt: us ;~I~ pmctj~
'by pe~p~ (al r~_m lOy' SOITliS .g1~lO~p pW;p~e')~8sia:e<S tnlE!1 got: 'U'I!aro:,exist ili1 wrilit:em form as of b ~t
'MIL Pllease' $pa~e 'somiS tillihl!' to ~hrow' wme li;glh.t:en ~hiis W;pJC" Here' i~ ,anwh~1i' way ,~fpwtiililg "tne qu~stion: Lets ta~8 oW ImJadeesl .books out ef the eQuati~n far a, miiflili,te. I~we wafllt to ,ddnl8 SUflinan iii t'B,ii'mS, ;of w\haIt:(;'arne to
'~'r'IC'-',~;1I-h- e 0_ O'IP!II;;!I ullefl Ih"-- carl! we S8!;Y 1Il!11~1, on Y,I"I;, I~' ,~;.iI,C<,'~III.f- "",8 COJ!lSI!!.!@iFe, ,--,~ !WIlmnaili Willi ',rl'''·'1i'iIIt-' ,-- ,',,-",!-'~'r-ii" ','-I'",~, g, ailil'Y W~, -",--."A',-d' ,'c,-J~,_",,.·I'II!! I rOll!1g111 lOW as I,
i9,
ii'
tI!S
be ooriisidertia as S!Urnnah: ialtitol!9~ ;aHA ,9. C, D, E, iaJn.d ~~ pra,dijc8:dl by people and tharo:iis;how Ulliii¥mamed to us" F AfilC it happens t,o be, ~m !OJ IE, F :aJa alis'o wrilit8ill hi hade:N Ibooks;. God! kln!DM 1h~ tJ~st May G-od gliJide m ~ Inl Uil~' In;g:ht: diifeCl\iort,
Re:s~onse:
~j'''---
n ~s '!lJO
1\;0-
---IiI...·-k-"--- ."......---~-----(~lJ:g}lJ!m6rn.s.,lUi
~.-.-,,,,,
jIIOilil!
---:#Il-.. W!ilyj
an
-0;;;
C1pQ~~mmc
--an
aililiQ
---.4I-~mii a_50'- ~ _....~'!i' ';"l!.')!Jfi3~"", 'w '1- ,.-.111""'_" .... ~il-._"i'\c;. ~ ',"';I!.!!
iEVlill
Crh,lIO!Se
----"!Ii:-,H--
lil~1 as
,trtO'~~
yOlil
ca!l1 at
be: 18dlaS~Fa;y',li\filsJ'iJal~latlit.. IIhope the Mufti Sahib you tal~d '00 andl his
s.tudems and
~h8JSafThei i~P,PfilJ.aOH'!:.
i!lill
crowd rathle!f' ~1i1,aU1ani ~r1)d i~dua~ is v,e-:ry'vallid. It is indeed 'what idli'stingwj'iS;he~ ~m _~!l!!~h-e 1- - -..io':\CI,lj-a!u_S kl~ I!JI'I",I! _E!i::;;S
!'I;!\ __
,7"11- -, O __EliS
Il'in~:e€d !Mufti: Sahib is IFlight-n d~imIming ,tlf!~t$!ufilnuh aWildI~~_.dittrll :~fii!; both, rol~owed'by' too crow. i S,Wlnnah m~1
HOWtWJ~J,
pna~llhsil1g it ngJhi~ from 'Ul@tillJi8 of ;~he pFloph!et ~a!laihis$tdaa;m,;i3ii'i.-odl coowd ,cd had lUllfoUowlii;d it mo~' 'ihe,
-I' __ --'Ii - -, V!I ia'nEt ~ Eli '"d- em_lS@ ''''1
~n-
~H"t- --; -; ,--:-h~'- '""', - ,-,-h aY(II!! W~- - ,- -I~ I13,~Y :ell __ !i"I! pU!!.I __ h-..II_ I~~~'I!.V M..11:a1!.8 ~ II.. 8 ProIp__ ~II:; ~~I~8j1l __ -:- ·~k __ ro __- "'"~ -IIlIA :: - -lk,li-S__S!;;!I. Ii'rlJ)'_ r'iI.-., '"
-'.-~'i_ren~" .i'---.-
ahad: a report ln~ftIsffl~d by' ens of a '!few un,d~Vliduar<s. Th~!'e'fOf~,one slnt)U~dn"~ ooflfl!.ised by 1he be
hlUJftdroaijl
I!;;;.·"ln- ,,,,rr:r,i'~ ill1 D1~ll---'rj"'d ~1Ie a PI!<I! __ 0 L~ _1;i!\_~_1J1!1'SI ::~it-,fttn-'IfI".)I~til~~-I:_W',~ __ ~ ""' .... ,"'~ IO!! pe_._ ...._ .--:1-1;iI~~,
r.
'Wi,~Co
'!1!!.I;.!I~
~'iJ'~'leiobllc.l. ~ ~·IjLI;II
~l _
,;0;,;;'1;;
~~~
a.~all.11
I ',..~ .•- laa I .'.. a_nd hi, ~i,. - lWhil~ ~unn81) is (t _~'! III'!_is rem.-·-, fill-. I:..'j. .$~ _:a.a.m , : ~ $ dil~~S\1 l... g ____ n ~ g~C!U$ ---li Ip,:r~_oo
i"
• ......IL~
'm
!;I!
~ii'iId 111'1'1801-'M'. ,"!III''"''__ ',I"'~....~_ €,):)nFoCli!o'i!io.Clii!OI d _' C-,I;io,,",,~ , ~I!''''''I~~ ""' __........' ~r ,.;I! -,_II~Ii1;o_;!!1IOOi"iiilI'!l6i'\i!!>'" Ik·S~_~c.,e;, .. ifiii76JAi'\CIi1;1';C1 ,~ ~ Er,.. ' ~'!.!! '~il.iii'ii -~1It ~ _"II;~ ... I!;III ""y
h~d'~h
C:UJ.M'llion;
How woold ~.lhaum~riJ~~(;.n Ilik~' me dis~iri!gyishb~tw~~ ~h~ adJUal1 Syru'~hl ~nd n~n·SYnnah p~oti~>$? Wlil~; ~~~riaJ p
'wcu~don~ use,?'
Respo!1se~ l~rs, ta'ke. a few e~p'l'e:$'; br8nC:h)~, Sa;lat. ~'~jji !~i~mdi'siion I~hat~a), b~dl. ~_~mah. and! fJif1liswak,{WMhi''fiIg 1~~1h wirth ~ trE!i~ls
te bg mUgliousJy de:srlr~b:le'
lU1N·8rs3.1aroa;ptanca
amongst Ml.!IS!mms'ifI!'BI wo~1d1'OV'ef. Thsi first ~mt!'H pmc~iceSi ante Su rlirnah {18rVl6:n '!hough alrel!Jmcis~orTh
chJ!3s, l"tQt f1inc a merntiOr!i itll the OUr'an) wn)ille ~he last UlIree aJ~$i hadli~n-.bacSed1prnc~iQ&S. 'ilTht:3i 'le"1i~g qu~st1ons
fur t-nadilh~as.ed
p-r-adices
t'O qualifY
i~S
SUIr'ilWlIahawe, 'ltneSe::: 11)1 'l-nts p~ctiice l~ll19ious hi InSJtu:rI$f? ,2) ~s 'from day-one a~d has oofitinued to
'W'as, lit give~ by the' rP~'Phet WI ,am Musli'iTIS iin a w-ay UI!OO: started gl8'ffing praotiedl lt
date'"
the
~radr,ces.Beam
tin tl:aCliititill butt lii'lot al~ praotisiiW1lg Muslims, me world oveJf fbHow Uilem. Man;v' schtolam inl ESViPt and
elsewhe~ in peop'~e
W'ib; .. .Q ~
iU!..o'
n~~
~I
rolf r;~e~Iil'ing
ta~Hl Ibut IS ~arge, lrill!.ilmtwf' of lliem' ucSi othliE:i\l" i'IiIIe~hOOS1 deasn1iiiig them, Wi['
"L-
A ... -- -~ Ifl-A
sueh - ---"-l"---,c. '';:;'Io'iri---d ~~u~um:s In !LI!~Q' case - ""_''",;-a..--I--------"--;I/Iooa. .-- - ....r "!ynQfa_ IPray-.eh-,Q" 11..--- n ~h·- nea ; E"..II an ;.jI,!ol!mll! Ino'I:'~1I!'11""SUO_ . 'if~_l!'iIaI!lIDnlQ< ~IJ~i~iiln:~o,'UII---r--u;'U!fYl!f!I~ ~ J8 ..-iI"'-d Iii.!! --d nrill----~-I:.. a~!
()\¥
~,~jJ~1i~Si
which ,staT:1:ed flight fro.'m 'tne beg'ifill1lin;g ami 'which are: slm un~n:l'mou:sl~lifdJlowed by
MLf$I~ms. And Ul~{fe ,aff.8'~noo8 wh~-ch are' lFr!adilh~balSed lout arefi't; "w~despread. Thar:5 wfila:t distiiraguLl$hs8, a S~nirt~ln:
::"'-~': prat"",~JC8
'Which h-,..rlh-llru-a"~-:"I:~· in lkli'icmi'i:'~n'-~,it'w",.-i1[~ in........ ,·-d 11.'.'!J'I-:I!1·i ,i!'"- O,P- _e,~,;6-, A 1:: th.L "'f:I_pS ~iS 0 __ -!lJ 11_.a;~ _I!. __ ,,*,,,5 _ I~, u'IoN!UceI. Y',I' _,_e nrl:-:'c;Iil',~ I5!!S ,__ _ _
E\ffl!}fWh~f€
IffI;(i,'",~,~ it
c -,~in 108:!,l!!:! I
-n
P~~le
can wooF' bealiids, ~lIl'!Id :9Jl1·8!n!l'u:lhs, But th~~ ~sh~uld nO't oj\ajm 'U'nat it lis: a pfi1d&c~ giwn
,8
f.dI~OWid by ;a.iIIL,eHh~ras
jIj; b"oriSn",nL' ____ IS, ..:;'COnUlemf!e'1i.i!1 ';.11 ~J .-- -.-;11- ----.-.-;11
_!.I!O!'
k<!ie."-
even
U'€)I 'lirs~,thf" . -.
nraotl1oors are- v,fll"",:'m-;-Cnl .. rell';i'i"cr s' i'lM! 'rt~f~urend rami fClb w - . lM!urst'ms all QV€lr tie: world . , 'U'ile· ~__ CO' - -. _.. - •. - - iY _;JiJ - J~~ U. I . • __ a __ __ ..._._ --e:d,~;, _ I .. - - .- __ ~I~t .!!.I'" .
~f '~hei hree are fbillow-ed by' a, fflw MwUms claiJilmifig U\,€TI1 'to be fflUgjitJusily d~i:raO:I'Ei O:~'bi~1Jd'iWl!g" 1hElY d~!fi!t~ 1 but Ih~.v-e lmiv~~al aCOOfptaHi~O~ amongst
1m MuiU
~-fbUOW:iiFilg the
ra~~taO'c~
~f '~h€i~~ p,!i'acllloos ~
Q:~
~y
net ikeep, beaJd but ,6 ~ut ,of'1hese 8 rrqigM :s~' th~t bl€affl is! p~rt ,of Islarlii! I~eru '~()ugh th~ do, i!'i!.o.t: k€ep one",
:s,Q
,Aoo~:ur:drli1gl Ul~s P~!"$Orrii00%, 'to '00%, M~~im8! i~'~el Wi)'J1l'd to. , wOiJ'ld ~~:fth~~ ~~e;p~ng a b~.aJrd1 a, I~rt o,f IlcS~~m ~ aild
is!
~llhBrs. say' it '~Uim,ed iflU!'~,'tElla& 901%; of tha 50no1afS: bermeve' ~hail1hese IP'fac1iees all'S part 01TI'sl~mn~,wolUil'd 'lhat 'fan undell" 'ffihie ' definition of '~S'Ulifli'il:ah,1l '~at' has l"tae-h~1 ~fy,o~ hhe
1O':'';;;ii''ii'!in- . !w.!'!W\. ;;,.:.' Ir\;.,.. ....,.. ~
t:n~sreg~rds.
$:iJ:t1'f1!ah
oili1b!3;ril~: Was, ~he pra,ctDc8 in question ~I~gious in rnatut'e ,andl 2) Was: i~:follo_d 'I!) Mtl18liim~ (and
~i81[i8rore' ~h8
next
'tftlfi8;B'
m '~lhe''ii1I1ajoniy
tileiIF CJpin~onl ,c(uJrd n.avQ been CO\l'1lv~rted when hadilh of tfl~ '~iro c~nrt.yry '~;;!Ijrat1l
became famo'us.
~meriltiooed ~filllWf:Y II~H-'av,i(J(jJ51 ~pr(Y tm~t 'whil8i pra-yers 'p-~ssed bo~h tes:ts\i beard ,and MT8W8_k, eiVe:n 'lhougn pradiis~['j by ~h~prophet didwt beecme fegu~~r:lry a, 'iJJifi i'vAilffl1aili:eHgious IPt~_,dic!!?J ke sa;lat- d~d. H; di:d not lb~oome un~v~rsal ~~U$@I' r U b it W,aiSl!l~t racths<ed by' M IUsl imtS in a, Im*rity alII ~hmi!,jlQ'h()ut '~rl,ei p
last
fbUrt'89ili'll
h~iFL.Q'fili3deaD'$, ,
".f Afri~' '~-<- - willi fnld,~·-II-j.- w- -"::n>_·CiIi,yoU sa_i~h. ~5"1__, g
u
,A religious I~Fa-dice' Slnould Ib€::full:oW"ed tJ.,Y an pradiSii[!'ilg Mus~i'msil not lome; 01' many", in all PIM of the, iMUlsmm 'world in
·...... -r iOn,I!Et
~
Ilfc~,-,·--:-,"',~!Co ~-,yC!Ulgo:~o"",~~re
yl~ I!~!I~. 111!y,b
ii1i""'tt-iif'fll ~~ _II~~
Iffr'itti;ni
~~~-!!!~~l
~~ni"1'Ji
U.V~Uly
b."",~~
~ __ -.
If;.~~i!_i;;:;;"" U~r~~9~!1
,'5~
Q'-g
meiiltlolil'@d l8'aifili~r,
'On~
cat~,C)ry of p~elJ1~s
aU~alfrlllwhille
Gan tlj,fild a ~irnilaJ[f €i·lmWilpl€, 'ift! 1h~'case ,of 'Ih€) QUr"~Wil\;, A1It~ooghth~· GUJr"'an i!9 one b~dk,fiilty pres~N,oolfrom Gi)dJ~ th~
'tooiSl(!f
beriews
tfiaJt 'there W'e:re S-eV~f.ru \i\$t;SiaifliSO'f it. hik Ml!i,ftj So Qf hls ,swdent. lhvs
th~t· n ...:. I..... :"jh~ ..,11' D~h'.... !:ili~ !~-i 4!'-'d~(: b.."=fDi,';a; '~\" .... -' Ji;1:>"c. ~iLi_I "','50n "'~D. :il'D1~6~! ;Ii;mr~ ...._ "~""_ __iljI _lLj n"!I;<oI!;!!!! IH'Il!' U"'lI'YfiI,l;r' tv. _..iY [ ,,,,,.~J...,,,.,,",, _II~., t I~~, .... l!;j,f g __ MIII!;!!.... ,,;;I"""~""'I,gl verslons leo':''!I€i''G1l!;!!-n~"Il"" ,~f'O't6""ilj-'h!'"l ili~; ~,c,iCli'i __ ! ""I _Ii.,.. ~""'Il!. _!
~'Ifll,olll1i€)rwords,
.. ~ - ,!Ii ,-,jjlr n-t .. :---- -, •..J. 'e'I'j.---:- f'I--: h '~';- ) 'Y'I, a,r.!:i, ",.;Ii!.!!. _.' _-El_ '.1' ,~Ii-.''-'iIi' in ~~ -IH _sa P!.... ,"""" ~...18 rea- n~ ftl- Un JeI.lI' 8. eli .. C " Illn!_ case """,Q'!;!lli'! 'I.I.a. _,h, is ~'m ""' ~--rlin -JI1Il- .II ~~, __ .IL-i:;ie!!_., -, ,- :: _.-.;!Ii' .... ! Ii-! - ---:- _'"J' ... iI. !!.!!I
,~.t~~~.t;,..(~;(J!q...~~M:,J~~rJ'~~J'~~,e~vAfJJ.lJ'.v.,;;~~~~~'I.'£.'~d:,~~.Af~~t:;:;J~,VW~"A#' _0 --', - ,,.- -- (', " "r.: " r:' ii', ...a' , " «r,., fJ ~j"~~~t~?2'Jj'~,L,MT'~ ~V"~~'~ ~li~'~~rv,L..I~,~~;I~~.#~_f--It'i1rt~C)~~(~'L,~iIJ~~J';IJO;ur"Vl'-b1'~v:V~
,,;1'" (' ,_, ,.~ ." .'
'!i!!I
..
'~I
!!!'
~I!I!!I
=~'
__
'_
.-~
!!!!!!I
'.'
'~_
,.Ik'I_('"
~ 1~!d~j'7-;li.,~u;f", (JJr,~~~~;L~J;bj.t¥ij'~rL/~~I(~cM~\~f.h~~Ll;lJ;fv!~(wJ'v~.lu;,r:Lu~VJ'J~l1:t~, . {dlll- r:~, Jr.J~ M·,jlP'~~ ~_.j'..!i~. -~t,iL~ .~,,~'~,:(;'~~ .:..,rs.;,... -:".;'~. ~,Ch(. ~ll' iL~J,L)-=E_r\ ~, .:.~3· iiJ .... I;.J',~-" ~'P1[+t-AJjt~ ~' " _1l»',,!11~ u,L,.r
-'-L' {r"'- '., .' ~, ., ,'" - ("" .'---' r~~ ,~,;Jj' '-,. ~,UJtl;:....r1~-{/[j.;JVV.!tJ.Ii~V
.1.Jiio:
-y-t)":L _ ()~~. - .............. ~~ ""'" ~(&, -,,,
~'II;,)'""iI;)~'_
~~-I~,~ti~~J~t.~~~~J~~ r~kh~c'r,~!L(~~.t,~:;,rJJt.M~}~iJr~)ll;J-M.\~
dti:J'i~~ #~~,vtJldJlVl,L, ~
!l)';o.~
,,:I'CI,,,
--
--
i'~--
!;,;f..
.I~.
~U'~'»J;.r\~~v
1:4\'.~
"~;;I.
~l. oM _, ,. - . - ." _ (". fli:. _.J'.~" r Ji ~"." if,;; ~ -,,~.t.f"~-~~iI,)i,;4g~~J,'t-,- ~~~~l7.~ ,:tJ!I"iI
oc;
("'II
'~~',.t(: ~vrD'~~J~',lJ,,",\f.~ .
,,. ,~'-,"" ...
.1- ('
t..'{,
tf~~"~/~f~rJ~!.b~.tV~I(J~J~~J~~~~:J:Jt~(P'(.l(j/JZ~o:nJ~,J~ltt;iJtif(/jL,'~~~J~fJ4w£"'frF: ~ , .....;. ~ ..( .. .. '. f.,.f' ~',.' ~1 t,:.'~' ...L.,.~~~,yo~t5.i'J.; - PlJiik..JD'1 ~~t:f,'+:,I;.t, l~j~'~,~~J'A~J' r~.. ,...- 11'/..--~, ' .. ~~Iu..,.J r
II! ~ III ~",'_I
1..
•-
I.,
~.-
••
_.-
,.,~'
~'i-
..
il' .' ..
.
'r. ~
"Vo
""1;,.Q~£~J~~I!lJ~L:~~I?,;t'~U!1~~v!~~nt,~~·,v I - ... ~
4..L~kJ~~rtb;tlf-~~Ir~~.U~1'}I~£,Lj'trA-~r":,,,cr~~,~b'lfli~o;:,)~~AJlfJD~/~~~~\~~~
I~'
","¥~Ll
If.'''"·~t~~!1
mlCl~~elsed r
i'1€iW w,mi'~of
and olaiming that slUlCn is,~h~ plmnshmnent rer ;ajIIP~Qpl~'who' iQfEll glllllty ,of bla~pilhEimirig ;agj~t~nst, p~p:hre~,of ~slam. '~.he
~ -.,1;1- . , .i8rcy k-fI,;;dJiYl S iiln--'-~'- ue n 0
him'." ~ ... ce _ y el __"=",,,d8 ,~Iio.''-'~}hA-'-'j -n~ ~s '1.-'- I-I-rnili-'-mll"'\I'L __ iiini'~ '-'I'::'I'fi'i"j;-Ifi~.ji~-:: O~ilr ,,__.. le%IlI--, II"':-nr.'!or 1~!I~!l, IL J3 ui81i1ii18 __u ,,- IUlIiit" _5~a_.,c'r' ~ :ai, .. ,glir ~.ll!lIg . ,I ~!'!f ;a" g,W!~! ..,~3,!l,'i.!! pro _ !8 e
.1..
'~~w.
a~~ments:
<5; ~-,-,
- ·jllitio,;; ... iI o;I!{p~5~~y l(lnIii.;;l\"""iI'd!m,c,1I _s.. __'~" .I~,l""r ~··;ki~h in '1 - am, : :... gu.~!!-).! V~ .:!j{'"-: ,L _I;;I~J _. '!" pU! rni- aUft-'fi~ .Vol, ~! !.I;ii, u::5.~- -'
r,A'n: ""t::W!!loi!L!3I
Ryshdi~ mil:!rst ~~,. ll'ila: other ~.rgli.nrt~filt is, that :$i[f!;c~ p!J~li:s'hm~n"!to~ an,Y' p;€'fSomr.whether dT ~n'8i
d.
M~s!Jimor non·M~lS!I~m:!, ho w
~'Q_
bl-~-h __81i'Tira; - .C'i""in-j. '~m p_ ....Py ~ t'-If liCoJI- B- d~ -;I;ml- [fC...II ~-Im 8, n lR.jjll:-h.-lli- 1m ... ,~J - - ~; ;f';n- ~"", ha mll.·c;:t -, __at""P - __Q:;:;l '!;I_,g'P! __ 5~ _ .€1 -:f"i"'I{: 'm- iO' .:!'_;aI ITli 3_'ro'iI_lI.. a._I;;!!.:;Iu .. "l;,i!S ,'I;;!_@i . ~~D' !i,;l8a!I~,l!'_"" _8 -,II _""" _ _ U\~~ 'l'iN:OI I~Ba'imsOOJif,~d? Th~re sre :sQm~o1h~fi" iSi.!rues 1lhm ~~
'tlio.,c, SO!i!.o-iCi ... ~ y_,",,", .... Ai~;Nl'II~b'Cl'i'iI H~,_IO'!Ir;."'"""VII
I::""~' gfl::l'L.
a$~rat~d
mn if i! WM
'Lilli i.i!oI" I!'iI<iD''''''eo V.V'j'Yi:;I hHi:;Il,!.I',1;i<
_I:.:H
~"'o6't
Il!Ilg
~,""UII~i,"",U
e-Oi!in""",O!ii"ii
i'iif.cA y""_€lITo;I1,,I!,
das _.
1..:Ilc,ct· ~
I;;!;~,,","n
hi-:~ IEIIi,.,-ffiI wtcn _.is W--: m,v'Jli1I- ;iITil.-;l-r ... m.I;I<'!'i3. _._!tII. 11- .. as ..... 9 '!.lIE\I
'1;;! ••
III!I!E!
1(-r'!IV a ..
lif 18!l:iit'-i'rn,W,;;!iif" nr-,t-,-:- F~in:-: -'nof'll~ir .. ~.ua ... _.!OJ?,"" •• Q", Q~a:!"~L g !.LIir!I~'.
"tm~ Islam le law. oo1W;ld Mus(i me slilll ,@Oal\f:ir' iiis, life i~'lintel,British, territory according to '~haJtlaW'~w~lidhl Brimun lis, not
ii"iI~~~miC:id· Ik.~ct? II~I.-lI1n'-, ~- ....ini\f;itt""..I1wfr he nt Ih!lm l :::II"".,,~ .... !..I.:r.' ,if'(.... .. e. 1i,OI8 p""", 'i;.;l'VI!o!11l,il !...
.>Q. _~ ,)~ '!;!l~ . ,. __ .
n ~
inon ,.~I
'l\hiiN'li.-h u nwnn,.;.'r'illli'-llln_, w'-h~.-;.""r h,- W,'i:!i;Eo_ """'!,w",:""IIN' 'I;;! J;;;l!!il!i!'. 1;;11 hiliill~... El _ 'o!:iU '!"'~ '~..Ii"'¥,\afll.;;l\ . . -If? _,.' ....!I,!!9 il"'. '1;.I',1l"'" _. ,~, .. ,', ....p .. e . g .... ~ .... _
-c,
l8·000~ ~'kJi-~dhl'-il'¥"Wj 'ilh'·*Hf-b'ed: ._ ~iI1d _ ... _ 'li!.~ IU~Jn _.J . lIL .J. .. ..
(!i~VEiI ::::1-. .
iTIi1!il ., (}
'tili'iolli)!'1itandi:rng Ofi ti']e, '~o. . illrn' Jfl,€iI'iits m~ntil)n;€d aoove _ _ . _ ... . '_'.. . ,_ __ • ::::!I!J. _ . _ . __ ... ,_ , __
~m~pthlasa.Z€1 im;lXifita~~ WO
~'SiSI~~
''ilitt~f~ ;$~riOL:r!S
m(j~1
come· an(YiN'Jitere
'OIOSi
aga~n~t I~~am ~uldl 'ihe, Ip:~pti!et: ,af Isilam. :f!Uh,jl'rU!~d (,if '(!hem - al~,1hoY$a,ndls (~f rt t'ilu'fiidoods and 'lh('jl.u~i~mds)of Ulenft! - bel aU m l de~affld equailiY gui l±y'(j,f a ~rUm~ lPu!1ishabl:e :by' imml~,;(:1:i8ie. e~irn~jil,tdH'di':aJ~8Ul fiOl mi~ttl:erwJh~~~F' t1Ihie,y wern, n~ing(~' d ~f "t~t. We!~ the iQO"f!t:;t 1~1antic po.~UljO!i] regafding ,such [people W~ MUSililTil$tth!~nmlJiS'ta~n91e 'loT mill !'(ins,!of [p>€iople 'W
i
operate
;a!I'1 OV8it t~,a !gIDbe' iif1l' 1he 'foi1ilfil of dea~.hl ,sQuad.s'to 'talka care, 011 thie reQui'r~mnems; Im'the 'Islamic ,la,W"'~naJt :t~pu~ates s book en his, was
imm~'i!1Jte kim-iOg al~ blasphe:nnets\, Mom-over!, Rushdia has, 'ii1fienti~n8d harolft' anyrthTrng ii'irnmiis infamousi '~or own:: He borrowed most con.demfilable
i
m his, nnate(~aJfm",om
S~ Mre
ina
M u~mm
:souroes
101 1he
earlDerf tiIFflHi-S.
Ir "S~anve:
'VEI~WI'
i~111other 1Mi!JS1im 5-0UrceS '~h3!, enaiblted 1he '3,ytntof' ,of' i~;~.o boli'tQW mMeria~ from
'fot his, ~o.ok., ~'f e welfo8fair"':miilfldeg, Ifij~,Hnalfl!s! ~ m~~~;'ilii'rsldl~mi;!Ulicl'U'nal alii such lmna~rclou:s w W lmalenal should be' i6"~pUi!FiIged
'~Oiiil1 ~he
of' RlUlsihd~e's inrorrna-tf.0,1\Ii" 1;0 demand lR!u$ihdh~'~s headl 'fOf' a c~ma 'fOf' whroh thOO8 8~~isf ,onel'S 'trmimfi all'il), ,chafg8s, would
'iha1! ,bflirngs 'iftJ:1i8 t,o t'nsl ,O'lher ;im:ponarn loonsrdmaitotJ'i lassociated w;ith ,tlM~s1ki11l-\~5ih;die, as ,emnotional!ly charged in Si!Woh
Ii-._ .. -f ,w-o:k 0'_
Si8ii'il1~meifrt:; Should M ~.rS!limsbe quite fur a pe~Qn 'wh~ ~a$ b''1-11r,.;~_!_1"1'1QIIf"rLU5 .. yn8, \;0'1' - 10, --1'1'..4·-
,1ft
s:lt~Honl ,as t.o demand ~a~nl Ui'JjdJ~t alii cireum~:ances, b- - ~ne ----h__8 t-':wll.,- -- h- n- ----we 3_1Ii6i::S8er.'l;lD'!ig! - ~nOS8i _JOtJlllJli ..--- -- - - -1,,·-- ~rop
bla,sphSimed again'll Hiett" [prophet wi,tho~l mllid~ngout 'what 'U1e f.ai'r-tf.tfliient fof sueh ;a, person under illslarmie ~aw' ilS? w
i"'Io-.,I\--
~Ulj al1l;
4,,,",, -
U:I!e'
'..... , - ..~
!.V pl!'I;.!!~CiI
-~- -,..iI-Cke'itny
fflqldlf.es, lM~s~ims to be fair in d@)1:1ding ~vei}'(iFil€:'ilrllcll~diil1gl'~eir IEHu€oti€$. ~none of '~h+]i with 'pa~s!:lg~. the QuF'ao 1i;.rFgl€<S 'tn* beljeV8f$ to be fair llI!tiio:er
,~III iciFJeUfliins,larcces,
th~.ns; Beli8Vl!3lrs.be ~t8a;dlfa$t 10f lhe sa!ke of Allati'u iri pursuing "
jliJSUCoei,aJifLul
let ~W thQ enmity O'f' 8l nati!Ond~55ilJ~tde from beirtg) fa~F:i be mhr. ~hm YO~I ~sti'ie' Icllosg ,AJllah m()ws what ,OWlI dO~'1(,Qufarll: 5::18) ~\q-, I!.L - - - ;r""'f\ -_'" _S fih _ere,!U_ ell e_:n.J!I! 8' _ -!:!I-Y
rn~'tn03i1i' __ '8 i""!F.llp,,!I;Il1-, - -i::I'hm-nh!;, p.SE!i_!/I:!. _ _I!l, __ ;!I!l, w~; 00l __S_I;;!'I;!' 1~_!IeI,!i:II~~ e __~ ~ .;- --nIDd·
,COn -
4(""r
!U
Ru~hdi~ 'V€ry ~ffl!flu'lly iarnol d~[.Q;e1 IOb;j€ot~~I;y' 'wJ1eU1er tee; d~se~d induv[d~aJ~s,at S'mke~,ine wry ~p~tion '
~o be kiUed or
li:llf:IJ
o,f Our 1'a~~ afild ~h~ siincerity af our at~~chml!3lFi1t, it awe,~llso ufid~if5;triet to
R'i!;i~h:d'i'€' ~s
!!l
~ealiFrli\fill ~~U1l11,,Me '(he 'two' dl~m;'S C(jrred:? ,M fOlf '(he first one. the, ~act of' 1hE=' 1 matbr ~stMt
k, - I!:l__ iil_i ... YY
,~-h-
i501;I!:iij,
k -, ~.y€: due
illf--"1-dj, __ eH~ v
t-
,11<,;;;, !!.V
11,~~ :1Ji""i' "'\'I"" U"~Ifo~' .... :, - JI,.,,,... ;"'."" ... ;1" ... lU ..... " 'WII! .... ~MW~
~>,;l!~II!I
"",r
II~~ ... _HII 1i.I','1' ...!!f''''''joi'''G, ,~b ,. 1'l~!I,,1! '-"11'111;;1 ......... ~ ~_~.
'iiC!I~"1' "'""
... ,
fn.'I'
!io!'
;ilra,c, ~Q'"
I\!ii __ g u
Ii'iIO" 81 !I _.I!. __
in
:~o?n~.i?
iIo
b·: -'I
u","","d,c,ntI gl;",'1.,-:I.~I
M' l..:I'.,;i!!i.. ,,1,\;0 -~, Ik.,c, l iII,"'::';";' 1,~I1I'1'i'i; ~-_..II 'V~,~ !I~~ I IU ~~J~, """'_~ '"'" , ~.,,",ig~ ~I! gny
n....
a M' ~
lost.;.,f 11i,:!;,g~I,'I.l,-'l;i-Y.j!k<5it !i..c. d"dln1t ~iIi~eil"'!I',1~',.,..:!!Oli' .... '~""''iI,"",,'''''>D ..lie. - ~.-.I\c.A ba .... :.;.uh:illil!Y-J!!Ol'. !!;IIN_ II! !!!;III!. ~ I~, ~: I :11 ''!'II'!:-!!II~~ y~'~
",II.,€-''l'1 ~r~'"" I!OII veifS~' Ir!:ii~f.!;", "'bi' of c:· ~ _ ~_!, II~I""!J!'"'''''' ~II! - ~ 'I w"",_ _.
~'r,1 _"'"
1f;~:ILi'~1'm·.~ l _, _
""i'lI(:l.<,l€Ii'i~I'i5,4;;O~t:nn ~hCli r;!}.W II.'lq~1 '·' I"",,,",, _ _ c- ;eioi!j, ii'ii.j'II""'~o~ 1Io~'81!;,it!! II :~ 1e.ii'iCl~lt',ei'sr ' 'n ~ II~I.u _ MI--'!i !;II1"n! __ II!I __ iljI I~ ~ lei; '''~'~I~: ~!.... ~;s:'II-er 'W\!;rI"'" !::II-I 'I~' _ II I~II! _ '~":""€:l _ 'Y'U ""'-11'" _ '"' ~_ '!! IIII __
~:3fta:rrnlmust face: ~,plitall F,)I!.JiWll'hme:J;'!lt? M\Y anS~f {ithe religiOUS. p~ctioo' of th~ proph~li'
1~\I\c.lfI1 ..:........_Ifi.i ~~E)l ~
t~ ~his Que~~]on~$ ~$I~mi$ derived ffo~ the, Qur-aJ'i!, l!awid Slulnah that
,SOU~$
ofigina~
...."a ~"j!!!~'
W:h~t:Mu~l~rn$ say,.
1.e.1 'h....~_~' 'Q'II.,Ji<!'li'il Iil!~~' tha .";-_ ~Jll ~~
'ei'Ii'I..I1 ,,~,~ue.~, ....ao'5ill"lil.~' ..... """~ Q q.1.J'le '~!llfY u.~'"~-"~ 'VI'9-~lJlllt oi!j:"" ~,i'J'iI ,t-;!"7' ~ .e;r"'f'lia!19.3 ~I"IYI!'!Y~II
~1!!!Y~~'liUf~~
'ilihe basis on
thi~ p~ph'~)
'9lart ~aJ~1 'Ihat 'I'Kjll 'tt1:ooe al1ii~~gst,-rh~m who "tlWim 'lti'ilf~!ir ;a('lks «Ii:! Isll'amJ,lnl It, ~s ~fgrnifh:l'an~ I!~m' that '~en b to
-- - - - - - I -1- I.,_- ! _S_ e m~al'ilHngs.,li-hI !~i --- - -t ,~U -itn- 1 en ~-"- source- 00-I' s!.!Igges- ling-- I'00- -me-- ,_- ','"~w-h-d"1h - IlnIDS - -- Ie - - - ----, - ",[proper 00- -me' __ - -l(jt to--. ii:: a my'- ,"1- '1'. - - I",-- -- - .-·t"-- - '-' ~, 'I"._._ a·· I,
.... - -.' I -, . , .'.'I" UtI' -----
--
--
--'--
....
--
.--
'-'-
-.-
""
-,'"
",
'~S;
'ihetre were UNO s]Qliificanl co~cepm ,of ~h8 Curan 1hat calmli!J~:be
Qurarn ~S! ui'!;ambnQ UitlusJly,cJ&arU'na!t: th)af-e ,oou~dl be only'Mo vaHdlreasons; fur ler\iierllan Iksr:ami:c: state, ~ get san~tiDn a
[pelfWnll:
w, ~i~1
a~sO
nfiscrLi:e'~on earth. ,(!QuManl: 5i::32) 'Whi Ie,the pUii~hilil1ent fur a mli.nrJefElf w,aS slmpile, dla-a!tml, the puni'shmnent
DClmmititilng ia,l'i!fY~n8 of '~e' CriIlil18S, 1almng lin ~h8 lamer eat'SigrOii1' WS~IIin mailllty case~. eiV@il1more Qufara dEClared thaJt if a ,petsO:WIl was IkiU@d reasons -riOt
_VI~JiYt'3!.
ref one
Olfli9 llYn!)
persen Inrad" as, i,f. lkilled ~h8 entire Irnrlii.ulkilfl:dl. I'Qur'aTilr~ 5Ii:a~ Salman of uea~r~gIrfdsmiw en ,flt·aTUl,Blasph~min9J
Rus!~d~e has nQiUl8iif kline:dlanyo~8! flOf was h8 guilty did] nat ;a!rITr1QU!M (;~e,atirl;gmiscmief' on ~,
earthl beCiJjlllSe '~rue ~attet ,crimei hlas been descriibed by lime,Allm~QIMy ~ imS81~lin thue 'Words; -rhose, witto 'light. against AJllah and IH~s,1fi!18sserllger 2l'ltd
IC altel !lie
m~echi8if on 'earlh.,11 (QJjfB_fl1,~'5~'331~1 Tihess! wiJ:~ldlmg31 'cou~dl bi9 appmca~b1e lin the
(;aSia
(If it w~re causing ,tn,~ Irie~ p:~I)p'effl; 'Or honour o11-th~ccmmon pgo,pl~iWI be
waSI
,m ~he
fi ~~ rdl:
s.mkii' ot 'f1irefir IM~ar.ioWL~ ,designs . .sa~mnan Rumdie Ciusun9 mLlsch&8f On ih~ ,ether -i'mportant ki'I'- ..:II k;.~ ~I-._J t~Y "")I I~!~
l8'anh.
~n'Ejl
--:: '-"-'~""wrf" Il 'ur.c.~,-,lli-IP..II\- 'W... i11f.:""j kiWd, _ OL 8_ I!.__ ~ __ 111.;1 I:;Q~ __" _'IU 51 111_ e '~!1.;1 a yO _'e! _ :~h-if'~ho'!lnl~rl::,-'--m'l~n:'J'n-,,,,,~,,,,,,,~Jli;,cil,r;-;m-if'i!i-ifI),,'R pe!iJp_J~ ,~"",,re _au"8 . I!i.I'I:! ei _
Aim" ,~
mO __ ~
,,"nm-6:Mrt:l- 8 'tli;;- 1~1t-"- ,w,-, W--:-I c_ __e~ __iiaI_ __'SlIJ_ J!>S __ 0 _ere:
I!~, 1",,1;!;!!
~i
"'iI';t;
_Om - i8..<Qt -. 'm!!le 'y~g ,1:1 1iT'i,.... 04""'1__h---- - >!i In';';"\! ~ Urm!gr!
-
'rof''Iih€:' AJli!J1igMy
to
kin hls
AIIi'i"i"-hiY-~i lio""lkl~'- p_a;ce -1--f(lil,h'!i!1I@I~,'"!I"iJ:."-' l(nI"'-- Q ' __ ~ 11,!~lSi_ J __ !llIg -'fl'r--- --- Inii.. ""-,;;II ,ii-!._!~:~!g_ 'I!.'!:!_N Uf!ii!3fl!51 "1' ";;;;I!OIlJ!
~L$&OOlS
in '~.hehf1S'tory ,of'imn~nI<iM,'Wllcany
,-
QiUlt: a
demiflJitj1 p~li~'
of'ltils
,- '"i'"~-;:.,c,'r11 ge_ 'Y'"''''"tP,-_e k1n;r;;-;wirr-: ~;'II w:l~'H:j,e;,~,·tW;<5';~' a ,,!~ :S:,g-.....__ ~ -f..lJ~-;:'it,... __ L'\oI· gI !11;,i! t: '!;I"~,I_ __!*II""'
11ft as w
e""jl-h_ ~_@i
'ut---.-
_ , W-!i'\Clli-11I1'-~~~,\m'" !i.!! lli;,~ Him Ibe:~ ..." __ _ 'e! 1:l!__ 'Y!!ei"",!i.! .... ,;r... y,;r . ___ ..:-"":;:"i~-.-:thiCi'U -~,;r
0;;1
. 'IN _ ~II,k!IOrl 'I(J- ..I~,.v.e. ---Ii' . ·Se-i2!as - -~II , 'Tii;;.e' !i.!!m~r~(noo wS'_Si ~h a~j,'" SIn:!OO •In'll ~'Foecas_ €I 01('t'he::_'I" Iii· Imnl2!s__ n!9_.r IL JI;'I::.: .' _ alS,
e
m~ag;a.
IUiS>ed
VII
'i'iffl nl;:;;ii'I!'iI""-I:. ....A h'I!,",_;,.,;,!:~ n!!!lii""_1h.....- n~ ~Ih,c.;... _->;.,;~,y"", v., .... !'!"Ui:!l~! y_,....: eoc:W;f"rACo .;-;,f;
.~ It~""; !thco
;!";If
ii'lC;e;,fi\i!"i;rIi me; - -- ir\C;'co -h.;~, ,...,ji'th ilhe;t i~I"";_"" __'__,,",,_'__~,",Ji!Y ~'!ioJ Ci~!'"" '~! _,€:I••
m~a;g;~
m Muhammad:;,
aliifj]h~ssa11a~m", '~ffl
~~\c'IC~d)uH~ . ~ _ .. _ __. c: 0: .,. _ _ _ b~I&-1j\e illl itlo~~IS€!i thM1'WEf'-, _... ....~ _ f€I ,
,to g~t pu fili~h€!d~n th~ 'Y'~'iJ lire" Hthey did nit d~$~~' ail'l'}' ~Ia:!(.d~ilitu"ough ~~~ltr!I" Q~il'e!fila~wi~l1Iy, i~ p~~on ' if 'fae~ dealh iIlrn 't1Jrrst p.1:ace~ hli reftlesoo to be!lh~V'e'iln ial mesnge;i' hi ~ad to again 'U1e if 'fetoe death
~~d ~o
disbem'€:!!J€d,;, Ho:wl~-'\fer; ~u(ih p14iJ'i1~shmef"i!t: fl)othijng (~ do wJt,1l) '1Jh€:: iSiPO~i~ateswho ne-ver wieiOe~vlool'ihe' m~$agi;!: 'fr,o.~ t'h~ had m~~n91~r
~S~!;l,Jrn~: I~w'.
Lers
fUJ;\W
,al
publlic ~nc8
in
ilih~ ,anSMf ag:ajn is,d~rnY in '~]'H~I ttli~~Jif\i\~. There 'W@re' t: Ih~aslt'~hTie~i a leases 01i tJlasphemy ,~g,a'inst '~Jh;e IrOprt~ ~nd 1hs P -- . ----- -- --- -- -- lon8 • - - -I. ,... --- .-- ';',' ---- --f . e-ml - ------- - - - -- -- a, _- ---1 -- ---- -- "--Ily.. me&-'Sa,g,8of' Is,! am nan - t-"- --d-- mnt-h 81C- !lJ r'an. In If1Im8 ',"'(II, ~-'h-- --- t- h 8J8-- was a, sugg-m-- .. en ~-n ~hos- 8 wh i'J! were --,gUll .of' fu' -Ie . -. .'_.' :l ' ., ."
I"
'
:'
..
':
'I -
I'
'l (,
-'
.. '
,"...
: ,'
...
:.
I' -
I',
It.·
_.
'.....
--
'.
., [..
"," ..
. ",
offienoe ought W' lbe I,(jlled" If tnr&'fa was t~ be, a pilIlifiiSinlilTIerN: '~orblasphsml1Y", oleariy litt' was, the Qufan W:nEif~; It sn~uld Irna,ve'
been me'r'iI~io'ned" especially
WI'l!3!1il
CWUifif~no6!
rue, ~\FO\pher,s,Ilif:el:time.
'ifiB! passages, iimwin'iolill cases, of !blaspheflillll h~e been mlSntIT!!ll1ed aF~ round in U1e in tmi8 au ~an in thi8l'fbUowiing V""8if.$e3::
i1fI! Ui@j,fi~t' pass.age~ tile, Qufia;fiir informs us thm ~h8n'8 Mre, some ~'i3~rriliS1pjred: nrypoorEfes, WinO, used to
,CornEl'
W' 'the
prophets ga~narn'ng5, ith 't:hSI m~~jv-e, tease ~ii1l i'nl a ''Way 1hat 'ltneir- chceaip~ w to sinfUl de5iire~ ooulidl be sa!iSfiad on the ~n@l hand and ~t ~heill"offenoe sh!Oy~dl'go uru1~Ii~d ,
-- - w -......:I 4!h..... W;';"I!J!u f -- -... --'IA LIOn ""n
('Hli
the
oth;[iiiF.
sa¥iing rJi,-alinl3(ple,ai'13i say L~again') in a, W,!3(Y' 'that -they 'would twis& their' tOfligue ~o prcdan;gl 'Ilhe, iletler !r so as, 1~ give,
0.' a __ (l~!I,.!!
1.., .....
1I'~i!i8!;!1._
iifri --
Il:- - -- - h - -- Il-.,- -..-I~I' !--- - iIl- - .-11 ..." ...... Iil.-.ll- ..,.-- "ni'ii ·th -- - ---- iCI!i;....,~n; .~ ~h"- --rniiTl< - .... , - --- - ii"it----- .f"~-- --;Cj;-·t-(FUr ,6 __ ~~rg ; J'1I:S:~8~Ui',,",,~W_ -~Q;lai"inl!',~ _ 8 [J:Ierp;';'ilil,i~!L-'i,,!!~Q ~_ C_I.!I~8I 'w ,an,y' i-'Umg~~mllh.;in ; ep!, I Q~ ~U8
,..:I'.... m.~'
II.;!'I;,I~ ~ i,"
,Dj.~\CI;--:~~"",w"""¥-,,",,r, '~'1-,.,,- ~~(' ,~~·dl·'~h;'~'.....i L."'~.;C,j;.ra_;" ~~'61',Q',i\C>~' !.!III@ 'Ii;;!I,IUli i!:!Illli <:I!~d iii I"" w ~JI"",,'¥',,",,I <:I. !i;;Ii~ 10:.0 ~I.:!'! ~
re..;:;,: ~~', I~...~ \-~"""i<'5Id,re.,,:,;: It -n_Z111 IllY • -- -i'!i'i~ iQ'~ 1g 111gI1' 11ll"'",""Q iQ''"''\y
il:dll!!.!
sam9! purpose. ih(;J ,second IP'UlS--a;g:e,tilat men~.ions an ~niSUJlt~ngla-ttitl!Jd!e 'm '!he disbE'iI~i3;\ilr.f'1S is, :91is~'"i8;eilie-vers,~ dortl ma~e ,such
in~Pvf,F,i'/I;il1l.l!8_::lII~!i.iI_ ·-1-, ____ I!.!I
Y!I!I_
'~Iil-j ,.-Ili- 1f,:-'Ii-: !16-:--, ~•...,,_ M-k .... ,di'OUL e! uiSi wh~IJ!!,'q~HSLI;;! m'- .......'!,IL ,~- - ,~rt\",jl :a~ , fi'n II:! 1;;!I_:s.~S", __ev,""rs\'U~ a_~_ ""'lfli ';~··r'ifini-,i1iA -,
1
gf 'your IFIe!ligioil1. _ndl 'fhr AlI~a:hi~ )Nll!l ,~~ tru~ b~r:i~iI(€ft. When Y01Jl!are call~d A ,
'rot pmyerS<,
~ifi(lW
-, ,;j.:~
1~'m'l n a
'--near o~ _
Q_.
__ ....","""
Hm,;;>fIib\e'"
__ i,
"--,~~..... A ~ 1:o;:B{li;Di;~---, ---'-i!ii!fie ....--1:;,.' g~ 1'!.'I1:iilIii! t:";.,,,I'fi .... m"!:-!,I!!I,...__ "'H un~~I!:'!IY~ ~ __ """",,,,,,n:; W ....II" __ ""n~:r <l'IrD11.;;.",,;.-I 111I'oI'~~'--'e;JI\i\iEo su",'k """
'ihe ttilird lpafia;g;~ re~~,aM t~ 'thie"topic a,ppears i:~ 'the lSi~ ..th~rd dlapteil'"O'("Qufan tiUed IIMyplOmtEJs
-""ii"ii.iiI _He. _€: >a __ "" ih,i!",,1!;!!1!.tk--, Ifl-- '__1"1'--:--,;:.. w
,a.n:"'llf--BS ,1rr;;,f11--,ij,i.i\C;;- - 'wit- i'''ii Ion': e _IW!! __ :t;,! __ ~v.JJ!i!!',,",!U:iIl' .iiJ, _!!I
,.rd I,,!!~
beH~~F$, 'bi;j~~h~~ h)iP-Ocri~~ ""15... ~111""~iiJi\Ci~' :_ glu ~~I li!i.!l~ ....'!IIl''!;,l,,;!, so".-I1
Ui'a - clle;cii" '"'!:'!IS,~-L ~_~-
r-
,jik;6 'IJ!!!,""
h6~.-II . ","!:-!lldl.
~i"i;i!>"'" - A ~!!"'~~!i.!liI·
'11..6 _rll~
-t~~ ~iFOp~
w~s:'t1"i!e' 1!'iI1!'ler, d:idfi't '~a,'08 deallh ii'fII,i~,etnbuti~fi 'th!8 cJ~r aot 01' b~a~phi€lmy he ~md h'i~ com;panio~s ~re' he, 'f,w
'''h~ 9
q'
~h"'~
'"-!!_ - ""....
oIIl..,ost ~ 11;11-
i"f 1-
..Jle;eorl-.. rn"'''' ii'lC!j"jj-- -i"':if'i'("ii ~rn!' -'I __Vb ~....""lIU-I! ~I' ~:;;!' I;II,~, '-"_._ g_
pun~hm~nt
for bl;a;sphemy', WJ'ilfy am,1M~~Hmsdemaifilding t'~~,t, ~h;oo~ gufillty of thl:s O'liFe-rl)[)e shcUJ~dfaoo d~a!~h? 'lh~ ans,~r
wef@:
proph~t d'YJill:1ig i~ ~ilr:~I~mel, h fili"tOO~~hlt!i ~re' rdll~ma~nd'~ngh~ h~a!dl of Salmliil~n- $I1idie land ~ ~
bl~$phem€!i~, I~~i~'i!~ in
-too Ilg~t af 'those, r~c]d€:ints't'hllt, such, WaiS tree j::uJlnjis'h ment for ,StU blasph~mers", 'lhe 'fad~():ftt'i,~ ~atrer ihs 'ltiJat.;as we ~a'!l'e' tOr,atrfi\edl ,ar~e. therreis, no p~!ilT:S:hm~!f'IJt: bl~sphe~y fo~
iiff'!
1S!la~l. y.~t:thooe
pe~pr~ who ffl~i~'E)d ~h~ m~~a:gi~ '0" the m~$~ng~rs dire~I~. ~s d~ri6ed ~lbo'\!'~'u ~r~ d~~,tifiI€dto tii~' w '~med,rr;)n!~ Of' "lNiely
-t~ ,other'i aft,~r a,iC~~in G~d-or.d:aJi d~fiidlh'\~ was ~adlli'IiJd.,'il"lll1at de8d~lmeirtad ,91I"ready reawedl 'for th~1dl~be;lie-vef$ of ~ed
Ma_1(ka~,Mllirteen yea_f5 after llia prop hue mBssiotiJ hi!d sJtaJned~ at Ule tl'me whentfli8
fOJ1cedto migf3kl' from thel c~
m, M~d'itrnah.,
HOW~Ji9l~
,God dleltf~d
'wilhi the oonSiith3ratiQftls of 19I wRsdoril'i allI:ild lr1ie~y,. 'ihe 'fiirsttIPhassl of' that pu rlIishlTl:STlt 'look care of UL'!3; rr6re [Leadership is e of' Qt:rr-.a!i~l'iIl. dan '~nat:ruhed Malkkah, two yealr"S after UI1!Jm~gm~ioo lin 1he Balle or Baar:. What lp:fooa,ss oonltiinu:ea fur 'ffliiS! dififi-ereni&~eopl~ at dfiliferElirilt: o~'iof1lS;, 'Whernl '~e poop!e' OF ·~.n~ book, IDe-.J~
H~rll
and '~h~i h1ri!Stiafis, crinilina~ly d~fIIile:d 1h~ C lin '~1'rI}a~f C®S8tn,a pUliflJirsitilrnam was
pro~h8r:8 m8$SfttQa, they ~oo biEC-afl1iUE!, aUg~b!le, llie divine pUii~rumnem, lor
relaxed to net n~~sita~~ death '[;'011 ~h~rn. Ins:!8':ad ~ey wtliris 'r0J1~9dJto ,Ii,velthe: !Iie ,of' s8o(]li'td~r:me' ci11~\8Ii1S tha M LI!~I~nml in 6odiety' on lpajfiirnQJ1i':q,a, '@he filongM[~~1iffl m.~Qu ran: 9:29) ~owev@r;r because' those J'ews and] Chris~]'ans, ni) nadl w deii~ad the' Iprophet ,s, essage' m
1
'Yffliil d~dn~tjust ,cn~n~'tfil,e fiIiIi€!:s~flI!lef 'oF GQd's rlliIEiSEt!!!i_g~'Ib'ii,jt: ~nl' ,on to insUII(~tea~!u!", and] tl'il'r~~ten h~s U~"!' ~1n!~~ trt ' w cons'ldered
I il(k~!lll:!'r'
-~Ilo.,-
-.-
---Issue:
-1~e'-llm--- ~'iIf'-&.'dJ'- ----- ;f-;:'-d_~ iQ,i;./!! "'1 ,(L !U'_,a~~lllemy --1,"11-.,0 -f'Ilo..'II--n,lI..-----·-_'I: '!i;I>a_~~_aln ri~'S!~··1-113' wa'S ~o~n
...... --!..II h'iCi; In a ~,JI- -1'-- OO~11I~~-,~'wU_W!~Q ik- II~'-II-.-II k1iIU!Um --;II-m;i" iU8' 11\1 _81!J
'wiihout htm g,etling the b~j;iiJem o,f g~inQithrough a mal? 'ihel fad ~8;liat ~jlllng him w~~hom a mal would be; Ilu'1l-;1131~mnnc. l
On8 milght ,ask as to why 1hen scms 'p&Oip~e'W@f8 lKiI'leddiulling
W' ~his ques~jon ii's: 1hat 1<8'b Bin ,As~r,aff ~Fild othQn'S WJ"!OIW9'F'81 kjlllsd: dMrirng the ~~1ln8
,M dlanfied
as W\alS
-.: •• --
A~,n·_eli .11\:: ,-nifliihiiloEillC;, ~h- _~alL'!(L B!oI!--v ,~'ilj\\f>'--,;;;Iin" -, ... -: -- ~',I!k. ~e 8'8_ ~E!i_ - -·--'rili·r '!.!o 1!I0 ai .!O!!1ii!::i ~_ J:Ii n -i<':--:rr,:-i"~I~ !;,i!! !,I;!!J.a'!,;,o~- g me~agles _:s !;,i!~ M
m~~ng)m.
H~ us€:dIHlis
$cwoms~in Ute'C-as-eII)f n~~ na'6on 'th~l mC€Jved 1he h:lstm;ess~n9~f'. every f,ad that Ka'b ih~
,aJ 'iltii~1 befQ'FJI$
'~BY w~oo punished, a was th~ norman 1~l!jjh~' :llslamic ~alW:Iwa~ ii'n litsetf a 1M
'1!.' __
- 0 _ 'YI!i(11 11- A'drfiio l!. --J@;""';;11j,i!8PiLl!!1!~LJTi!@I!'h ... ..:;"--.----·-tr-- --t 1:1, -riM;;,-~ ~~i8i ~! . _~
----,;;1\--
UDlQ,8'F
~1we ,aJsSUm~ 'U1at'Ih~ ~1.lini~hm,ent,'101" ~~tSiph,eJ'l1f aiSi dea~h in Islam" ,and if' .sa~nIf1an b w Rushdi~ 'was IiY11ng a nOIil,'-.MYSI~Wi in
ooun~'; as he' liS!now'. oo~I'd lIi1eJ ,s~ill bE'J·lklllledif Mus!iifiliilSfOund him' gM'ilty'
.-
Qf iniS!~ltin;g,their prophet?
11lo. ..
!:S'
i'I
-iiti;ed
!lu',I!~ :::iiUC
was,..;.;.,
U'I,oo'""l;;,.C!i!iJJS ...
",,,,,,
--' .~~~ y~g ton.n....:in;n ... u..at '!!in -"'l"iiiElo ........- -1..111.0,'11an !)''''';I I .... wlt!;;!! NI . i;,.i
;I!h~"· .""~
li"iai"IC ....m. --
iF-~!~ill
i"",~ :::I!Yh~\r VIi' .... co I w~ ii'ij- -·r,it;;.. ,..,.1: •hlo;lY -I-(]"nI !::II
Ik.'~
!dQ'
'ir.iEIIl-'ii'ij·.... I~!y;U:g
~·! ...
-,f';
i'i"j)ill'ildD,1M Ii"IPCI-::.I~ tt!hi<!:i~' ._I'~~W-aS ,~ b .a~'!!inc ['ICL~"g· Hlifil The M' '--~~l'ii'i"il,dlif> '!!indo 'f"':r R.·- -shdne:~D.I~:c...<l'Id ffi, h-.~'~ tOT' tir,'I P'ii""'- Or,.; ls ilL," _'" Y'I F'-"" _ ~ __ ~__~~ ~sla:ii'ii'iI __ _ !:l! ~g! ~g ~'_ g r 1;iI'~~. ~ __ !i,l. __~ ~~ ~ _ !U~ __ I _...-- _ IIY_ ~ ,u. " li'i!1g. ... II !,_"_ "-',.,~_Il:!i",,!'!!, _ ,__ ~ 'I,;,i!I'.... ~
_i,;!
:05 i'"-!!
faw _
p~a1C~
(lisl~IIifiJ who wacs, kJnown to ~a,'iie' \l'nsUted t~'@ hflr!r'b12l o,f an old ~ady m ~~quili9
Iio.h,c;h!i.I!"'!I'" NO
c 1'1- !I;,l! !i.L'1 SEl9 1!I.~ed-'i'I'iliI'ii 11rt-ji' :rI-iilY-- i'\ftiiiGn-_II:' O. ~"'I/I'"' _9 'llJM::mr-::,f l!l'mifiifije ... 0 _JY !Ell Ai~n"~:,- -;a 11;'0-11" _0. __ _ e- !io!!ii!! __ !"",'!.:!!g ~
~n __ .JS w;!l;lIi;j~ n. - r::~~IiCi; [prop _l!:!I~ ,91;;,1'," Il!1i- ~. ,",\jI" YI!e OOi!;!l.'!Ol' e---'--:-'-I1"'"" IC"'''''
'womed fOr her iltl!dl visu!:ed tiler nome. The Mus~im demand lha~
of' t~e
very OPP()SU~, diredl()c11!1 wlM;at,ttrr,eprophet: o,f llsl~m had [brought ilha Qli r:'Jan ~S~ IIlLl$oorq, good tU:dl~k)ur ,can1t: bEll ~h~ lof ' s~m~ as· th~ bad (ll1u~. So' ~P€~ 'lb,aJj ,be:h~Ni()u~' wHh
'tn~ ifll!l~ wilh
Q,'i;ifoi!:!Jr.c~. I~ _"""'""~ ....n;}I.,,.,.;p,~,
~rq
j'O:iU,
w1hom you ha~ I~nmlrw 'h:a:s b~oome, y,olllr bo~om 'In'end. And
lifl..:'-'h - ~<'ii~ -r'ii 1j.~.18 _""U!JlI.... 1;;,>1;0
e;,n'll
nrI~!iI, __
,A,iinG, _ _
=st
L...~~, 'rII!
i~/N:MVr(\L7~I~lJ1:b~L*~'~~v!~Vlr~ft~~~~?V=Vl'Jo'~L,vvJ~+-ti;~JJ...(.VItJt:,.~~J~.~~f;
~~,itJj1~'VJ:Jy:f;·,~,·~~~b,,~/~A/J'tL,.'l)Jijitf~~~fJ~~~lh'~i'{~7..C~t,~r~,'L
~ ~ _. _
.'l)J~APll~"'~JJL~'b'~(;!~rZ~
~ [I! ~ ....
I
~~~,~;;,'~~~'~(~~i~)~
~.l~r~.,v~J'~tI~Llt:Tr;ry~;L
'~f-~~.~r~I~~,~~t.n~ttJCr~
~tl~~j'~Ir!~J~w~~ ~J'I~~~~a~~~WLJ.r."~,;;f4C~j~'cJ~;~~f/V~I~J1'Lf~~~jJi~'~'~~£..JtZ~~
~~JfJ'iL,'G~jJ~!f~J\~,~~jr:~~~~j~;~'J't!!'~j£J;L~~\II~J~;tC~~~J,LI""J6t'r~rJI;N-'~~~J~),j4~;" J~'~~~J'I~~~rJ~;wfif~wV:~~~'!~t.LtJr.J.'~~~~V}~J~i¥J~fr-tft)'h~w'!tJ':~!iL~A~YLL;jfr.ftLf
-;~}tJft~'r~lt~J~'I.8I..J/~~'~'4!1,,/lJjif"~Iv!'.1..~wrJf~,J
J/~IJ/~~J~LfJt~hL~JcJ~~Jj,~tKj~ct;~~l~ft)~fJf~~J~~L~(\:LIJrvn£r"..Jf\t~,rjf'FblJtAbt
,rii;v!~~.JjLl.$JL.;I~~~~,~eJ;iW~~nv1~fli{.r:J.J~Ji.~J~.Lt~~~;;.jL~~Jt~~~'fi..t~l"lL~,~'Jjv:;:+-wt
,-Lf~~'Jl~~I~p~L~,rfijL~(AJ~j~,)t~~1jLtJ;;;\,d~~~~jd'~~vf~t(J!~u\J~:l.~e~r;~r~R:a (ji
'r(MVJL...L~'cl~r.fY~~J~JniiU:'J;'~~~~~'~Or!!tJli.b¥uJ~:~'t~~~~b:lK~~,,~tJ~.rc),~~
~,tMJ.,.(~,,~ ~'"':/~~" -t'(ln,n "~~,N'lL ~
~btJ.i(~fj~~~if~~uJj:t~~~r£,rJ~~cJ~1c.
,~/d{:~Jf~n'~fV!c1jfj';;JJdt~Jt'~uJYJ~~~(~wr~'c:J'IJtL ~v('¥I~r'~.!:Lf~w~~;ITNfaJu.l"~!filjfuJ'~~,~!lJ!~!Jpff#~,k.~~~,j~~i~""~,~,cj~cibdrJt1tLIJfLr,\Lf
_~ ~-'f:'- ~LL·,~ t:l*~V~LI~'~l-T'~' ~~', .. ~w- - - ~iL»1,.£'11~:~If~ -~ __ ~t.,.,LL~ r .1[ ,J~,
_~l., , ~l. -
Jl)'~'
I:!!"
JV~~?' J~~.J~J LIrIJ~~'~~Jl~~~jJ,!L~lJiJ~I~J{~L,r.;\L/J~V:'jlW~e;r../~'L~)~rifL,~.;,;1"L.f~~~t4Jh::.r ;~':l~~' ~~,J~~:~b.~r'~~~' '~~~ ~ (.~~",~i.'.Jf.'_~,~", (~J~t.~~~;.~"I~:!('J~,~ f'].f.~u( <~ Lt-,If; ~( I rJ IJV1. ~~ ttt:w..'i :t.',,/~.:~, - ~ t) ~ -vf ~ . __ ~~ r __ ( V.~ ~7~~! .. ~ U~\I~'~It).V'~ _""'I~)
d,r~JL-~,~)',J~l~ p(....fi'~):jL~~,~,l:~If~jfJ~~~Jt.t.l;J,;I'~,/~~t'nh,~J~~~hJ~J'~.~~Jc;tJ-r
a~
~'T
_t
~,?-
iI-
:/.
-~;~.
-~
,~IL
"~=J~,.
~
-¥~~bn~
~Ur.~Jvt1i'L~J~vit.t;f{~~n~'~tf~ti~vl~pcJt!fnJJtM~~Ir:;;;..~',r,~)J.-.LJ~L~~vJ~~lkJ:;;J)~
tI~~-o(iJ,eY~~,~J~~JII1~,Jjr\~~'lft~~;'I:t~flf(f!"J}lt~~/J~'~/'Ja;~,1tt\0~JfI1fJY~~~/u~Wjt ~~~-~'~'~II',t..~.JjrrV~~'~J.~~t.tnJk;~,~~JJ"l~b~Ii.r;!'lt"cft''i.lLr,~J'(.~,~J~.l1~~Llr~;".fw(~P~~,I~ )j;~~~;;IJ_LU~r:·,-.'~:f"UY"~~~h~n"d~»lw!t.. ''''C':r~~.r~~'~n;",..<"~JIr--~utJ'r-rl;L;~t',sfr~bJ'VJ1l'~ ~,~, d "~ ~~Ij,;;;_·.JJ' .JU' /ill ~ .,"'F 'Il I =:u~ ,~, ~
';/ '!' ~
'II -
-rf~/r