CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 1
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 2
Contents
1. Energy efficiency technologies 2. Modelling energy efficiency Task 1: Build a simple steady-state model of a dwelling Task 2: Investigate the effects of various energy efficiency measures
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 3
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 4
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_efficiency CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 5
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 6
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 8
Insulated studwork involves insulation held between a timber-framing system Using a fibre-based insulation, a typical thickness is around 120mm This disadvantage of this method is the space taken up inside the room.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 9
Rigid insulation board is plasterboard with a backing of insulation These are fixed to the wall surface Typical thickness is 60mm, so less space is taken up inside the room.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 10
Disadvantages
Can leave thermal bridges Fixing can be difficult Reduced room size Fittings (skirting, plugs, light switches etc.) need to be repositioned Disruptive to occupants.
Using solid wall internal insulation, U-value reductions from 2.1W/m2K to 0.3W/m2K are possible.
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 11
Wet render systems consist of an insulation layer fixed to the outside existing wall An external render (such as thick sand / cement) is then applied on a wire mesh on the outside of this insulation
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 12
Dry cladding systems consist of an insulation layer fixed to the outside existing wall The outside face of the insulation is then cladded. Possible materials include:
timber panels stone or clay tiles brick slip aluminium panels.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk Slide 13
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Disadvantages
Must be installed by a specialist contractor Can have a long payback time May change the external appearance of the dwelling Not suitable for historic / listed buildings May require alteration to guttering, satellite dishes etc.
Using solid wall external insulation, U-value reductions from 2.1W/m2K to 0.3W/m2K are possible.
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 14
Wall U-values
Typical U-value data is available in the SAP 2005 The table below shows wall U-values for different construction types and age bands (A=old, K=modern)
SAP 2005, Appendix S CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 15
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 16
Roof insulation 1
Roof insulation is typically either:
Insulation between joists Insulating rafters
Insulation between joists should be around 250 to 300mm thick Mineral wool quilt is often used Insulate between joists first, and then on top of joists if necessary This can reduce typical Uvalues from 1.9W/m2K (no insulation) to 0.16 W/m2K.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 17
Roof insulation 2
Roof insulation is typically either:
Insulation between joists Insulating rafters
Insulating rafters from the inside is known as ventilated roof construction An air gap of 50mm should be left between insulation and roof felt Rigid insulation board can be used at the inside of the rafters This can reduce typical U-values from 1.9W/m2K (no insulation) to 0.20 W/m2K.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 18
Floor insulation 1
Timber floors can be insulated:
From above, by removing the floorboards From below, from access via a basement etc.
Mineral wool insulation or rigid insulation boards are often used To avoid condensation, ventilation beneath the floor is important This can reduce typical Uvalues from 0.7W/m2K to 0.20 to 0.25W/m2K.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 19
Floor insulation 2
For solid concrete floor slabs, insulation can be installed:
Above the concrete slab Below the concrete slab
Insulation above the slab is typically rigid insulation. This option increases the floor height If the floor is being replaced then insulation can be incorporated below the floor slab Typical U-values can be reduced from 0.7W/m2K to 0.20 to 0.25W/m2K.
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 20
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk
In some cases, the greatest heat loss reductions can be made through draughtstripping.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 21
SAP 2005 CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 22
Ventilation 1
All dwellings require ventilation:
For health and comfort of occupants To ensure safe operation of combustion appliances (e.g. gas boilers) To control condensation by removing water vapour To remove any pollutants and odours
The simplest form of ventilation is natural background ventilators such as trickle vents.
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 23
Ventilation 2
Local ventilation
Extract fans. These remove stale or polluted air while fresh air is drawn in via background ventilators Single room heat recovery ventilators. These are combined supply and extract fans for a single room, with up to 60% heat recovery
Ventilation 3
Mechanical extract ventilation (MEV)
Uses fans to continually draw air from rooms Requires a central ventilation unit, usually positioned in the loft
Airtightness
Air leakage is the infiltration of air via unwanted gaps and cracks in the building envelope Too much air leakage leads to heat loss as well as discomfort from cold draughts Air tightness can be tested using a blower door test (blowing air into the dwelling) Best practice is an air permeability of 5m3/(hm2) @ 50Pa.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 26
Heating systems 1
Three main types:
Wet central heating, e.g. boiler and radiators Other central heating, e.g. warm-air heating or electric storage Individual room heaters
Heating systems 2
Condensing gas boilers
A direct replacement for old boilers Can have seasonal efficiencies of up to 90% Efficiency remains high at part-load Essentially the same as noncondensing boilers, but they extract more heat Flue gases are cooler, so water vapour is visible Condensed water is drained.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 28
Heating systems 3
Other boiler options
Combined heat and power Heat pumps Biomass boilers District heating
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 29
Heating systems 4
Boiler efficiencies are available in the SAP Table 4b For example:
SAP 2005 CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 30
Heating controls
Thermostatic radiator valves
Fitted to individual radiators Have a setpoint temperature to control the flow of water Not for use in a room with a room thermostat
Room thermostat
Turns the heating system off at a setpoint temperature
Zone control
Allows control of 2 or more space heating zones.
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 31 www.energysavingtrust.org.uk
Heating controls 2
Living room, bedroom and external air temperatures, recorded at 45 minute intervals, for a single house on Monday 10th December 2007
25 20 Temperature ( o C) 15
Living room
10 5 0 -5 00:00
Heating
Heating
06:00
18:00
00:00
M.D. Shipworth, S.K. Firth et al. Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics, Building Research and Information CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 32
Heating controls 3
Thermostat settings estimated and reported (for 200 centrally heated homes)
35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
o
% of dwellings
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Temperature ( C)
M.D. Shipworth, S.K. Firth et al. Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics, Building Research and Information CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 33
Heating controls 4
Central heating hours reported on-duty and estimated active (for 200 centrally heated homes)
30%
% of dwellings
20%
15%
10% 5%
0% 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
M.D. Shipworth, S.K. Firth et al. Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics, Building Research and Information CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 34
Hot water 1
Hot water can be supplied:
Directly by a combi boiler (i.e. no hot water tank) Indirectly using a hot water tank to store the hot water
A simple measure is to insulate the hot water tank Here is an example of:
A poorly insulated tank A well insulated tank
Alternatively replacement hot water cylinders have factoryapplied (spray foam) insulation of thickness 50 to 80mm.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 35
Hot water 2
The hot water primary pipework can also be insulated
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 36
Lighting 1
Lighting energy demand can be reduced by:
Using energy efficient lamps Using energy efficient light fittings (that only accept particular types of lamps) Controlling lighting use (timer switched, occupancy detection) Maximising use of daylight
Lighting 2
Energy efficient lamps include:
Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) Tungsten halogen
Lighting 3
Energy efficient lamps include:
Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) Tungsten halogen
Appliances 1
Energy efficient appliances use less electricity to provide the same function There may be a heat replacement effect where a small amount of additional space heating is required to replace the internal heat gains.
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 40
Appliances 2
Most appliances now have energy ratings This is EU compulsory scheme introduced in 1995 Energy labels give estimated fuel consumption and a rating from A (most efficient) to G (least efficient) There is an A++ rating for cold appliances (fridges, freezers etc.) Note energy ratings are different from actual fuel consumption, i.e. a large A rated fridge may consume more energy than a small B rated one.
Slide 41
www.energysavingtrust.org.uk
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Appliances 3
Trends in energy consumption of appliances 1965 to 2005
1,800
Lighting
1,600
Consumer electronics and ICT (information and communication technologies) are areas of rising energy consumption.
1970
1975
1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
Year
M Coleman, AJ Wright, N Brown and SK Firth, Domestic consumer electronics appliance monitoring: A practical perspective and implications for inter-disciplinary research, Energy Efficiency in Domestic Appliances and Lighting, Berlin, 2009
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 42
Appliances 4
Standby power can be a major source of energy use This is wasted energy use, equivalent to a leaky tap
M Coleman, AJ Wright, N Brown and SK Firth, Domestic consumer electronics appliance monitoring: A practical perspective and implications for inter-disciplinary research, Energy Efficiency in Domestic Appliances and Lighting, Berlin, 2009
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 43
Appliances 5
Typical appliance electricity use
Appliance category Continuous Category description Continuously switched on and constant power consumption Example appliances Clocks 1 Burglar alarms 2 Broadband modems 1 Televisions CRT 1 Televisions LCD 1 Televisions plasma 1 Set top boxes 1 Audio HiFi 1 Mobile phone chargers 1 Desktop computer 1 Fridges / freezers / fridge freezers 3, 4 Typical power (W) 2.5 5 4 84 130 253 17 14 4 100 80 to 250 in-use Typical standby power (W) 3.5 2.0 2.7 8.0 8.2 2.8 7.1 8.8
Standby
Actively switched on by householders. When not in use, power consumption may be non-zero.
Cold
Continuously switched on and power consumption cycles between zero and a set power level Actively switched on by householders. When not in use, power consumption is zero.
Active
Kettles Electric hobs 5 Washing machine 5 Electric showers Lighting - CFL Lighting - incandescent
S. Firth, K. Lomas, A. Wright and R. Wall. Identifying trends in the use of domestic appliances from household electricity consumption measurements, Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 926-936
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 44
Appliances 6
Five-minutely total power consumption recorded over a sample day at a single dwelling
2000 1800 Total power consumption (W) 1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0 00:00 03:00 06:00 09:00 12:00 15:00 18:00 21:00
Continuous appliances and appliances on standby Cycling appliances Active appliances with high power consumption
Time of day
S. Firth, K. Lomas, A. Wright and R. Wall. Identifying trends in the use of domestic appliances from household electricity consumption measurements, Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 926-936
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 45
Khazzoom-Brookes Postulate
As efficiency improves, people or companies can use the same amount of energy to produce more services This has two effects
The money you save is released to spend on something else (i.e. a high energy consuming service, i.e. transport) As energy-intensive processes become more efficient, they become more financially attractive
In a free market, energy efficiency could actually increase energy use This is disputed by some energy experts.
George Monbiot, Heat, Penguin Books
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 46
Rebound effect
Energy efficiency interventions may not always result in the expected energy savings This can be due to the rebound effect and can include:
The intervention not being applied correctly, i.e. cavity wall insulation being installed poorly Occupants using the improved energy efficiency to increase their use / comfort levels. For example, insulation which reduces heating bills may result in occupants using the heating more (typical in low-income households).
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 47
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 49
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 50
What is a model?
PARAMETERS
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 51
Qsolar
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 52
Qventilation
Air changes, N = 1 ach (air changes per hour) Volume, V = 220 m3
Qcasual_gains
Assume average rate of 700 W
Qsolar
Assume average rate of 250 W
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering Slide 53
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 54
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 55
Tasks
Task 1: Build a simple steady-state energy model of dwelling Task 2: Investigate the effects of various energy efficiency measures
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 56
Any questions?
CVP304: Renewable Energy and Low Carbon Technologies, MSc Low Carbon Buildings Design and Modelling, Department of Civil and Building Engineering
Slide 57