PROFILING
A Report from
Communities Across
America
SEPTEMBER 2010
232456782&95::;)<
5#.&5&3+$8:(3$,"#$-.(:#$/35$-8=-,/3.#$()$
'/;$#3)(0.#9#3,$/.,&2&,1$)(''(;&3+$,"#$&3&,&/'$
/(0"1$(2(%$%&')$*"(3"$&4$5.#,6$$7/$/&/(++%$
&32#-,&+/,(01$:0(.#580#<$#L.#:,$;"#3$,"#0#$
/(0"1$(2(%$!&2$%&'$)"1*&#,$/&$/!.#81$.#$ &-$ ,08-,;(0,"1$ &3)(09/,&(3<$ 0#'#2/3,$ ,($ ,"#$
/!"$4'/')"69$$
'(./'&,1$/35$,&9#)0/9#<$,"/,$'&3B-$/$:#0-(3$()$
/$:/0,&.8'/0$0/.#<$#,"3&.&,1<$3/,&(3/'$(0&+&3<$(0$
:;&+(#,($;&#"1-$<&'1/&#$=./%$=&'#3.+$ 0#'&+&(3$,($/3$&5#3,&)$.0&9&3/'$&3.&5#3,$(0$
>"5?")-$ ,.13'11.#8$ /!"$ 1/&)."1$ &4$ !")$ -."#9#?D$!$!"0(8+"(8,$,"&-$0#:(0,<$,"#$,#09$
&2#$ (#,$ !")$ 1@$ "A*")."#3"1$ ?".#8$ C0/.&/'$:0()&'&3+D$&-$8-#5$,($5#-.0&=#$/''$()$,"#$
,1:#-$()$0/.&/'<$#,"3&.$/35$0#'&+&(8-$:0()&'&3+$
*)&!$+",
,"/,$/0#$0#)#0#3.#5$&3$,"&-$5#)&3&,&(3?
!"#$ %&''$ ()$ *&+",-$ .'#/0'1$ -,/,#-$ ,"/,$
#2#01(3#$ &3$ ,"#$ 43&,#5$ 6,/,#-$ &-$ #3,&,'#5$
,($ #78/'$ ,0#/,9#3,$ /35$ #78/'$ :0(,#.,&(3$
835#0$,"#$'/;<$,"/,$#2#01(3#$-"(8'5$=#$)0##$
)0(9$830#/-(3/='#$-#/0."#-$/35$-#&>80#-<$
/35$ -"(8'5$ =#$ /))(05#5$ /$ :0#-89:,&(3$ ()$
&33(.#3.#?$ @(;#2#0<$ ,"&-$ &-$ 3(,$ ,"#$ 0#/'&,1$
)(0$ 9&''&(3-$ ()$ :#(:'#$ &3$ ,"#$ 43&,#5$ 6,/,#-$
;"($ "/2#$ =##3$ 5#3$ ,"#-#$ 0&+",-A/35$
9/31$ (,"#0-A58#$ ,($ 0/.&/'$ :0()&'&3+?$ !"&-$
0#:(0,$-##B-$,($5#9(3-,0/,#$,"#$:#02/-&2#$
3/,80#$ ()$ ,"&-$ 3/,&(3;&5#$ :0(='#9<$
5(.89#3,$&,-$&9:/.,$(3$&35&2&58/'-<$)/9&'&#-$
/35$ .(9983&,&#-$ /.0(--$ ,"#$ .(83,01<$ /35$
:0(:(-#$ 0#.(99#35/,&(3-$ ,($ #35$ ,"&-$
"/09)8'$/35$&3#))#.,&2#$:0/.,&.#?$
!"#$%&'()"*'+"**,-#.#%&/'
01%'2*34$.'"('54$#46'
7)"!'6#-8
<+&DEEF:&G8+)%',&<+')#+!'1$+!/&#).$#')2&
'(!'&!..#$318!')/,&HD&81//1$+&G8)#1"!+%:&!&
+*8;)#&)I*19!/)+'&'$&'()&)+'1#)&.$.*/!'1$+&
$5&J!+!2!:&(!9)&;))+&'()&91"'18%&$5&#!"1!/&
.#$51/1+-6& & K$4)9)#:& 1'& (!%& ;))+& .#$9)+&
#).)!')2/,& '(!'& #!"1!/& .#$51/1+-& 1%& !& 5!1/)2&
%'#!')-,& 1+& 8*/'1./)& /!4& )+5$#")8)+'&
9)+'*#)%:& 4()'()#& 1'& 1%& "$8;!'1+-& '()&
2#*-& '#!2):& 51-('1+-& ')##$#1%8& $#& )+5$#"1+-&
1881-#!'1$+& /!46& & 7()& 21%"#181+!'$#,& !+2&
1+)55)"'*!/& /!4& )+5$#")8)+'& .#!"'1")%&
2)%"#1;)2&;)/$4&!#)&!//&)3!8./)%&$5&#!"1!/&
.#$51/1+-:& !%& '(),& !//& #)/,& $+& #!"):& )'(+1"1',:&
#)/1-1$+&$#&!"#$%!"&'%($)$!'"*'"'*+,*#$#+#-'.%('
(-&-/"!#'$!0$1"#%(*'%.'1($2$!"&'"1#$/$#34
!"$
!#
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
(;:8;<&+21!&<87=&;7>򩎧&?&
@12>/2&+213/:3817&A#@+B
9)#:;;:<#%#)%"!0)%-#&*1=(,#20)+*2"(+#',#
"$(#>(5%1"3()"#0/#?*&"!2(#/0*)+#"$%"#'-%2@&#
%)+#7%"!)0&#.(1(#".0#"0#"$1((#"!3(ĭ(#
-!@(-,#"0#'(#&"055(+#%)+#&(%12$(+#/01#+1*4&#
"$%)#.$!"(&<#'*"#.(1(#!"##$!%&"!'#"0#'(#/0*)+#
%2"*%--,# !)# 50&&(&&!0)# 0/# 20)"1%'%)+8:#
A*3(10*&# 0"$(1# )%"!0)%-# &"*+!(&# %)+#
&*1=(,&# 510=(# "$%"# 1%2!%-# 510/!-!)4# !&#
!)(//(2"!=(<#%)+#"$%"#.$()#-%.#()/012(3()"#
!)&"(%+# *"!-!B(&# %# &"1%"(4,# "$%"# 51!01!"!B(&#
"%14("!)4# ("!")*+,$ %+-%.*,/(#$ /0$ .(%1%+*!$
*.,%)%,'2$#3.4$*##5"4*)%/(<#1%"$(1#"$%)#1%2!%-#
01#("$)!2#!+()"!",<#"$(!1#510+*2"!=!",#1%"(#C"$(#
1%"(# %"# .$!2$# "$(,# %2"*%--,# /!)+# +1*4&# 0)#
&03(0)(#"$(,#&(%12$D#40(&#*58#
$()#9#5%&&(+#"$10*4$#2*&"03&<#9#.%&#
&"055(+#',#9NO#P933!41%"!0)#%)+#N*&"03&#
O)/012(3()"Q#0//!2(1&R#.$0#&"%"(+#"$%"#9#
S-00@(+#61%'T#1%"$(1#"$%)#U(V!2%)R8##J$(,#
%&@(+#3(#%'0*"#3,#/%!"$8##9#"0-+#"$(3#9#
.%&#%#N%"$0-!2#%)+#.$,#.%&#!"#%)#!&&*(8##
J$(,#%&@(+#3(#!/#9#$%+#'(()#20)&!+(1!)4#
'(203!)4#20)=(1"(+#"0#9&-%3#%)+#9#%&@(+#
.$,#.0*-+#9#"(--#"$(3W##M$,#.0*-+#"$%"#'(#
%)#!&&*(W##9&#!"#!--(4%-#)0.#"0#'(#%#U*&-!3WT##
!"
X6(*+.%#./$7(8!"!!"#2$9%,+"##2$
:/3#,/+
#
6/"(1# Y(5"8# II<# :;;I<# "$(# 40=(1)3()"#
%+05"(+# )(.# 51041%3&# %)+# 50-!2!(&# "$%"#
&(=(1(-,# 2*1"%!-(+# 2!=!-# 1!4$"&<# 2!=!-# -!'(1"!(&<#
%)+# $*3%)# 1!4$"&# !)# "$(# )%3(# 0/# S)%"!0)%-#
&(2*1!",8T# # 6&# %# 1(&*-"<# 61%'&<# U!++-(#
O%&"(1)(1&<# U*&-!3&<# Y0*"$# 6&!%)&X%)+#
"$0&(# .$0# %1(# 3!&"%@()# /01# "$(3X$%=(#
'(203(# %*"03%"!2%--,# &*&5(2"# %)+# $%=(#
'(()# "%14("(+# ',# -%.# ()/012(3()"<# '0"$#
%"#"$(#'01+(1#%)+#.!"$!)#"$(#Z)!"(+#Y"%"(&8##
J$(,#$%=(#'(()#&*'L(2"(+#"0#&*1=(!--%)2(<#
&"05&<# !)"(1104%"!0)&<# !)"1*&!=(# [*(&"!0)!)4<#
!)=%&!=(#&(%12$(&<#%)+#-()4"$,#%)+#%1'!"1%1,#
+("()"!0)&8
9)#:;;E#"0#:;;F<#"$(#A%11%4%)&(""#G0-!2(#
>(5%1"3()"# !)# H$0+(# 9&-%)+# '(4%)# '%&!)4#
"$(!1# +(2!&!0)&# "0# &(%12$# 0)# 510'%'-(#
2%*&(<# 1%"$(1# "$%)# 0)# 1%2(<# %)+# &((@!)4#
&*5(1=!&01,#%5510=%-8##6&#%#1(&*-"<#3!)01!"!(&#
.()"#/103#'(!)4#"$1((#"!3(&#%&#-!@(-,#"0#'(#
&(%12$(+# "0# 0)-,# I8F# "!3(&# %&# -!@(-,8# # J$(#
+(5%1"3()"K&# &(%12$# 510+*2"!=!",# 1%"(#
L*35(+# "0# F;# 5(12()"<# 0)(# 0/# "$(# $!4$(&"#
!)#"$(#&"%"(8!##M$!-(#!"#$%&#'(()#510=()#"$%"#
-%.#()/012(3()"#0//!2(1&#%1(#301(#(//(2"!=(#
.$()# "$(,# '%&(# !)=(&"!4%"!0)&# 0)# 1(-(=%)"#
!)+!2%"01&# 0/# 21!3!)%-# %2"!=!",# 1%"$(1# "$%)#
N\G#4*!+(-!)(&#%--0.#%4()"&#"0#S1(=!(.#
0)#1%2(<#+%"%#20--(2"(+#!)#)*3(10*&#&"%"(&#
%)+# %)%-,B(# !)/013%"!0)T# "1%)&501"(+# ',#
&$0.&#"$%"#1%2!%-#510/!-!)4#&"!--#20)"!)*(&8
"$0&(#()"(1!)4#01#-(%=!)4#"$(#20*)"1,#.!"$0*"#
!)+!=!+*%-!B(+# &*&5!2!0)8"# # J$!&# 05()&# "$(#
+001# "0# 1%2!%-# 510/!-!)48# # 64()"&# %1(# %-&0#
4!=()# .!+(# -%"!"*+(# "0# &"05<# [*(&"!0)# %)+#
+("%!)#5(05-(<#)0"#0)-,#%"#"$(#'01+(1#%)+#%"#
!",1/*+,*/70>+,5&6!#7,)&,)/$#,4>,P2Q,4&()",
&07R,*&(+,FM//7+,'()&,)"#,'(5/4&.*,:0/**,-&E,
*&,)"/),"#,!&.07,P-#R,%/))#7,7&1(8,S#,!6'#7,
1"'0#,L,"#07,"'48,S#,7'7,(&),$(&1,1"&,)"/),
*)6/(:#6, 1/*, 1"&, 1/*, %/))'(:, "'4, 7&1(8,
S'*, -/:, 1/*, /0*&, )"&6&.:"0>, *#/6!"#78,
S'*, T04&, P-&&$*, 1#6#R, *#/6!"#7UL, /4, (&),
*.6#, 1"/), L, /4, :&'(:, )&, )#00, "'4, 1"#(, "#,
'*,&07,#(&.:",/(7,/*$*,1">,"'*,5/)"#6,/(7,
:6/(75/)"#6, /(7, *&&(, "'4, V, F4#6'!/(*, /00,
)"6##,V,/6#,!&(*)/()0>,*)&%%#7,->,)"#,9=F,
233,%#6!#(),&5,)"#,)'4#UW,#,
=.!", %6&:6/4*, /6#, (&), &(0>,
/()')"#)'!/0, )&, &.6, !&6#, C/0.#*X, )"#>, /6#,
!&.()#6%6&7.!)'C#Y,!"#!$%#&"'(!#")#*+,'(-#
./# +00# 0%//1# ("!# *"2%1# /+)%8, , ="#07&(,
Z/!&-*&(+,/(,<('C#6*')>,&5,L00'(&'*,!&4%.)#6,
*!'#(!#,%6&5#**&6,1')",#E%#6)'*#,'(,/C'/)'&(,
*#!.6')>+, *)/)#*, )"/), [4&6#, *!6##('(:, !/(,
6#*.0),'(,0#**,*#!.6')>,1"#(,'),7'6#!)*,/))#()'&(,
/(7, 6#*&.6!#*, )&, )"#, \3, )&, H3, %#6!#(), &5,
%#&%0#, 1"&, /6#, (&), /, *#!.6')>, )"6#/)8W$
F*, "#, %&'()*, &.)+, )"#, <8=8, :&C#6(4#(),
"/*, 0'4')#7, 6#*&.6!#*+, )#!"(&0&:'#*+, /(7,
)'4#, )&, 7#C&)#, )&, )"#, !&.()6>B*, *#!.6')>+,
/(7, '), !/((&), /55&67, )&, 1/*)#, )"#4, &(, /(,
'(#55#!)'C#,*)6/)#:>,)"/),!&(*'*)#()0>,%6&C#,
)&,-#,!&.()#6%6&7.!)'C#8,
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
!"#!$%&'()*+,-.),/0*&,1')"'(,233,4'0#*,&5,/(,
'()#6(/)'&(/0,-&67#68,,9"'*,%.)*,)"#,6#*'7#()*,
&5, *':('5'!/(), (.4-#6*, &5, 4/;&6, <8=8, !')'#*+,
/(7, '(, *&4#, !/*#*+, )"#, 6#*'7#()*, &5, )"#,
#()'6#, *)/)#*+, /), )"#, 4#6!>, &5, ?@AB*, 1'7#,
'(C#*)':/)'C#,%&1#6*8,
,./0.1(234!(1056(.57(
#4859:39:33430;<(*:.;83:;
!#(#,&5,)"#,%6&-0#4*,1')",6/!'/0,%6&5'0'(:,
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
(;:8;<&+21!&<87=&87&)558=2;3817&
$7412:/5/73
!"!./%./%'-(%6!"(%;%6"/%("<*!(%(!$%J0$).3"'%
8!$% 9:;A/% BCCD% E-0$/(.3% ;'#$/(.*"(.#$%
F5$)"(.#$% G<.+$4.'$/% HE;FGI! 1% 6!.3!%
.054$0$'(/% (!$% E$3$0&$)% BCCD% J((-)'$?%
G$'$)"4A/% G<.+$4.'$/% ,-)% E-0$/(.3% 9:;%
F5$)"(.-'/1"% $K54.3.(4?% "44-6/% (!$% </$% -,%
)"3$1% $(!'.3.(?1% "'+% )$4.*.-'% "/% "% ,"3(-)%
.'% +$($)0.'.'*% 6!$(!$)% (-% /(")(% "'% 9:;%
.'#$/(.*"(.-'7LC%%M'+$)%(!$%G<.+$4.'$/1%"'%9:;%
"*$'(%3"'%/(")(%"'%"//$//0$'(%6.(!%4.((4$%(-%
'-% ,"3(<"4% 5)$+.3"($1##% 3)$"(.'*% "% /3$'").-%
6!$)$% 0$0&$)/% -,% 3-00<'.(.$/% /.'*4$+%
-<(%,-)%5)-,.4.'*%5-/(NOPLL%3"'%&$%/<&2$3($+%
(-% &)-"+% /<)#$.44"'3$% "'+% +"("% *"(!$).'*%
&"/$+% -'% (!$.)% )"3$1% $(!'.3.(?1% )$4.*.-'% -)%
'"(.-'"4%-).*.'7%
!
,/2(&6(("&.1);3("#(.&;5$"0&#,(&4'10'/3&
#1&#/'0(#&4(14%(&-1'&3$"1'&#'/--$)&1--("5(5&
/5&/&4'(#(=#&),()F&#,(&$33$0'/#$1"&5#/#;5&
1-&#,15(&7,1&%11F&E-1'($0"8H&&R1'&(=/34%(+&
1--$)('5&$"&S/5#1"+&T1'#,&C/'1%$"/&'(41'#(.&
#,/#& UV& 4(')("#& 1-& 5#/#(& ),/'0(5& '(5;%#$"0&
-'13& JKL?0@& 7('(& -1'& 3$5.(3(/"1'58&&
W$0,#*X#,'((& 4(')("#& 1-& #,15(& 7('(& -1'&
#'/--$)& 2$1%/#$1"58!#& & :1#,& #,(& O9B& >--$)(&
1-& N"54()#1'& S("('/%& ?>NS@& /".& #,(&
S12('"3("#& <))1;"#/6$%$#*& >--$)(& ?S<>@&
,/2(& $.("#$-$(.& ";3('1;5& 3/I1'& -%/75& $"&
#,(& 4'10'/3+& $")%;.$"0& /& %/)F& 1-& (--()#$2(&
#'/$"$"0& /".& 4'1#()#$1"& /0/$"5#& '/)$/%&
4'1-$%$"0&/".&1#,('&)$2$%X'$0,#5&/6;5(58!$
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
!"#$%&'()("#%*+&#,(&-(.('/%&012('"3("#&,(%.&
4'$3/'*& '(541"5$6$%$#*& -1'& #,(& ("-1')(3("#&
1-& -(.('/%& $33$0'/#$1"& %/78& & 917(2('+&
5(2('/%& 4'10'/35& $"$#$/#(.& 6*& #,(& 5()1".&
:;5,& <.3$"$5#'/#$1"& /".& (=4/".(.& 6*& #,(&
>6/3/& <.3$"$5#'/#$1"& ,/2(& 5,$-#(.& #,(&
'(541"5$6$%$#*& /".& )15#& 1-& ("-1')$"0& )$2$%&
?#,/#& $5+& "1")'$3$"/%@& $33$0'/#$1"& %/7& #1&
5#/#(&/".&%1)/%&%/7&("-1')(3("#8
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
#17938363817;A&;7@&!/@/2;A&
*;>9&;7@&+287:80A/9
<=/&*;>&(/?;2@87?&(;:8;A&
+21!&A87?&
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
!"#$"!$%"&'(#)*&+!,&#-,%#$"!.%//#!0#12)3#4!"#
-%4'#&!#24'#$%"/!4#)*&+*4#*&/#5,"*/-*.&*!4#&+%#
%6,21#$"!&%.&*!4#!0#&+%#12)/78#!!"#$%&%'(!)*%!
+,-,!-./'%0%!1#.')!'.2%3!45!9+"%4#:7#;4*&%-#
<&2&%/!!#=67789!)*:)!4)!4;!5#)!.5<#5;)4).)4#5:2!
=#'! 2:$! %5=#'<%0%5)! )#! 0:>%! :! /'%)%?).:2!
)':==4<! ;)#/@)*:)! 4;(! ;)#//45A! ;#0%#5%!
=#'! :! )':==4<! &4#2:)4#5! B%<:.;%! )*%C! $:5)!
)#! 45&%;)4A:)%! ;#0%! #)*%'! <'40%(! $*4<*!
)*%C! $#.23! 5#)! B%! :B2%! )#! 3#! $4)*#.)! )*%!
D/'%)%?)E! #=! )*%! )':==4<! &4#2:)4#5@:;! 2#5A!
:;! )*%! #==4<%';! *:3! )*%! '%F.4'%3! :0#.5)!
#=! <%'):45)C! G/'#B:B2%! <:.;%9! )#! B%24%&%! :!
)':==4<!&4#2:)4#5!*:3!#<<.''%3,!
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
)73/27;3817;<&*;=&+21>8?839&
(;:8;<&+21!&<87@
U%&#"%)&,2%)+' +).' #$&)<+,$1#$' (+#)"'
!"21,<,&,2%$')3),%$&'")(,)+'!"2/,+,%37''V1#'R7S7'
1)$' $,3%#6' )%6' ")&,/,#6' &.2' ,%&#"%)&,2%)+'
&"#)&,#$W' V1#' U%&#"%)&,2%)+' F2%4#%&,2%'
2%' &1#' N+,5,%)&,2%' 2/' H++' ?2"5$' 2/' G)(,)+'
O,$(",5,%)&,2%' IUFNGOJ;' .1,(1' !"21,<,&$'
6,$&,%(&,2%$' <)$#6' 2%' ")(#;' (2+2";' 6#$(#%&;'
2"' %)&,2%)+' 2"' #&1%,(' 2",3,%' &1)&' 1)4#'
&1#' !-"!2$#' 2"' #//#(&! 2/' ,5!),",%3' &1#'
#=-)+' #%X205#%&' 2/' &1#,"' ",31&$Y' )%6' &1#'
U%&#"%)&,2%)+'F24#%)%&'2%'F,4,+')%6'Z2+,&,()+'
G,31&$' IUFFZGJ;' .1,(1' "#=-,"#$' )' $,3%#6'
!)"&0'&2'#%$-"#'&1)&'[)++',%6,4,6-)+$'.,&1,%',&$'
&#"",&2"0' )%6' $-<X#(&' &2' ,&$' X-",$6,(&,2%' \)"#'
)<+#' &2' #@#"(,$#]' &1#' ",31&$' "#(23%,>#6' ,%'
&1#'!"#$#%&'F24#%)%&;'.,&12-&'6,$&,%(&,2%'2/'
)%0':,%6;'$-(1')$'")(#;'(2+2-";'$#@;'+)%3-)3#;'
"#+,3,2%;'!2+,&,()+;'2"'2&1#"'2!,%,2%;'%)&,2%)+'2"'
$2(,)+'2",3,%;'!"2!#"&0;'<,"&1'2"'2&1#"'$&)&-$78
V1#' &.2' (255,&&##$' &1)&' 52%,&2"'
(25!+,)%(#' .,&1' UFNGO' )%6' UFFZG' 1)4#'
/2-%6'&1)&'&1#'R7S7',$',%'4,2+)&,2%'2/',&$'&"#)&0'
2<+,3)&,2%$7''?2"'#@)5!+#;'&1#'K-5)%'G,31&$'
F255,&&##;'.1,(1'52%,&2"$'(25!+,)%(#'.,&1'
&1#'UFFZG;'(",&,(,>#6'R7S7'!"23")5$'&1)&')++2.'
+2()+')%6'$&)&#'+).'#%/2"(#5#%&'&2'#%/2"(#'
/#6#")+' ,55,3")&,2%' +).;' <#()-$#' 2/' &1#'
!2+,(#'2//,(#"$^'+)(:'2/'&"),%,%3'2"'#@!#"&,$#'
,%'&1,$'(25!+#@')"#)'2/'+).7''V1#'R7S7'"#!2"&$'
$-<5,&' &2' &"#)&0' 52%,&2",%3' <26,#$'
1)4#' <##%' (",&,(,>#6' /2"' &1#,"' 25,$$,2%$;'
6#/,(,#%(,#$;' )%6' 5,$(1)")(&#",>)&,2%$' )%6'
1)4#' /),+#6' &2' )((-")&#+0' 62(-5#%&' &1#'
!#"4)$,4#'%)&-"#')%6'6#4)$&)&,%3',5!)(&'2/'
")(,)+'!"2/,+,%3',%'&1#'R%,'S&)&#$7
2(#*,&,#21#"&24"9##G2$)8)+0#12#"7..)""(7-#
+,.%,-# 4+2(%-%13# "7%&"# ',8)# <))1# (%-)*# &',&#
$)+)#,<-)#&2#28)+.2/)#&')#-)3,-#2<"&,.-)"#
&',&# $)+)# 47&# %1# 4-,.)# ,(&)+# &')# 2+*%1,1.)#
$,"# 4,"")*9# # ='7"0# )8)1# $')+)# '21)"&#
)((2+&"#,+)#/,*)#&2#%1&+2*7.)#)(().&%8)#-,$"#
&2# .2/<,&# +,.%,-# 4+2(%-%130# &')6# ,+)# 2(&)1#
71*)+/%1)*# ,1*# &'$,+&)*0# -),8%13# 8%.&%/"#
$%&'#12#+),-%"&%.#+).27+")9
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
)./.0(/12(345/6(3/78(
#415698:418(/12(
,054;;012/.:418
=')#
&)"&%/21%)"#
(+2/#
*%8)+")#
4247-,&%21"# &',&# )/)+3)*# (+2/# &')# &'($%
)*$% +,-)*% '),+%13"# .-),+-6# *)/21"&+,&)#
&',&#+,.%,-#4+2(%-%13#%"#,#1,&%21$%*)#4+,.&%.)#
&',&# ',"# *)8,"&,&)*# %1*%8%*7,-"0# (,/%-%)"#
,1*# .2//71%&%)"# ,.+2""# &')# HF9# E7+&')+0#
17/)+27"#1,&%21,-#"&7*%)"#,1*#328)+1/)1&#
%18)"&%3,&%21"# ,1*# +)42+&"# ,--# *2.7/)1&#
&')# %1)((%.,.6# 2(# +,.%,-# 4+2(%-%13# ,"# ,# &22-#
&2#.2/<,&#.+%/)9#='%"#4+,.&%.)#<2&'#%1"&%--"#
(),+# 2(# -,$# )1(2+.)/)1&# %1# .2//71%&%)"I
4+)8)1&%13# &')# 42-%.)J.2//71%&6# +)-,&%21"#
&',&# ,+)# 1).)"",+6# &2# .2/<,&# .+%/)I,1*#
*%8)+&"# 4+).%27"# +)"27+.)"# ,$,6# (+2/#
%18)"&%3,&%13# ,.&7,-# .+%/)"# ,1*# &'+),&"# &2#
1,&%21,-# ").7+%&69# ='%"# 4+,.&%.)# /7"&# <)#
)+,*%.,&)*#%1#,--#%&"#(2+/"9#=2#&',&#)1*0#KLM#
,1*# 27+# 4,+&1)+"# %1# &')# .'(/'#% % 0,"1/#/234%
&'($%)*$%+,-)*%.,/4,%31#2(()+#&')#(2--2$%13#
+).2//)1*,&%21"N
!"
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
(/:155/7<;38179&31&
+2/98</73&'=;5;&
!" #$%&'(%)*" +,-.-" &/012(" 1$3%"
40)3$%&&" *0" %)-5*" */%" 6)(" 7-5'-2"
#$08'2')3"95*"08":;<;=">/'5/"?$0/','*&"
?$08'2')3" ,-&%(" 0)" $-5%=" $%2'3'0)="
%*/)'5'*@" -)(" )-*'0)-2" 0$'3')" -*" */%"
8%(%$-2="&*-*%"-)("205-2"2%A%2&B"
!" #$%&'(%)*" +,-.-" &/012(" '&&1%" -)"
%C%51*'A%" 0$(%$" ?$0/','*')3" $-5'-2"
?$08'2')3",@"8%(%$-2"088'5%$&"-)(",-))')3"
2->" %)80$5%.%)*" ?$-5*'5%&" */-*"
('&?$0?0$*'0)-*%2@" *-$3%*" ?%0?2%" 80$"
')A%&*'3-*'0)" -)(" %)80$5%.%)*" ,-&%("
0)" $-5%=" %*/)'5'*@=" $%2'3'0)" 0$" )-*'0)-2"
0$'3')B" " D/%" %C%51*'A%" 0$(%$" &/012("
-2&0" $%E1'$%" */%" 5022%5*'0)" 08" (-*-" ,@"
8%(%$-2" %)80$5%.%)*" -3%)5'%&" -,01*"
2->"%)80$5%.%)*"-5*'0)&",$0F%)"(0>)"
,@" */%" -??-$%)*" 0$" ?%$5%'A%(" $-5%="
%*/)'5'*@=")-*'0)-2"0$'3')"-)("$%2'3'0)"08"
')('A'(1-2&" *-$3%*%(" ,@" %)80$5%.%)*"
-3%)*&B
!" #$%&'(%)*" +,-.-" &/012(" &*-*%"
1)%E1'A05-22@" */-*" */%" 8%(%$-2"
30A%$).%)*"-20)%"/-&"G1$'&('5*'0)"-)("
-1*/0$'*@" *0" %)80$5%" '..'3$-*'0)" 2->&"
-)(" /-2*" H46" ?$03$-.&" */-*" %)3-3%"
&*-*%" -)(" 205-2" ?02'5%" ')" '..'3$-*'0)"
%)80$5%.%)*"-5*'A'*'%&B
(/:155/7<;38179&31&3>/&
?/0;235/73&14&@6938:/
!!
(/:155/7<;38179&31&3>/&
?/0;235/73&14&A15/B;7<&
%/:6283C
!" D/%"I%?-$*.%)*"08"X0.%2-)("Y%51$'*@"
KIXYL" &/012(" *%$.')-*%" */%" :UZK3L"
?$03$-.B"
!" IXY"
&/012("
&1&?%)("
*/%"
'.?2%.%)*-*'0)" 08" 49#=" Y%51$%"
40..1)'*'%&" -)(" &'.'2-$" ?$03$-.&"
1)2%&&" -)(" 1)*'2" &-8%31-$(&" -$%" ?1*"
')" ?2-5%" >/%)%A%$" 5022-,0$-*')3" >'*/"
,./011.23456027(50(
#0289.77
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
8% <)&3-$!!%!0)/('%$&#*"%"0$%A&'%F#*1#(%
>-),1(1&3% =*"% ),% JKLK5% $!"#I(1!01&3% #%
,$'$-#(%I#&%)&%2-),1(1&3%I#!$'%)&%-#*$5%
-$(131)&5%$"0&1*1"6%#&'%&#"1)&#(%)-131&%#"%
"0$%,$'$-#(5%!"#"$%#&'%()*#(%($4$(!7%
8% <)&3-$!!% !0)/('% 2-)41'$% )4$-!130"% ")%
$&!/-$% "0#"% "0$% 4#-1)/!% #3$&*1$!% ),%
"0$% $E$*/"14$% I-#&*0% #-$% /&'$-"#?1&3%
"0$% -$,)-.!% 1'$&"1,1$'% 1&% "0$%
-$*)..$&'#"1)&!% #I)4$7% % @,% #3$&*1$!%
')%&)"%#')2"%"0$!$%-$,)-.!5%<)&3-$!!%
!0)/('%#')2"%($31!(#"1)&%.#&'#"1&3%"0$%
*0#&3$!%1&%2)(1*67
8% <)&3-$!!%!0)/('%-$2$#(%!$*"1)&%JMNG3H%
), "0$%@..13-#"1)&%#&'%C#"1)&#(1"6%=*"7%
!"#$%&'!&("#)"*&+('!)*),-.&&"&(/0123&4215�/9&":2199&"5/28:;
(/:155/7<;38179&31&93;3/&
;7<&=1:;=&>1?/275/739
!" #$%$&" %'(" )*+%)" ,*-&.'/&'$0" 01*2)("
%(*3$")&,40)%$4*'"$1%$"0$.*',)5"3.*1464$0"
3.*74)4'," 6%0&(" *'" .%+&8" .&)4,4*'8"
&$1'4+4$5" %'(" '%$4*'%)" *.4,4'9" " #2+1"
)&,40)%$4*'" 01*2)(" %)0*" /%'(%$&" $1%$"
)*+%)"3*)4+&"(&3%.$/&'$0"+*))&+$"(%$%"
%6*2$" 0$*308" 7.40:08" 0&%.+1&08" %..&0$0"
%'(" 3.*0&+2$4*'09" " ;1%$" (%$%" 01*2)("
6&" 6.*:&'" (*<'" 65" $1&" %33%.&'$" *."
3&.+&4-&(".%+&8".&)4,4*'8"'%$4*'%)"*.4,4'"
*." &$1'4+4$5" *7" $1*0&" $%.,&$&(" 7*."
&'7*.+&/&'$"%+$4*'0"%'("*2$+*/&09
!"
!"!#$%&'!()$**+,-
,./011.23456027(8901(:6.;3(
<652.77.7
!"#
!"#)(3#44-*#&+(,-.&)**+(504$-&6.#&+(
7%*8-&6.#&
!$"#!"#$%&!"#-&#--5'&#-&(0&3($-#6'/,:)'&
3($3'/$&#$&!"'&>5-)#;&3(;;5$#!*9&!"'-'&
(00#3'/-?&),+&'$0(/3';'$!&(00#3'/-&(/&
1(2'/$;'$!&(00#3'/-?&,/'&!"'*&:'#$1&
!/,#$'6&+#!"&/')#,:)'&#$0(/;,!#($&($&8-),;&
,$6&>5-)#;-&,-&(..(-'6&!(&-(;'&:#1(!'6&
#$0(/;,!#($&+#!"&-(5/3'-&!",!&@,/'A&$(!&
/',))*&05))*&,33/'6#!'6&,1'$3#'-B=&
!"%,%'(98%:-+(,-.&)**+(504$-&6.#&+(
7%*8-&6.#&
!"#
!"#$%&'%("#&)*+(,-.&)**+(/#0*.#&+(
1)2%*
!"
ENDNOTES
1.!
!U.S.!House!of!Representatives.!End!Racial!Profiling!Act!of!2010,!111th!Congress,!
2nd!Sess.!2010!H.R.!5748.
2.!
U.S.!Department!of!Justice,!Bureau!of!Justice!Statistics.!Contacts!between!Police!
and!the!Public:!Findings!from!the!2002!National!Survey,!<http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/
content/pub/pdf/cpp02.pdf>.
3.!
American!Civil!Liberties!Union!of!Rhode!Island.!The!Persistence!of!Racial!Profiling!in!
Rhode!Island:!An!Update,!April!2005,!<http://www.aclu.org/FilesPDFs/profiling_ri_
update.pdf>.
4.!
U.S.!Customs!and!Border!Protection,!Department!of!Homeland!Security.!Policy!
Regarding!Border!Search!of!Information,!July!16,!2008,!<http://www.customs.gov/
linkhandler/cgov/travel/admissibility/search_authority.ctt/search_authority.pdf>.
5.!
The!Sikh!Coalition.!The!TSA!Report!Card:!A!Quarterly!Review!of!Security!
Screenings!of!Sikh!Travelers!in!U.S.!Airports,!August!2009.
6.!
Amardeep!Singh,!testimony!before!the!House!Judiciary!Committee!Subcommittee!
on!the!Constitution,!Civil!Rights!and!Civil!Liberties,!<http://judiciary.house.gov/
hearings/pdf/Singh100617.pdf>.
7.!
Sheldon!Jacobson,!interviewed!by!Phil!Ciciora.!News!Bureau,!Jan.!7,!2010,!<http://
illinois.edu/lb/article/72/33799>.
8.!
The!DIOG,!giving!guidance!to!the!implementation!of!the!guidelines,!was!only!made!
available!in!a!heavily!redacted!version!through!FOIA!suitsthere!is!currently!a!suit!to!
disclose!all!of!the!DIOG,!unredacted.!<!<http://www.muslimadvocates.org/DIOGs_
pt1.pdf>.
9.!
U.S.!Department!of!Justice.!The!Attorney!Generals!Guide!for!Domestic!FBI!
Operations,!December!2008,!<http://www.justice.gov/ag/readingroom/guidelines.
pdf>.
10.! Federal!Bureau!of!Investigation.!Domestic!Investigation!and!Operations!Guide,!
December!2008,!pp.!27,!32,!<http://www.muslimadvocates.org/DIOGs_Chapter4.
pdf>.!
11.! Attorney!Generals!Guide!for!Domestic!FBI!Operations,!11A.,!December!2008,!
<http://www.justice.gov/ag/readingroom/guidelines.pdf>.!
12.! Vera!Institute!of!Justice.!Law!Enforcement!and!Arab-American!Community!Relations!
after!September!11,!2001:!Engagement!in!a!Time!of!Uncertainty;!2006,!pp!13,!21,!
<http://www.vera.org/download?file=147/Arab%2BAmerican%2Bcommunity%2Br
elations.pdf>.
67
13.! Immigration!Policy!Center,!Targets!of!Suspicion:!The!Impact!of!Post-9/11!Policies!
on!Muslims,!Arabs!and!South!Asians!in!the!United!States,!2004,!!<http://ispu.org/
reports/articledetailpb-63.html>.
!
14.! Lisa!M.!Seghetti,!Karma!Ester!and!Michael!John!Garcia.!Enforcing!Immigration!Law:!
The!Role!of!State!and!Local!Law!Enforcement,!Congressional!Research!Service,!
2009,!!<http://www.au.af.mil/au/awc/awcgate/crs/rl32270.pdf>.
15.! University!of!North!Carolina!Immigration!and!Human!Rights!Policy!Clinic!and!the!
American!Civil!Liberties!Union!of!North!Carolina!Foundation.!The!Policies!and!Politics!
of!Local!Immigration!Enforcement!Laws,!February!2009!<http://www.law.unc.edu/
documents/clinicalprograms/287gpolicyreview.pdf>.!
16.! Government!Accountability!Office,!Immigration.!Enforcement:!Better!Controls!
Needed!over!Program!Authorizing!State!and!Local!Enforcement!of!Federal!
Immigration!Laws,!January!2009,!<http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d09109.pdf>
17.! U.S.!Department!of!Homeland!Security,!Immigration!and!Customs!Enforcement.!
Criminal!Alien!Program,!Fact!Sheet,!(Nov.!19,!2008),!!<http://www.ice.gov/pi/
news/factsheets/criminal_alien_program.htm>.
18.! Trevor!Gardner!II!and!Aarti!Kohli,!The!Chief!Justice!Earl!Warren!Institute!on!Race,!
Ethnicity,!and!Diversity,!University!of!California!Berkeley,!Berkeley!Law!School.!The!
C.A.P.!Effect:!Racial!Profiling!in!the!ICE!Criminal!Alien!Program,!2009,!!!<http://www.
law.berkeley.edu/files/policybrief_irving_FINAL.pdf>.
19.! U.S.!Immigration!and!Customs!Enforcement.!Secure!Communities;!IDENT/IAFIS!
Interoperability!Monthly!Statistics!through!October!31,!2009,!!!<http://www.
ccrjustice.org/secure-communities/files2.!IDENT!Interoperability!Statistics.pdf.
20.! Id.
21.! To!view!the!documents!released!by!DHS,!ICE,!and!the!FBI!in!response!to!this!FOIA!
request!in!their!entirety,!see!!<http://www.ccrjustice.org/secure-communities>.
22.! Whren!v.!United!States,!517!U.S.!806!(1996).
23.! U.S.!v.!Brignoni-Ponce,!422!U.S.!873!(1975).
24.! Reno!v.!American-Arab!Anti-Discrimination!Committee!(ADC),!525!U.S.!471!(1999).
25.! Reno!at!488.
26.! The!testimonies!quoted!in!this!report!were!received!by!a!panel!of!local!and!national!
commissioners!at!a!series!of!hearings!held!in!the!summer!of!2010!by!Rights!Working!
Group!and!local!and!national!partners.!Some!of!these!testimonies!were!given!
anonymously.!All!of!the!testimonies!are!on!file!with!the!authors!of!this!report.!
27.! End!Racial!Profiling!Act!of!2010,!H.R.!5748,!111th!Cong.!(2nd!Sess.!2010).
28.! Police!Executive!Research!Forum,!Racially!Biased!Policing:!A!Principled!Response,!
2001,!!!!<http://www.cops.usdoj.gov/html/cd_rom/resources_law_enf/pubs/
MiamiPoliceDepartmentCitizenContactCard.pdf>.
68