The Reckoning
At the 10-year mark, the wounds and collective
scar tissue of today’s wars amount to a national
pathology. America, and those who volunteered
to defend it, could take a generation to heal.
By James Kitfield
22 sep tem ber 10, 2 011 nationa l jou r na l
The odyssey begins: Soldiers in Afghanistan
evacuate a comrade who stepped on a land mine.
23
national security
T
he troops come home from in Maryland or Travis Air Force Base in Cali- names joined the honor roll of more than
war much the way they left, fornia, where the buses waiting to meet them 6,000 fallen service members from Iraq and
largely invisible to a dis- bear large red crosses. The critically wound- Afghanistan. The deafening silence of the
tracted nation. Returning ed emerge from the massive C-17 transports dead continues to send shock waves through
units are typically met at an first, nearly invisible beneath bandages, a a landscape of grief inhabited by their fami-
airfield by buses that shut- jungle of medical equipment strapped to lies and comrades—the collateral wounded of
tle them to a gated military their gurneys. Next out are the less-dire cas- these wars.
base. On a parade ground, a commander re- es, carried on stretchers. Finally, the am- “A death in the military is unlike any oth-
minds the assembled, some of the more than bulatory patients shuffle single file to the er loss in our society, because there are so
2.3 million service members deployed during waiting buses. In the past decade, Air Mobil- many complicating factors,” says Bonnie Car-
the past decade of war, of all that they accom- ity Command has flown more than 35,600 roll, founder and president of the Tragedy
plished. He recalls the brothers in arms who aeromedical-evacuation sorties, transport- Assistance Program for Survivors, or TAPS,
didn’t make it back and the memories that ing more than 177,000 wounded or ill service which reaches out to grieving military fami-
unite those who did. The shared hardships, members home. lies with “peer professionals” who have social
the moments of terror and elation, the con- Staff Sgt. Dan Nevins was one of those pa- work degrees and have also lost loved ones in
stant joking that held the awfulness at bay. tients who landed on the tarmac at Andrews the military. Because deaths often happen on
The unbearable melancholy that descends at in 2005 clinging to life. Having already lost long combat deployments, Carroll says, griev-
the playing of “Taps.” one leg, he fought through 18 months and 30 ing spouses sometimes trick themselves into
The commander dismisses the forma- surgeries at Walter Reed Army Medical Cen- thinking that a missing service member will
tion, and the troops realize that the ties that ter trying in vain to save the other. “In retro- still walk through the front door someday.
bound their lives together are breaking. The spect, finally letting go of my other leg and Other times, the manner of death is so trau-
married service members run into the open getting on with my life was the best decision matic that families receive multiple sets of
arms of their families, husbands holding ba- I ever made,” says Nevins, who now works for remains. “When a death is so horrific in na-
bies they’ve never met, uniformed women the nonprofit Wounded Warrior Project help- ture, and the spouse hears about it repeatedly
hugging young children they can hardly rec- ing other injured veterans try to get on with in the media or third-party accounts, they can
ognize. Even before the smiles and tears sub- their lives. create a memory that leads to their own post-
side, spouses sense the vast gulf that now lies Thousands of other troopers have re- traumatic stress disorder.”
between them and wonder how to get across. turned home in flag-draped coffins at Do-
Single troopers head for the barracks, crack- ver Air Force Base in Delaware. Last month, THE PATHOLOGY OF WAR
ing wise but often wishing that they, too, had President Obama and other senior officials Every war leaves its imprint on those who
family to welcome them home. And, inevita- traveled to Dover to honor the 30 American fight it and on the national psyche. At the 10-
bly, there are the stragglers—young soldiers troops killed in Afghanistan on Aug. 6 after year mark, the wounds and mental scar tissue
shuffling and chain-smoking, unsure of where their helicopter was shot down, the worst from Afghanistan and Iraq have amassed into
to go or what to do next. Having come of age single-day loss of the long Afghan war. Their something like a pathology unique to these
on distant battlefields, they are suddenly lost conflicts—one that will afflict this country
in America. for a generation.
Even Col. David Sutherland, a decorated Due largely to advances in combat medi-
commander who served in Iraq, was shocked Marching Home cine, rapid aeromedical evacuation, and body
by the dizzying sense of alienation he felt on Hundreds of thousands of veterans of Afghanistan armor, the wars have proven to be the least
reentry. “Never in the history of our Repub- and Iraq have or will soon rejoin the civilian world. lethal in modern U.S. history. According to
lic have so few been asked to do so much for Dr. Ronald Glasser, a Vietnam-era Army sur-
so long. And yet, when soldiers return home, Veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan leaving geon and the author of the recent book, Bro-
active duty (estimated)
they feel acutely this disconnect between the ken Bodies, Shattered Minds: A Medical Odyssey
photo: (pre vious page) ap/Rodrigo Abd
military and a civilian society that doesn’t 350,000 from Vietnam to Afghanistan, for every battle-
even seem to be at war,” says Sutherland, the 300,000 field death, 16 service members survived their
Joint Staff’s special assistant in charge of the wounds. The ratio in Vietnam, he said, was
250,000
Warrior and Family Support program. “We 2.4 wounded for every death. In the Civil War,
fall into the same trap of our fathers from 200,000 the ratio was less than 1-to-1, with few soldiers
World War II or Vietnam, which is to keep the 150,000 surviving battlefield wounds.
memories of those sacred moments on the 100,000 In his book, Glasser warns that the na-
battlefield to ourselves. That’s how they be- tion will face a moral and economic reckon-
50,000
come secrets, and secrets are not healthy.” ing in caring for so many wounded veterans.
Tens of thousands of other troops return 0
’02 ’04 ’06 ’08 ’10 ’12 ’14 ’16 ’18 ’20 ’22
“Because of body armor there have been rela-
home on the aeromedical-evacuation flights tively few of the penetrating chest wounds or
Source: Veterans Affairs
that land routinely at Andrews Air Force Base abdominal injuries that caused so many battle
THE VOLUNTEERS
Today’s wars are the first ex-
tended conflicts to be fought
A deep bench: As a share of soldiers injured, more not by draftees but by a rela-
wounded soldiers survive now than ever before. tively small cohort of volun-
teers. That partly explains
deaths in past wars,” he tells National Journal. says Dr. Shane McNamee, the chief of physical why the pathologies specific to this war
“But no one was really prepared for the num- medicine and rehabilitation at the VA’s Poly- have been so hard to predict. Like previous
ber of seriously wounded survivors.” Accord- trauma Rehabilitation Center in Richmond, generations, however, today’s veterans gen-
ing to the Pentagon, 168,000 service mem- Va. “In the past five years, I can’t tell you how erally keep the toxic aftereffects of war to
bers wounded or injured in these wars are many times we have regeared to tailor our themselves; they are simply too painful to ad-
graded “60 percent disabled” or higher, and care delivery to subsequent waves of service mit or confront.
the VA faces a 492,000-case backlog of dis- members with different kinds of wounds.” The small size of the all-volunteer force,
ability claims. More than 508,000 veterans of But improvised explosive devices, the en- for instance, has necessitated multiple com-
today’s wars have already been treated at VA emy weapon of choice in both conflicts, have bat deployments with inadequate breaks in
hospitals and clinics. The Congressional Bud- caused their signature wounds, creating more between, which mental-health experts be-
get Office estimates that the medical costs as- than 1,300 amputees, numerous burn victims, lieve greatly increases the propensity for
sociated with today’s veterans could come to and unknown numbers who suffer from trau- PTSD and its effects: depression, drug abuse,
$40 billion to $55 billion over the next decade. matic brain injury. According to the advoca- failed marriages, and emotional distress. The
Just as the current wars have dragged on, cy group Veterans for Common Sense, more Defense Department’s Task Force on Mental
with tactics and geography shifting over the than 190,000 troops have suffered a con- Health found in 2007 that 38 percent of all
years, the pathology of these wounds has also cussion or brain injury. There is also grow- active-duty service members have reported
mutated over time. Early on in Afghanistan, ing evidence of links between TBI and post- psychological symptoms after their tours. In
for instance, small arms caused many inju- traumatic stress disorder. “They both injure some months this year, the suicide rate for
ries. A few years into the fighting in Iraq—as similar areas of the brain and exhibit simi- active-duty service members has exceeded
insurgent bombs got bigger and the armor lar symptoms,” says McNamee. “The lines combat deaths, and in April, the VA’s suicide-
on U.S. military vehicles got thicker—troops between them are pretty gray.” According prevention hotline received more than 14,000
absorbed blast waves through their seats, to a 2008 Rand survey, one in five veterans calls—the most ever recorded in a single
causing a spike in spinal-cord injuries, con- of these wars—some 300,000 people—are month. Dr. Robert Petzel, the VA undersecre-
cussions, and brain trauma. Over the last suffering either from major depression or tary of health, says that doctors have become
18 months in Afghanistan, the profile has PTSD, while 320,000 have suffered concus- expert at recognizing and treating PTSD. “It’s
changed again. sions or TBI. probably true that multiple combat deploy-
“As Afghanistan has turned primarily into Those growing numbers are significant. By ments increase the likelihood of PTSD,” he
photo: ap/Eric Gay
a war of dismounted infantry, our polytrauma allowing the Vietnam War—and the physical warns, “though we don’t have adequate re-
wards have seen a huge influx of troopers with and emotional trauma it caused—to recede search to prove that yet.”
really massive injuries from absorbing blasts from our national consciousness, America Today’s all-volunteer force is also old-
while on foot patrol, including multiple am- inherited an epidemic of veterans suffering er than its draft-era counterpart, with more
putations, really severe brain injury, and the from the attendant ills of PTSD. Today, the married service members and a larger num-
emotional wounds that go with all of that,” post-9/11 generation of volunteers faces the ber of uniformed women (14.6 percent of
photos: (top to bot tom) get t y/afp/PETER PARK S; get t y/Scot t Ol son
As a percentage of the overall deployed develop long after service members return Dan Nevin’s began in Iraq in a Humvee that
force, the National Guard and Reserves have home, and we’re seeing an increase in virtu- was bouncing down a dusty road outside the
also shouldered more of the burden in Af- ally all of the metrics that track them,” says Sunni-insurgent stronghold of Falluja. With-
ghanistan and Iraq than in wars past. Yet as clinical psychologist Barbara Van Dahlen, the out warning, his vehicle struck a roadside
citizen-soldiers, reservists are less prepared founder and president of the nonprofit Give bomb. In an instant, Nov. 10, 2004, became
for the stresses of a long combat tour. Indeed, an Hour, which connects veterans to a net- the day that changed his life forever. By the
the Task Force on Mental Health found that work of 6,000 mental-health professionals for time Nevin arrived at the U.S. military hos-
49 percent of National Guardsmen report- free treatment. pital in Landstuhl, Germany, 12 hours later,
ed experiencing psychological troubles after Despite improvements in the military and he had already lost one leg. Eventually, he lost
their deployments. VA health care systems—and the cooperation the other to a bone infection.
With the wars now winding down, the of nearly 5,000 nonprofits that serve military In 2004 and 2005, the insurgencies that
Pentagon estimates that as many as 1 mil- personnel—Van Dahlen sees a population at would eventually drive Iraq to the brink of civ-
lion service members are likely to leave active severe risk. “We should have learned from il war grew; correspondingly, the number of
duty in the next five years. They will enter a Vietnam, because all you have to do is study critically wounded service members pouring
struggling economy where the jobless rate for the homeless population today to understand into the military medical system spiked. Nev-
young (ages 18 to 24) male veterans of Iraq that an awful lot of those veterans never re- in had to wait a week to get space on one of the
and Afghanistan was 21.9 percent last year, ally made it all the way home,” she says. “If we crowded medical flights from Germany, and
and where veterans make up an estimated 20 don’t get ahead of the challenge, we will risk when he arrived at Walter Reed Army Medi-
percent of the homeless population. Many ex- losing this generation of veterans.” cal Center, the staff was nearly overwhelmed.
perts believe that the nation is simply unpre- The care “was absolutely world-class,” he
pared for that approaching army of suffering. THE ODYSSEY says. But the caregivers “just couldn’t handle
“There are combat wounds you can see, The odyssey begins on a day like any other, all of the wounded. Those guys worked day
on strong leadership, showing up for forma- me,” she says. Finally, her brother’s father-in- that provide stipends and travel allowances
tion, knowing that our families are taken care law, himself a former Marine, called a friend at for family members who care for seriously
of,” Dudek says. “I think the Army realized a local veterans’ center, who reached out. “It’s wounded veterans. “The departments of De-
that we can’t just treat wounded soldiers like taken me awhile to learn how to manage my fense and Veterans Affairs have gone from a
patients. We need to continue to treat them disease, and it’s gotten better,” she says. “But relatively low-level of interaction in 2001 to
like soldiers, too.” I don’t think I’ll ever be totally cured.” a degree of cooperation that is historically
That epiphany led to the establishment in Cases like Schiliro—veterans who need unprecedented,” says Petzel, the VA health
2007 of 29 community-based Warrior Tran- care but fall into the gap between military undersecretary.
sition Units for all soldiers whose care re- medical treatment and VA follow-on care— For all of those advances, however, ma-
quires at least six months of complex medi- have driven reforms designed to make the jor problems persist. Despite the move to a
cal treatment. The units blend the efforts of transition more seamless. The Pentagon and joint disability evaluation process designed to
a primary-care doctor, a nurse case manager, the VA established a Joint Executive Council streamline claims procedures, some veterans
and a squad leader. Soldiers help shape their that issued 26 initiatives to standardize treat- are still waiting up to 400 days for a decision
own comprehensive transition plans, which ment and evaluation systems. For instance, on whether they will receive payments and at
include career and employment goals; Soldier military treatment facilities today typically what levels, and a backlog of nearly 500,000
and Family Assistance Centers aid their fam- don’t release a wounded service member un- late claims have gone beyond the 125-day
ily members. til he or she has scheduled appointments in standard at the VA. Until disability payments
Still, the challenges are so complex that the Veterans Health Administration system. begin, easing some of their financial burdens,
even this well-intentioned program initially If requested, one of a hundred VA “transi- wounded veterans are susceptible to alcohol
went awry in some places. Media investiga- tion patient advocates” will even travel with or drug abuse—or worse—to alleviate their
tions of various units showed conflicts be- service members as they move from ma- suffering. “I know that VA and DOD have big
tween the medical and military staff, over- jor military hospitals to VA hospitals closer challenges,” Senate Veterans’ Affairs Com-
crowding, and an overreliance on medication. to home. Anticipating demand, the VA also mittee Chairwoman Patty Murray, D-Wash.,
An Army Inspector General’s report issued hired 7,000 mental-health officials in re- said at a hearing earlier this year. “But service
in January estimated that up to a third of all cent years, expanded suicide-prevention ho- members and veterans continue to take their
soldiers in Warrior Transition Units last year tlines, and established caregiver programs own lives at an alarming rate. Wait times for
were overmedicated, hooked on drugs, or benefits continue to drag on for an
abusing illegal substances. average of a year or far more.”
The Army has investigated the charges but Another sign of trouble: Despite
hasn’t backed away from the concept. “We aggressive outreach, only about half
did have some inexperienced leaders in War- of the Iraq and Afghanistan vets
rior Transition Units who didn’t fully under- have even registered with the VA,
stand the complexity of tailoring a treatment meaning there is a vast at-risk pop-
regime to each soldier, and some soldiers do ulation. “A chief lesson of Vietnam
feel that military drills get in the way of their was that we need to get new veter-
recovery,” says Dudek, who commanded a ans help as early as possible, before
transition unit in Seattle. “There were also their lives spiral into crisis,” says
some conflicts between nurse case manag- Fern Taylor, supervisor of a clinic
ers and squad leaders. But with good leader- for returning veterans at a VA hos-
ship, that organizational friction usually gets pital in Houston. “Too often, our
quickly resolved.” He adds that “the last thing first contact with a veteran is in the
we need to do is come back wounded and just emergency room, through the crim-
‘take a knee.’ What I told my soldiers is that inal-justice system, or on our sui-
you have to fight to overcome the pain, the ap- cide-prevention hotline.”
athy, and the fear of an uncertain future. And Kathy Molitor, the suicide-pre-
for me and a lot of them, it is the hardest fight vention coordinator at a VA post-
of our lives.” deployment clinic in Houston, has
no doubt that many vets need help.
FALLING THROUGH THE CRACKS In 2007, the VA’s suicide hotline re-
When Lance Cpl. Nancy Schiliro was medi- ceived 9, 400 calls, she says, and the
cally discharged from the Marine Corps in next year, it jumped to 67,400. In
2005 after losing an eye in a mortar attack in 2009, it reached 119,000, and last
Iraq, there was no long counseling session or year it was up to 135,000. Just listen-
transition unit. They hadn’t been created yet. ing to the calls for help can induce
photo: get t y images /Ale x Wong
One day she was living in the 24/7 bubble of secondary traumatic stress: I feel like
life as a Marine—being told what to do, where an animal, unfit for civilized society.…
to go, when to eat, and who to hang out with— My husband only wants to hang out
and the next day she was home and that bub- and drink and do drugs with his bud-
ble had burst. The whole experience was dies.… I can’t talk to my wife because
so disorienting that, for six months, Schil- she might be infected with my disease.…
iro didn’t even realize that she was suffering The road back: A Marine My husband barks orders at our chil-
from PTSD. “I wasn’t sleeping. I jumped at exercises at Walter Reed dren like they were soldiers.… After
loud noises. I basically stayed to myself and Army Medical Center in 2007. watching my buddy blown to bits, I’m
stopped interacting with people. I just wasn’t angry all the time.… Why does Daddy
Deployed to Iraq
20,000 have much to contribute and even to teach us.
or Afghanistan
15,000 But combat veterans struggling to regain a
10,000
Not deployed sense of normalcy in everyday life need and
5,000
deserve the same assurances at home that
0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 their buddies gave them on faraway battle-
fields: They need to know that someone has
Sources: Armed Forces Health Surveillance Center; Defense Manpower Data Center; CBO
their back. n