Thinking in Boxes - The Cornell Daily Sun

Thinking in Boxes | The Cornell Daily Sun
http://www.cornellsun.com/section/arts/content/2010/04/19/thin...
(/)
Username Password
Log In
Register (/user/register) | Forgot Password? (/user/password) News (/section/news) Sports (/section/sports) Opinion (/section/opinion) Arts (/section/arts) Science (/section/science) Red Letter Daze (/redletterdaze) Blogs (/blog) The Sun Online Email newsletter (/sunmailer) Twitter (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) RSS (/rss) Video (/video) Advertising (/content/advertising-us) Flyerboard (http://www.paperg.com/yerboard.php?pid=505&bid=200&cid=0) Front Page (/) Arts & Entertainment (/section/arts)
Thinking in Boxes
E-Mail (/forward?path=node/42302) Print (/print/42302) Discuss (#comments) Share
(http://twitter.com /home?status=RT+%40cornellsun%3A+Thinking+in+Boxes+-+http%3A%2F %2Fcornellsun.com%2Fnode%2F42302) (http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=<url>) (http://digg.com/submit?url=http%3A%2F
%2Fwww.cornellsun.com%2Fsection%2Farts%2Fcontent%2F2010%2F04%2F19%2Fthinkingboxes&title=Thinking+in+Boxes&media=news) (javascript:void(0))
1 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
(http://del.icio.us/post?url=http%3A%2F
%2Fwww.cornellsun.com%2Fsection%2Farts%2Fcontent%2F2010%2F04%2F19%2Fthinkingboxes&title=Thinking+in+Boxes)
Advertisement
(http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery /ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=1203__zoneid=242__cb=4d8a98a214__oadest=http %3A%2F%2Fcornellsun.com%2Fadvertise-us)
Related
Topics: lecture (/category/related-topics/lecture), architecture (/category/related-topics/architecture), architects (/category/related-topics/architects)
Rem Koolhaas' Lecture at Cornell

April 19, 2010 By (user/2090)Will Cordeiro (/user/2090) Rem Koolhaas, globetrotting architectural provocateur, lectured a jam-packed Call Auditorium last Wednesday about his vision of a global generic architecture, claiming that the box is the nal form of architecture. Koolhaas gave a brief history lesson about the inuence of technology on American building practices mostly cribbed from his early book Delirious New York before delving into the history of his rms projects over the last ten years. While the embrace of paradoxes has made Koolhaas innovative theoretical raids on architectural complacency a salient point of departure for a whole generation of younger practitioners, his talk Wednesday positioned his own ideas as the new complacency. Inevitably, the old vanguard becomes the next establishment: His provocative paradoxes that once shook up thinking in the eld now seem pasted together in a ippant and imsy discourse riddled with ideological contradictions. While critiquing celebrity architects who assert their own signature look over an architecture that reects the values of a civilization, Koolhaas himself has been a principle exponent of branding. Its easy to laugh at a picture of a fat-headed, smarmy-looking Daniel Libeskind, poster boy for todays starchitect in his black suit and thick frames, shilling designs that memorialize cultural grief while he rakes in bank. Koolhaas, however, ironically acknowledges he has more in common with the jet-set lifestyle of Libeskind than the old fashioned image of an architect with his sleeves rolled up, directing the dirty work and heavy lifting on site, holding a blueprint if not exactly wearing a blue collar. But Koolhaas and OMA retain their well-remunerated prestige by creating recognizable even kitsch-like landmarks: Every pan-out during Olympic coverage to the CCTV Headquarters on Beijings skyline, for example, both implicitly plugged OMA and helped put Beijing on the map as player in the global marketplace. Likewise, Koolhaass designs for Pradas agship stores locates his aesthetic as mutually benecial to a vision of global corporate hegemony. In the new world order, Koolhaas claims, there will be little for us to do but shop hence, in his Prada stores luxury is not shopping. The Prada stores are designed around archives, theaters, runways, laboratories, peepshows and clinics that supposedly create a differentiated space that resists the generic shopping mall that has inltrated everything from hospitals to airports to museums: Each agship store, moreover, is different in its design and merchandise so that it becomes sought out as a Mecca. The consumer is given a space for the luxury of clarity and focus: A showroom has been transformed into a museum, which Koolhaas says are popular for their lack of content
2 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
one can come and go moved only by whim and contemplation, with no pressures and no decisions to be made. The Beverly Hills store literalized this museum effect by keeping intact the Guggenheim logo of its previous occupant, offering the symbolic capital of a brand name emptied of any content, as if the Prada wares (and Koolhaass design) were being displayed as the latest trend in arts fashion system. All this, perhaps, reveals that Western modernism which is still, like it or not, our civilization values recognizable individual style; for OMA to thrive as a business, it must conform to a larger corporate culture that values recognizable brand individuality above all else. What better representation of how architecture supports corporate interest by museumcation than superimposing the Prada and Guggenheim logo in a signature landmark? Against this background, we can read the thirty-four soccer elds worth of museum space designed by OMA in the last ten years. One of the rms proposals for the MoMA was to re-think the concept of a museum as a space of selection; the vast holdings of most museums acquisitions are frozen in an inaccessible vault. Koolhaas envisioned a storage space that could be accessed by viewers, which would turn museum-goers into curators. Ironically, however, breaking down the institutional framing provided by the museum would also make the spectator a type of shopper, exchanging contemplative focus for an experience that was much like the busy maze of merchandize in a museum shop. To navigate such opposed visions of design, Koolhaas described planning a tower based on at least four independent criteria: virtual (conceptual), circulation (mobility), collective (social space) and executive (making money). Optimizing any one criterion results in a different design, so that the ultimate building will necessarily be a hybridized form that contradicts some of these goals, while incorporating compromises from all of them. His design process is thereby more pragmatic and self-conscious about what it prioritizes. Nonetheless, he also referred to the autonomous box as not dened by human users. The box is a catchall that can be endlessly repurposed, responsive to pluralistic or changing needs exactly because it is oblivious to any specic function. Many of his architectural diagrams highlighted this vacuum of content by appearing as little more than multicolored stacked rectangles where architectural details were absent and had been overtaken by the textual labels written on them: conference room, gym, parking. Koolhaas emphasized instead what he called a program reshufe by focusing on which boxes connected to others to produce more openness between sites and arranging novel intersections of purposes, inspired by the Downtown Athletic Clubs 9th oor that houses a side-by-side boxing gym and oyster bar. Similarly, his proposal for the Whitneys extension extended exhibits into prosaic spaces such as the parking garage and escalators, deconsecrating the museums framing of art. His planning initiatives also invert traditional distinctions, such as the pastoral campus against its crowded urban environs. At the Illinois Institute of Technology in Chicago, for example, he fractured the clear, linear space that cut a zone of nothingness through the middle of campus to create obstructions which made the site resemble the density of the surrounding city, tracing the zigzagging angles of the footpaths used by students as they hurried to classes. He also highlighted rather than hid the elevated train tracks that bisect the campus, which not insignicantly were designed by Mies van der Rohe. Even as he promulgates the generic box, Koolhaas rewrites and disrupts the linear grids on the very grounds of the boxs biggest Modernist exponent. Likewise, at Harvard where he now teaches, Koolhaas proposed a radical plan (though rejected) to divert the stranglehold that the pretentions of the campus architecture had vis-a-vis the rest of the community. Koolhaas described the periphery of the campus as a demoralized zone since there was a stark contrast between the egregious wealth of Harvards buildings and its more pedestrian neighbors. His idea was to create a canal and l 150 acres of the l-in Charles River, opening up a meandering course of new development that would de-center Harvards occupation of Cambridge. His riposte to detractors of the plan was that we have a stubbornly timid vision despite the magnitude of means. Such fantasias are situated on the ambiguous frontier between re-visions of urban plannings utopian potential
3 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
and an ironic embrace of the concrete landll that urban planning too often effects. While Harvard is not going to budge anytime soon, Koolhaas has recently been granted an enormous budget in Dubai to create an articial island city that not surprisingly looks a lot like New York taken to delirious new heights with globes and zigzag towers. Todays architect, according to Koolhaas, traverses a destabilized, yet oddly homogenized, urban landscape, a terrain of inevitable global corporate dominion where Dubai, Las Vegas, Lagos and the tomorrows overnight megalopolis in China are nearly synonymous, devoid of their cultural heritage and historical specicity. But the paradox is that the so-called generic architecture that Koolhaas favors has its roots in historically contingent zoning laws, technological conditions and architectural and geographical contexts. Furthermore, specic economic factors of the new globalism make it more likely that tomorrows most innovative skyscrapers at once generic and spectacular will arise in the deserts of the Middle East and the rapid sprawl of Southeast Asia rather than in Chicago and New York. Add new comment (/comment/reply/42302#comment-form) Email this Arts Story (/forward?path=node%2F42302) Printer-friendly version (/print/42302)
Advertisement
(http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery
/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=1196__zoneid=199__cb=0004b524b0__oadest=http%3A%2F %2Fphones.verizonwireless.com%2Fskypemobile%2F)
Search
Search
Advertisement
4 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
Popular Arts Stories

Thinking in Boxes (/section/arts/content/2010/04/19/thinking-boxes) Greek Freak Show (/section/arts/content/2010/04/19/greek-freak-show) Big, Big Love For Amanda Seyfried (/section/arts/content/2010/04/19/big-big-love-amanda-seyfried) Working in Contradictions (/section/arts/content/2010/04/19/working-contradictions) The Consequences of Riding the Train (/section/arts/content/2010/04/16/consequences-riding-train)
Check us out!
The Cornell Daily Sun on Twitter

redletterdaze (http://twitter.com/redletterdaze) Red Letter Daze coming out on Thursday! This week we're celebrating Earth Day! Go Big Green (?)
about 1 hour ago (http://twitter.com/redletterdaze/status/12481311577)
cornellsun (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) Cornell Class of 2009 Grads Find Fewer Jobs, Earn Less Than In Previous Years http://bit.ly/97J4qi (http://bit.ly/97J4qi)
15 hours ago (http://twitter.com/cornellsun/status/12446369770)
cornellsun (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) Local Coffee Union Cancels National Labor Relations Board Election http://bit.ly/a5s0HT (http://bit.ly/a5s0HT)
cornellsun (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) Department of Energy Undersecretary Steven Koonin Discusses Mission, Goals for Sustainability http://bit.ly/dwN8nl (http://bit.ly/dwN8nl)
cornellsun (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) Olayan '77 Honored With Entrepreneur of the Year Award http://bit.ly /9uY4Xx (http://bit.ly/9uY4Xx)
(http://twitter.com)
Join the conversation (http://twitter.com/cornellsun/lists/cornellsun)
(http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery
/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=1222__zoneid=241__cb=385a13a660__oadest=http%3A%2F%2Ftwitter.com%2FCornellsun) (http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery
/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=1223__zoneid=241__cb=929ddb2c1f__oadest=http%3A%2F %2Fwww.facebook.com%2Fcornellsun)
5 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
Advertisement
Join the CornellSun.com Team! Developers, Designers, Video producers, bloggers all welcome. Apply now! (http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery
/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=660__zoneid=200__cb=20e9d9325c__oadest=http%3A%2F %2Fcornellsun.com%2Fjoin%2Fweb)
Buy HP ProCurve networking products http://www.shopricom.com (http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery

/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=666__zoneid=200__cb=bc309863b2__oadest=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.shopricom.com)
Advertise with The Sun Put your own ad here! Click to learn more about advertising on CornellSun.com! (http://www.oncampusweb.com
/delivery/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=664__zoneid=200__cb=b9e5943c86__oadest=http%3A%2F %2Fcornellsun.com%2Fcontent%2Fadvertising-us)
Advertisement
(http://www.oncampusweb.com/delivery/ck.php?oaparams=2__bannerid=1228__zoneid=243__cb=d7fa5d095c__oadest=http %3A%2F%2Fcornellsun.com%2Fcontent%2Fadvertising-us)
Sections
News (/section/news) Sports (/section/sports) Opinion (/section/opinion) Arts (/section/arts) Science (/section/science) Red Letter Daze (/redletterdaze) Blogs (/blog)
Online
Email newsletter (/sunmailer) Twitter (http://twitter.com/cornellsun) RSS (/rss) Video (/video) Advertising (/content/advertising-us) Flyerboard (http://www.paperg.com/yerboard.php?pid=505&bid=200&cid=0)
6 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM
Information
Advertise (/content/advertising-us) Join the Sun (/join) About Cornellsun.com (/content/about-cornellsun.com) About the Sun (/about) Contact (/contact) Privacy Policy (/privacy) Posts and Comments are the exclusive property of their owners. All other content 2010 The Cornell Daily Sun. All Rights Reserved.
7 of 7
4/19/10 8:36 PM

Thinking in Boxes - The Cornell Daily Sun

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Deskripsi Asli:

Judul Asli

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Thinking in Boxes - The Cornell Daily Sun

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Thinking in Boxes | The Cornell Daily Sun